Director Reacts - Dimash Qudaibergen - Love of Tired Swans MV

[@asia394]

This clip was released on April 18, 2019. and since then there's been a lot of controversy around it. Some viewers thought that if a song is about swans, then you should show the swans and their history. But the director of this video Badoev showed the legend of the red angels. //// Angels lived in their own country. They had their own God. They lived peacefully on the lake, loved each other and did not know the grief. But the evil demons broke out of the ground and took the red angels prisoner. So that the angels could not fly away, they broke one wing. Many of them could not move. Dimasha and his girlfriend were also broken one wing. At this time Dimash mentally recalled a happy life in the past. And suddenly Dimash decided to try to break free. He began to sing with his angelic voice. From the marvelous sounds of his voice the red angels came to life, began to splash in the lake. Dimash and her friend ran into the mountains, climbed to the top and decided to try to fly away. But because of the broken wings to fly away one by one they could not. They began to fall into the abyss. Then they held hands tightly. They got two wings for two. And they flew. ///// It was a story about love, loyalty, fall. The fact that you can only be saved together together. Only those who have held hands together, helping each other, can "take off" and achieve something in life.

[@mariasoto-ob9be]

Very good and interesting comment!

[@christelsegbars1630]

Dear beautiful humans, I don't care if the visuals are accurate, the lyrics speak to me so much as I just had to put down my baby girl dog Diva.... since then her lifepartner, my male dog Baco has such tired eyes, keeps surching for her, hé crawls into my arms and sighs...I think it's a beautiful song, thank you Rosco.😢😢😢

[@ideagirl]

Thank you for the explanation.

[@EllanaTs]

@@christelsegbars1630 my condolences! Hugs!

[@ideagirl]

@christelsegbars1630 OH, dear God. Please be with this human and doggy as they grieve. Hold them close. Send them comforting angels to surround them. I do understand. Last Thanksgiving, I had to put down my service animal of 18 years. I have cried and cried. And boohooed and boohooed. So don't keep the tears in. They are actually healing. And if I were you, I would actually talk to your other doggy and explain. As you know, they experience deep grief too. So hearing your soothing voice every day helps them. I've had to put down 4 other doggies in my lifetime. Something out of this world happened after my 2nd dog died. I would be in bed about to go to sleep when I felt something jump on the bed. I opened my eyes and couldn't see anything. Then I felt something very familiar. A little doggy curling up in his favorite place to cuddle and sleep. It was my dog who died. I even moved and got another doggy. But he moved with me. Then he stopped visiting after a long period of grieving. I'm so glad you have this song and lyrics to identify with. Special blessings sent your way. God Bless you and your other doggy.

[@NancyHole]

I heard all of your comments on this video. I'm not sure if this will give you any insight, and I can't for the life of me remember which DEAR wrote it, but here is the insider scoop on this video: The song of the "exhausted swans" is wonderfully suited to looking at our human relationships. It's about love and difficult human relationships. Once found, swans usually keep their mate for life. Alan Badoev (Ukrainian film director, clip maker, producer) was inspired to make this video in very different ways. The result is a mixture of the legend of one-winged angels that can only fly in pairs and the style of the film "Romeo and Juliet" by Italian director Franco Zeffirelli. Alan Badoev spoke about the main idea as follows: "Working with Dimash, I wanted to remind viewers once again that even as single-winged creatures, we can fly if we hold hands and split the sky in two." It was shot on a large scale - in beautiful locations in Spain near Malaga and in Ukraine. More than 70 different specialists were involved in the shooting. The music video premiered on April 18, 2019. This video is full of imagery, symbolism and mysticism and not easy to understand at first, but certainly one of the most beautiful Dimash music videos. It is indeed very elaborately produced, so to speak a short film of high perfection and also shows Dimash as a talented actor. These colorful red and yellow robes and graceful movements of the dancers, the way the faces were made up, harmonize wonderfully with the chosen landscapes - it gives the impression that they are not of and not from this world, as if we were given a glimpse into a world beyond ours. In a way, what happened reminds me of the time we are going through right now... A beautiful place, another planet where these angel/swan beings live. They have been attacked by a dark force and robbed of their wings and soulful beauty. Dimash as the main protagonist and his mate are being pushed onto the rock (like a sacrificial altar) by dark creatures - hurt, full of pain and suffering, he begs his soul mate for forgiveness, he couldn't protect her, they got separated... He remembers the time when beauty and love were still on their planet, they all had a companion and joy in being together and dancing. Perhaps they have betrayed their essence and love and God's creation? Apocalyptic scenes of destruction follow, a fireball descends, the earth trembles, a volcano erupts and releases these dark creatures. Many of the angelic/swan beings become separated from one another, die, or appear frozen and soulless and burnt out, without power or hope. Dimash, sad and desperate, sings of the lost love, the soulless cold that now lies over everything and that they are not made to live alone and apart from each other... Suddenly there is anger, strength and fighting spirit in Dimash, he raises his voice to the higher dimensions and energetic flashes revive him and some of the other swan beings; a powerful, magnificent scene - he stands there beautifully and wildly, reminiscent of depictions of Archangel Michael. This power and energy dissolves the destructive creatures, they turn to ash. He comes back into self-empowerment and can save his love, takes her by the hand, they run up to the cliff edge and let themselves fall into a new life together - their wings carry them together into the next dimension. And again we are talking about this love - the love that gives what the other needs. Love that acts, that brings together and overcomes separation and division.

[@juliekeesee3499]

This was an article in Russian newspaper regarding the directors vision. It was in the form of translated screenshots so I don't know who to credit for the article or translation .... Love of Tired Swans "Alan Badoev Shot A Clip For Dimash Kudaibergen " When we love, there is neither time nor place - there is only the feelings of wings behind our backs and the readiness to take off at any moment . This is the determination to take off, to become a little Icarus - in the clip from "Love of Tired Swans " from Alan Badoev and Dimash Kudaibergen. China or the Celestial , is fraught with many mysteries and, it would seem, not the first century is collecting the legends of the world - the main evidence that there are miracles on our planet. One of them is about one-winged angels who can neither fly up nor live on earth and die, one after another falling into the water, as if in eternity. In fact, these swans are people . Once flying in the sky, jumping from a cliff in search of a sensation of flight, chained to stones for the theft of fire , making amazing discoveries, fantastic inventions , turned into one-winged or completely wingless angels , falling to the earth, like Lucifer. And from here - from the fallen angel , so many passions, so many empty emotions and after them - defeats. Having lost the ability to take off , we gradually grow together with the earth , plunging more and more into the darkness thrusting our feelings and thoughts into cold water so that they would shrink from the cold chill and no longer disturb. But life is a great force, like love that comes without asking and settles on the shoulders , leaving a feeling of itching, burning , without hope of getting rid of it. But here the itching goes away , like all the torments and we feel how one wing suddenly grows behind our backs and its flap - this is a new life. A new moment in which we are born again and become one winged swans. There are such legends that are experiencing centuries and there are such voices that do not care about borders - personal or state, rules and prohibitions are not important - generally accepted or invented in books, because they penetrate every heart. The secret is simple - if the voice sounds like a man who sweeps a person out of his way with a powerful wave, it means nothing to prevent any obstacles to him - only the heart can watch and it will hear this call. The voice of Dimash Kudaibergen is a rising superstar , exactly like that. As if from somewhere with the records of the company "Melody" , from the dusty cabinet on the balcony, Muslim Magomayev returned. Suddenly turned 30 years - and before us is young Alexander Gradsky. But no, we will not compare the works of these artists, because every voice that can tear down walls is unique. It would be possible to say "penetrating the goose" and come up with thousands more cliches, but we will say much easier. The voice of Kudaibergen is as if your wing moves, as if the water is warming, where your thoughts and the sun rises above the ground to which you are chained. The video of the song "Love of Tired Swans " is a skillful, clear, deft and terrifying metaphorical story - illustration. No, not love, no, not the birth of a wing, not easy - a tearful drama about swans - all this does not matter. The video was filmed in Spain and Ukraine and in time, the shooting took more than 3 days. For the first time, Alan Badoev worked for the Chinese media market , because the song, written in 2014, is published in two languages at once - Russian and Chinese. In the video, Alan Badoev accurately reflected this important thing - this is the first movement on his way to wings, when his legs are not yet firm, but his eyes are already looking up. And this look is the most important thing in a person. The firm intention to fly up, in spite of everything , embodied by the brilliant FREEDOM ballet. "In my work with Dimash, I wanted to remind the viewer once again, that even being one-winged we can fly" the director reveals the idea of the video. If you carefully pay attention to the details of the clip, the main idea emerges by itself , separately from your thoughts. The main thing here is not the love that the main characters experience and the release from the shackles that still occurs. The point is that there is no time around us, no problems and barriers. There is only Cosmos , with which we touch fingers - unique fingers, each with its own pattern and imprint. This uniqueness is our eternity, which must be accepted into ourselves. Accepting eternity , awakening and then - liberation from shackles and barriers , victory over a demon and perpetual flight is the main idea of the clip. And his heroes are flying from a cliff, as if Icarus of our time. By the way, about the demons that take the flock off-guard - where did they come from? All this - our doubts and fears, insults and empty emotions, taking energy, chaining back. Each of us is Lucifer himself , and this must be accepted , as well as his own uniqueness. Swans conquer their demons by unity (for which they needed a red cube) and by accepting that you need to know yourself first and foremost, and love will come as a reward. And she came to the main character , and freed him, giving his soul the opportunity to fly away with the one to whom he was traveling this difficult path. And, together with him, it seems as if we are all flying - little Icares of our century , letting ourselves go and losing our Lucifer along the road, losing our scorched earth that our life seems to us to be. Together with Dimash and Badoev each of us supposedly makes his leap into eternity and settles in the sky, sometimes shining on earth and awakening new swans."

[@nicevinci_dear]

The discription of the video tells, that this video is based on an old German legend about a single-winged angels. The angels can’t fly without the right partner. In the video both of them lose a wing but if they are together, they are can fly again. The video was shot in the highlands of Spain. There is a making of video with background information and interviews with Dimash and the director Alan Badoev, a Ukrainian film director: kzbin.info/www/bejne/bmKreoCboNR9qq8 I have many Dimash songs that I consider favorites and I can't decide which one is better. However, I can say with certainty that this song is my absolute favorite song. It wasn't until I started listening to Dimash that I realized how incredibly beautiful songs are in Russian. Unfortunately it is also a very difficult language, at least for me. Love Of Tired Swans is also a song written by Igor Krutoy, although Lara Fabian sang it for the first time. And there is a version from his last concert in Almaty, Kazakhstan Part 2 in September 2022. The song starts at about 12.50 minutes. After that he sings with the Dears. What fascinates me is that in many songs that we know, Dimash's voice sounds now much deeper in the lower notes. He must have worked pretty hard on it. I love it. Love Of Tired Swans Almaty concert Part 2 min. 12:50: kzbin.info/www/bejne/m3Kopn2ipKiSjs0 Greeting and love from Germany❤️🎶

[@p.f.5718]

The end is like this: Even you have only one wing you can survive together - because you both have two wings. And the falling down is important because you have to gain speed to get of together. It’s like an airplane to start with no runway. They didn’t want to fall to death they wanted to fly only with two wings. Love from Austria 🇦🇹

[@monikaberger1979]

Wow ❤

[@marianelechiguerra]

Esta canción me parece preciosa,con un gran profesional como el director,estoyviviendola mejor, mil gracias!

[@thewarriorforever]

Criticisms are like compliments,everyone has their say,and everyone is right or wrong,depends on the points of view and tastes that are personal..What one don't like another like a lot,and is good and right so..But a very important thing is the respect for the opinions of the others..Personally i like a lot every mv of Dimash because for me are work of art of high level and quality,and i like the collaboration Dimash with Badoev because are 2 genius in their works/arts,Dimash like singer/artist and Badoev like director..Obviously for who don't understand art and geniality is more simple and easy criticize than make an effort to understand..King Angel Dimash Forever

[@RR-LMSL18]

Stunningly beautiful visuals, lyrics, and music. In my opinion, Dimash is to music as Shakespeare is to literature. Dimash is my addiction;)

[@carmenmariella443]

Dimash is a miracle, so his absolute powerful and unshakable presence on stage, compared by some to a god of music, sometimes to a prince or king, the energy he absorbs from the Universe, then how he anchors himself to the Earth, his connection with the Divinity, all at a place, it gives him the strength and confidence to "command the audience, to order the orchestra, to order the song", so that everything comes out the way he wants and how Dimash feels, that is unique. All these qualities are only at Dimash, absolutely. The goosebumps and hypnosis induced by Dimash are the characteristics of his concerts and appearance on stage, which are shaped by his endless beauty, sometimes translucent, sometimes sensual, sometimes angelic !!! Dimash is storm, thunder, lightning, sun, rain, smile, but also love and last but not least he is our hope and our daily light, he is our spiritual food when you put your head on the pillow and start dreaming like tomorrow it's a day… !!!!! Dimash has God's kiss on his heart!!!! Dimash's cerebral hemisphere are like the mathematics of song. The precision, the climax of the pieces, the breath control, all are mathematical. Nothing higher, nothing lower. Absolute accuracy !!! Not to mention, he has the number of destiny 7, the number of God. One more proof that Dimash is sent by God in the art of love through song!!!

[@chickencaramel]

Not a day passes that I do not listen to Dimash. He is a phenomenal singer and artist and a great human being. Thank you for reacting to him.

[@maisaebrahim9048]

As always Dimash is the best

[@bookworm8385]

The director had his own artistic vision, Dears just wanted to see close-ups of Dimash singing. ❤

[@ij4091]

This is an MV, not an Oscar-winning feature film. Everyone has their point of view. I love all Dimasha's MVs because they are different, not common, intriguing, forcing you to think, to draw your own conclusions. I respect Dimash for his courage in choosing the script, for his unconventional approach to art, for trusting the directors. Such intriguing works always attract me. And technical matters are not important to me if the work appeals to me. But I'm just an ordinary viewer, not a specialist,

[@sabinelenz2050]

Very good comment. 👍😘

[@JustMyOpinion1010]

I agree with some of his viewpoints. I guess it is how he brought his point across that started working on my nerves a bit.

[@anistardi]

If technical review is not important to you, you should not watch this video.

[@JustMyOpinion1010]

@@anistardi but one can get your point across in different ways. I feel that criticism should always be constructive and shared in a respectful way. It is a skill that seems to be sorely lacking these days.

[@anistardi]

@@JustMyOpinion1010 Not lacking, but because of internet so they can be anonimous and mostly they are kid or teenager.

[@nassfaceless]

As I remember it was a first video of him we saw on TV and it was shocked to hear THIS among all russian-language pop music that period. But MV still the same level with everyone’s else

[@lindahake1666]

The final scene shows that even though they each had a wing lasered off, by flying together they were able to survive. Just for your own enjoyment, watch the performance of this song at the Kremlin. It’s so good!!! Thanks for your reaction and support of Dimash. 💞💞💞🤗

[@evawettergren7492]

Appreciate your analysis and critique of the video and cinematography. Somehow when you don't automatically like everything it means more when you actually do like things.

[@UNDERFLIPED]

the ending was they needed eachother to fly! (their each one wing was halfened) they were broken apart but whole together! Thats what I took from it

[@maricarmengisbert-rh4fd]

Querido Roscoe,soy española y dear absoluta de Dimash ,le conoci von esta cancion ya hace mas de un año ,pero no esta version ,sino otra en un cocierto muy elegante y mas jovencito,esta en cocreto esta integramente rdada en mi pais ,en las minas de Rio Tinto (Huelva) ,España ,y es maravillosa como todo lo que hace Dimash ,tiene una belleza cromatica y unos escenarios naturales sacados de otro planeta ,es un espectaculo hermoso a la vista y al oido ,con la voz angelical de mi rey kazajo,me gustan mucho tus reacciones y te sigo ,bravo Dimash el mejor del mundo ,le amo ,Carmen .🤗🤗🤗🎆🎆👑👑🤩🤩🤲🤲✌️✌️🌟🌟🌟🌍🌍💯💯🫂🫂🙏🙏🙏🇰🇿🇰🇿🇪🇦🇪🇦

[@lorenasaez1679]

Así es,de hecho hace honor a España, pues la chica lleva la los colores de la bandera ❤❤ yo escucho a Dimash desde hace 4 años...y es magia

[@DQ_Mine]

Exquisite. I love it! It helped when a fan explained the story.

[@montseandreulopez7279]

All Dimash's vídeos are amazing. This song is very beautiful and it wasmy first Dimash's song three years ago. ❤🎼❤🎼❤🎼❤

[@RogerioEsteves-c3u]

DIMASH CADA DIA QUE PASSA IMPRESIONA MAIS E FICA MAIS GENIAL

[@СветланаКаляева-ю1п]

Димаш 😃☝️🤗🤩💯🤴👍👍👍🤩🤩🤩💞💞💞👏👏👏

[@gdouglas999]

I agree with you, and with those who have a problem with the music video. This is probably my favorite Dimash song, but I want to see him singing it live, not buried in endless imagery that this video presents. I can (and have) watched live versions (especially the one at the Kremlin) dozens, and perhaps hundreds, of times by now. As for this music video, I will only watch it when someone is reacting to it, but always feel as if the reactor has been cheated of Dimash's incredible stage performance of the song.

[@anaissalazarrealtor]

Este video trata de la historia de Los Ángeles Rojos caídos, no de Cisnes, es una historia triste pero a la vez llena de esperanza, ya que el final, cada uno vuela con la ayuda del ala del otro, eso es amor!

[@gamilaabbas588]

This is one of my favorites 🥰 I looove the MV and the song and of course I looooove my king Dimash ❤️ Thank you Roscoe for your reaction ❤️

[@KoReGAMEREUS]

Please react to the song "EL AMOR EN TI" of Dimash✌

[@francelarebelle1138]

Oh yes!

[@marantonio9103]

Of course, directors differ on many things, but we know you love Dimash.

[@bahardemirci9810]

Dmash ❤️❤️🙏🙏❤️❤️🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️🙏❤️🙏❤️❤️

[@Javier-id4lq]

Thanks for your analysis.

[@giselasenergyart1709]

Thank you for your great reaction! Amazing vocals by Dimash like always and what a beautiful song! ❤

[@marisaperezsuarez6893]

Siempre he dicho que no representan cisnes sino angeles caidos....❤ gracias.

[@mrychards6682]

As always, I love Dimash's voice. I love the majority of his videos, with a handful of exceptions, including this one. That is reality. We are all different, and even those of us who love Dimash can like or even dislike particular songs/videos. Thank you for your knowledgeable reaction to it and for continuing to react to Dimash.

[@suzanne6664]

You need to see the story first. There is a reason for everything he does. He sings this at concerts, mostly Igor's. The MV is to show an interpretation of the story and what happens to the swans. The song says Swans cannot live apart. He has a very vivid imagination and produces things that most people would not even conceive. PS. he says he doesn't want pple to concentrate on his voice and octaves, but what he does. As with One Sky, its not about his voice, or the music, its about the message. I think you should see all his MV's, especially Screaming, then Okey, with a very strong story, Golden, also very different. Have u seen War and Peace, which he did many years b4 One Sky? There are so many performances still to see and many concerts which showcase all different aspects of him. I think the more you see the more u will understand him. Even go back to when he lived in China. 2 concerts are Fuzhou and Shenzen.

[@duniatucker1638]

This is a MASTERPIECE 💖💞💕

[@ideagirl]

Thank you for sharing. As always Dimash's voice is Stunningly Exquisite! Kudos to the directors and whomever created this concept. It's also Stunningly Exquisite. Kudos to the art designers. And applause for everyone designing and creating this work of art. It immediately grabbed my heart and captured me. I'm gone. So. I think about this. And I had the same thoughts about Jin. What happens when you discover you have this amazing voice inside you? It's like a secret chamber is opened and sweet butterflies fly out with beauty and ease. The only way I can relate is...I finally took private voice lessons when I returned to college at 50. Being a musical theatre person, I really wanted to tap into all I had. There is a specific technique a voice coach uses to discover your range. The technique is really fascinating. I found out I really was a soprano, not an alto. I can't imagine them discovering their hidden talent. What it felt like. How it would change their lives forever and beyond. So as I continue to listen to Dimash, who has the most amazing range of any singer ever....his voice teacher probably fainted upon discovery of Dimash's talent! And Jin, when he found out... his voice teacher said he became her best student ever. Practicing and practicing. And developing and developing his velvet belting voice. It seems Dimash's voice and tone and frequency actually reaches other planets and universes. And speaks personally to angels in Heaven!

[@DQ_Mine]

❤

[@ideagirl]

@@DQ_Mine 💕

[@mariasoto-ob9be]

El final del video, que está lleno de simbolismos sobre los ángeles de una sola ala, quiere expresar una vez más que todos podemos salvarnos, en este caso salir volando, si alguien nos tiende una mano, en este caso otro angel que comparte su ala con Dimash para volar juntos. Amor, unión y esperanza, como siempre, son los mensajes que nos envía Dimash con sus canciones.

[@rosarionavega1966]

Dimash especial y tú consigues que veamos y entendámos lo especial y extraordinario que es, por tus sentimientos y reacciónes tan sinceras al escuchar su voz, desde España, gracias ❤

[@analia9306]

Amo ésta canción pero prefiero cuando la canta en vivo.Saludos para ti y todos los Dears desde Argentina!!!🤗❤🇦🇷

[@rada-tut]

I totally agree with you. This clip is made in a hack. Both the idea of the plot and the special effects are not at the same height as Dimash. He deserves more

[@emaema1764]

Kod svih Slovena, Rusa, Srba, Čeha , Poljaka itd...labud je simbol odanosti. Labud nikad ne menja partnera , često i umire ako ih razdvoje. Ljubav labudova je nešto što se ne sme napadati, oni mogu da žive samo zajedno. Zato naslov pesme Ljubav umornih labudova, nama Slovenima sve govori, iako ste zmorni, ne zaboravite svoju prirodu, ne razdvajajte se, umrećete ako se prevarite....To je i oesma o izazovima današnjeg sveta koji razdvaja ljubavne parove, umara ih, vara ih, dok ih ne razdvoji... A kad ih razdvoje, života više nema....

[@markoprskalo6127]

Tako je

[@adrianapartida2968]

A mi si me gusto mucho el video

[@DearsPears]

This clip was shot in Spain, directed by Alan Badoev from Ukraine. Very talented.

[@dougfriendly7676]

Over-produced, though. I'm with Roscoe on this one. Much prefer the live performances.

[@ЦветокМира-у4р]

Вы можете посмотреть выступление Димаша с этой песней на многих концертах.На его канале есть концертная версия песни

[@blancagaetemellado4624]

Esta canción es mi top uno ...pero me gustan las presentaciones en vivo....y lo bueno tengo muchas para ver ya que la canta en todos sus conciertos......la letra muy bella y la interpretación de Dimash en vivo un deleite vocal y visual....

[@MaryAnnRankin-r4p]

I wish you could direct a video for Dimash. Your enthusiasm for his talent and your passion for your direction would be dynamic to see

[@lianasokara3963]

I adore this MV ❤ It potrays perfectly the story of the Red Angels. There is a comment below that talks about the this story

[@izayama9183]

Gosto muito do seu react a Dimash

[@sallystubbs7417]

THSNK YOU for your reaction and comments!

[@josephanna9349]

Reactors seem to have troubles with this MV and i can t understand why because to me its obvious that Dimash and his director wanted to do more with this video than to create pictures to the lyrics. But then I m already familiar with the work of artists that have to work their way around censorship. Its my most favorite kind of art actually. And maybe also lots of people do not realize that Dimash has spoken against the tendency of certain nations to absorb other nations long before the war in Ukraine.

[@nancyhashiguchi8470]

awesome!!!

[@ЭммаДунаева-ю3ш]

Хотите посмотреть без клипа, очень легко- смотрите без клипа, много роликов на концертах, где Димаш поет эту суперпесню

[@bayanbarmankulova121]

Изобразительный фон, на мой взгляд, избыточен, тяжеловесен, рассчитан на тех, кому мало голоса, слов и мелодии, кому надо всё расшифровать.

[@Алмазовна-о2н]

Автор, видимо, захотел посмотреть с клипом, в силу своей профессии. И, думаю, его критика здесь вполне оправдана. Этот проект, наверно, единственный, который меня тоже смущал с самого начала. Концепция очень нравится, но действительно много моментов, режущих глаз дилетантским исполнением даже мне, дилетанту. Этот полет в закат мне напоминает китайские фэнтези фильмы, где так же "летают" неестественно, очевидно подвешенные на тросе. В общем, я тоже испытывала горькое сожаление от всего этого.

[@yolandagomes3174]

Hola director. Le recomiendo la presentación en vivo con Krutoy Para analizar y disfrutar más a Dimash esa versión que le recomiendo es buenisima, espectacular. Los videos clip cambia mucho, los efectos son muy fuertes Creo que el director con la producción tenían otro concepto de la cancion. Pero no deja de ser una magistral presentación. Dimash es maravilloso 👏 Excelentes análisis. Saludos desde Panamá 🇵🇦

[@clararoldan2732]

Estimado director,este video nunca me terminó de convencer. Por eso me gusta la versión con krutoy tocando el piano y una pantalla viva de cisnes y Dimash cantando con su hermoso traje elegante,es más bello.Me molesta no ver a nuestro kasajo cantando libremente 😢 Totalmente de acuerdo con UD.saludos abuela de Argentina

[@patriciaple4342]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Belle réaction magnifique Dimash ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@rosarosa898]

Me encanta, es hermoso!! Este film esta rodado en mi pais España. En las Minas de Río Tinto Huelva. Dimash es súper detallista ya que la bailarina protagonista lleba puesto por vestido, la bandera de España a diferencia de las demás que es solo rojo. Todo un detalle de agradecer. Grande nuestro Dimash 🎼 mil gracias por seguir reaccionando al mas grande y único DIMASH

[@miguelsolo416]

Vaya, nunca me había fijado en este detalle de la bandera española, y que fuera rodado en España. Gracias por compartirlo.

[@carolinaacosta7321]

great MV thanks

[@yayangyang7136]

Very good reaction and analisis..... love it❤

[@francelarebelle1138]

Thank you for your reaction

[@marantonio9103]

Thank you for your reaction. We know you like Dimash.

[@puribuenoesteban]

Gracias por traer denuevo a Dimash a tu canal. Saludos desdd España.❤Dimash❤.

[@ewasz.8947]

Dziękuję za tłumaczenie polskie 🙏❤ teledyski Dimasha są zawsze niesamowite ❣️ kocham

[@cleilanunez8490]

Yayyyy Dimash! That voice makes me crazy! Like you said, I love to get lost in his voice❤

[@biljanakv]

Dimash ❤❤❤❤❤

[@kulamars]

Es una de mis favoritas, pero prefiero cuando lacanta en vivo. Aunque el video esta bien, como dice usted. Hay momentos y momentos.

[@gluvisgarcia8748]

Hola, con esta hermosa cancion conoci a Dimash por eso la amo, el en todos sus conciertos la canta es espectacular, me gustan mucho tus reacciones, son fantasticas, si quieres ver un buen video te recomiendo The History Of One Sky, es un video fuerte, con un gran mensaje una verdadera obra de arte que todo el mundo deberia conocer, las imagenes , la voz,el mensaje de Dimash son Magistrales un Arte, gracias, besos

[@ConnieBach]

He’s the greatest on the planet yes!!!❤❤❤

[@PatriciaPalmer-o3e]

Swans mate for life and frequently used in imagery and themes in his performances and videos.

[@francelarebelle1138]

❤❤❤

[@Fearless_walker]

The last scene shows that the two of them tried to fly with their last strength, even though they were so injured. And they did it and became free. But I'm also of the opinion that the video doesn't completely match this song. But those were Dimasch's first steps in video production. He's very talented and can do a lot more.

[@lisamomon6793]

There's a making of video about this video It from a short story about angels. Looks like they change their .minds about the ending

[@1oldcrow350]

💜

[@giuseppecefali9302]

Magnifico dimash voce epica ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Bludreamgirl]

God this has to be my favorite dimash song, I love walking up to see a Roscoe reaction to dimash thank you! 😭

[@coralesangiovannibattistastezz]

I love Dimash ❤ Kisses from Italy 😘😘😘

[@fiorelasuarez7872]

Saludos desde Venezuela muchas gracias por compartir y reaccionar al maestro Dimash es hermoso el video y la interpretación impresionante ❤😮😊 por favor puedes reaccionar a Acros y Know los videos son maravillosos 😊❤

[@KathySwampQueen]

KNOW is already in the videos 🦌💜😊 here's the link kzbin.info/www/bejne/qpycaGOqgdR8i9Esi=Cx-42pvzWrDDcmnu

[@barefootalien]

If I had to guess, I'd think that the director did the practical effects, wire work, etc, and... sucks. They might've done some of the poorer VFX as well... but then they outsourced some of the more difficult and expansive scenes, like the meteors and lasers, and Dimash's burst of power to a company that frankly stole the show. Just a guess, but I tend to _be_ one of those subcontractors that make companies wish they'd given me the whole project, and this has that kind of dynamic written all over it. It's also possible that Dimash and/or Igor wanted to use some university kids. This was right around the time Dimash got his Master's (he's currently working on his Ph.D. in addition to being a world-famous popera star, and seriously influential philanthropist, a cultural ambassador for his nation, and building and running his creative center. So maybe this was a Master's project for some filmmaking students from Russia, Ukraine, and/or Kazakhstan. (If you didn't know, Igor Krutoy is a Ukrainian-born Russian. He's won knighthood-level accolades from four different governments: USSR, Russian Federation, Ukraine, and Kazakhstan.)

[@brasil1604]

Epic and amazing 💜💗💝💖

[@FawziaTung]

The final flying away is about the use of one wing each (since they had the other one cut off by laser beam) to manage to fly as one.

[@Pilutta100]

Totally agree with you. I had the feeling throughout the whole video that I was close to tears and then smthng was kinda off af, if I would have been 15 I would have bought it all❤ Dimash is amazing and I just always want to see more. Hugs from Sweden.

[@samatappasov3248]

Hi from KYRGYZSTAN 🇰🇬!Thanks for your reaction!

[@marlenemarenco9694]

Me encanta Dimash 💯💯🇨🇷❤️

[@dougfriendly7676]

Yes, yes, yes! I've always thought this music video (beautiful as it is) was a distraction from Dimash's incredible vocals on this song---which is why I always recommend that reactors first witness his spectacular vocal performance of this song live in Moscow.

[@nadaassaly8185]

❤❤

[@nataliakouzel562]

🤗🤗🤗🤗thank you🥰🥰

[@rosemaryshackleton4780]

There seems to be a reference to the story of angels each with only one wing who can only fly in pairs which appears to have happened at the end after they'd both had a wing (or half a wing) lasered off. Maybe the story is that together anything is possible 🪽🪽

[@amyrosado4066]

I respect your directors point of veiw! Awsome reaction as usual! 🙏🏼🙌🏻😘🥰

[@baurhan-ov5zx]

👌🔥👏

[@stellamarina.]

It's not just people being in the background. You missed the symbolisms and the meaning! How many famous singers have such an amazing MV production?

[@floweroflife0306]

Great rection to the best singer in the world.

[@ekm9055]

Roscoe, nie!!! Przeczytaj najpierw komentarz od użytkownika "asia394". Tam dowiesz się, dlaczego są pokazane elementy, których ty nie umieszczałbyś w żadnym video, jako reżyser. Są częścią historii, o której opowiada Dimash. Jeżeli masz uczucie "niespójności", to dlatego, że DOKŁADNIE taki efekt miał zostać wywołany w naszym żołądku, sercu, duszy. U Dimasha nie ma nigdy elementów przypadkowych, nigdy rzeczy tylko "dla dekoracji". Wszystko jest celowe i pełni swoją funkcję. To tak jakbyś wyszedł na ulicę i zażądał posuwania znaków drogowych, bo ci "szpecą krajobraz"! Nie! Dimash przekazuje wiadomość równolegle na wielu poziomach: scen filmowych, kolorystyki, głosu, emocji, muzyki w tle, tekstu, nietypowych symboli uzupełniających obraz, porównań z historią realną, odniesień do literatury, muzyki i sztuki malarskiej już istniejącej na świecie, przewidywań dla przyszłości, historii dziejącej się w drugim planie, analogii z fragmentami innych piosenek Dimasha (z którymi razem te wycinki danych tworzą oddzielną, spójną informację). Dimasha trzeba oglądać z naprawdę otwartymi oczami. Czy zauważyłeś ruiny starożytnej cywilizacji? Fakt, że Anioły mogą bezpiecznie przebywać tylko w "pudełku"? Że są uwięzione we wspólnej "sieci" (internet)? Że na brzegu stoją szpalery żołnierzy, gotowych do ataku? To tylko wybrane elementy całego przekazu. Jest ich dużo więcej. Obejrzyj i pomyśl jeszcze raz!

[@abeersharawi1605]

Thank you so much 😘😘 i wish you can hear the same song in lara fabian voice

[@corysoles]

I understand that you look at the video from the perspective of a director. I thought it was beautiful, but I do agree that the lightning when Dimash fights the "bad guys" took me a little out of the enchantment. Thank you for your honesty. Kisses.

[@SaveOurChildren7]

I see no fault in this video clip, nor do 99% coaches and directors ❤❤❤❤

[@ThisRoscoe]

This is the beauty of the difference in opinions, my friend. :)

[@MosheGavrielBinkovitz]

@@ThisRoscoe I apologize! It's not a matter of opinion one way or another! There is a clear difference between a video where the artist sings alone and a video where the singer sings in the background and actually the video presents you with a message or an idea! This time you got confused my friend! Do you expect a music video to present Dimash as in a live performance?!

[@jvshuwa]

@@ThisRoscoeI understand your opinion. I prefer “live” performances, so it just focuses on his voice. But yeah I guess this director is a little strange, I don’t like some of his Music Videos.

[@queeniebennett5589]

I agree

[@gladysrebezonsaavedra9816]

Hay personas que pueden hacer varias cosas a la vez😮

[@wkusnaj167]

А мне нравится первая версия песни...

[@Florida.miass.Russia]

Чья версия?

[@KathySwampQueen]

Good morning Dears!!! 🦌💜😊 Join the #CouchCrew for the Livestream at 12pm EST today!! It'll be fun I promise 😊....you know our beloved Roscoe might be able to play some Dimash!!! 🦌🦌🦌🦌

[@ThisRoscoe]

Kathy, my DEARest 😆, I do have Dimash on a list, but its a HUGE list and I'm gonna be rogue the entire time (plus Fireball so WHO KNOWS 🥴). I can't necessarily guarantee that Dimash will be played. Don't want to let anyone down if they show up for a multi-hour livestream and get disappointed.

[@RR-LMSL18]

You can close your eyes if you don’t care for the visuals. I love love love the visuals.

[@ThisRoscoe]

You're right, I wasn't thinking. Next video: "Director *_with his eyes closed_* Reacts".

[@anistardi]

@@ThisRoscoe 🤣🤣🤣 It is funny that you have to deal with stupid random people on internet who do not understand a director profession.

[@TamaraPanera]

💜💜

[@RosalindaHenry-hm5jc]

Si, Roscoe, there were scenes I felt conflicted with, too. Your advise should be used to make this an even better video😊 Of course, Dimash's voice needs no correction 🎶😀👍

[@pilar1366]

Este vídeo es una obra de arte! Filmado en las Minas de Riotinto, España. No entiendo que te pasó con esta maravilla. Es arte! Puedes reaccionar al vídeo de Know y al de Golden... Saludos

[@JustMyOpinion1010]

You need to pay attention to the colour of the sky in the images you didn't like. Time doesn't run in a continuum in the storyline. See the demons, look at the sky. Think about it. When they jump off the cliff and fly away, it is also not a happy ending. You need to think because there is symbolism and innuendo in everything. (I agree that some of those images looked a bit corny. And when they.

[@elida8300]

🙏🇧🇷♥️🇰🇿