Refuting Yaser Al-Qadi's claim that calling the dead is not paganism P2

Refuting Yaser Al-Qadi's claim that calling the dead is not paganism P2
Here in P2 I explored the Ayat that described invoking the dead of being Shirk & Kufr unlike What
Yasir alleged that originally it is neither Shirk nor Kufr to invoke the dead, but it is Haram or Bid’ah. This is a mere lie, which leads to believe that no Shirk occurred in the Ummah since non of it said the saint is my god.
Such false claim will encourage ex-Brelvis to return to their cult they abandoned.
I don’t recommend to seek knowledge from Yasir after many confusing statements he came out with who kept pleasing all except Allah & Muslim community. May be Sufis, Deobandis, Hamza Yusuf & his Sheikh Nooh Keller will be pleased with him.
Support me on patreon : / dimashqiah
www.sheikhdimashqiah.com

[@dimashqiah151]

The good point here is: How come a usual matter of Shirk turns to be sometimes Shirk & some other times Bid'ah? This is playing & messing in the religion of Allah. Waht is Shirk remains Shirk, it doesn't become Bid'ah if a person didn't know it is.

[@amirulafiq4371]

Assalamualaikum wr wb sheikh, have you read my comment regarding Uthman ibn Hunaif? This is a different incident than the one already addressed. It took place during the caliphate of Uthman RA. I need your help. Jazak Allahu Khayran

[@user-kj8yl6sn2z]

جميل أن نراك مع ابو مصعب وجدي عكاري للحديث عن التوحيد ومعنى التوحيد ومايناقضة من بناء الأضرحة والرقص الإلهي والتوسل برجال الدين والدعاء للأموات بالشفاء الخ..

[@hassanabdaladl]

Lol shirk remains shirk, yea, ya shaykh? Tyb, asking someone for help when they're alive shouldn't just become shirk once they pass away then, right? It should be shirk to ask someone for help when they're alive then, as well, sah? Because "shirk remains shirk", right ya shaykh? lol honestly I'm so disappointed with your akhlaq in this video. You're the one "playing & messing" with the religion. May Allah guide you and guide me.

[@amirulafiq4371]

@@hassanabdaladl As before you don't comprehend the difference between seeking aid within one's ability and seeking aid in matters of the unseen. The latter is Allah's Prerogative! As before you're assuming that people in the graves are aware of the affairs of the world and the identities of every human being on the face of the earth and have the ability to aid with the expense of asking directly from Allah SWT. No one knows the Unseen except Him. This is Tawhid al Asma was Sifat. No one is like Him! Which is why He Is worthy of worship in the first place! You still failed to provide clear evidence from the mouth of the Prophet SAW that this is allowed or that the deceased have the power to do this.

[@hassanabdaladl]

@@amirulafiq4371 ibn Qayyim said, “The Messenger of God (peace and blessings be upon him) enjoined upon his community that, if they send greetings to the inhabitants of the graves, they should do so in a way similar to the greetings of the living by saying, ‘Peace be upon you O inhabitants of the believers.’ This speech is directed to those who hear and perceive. Otherwise, it would be tantamount to speaking to inanimate objects. The pious ancestors are in agreement over this and the texts narrated from them on the dead hearing the living and are pleased with their visits have reached the level of tawatur (multiple contiguous channels of transmission leading back to the Prophet). There are many more evidences lol in fact there's almost ijma3 that the dead are aware of what's going on above to varying degrees, particularly by way of hearing. Generally, only the salafis have departed from this opinion. Al Azhar has a clear fatwa on this.

[@higherfrequency444]

Hide your wife’s and kids from Yasir Qadi

[@MegaMucahid]

Allahu Akbar sadaqt wa the whole ummah. This guy is poison I am not a someone who believes in weird things but he has definitely an agenda. It is amazing how he get pushed in America and by the way they are selling the Deen Yaqeen and this whole institution are sponsored by the government. They make a lot of money and then you look at Sheikh dimashqiah he gives his whole life for the Da'wah and he must ask for donations Ai3b Walla. It is a Shame. I love sheikh dimashqiah he is very just May Allah bless him.

[@drfarheenkhan81]

Jazaak Allaahu khairan shaikh, for this video. This was much needed. May Allaah bless you and protect you and reward you with the best of both the worlds.

[@scaryjoker]

Yasir qadhi taught me that asking Krishna (who I don't believe is god) to aid me is not shirk.

[@halalhomer]

Lol

[@hm9825]

@@halalhomer lol

[@amirulafiq4371]

This means that the likes of YQ, heretical sufis and Barelwis haven't denounced paganism. Same concept, only the gods have changed.

[@shadowwhowalk]

It would be especially foolish and ignorant to believe that Krishna is a Muslim and can give intercession with Allah, but not neccessarily Shirk according to the majority of scholars.

[@amirulafiq4371]

@@shadowwhowalk Assalamualaikum, Majority opinion doesn't equal truth. If we're gonna take the majority opinion as THE ONLY criteria for truth, then the alleged crucifixion of Jesus AS is considered truth bcuz many people even in the 2nd century believed this! Yet the Qur'an debunks this "incident" in just one verse and calls it CONJECTURE. Anyways this is A FALSE GENERALIZATION. NOT ALL SCHOLARS HELD THIS VIEW. THIS IS WHY TAQLID AND BLIND FOLLOWING CAN BE A A FITNA, at least to the laymen. It's clear you don't know what it means when invocation is worship. Bcuz you are calling upon The One Who Is The Only One Who Hears! You're calling upon The One Who Helps when no one else is around, WHEN NO OTHER BEING WITH SIMILAR ATTRIBUTES EXISTS. This is the Unique Attribute of Allah SWT. NO OTHER BEING SHARES THIS. This is the reason WHY HE SWT IS WORTHY OF WORSHIP IN THE FIRST PLACE, because NO ONE IS LIKE UNTO HIM SWT. IF THERE ARE OTHERS WHO SHARE IN HIS SWT ATTRIBUTES NAUZUBILLAH, THEN HE OR SHE IS ESSENTIALLY WORTHY OF WORSHIP. It's shirk the same way sacrificing for others instead of Allah SWT is shirk. THE UDHIYAH IS ONLY FOR ALLAH SWT! Would you agree? It's shirk the same way making a pagan pilgrimage other than the Islamic Hajj is shirk. HAJJ IS ONLY FOR ALLAH SWT! Would you agree? It's shirk the same way prostrating to others instead of Allah SWT is shirk. This is why prostration of respect is abrogated within the Sunnah. PROSTRATION BECAME THE EXCLUSIVE RIGHT OF ALLAH SWT. Again would you agree? Likewise invoking is an act of worship bcuz IT IS THE EXCLUSIVE RIGHT OF ALLAH SWT! NO ONE ELSE IS INVOKED BCUZ NO ONE ELSE IS ALL-HEARING.

[@user-lz1qw3nw8c]

Even the language explains that, it IS SHIRK. Cambridge dictionary: Invoke - to call on someone or something, especially God, for help

[@KassimEffect]

Background is beautiful mashallah.

[@mohammadamin9096]

Yasir Qadhi needs a DEEEEPER dive lol

[@myasesaleh4631]

Part 3? Keep up the great work shaikh

[@Khaledf]

بارك الله فيك وجزاك الله خيرا .

[@maha-md6yg]

جزاك الله خير

[@darwishendalga3529]

الحمد لله، و جزاكم الله خيرا يا شيخ

[@muhammadsharif7990]

thank you brother! very nice lecture w proofs!

[@rustigjazz]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@AereForst]

‏بارك الله فيك يا شيخ محاضرة مفيدة جدا للذي يفقه في دينه وعلى ربه يتوكل و هو مخلص

[@dimashqiah151]

Asking the dead is paganism P1 kzbin.info/www/bejne/oJjGXpmjnpuBjrs P2 kzbin.info/www/bejne/a4SkemaOmbGqqJo P3 kzbin.info/www/bejne/qninf6uaYqmdfqs

[@mdrasid007]

Maa sha Allah ,very good response not only to Yasir Qadhi but all Suffi Shia cult.Well done ,May Allah reward you

[@aboodia4315]

Quran and Sunnah baby. Pure & Simple. Elhamdulilahi Rabil 3alamin. Baraka Allahu feek.

[@safiasaleh7322]

Insha Allah YQ takes the advice given

[@JesusIstMuslim]

Thank you

[@khapsari5859]

Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakaatuh shaykhna how are you? Is it possible to contact you for a podcast? Jazaakumullaahukhaira wa Assalaamu'alaikumwarrahmatullaahiwabarakaatuh

[@saadshaban7929]

ماشاء الله ذادكم الله. علما من فضلة لنفع الأسلام

[@nsubugaivan5489]

Wisedom, shykh is good at explaining....jazakallahu

[@user-dv7ik9cm7d]

زدهم حفظك الله واستمر ولا تتوقف عن متابعتهم والقضاء عليهم

[@namenik164]

السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته.يا شيخنا لو وصلك رسلتي أرجوك تنبيه لي.اريد التوصل معك لاستفتاء بارك الله فيك

[@user-dv7ik9cm7d]

تابعهم في كل مكان وهذه مهمة لك لكي تحمي المسلمين الجدد

[@rashidnehal4712]

Sheikh, hope you have discussed this with YQ before publishing this video in sha Allah.

[@abehajalatiq5253]

بارك الله لنا في عمرك وعلمك شخنا الفاضل الجليل ولا نخشى على أنفسنا إلا من كثر هؤلاء المزيفون المحرفون وإضطهاد وتهميش الاسوياء الاتقياء ليتصدر أمثال خونة الأمة وشرارها ألا لعنة الله عليهم حفظك الله شيخنا

[@iimiboy]

Jazakallah khair sheikh, yasir qadhis followers are blind and defend him no matter what he says, aren't they taking him as a prophet?

[@mohamedfaisal5059]

Not true bro, I used to follow him and love him for the sake of Allah, but now here I'm.

[@iimiboy]

@@mohamedfaisal5059 same with me, I used to love his seerah of the prophet saw said other lectures but he is a clear deviant slowly misguiding his followers

[@yousefshokir6481]

They are not considered to take him as a prophet. It may be due to their ignorance and his eloquence in speech. We have to think good of them I disagree with brother Yaser in a few affairs, despite this I ask Allah to guide myself and him to that which is correct. Ameen

[@tayloryoung4974]

@@yousefshokir6481 😂😂😂 You disagree with him only?? You only disagree with a shirk apologetic?? This is a matter of love and hate for the sake of Allah.

[@yousefshokir6481]

@@tayloryoung4974 I believe it is shirk. I didn’t say he was my shaykh or I follow him in anyway. He has some things which he says which coincides with the truth. I asked Allah to guide him and his followers to the truth in those affairs which he has errored in. Don’t be extreme. هلك المتنطعون

[@alalnajjar2187]

I swear by Allah alone that I never liked this yassir Qadi walhmadulillah

[@doc83]

Brother it's not about liking any particular personality, but arriving at the truth.

[@alalnajjar2187]

@@doc83 True . I never liked him because he is fake and an innovator. Not because of his personality or his appearance. Keep in mind prophet Muhammad Sallaa Allahi Alihi wasallam liked some people and disliked others. He liked some Sahabah more than others. So there is nothing wrong about this.

[@doc83]

@@alalnajjar2187 My point is that if you disagree with someone on a particular issue, especially a Muslim, moreover someone who is clearly learned, we should refrain from directing any personal insults towards that individual, but rather respond with our textual evidences with good etiquette and manner. We should leave the matter of labelling someone an innovator etc, to our scholars. As a lay person, it is not my remit to label someone as am innovator etc. May Allah guide us.

[@alalnajjar2187]

@@doc83 I am 100% sure he is an innovator. I do not need scholars to say it. Anyhow this will cause arguments so I will refrain from replying at this point. Jazakum Allaah Khairan. May Allah guide innovators back to the true ways of the salaf before it is too late. Ameen. ثُمَّ جَعَلْنَاكَ عَلَىٰ شَرِيعَةٍ مِّنَ الْأَمْرِ فَاتَّبِعْهَا وَلَا تَتَّبِعْ أَهْوَاءَ الَّذِينَ لَا يَعْلَمُونَ

[@aboodia4315]

fact! SubhanaAllah!

[@rosya.traveler4269]

what's the name of this sheikh? can someone tell me?

[@88Grimmjow]

Abdul Rahman Dimashqiyah

[@Adrian-yf1zg]

The first narration, is about closing the doorways to shirk. Can the shaykh confirm he if thinks ibn hajar al haythami is a mushrik or promoted shirk?

[@yousefshokir6481]

Why would he think that

[@hassanabdaladl]

Lol @A drian good question, my friend. May Allah reward you with good

[@alialsaffar9]

ما اوضح معالم الشرك وما اظلم ممن يبررها

[@yesyoureright]

May Allah guide yaser qadhi and his likes as they can be very beneficial once they give up there modernised Islamic views on Certain topics. Allah Hu Allam

[@azomasarani7670]

ما شاء الله

[@ashah4034]

If you invoke them, they hear not your call; and if (in case) they were to hear, they could not grant it to you. And on the Day of Resurrection, they will disown your shirk (i.e. in worshipping them). And none can inform you like Him Who is the All-Knower. Surah Faatir, 35:14

[@user-co8id8tx7m]

ان الله لايغفر ان يشرك به ويغفر مادون ذلك لمن يشاء. حفض الله شيخنا الدمشقية من كل مكروه. ونفعنا بعلمه وامد الله في عمره

[@ym-hy4zs]

Another point that Aulia of Allah who is still alive who can ask dua for us to Allah and bring good from Allah. Is this understanding shirk or bidah ?

[@Khaledf]

يادكتور دمشقية. حاتم العوني هو الذي تولى هذا الرأي وتبناه وبثه في الناس. ولا اظن الدكتور ياسر إلا تبع لحاتم في ذلك. وفقك الله ياشيخ دمشقية وثلتك وسددك.

[@Mohammedibrahim853]

Assalamualaikum how can i ask u questions? Do u have a email?

[@isaiahcampbell2193]

Mary is divine because she can understand any language?

[@ym-hy4zs]

Exactly this is Christian beleif mentioned by Allah in Quran

[@G_1allah]

All Catholics believe Mary is God if they call her the mother of God . What does that make her

[@user-dv7ik9cm7d]

ارجوا منك انت تعطي وقتك للرد علي المتحدثين باللغة الانجليزية

[@stonerosesuk]

43:00

[@marwahparuk3823]

I like the listen to the sheikh dont call names just give lecture and love. It's like u r being sinecal. No dont do that

[@delpthepath127]

Does the speaker’s view also apply to the tashahhud prayer where Muhammad is addressed to directly?

[@soid212]

Adressing the Prophet (saw) directly not an issue, asking for help is the issue.

[@delpthepath127]

@@soid212 😂 of course. Typical. He’s not dead huh? A divine being this Muhammad ain’t he?

[@soid212]

@@delpthepath127 nothing funny about this Discussion. The Prophet (saw) died just as every other human being is destined to die. This is very clear from Quran..

[@delpthepath127]

@@soid212 yet you somehow feel it’s okay to speak to him directly in your prayer, while claiming in the same breath that speaking to the dead is shirk. Great logic. Maybe if I mute my mind and avoid any form rigorous logical reasoning, you’d make sense to me.

[@soid212]

@@delpthepath127 Don't misguide Muslims. No, we don't believe that Muhammad (saw) listen to us directly and neither are we speaking to him Directly. Our Salam is presented to him.. Allah delivers the سلام as he wills through his Angels.. Have you never sent a letter to someone. Even if the person is not present or not even listening, you can address the person in a letter or a text message if you will. So no we don't believe he is alive and no we don't speak to him directly.

[@twoangels3405]

Christ Jesus is your God and mine. There is no other Who could you compare him to Christ Jesus bless you.

[@bxs4122]

Jesus pbuh was a man, a chosen prophet who ate and slept and became hungry, he prostrates and worships the CREATOR (Mathew 26:39) ALLAH who was always here before and after Jesus, Jesus is the son of Mary not the CREATOR OF THE UNIVERSE, ALLAH IS THE CREATOR OF THE UNIVERSE THE LORD OF THE UNSEEN, THE ONE WHO SENT ANGEL GABERIEL TO MARY TO BLESS HER WITH A CHILD, ALLAH doesn't sleep or eat and He has not been seen by men, I invite you to the true religion of JESUS, look at this sheikh in this video, Does he resemble Jesus or does your priest resemble Jesus, we are closer to Jesus than you(Christians) will ever be

[@sarkissati1217]

Адама и Еву создал Энки ⚡☝️⚡

[@supersleeper8545]

The irony here is that there is nothing to refute. May Allah bless Sheikh Yasir Qhadi, and may bless us to continue to benefit from him. May Allah protect us from this propaganda.

[@user-ki7do3hx8u]

R u kidding me? سبحان الله

[@marwahparuk3823]

ALLAH UAKBAR do yr lecturers without calling name's 🤨

[@shafiullahnoory6761]

lets call a spade a spade .

[@Cheguevara2.0]

Dude what have you done to help the Syrians and Uigur? Talking all these theories isnt going to help the real problems in this world. Dude Allah guides whom he want and leads astray those whom he wants.