Dewalt Extreme 12V VS Milwaukee Fuel 12V Power Screwdrivers Review and Screw test

[@josephmerz2666]

saw this video when it came out . here i am watching it again .turns out the wobbling chuck on seemly all dewalts is a real game changer to me . very few reviews point out this wobble -but you did . i have 3 impacts and the wobble on all of them is significant . this was a great review you did

[@supremekizzle]

This is the totally wrong application for these tools. You should be doing precision tests for these for a more realistic test. You wouldn't use a 1/4 ratchet to break a crank bolt, would you?

[@Impact-OG]

The point was to drain the batteries, if I had did that test I would have been testing for 12 hours. Thanks for watching

[@Sir_Pants_Alot]

@@Impact-OG this doesn’t even tell you much about the battery life you can expect doing the tasks they’re built for though. There’s different torque required and that creates different battery load. Each tool can and does handle that differently. It’s possible for one to die faster drilling and last longer just driving fasteners because that’s what the motor is geared to do. Think about an mpg test on the highway vs towing a trailer. A turbocharged 4 cylinder gets better gas mileage on a flat highway than a V8. But if you strap on a heavy trailer and go up a grade the V8 will do better. Drilling these holes is the towing scenario. And you’re testing it with Honda Accords. The test is fair. But it doesn’t tell you anything particularly helpful.

[@Rellikman]

Your going to burn out both drivers on larger holes in fast speed. Just saying, this is exactly why I avoid buying used tools. There are gears/speeds for a reason. You also use a brand new paddle but with the Milwaukee first and the bit is worn to be using in the dewalt. Not a fair comparison

[@Toolboss0826]

Just cause it’s the fastest doesn’t mean it’s the best

[@miguelledezma1394]

The fat handle on the m12 line kills it for me. But i would totally like them impact wrenches

[@wallacerickmanii]

I have to agree. As much as it kinda pains me. I’m a Milwaukee guy, but the ergonomics on the 12v line (on things like drills and drivers etc anyway) just don’t cut it for me.

[@Bathtubcrocodile]

I agree. Tried the m12 cd-0 screw driver and it is bulky, top heavy and not small at all. Size except battery is m18. Just a bit shorter in height because of the battery handle than a m18. But the bad grip trade-off kills it for me. And with that in my mind I'd go for the smallest m18 impact wrench rather than the stubby m12. Don't really know the strenght differences between them, but lug nuts should not be a problem. I own the mid torque m18 impact wrench and it's a dream. Almost make changing tires a somewhat enjoyable task.

[@ceddywilliams]

I thought these are screwdrivers not drills??

[@ronyoe]

Why no new bit for the dewalt?

[@Impact-OG]

Because I am cheap and didn't want to spend another $ 20 on drill bits

[@gustavomacall4997]

I know alot of people don't like the handles of the m12 tools but I use xl gloves so I don't find it to be in issue once you get use to the tool .

[@gustavomacall4997]

The perfect solution is to have both 🙂 I'm loyal to both team Red and team Yellow.

[@connerjones4708]

witch one do you like more?

[@RobbertN]

DeWalt

[@rcwildman9255]

I don’t know if it’s the same on this dewalt but on my dewalt 12v drill I put a 5ah battery on it I don’t know if it had a power detect or something on it but it gained a bunch of speed (rpm) no load speed vs the 2ah no load speed.

[@GTRliffe]

you didn’t mention weight? two speed gearbox adds weight and that’s a negative when using all day

[@NarySllim]

I have both. The Milwaukee has its place especially with the 90 degree and offset bit holder but for everyday stuff…..it’s always the dewalt.

[@Impact-OG]

YEs and the Dewalt is lighter to.

[@darrensmith6782]

Bosch screwdriver is the best. Almost half the weight and the same power.

[@NarySllim]

@@darrensmith6782I prefer the ergonomics of the dewalts myself but nothing wrong with Bosch. Power to weight ratio is very good.

[@BobEllis79]

I bought both and kept the DeWalt. The Milwaukee was handy but felt front heavy with the hex and drill chucks and the unit I had would get stuck in between the speeds. Not good for a top of the line tool. For the price of the Milwaukee kit, even on sale, I now have the DeWalt kit plus the matching drill bare tool. Instead of swapping chucks I just grab the other one, I spend a lot of time pre-drilling and then fastening and it's quicker to have two tools ready than one versatile tool for me.

[@27bonegloss]

I have bought both and the Bosch Brushless Flexiclick . The Dewalt has unbeatable ergonomics and is easily the only one for my use.

[@dfs7979]

@@27bonegloss Yep I am in the same boat. I have both the extreme driver and drill. I tried to like the Milwaukee but it is just a mess. Not well balanced, loud, and the reverse button is in the wrong place. I'm currently using the Bosch brushless flexiclick as my daily driver. I hear DeWalt might be dropping a multi-head install driver soon for the 12v platform. hmmm... would I give up the Bosch for that? Not sure. If Festool made a CXS that was brushless and had decent right angle and offset adapters I'd choose that.

[@CCA862]

Thanks for the Great demo. Which tool do you think have better build and last long?

[@Impact-OG]

you know its to early to tell I have both for under 6 months so we will see thanks for watching man

[@hksjoshua]

I got a hold of two of these dcb126 batts at the Moore Oklahoma Lowe's today buy purchasing a dcf902f2 3/8ths impact and a dcd701 drill! Go check your local lowes today!

[@Impact-OG]

Yeah i was just at mine they dont have nothing out for the dewalt 12v tools, nothing thanks for watching man

[@franciscoagosto2447]

Thanks for the video Al! I feel like a more apples to apples would have been the DCF601 vs the Milwaukee screwdriver. Still enjoyed the video. I wanted the Milwaukee (installation) for the longest time, went and tested it in store. Didn't like it one bit (the handle). Went with the Dewalt! Keep the videos coming!!

[@Toolboss0826]

100 percent agree that’s why I like dewalt. The Milwaukee handles are too big

[@frosty0419]

Why were you using the drill head.? The Milwaukee comes with a head that locks the bits in.

[@Impact-OG]

Yep I realized that after I had filmed, I just grabbed the head the was out in the shop with me, all the others were inside hahaha

[@frosty0419]

@@Impact-OG lol. I was wondering. Keep it up!

[@Impact-OG]

@@frosty0419 Thanks buddy, The full review of the Milwaukee installation tool will be out later.

[@frosty0419]

@@Impact-OG I have it. That’s how I knew. I wasn’t sure at first about the purchase but after using it I love it. Perfect for its purpose. The little impact is sometimes too powerful. This tool is perfect of poser and precision especially in those had to reach places and corners.

[@RedRyz3n]

my 2402 randomly stops working as though its running low on battery which it isnt. I use it almost everyday for basic screwdriver things. I have the hammer m12 and m18 for hardcore stuff as well as this install driver which has it's place. I think I'm gonna get this dewalt as my main screwdriver. Extremely disappointed.

[@smc65714]

Apples to Oranges here,Proved nothing ,but ,People really abuse their tools!

[@Impact-OG]

Yeah man I don't know people seem to like to watch it. thanks for watching man

[@dtbmjax]

So a new bit when starting out with the Milwaukee and it "used" when testing on the Dewalt. Nope. Bad testing criteria.

[@J.Wick.]

No loyalty here. My tool bag looks like a skittles bag. If i had to pick a favorite, it'd be Metabo HPT for most things, followed by Kobalt in the 18-24V Range for the fill-in tools. As far as 12V, I have both Dewalt and Milwaukee...Be hard to pick a favorite there. I like them both. I'd probably side with Dewalt if they offered more tools in the 12V line. They are more comfortable, but Milwaukee has just about everything in 12v....Ive also tried Bosch 12V, they were nice also. But the line just isn't there.

[@MrBostonBilly]

What kind of challenge is this, if your going to use the drill chuck on one, then use it on both and you are use spase bits in a quick connect this is just a farce not a fair challenge in anyway dont waist people's time

[@baldurivar]

Dammit! I have been looking for a video that compares Dewalt dcf601 to Milwauke 2401-20. Why are you comparing apples to oranges! This Milwaukee 4in1 is comparable to the Dewalt 5in1 tool. This DCF601B screwdriver should be put up against the 2401-20.

[@AbulHussain-hh9rg]

Tight spaces and precision driving.

[@Synister_one]

If you are comparing them against each other then should be tested as they come. If it causes extra time because they only have a magnet retention. Then that should be reflected in the time. Also when the Milwaukee cut out you did not use it's time from that and started over. Using that time and the poor chuck design the Dewalt would have surpassed the Milwaukee

[@greenmonster3285]

Goodmorning RYOBI POWER!!!

[@lilbigdaddy3042]

So no power?

[@Impact-OG]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@brandocommando4459]

Lol funny you say that. My boss gave me an 18v Ryobi drill to use... One the battery died I used by 12v DeWalt and the power from it (half the size too) was a massive difference.

[@wayneminzey6990]

Nice video Al

[@loucifer4205]

I don't know why Milwaukee has that handle in the front it would be so much more compact

[@Techprep23]

They tried to copy festool

[@loucifer4205]

@@Techprep23 that's all they do is copy

[@Techprep23]

@@loucifer4205 and they wonder why the consumers wish every other name brand would make a 12 volt line I'm not a fan of Milwaukee's 12 volt line at all ergonomics are disaster Milwaukee thinks too highly of themselves and they're too expensive. I'm perfectly happy with my DeWalt Xtreme 12 volt tools I have bought. I have the impact driver the 3/8 impact wrench which is basically the impact driver but a 3/8 anvil same motor same power settings at the top of the tool. I also have the 12 volt extreme half inch drive impact wrench with 250 foot pounds tightening 350 or 400 foot pounds removal works wonders on lug nuts. I barely touch my rigid 18 volt collection.

[@loucifer4205]

@G K I can't stand the battery in the handle. The only tool where the battery in handle works is the ratchets, I have almost every 12v dewalt extreme and they're great almost never use my 20v tools anymore

[@Techprep23]

@@loucifer4205 I had the rigid 12 volt set the impact driver and drill really my first foray into name brand power tools so I didn't know any better at the time. They were the exact same setup as Milwaukee 12 volt battery in the handle. The grip is fat as hell. I wear a medium sized glove as a 6 ft 300 lb man so I have small hands and they're impossible to use. I was not paying Makita prices for the lack of power that they're 12 volt line offers in comparison to other brands. So on a whim I got the DeWalt 12 volt xtreme. They're impact driver was 1450 inch pounds compared to the 1200 inch pounds Makita offered. It was $130 bucks for the kit the impact driver two 2 amp hour batteries charger in a bag. Makita wanted 180 dollars for their impact driver a2 amp hour battery charger in a bag. I like that the DeWalt had speed settings as well and one of them being the auto cut off when the tool senses it needs to activate the hammer it shuts off. Go to my buddy's houses all I bring is my 12 volt and a 5 amp hour battery because they really do come alive with a 5 amp hour battery compared to the 2 amp hour battery they're fantastic I love that 12 volt half inch impact wrench I want the one in 3/8 as well.

[@Sharps_and_i_edc]

Why not just use the 1/4 hex haha

[@Impact-OG]

I realised that after I filmed it, 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@blaquejaque9702]

You cheated DeWalt stopping mid drill and by not giving it a new paddle bit too

[@prestigemechanical1145]

Made for HVAC guys

[@g.ramirez9241]

Redo with new dewalt 5ah

[@Impact-OG]

I would if I still had them. I have sold about $2,000 worth of tools in the last month. Thanks for watching

[@g.ramirez9241]

@@Impact-OG I was only wanting to see what the dewalt could do with the 5ah battery before purchasing but ended up purchasing and is way more powerful than I expected by far quieter and just as fast as my impact thanks again !

[@eltigreoo]

So Milwaukee 114 and dewalt 91 and you only have 50 holes 🤣🤣😂😂😂😂

[@Impact-OG]

That is just one peice of wood, 🪵 lol i cut out most of the boring stuff. Thanks for watching

[@wax-ecstatic]

whoa dude.. chill out with that intro. save that for them loud ass teenagers

[@Impact-OG]

That wasn't loud, and if I talk slow, then people say I'm boring. I can't win. Thanks for watching

[@mikevee6992]

Use the hex head !!!!!

[@redbugg99]

Stay off the drugs

[@sncat]

🙂)) clown

[@DanielGomez-cf6vk]

Team red all day hate default

[@loucifer323]

So you favor China over America Milwaukee is owned by China Dewalt is a American company

[@DanielGomez-cf6vk]

@@loucifer323 dewalt has gone downhill when the 20 volt line released

[@loucifer323]

@@DanielGomez-cf6vk Milwaukee has gone downhill since it was bought by TTI a Chinese company

[@conspiraciesexposed7760]

@@DanielGomez-cf6vk ??? Dewalts the best