Did Woman Assault Neighbor with a Flashlight? | Part 1

Tanner claims his neighbor Marian kicked his French bulldog and assaulted him with a flashlight! Marian denies this.
#JudgeJudy
The Original! There’s only ONE Judge Judy. Visit our website for where to watch, weekdays.
Subscribe to Judge Judy on KZbin: / @judgejudy

[@williamtefft3477]

JJ cant refuse looking at pictures of pets, I think she likes them more then people😅😅😅

[@brendabronfman9736]

With very good reason!!🐾🥰

[@silethaking279]

Me too!!😃😃

[@deenikki9690]

Now he knows JJ doesn’t like irresponsible pet owners. Why is your pet off their leash? 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@_stxrblazerr]

😂 I couldn't ever own a dog too much for me

[@amberr1241]

The moment I heard him say his dog was not on his leash I knew that he may have already lost his case. Smh. 🤦‍♀

[@MonkyPocks01]

There is one thing, more than any other thing, JJ will always agree to. If a litigant says they have a picture of their dog, she will want to see it.

[@bubbaXzone]

lmao she never turns that down ever

[@glenngatlin8475]

She loves doggies!!!!

[@samanthaproctor6370]

Gotta find something to look forward to in this job lmao

[@themirrorsofmymind]

Somebody once joked that if she were a judge on a mass or serial muder trial and heard the killer had a dog... JJ: _"I'd like to take a look at the dog."_

[@annea.4173]

There is actually one case that I watched a few days ago where she was so angry at an irresponsible dog owner that she refused to look at his pictures of the doggo.

[@joecrawford172]

As someone who walks their dog on leash 100% of the time, I can tell you that our walks are filled with off leash dogs charging us randomly and frequently.

[@michaelbaldwin3003]

Same and it’s really annoying and irresponsible of the owners too let them do that.

[@spikefivefivefive]

*Pepper spray*

[@whocares_bear]

That's because dogs are worthless garbage pets. The fact that you have to literally keep them on leashes, fenced in or in a kennel so they don't destroy the house speaks volumes. Whereas every cat I had I let out during the day and it just chilled around the block (normally close to my townhouse), minded it's business and would always come back. No scratched up furniture because I spent like 2 days training it as a kitten to use the scratching post. Dogs are never free for a reason, and when they are - you and the plaintiff just described what happened.

[@courtneyemm4570]

@@whocares_bearMy dog has never destroyed the house, her recall is amazing and she can go off leash in a field under my complete control If they’re trained properly they can go off leash and not be kennelled

[@Bih1stOfAll]

​@@whocares_bearSeek counseling please

[@YarnCrafts4lefties]

When a dog case starts with a dog off leash its not going to go well for the owner.

[@richardreppert6162]

Never does with any dog cases

[@nicolejohnson9244]

@@richardreppert6162sure it does I’ve seen where dog owners that have their dogs leashed and they get into a dog fight and they don’t lose cause there was no negligence. Like she says “dogs act like dogs it’s our responsibility to be good pet owners” if they are taking all precautions and something happens, that’s not the owners fault. Just like I’ve seen a leashed dog attack an unleashed dog that ran up to it on here and they didn’t get their vet bills cause they were negligent. That’s called THE LAW.

[@NPitts-cw3oe]

I'm not a minute and I can tell you someone is high ..

[@jobuck879]

@@nicolejohnson9244 Did you read the comment…OFF LEASH…. The only acceptable scenario is inside a dog park. Off leash and roaming free will end up with you losing your case.

[@ninabtha1]

Nope

[@knic7]

I like how she brought the flashlight.

[@tmarcia83]

😂😂🔦

[@niqueaustin4292]

🔦 Get away from me 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@RaleighLink]

Imagine suing someone because you can’t be a responsible dog owner and leash your dog lol

[@stuff1784]

The audacity!!

[@Valexia683]

it is a dog owner, is anyone surprised? it is very rare that i see a responsible dog owner. these people have become a giant menace to society

[@kaelincampbell1930]

@@Valexia683oh please, get real 😂

[@r.r911]

As soon as he said his dog was unleasehed, I already know he lost his case. 😅

[@stephanieyee9784]

Just because his dog is smaller than her dogs doesn't mean its a timid and well-behaved.

[@sheurekamontgomery9992]

For real because them Chihuahuas will try to tear a chunk out your ankles!!!😂😂😂😂😂

[@amberbiggs]

I love how JJ always takes time to view a photo of every dog, and then can't help but smile ❤

[@themirrorsofmymind]

She *ALWAYS* takes a look at the dog! _"Byrd, I'll take a look at those photos, please..."_

[@misssss.anthropic]

I thought the same thing! I love how she'll always look at puppy pictures

[@loveofmangos001]

If she was Asian, she would have wanted to eat them

[@Anabel_Love22]

​@@themirrorsofmymindIt's the law in Judy's court. Always bring a photo or a dog in general. 😂

[@moonscar119]

JJ has never refused to see a picture of a dog lol

[@elvickRULES]

I saw one a few days ago where she did. She was so annoyed by the defendant she refused pictures.

[@Kweghp]

If your dog is off leash, never go on Judge Judy 😂

[@jeer0920]

They did their homework. They’re both like “I’ve got pictures.” Trying to win JJ over lol

[@moretoliving2236]

Lol, lady’s face when JJ said she was not going to be compensated for moving.

[@alexiskarin]

Something always irks me about the people who slide the papers to Byrd instead of handing them to him.

[@kariburden99]

Me too like damn have some type of courtesy

[@jamesfox2579]

I feel the same way about transactions with money.

[@missbradicah]

The slide doesn't rankle me, unlike the lean across the podium and nearly hold the evidence above their head, for Byrd to retrieve.

[@annuwanttoknowmore6961]

He looks and sound like he can be John Cena little brother. 😂😂

[@gigibali]

😂😂

[@packnetadaija]

“Then he went off the chain” 😂😂😂 that narrator 😂😂

[@cronullacruller]

The way Judge Judy lights up when someone says they brought photos of their dog lol

[@cotewill99]

Can't be lunch time without Judge Judy

[@MonicaMariaMclean-zi1fs]

I love to have lunch while watching this Judge Judy 😊😊

[@queenofawesome2550]

Why was his dog off the leash? Obviously his dog is his responsibility why sue the woman for defending herself from it?

[@anthonycirami8500]

Hey Judge Judy Lunch Crew

[@zuritribe4844]

[@packnetadaija]

Wassup! 😂😂

[@Luckyliquidsilver]

Wow the accuracy

[@mezh1559]

👋

[@naiboogieb6587]

Hey yall 🖐

[@declanmollan5008]

1:48 --> the only time JJ really smiles is when she sees pictures of dogs 🤩

[@RobRomeo73]

10 seconds in and I already know this guys gonna lose. JJ hates off-leash dogs

[@angelamoore7565]

As a non American, why as people will sue for anything would you not do the basics to protect yourself from being found liable. Boggles my mind

[@christinedavis7850]

I know do the responsible common sense thing. I am American n not everyone sues in the US but the truly stupid do

[@anndeecosita3586]

There are plenty of times in the USA that no lawsuit is filed. You don’t hear about it because a non-lawsuit is non-news. People who are poor and broke tend not care about being sued because they don’t have anything, and most people don’t bother suing poor, broke people. You can’t get blood from a turnip, and it could possibly cost you more to sue than you win.

[@Sundayschoolnetwork]

Any decent person would have ran to get their dog and apologize profusely for not having controlled their dog on a leash.

[@timothyhh]

Hey look! The Duchess of Cornwall is on Judge Judy.

[@Leviticus01]

😂

[@catherineadair9078]

This lady is much better looking.

[@yolandascholten2012]

Camilla, yep there’s a likeness.

[@brandikins11]

Oooo now we’re getting them earlier in the day. I can enjoy some J-Ju with my ☕️

[@delanac1809]

For some reason I love the defendant's hair.

[@Hugatree1]

Priceless 😂😂😂

[@HAZYHEAUX]

I always hoped that when I start going grey that it will eventually turn white like the defendant's

[@delanac1809]

@@HAZYHEAUX me too

[@xtian384]

the defendant betrayed herself with her body language; when she described what happened when the dog ran to her she instinctively mimicked a kick. She did kick the dog.

[@thespear4083]

As was her right.

[@xtian384]

@@thespear4083it’s still perjury….

[@bostonteaparty3926]

You can tell JJ is an animal lover - especially dogs. I love it!

[@starflowermarie86]

At 1:15 you KNOW you see the excitemnt in JJ's face when she gets to see a pic of the dog n shes tryin to be low key 😂💜

[@mommyxo9580]

An early upload this morning?! 😍 Love it! In time for my breakfast...instead of lunch. Lol Edit: loved having an early upload, but sad that part 2 is taking a while! Lol

[@JRspeaking]

Did you find part 2?

[@litledevel15]

I just know that JJ gets her day made when people bring in pictures of their dogs 😊

[@ciarau12]

Happy Monday yall! Love an early upload 🤣

[@Sheaun]

So his dogs were off leash, she allegedly kicked it, then he came up, at night, to confront her and she clocked him with a flashlight... 🤷 sounds about right to me. He's lucky she didn't 🔫 him.

[@victoriahladek8665]

Right I would have been 🔫🔫⚡️⚡️ tased

[@bubbaXzone]

or pepper sprayyy

[@Naturefan354]

They're both full of crap though 😂 He had 1 little French bull dog and I understand he was unleashed but those dogs are totally non intimidating and not aggressive, so why did she have to kick a small little dog? She had 2 bigger dogs and she totally overreacted if that happened and I would have been angry to if someone kicked my small dog for no reason. She sounds like a big karen to me so I actually believe it😂

[@victoriahladek8665]

@@Naturefan354 you say that but I had one of them bite me before

[@Naturefan354]

@@victoriahladek8665 I have a chihuahua and he is feisty and I know they bite but to kick a small dog like that especially a docile french bull dog? IDK 🤷‍♀️ I just think most kind and reasonable people's instinct is to not hurt an animal unless you're actually in real danger or threat? The only exception is someone with a legitimate phobia of dogs

[@TheAmerica4evr]

What is Camila doing with judge Judy ?

[@dem9844]

His body language said EVERYTHING even BEFORE JJ read off what the case was about. Saw him and thought, hmm yeah naw naw 😅.... nice try though 😂

[@meganmoon6197]

Lmfao did anyone else think “you kicked my dog and now he need operation”

[@ramenn00dle76]

I thought that said "fleshlight" and got so scared. Lord forgive me 😩

[@johnsmi213]

I thought the same thing when I first glanced at the title.

[@jessypash9599]

Judge Judy and her love for dogs always make me smile

[@rachelrobertson346]

If a dog is running at me, I'm KICKING it

[@karnagekarnival5127]

Same af I'm not risking a bite. If the dog doesn't have the rabies vaccine you end up needing like 5 shots, fuck that I'm kicking the dog 😂😂😂

[@nicolebear]

If I had a dog, I would NOT let it go off-leash in my apartment community or jump on my neighbors. The female neighbor was trying to defend herself from her neighbor's uncontrollable dog approaching her dogs.

[@InuitInua]

The dog should have been leashed but what the hell was she expecting a French bulldog to do? Wheeze on her?

[@dawnellafreeman4860]

🤣🤣

[@delanac1809]

Maybe she didn't want her dogs to hurt it?

[@Arthur5260]

Made me spill my coffee I laughed so hard.

[@autumnjade815]

It doesn’t matter. People don’t have to put up with being touched by someone’s strange animal.

[@trekgirl65]

French bull dogs an do a lot of damage. Like all dogs can.

[@mimimonster]

“I have pictures of my dogs” JJ: “I’d like to see them… I don’t need to see them really but I want to see them…”

[@stratfordbaby]

Even if she had kicked his dog, it was still his fault. If someone had kicked my dog, I would not be angry if I had them out of my control.

[@brentwells4751]

Hey Judy! We dont need the episode teaser at the start of the clip! We're here to watch Judge Judy

[@anthonycirami8500]

The thumbnail 😂

[@vana4x4]

Whoot whoot! What a pleasant Monday surprise!! Hiya JJ lunch crew! (Or, breakfast crew 😝)

[@crimsonite2044]

Dammit The Plaintiff is kinda cute

[@Wish_I-hada.cleverusername31]

She brought that deadly weapon into court?!😂

[@queenbee3647]

JJ cant stand dogs off the leash. The guy doesnt stand a chance.

[@monicaxxx4726]

Wheres part 2

[@marie_FKH]

She just looks like an absolute Karen

[@Cookie-gi7cr]

Why’d he have to assault him ?? Seems like a nasty old lady

[@Hugatree1]

Yup Karen on steroids

[@Octodactylpus]

If you watch the rest of it, he's the one acting like a Karen. She is quiet, respectful of the judge and doesn't argue once when she's told her counter-claim is being dismissed. I think I get what you're saying; she has RBF and an old-school haircut, but I think it's good to acknowledge she's actually the opposite of a Karen too.

[@JESUSLOVESYOU219]

Tell me why they look like mother and son 😂

[@_PAIGE94]

An early upload?? Bless you 🥲

[@joerodriguez5953]

Pt 2 ???

[@WWRNC]

Oh snap a JJ noon upload!

[@NamekRyuteki]

Anyone else confused that they can't find part 2? EDIT: not sure why it didnt pop up in my subscriptions but it decided to show up 😅

[@RLucas3000]

1) where is part 2? 2) Tanner looks cute! 3) Defendant looks like a Karen, but I’m making no judgements until the end 4) Tanner has 2 strikes against him (dog off leash; story didn’t quite match filing), BUT 5) none of that matters if she assaulted him first (and she also has one strike, for filing for extraneous bs) 6) I’m predicting he will win at least something

[@trekgirl65]

Part 2 when it is downloaded. Just be patient, slow down.

[@trekgirl65]

And defendant was the dude. Plaintiff was the lady. You do not know much about this case. no Karen here.

[@zazzaz6533]

​@trekgirl65 check again.

[@QAsession]

​@@trekgirl65 Nah... u r wrong

[@QAsession]

Ooh... you must be sitting on the edge of your seat 😂😂😂

[@mel924]

Part 2?

[@johnathan7050]

She’s crazy absolutely crazy

[@user_id2134]

imagine feeling so terrorized by a FRENCH BULLDOG that you had to hire an ATTORNEY because you “don’t feel safe in your community” 😂🤡

[@YoshiBugatti]

John Cena vs Hulk Hogan

[@thegreencat9947]

😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁

[@Juventinos]

the dog is off leash. are we done here?.. i think we are done here :))

[@Anabel_Love22]

JJ will always find a reason to look at a photo of a dog. It's so cute.

[@ThePrimeMinisterOfTheBlock]

"He's a french bulldog" "Oh he's SMALL" HAHHAHAJAJHAHAJJAA 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧💂💂💂💂RULE BRITANNIA 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧👑👑👑👑👑

[@HunterBidenCocaineBag]

He looks ripped under that shirt.

[@robbymarton74]

Ok what’s taking so long for part 2?

[@marjorieschultz5735]

As someone who has a Labrador retriever I can tell you that this elderly lady can not control 2 of them on leash if they want to chase something.

[@LisaNix2]

Oh we’re early today!!!😄

[@F.A.Ymusic]

I'm looking for part 2

[@nellyc1002]

Me too 2 hours later slacking lol Jk

[@F.A.Ymusic]

LOL Part 2 is up now

[@iLoveBoysandBerries]

Plaintiff is cute af

[@Atrus999]

I think you mean the defendant. 😍

[@Thursdaysindecember]

An off leash bulldog. I know enough about JJ to say it isn’t looking good for them!

[@hateisforlosers6116]

I don't get why people don't keep their pets on the leash???? I never go anywhere without my fur babies on their leash.

[@jazzyj6640]

"My dog would never" 😊

[@tommorales2371]

Good God, that plaintiff is BEAUTIFUL, that old woman is terrifying 😢

[@Amylan1]

No leash foe a dog is equivalent as a car with no insurance to JJ

[@julissaarredondo6444]

Never go on JJ if your dog was not leashed , you didn’t have insurance “that day” of an accident 😂

[@DIDYOUSEETHAT172]

As a contractor I was in court more times than I can count over the years. I am no saint, but I do not lie or exaggerate in my life. Because (living with three brothers, and seven satellite cousins hanging around ) I learned very early in life, someone always knows the truth, and is more than happy to blab it. I will never understand why people go overboard or exaggerate to try to look better, the truth comes out, tell the truth, the whole truth, or don't bother going to court.

[@purgatoriprytania5382]

Yes

[@greenlighttrrop4769]

So no part 2?

[@sk5835]

Lol, she doesn't need to see the picture of the dog, she just wants to :-)

[@maggiew6200]

Key words OFF LEASH!!!!

[@therealnickroberts]

Stop with the bs intros. Why would I want to watch a preview of what I'm literally about to watch?

[@8213apice]

The plaintiff is handsome ❤

[@DillDough4u]

Get in line henny. I’m sitting on his face first 🍑

[@liftedgifted6010]

Yet irresponsible

[@user-co8cm5bw5w]

I mean, his dog was off leash and I get that. It's irresponsible. I will say, though, that I do believe she kicked his dog. She seems like the type that would do that. However, I think the neighborhood nut over there had no reason to assault him with a flashlight and knock his tooth out. That was a serious overreaction and she should have been at least partially responsible for the cost. He could have been much more seriously injured than he was.

[@DIDYOUSEETHAT172]

2:51 Right now with all the "I am such begone victim" crap and want moving expenses, I don't trust thins lady! WTFF!!

[@M131A]

“Why you kick my dog?”

[@elizabethgalligan1805]

All 3 dogs are cute, though 😊

[@domisthebomb09]

We''ve uploaded early! JJ production team once again knows their audience.

[@ninosimone]

Plaintiff dog looks just like him 😳

[@qendresashillova]

Today I was walking in the streets of my neighborhood, some dogs were there playing with each other, barking and so on. I was not sure what to do in case they chase me, to take the chance and do some exercise(runing away) or stay and fight back. So, as an elegant lady that I am, I decided to keep calm and ignore them. I won. Me 1: 0 dogs. Good.

[@Octodactylpus]

I love that she brought the flashlight

[@Mjt1262]

Dude maybe smoked a lil before the case

[@bpxl53yewz29]

So many irresponsible dog owners.

[@coltonblake13]

I understand trickle feeds... but it doesnt take over an hour to watch 4min.

[@TheAdelaide9]

There was no reason for her to kick this dog, what’s wrong with her? A nice person would have waited for his owner to come for his dog, and may be have a talk

[@trekgirl65]

Especially a dog that is not in a threatening situation.

[@Lenasevilla-yb4ei]

🗣️🗣️🗣️it’s an animal not a child cope

[@knowsnugget3321]

“People who pride themselves on their "complexity" and deride others for being "simplistic" should realize that the truth is often not very complicated. What gets complex is evading the truth.”

[@geminisunleomoon]

Part 2 of this story is missing

[@trekgirl65]

Not missing at all.

[@freezingfiremr]

The moment I heard "Off leash" Uh uh.. So far defendants winning😂