Destructive Sisters | Judge Mathis

[@watchyatone702]

I feel bad for the plaintiff. Drug exposed brains don't process information like healthy brains. That's why she's coming across this way.

[@torijones1347]

Yep I was thinking the same. Sad story all the way around

[@jabarry79]

Yes me too. It sort of made me sad for them watching thIs 🙏🏾

[@Provostialish]

Exactly. As soon as the defendant revealed that the plaintiff was “born with some things,” I automatically knew what was up and said everyone needs to give her some grace.

[@QuilaGee]

Same

[@aquoyahrobinson1630]

Exactly

[@jasmineadamson4570]

Yeah the mother’s action had an effect on the plaintiff mentally she’s not fully aware.

[@shani9165]

I could tell as well.. she kinda looks like it

[@Provostialish]

Unpopular opinion: I *hate* when people make excuses for their parents like the defendant did: “My mom did the best she could do.” *NO SHE DIDN’T* ! Using drugs, especially while pregnant, is NOT the best you can do as a parent. Mom failed them and this is the result.

[@Ms2010collegegurl]

Exactly!

[@Shellygrrl2573]

To be fair, children born addicted to substances( pretty sure since the defendant said she took care of ALL her siblings since the age of 10 all of them were born addicted) have been altered in their brain activity. The one with worse signs is the plaintiff and that's why she is so delusional in her thought process of calling her sister selfish when her sister took her into her home.

[@Provostialish]

@@Shellygrrl2573 I completely agree, which is why I said what I said about their mom. I’m not knocking the plaintiff or defendant. It’s terrible and unfair that they were born and raised under such crappy circumstances.

[@DrinkinCoffeeBih]

@@Ms2010collegegurlyou are such a beautiful woman 🥰🥰🥰

[@CY82960]

She's not making excuses. She's speaking her truth, she was around, and she saw the struggles her mom faced. Doing drugs while pregnant is horrible, but that's doesn't stop you from loving your mother.

[@bestrong8543]

Their mom is 100% liable for how the plaintiff is behaving and this is all a result of their mom abusing drugs while pregnant

[@rosiemiller8531]

Totally facts

[@malknowsitall]

This case was really ridiculous. She is clearly hurting that family needs therapy. Dysfunctional

[@fwb1012]

The plaintiff needs to get speech therapy and regular therapy. Big sister may have some resentment for having to “raise” her from 10 years old😢 This is sad.

[@Holliewood54]

Damn the plaintiff can’t even get a proper sentence out & the defendant a little off too , prime example don’t do drugs while pregnant because this is beyond sad !!!!

[@Lanie-sl9ne]

Sad

[@johnny2bi4]

That’s because she’s trying to lie not drugs. When she’s not thinking of what to say there are no interruptions like at the end

[@JaNaeSmith-vk7uk]

It is hard being the eldest daughter. I feel her.

[@kirkmo1666]

The judge and the audience are out of line. My opinion.

[@torijones1347]

Totally

[@kirkmo1666]

​@@torijones1347JM, should offer counseling. The devil has divided this beautiful family.

[@afropowa1598]

Yeah, he was being real rude to the plaintiff for no reason. That karma came back to him with that divorce.

[@NappyWayz]

Yep

[@TROLLzenbergRAW]

Facts SUPER CLOWNS … and that’s why His ass going thru it now with his wife… his actions was DISGUSTING to this clearly traumatized young black girl …

[@nettricegaskins1871]

When the defendant said her sister had "something in her" when she was born I knew what was coming: her mother was on drugs. This is possibly why she was struggling to recall certain things. The defendant was/is in denial about the mother and she possibly took out her anger and frustration on her younger sister (and son). They all need counseling.

[@sereneamani1713]

What and where was the denial?

[@ldd2112]

Mathis was very mean to the plaintiff for no reason. He failed to realize that every family is different from his family. He reality is her reality.

[@wordplay6665]

Because she started off throwing her sister under the bus

[@sybilwhite1259]

Wow it's so sad the effect the mother's drug use had on the plaintiff 😢 actually the mom's problems effected both her daughters soooooo sad.

[@itscollysworld1389]

Sadder how judge treated her

[@daffeneydaniel9937]

Nah the Judge was very condescending… it’s like he takes things personal and make the case about him.

[@heathab...._-_]

EXACTLY

[@kimberlywinkfield876]

JM is totally outta pocket

[@eleanormcgee1507]

I can’t continue to watch JM bs on this case 😡😡😡😡😡JM clearly see and heard the other sister explaining baby girl diagnoses yet you continue to ridicule baby girl .

[@queennola3039]

I feel so bad for the plaintiff.. 😢

[@theresacoringgray6885]

She seems SOOOOO LOST .....

[@sybilwhite1259]

If the mother is alive someone needs to take her to court for the problems she called her entire family!!!!

[@CY82960]

The daughter seems to love her mother.

[@PrincessZaire100]

@@CY82960daughter is singlur, she has MULTIPLE daughters.

[@CY82960]

I can only speak for the one standing before the judge, the defendant, she seems to love her mom very much,what the plural do , I can't speak on that. Just the singular that I see. Thanks for the English lesson, though much appreciated, I never knew that, so is feet singular and foots plural???? U know like my foots hurts when I walked ?.

[@theresacoringgray6885]

Right

[@patrickyancy7067]

JM is unfit. He mocks a person who obviously is suffering from some sort of disability

[@Angela-hk5io]

Yeah, he can be very mean spirited.

[@DarlinReal]

Because he realized she's unsuccessfully making up stories as she tries to debunk her sister's side of the story.

[@yemedemure414]

Beautiful Sisters! The younger one looks like Fantasia! ❤❤

[@4CQueen]

Yes she does.

[@temdailey]

Yes

[@breeziem4988]

I couldn’t even finish watching because of how he was treating the plaintiff

[@kimberlynoel5635]

This case broke my heart 😢

[@SamuelGriffin-zt1ze]

One of the saddest cases on Judge Mathis

[@4CQueen]

And he thought it was okay to make fun of her, he & the audience made me sick during this case.

[@TROLLzenbergRAW]

Bruhhhhh she was 14 wtf u mean Y SHE GO OVER HER HOUSE TO EAT… JM killlll me thinking knows everything … YOU DONT KNO WHAT THAT GIRL BEEN THRU IN HER LIFE AND U PLAYING WITH HER LIKE ITS FUNNY… DID YA WIFE GIVE U EXAMPLES ON Y SHE DIVORCING u 🤡? How about you explain that? Give us examples… just like we ALL THOUGHT LIFE WAS GOOD FOR U FROM THE OUTSIDE BUT IN REALITY YOU WAS FAILLLLIIINNNGGGGG YOUR MARRIAGE U 🤡 … picking on that young girl who went thru trauma that u JOKING WITH AND PLAYING WITH … u can clearly see she has some type of issues smh

[@sereneamani1713]

At least you identify as what you are. JM's marriage and/or divorce has no connection to this case.

[@eboneep6354]

This is alot to unpack😢

[@747hitman]

this poor young lady has some type of mental issue i believe

[@4CQueen]

She was born with drugs in her system due to her pathetic mother's irresponsible behavior. She probably has ADHD, JM thinks it's funny.

[@pamelajones-meadows7627]

Judge you can't always judge by what you've gone through all families are different...

[@DarlinReal]

Exactly!

[@LeoSun33]

The young girl CLEARLY displays sign of damage from the way she grew up along with mental health issues. Just because the big sister braved through the trauma of the mother doesn’t mean the little sister is able to brave through and look like she has it all together.

[@sereneamani1713]

The big sister did not "brave through the trauma". They and the rest of their family including the children of the big sister have been affected and traumatiizedd.

[@LeoSun33]

@@sereneamani1713 I’m not saying that the big sister has not been traumatized or affected. I’m saying she braved through the trauma because she is putting on a brave mature face for court. The term “brave through…” means to face to endure with courage.

[@CY82960]

Judge Mathis, it's not about u and your family.

[@TROLLzenbergRAW]

Word up him and his family need to be on DIVORCE COURT

[@bajanb3auty2nv]

This case made me cringe… the plaintiff's inability to speak in clear and full sentences…smh

[@Provostialish]

Her mom was using drugs while pregnant with her.

[@bajanb3auty2nv]

@@Provostialish yes I know very sad

[@4CQueen]

She probably has undiagnosed ADHD due to her mother's irresponsible behavior & drug use.

[@shebasanon4936]

It’s not funny to the audience!!

[@getbusydrizzy5296]

MOMMA WAS THE PROBLEM....HER SELFISHNESS IS THE START OF ALL OF THIS

[@krystaperry288]

Lord, JM is so out of touch. He’s the type that would question someone who moved into with a s*x offenders house bc “why would you go”……. I don’t believe the defendant is just sooooo innocent and such a savior. People will treat you terribly but help you bc they have power over you.

[@adriagray9427]

GM clearly sees something off about her and continues to treat her poorly😢

[@tj4970]

I don’t think that but more he’s making her make valid statements not just throw words out there

[@NKAB4]

I was a full time sitter for my sister it’s an 12 yrs age difference…I watched her while my mom worked while she slept while she blinked I was always bbysitting…one day she was off I wanted to go be with my friends she said take her with you…I told her aren’t you off today…she said if I take care you then you need to take care her😧😧😧…tf you’re supposed to take care me I’m not supposed to be your full time sitter…

[@Shellygrrl2573]

Damn. As a mom I say sorry to you for your mother's inability to be one. I hope you have healing and all the love you deserve. My mother did drugs her entire life but had some minimal sense to hand me off to my grandma to raise me. My nana is my mom and I thank everything good that I had her.

[@NKAB4]

@@Shellygrrl2573 I have an older sister &nd she was my safety net when she was home from college…my mom treated me bad cus I loved my dad I’ll admit he wasn’t a great man bt as a chld you don’t know those things…after a while we didn’t want him in the home…bt she came up with every excuse to justify the fact that she wanted him…like we should be happy to have a dad in the home most kds don’t even have a dad etc etc…when enough was enough &nd he was finally gone I would ask about him &nd caught hell…he did the crime I did the time she hated me for loving him…I can’t stop cus she did why would she even expect me to…needless to say I really don’t care for him/her cus throughout the yrs he showed me he never cared &nd to this day she’s still something else…

[@4CQueen]

I forgot how much i can't stand JM's audience, they think everything is so damn funny. There's nothing funny about this case at all.

[@lindawilliams7845]

The plaintiff deserves grace

[@codiestrauss8132]

The Plaintiff couldn't really get her point across i think she was nervous

[@4CQueen]

She did look scared for a minute there.

[@torijones1347]

She put on gloves just to touch her sisters items. Wow that’s next level dislike

[@Shellygrrl2573]

That is a sign of OCD and germaphobia NOT dislike, because she let that hateful girl into her home. I believe the plaintiff took the laptop with her but from the dysfunction of her brain from being born addicted to substances has altered her perception of reality. If someone lets you mooche off them without paying rent or paying for anything, they are not selfish as the plaintiff tried to say.

[@torijones1347]

@@Shellygrrl2573 I mean I’m not in her mind so you might be right. But in my opinion it’s out of dislike of her sister.

[@queennola3039]

The defendant and plaintiff has the same face..

[@kimlewis-yd1jq]

Everybody older and brother and sister ain’t the same . He comparing his older brother to her . Two completely different people

[@LeshaFBaby]

Whole case is sad and parents to blame..and the plantiff is a little throwed and most likely will be used and taken advantage of

[@marysimmons3481]

Wow, that should give that plaintiff some help she has problems

[@datbwoyyeah]

thought that was fantasia at first 😭🤣

[@ronzelljones1979]

I thought the same thing too

[@shavonnasargent1464]

Judge Mathis can be so hypocritical, arrogant, dismissive, and judgemental

[@AndreaMoore-k6z]

This case is a hot mess

[@kimf442]

Right!!

[@meicolar1724]

He can smell a crackhead but refused to address the plaintiff being a victim of her mother's drug use during pregnancy. Something is not right...she needs help.

[@finally97]

JM didn't treat the plaintiff any differently than any other plaintiff making accusations about the defendant. He always challenges them on their assertions. The fact that the plaintiff has obvious deficits doesn't change how he operates. If anything, he was more patient and didn't yell. They all clearly have issues as a result of their mother's addiction and need major therapy. I wonder if the defendant somehow inadvertently holds her sister responsible for everything that followed after she was born with drugs in her system. So much to unpack. Whew!

[@susiesolangesimpson2828]

Off work 🙌🏽 I hope that y’all have a good weekend!

[@loribryant884]

Thank you and you as well ☺️ 😊 🙏

[@Rachel0911]

Come on Fantasia think!!

[@cieraalcy7760]

I believe the plaintiff is extremely ungrateful towards her sister!! What 10 year old child can care for kids!!

[@PrincessZaire100]

“She’s special so she’s special.” She went to another family because her MOTHER WAS ON DRUGS, and the defendant wants them to respect the mother so badly, and no maam she doesn’t.

[@nadiapascal2820]

Exhausted listening to this 🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@1shaymocha]

Im so confused 😕 😫

[@angelphilbert1200]

The Plaintiff has a weird blank stare. All her screws are not screwed on tightly enough. This is sad, really.

[@4CQueen]

She was born with drugs in her system & probably has undiagnosed ADHD or brain damage , it's not her fault that her mother was a drug using POS & it doesn't give JM the right to rip her to pieces on national TV. He was acting like he hit the pipe himself before this court session . 😅😂😅

[@sharonbarnett1828]

They Both needs to Seek Help This is so Sad🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@velishajohnson9011]

The plaintiff has problems expressing herself

[@TheTrapNerdPodcast]

I hate when people say BROUGHT as in purchased lol

[@momaluv0868]

Happy Friday all! Praying for those in Florida ❤❤

[@SamuelGriffin-zt1ze]

All jokes aside this is a very serious matter

[@SamuelGriffin-zt1ze]

Sometimes siblings don't get along from the day they were born up until they became adults

[@Birthdayy52]

😢 it be your own Family

[@Rysofly]

This is one wild ass crazy over the top family.

[@maine4263]

The plaintiff looks like Fantasia

[@shebasanon4936]

Sad case

[@TheTrapNerdPodcast]

LAP LAP LAP LAPTOP NOT LAB

[@carribeanamericanqueen3260]

I had to turn this episode off, couldn’t stomach anymore. The judge being so rude to this young lady. Who both are clearly the product of a drug addicted mother. Have to unsubscribe from this Chanel. Exploiting people pain for entertainment is all I see

[@CNae03]

Exactly very painful to watch

[@MPPG663]

"A pacific example..." 😂😂

[@meicolar1724]

Gloves to pull out her things...I believe the plaintiff 😢

[@KingLeo521]

There are too many excuses being made in these comments for the plaintiff. There are people who go through these same things and turn out to be very successful, stop it.

[@veen0610]

This plaintiff is one of the biggest liars I've seen on the show lol

[@Rysofly]

This is crazy

[@JoannBlanding-dp6ib]

The other sister keeping her mouth. Close

[@cherry0078]

Thanks so much.

[@nyjahbrand1466]

Bringing someone to court and your the true menace is crazy.

[@mahailiabrown3972]

They are all so beautiful. And I hope that the plaintiff wine graduates from school to the whole family can at least forgive each other. And move on, I don't mean that they have to communicate be friends or anything like that, but sometimes a small issue seems big at first until you revisited. Or get older? You know, so I hope that they get some type of help cuz. It seems like there's some underlining issues that it's not really touched upon on here and it shouldn't be and I hope that they all live a life that they are happy with.And if they have children, I hope that their children succeed and live a life that they are also happy with

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

That's a very touching and beautiful message, Mahailia. It feels very comforting. I'm sure they'll appreciate it. All good things to you and yours always. ❤🎉

[@tjbooker9948]

I'll pay their claims and counter claims for them both to shut the hell up.

[@KayB-l5h]

That was a lot 😳

[@urluvizmyluv1999]

They're all beautiful

[@maxinerussell6857]

This young lady is lying lying lying. This better be care of how she treats people. What you do comes back to you. Love Her From Distance.

[@michellebriggs1347]

Judge Mathis should have been able to see her developmental issues smh He’s annoying sometimes

[@angelagray736]

They are pretty young ladies

[@brendawelch6477]

So she can't even explain herself about her sister

[@emiilyjaane7]

Specific NOT pacific... Girl talking about the ocean 😂

[@Fanouvvi]

Hey don’t laugh at her. As we all could tell that there’s a speech impediment in her voice. Knowing that she is a victim of drugs caused by her mom. That’s not 😎

[@DomoniqueTanner-xh2gq]

I love judge mathis but he was being so nasty to the plaintiff

[@karendorsey4780]

The plaintiff was definitely affected by their Mothers drug use. The defendant taking up for the Mother. I get it! But their Mother should be held accountable for her actions! It has affected her children. This is truly a sad case.

[@maryconney-tg1li]

Family ain't ish😢

[@zsamilwest7865]

This is ridiculous!

[@afropowa1598]

The plaintiff's witness is a cutie pie fo sho!

[@paulettestreater6653]

I can't stand the way this dude handles these litigants!!!

[@TalkswithMellow]

Thought judge Mathis would give the plaintiff more grace knowing the mom used drugs while pregnant

[@leannbuggs888]

You claim she was BAD TO YOU, but your but couldn't give Judge mathis one example. Girl please!!

[@elee313]

She can't process her lies the plaintiff

[@MyGoodenessGracious]

Frst off every family dynamic is dffrnt. Wht does u & your brother have to do with her & her sister. JM so weird & self centered.

[@shannonmays5633]

she just lying and making up stories and doing her big sister bogus

[@JoannBlanding-dp6ib]

Very ungrateful

[@yogib8]

How sad…

[@Fanouvvi]

Gab is a manipulator who pretends to be inadequate and speechless. After the case she all vocally says she doesn’t remember what happened to her from ages 3 to 7 years old but while she was in the courtroom she acted as a mute. This family is dysfunctional and needs healing for their souls.

[@mahailiabrown3972]

If they are 10 years apart, how would the little sister? Remember her doing anything for her like raising her at 10 like, you know, cause this is to say I was raising uses, I was 10 years old, that's when she was born. She's not gonna remember that. That's like when family members come up to you and they'd be like I haven't seen you since you as a baby and you would look at them and they were like, you remember and you just look at them and be like, who are you because you don't know them? Like what

[@VANITYISFARE]

You remember who raised you .

[@tratrazy1633]

You remember

[@yokimawhittaker5193]

Did she mean terristic threat?

[@thetallgiirl]

the plaintiff is slow fr

[@quickdrawmcgraw450]

Products of drug and alcohol use