Did Winona Ryder Hate Heathers the Musical?

It’s story time!
Listen to these stories and try to decipher the two truths and one lie.
Instagram:
Ryan - @ mccarya
Samantha - @ Samantha_Fekete
@samandryan
Sam's Book, Nightstand Notes: a.co/d/4Wf31uW
We're Sam & Ryan! Samantha Fekete is a content creator/production manager who works full time at Spellbound Inc. Ryan McCartan is an actor who you may recognize as Diggie from Disney Channel's Liv and Maddie, JD from Heathers the Musical, Hans from Frozen on Broadway, and more! We create content to entertain and inform. Subscribe to take a deep dive into out content! If you subscribe, you officially become Daddy, a part of the best fan base out there.

[@abby04g30]

I’m gonna guess the stalker was the lie, because you seemed very passionate about the white trenchcoat and I feel a theatre that small would DEFINITELY break fire codes for people like that 😂😂😂😂😂

[@usayitwedoit9180]

Him describing the JD plot of Heathers really clears up how crazy he was, despite it seeming all somewhat normal when you watch. We were brainwashed too. 😂

[@shannon.a.smithh]

There is no way you made Billy Crystal or Winona Ryder sit on a stool for a whole musical! Surely it was a chair or something lol. That’s my vote for lie 😂

[@_RealCharlotteMorningstar_]

Same

[@caitcassar9695]

Agreed. I think Winona saw it in New York instead.

[@GamerKAndGamerE]

I agree

[@mus1c_lov3r]

It took me until this video to realize Ryan got to meet Chris Slater and I am now VERY jealous 😭

[@adalinebisciglia4989]

love the sam and colby profile pic

[@mus1c_lov3r]

@@adalinebisciglia4989 Thankssss

[@polyamorus_potato]

Same here

[@moviemelody2210]

A guy playing a high school student that’s got nothing between his ears and a high school student that’s a psychopath at the SAME TIME?! Wow that’s impressive

[@olymperambles]

you talking about JD not being as a ghost in the end of Heathers makes me think about how, for the closing night of the uk tour earlier this year, Jacob Fowler (JD) was there with Kurt, Ram and Heather C. in the end... so I think (and hope) the stalker one is the lie because thats just creepy.

[@marissaconklin5098]

Goodness if that stalker story is true, that's terrifying...

[@jacksonhoopah]

yep... can relate

[@janelleannelisegodley9325]

i was honestly worried that we would never get to find out which stories were true and which one was false, sooooo very much looking forward to the next installment of this little series 😅

[@VeronicaSawyer.]

Ok I hope heather isn’t here because I just saw her somewhere

[@heatherchandlers]

SURPRISE

[@VeronicaSawyer.]

@@heatherchandlersoh no

[@heatherdukeswifeandgirlfriend]

the girls are fighting

[@VeronicaSawyer.]

@@heatherdukeswifeandgirlfriendwhat is with the username

[@heatherdukeswifeandgirlfriend]

@@VeronicaSawyer. nothing.

[@ROCKYHORRORHURRAH]

6:00 About jd being the antagonist. Literally every heathers fan I’ve ever talked to (online or irl) don’t hate jd. Like of course we hate him when hes making Veronica sad or killing her friends but all the other times we adore him

[@sus1e62]

I think the lie is either the stalker story or the white trench coat, although i do think that would be a look for JD. Also Ryan curly hair supremacy

[@NicoNeoX]

At the end of the very recent UK tour (2023) Jacob (JD's actor) came out on the balcony at the end, but in the usual outfit, he did this at the last 2 shows of the tour (which I was lucky enough to witness both live)

[@noodlearg9745]

they all seem very believable but i’m going to say the trench coat story was the lie

[@mwmheps]

Oooh interesting concept and fun stories! I'm gonna say the second one contains the lie and something's off about it, either it wasn't Billy Crystal or you didn't break the fire codes or something :D

[@marissaconklin5098]

Creative way to share stories with us, cool!

[@silshine]

its the costume designer, amy clark did the costume design for heathers, genevieve tyrell for liv and maddie. i may be wrong but im a costume design nerd lol

[@maizefraga4274]

Noooooo, i thought he was gonna say witch one was the lie at the end, now I'm super curious

[@user-vj6zw9ib7u]

4 minutes after posing! just what i needed- another sam and ryan content

[@ashleydavis1611]

I LOVE this video idea! Please keep doing them!!!!

[@DuelaCypher]

I hope that the lie was the stalker but I feel like it was the trenchcoat

[@wilhelminaharker6417]

I don't know if it's that I'm really gullible or that you're an amazing storyteller (I guess kinda both) but every story seems to be truthing! So I'm gonna say the last one, because it seems maybe a little too much Can't wait to hear your other stories! P.S love your sweater

[@heatherrockwell9012]

Good lord your hair is gorgeous today. I love this video concept!

[@Ksawy-lf4tz]

Thanks you for talking about Heather I needed that

[@kaylam1491]

I'm not a big commenter, but I need you to know that this was a lot of fun. Really good idea for a style of video, and incentive to come back later.

[@jennifercordova3847]

Yeiii !! New video ! Haopy for thisss 🎉❤

[@polyamorus_potato]

I would've loved to see the white trenchcoat at the end! I will probably draw it sometime, that sounds so amazing.

[@user-sj8gj2jt1q]

I vote fire codes was a lie. the white trenchcoat is brilliant and the stalker story is super detailed and terrifying to be a lie

[@saturn8413]

ryan to the white trenchcoat: you were meant to be mine!! Also, rip white trenchcoat

[@limeamongus]

At first I was like "is this clickbait?" because I had read that Winona Ryder saw the original Joe's Pub workshop and was so moved by it... but I was kind of wrong?

[@kellyjenkins9398]

I literally just realized Ryan was on Liv and Maddy... My sister was watching it and his face just popped up. I was so confused hahaha

[@dgm01994]

The stalker and the trench coat has to be the two truths. Breaking fire code is the lie in my opinion

[@HeatherChandler-up5ug]

The white Trenchcoat would have looked so good! You sounded very passionate about the Trenchcoat, so imma say that’s true but I’m not sure about the others

[@kendylteixeira6745]

Rip J.Ds white trench coat

[@emmahoward9042]

I feel like it would be like Ryan to make the lie a small detail in one of the stories lol. My best guess is that Christian Slater also saw Heathers in Hollywood and not in New York like he said. But if it is just one of the big three, I feel like the stalker is the least likely. Or at least it wasn't that serious.

[@nicoletrudell2065]

There was coverage in Broadway media of Christian seeing the show in New York.

[@ph.stolensky2385]

The story with Winona was so colorable, it seems like totally true. If something looks very truish it`s a lie, so i guess Ryan made his howework well and that story`s made-up

[@delfgallast]

OMG this was just what i needed

[@VeronicaSawyer.]

Omg a copy of me

[@delfgallast]

@@VeronicaSawyer. hi barbie

[@VeronicaSawyer.]

@@delfgallast we the same person I’m not surprised because it’s a Sam and Ryan video

[@delfgallast]

@@VeronicaSawyer. fr we are like twins or something

[@VeronicaSawyer.]

@@delfgallast i know it crazy

[@chrisoulalakkas7935]

Never angry. Be in control. Be in power.

[@Knockoutt126]

I believe all of these but I’ll say trench coat bc I’ll be DEVASTATED if they really cut such a cool idea. I love the video concept tho, I can’t wait for the next one!

[@ashlikesart]

My guess is that the stalker wasnt a lie, superfans can be crazy Ik winona ryder did see the show at some point, im pretty sure ive seen pictures of her with the off broadway cast but i think the bit about the other dude (bill cristal?) May have been a lie- or at least a half truth. The white trenchcoat could also be a lie, as although ryan did seem passionate about it, he is an actor. Its kind of his job to pretend and convice people he isnt. Something about that seems slightly untruthful Can't wait for the next video when the answers revealed!

[@sxys.]

LOVE THIS HAHAHA❤

[@penguin._.pudding]

maybe the second one cause it seems pretty simple but there may be a part of it that isnt true

[@emily3254]

I feel like the other person you broke fire codes for wasn't billy crystal

[@Measuresderepo]

Stalker was the lie, ‘cause where did the son go?

[@emjackson7298]

i lovee this idea so much, my guess is the white trench coat, i kind of believe them all though!💜

[@stxr_grl]

I think that the first one is the lie. Either that one or the stalker one… I’m probably wrong tho lmao

[@Janatje]

RIP white trench coat

[@Readwithbrooklyn]

yay! were with dad today( i love mom though too)

[@Nicks_dr.Pepper]

I guess we are with dad today😊

[@Tiklemonstr]

I think the second story was real until you said that the actor of JD in the original movie also saw the musical adaptation

[@MiLe-ql9ol]

But he did tho, they took some pictures with him and everything lmao

[@katiestroodle]

hair do be hairing

[@disasterd0lls]

I KNEW IT WAS THE FIRST ONE BECAUSE VERONICASHOOTS JD AND VERONICA RUNS OUTSIDE WITH THE BOMB

[@lucaskelso7954]

I have one question I think you would know the answer since you were the original JD so like how did Veronica find JDs address

[@cursedkaleidoscope]

I feel like it could easily be a lie that you only broke fire code once so I'm going with fire code is the lie

[@shayne7994]

rip white trenchcoat 😢

[@arwenford2554]

I think white trench coat because don’t think ryan would want to see JD angelic as he didn’t like him.

[@MissLaurenLipstick]

I agree

[@littlefeeblefrogman]

Im loving the divorced parents vibe of the channel rn

[@user-vz3ws3wi8d]

RIP ;(

[@NotATheatrePerson]

hey, i just auditioned for my school musical and was cut. i thought this would be a good place to share because a lot of you would be part of the theatre community. i’ve never been cut in a show before and i just want to know if any of you have tips on how to cope. when i saw the cast list i had a panic attack and now im hiding in my school bathroom, what would you guys do?

[@claire-mckenna2561]

okay just stumbled upon this, so it's def late but I would 100% recommend joining stage crew. so much fun and a great way to stay connected in the theater community:)

[@NotATheatrePerson]

thanks, i’m doing production team now, and. i found another show to audition for in a month or two! i really appreciate you taking time out of your day to respond to my comment!!

[@-CHILD_OF_APPOLO-]

RIP white trench coat we will miss you

[@evaHoltk]

Rip white trenchcoat

[@mariabelenvargassanmartin2314]

hmm i think the 3rd story is the lie, he started swinging his chair back and ford when he started telling it (but if it wasn't then I am so sorry that happened to you, that must have been so scary)

[@JermyaBurgest-wt2sq]

I think that it is the stalker what is a lie

[@CanadianChick811]

There was no stool. That's insanity. I don't think a theatre would let you break fire code for the President.

[@TheaterKidThatLovesHeathers]

I feel like there was something off about the second story!

[@christianthompson3926]

Fire codes is a lie...I suppose a theater could have that happen, maybe even on purpose, but I seriously doubt the actors or anyone else involved in the production would have any reason to know (or care) about building codes or occupancy codes.

[@GiaBlinks]

Did Billy show up spontaneously? That a seat would not have been available? A potential investor would have made arrangements, and would have been in communication with someone.

[@lilytremble2937]

I feel like it’s the second one there’s just so much that could have been the lie

[@LouieDog55]

Can’t play or it would be cheating 😏😜

[@theravenstag804]

I'm guessing the 1st story holds the lie.

[@thomasheyes5747]

I want to say it was the last one

[@jacquiesilvestri8402]

I feel like the lie was the breaking fire code, and it was just the person that was changed, Billy Crystal was another famous person

[@-MischaMayhem]

RIP for the white trench coat

[@Fan_Girl_Channel]

What happened to hi daddy 😭😭😭😭

[@sarebear7777]

RIP tableau trenchcoat

[@beatrixflynn5126]

Im gonn guess that that was not the last time you had a run in with the stalker, and she interacted with you in a big way again after that story.

[@gordon5114]

I'm thinking 2 and that the lie was that only Slater saw Heathers in NYC

[@rosilynviolet]

i really wish that I had gotten to see heathers the musical with the original cast but i was like nine when it came out lmao

[@Heathersproshotedits1989]

I was like 4-5 🥲

[@Heathersproshotedits1989]

And in the UK

[@kerahbundy5705]

I hope to God that the stalker was the lie, but I honestly think it was the trench coat.

[@N.o.v.aspark]

it was the stalker because it seemed like he was reading from a script and going by bulletpoints

[@happyclam1266]

I'm going to guess it was breaking the fire code that was the lie. Done ok let's see part 2!

[@horrorglitch9298]

I think it was 1 because it had the least detail to it so it would be easier to lie about it

[@that1raccoon09]

I love you Ryan! 💜💜

[@shannon2762]

I refuse to believe in the white trench coat

[@YogiGospel]

Love this format! Would love to see a video response from Sam from a fan’s perspective! Potentially questionable use of power from this producer…

[@nxtcpplxpsn9151]

absolutely trench coat story is the lie.

[@ghibliguru_]

I'm gonna say the trench coat one was a lie because the other stories seem too common and expected

[@willeamer]

Number 1 is lie, as don't believe it was the same casting team as surely it'd be called Disney's Heather's if it was the casting team of liv and maddie

[@alyssataylorsversion13]

ummm that's not how that works

[@oneofthesams]

I believe them all, incredible storytelling, but I want to say that the stalker one is the lie since it seemed the least passionate? My second guess is Winona Rider only for the fact that NO SHOT DID YOU MAKE A LITERAL GODDESS SIT ON A STOOL. Someone had to have given up their chair for her Majesty. Also, I feel as though if fire code is a legal issue you wouldn't be as open about sharing that if there could be potential of consequences? THE PASSION IN THE TRENCH COAT. I UNDERSTAND SEVERELY THE PAIN IT CAUSES WHEN SOMETHING WOULD HAVE LOOKED INCREDIBLE BUT THE DIRECTOR SAYS NO- In conclusion, I have no idea🫠

[@Zoemme99]

I think the stalker. I think she existed, but I think the last thing with her and Kurt and Ram at the restaurant isn’t true.

[@brysonmorlan6789]

I feel like the second story is a lie. I’m sure Winona Ryder was very kind but I doubt she stayed to talk to EVERY single cast member

[@shannon2762]

I’m pretty sure there’re pictures of her with the cast

[@gmann6269]

Well he's probably exaggerating. After all he is one of those people who says "literally" all the time.

[@bizbethj]

My guess is the second one isn't true because I think you lied about how many times the fire code was broken.

[@jennifercordova3847]

I think the first one is a lie , not sure hahah

[@Musicalsrlove]

Heathers is turning into a phase 😭

[@TheatreKidAesthetic]

Heathers is not a phase, it's a lifestyle XD

[@Theestybestie30]

REALLLL

[@mae5545]

Rip the white trench coat

[@dumpmoreboys4713]

I’m gonna say the lie is that the stalker had an 8 year old son who came to the shows with her. I bet she SAID she had a son but he was never there so it was a quicker red flag

[@Fan_Girl_Channel]

Ooooooo the haircut

[@yassqueensparkleface]

i feel like the first one is a lie because of how specific the third one is and the second one seems pretty realistic also i love your videos! i dont think ive ever been this early lol

[@Nonnac11]

My best guess is that it wasn't Billy Crystal who came to see the show and was interested in investing

[@mole5682]

I think the white trench coat is the lie

[@Scarlett-yt8qb]

I feel like it's the stalker bcs everything ells seems like it could have happened