Did Man Rent under False Pretenses? | Part 2

Were sublessors Carolina and her boyfriend Michael authorized to let Jamar move into their place?
The Original! There’s only ONE Judge Judy. Visit our website for where to watch, weekdays.
Subscribe to Judge Judy on KZbin: / @judgejudy
#JudgeJudy

[@lightspeedlees9399]

Bro shouted objection like he was playing Pheonix Wright 😂

[@Itshills]

😂😂😂 I had to sit down from how hard this made me laugh

[@MrsReese-ur6hh]

😂😂😂😂

[@djanime317]

NOT PHOENIX WRIGHT 😂😂😂😂😂

[@brucevarnes978]

OMG I love those games.

[@DreAAJ]

Only the real 1's knows who that is 😂

[@JJPrizeDistributionComittee]

"I broke a rule, not a law!" Yeah, that's why you lost. Nobody was trying to throw you in jail, you know!

[@ceeedwards8453]

"I broke a rule, not the law"?... Ok she's in a select group where law is not applicable...

[@stevelozano9523]

That gentlemen that was "supposedly" in the business for 15 years didn't know he wasn't suppose to sublet? They were just trying to scam the landlord. Landlord should sue them for breach.

[@justfixitsolutions]

lol i broke a rule not the law!!

[@jhutch1681]

Still wrong. Disrespectful, self serving, dishonest, and very entitled. Wrong.

[@Shadyangel86]

When she said that I rolled my eyes so damn hard they might be stuck 😂

[@amklacko]

Man, everyone here is annoying

[@polkadots2823]

That's hearsay! 😂

[@anndeecosita3586]

Objection. 😂

[@evonza4858]

Including the judge 🤔

[@truelife974]

The lack of self control.

[@thomasludwig9117]

The plaintiff was trying like hell to piss Judge Judy off.

[@iykeharrison9161]

Seriously he was starting to piss me off. He was winning but just couldn't shut up

[@peryole]

He successfully pissed me off, he was annoying and the green card thing was more annoying.

[@meilease4851]

That's why she took control the way she did - she wasn't gonna deal with his crap.

[@aaa-pp]

He will make a good lawyer😅

[@L.Spencer]

Objection! I wonder if people watch Perry Mason to prepare for being on JJ.

[@peryole]

Both parties were super annoying. Him shuffling through the papers and the defendant claiming hearsay when he's standing right there!...such an ignoramus.

[@kevine.lemaster8473]

I couldn't believe he said hearsay. Had no idea what he's talking about

[@liveliketima1743]

The hearsay sent me to the moon because why would he say that 😂😂😂

[@c.j.williams513]

😂😂😂 Right!!😂😂 You can tell they were waiting for this moment for them to look like lawyers!!! Failed miserably!!

[@c.j.williams513]

​@@liveliketima1743😂😂😂

[@polkadots2823]

That's hearsay! Objection! 😂😂😂😂😂

[@Nevaeh1]

They had no business subletting

[@sjean8306]

Objections and hearsay…..this episode didn’t disappoint 😂

[@chrizrglass]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@holckylondon]

So funny 😂

[@LilMissNichole]

“I broke a rule, not a law!” Lady, why else do people go to court???

[@mariatomas8220]

😂😂😂😂

[@nicoledillard7358]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@jeffreyclinard2002]

Please don't interrupt Judy when she's giving the other party the business. It only makes her mad at best, and will get your claim dismissed at worse.

[@trekgirl65]

He lost at the beginning of the case.

[@mikellwells3286]

"I broke a rule not a law" NO! A LEASE IS A *LEGALLY BINDING AGREEMENT* key word legally. It makes it law.

[@citytrees1752]

Yes, this wasn't criminal court, but that doesn't mean you aren't a law breaker. It's like saying speeding isn't breaking the law.

[@trekgirl65]

there was no lease on an illegal sublet room.

[@dragastarr2926]

@@trekgirl65They are talking about the defendants’ lease; they broke their lease by trying to illegally sublet.

[@mikellwells3286]

@@dragastarr2926 thank you. This.

[@jimmyfinchum79]

Guy said objection like he was on Matlock

[@GAS.M3]

Lol “objection your honor”..🤦‍♂️ This guy watches too many movies..😂😂 Male Defendant reminds me and sounds like Squidward..😂

[@_PAIGE94]

😂😂

[@brocktoon8]

Squidward!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 🤣😂🤣😂

[@djanime317]

Squidward or Megamind 😂😂😂😂😂

[@Crazycatlady71]

Squidward! Yes! I've been racking my brain trying to think of who the male defendant reminded me of and it's Squidward! Thank you!

[@NOCALGooN916]

This was a funny case both defendant and plaintiffs watched to much law and order 😂

[@anitaclue9868]

😂😂😂

[@ishahcanah7351]

😂

[@seashellesbelles7232]

People are so dumb thinking the word objection is used to say, “I disagree!” Um, no. First of all, you can’t just say objection in court. You have to state the type of objection you are making. “Hearsay, Argumentative, Leading, Speculation, Asked and Answered, Facts not in Evidence, etc.” Saying just the word “objection” would get you nowhere and laughed at.

[@serpentvert]

Why would you sublet unpermitted and then keep the plaintiff's deposit when he got kicked out? Pure scam.

[@Nevaeh1]

@@serpentvert the same reason why they weren’t giving the rent they were collecting from him to their landlord

[@shontae445]

Judge judy's famous words " I don't care"!!😂

[@trinity72gp]

Defendants don't have clean hands - so no help from JJ with the deposit!

[@trinity72gp]

I broke a rule not the law! 😂 Cost you a grand on JJ though 👩🏻‍⚖️

[@angelinahorskin1406]

It actually cost Judge Judy lol they are the ones who pay for it… I was going to go on there. You both get $500 for going and if you win then Judy pays it up to 10k if im not mistaken

[@johnsmi213]

@@angelinahorskin1406 They both get $250 appearance fee and up to $5000 judgment.

[@gingerbreadgreeneyes]

⁠@@angelinahorskin1406i think you’re right about everything else but the payment. she pays up to $5k on this show and $10k on judy justice

[@SuperGem1979]

What did he take from an unfurnished apartment?

[@cuprunnethover2]

You got to be kidding me when she said I broke a rule and not the law! Smh

[@HH-gc4xq]

People are watching too many TV attorney shows. "Objection, your honor"😂

[@BotheredBittyEstherBoo]

Plaintiff yelling “objection” as if they were in criminal court. 😂 this ain’t law and order buddy

[@Julie-sl8ul]

Three knuckleheads. JJ earned every penny 😂

[@evonza4858]

She's a knucklehead herself 🤭

[@andrewlee6025]

I’m convinced that before their hearing, the plaintiff watched too many law and order episodes with the objection and seeking ‘legal’ apartment and the defendant watched too few JJ episodes to misuse ‘that’s hearsay’.

[@jernigan007]

KAREN IS BUSTED !!

[@shaneclark5022]

:shiny-butt-green-pants:

[@apollonia-ava]

Which part of “SHUT UP” !! does the plaintiff not understand ? 😂

[@PrePre_]

To the plantiff: Does it look like you're losing? Be quiet 🙃

[@nepodidon]

Objection your honor!!

[@nancygreen1655]

The parties in the “illegal sublet” case think they are lawyers in a regular court!” “😂 “that’s hearsay” “I object”. 😂

[@nkemazikiwe3426]

The entitlement of the defendants is baffling

[@truegrizzlesfan2292]

Someone watch too much law and order 😅

[@idontno0]

One guy yells "objection!" And the other is trying with "hearsay" and tries ro throw in the "ive been in business for 15yrs but I'm subletting an apartment illegally".

[@edwinungerer7989]

That would make for the perfect isekai anime title

[@chrizrglass]

All of these people are annoying-plaintiff and defendants

[@bettyt8092]

I don’t know. They were both annoying lol

[@stratfordbaby]

Plaintiff was superbly annoying.

[@Sara.Rose.]

Lady with the gold necklace is back

[@darlenefraser3022]

OMG!!! 😂😂😂

[@Kaboomboo]

It _is_ a nice necklace.

[@thomasludwig9117]

You mean Cleopatra?

[@brocktoon8]

Facial expression lady 😂

[@darlenefraser3022]

@@Kaboomboo Right? It catches my eye every time because I’d like one just like it!

[@heyheyitsred]

Both men/parties are trying too hard to outsmart each other! It’s irritating.

[@antoniomanson165]

“You’re a tough learner” ima use that on my employees

[@JaymiLei]

The male defendant standing there looking like used car salesman.. saying he's been "in the business".. business of getting evicted from rented apartments and trying to get out of it by illegally subletting? Even if the plaintiff put holes in the walls before he left, it wouldn't matter because they weren't supposed to have had him sublet in the first place. Period.

[@Nan-59]

She broke a rule, not a LAW ! And she paid for it too!!!🎉🎉🎉🎉😊

[@paulheath8073]

Why is Defendant #1 still talking about the stolen TV? The plaintiff doesn't have your TV, you can't say false, negative, slander comments when the case is won, and your nonsense counterclaim was dismissed, you were 🚫 suing for stolen property, the only thing you were counterclaim for was rent

[@billmoran3219]

Plaintiff doesn’t understand he’s winning yet he’s still trying to sabotage his own case! Lady at the end, I broke a rule not a law , well the law sure was against you and sunk you case !

[@VioletWings1353]

Lady, each state has laws regarding subletting. They aren't just "rules" as she stated. 😂

[@Khxrmx3]

Love how the plaintiff kept talking when he wasn’t supposed to

[@FrostBite-kl7pf]

give that man his rent money back

[@Nevaeh1]

He’s not entitled to a rent refund because he lived there those months. He’s only entitled to his security deposit back.

[@FrostBite-kl7pf]

@@Nevaeh1 he got something back

[@lazkid220]

so he should live there for free?

[@FrostBite-kl7pf]

@@lazkid220 i agree 💯

[@HeyCoachBarbara]

The defendants boyfriend brought no value to this case. 😭🤣🤣🤣

[@omabeautybar9769]

The lady in the back 0:13 ooooo girl I did the same 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@TheYounghoney]

That guy must have watched law and order before coming to court😂

[@circa1720]

Correct! Correct! Correct! Correct! Correct! ..........

[@CanadianAnglican]

Lol they thought they were getting free money.

[@ashleywhite3310]

“I broke a rule, not the Law” 🤦‍♀️ that says everything!!

[@swampthing5183]

I object 😅😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 I'm glad i woke up at 3 am to watch this 😄

[@joshuahamilton2441]

Someone need to get the defendants a dictionary.

[@kenmattel7292]

The plaintiff swears he is Jack MaCoy lmao 😂

[@Elijah-bj8pv]

You’re a tough learner 😂😂😂😂😂 I cantttt

[@israelcm7246]

Don't mess with Judge Judy 😂😅

[@I_am_enigma53]

I really don't like the plaintiff. Or the defendants. None of these people have a moral compass.

[@drtr4uma626]

My dude owns the world’s longest tie.

[@psoteriou3884]

Lol just noticed it😅

[@MichaelJones-yx4zv]

So patient jeeze

[@kmallory100]

The defendant said he had "15 years in the busniness." What business? Lol

[@cynthiatrivella4445]

She "broke the rule and not the law." She must think JJ just arrived here to the planet Earth.

[@kia4334]

I knew she was lying from her face. 😂

[@vernonscloset]

The Plaintiff IS SO ANNOYING!

[@BumblebeeKisses]

It was like watching a bad rendition of Perry Mason smh

[@Skyline201992]

I’m convinced that the people that see JJ. Don’t watch JJ 😂

[@Elijah-bj8pv]

11:59 🕰️ 😂😂😂😂😂 lord Jesus help us please 😂😂😂

[@dubemccready7438]

The arrogance of these defendants in last case - having the gall to sublet, illegal no permission from landlord. She says we did not do anything wrong??

[@alexajones7453]

They had leftover furniture in an “unfurnished” apartment

[@alexajones7453]

And if he paid for furniture it’s his?!?!

[@anndeecosita3586]

This was a weird case that didn’t entirely make sense.

[@musicjunkie274]

These people watched too many courtroom dramas before they came on

[@miriamkivlehan3498]

No ma'am...when you broke the T&Cs of a LEGALLY BINDING contract - you BROKE COMMON LAW! Exuberant plaintiff and dishonest defendants

[@Rantsack]

When people think they’re lawyers, it still doesn’t see that they’re not losing. What idiots.

[@phoenixrising1242]

Not a $5 thief. 😂😂😂

[@nora4981]

0:11 I don’t know why the defendants face here and later Byrd’s face crack me up 😂… granted I think this was the time Byrd’s wife was having brain cancer

[@samanthaproctor6370]

I didnt know his wife had brain cancer

[@dwaynesmith9482]

The rule was the law genius

[@Orcl1100]

Objection your honor! 😂

[@kgrimes842]

I broke a rule not a law! Uh lady that lease is a LEGAL contract! You did break the law. Just because you don't go to jail for something doesn't mean it's just a rule 🤦

[@sarabpreetkaur3360]

Scammers all of them.

[@sammyjo8109]

She definatly knew she as in the wrong!! Just a cry baby because she wanted money for cleaning etc. she would have been charged had they completed their lease or been evicted which was happening anyway. Since he was "in the business" so long he also knew exactly wat they were doing and that they could not sublease. JJ ruled correctly. I feel sorry for the couple who had to hurry to find another apt.

[@sss1298]

1900 a month for a room is WILD

[@vashonm]

Bro come ready he was not playing games lol

[@trinity72gp]

Let's see......

[@weirdnomad8868]

"I broke a rule, not the law" tells me everything I need to know about her

[@Phyoomz]

Nah, u call me a thief on national television, get ready for this defamation suit.

[@Shining1-l6v]

Wow, you’re a major snowflake.

[@pontiac38gm]

Plantiff: your honor i... JJ: bup bup!!! Did i ask you anything?! 😅

[@dominikmuller5021]

This case is a great example why multimillionaires shouldn't judge normal people. Someone on a green card might be looking for a "legal appartment" and I really wish she'd looked at the lease agreement to figure out if it stated that he was supposed to be added to the lease.

[@Seacret_Agent]

She read his complaint which stated he knew that subletting was not allowed in their lease, and while he states otherwise in court, his sworn statement says that he knew he was leasing the apartment illegally, which is why she didn't need to look at his copy of his lease. The other lease from the defendants was not provided, so she could not view that one. She ruled in favor of the plaintiff to receive his deposit back, so I'm not sure what you are mad about? He received what he was suing for?

[@dominikmuller5021]

@@Seacret_Agent His argument although not clearly stated was that he was supposed to be added to the lease and that he was therefore not illegally subletting when managment advised him that it was in fact illegal to sublet. If you listen back to that section on part one you'll learn that.

[@dragastarr2926]

@@dominikmuller5021Even if that was his intention (which I believe was), he knows now after moving out that he was never added to the lease so why would he get all of his money back?

[@laurasaw6933]

I like that she said I broke a rule not the law

[@jamesdietz29]

Plaintiff was so amped up he wasn't listening to JJ.

[@Alice-fr1ef]

Do not speak when you are winning and have evidence of everything. Educate them Judge Judy. They need it.

[@MaleOrderBride]

Hmm what happened to "the doctrine of clean hands coming to court"?😮 the plaintiff KNEW he was breaking the law by sub-letting an apartment. Judy usually says people who break the law don't get any money?😮

[@marianaya5824]

The male defendent looks like the villain from Lemony Snickets... 👀 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@5600abcdefg]

Defendants are unethical; knowingly lied to their landlord and broke their lease. JJ should have given everything back to the plaintiff.

[@channeltopone636]

nguoi gio da noi nhung thu khong hay voi minh trong ho that su khong mot su thich dep. Nguoi phu nu hoa do that su kha la hay

[@taltamir]

The plaintiff seemed to be twitching and shaking. I was wondering if he was on some sort of stimulant when it was filmed... Also man kept on interrupt JJ while he was winning. Here she is tearing the defendants a new one and he has to interrupt her.

[@mamathemeat]

He probably did steal some stuff cuz he was angry 😂 oh well that’s what happens when you play stupid games you win stupid prizes

[@misssharon6718]

Plaintiff said the craigslist ad said sublet so he did know it was subleasing.

[@LeoLeo-ni1mf]

The plaintiff came prepared 😊

[@allison6783]

JJ is so fair 👏

[@Rantsack]

People need to learn to organize and use a fking bookmark or tab to separate all the papers. Instead of digging through ALL the papers to give JJ what she DID NOT asked for

[@Rushyesgenesis]

2:04 I don’t care (Woman laughs in background) 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@user-rf5vp4uc2e]

Depends on the state…JJ could be wrong! If she is not allowed to sublet that may not hold in terms of agreement between the two? That is an assumption by JJ?

[@antoniofransch971]

$700 dollar deposit ...$700 dollar deposit .......$700 dollar deposit ........i😅😅😂😂😂

[@sconex8072]

It’s funny how Judy fanboys are salivating over the plaintiff saying objection and defendant saying hearsay claiming they watch too much tv. It’s almost as if Judge Judy isn’t an actual courtroom 😊. Is that what we are saying…??😂