Desh Deshantar - RTI और RBI

[@pradeeppatel-dh3rc]

एक ज्वलंत और विशेष मुद्दे पर तर्कसंगत चर्चा के द्वारा जनता को इस मुद्दे की बारीकी व गहराई को समझाने के लिए धन्यवाद ।

[@Shivam-xf6wn]

Ak bhatacharya jee puts very valid points...

[@JaiHind-lo9dj]

J Sai Deepak As always super

[@राहगीरअलबेला]

Great deepak sir

[@civilservicesacheaver7079]

चुनावी माहौल की तपिश में राज्यसभा टीवी का यह कार्यक्रम वट वृक्ष की सी शीतलता प्रदान कर रहा है......अद्भुत विद्वत समागम

[@mitanshurajsingh6837]

Bhattacharya sir made it very clear... Thank you rstv

[@jayanti5202]

j sai deepak presence is enough to lure me to watch any debate....

[@akshaytawar6012]

Good

[@rakeshpandey458]

RBI भारत का केन्द्रिय बैंक है जिसके कार्यों का सीधा प्रभाव देश और नागरिकों पर पड़ता है । अत: RBI की यह जिम्मेदारी बनती है कि वह बैंकिंग नीतियों की दशा और दिशा को RTI कानून के तहत नागरिकों के साथ साझा करे । हालाँकि ऐसी सूचनाएँ जिससे देश में निवेश एवं आर्थिक क्रियाकलापों पर प्रतिकूल प्रभाव पड़े और उन सूचनाओं से आम जन का कोई सरोकार ना हो , ऐसी सूचनाओं को साझा ना करना ही बेहतर है ।

[@rkveer7867]

Dhanyawad team rstv nd kavindra sir

[@shashiketan]

Supreme Court in in it's judgement said that RBI cannot deny information on Annual inspection report of banks to RTI. RBI position is that under Section8(1)E - It shares a fiduciary relationship with the bank and hence cannot disclose information. However, RBI needs to explain what's the fiduciary relationship here. Why Disclosure is essential? - RBI provision which overrules RTI: RTI supersedes every other section in RBI Section 22, RTI: this will prevail over any other legislation other than official secrets act - RTI Act, 2005 - RBI has fiduciary relationship with people as well. In 2016: SC - RBI & banks don't have fiduciary relationship - If needed in public interest . PI can be determined by CJI, speaker LS, President/ governor, Administrator of UT - Macro level - bank health not revealing private individuals Effect: - Can be an impact on economy. - real state of banks. - Capitalization, share holders should fund money to save depositors in public interest It is very important for institution like RBI to have disclosure & transparency to build public trust while maintaining confidentiality & fiduciary relationship with its banks. RBI & RTI can exist together.

[@ma9har]

Nice 👌

[@chandrikaprasad6930]

Thanks rstv

[@ArunKumar-ev4wj]

Good debate

[@sonu-df1se]

dhanywad

[@खुदहै]

शुक्रिया आप का

[@jagadishmallick97]

Gulshan Tiwari Modi is a Great Political

[@खुदहै]

@@jagadishmallick97Sorry Sir I don't no Modi good political But recently better than other political leader

[@peacetalk-hindi]

j sai deepak was enough to clear the issue at last part of video

[@PankajVerma-qg3dx]

J sai deepak u always rock..Rajya sabha TV hafte main kam se kam unhe 3 baar bulaya karo..aur possible hai to roz..

[@rameshchandra6287]

4ffreeqaaw111fgģ

[@janvigii3028]

RBI की स्वायत्तता पर भी आँच ना आए इसलिए जरूरी है कि अपनी सूचना साझा करने के समय क्या RTI को अपनी सूचनाओं को बताया जाना करगार सिद्ध होगा ये तो आने वाला वक्त ही बता सकता है!

[@mystictilopa2812]

16.22 के आगे साई दीपक ने गलत जानकारी दी है की RTI Act के sec 22 मे official secret act को exception माना गया है.

[@officialshobhit]

j sai deepak is, i see, the most intelligent panellist.

[@chandanthakur3480]

All institution of india should disclose its information publicly... except which matters is under the defence..is not included in it..

[@mahaprabhudey2724]

RBI should disclose only positive information of public bank review report. RBI should not disclose any negative information about public bank. Thank you.

[@agriguru3899]

Issue kya h unable to understand??????

[@manish-hb2qm]

Good debate sir, should be tranprancy

[@Radhey_Shyam11]

RTI ke dayre mein govt.ko unhi field Ko rkha Jana chye jisse kisi individuals ki personal information ka galat use naa ho or rahi baat RBI jaise sanstha ki to isme unhi subjects Ko RTI k Ander rkha Jaye jisse transparency bni rhe or public interest b prabhavit na ho.aaj ke time mein dekha Jaye to log RTI ka galat trike se istemaal kr rhe h,RTI ka mechanism ek simple way m hona chye jaha public easy way m wo saari jaankari hansil kr ske jo RTI ke dayre m rkhi h...

[@premsagar-up1jj]

Then why yearly lakhs of crores are written off, why. Public should know.

[@OctaneClasses]

Notification nhi aata hai sir

[@ashuv5398]

make video on chabahar port

[@BhatnerIAS]

IAS Prelims की तैयारी में CSAT को लेकर परेशान हैं तो हमारा चैनल Bhatner IAS देखें...CSAT का कोर्स हिन्दी माध्यम में जारी है, आधे से ज़्यादा कोर्स हो चुका है, 30 अप्रैल तक finally Complete हो जाएगा...

[@subhashinisuman3161]

If u share PDF on telegram or any other site of all the Programs then it is very easy to grasp knowledge

[@AnilKumar-pv9en]

Subhashini Suman didi yeh upsc coaching nahi karwata hai.

[@subhashinisuman3161]

@@AnilKumar-pv9en yeah I kW about that bt they know the information is how much important for anyone dear

[@aspirant8996]

No institution wants transparency. We live in India. We should keep minimum amount in accounts then let's see how the economy runs.

[@yashharshvardhan256]

The concept of a 'fiduciary relationship' especially between public institutions which maintain a large interface falls short of any 'credibility'.However, the associated risks of bringing into light the financial relations which the banks maintain with their customers,their financial position in terms of the loans which they lend 'except the retail ones' does require wide ranging deliberations. Equally, let's not forget,that various SCB's do come out with their list of wilful defaulters in the public domain and do submit their annual performance reports highlighting their achievements and the downside risks to their business. Therefore,what is required are readjustments in the system wherein the crucial aspects which tend to bolster the larger 'national interest' are given the top most priority.