Dimash - Olympico (Ogni Pietra) REACTION & REVIEW! FIRST TIME HEARING!

[@jerseybultaoreune6107]

The moment I realized you were reacting to this version, I thought, "Oh nooo... How long will it take him to catch it?!" 🤔 (Not long, of course...) I am a massive fan of Dimash, but I cannot bring myself to watch this version, ever. Aside from the obvious (sorry dears, these are not live vocals!!!), to me, the energy of the performance is super uncomfortable. Dimash's movements, which are usually organic, seem forced and awkward. I applaud you for demonstrating such respect for Dimash in this reaction - but of course, you "get it". This takes nothing away from him as a vocalist/artist; it's just an unfortunate reality of how "the business" works. And for those criticizing DH for not putting the whole lip sync thing aside - he can't. I'm the same way; it's distracting AF. Once a musician picks up on something like that, you can't not focus on it. 🤷‍♀️ Looking forward to your next Dimash reaction, my friend!!! 🤗🤘❤

[@THEDavidHeretic]

FEELIN' YOU Jersey!!! You get it, you know exactly what I'm talking about and why I feel the way I do about it. It's not a slam against him at all, quite the opposite. I gave him a TON of praise for doing what he did, and he earned a TON of respect from me for doing what he did.

[@jerseybultaoreune6107]

@@THEDavidHeretic There are so many fanbases who want to be placated when it comes to their faves, regardless of circumstance. (Or, should I say, very vocal minorities within said fanbases.) I think that mentality is not only juvenile, but it also does a tremendous disservice to the artist/band themselves. We all know what happens when musicians surround themselves with nothing but fawning "yes men" - that episode of Behind the Music won't end well. (Is that still a thing?! 😆) I cannot WAIT to see you react to "S.O.S."!!!

[@realitycheck5376]

I've been watching Dimash for years now and I can tell you that most everything he does is lip synced with the exception of the 2017 Singer contest and a few other things. The funny thing is he has the ability, from what I've heard, to easily do a song in one take. In fact I've seen videos of the commercialized video and the actual recording of he song in the studio and they were exactly the same. Someone showcased this in side by side videos. People don't realize this but if you go back to Mariah, Whitney, Celine and all the greats, you'll find that they all did it and it's nothing new. I'm pretty sure you guys already know this but It is very disappointing none the less.

[@DiaLinwen]

@@realitycheck5376 Are you for real? Have you watched his solo concerts? Dimash sings live a lot. He has many songs with over 50, 30, 20 or 10 or 5 different live versions.

[@DiaLinwen]

@@realitycheck5376 Just an example of a video I did collecting all the 30 different versions of a single song (+ some a capella versions). kzbin.info/www/bejne/qKaploCJqt2jha8 From recent concerts there are 3 more not included in the first video, so far I only compiled the endings: kzbin.info/www/bejne/a5W0nX-BjZKCnJo

[@debbiemorgan859]

I don't know why this was the version requested. Yes, this is 100% lip synced. The sheer size of the venue and the importance of the occasion would not have allowed for a live performance. Too much at risk of equipment failure especially with wireless mikes. The best version of this is from the Astana concert which is 100% live, there's even a fan cam version that is very close up. You're absolutely right, he doesn't like lip syncing and in Russia where it's a common thing to be done for even the smallest performance to be lip synced he's known as a freak for insisting on doing a live performance.

[@szolanek]

I wonder, how the runners pretend it.

[@gregkirk1842]

I dont see why size would matter. All the more reason to have an authentic music performance, not a cartoon. Live performances are just that. Thats the whole point.

[@rhnkdhjkg]

@@gregkirk1842 You have no idea how the big official events like this go then. kzbin.info/www/bejne/aH62hHaci8-IkNk These are two of the finest singers in the world. The soprano is one of the best ones in the world and you probably know Sohyang since you watch reaction channels. Why would these two have to lip synch? 🤔 Can't you understand it is not up to singers when it comes to an event like this?

[@DiaLinwen]

@@gregkirk1842 Such performances in Russia are simply not allowed to be live. Especially as Putin was present.

[@stillracer2514]

The fan cam is only good to watch Dimash up close, the audio is the worst ever.

[@ЛюдмилаЖаурова-к9ъ]

Не могу сказать как всегда спасибо за реакцию. Но Ваше мнение- это Ваше мнение. Как интересно смотреть на человека, который не верит в великий талант Димашика. Димаш и фоно это смешно. Ну, такие как Вы эксперты уже были. Не будем спорить. Советую Вам попасть на концерт этого гения. Найти того человека, которому Вы доверяете и который уже был на концерте. Вас поразят эти чистые ноты, Вас разорвёт эта энергетика. Люди плачут и смеются одновременно. Это чудесно!!!. Ребята, Диас, почему такие эксперты так развращены своей западной музыкой и думают, что всё такие. Поэтому нашему Димашику так тяжело. Но он трудолюбивая умница и всё равно скоро захватит мир и перевернёт всю музыку, весь вокал!!!Мира Всём!!

[@DiaLinwen]

Российский шоу бизнесс не менее развращенный чем западный. Все певцы, а уж тем более на выступлениях в России и на пост советском пространстве, иногда (или даже часто) поют под пререкорд - их никто не спрашивает хотят они или нет, живой звук не настраивают и все. Я не понимаю каким образом это умаляет достоинства и способности Димаша. Я была уже на 5и его сольниках и еду в Казахстан на еще один, для меня он лучший в мире певец, но я не слепая и не глухая. И от того, что он иногда поет под фонограмму мир не кончится, а вот его потрясающий голос на дольше сохранится.

[@ju1ietta]

А с чего Вы взяли, что этот реакционер не верит в талант Димаша? Вы с переводом смотрели и до конца? Он многократно восхитился феноменальным вокалом Димаша, ему очень понравилась песня и аранжировка, он поставил весьма высокую оценку всему выступлению. Он лишь был расстроен выступлением под фонограмму, но он винил в этом не Димаша, а продюсеров мероприятия. Лично мне честные искренние реакции очень нравятся. Ничего неуважительного по отношению к Димашу в этой реакции не было.

[@ТатьянаВ-з1п]

@@ju1ietta Да пусть не верит на здоровье, мужик интересный культурный и честно переживал высказывая свое мнение, но стоило лишь присмотреться к дыханию на холоде и положению кадыка и можно было всё понять, кроссовер как стиль и его оперный элемент требуют большой физической нагрузки.

[@ju1ietta]

@@ТатьянаВ-з1п Ни положение кадыка, ни пар не являются доводами. Пение под фонограмму не означает открывание рта как рыба. Певец при этом вполне может петь (а может и не петь, как делают плохие певцы). Вот только звук идёт не с микрофона, а с флэшки :) Димаш - феномен, и это главный вывод, к которому пришли все стороны этой дискуссии 🙂😙

[@DQ_Mine]

Gorgeous song. Beautifully sung. Even if it is lipsynced, Dimash still sang this song. He is professional. I don't think he was showing anger. He is showing seriousness. He knows the meaning of the words and believes in the message.

[@GrannyRalls]

Indeed! Plus, it's operatic and change in demeanor of both characters is what the song demanded, no? Love it! Love him! Live, taped or humming the dang thing!

[@DQ_Mine]

@@GrannyRalls Absolutely! I love this song so much, and the lyrics are so precious. Exactly the perfect song for Dimash. I believe he truly means each word. I'm reminded of the song "Lay Down". Completely different, but do you know what I mean? Encouraging. Caring.

[@SandraRegina-tl2be]

Existem cantores bons, ótimos, excelentes e existe DIMASH, simplesmente incrível, um grande abraço do BRASIL 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷💖

[@amandavanwyk5424]

There is an actual live version of this song. His mic is in a stationary position and the footage is zoomed in on him the whole time. Whoever requested this song should have known better than to send you this one.

[@JustMyOpinion1010]

There is nothing wrong with this one either.

[@lucy-mb4tr]

No se si será o no sincronización, pero quiero que veas la misma canción en su concierto de 2019, totalmente en vivo y se aleja también a distancia del micrófono por la potencia de su voz. Es un fuera de serie, una voz que jamás se comprenderá 🤗 Saludos desde Chile 🇨🇱

[@suedouglas5455]

I think this was live. Dimash can sing without a mic in an autorium of 40,000 people. You forget that Dimash is opera trained, and they don’t use mics. Having said that, this is the best version of this song at Dimash’s Arnau solo concert. Here’s the link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mpyzhGmqbZmknZY which is from the composer’s channel, Igor Krutoy.

[@Bpg5012trick]

He knows Dimash is a great singer from his sinful passion reaction. But no fan likes this version because they know it wasn't live. Dimash himself said some performances he wasn't allowed to sing live. Dimash with Igor Krutoy is the version fans want reactors to react too, because it is a live performance not this performance.

[@dearlola2378]

Si ve como termina Autumn Strong le explota la cabeza 😁😲kzbin.info/www/bejne/hnXXgolod6qLfpI minuto 5'55

[@Кузькинамать-о4и]

its not live as many other his songs

[@strimart]

Димаш - не поп певец, а натренированный оперный певец, где учат петь с высокой мощьностью голоса БЕЗ МИКРОФОНА. И чтобы не было технических проблем с настройками звука микрофон при слишком мощном звуке нужно отдалять. Вы - так себе эксперт. Димаш может петь и без микрофона, и весь стадион будет эзвучен, посмотрите Autumn strong в Киеве, и там отлично видна техника владения микрофона - приближая его и отдаляя, и в конце песни вообще убрав его на метр

[@dougfriendly7676]

We're talking about THIS performance of OLYMPICO, StrimArt00---not Autumn Strong in Kiev! Although he spends too much time talking about, he is correct in noticing that this particular performance of Olimpico is not live.

[@GrannyRalls]

@@dougfriendly7676 Amen to that! So much so, sounds like Dimash is somehow dishonest, no matter how many times we're told "it's not his fault!"

[@ju1ietta]

Ну не об этом же речь! Димаш действительно филигранно владеет микрофоном. И здесь уже был отличный пример с исполнением "Autumn Strong" в Киеве или Екатеринбурге, когда Димаш отводит руку с микрофоном и продолжает звучать великолепно. Да, он продолжает звучать мощно и красиво, однако отчетливо слышно, что с удалёнием микрофона громкость его голоса падает, что также является демонстраций живого исполнения. В данном конкретном исполнении "Олимпико" с удалёнием микрофона ни тон, ни громкость голоса не меняются ни на йоту. Что и требовалось доказать. Я люблю "Олимпико", но не данное исполнение, лишенное страсти и эмоциональной вовлеченности Димаша (полагаю, связано это именно с необходимостью петь под фанеру). Жаль, что для реакции было выбрано именно это выступление.

[@strimart]

@@ju1ietta а мне кажется, "анализ" этого реакционера неприменима к вокальным способностям Димаша. В качестве доказательства он приводит обоснование, что "невозможно петь на таком расстоянии без изменения тона". А теперь посмотрите 100% лайф Грешной страсти фанкама московского концерта, где в финальном вокализе Димаш также отводит микрофон на вытянатую руку и звук, кажется его звучит еще МОЩНЕЕ. Так что доводы этого господина несостоятельны. Второе: мы смотрим запись официального концерта с ПОСТПРОДАКШЕНОМ, где звукорежисеры и монтажеры скорректируют звук до идеального ровного звучания, даже если в реалтности были просадки тона. Поэтому мы не услышим на таких записях таких просадок. Я не обсуждвю Лайф это конкретное выступление или нет, это вообще не имеет значения, я считаю что доводы этого господина особенно в отношении Димаша, несостоятельны

[@ju1ietta]

@@strimart если мы будем ссылаться на постпродакшен, который вылизывает всё так, что от "живого" вообще ничего не остаётся, то это будет беспредметная дискуссия. Так же и увеличение мощности тона при отведении микрофона также не показатель, ведь на итоговый результат влияет не только удалённость микрофона, но и его тип, работа звукорежиссера за пультом, изменяющий динамику его мощности, ну и конечно усилия певца по увеличению мощности собственного голоса. Тут важнее другое - что изменение тона действительно присутствует. А полное отсутствие каких-либо изменений указывает на предзапись. На постпродакшене никто не будет выравнивать это до такой вылизанной степени, ибо Димаш сам сделал то, что считал нужным для необходимого по его мнению баланса мощности, тона и громкости. Данный реакционер не праздный зевака, на Димаше зарабатыааюший себе просмотры, а специалист и музыкант с большим опытом продакшена. Его мнение имеет вес.

[@lisabeaty1703]

You're wrong. Dimash has amazing mic control and integrity and would not lip sync. Watch his other performances of this song. He is a musical genius. His expression is the expression of the song.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

If you say so.....even though I clearly showed where the mic went all the way down to his chest, and yet the vocal note didn't change a single tenth of a decibel. Plus all of the other example I showed that very clearly showed it was, but that's o.k. you are certainly entitled to your opinion.

[@Roxy02930]

honestly this is a lipsync, just accept the truth

[@markgriffin45]

Yep, 100% lipsynced. Olympic type shows are always lipsynced. Muse London 2012 was the same.

[@gdouglas999]

He isn't wrong. He's right. Stop the NONSENSE about integrity; there is nothing wrong with lip-synching when the circumstances call for it. Dimash has done it OFTEN and you better as heck hope he continues to do so because it saves his vocal cords so that he is able to entertain us with his live vocals when the circumstances call for it.

[@anahills3836]

From what I know of Dimash, I think he would have either lip-synched as requested or not done the event at all. I don't think he would have purposely done a bad job just to make a point. He is very respectful and polite. In all the videos I've seen of him, interviews, casual clips, concerts, I have never heard him say anything bad about anyone. (The closest he came was mentioning "crazy presidents" in his little anti war talk at a concert.) I do know that at one point he wanted to sing "Daididau" at an event and just refused to do the event if he wasn't allowed to sing it, so he will insist on doing things his own way if it's important to him. And of course, he completely quit the "World's Best" competition when he found that, contrary to what he had been told, he would indeed have to compete against children. He walked away from the prize of one million dollars and, most likely, instant access to the western music industry. Even here, I have never heard him say anything about this or speak badly of those who misled him and spoke very rudely to him when he quit. So that's what I base my opinion on. I don't know Dimash personally though, so it's just my reading of him. There is a better video of this song where the sound is lined up properly and you see Dimash much better. As long as a singer is lip synching to their own voice I don't have a big problem with it.

[@DiaLinwen]

I completely agree with you. Dimash is a true professional and being a true professional includes lip syncing when necessary. Just to clarify about Daididau - it's a Kazakh folk song, and as a Kazakh he was upset they didn't want to allow him to perform it. He is very patriotic and it was very important to him to be able to perform this in an international event, where people performed songs from different countries. As to The World's Best - it was his condition from the start that he doesn't complete against children, and they promised him that, but towards the end of the competition, when he only had to perform one last song and to win a million dollar prize (everybody knew he was going to win), he suddenly discovered that there were children in the competition contrary to what he was promised. One of them was a girl he had known personally and helped before by contributing money from his concerts so she can participate in other contests (he always helps young artist, old people, the needy, etc.). How could he complete against her? Of course a person like him would quit even if it means giving up the prize money and fame.

[@tirallala1]

👉 This song was written specifically for Dimash and the opening ceremony of the II European games in Minsk in 2019. It was the first work that Igor Krutoy and Liliya Vinogradova created for Dimash. Igor Krutoy, *1954 in Ukrainian SSSR), singer and songwriter in Ukrainian and Honored Artist and music titan in Russia (billionaire). He is a world- famous composer who came out of retirement to write songs for Dimash. The maestro and Dimash have been working together from time to time since 2018. They are friends and have a father-son relationship. Lilia Vinogradova. She wrote the grandios lyrics and is known as a permanent co-author of the composer Igor Krutoy, with whom has created wonderful works in the crossover genre. They created the cycle for DA Hvorostovsky, albums for Sumi Jo, Anna Netrebko, Yusif Aivazov, Lara Fabian and others. This is the second song (first 'Oimpico') that Krutoy and Vinogradova created for Dimash. When she asked why she did it in Italian, the poet replied: “First, Italian is by definition the international language of music, the language that allows the vocalist to open up as much as possible. This is the best language for singing... And secondly, I. Y. Krutoy and me have a well-established tradition of writing most of our works in Italian when creating in the crossover genre.” Lilia Vinogradova says about Dimash: 'Imagine a diamond that is born in the bowels of the earth - And now it appears in the light of God, and people have the opportunity to look at it, touch it, and enjoy it. Dimash’s natural talent is akin to such a unique gem…. Nothing is more important in art than identity… And it’s not even the number of octaves that Dimash covers with his voice, not the technical capabilities, but the extent to which his soul, the scale of his personality, his mind, intellect and feelings can match his technical, vocal data… And now we've added Dimash as a new element to our creative symbiosis. Very young, something completely different, new, but insanely interesting, he completely has disarmed us, captivated and charmed us with its novelty…“ (dimashnews) Dimash is an opera singer too and so he sings this song in Italian (the language of music), with an opera voice (Bariton - Sopran). No one else then Dimash can sing this song alone. In December 2019, the song “Olimpico” performed by Dimash Qudaibergen became the Song of the Year 2019 in Russia. At the awards ceremony of the 'Victoria'Russian Music Awards in 2019, Dec. in the Kremlin Palace in Moscow, Igor Krutoy was awarded Composer of the Year, Dimash the Best Vocalist in Classical Music and he also received the Special Prize for Discovery of the Year. * "Victoria" Russian Music Awards 2019 - kzbin.info/www/bejne/nKPdnKeAYrqHp80 * Backstage "Victoria" Russian Music Awards - kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXiugayEhNx_aLs * Here is the best performance so far: Olimpico/ OgniPietra - kzbin.info/www/bejne/mpyzhGmqbZmknZY (Live!!!) * Olimpico - WorldSkills Kazan 2019 - kzbin.info/www/bejne/fampnmOdoriNmLM * Olimpico - New Wave 2019 Sochi - kzbin.info/www/bejne/emeshKaBgdespq8 * Olimpico - Digital Concert 20121 - kzbin.info/www/bejne/in2yh5qFbciprpI * Opening ceremony of the II European games: Олимпико / Ogni Pietra, Minsk, 21.06.2019 - kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y2m7eaubqNWti80 * Olimpico - Minsk 2019 (Jubiläum I. Krutoy)/ Love is like a Dream/ Mademoiselle Hyde - kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJXJqaKYgs95p8U (Fan video) * The trio also created the masterpiece 'Passione' - kzbin.info/www/bejne/boLXepKcpbl8rsU * Version at the first global online concert on January 16, 2021 - kzbin.info/www/bejne/in2yh5qFbciprpI Backstage-videos: * Dimash in Minsk. Backstage of "Ogni Pietra/Olimpico" - kzbin.info/www/bejne/hZy5Yq1vdrSMoM0 * DIMASH Kudaibergen & IGOR Krutoy VTB ARENA Moscow and world stars! - kzbin.info/www/bejne/iYHVl5eXeJl6o6M

[@tirallala1]

@@anacano3760 Hola Ana-Dear, tuve mucha suerte de ver a Dimash en Praga y todo fue en vivo allí. También cantó 'Olimpico' y como siempre fue impresionante, impecable y hermoso, al igual que el video.😘

[@rodrigorra3153]

There is no one in the world of music who handles the microphone like Dimash. Whether it's live or not, it's not Dimash's fault as you say yourself At the Arnau concert, he performs live and does it brilliantly or even better. Remember that he is trained in opera and there they don't use microphones because of the power of his voices and Dimash is the best at handling the microphone versus the power of his voice. Enjoy the show and don't be bothered by the issue of the microphone that Dimash always asks to be the most sophisticated in the world to be able to sing at his will. I have never seen such scrutiny with any other artist. Dimash has too much talent to make it seem like it wasn't real. Don't try to understand it, just enjoy it. The world had not seen an artist like him and sometimes I understand that they question him. Go ahead friend. Blessings from Panama.

[@rodrigorra3153]

@@anacano3760 Me mola mucho cuando los reaccionadores dudan de Dimash. He tratado de hacer un comentario decente y serio, pero no entiendo el porque a Dimash se le trata muchas veces de escrutar hasta lo mínimo. Hemos llegado a un grado tal de mediocridad en la música que hay gente que no se cree lo que hace y representa Dimash. Pero a Dimash nadie lo puede parar, solo Dios. Saludos Ana,

[@yuenkoi]

Wow magnificent performance and voice by Dimash. Bravo Dimash ❤️

[@ij4091]

I feel sorry for Dimash. There are photos from rehearsals where he gave his best. I don't know much about production, but sometimes I have the impression that after the fact (after the show) they make some changes before publishing. Maybe they put on a pre-prepared version. I don't know the name of the process, but sometimes I see sweat on my face, hair movement under the influence of exertion, a hole in the neck when she makes high notes, and the visual effect on the screen suggests synchronization. The Russian audience does not applaud much, looks around at the performance, only real fans give their best. And in films from such performances, there are many cheers, applause, joy, etc. Dimash's concerts are different. There, in fact, people play, enjoy and sing with him.

[@michael.albinus]

At least DAVID was not lip-synching... 😁😋😎

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Not this time, however I have had to lip-synch in the past due to the producers of the show demanding it. Trust me, we were not happy about it. One of my bands was actually all set to perform on a morning show (I won't say which one) and we were told 15 minutes before we were to perform that we were going to have to lip-synch. We said no, they said "Our way or the highway", and at the advisement of our manager we grabbed our gear and walked out. They were in breach of contract. They tried to sue us, we counter-sued, and in the end it all ended up being a wash.

[@katjatuliheimo9450]

You didnt see it. He has two (ten) pearsons here. Right one is a female, left one is a man. He's not sad. He's mostly talented singer and enterteiner on the planet Earth. He's out of our understanding... More talented you will ever experience in your life. He's the One. Dimash.

[@silbaoli]

If he didn't sing live, which I don't believe, it may have been a requirement of the event organizers. That happens. For a great singer of Dimash's level, singing live is a simple thing. For those who want to check it out, just go to one of their shows and see for yourself. It's 23 years of study, hard work, daily training, dedication and discipline. All this combined with Dimash's phenomenal talent and unparalleled versatility.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

I'm pretty sure I said that in the video, it wasn't his call it was the producers and the organizers call.

[@skirk9184]

He is NOT lip syncing. For God sakes people stop. Dimash controls his mic because he has a lot of power. This you will see in all his live shows. You are wrong. I know it looks that way at times, but it's not. I have seen a time they required he lip sync. It was just so obvious. When it comes to singing...there are many ways you can tell. Check out the other video of Olimpico....same outfit. Dimash is known for having to move his mic far away. He has been accused of this so much, often he will shake the mic back and forth to prove he is live. He has a top notch sound guy that works the board. Erlan knows what, when, how Dimash needs things. Dimash is a classically trained singer who has actual projection. He is also more powerful than many opera singers. He builds his lungs through swimming. Singing is a sport. Also, classically trained singers mouths look different when they sing. They control their vocals differently. However, you are right about production companies and most acts today. It's awful. But, Dimash is known to deliver. He is that good.. Another artist they will do it in a show like this. Watch the other video from Arnau concert. Olimpico. Sung live. Just as perfect. Dimash is not about the money. Check out his concerts.

[@gdouglas999]

This is not an accusation. It is a fact that you are still in denial about. This particular performance is not vocally live! You can call it overdubbed, playback or lip-synched but people who have spent their lives in the music industry, as this reactor has, know how to spot it. Stop acting like there is anything wrong with it. There isn't! Denial of facts is not a good look, S Kirk, and has never served anyone well.

[@geminitwin1160]

A couple thoughts. World Skills Kazan 2019 in Russia had nothing to do with athletics. It was the closing ceremony of an international competition showcasing vocational skills in many fields (and attended by Vladimir Putin; perhaps he decreed there must be playback.) Just kidding. Anyway, recording vocal tracks is said to often be mandated for televised shows in Russia, and frankly the whole endless discussion of if and when Dimash participates in this system is getting more than a little boring--no offense to you or others who find this topic so intriguing. Regarding your fantasy of Dimash being "pissed," suffice it to say he is unfailingly gracious and polite in his performances as well as offstage . He's not a tempermental Western "diva." Next, he is well known for his expert mic work in relation to his very powerful voice. And finally, you must know how the very entertaining Chili Peppers sounded singing their great songs live....thus the Super Bowl lipsync! I hope you will want to get to know Dimash a little better, and thank you for reacting to the finest male vocalist performing today.

[@macarenagalache9566]

En vivo y en directo. Él hace esos cambios en muchas canciones.

[@runtsgal]

There is a lot of controversy over this performance (at least what we ended up with after it was messed around) and I have to agree with you, this isn’t live. Rather than get defensive and deny it I just console myself with the knowledge that Dimash CAN and HAS sung this totally live. Like you said, not his fault.

[@fuminshoo1266]

Absolutely, and his live performance sounds just as good as this one if not better

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Just wait until my next Dimash reaction next month....I think everyone will like what I have to say there.

[@debbiemorgan859]

It's such a shame that he doesn't have the Astana performance on his own channel. It would make far more sense for Igor to have the European Games and the World Skills performances on his channel as it was because of him that Dimash did those events and for Dimash to have his own concert performances on his own channel.

[@simonbastien5949]

@@debbiemorgan859 100% agree

[@tirallala1]

Olimpico/ Ogni Pietra Our Earth was created for love We are its children, poets and heroes The life is born and goes and will be forever. You are strong, you know! Be brave! You are strong, you know! You are more powerful than your problems. As fast as a noble heart Catch up with it, embrace it [chorus: the young future] Go! Do not stop in the middle of your path. Brotherhood and Liberty. This world really needs you. Go! Be yourself and be ourselves. You can everything if you want it. Always forward, ever forward, as long as you can! You can! The world turns, although sometimes it makes you cry. Only the love is the answer to the question “Why?”. Your mind is your spirit It will stay with you. You are strong, you know! Be brave! You are strong, you know! You are more powerful than your problems. As fast as a noble heart Catch up with it, embrace it [chorus: the young future] Go! Do not stop in the middle of your path. Brotherhood and Liberty. This world really needs you. Go! Be yourself and be ourselves. You can everything if you want it. Always forward, ever forward, as long as you can! You can! You can! You are strong, you know! Be brave! You are strong, you know! You are more powerful than your problems. As fast as a noble heart Catch up with it, embrace it [chorus: the young future] Go! Do not stop in the middle of your path. Brotherhood and Liberty. This world really needs you. Go! Be yourself and be ourselves. You can everything if you want it. Always forward, ever forward, as long as you can! You can! Always forward, ever forward, as long as you can! Yes, you can! Yes, you can! (lyricstranslate)

[@marcelamercado113]

Un Unico

[@urszulacewka]

Dimash is a musical genius, he is a complete artist, he composes, sings is an instrumentalist, he reaches not only the ears, but the soul.

[@user-lu4vw6bt2m]

Recomiendo que reacciones a Autumn Strong del concierto de Kiev, Ucrania. También a Olímpico del concierto Arnau Kinetic Voice. A Stranger, Ave María, Fly Away de New Wave 2021. A Daybreak del Bastau concert en Astana.

[@ju1ietta]

"Stranger" лучше китайскую версию, что бы не было сомнений в живом исполнении.

[@mabelgraospolanco2947]

Estimado David, estás ante un revolucionario de la música, y que está cambiando paradigmas como los tuyos, y busca el respeto del artista y no se compromete con ninguna disquera ni compañía de música, y adicionalmente, no trabaja por dinero, él dona toda o la mayoría de sus ganancias y no le gusta que hablen de eso,pues considera que no se debe recurrir a ello para ganar popularidad, aún no lo conoces bien, que haga una vez o más playback la verdad no nos interesa a los Dears, sabemos de lo que es capaz de hacer, y a todo esto es UN GRAN SER HUMANO. Es lamentable que los artistss sufran todo lo que has referido y por ello tienes esos conceptos, como dicen conoces al monstruo de la industria musical por dentro y ojalá con estos nuevos artistas que se están haciendo respetar cambie en algo eso.

[@maryarroyomartin3782]

Dicono che E del vivo.. E non E arrabiato per niente... E lui puoi fare questo E di più... ❤

[@carodear7104]

Deberías escuchar Olímpico del digital show 2021 completamente en vivo y verás que con su experiencia aleja el microfono para que no sature su potente voz, debieras escuchar mas de sus canciones y te darás cuenta que el es capaz de lo imposible. Gracias por la reaccion. Saludos desde Chile.🇨🇱

[@dougfriendly7676]

Whether overdubbed or lip-synched (and it was one or the other, it was not live no matter what other Dears mistakenly claim), it doesn't really matter. It was Dimash's original recording, and it was brilliant. And thank you for pointing out that it was not Dimash's decision but the production company's. All of that being said, I reject any criticism of the way it was handled because this was a stadium of 40,000 people and the producers were simply using the technical processes they had available to them in order to make the performance as perfect as possible.

[@johnsmith_1942]

I've seen U2 play live in a stadium for 40 000 people. Bono wasn't lip syncing. In the end it is the artists call either to do it or not. He chose to do it.

[@dougfriendly7676]

@@johnsmith_1942 This performance took place in Russia. For whatever reason, Russian venues customarily require that performances be lip-synched. Could have something to do with television broadcast or quality control but I'm sure Dimash is willing to comply with whatever rules are put into place. There are simply some circumstances under which live vocal performances are not possible. In the end, it doesn't matter that the vocals aren't live if the audience doesn't notice---or doesn't care. It seems to only ever be an issue with those who are dissecting a particular performance on video, after the fact.

[@johnsmith_1942]

​I didn't know it's a common thing in Russia. I haven't heard that would be the case in rock concerts in Russia. Maybe they know that in pop music integrity is not as important for the fans. Sound checks and good audio costs money and they're broke for sure. Like you said, they (fans in Russia) probably don't care.

[@debbiemorgan859]

@@johnsmith_1942 this wasn't a solo concert though. This was a government event covered by numerous government controlled TV stations. He would have had no control over what was required or put out as the final product. You only have to watch the Moscow or St Petersburg concerts he did to see that even in Russia when it's his own concert he gives everything he has to the performance.

[@dougfriendly7676]

@@johnsmith_1942 I think you hit it all on the head.

[@marlenemarenco9694]

Dimash es fantástico 🆗🆗🆗

[@adrianareginato7636]

POR FAVOR ESCUCHALO EN SUS RECITALES Y LOS CANTA IGUAL, EL ES DE OTRO PLANETA. ES EN VIVO!!!!

[@bocinaloca5301]

Se entiende dimash es muy difícil de creer. Un fenómeno sin duda.

[@noahtomato3515]

To fellow Dears requesting reactions - whatever your views on whether Dimash lip-synchs, please can I ask you to avoid videos where you are aware people raise that he is lip-synching. Safe choices are: all the Singer performances; most SOS performances (NOT Emigala); most of the Digital show performances; most of the Kazakh language performances; Unforgettable Day at Gakku; Marigolds; Know Vocalise version; and of course all the music videos (because lip-synching is not a problem). Please ignore the Krutoy performances as a rule (or at least acknowledge there is some debate about whether the vocal is live). With love and respect. Noah.

[@machinanexus1391]

Even if its lip sync i don't think anyone can sing or record like that admit or not period

[@johnsonlo1564]

For Dimash, nothing is impossible, try to listen Autumn Strong, Anru 2020, he move the 🎤far from his body, but you still able to hear his powerful high note

[@debbiemorgan859]

This is true, being a trained opera singer he's well versed in the technique of vocal flight and Autum Strong at Arnau is a perfect example of that but unfortunately he was not allowed to sing live at this event.

[@DiaLinwen]

Yes, all the Late Autumn performances were live and it's clear as day, and he moved the mic completely away. Also there was a performance where his mic broke in the middle of a song and he just finished the song without it, and he was just a teenager then. He is perfectly capable of doing that. But this specific performance wasn't live due to the nature of the event.

[@evaetterer6000]

Yes you are right, i saw his face and the the anger in his eyes ! He shows that he didn't like it and he dont wanna do this cause he hades it ! Greatings and love from germany ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️

[@THEDavidHeretic]

That's why he did everything he could, short of dropping the mic, to show that he was lip-synching. I gained a ton of respect for him watching this video, watching him do everything he could without making it blatantly obvious to show that he was, and thus calling out those cowardly producers who forced him to do it. I loved it, and I seriously did gain a TON of respect for the man.

[@evaetterer6000]

@@THEDavidHeretic Yes he deserv that respect ! My dad was a band leader in germany calls this Kapellmeister they makes Volksmusik this is a kind of folk music ! He wrote the arrangements for the whole band and he would say the same things like you ! Greatings and love from germany ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️

[@fzrufi8400]

❤❤❤💙💙💚🧡💕💞💖💗 Dimash!!!!! Graciasss!!!

[@cherripaynegraham4638]

Amanda & Jersey..BRAVO. I agree & applaud Dimash for his courage to expose those people. This was first & last lip sync you will ever see him do. He said so. Doesn't need those producers anymore. He is a superstar now with his own record co. & production people. There is another live version out there. Try to find it. I can't find it right now.

[@Treefellow1]

I don't usually say this, but you reacted to the wrong version.. Yrs this version was tampered with (overdubbed) by the TV guys.. The BEST one, which is definitely live, is from his Arnau Kinetic Voice concert in Kazakhstan.. Find it on Igor Krotoy's channel.. Greetings from Cape Town South Africa.. Btw for Dimash, the impossible is possible!

[@Kobenoz]

Agree!

[@mhand00]

This is the link for it: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mpyzhGmqbZmknZY

[@debbiemorgan859]

Absolutely agree, I can't understand why anyone would request this performance. Dimash doesn't even bother making the correct mouth shape. It's like you want me lip syncing, you'll get me lip syncing.

[@mhand00]

@@debbiemorgan859 Probably because this performance is on his channel and the one from his Arnau concert only on Igor;s channel with heading in Cyrillic.

[@debbiemorgan859]

@@mhand00 true, we should definitely help reactors out by sending them links although everyone is going to have their own favourite performance but the World Skills performance sucked for many reasons, although none of them Dimash's fault. The images displayed on the pyramid were completely naff! 🤣

[@ayongkot]

even at the opening of European games in Minsk, Belarus where he sang this song, it seems lypsynched. if you want to see this song live, check his Moscow concert or his Arnau concert where he sang definitely live.

[@guittadabe5214]

I'm a huge Dimash fan, and your review doesn't offend me at all. The truth is never offensive to me!

[@kwgrid]

Oh my. The performance on Igor Krutoy's channel is the absolute best!!!!

[@joanadarcpereira3554]

Tem várias versões desta música até nos shows do Dimash pois ele é incrível único 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷

[@TurkGandalf]

You are partly right, but this is not lip-syncing; it is a technique where the singer sings along in parallel and does not just move their lips. This is referred to as "live-support playback" or "backing-track support." The playback is used as a support to enhance the live singing and ensure that the performance is consistent and of high quality. This technique is often used in large concerts and television performances to ensure that technical problems or acoustic challenges do not affect the performance. Given the size and importance of this organization, it is essential to minimize all potential technical problems from the outset. This includes measures such as the use of live-support playback to ensure optimal sound quality and a smooth performance. Such precautions are crucial to maintain professional quality and a seamless flow at significant events. The event where Dimash Kudaibergen performed was the closing ceremony of World Skills Kazan 2019. These international vocational competitions bring together young professionals from various countries. The 45th edition took place in August 2019 in Kazan, Russia. Over 1,350 participants from 63 countries competed in 56 vocational fields. Around 270,000 people attended the event, including prominent spectators such as Russian President Vladimir Putin and other high-ranking personalities from around the world.

[@JustMyOpinion1010]

It often happens that at large events like this the performances are prerecorded. Nearly always on TV. What I can say is that he is a master at having to do those performances since he often appears on tv, so he doesn't accidentally let a mic slip. Operatic projection is different and he sings with an extremely sensitive mic. At concerts he sometimes drops his mic on purpose in one song and you can only hear the sound change once it gets to around his stomach. Elizabther Zharof (Charismatic Voice) did an analysis of this performance and noted that he made a slight mistake at the end that he managed to correct, which means it was probably sung live as he wouldn't make a mistake in a studio recording. I think it is impossible to say for sure if it was live or not, but I don't think it really matters much. It doesn't take away from the sheer virtuosity.

[@lilianrojas5982]

DIMASH ❤🥰

[@VenusAway]

Эксперты и реакционеры могут бесконечно разбирать: фонограмма или живое исполнение🙈. Диарс всё равно😎🎼🎶🎶 так как на вопрос ответ знает только Димашик и организаторы. А я буду наслаждаться живым исполнением на концерте 23 сентября 2022 в Алмате🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@macarenagalache9566]

Lo imposible en Dimach, no existe.

[@alariepoet8015]

I'm glad you're aware it's not his call. I much prefer this other version: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mpyzhGmqbZmknZY. However, I don't think another singer could have performed this for him unless they agreed to be imposter Dimash. This piece was written by Igor Krutoy FOR Dimash's voice at the opening of the European Olympic games. Dimash is so seemless that many people accuse him of lip syncing even when he isn't. Dimash is extremely upright, so I can believe your theory. When Dimash performs live, he usually changes something about his vocal arrangement so the audience will feel they're getting a fresh version to make their ticket price worthwhile.

[@laylasofia3146]

merci pour votre réaction....DIMASH chantait en direct....détrompez vous.

[@dianabunaciu9645]

You should try a version of this song from one of his concerts. You will find that he is amazing, unique... Regards from Romania!

[@evaflintironstag9356]

The *actual* live version of this song sounds literally just as good. Sometimes he performs at venues where overdubbing is required, which is a bummer, but it happens to artists all the time. Regardless, overdubbing is absolutely not something he needs to do as he does EPIC performances live. Brace yourself, some fans will freak out because you pointed it out, but ignore it and just enjoy the music. 💜💜 Thanks for reacting to more Dimash. You belabored the non-live singing excessively, but I'm glad I stuck it out to the end, because you were ultimately super fair.

[@faywinap]

No, this was a live stream.

[@OnFight1997]

Lets not get stuck in the details please, there's 100 different versions of him singing this, all artists lipsync, some times not by choice even, he is just as good if not better in a live setting. I'd love to see you review one of those instead of the ranting, but I get the point.

[@caiqueparrot5374]

He's better live

[@jutme8500]

I suggest you react to Autumn Sttong at the Kieve concert. You wiil see how he sings live with the mike low in fact at hip low. I don't think this is lipsynk . There have been so many attempts to ruin Dimash's performance . Such a piyy !!!!!!

[@aurismosquera4308]

Si quieres algo impresionante y en vivo mira el la presntacion del Tour Arnau y el tema Autum strong....la distancia en la que aleja el microfono y sigue oyendose implecable....parecia increible pero cierto

[@vickielashley889]

Too bad this is the version you chose..there are so many live versions that are flawless!

[@THEDavidHeretic]

For the record, I didn't choose anything. I never choose anything on the channel. The channel is 100% request driven. This video was specifically chosen by the requester(s) and the link to the specific video was included in the request.

[@christine4109]

Thanks for your honest reaction. Too bad the requester sent this version. You should see (with us would be great ;) ) a live version of this song, either at the Astana concert or the fancam version. I have to say Dimash sometimes lipsyncs. I don't know why because he defintely can sing his songs live flawlessly. Probably because of the producer required him to do so on TV, or he cannot do all the very demanding songs in 3 hours, or because his health was not good. I don't know. As a fan, I wish him changed the song to make them less difficult to sing live. But I'm still a fan, and I'm grateful that he reserves his vocals so that he still can sing the songs that nobody else can to make us believe in magic.

[@guycavaluzzo2555]

You should react to unforgettable day but the gakku version where he proves he is singing live. Mind blowing. I have to see your face

[@Grims_TV]

For your next Reaction from him I would suggest Stranger the ending is just 🤯 “that’s the truth”

[@ju1ietta]

"Stranger" in China was live

[@roimerlopez1275]

Amazing reaction my friend David!!...Dimash is the best male singer of the world (In my personal opinion)...Now I want to invite you to meet, who is considered the Fourth All Time Vocal Trinity (with Whitney, Mariah and Celine) and one of the Best Female Singers of the World...The passion and dedication when Dimash is performing a song can only be compared with the person who has influenced him to sing leaving everything on stage: His idol, the queen, the incomparable, the Goddess: Lara Fabian.....Lara is the best female singer and performer of the world...She is a lyric soprano with a amazing vocal range and incredible breath control...She speaks and composes in 5 languages and sings in more than 15 languages....That's why she is the inspiration for Dimash and several singers around the world...You can see covers of her songs on KZbin made by singers of the stature of: Dimash, Diana Ankudinova, Polina Gagarina, Forestella, Julie Anne San Jose, Sissel Kyrkjebo, Floor Jansen, Diana Navarro, Giulia Falcone, Morissette Amon, Gabriel Henrique, Rimar, Katrina Velarde, Cakra Khan and others...Please react to her songs, all masterpieces, in LIVE versions, because Lara is more impressive when she sings live, so you can see why she is the idol of Dimash...Try to do it in this order and almost all songs are from the same Lara’s concert “From Lara With Love” in Montreal 1999, one of her best works: 1) Je Suis Malade (Singing in French)...2) Caruso (Singing in Italian)...3) Je T'AIME (2002 Live version in Paris Singing in French)...4) Perdere L'Amore (1999 Live version Singing in Italian)...5) Adagio (1999 Live version singing in english)...6) Broken Vow (1999 Live version singing in English)...7) You are Not From Here (1999 Live version singing in English)...8) Quédate (1999 Live version singing in Spanish)....9) Ti Amo Cosi (2019 Live version Singing a trío with Dimash and Aida Garifullina)....I hope to see you first reaction soon and if you don't mind, I'd like you to mention me as the person who recommended reacting to Lara...Here you have the link of her amazing performance of the song “Je Suis Malade”....kzbin.info/www/bejne/m3m2qp5qiKynq7s

[@dougfriendly7676]

Hi Roimer, I've been wanting to thank you (on behalf of myself and countless other Dears) for driving so many youtube reactors to their first Dimash experience. You have been so successful at that---more successful than myself, I must admit. I am not a Patreon for most of the channels and have wondered if you are and if that might be why you are having so much success at getting reactors to check out Dimash. Any tips you can give the rest of us for getting youtube reactors to start their Dimash journey would be appreciated. We all want to help!

[@roimerlopez1275]

@@dougfriendly7676 My friend Doug!!...I always read your comments in the Dimash's reactions....Thank you for your kind words!!...I appreciate them!!...What can I say?...I have been very lucky with several reactors who have decided to react to Dimash for first time after reading my recommendation... I'm not a Patreon...I wish be one!!...I just write a recommendation and send it to them... It's difficult because you have to spend a lot of time searching on KZbin for the new reactors, but when I found them, I send my recommendation...Some of them send a answer back...You just have to be patient and lucky!!....What do you think?

[@dougfriendly7676]

@@roimerlopez1275 Thank you, Roimer! I will try that! I hadn't thought about looking for new reactors who haven't yet discovered Dimash but that is exactly the right path to take. I encourage others to try the same thing since these efforts have been so successful for you. The more of us who suggest Dimash to reactors who are new to youtube, the more exposure Dimash gets in parts of the world where he is still virtually unknown. I want to be a small part in introducing Dimash to others. You may have seen that I have used a neighborhood site I can't name in full because youtube deletes me when I do (but it's all one word, the first part being "next" and the second part being "door") to post accolades about Dimash along with links to some of his most popular video performances. No one in my small town had ever heard of him before I started posting, but a considerable number have turned into fans and one senior lady became so captivated she made the difficult trip alone from our remote corner of the Pacific Northwest to Prague in order to see Dimash in concert. If I never turn another person into a Dear, this one will be satisfying to me. But I'm going to keep trying. The site, by the way, is available in the US, Canada, Australia and at least eight western European countries so there are opportunities for thousands of other Dears to introduce their own community members to our vocal hero.

[@roimerlopez1275]

@@dougfriendly7676 Yes, that's exactly what we must to do...I try to do it everyday but I have to work hard and sometimes I haven't enough free time...And I have problems because my computer is very old and is very expensive to buy a new...I live in Venezuela and in my country, with the economic crisis that we have, the electricity and the internet are a big problems...But you know, always we have to be positive and the crisis is going not to be a obstacle to continue promoting Dimash for every new reactor.

[@Pete16244]

I tell you this... I grew up on Metallica, Queen, Zeppelin, Purple, AC DC etc and also on american rap especialy Eminem and lyrical rap. But I like more then just rock and rap. And Dimash is reason why... I saw like 30 his songs and I have a chicken skin everytime I hear that again! He is definately the best singer ever... I saw like a hundred voice teachers reactions on manny his songs by manny of them and everyone is just shocked! :D he has the most octaves, he did D8 note wich is incredible! you definately have to see more.... D8 is in Unforgettable Day' live at Gakku but you will definately like Stranger... Love is like a dream, SOS, Opera 2.. .

[@matthewgoodA1206]

That’s a very interesting and insightful observation. Being that I am a total amateur with no technical background I very likely wouldn’t have caught it. But I agree with what you said about the whole production. I also almost always favor the artist over those pulling the strings. In my book it’s the artist who deserves far more credit. This whole deal reminds me of other performers who also showed some independence in the face of controlling companies. Specifically Nirvana. When they were hired to perform live at an Mtv Video Music Awards show, the band had their own ideas of what songs they wanted to perform. But Mtv insisted on them playing their big hit single at the time. Well, the band being who they were, and Kurt being who he was, they snuck in a little snippet on their own terms. When it was time to start, Kurt played the opening bars on his guitar of the song he had wanted to do instead. Then they switched to the song they were told to do. So I, too, love that streak of independence that some artists have. That they don’t 100% go along with every little thing they’re told to, is a testament to their character.

[@klaudia658491]

Hi, Olympico is a bad example. Watch Dimash- Ikanaide for your enjoyment

[@magasperb1414]

Uma pena tu não conhecer a carreira de Dimash.. não reconhecer o intérprete, compositor,produtor, Dimash é um artista independente completo na forma mais ampla da palavra.. está música foi escrita por não menos que Igor krutoy especialmente para ser interpretada por Dimash nas olimpíadas de Soshi.. essa apresentação é outro show onde ele interpretou novamente...

[@pirkkoukkonen8039]

Hi David and others! Igor Krutoy wrote a magnificent song and Dimash performed it to perfection. The problem lies in the word "live". Why use it anyway? There is no question that Dimash couldn't perform the song live, his vocal ability is well known and verified. Why not just say something like "performance on stage" or as they used to say in TV comedy series: "recorded in front of a live audience" 🤣🤣🤣. We watch music videos and listen to records without complaining or doubting the artists talent. I enjoy great performances despite the fact that I suspect/know that the vocals are prerecorded or processed afterwards. It's just the word "live" that bothers me. The reason for using the word is obviously to increase the marketing value of the video. How could we get rid of the false use of the word and restrict "live" to those rare situations, where the vocals truly lack of any manipulation. 🤔🤔🤔 Love from Finland 🤩🤩🤩

[@EvilsTwin66]

Sub for your thinking. Greets & best wishes from germany!

[@noahtomato3515]

So glad you said this was not a live performance. So many reactors just pretend it’s live. Some fans will insist it is live. Dimash lip-syncs sometimes, that’s the industry. But can he genuinely sing those notes? Absolutely!

[@THEDavidHeretic]

He did sing the song on the recording, so yes it was impressive from a recording standpoint.

[@susanbeckmolloy9536]

First, I despise this video. Probably the worst one to pick LOL. It may be lip syncing I don't know, but his mic control live is done solely by him. Watch his live concert performances. He has Held the mic at full arms length with full voice. Please react or simply watch a live (there is one of this song) performance and notice how often he holds the mic at mid chest range because of the strength of his vocals. He is a vocal genius. 😎

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Just wait for my next reaction to Dimash next month.....I have a feeling you're going to enjoy it.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

@@anacano3760 Si esa va a ser tu actitud, deja el canal y no vuelvas.

[@Javier-id4lq]

Thanks, but I don't see what's the point in uploading a reaction video to just say it is lip synced (which is true, by the way). Doesn't it make more sense, when you realize, to stop the reaction and make a small research to find the good video? It's not so complicated, you have it in Dimash's official channel, kzbin.info/www/bejne/mpyzhGmqbZmknZY

[@THEDavidHeretic]

For the record, I don't choose anything on the channel. This channel is 100% request driven, and all requests made are required to include a link to the specific video the requester wants me to use.

[@juliadetorres-unger5844]

Please react to Dimash Your Love, Across Endless Dimension, the version in Slavic Bazaar 2021, this very one please, Confessa+Diva Dance,and Stranger. Please, please, please, thanks a million!

[@gdouglas999]

Are you sure you want him to react to more lip-synched videos, Julia. Several of those are, and he is bound to make a big deal of it.

[@juliadetorres-unger5844]

@@gdouglas999 Lip synched or not it still is Dimash and that is still his voice. Am not really making a big fuss of it. Thank you for your accommodation. Thanks, thanks, thanks!

[@nikim6986]

If he drops the mic as you wished he should, that would be end of his career. Dimash has a goal that he hasn't completely achieved yet so he has to put up with all the crap they tell him to do, until the day he owns his own production company and becomes his own boss.

[@cucumber5919]

Согласен, тут фонограмма, но он может и умеет петь отлично. Посмотри любые песни из I am a Singer.

[@ЕленаВольхина-з6л]

Это не Олимпиада. Это конкурс профессионалов в различных профессиях. Проходит он ежегодно в России. В тот раз он проходил в Казани. И всегда очень грандиозное открытие. Не путайте название песни с мероприятием.

[@gokuazul3182]

Yeah it's 100% lip synced, but it's a great show and I saw an old rehersal and he can sing this song almost like in this video.

[@fzrufi8400]

Bravo bravooooooo!!!!

[@kunou4527]

As much of a problem as this is in the western world, I've found out it's even worse in the eastern countries (Russia, especially). To the point that some production companies have to put a label on the corner of a screen saying "Live Sound" when something is live, but you're still going to be incredibly suspicious of it. It's one of the reasons Diana Ankudinova rejected all the contract offers after she won You Are Super! and went the independent route (crowd funded her first album). She's so stubborn that I think there may have only been one or two times she agreed to do something non-live but it was government related performances. In that part of the world you can't really reject that kind of offer. Which may have also been why Dimash accepted it on this performance (government sponsorship involvement).

[@stillracer2514]

This was probably not the best version to react to as it's obviously lip syncing. There are much better live versions and the vocals are just as powerful.

[@SomeOnlinePerson]

Oh whoa. I'd seen something about this song being a lipsync, but I didn't realize they weren't talking about the version I saw. I know barely anything about music and stuff, and even I could tell right from the start that this just wasn't right. o.O

[@hitomiochiai8787]

Whether this performance was lips synced or not, its still his voice. 100% There are other performances of this song.

[@ТатьянаВ-з1п]

Hello David, ну и зря вы так думаете, у вас не было опыта работать с такой техникой мощного звучания. У Димаша отличная оперная школа и он прекрасно владеет микрофоном и использует его достаточно регулярно для построения динамической линии, чтобы облегчить мышечнуую нагрузку. Какой трек? Там живой оркестр с дирижером и его группа, лучше послушайте ещё пару живых выступлений, где он владеет микрофоном как волшебной палочкой и чаще в высоком регистре, где использует мощную опору на диафрагму, не пожалеете. Например Ikanaide 2021. Hi from Siberia.

[@kassandraberra9242]

EL NOMBRE CORRECTO ES “OLÍMPICO “ dicho por su autora

[@diasmemorylane5827]

I didn't care for "Olympico," but if you want another song with surprising vocals coming out of nowhere, to not add to your play list, this is a great one. Low, high, Kazakh folk techniques (but different from the ones he used in "Sinful Passion.") Nice job singing in English for a non-English speaker at the timekzbin.info/www/bejne/onfWc2h-i9OgiaM

[@macarenagalache9566]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/in2yh5qFbciprpI ahi lo tienes también en vivo. Canta exactamente igual.

[@Dana-di.dear1]

It's a shame... that the reactor couldn't enjoy, acknowledge, or comment on any of the phenomenal vocals in this song because he was too fixated on commenting about whether or not the artist was lipsyncing.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Did you watch the entire video? Did you miss all of the praise I heaped on him for everything he did on the recording and for calling out the producers? You might want to watch the video again, and this time focus on all of the praise I heaped upon him.

[@Dana-di.dear1]

@@THEDavidHeretic yes, I did. Maybe I misinterpreted some of your comments. But the focus of the reaction just kept coming back to whether not he was lipsyncing..that's all

[@fatidear1604]

@@Dana-di.dear1 yes

[@JM-zh6zd]

I think dimash purposely moved the mic down to his chest as if proclaiming it’s not live as a screw you to the big companies

[@THEDavidHeretic]

That's what I was saying as well.

[@mmsminimalmusic3110]

Yes, this was lip-sync, but I think you dwelled way too long on it, forgetting all about the song/singing. By the way, the choir was fake too: there are no mics and you can see that some of the guys start moving their mouths only after they saw the camera focusing on them. Likewise half of the orchestra was fake (apart from the conga man). There is not much live in Russia... And what bothers me is the naivety of so many dears who believe contrary to evidence that Dimash never lip-syncs. Yes, he does lip-sync, in particular in his performances in Russia. But who cares: I want a good audio, whether it is live or studio-produced. And Dimash is still the one who sings.

[@gdouglas999]

Thanks, MM. I can hardly believe all the denial I see in these comments. I fear that half of Dimash's fans are simply clueless about the real world!

[@sallystubbs7417]

Thank you. I would have scored the VOCALS, recorded or not, at least a 9.8 or 9.9. Dimash is an incredible vocalist. Yes, sometimes artists are told they must lip synch, which is unfortunate. Dimash has LIVE performances of this song, without all the lasers, dancers, hoopla. More Dimash please? Try his “Kieli Meken” for a change of pace. Or “Marigolds”

[@mariasolymosi3243]

Nagyon szomorú vagyok! Soha nem gondoltam, hogy közönségnek éneklő művészeket "elnémítanak", mert technikailag így jobb a szervezőknek. Itt van egy nagy zenekar, itt van az A-Stúdió Együttes, itt van egy nagylétszámú kórus, itt van a világ legjobban képzett, legsokoldalúbb énekese, aki imád énekelni, akinek tökéletes a mikrofonkezelése is és csak tátoghat? Ennyi előadót becsaptak és becsapták a közönséget is? Nem is tudom elhinni, fel vagyok háborodva! Sohasem hallottam ilyet, pedig betöltöttem a 78 évet. Greetings from Hungary!

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Nagyon elterjedt gyakorlat a televíziós műsorszórásnál.

[@MAC-sx4lc]

Incluso para hacer lipsync se necesita talento... Dimash lo hace perfectamente bien. Yo pensaría que en realidad canta la canción a todo pulmón, pero el micro simplemente está apagado

[@MAC-sx4lc]

@@angeliareyes3111 creo que Dimash ya ha demostrado lo suficiente su talento. Si hace o no lipsync por razones ajenas a él, no le resta nada como artista

[@MAC-sx4lc]

@@angeliareyes3111 exacto! Un conciertazo como los que da, amerita descansos entre canción y canción! Estamos totalmente de acuerdo!

[@MAC-sx4lc]

@@teresaz-l2963 este youtuber nunca ha dicho que Dimash no pueda cantar. Lo que dice es ésta actuación esa playback porque probablemente se lo exigieron a Dimash

[@jacquesmorency2278]

good day to you SIR..David Heretic.. you think DIMASH does lipsing????? sir please kindly listen to the ending of DIMASH's song when he sings the song live ( AUTUMN STRONG ) at ARNAU tour 2020..and see how far DIMASH is from his mic and how powerful is his voice. ..I will be there seen you react to this performance of DIMASH , and maybe your idea will be more accurate and you will have understood that DIMASH is an ALIEN with a set of double lungs ..DIMASH is a master of is art and craft...SIR ..MY best wishes and greetings from CANADA new sub..see you again

[@DiaLinwen]

All the performances of Late Autumn Dimash has ever done were always live, and yes, he moved his microphone away because his voice is amazing and powerful. It has nothing to do with the fact that this specific performance wasn't live because that's the format of this event.

[@tmasessa]

He was doing it subtly, but he was def letting us know. I love your attitude towards it. And the fact that you would literally stand there with your arm crossed. 🤣😂🤣😂 Awesome.

[@fischi9129]

To be fair, even if you lipsync, you have sung it at some point, I think even if lip synced it's fine, it's not the big of a deal a lot of people make it to be

[@THEDavidHeretic]

I absolutely agree. Like I said, it is his voice on the recording, so he had to sing it for the recording, so clearly he is capable of singing it. Keep in mind, I wasn't upset at Dimash at all for this, I gave him all the praise in the world for what he did. He earned a ton of respect from me for the way he handled it, I loved it.

[@fischi9129]

@@THEDavidHeretic yeah, what I'm saying it is that I think in general, even if the singer wants to, lipsyncing it it's fine. There are a lot of contextual things that can affect the voice, for example illness, stress/pressure, being tired, maybe the singer has a couple of songs being a bit harsh on the voice and sings em in lipsync a couple of concerts to protect their voice etc. I think they are all valid reasons. The only time I really can't stand lipsyncs if the singer lipsyncs an autotuned song, which is a cover that is barley changed of the original. My question there is... what did the musician provide? Singing? If I can hear autotune at first glance your singing probabl, isn't great, the song? it's a cover that is barley changed, might as well call it theft. Live performance? nope. So I think except in that case it's totally okay for whatever musician. As a fact there is a performance dimash had autotune on him and you can hear it in a couple of places, but funnily enaugh, in the really hard places of that song, where you should definitely hear the autotunr it was just not there. But then as well, we are humans, we get tired, make mistakes etc, I think it's understandable for singers/productions trying to cover them up as much as possible to have a better immage, we do the same thing whenever we tell a story that ibcludes ourselves ^^ (tho hhe autotune in that dimashs performance really sounded bad xD)

[@BH-sn7ws]

There is a live video of him singing with Igor Krutoy. Brett needs to be more careful about how he picks his videos. 😊

[@jaljal8913]

Ok,ok...so what's your problem sir?

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Don't have one, I think what he did was amazing and I applaud him for doing it. He earned a ton of respect from me for doing what he did.

[@Koquitaful]

Check OLIMPICO in CONCERT lINK: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mpyzhGmqbZmknZY

[@hardcorechristopher9174]

This was a shame great song great performance but it's not live whatsoever

[@nolviagajardo]

Entiendo que tu reacción se detenga en eso, pero no es lo medular, es un show y él no esta dando un examen. para mi es el mejor cantante del mundo, igual podrías analizarlo en su real dimensión, desgraciadamente no es el mejor video, hay otros en que canta en directo , pero tu mejor que nadie conoce el "negocio"

[@nimaside]

Oh boy. The Dears are Dimash's body guards. As soon as I saw that you would react to this version I knew hell would come down upon you. His fans are the most nutty obsessed people online. He's amazing and perhaps technically the best vocalist of a generation, but his fans are frightful. Whomever gave you this link...It's their fault lol.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Actually the majority of the Dears have been very respectful. They may not agree with me, and that's fine, but for the most part they disagreed with me in a respectful way. Only 13 of them had to be blocked for being disrespectful and getting personal (name calling, threatening, etc.). I was actually expecting it to be a lot worse, so I'm very pleasantly surprised.

[@lucynalatos-gacon4243]

A nawet jeśli to o czym to świadczy? Że zawsze śpiewa z playbacku,na koncertach też? Dimash na każdym koncercie improwizuje,jest wiele wersji każdej piosenki.Ale przecież jak każdy nie zawsze śpiewa na żywo,to oczywiste.Ale to nic nie znaczy .Ale nazwa Heretic do czegoś zobowiązuje .