Do All Disbelievers Go To Hell in Islam?

[@zebulongoertzel5162]

All these Quranic mentions of Mercy aren't sarcasm or hyperbole, Allah really is Merciful. We'd better believe it.

[@aftablondon]

I do!

[@Omgirrl]

No veiled threat there.

[@divyavichar]

@@zebulongoertzel5162 Or else.

[@QuadrantRoyale]

Don't get carried away now...

[@TikyeWilliams]

Ameen

[@b-sideplank]

this question deserves a more complete answer, involving more complex situations, but not uncommon ones.

[@007kash007]

can you list a few

[@hello.bellot8407]

Alhamdulillah you make it simple

[@Reewnat]

The only addition I would add to this succinct explanation is that kufr is the rejection of truth. According to scholars that I have listened to, the truth has to be apparent to the person in their heart, and it is rejected. Is simply telling someone sufficient for them to grasp the truth or to seek further research? Many shuyukh , as I understand them, have said simple conveyance is not enough to cross that threshold for that person receiving (though the person offering the advice/truth may have satisfied the requirement of spreading the message).

[@DestinyAwaits19]

Islam is not the truth. God is truth. Heaven is truth. But not islam. Look up something called NDE. Near Death Experience. Its where people die and come back to life. They all report of Akhira. They say they met God and walked through his shiny meadows, felt his beautiful winds and drank his perfect water. They were atheists, agnostics, Christians, Muslims, Jews, Buddists. It didn't matter what they were. God loved them regardless of their beliefs. God doesn't care if you believe in him or not.

[@tarikchadili9696]

that's exactly how I've been seeing things all along. Allah is the best of judges, so much that he can accurately quantify both good and bad deeds on a scale. It's not our place to tell him what's wrong or right.

[@_zaaphiel]

The Maturidi position on this >>>>>>>

[@user-bn2nv5mx2g]

What’s the Maturidi position

[@KtKo0t]

Allahumma barik

[@shamimazad007]

Simple answer YES. Tauhid is must for entering Jannah.

[@triesposto]

Assalamu Alaykum. While I do agree with the premise, I'd like to ask you to expand on, and consider incomplete the "It's enough to tell them that Allah is One and he sent a Messenger named Muhammad". There is a problem with this, ignoring basic human psychology. For example, how many Muslims do you know born as Muslims in Muslim lands, and all of them have heard of Hinduism, Christianity, Buddhism etc etc. Be realistic in the answer on how many of them (including me for some of them), have researched all of these religions considering they are born and bred that they are upon the haqq and everything else is irrelevant to hear let alone research. I can speak for my place, and say that 90% of Muslim population here, haven't even considered in their life to research another religion as they are content in what they are. Certain people are by nature not inquisitive, it is how their brain is wired, are they blamed for that? I can argue that majority of Americans, who were born as "Christians", haven't even considered researching the topic of Islam, Muhammad s.a.w.s. and the Islamic message for the same reasons. That was the first bit, the second bit would be; what if the inquisitive kind among them have doubts in their own religion, and try researching, and go to the local Imam, and Imam is for example a flat-earther, what would give this person motivation to search for a second Imam rather than search for a Baptist priest to hear his thing? It doesn't even have to be as extreme as flat-earth, let's say the person is very intelligent, and has genuine questions about existence of God, providence, good-evil, unseen world etc. - and the Imam is unable to answer him in a logical fashion? I've had a genuine atheist looking for answers, go to the local average-iq imam and asked him "why is this and this" and his answer was "because Allah said so in the Qur'an and that's the end of it". And so she lost interest believing "this is what they believe and I see it as not true". What if she encountered, idk, William Lane Craig who has at least some philosophical ground to stand on, and he satisfies her question? Wouldn't this woman also believe in Islam the same way if she met Imam Al-Ghazali, who'd perhaps stun her with direct and complex answers. Can it truly be said for her, that she "recieved the message" ? Jazzakallah hayren shaykh, just food for thought.

[@duralumin_]

This question i also want answered beause it has been in my head for a while

[@yeager1234]

exactly nice, explained.

[@triesposto]

@@duralumin_ Salam akhi, I, for myself have long since removed this shubha by knowing that Allah s.w.t. is indeed the most-merciful and most-just. Being the most-just, He'll judge every person according to his own circumstances, and no-one on Qiyamah will say that they have been wronged - as we are told by the Qur'an. My main contention and reason for the comment is really in the approach on propagation of "what is considered as message received", and I'd like our daees to explore further this question and place importance upon it. I'm certain Shaykh just overlooked the intricacies and would like his take on the issue.

[@duralumin_]

@@triesposto Wa alaikum as salam wa rahmatullah wa barakatuh, I see JazakAllahu Khairan

[@poopyfarts6848]

If you're genuine in your search for the truth, you'll keep looking no matter what

[@Iamfsaly]

Surah Al-Bayyina 6 (Those who disbelieve among the People of the Book and the idolaters will have the Fire of Hell, there to remain. They are the worst of creation.) Sahih Muslim 153 (By Him in Whose hand is the life of Muhammad, he who amongst the community of Jews or Christians hears about me, but does not affirm his belief in that with which I have been sent and dies in this state (of disbelief), he shall be but one of the denizens of Hell-Fire.)

[@tarikchadili9696]

straight and to the point lol

[@Alandforman]

Also, let's be clear, the Koran is a patchwork of what we call plagiarism nowadays. Where did the Koran writers get the concept that God is One? Torah. Where did they get the concept of eternal punishment in hell? New Testament. Furthermore, the muslims believe that by works, albeit immoral works such as fighting, murder, lying, deceit, guile, raping, enslaving, the "infidels" they will gain God's favor. However, how many laws have they broken from God's Commandments alone by following such a religion of "peace"? It's nonsense.

[@ALWAYSFAITHFUL247]

Alhamdulillah..

[@user-bn2nv5mx2g]

By your logic when you “suspend” Hadith Al Fatarah because “it’s Ahad” then what it is the point of calling people to Islam if they just go to paradise anyway? If anything, by that logic then you would hide the message in order to get everyone into paradise.

[@nurjahanhaq6342]

That’s what I’ve been thinking too.

[@Lele-ob8pe]

Consider this: Would it be illogical to punish someone without knowing the true message, or that he knows distorted message of Islam (like ISIS?) Regarding your question: There is no good & bad i.e. morals outside of paradigm you're representing. So if you didn't hear the message of Islam, and you went living a completely liberal/atheistic life, you'd be bound to commit evil such as zina, ribba or other types of sins, which in today's society aren't illegal and sometimes are well-paid. There's also a chance you'd be completely good and avoid all evil according to our standards, but who is willing to take that chance? Are you, as a fellow, good human being able to let someone take that chance, or would you rather inform them in a right manner of what good and evil is, so he might avoid punishment? Rewind that further to the age of American slavery and Great Britain, and you'd be employing hundreds of black folk treating them like animals, believeing you are righteous because it's all made legal by human-made laws. Islam tells you: in order to be good and moral and avoid punishment in the afterlife, you are to do this and avoid that, and we got what is good and bad from God Himself rather than man-made laws and what's currently "trending". That's why Dawah is very important and encouraged, because the closer you get someone to God, the more likely he is to commit good and avoid evil. If however your dawah is bad (i.e. ISIS) and you distance that person from God by a hateful and illogical rhetoric, that person's circumstances and reasons will be considered by Allah and he will be put on an individual test

[@SafinaSociety]

It is not suspended for being ahad. Rather because the mutawatir verse is stronger, and ahad does not provide exception to mutawatir. Second point... If you do not dawa you are sinful

[@user-bn2nv5mx2g]

@@Lele-ob8pe I’m in complete agreement with what you’re saying.

[@user-bn2nv5mx2g]

@@SafinaSociety1. I don’t see a contradiction between Hadith Al Fatarah and the Ayah you cited. 2. I was asking the question from a logical point of you rather than a Shar’i point of view since that’s how “you guys” like to approach the deen. From a logical point of view the answer you provided doesn’t suffice.

[@shahriarahmed358]

To say with جزم that those who haven’t received the message and those who have received a distorted message will enter heaven مطلقا is a problematic stance. As this has some لوازمات that don’t make sense: - if they will go to heaven then why even give them dawat? Why place them in a scenario where they may enter hell forever? And answering by saying “because dawat is essential” is not a good جواب to the إشكال, since the action of dawat is fard kifaya. Also it can be said that if Allah will forgive those who don’t know the message then surely Allah will forgive those who haven’t given dawat since they are Muslim. - if ppl will enter paradise by not knowing about Islam then that makes the action of dawat pointless - to do إلغاء of a خبر الواحد due to the apparent contradiction, then to make جزم on the above mentioned ppl going to heaven is not correct, if you do توقف on the meaning of what nabi ﷺ is saying then توقف should also be taken when stating the outcome of those who never received the message. The Ashari and Maturidi already have stances on these issues. It is better to just state them and what book you are taking reference from. Allah knows best.

[@TikyeWilliams]

Allah SWT knows best

[@MohammedKhan-qs5nr]

Can't believe you do this for a living (or for a major part of your life) and still this so wrong. Subhanallah

[@bigballerbrandon1]

Salam, what does Dr. Shadee mean at the 4:49 mark by the word “aqwal”?

[@V0ayger]

According to my knowledge it means "quotes" or "sayings"

[@bigballerbrandon1]

@@V0aygerJazakallah khayr. What would aqwal mean in this context though?

[@sheikhjahidhossainjunayed4525]

@@bigballerbrandon1 opinion about Abu Talib

[@musti12312]

@@bigballerbrandon1 differing opinion (literally discussions on the issue)

[@suraiyamansoor9740]

Beliefs are stirring a lot of criticism and arguments amongst religions. Well; nobody can ever raise themselves into The Knowledge of The One and Only CREATOR OF THIS WORLD. BEST ZIP UP ONE MOUTH. SEAL ONE Thoughts and Let God handle this world of Religions which evidences man built RELIGIONS because of his beliefs and blamed GOD as the Constructor of Religions and beliefs.

[@JaleelBeig]

Disbelievers is different yet a subset from non believers. All disbelievers go to hell but not all non believers do.

[@Shadow4209]

Assalamu Alaykum. A simple answer would be if you disbelieve in Allah and the Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وسلم) then there’s no way you will be able to avoid hell. You will remain in hell forever for disbelieving in Allah. But if you never got the message of Islam then on the day of judgment, Allah will test you and decide whether you’re going to paradise or hell. والله أعلم

[@abu_muhammad]

💯

[@malihahassan1]

The main point is you have to receive the message. Allah knows best

[@Alandforman]

You guys profess to know that your Allah is merciful, but by what evidence do you show this? Where does your Allah show mercy in the Koran? Example(s)? On the other hand, Jehovah is merciful as His actions are related to in the Bible. While dead in sins and offenses, He died for us. That's mercy! We didn't deserve His atonement on the cross, yet He did it. That's mercy!

[@ti6091]

@@Alandforman read the Quran for yourself Instead of believing in human sacrifice

[@sinmipillot]

Hello, brothers and sisters, Automatically, we are all born sinners and deserve to go to hell. Our good deeds can not save us because good deeds can not guarantee us heaven. Jesus loves you and wants to have a relationship with you if you allow him. God gave Jesus to die for our sins in order for us not to go to hell anymore (Read John 3:16). Jesus is the guarantee and not your good deeds. Death could happen any day and anytime, and if you haven't given your life to Jesus, it might be too late. All you have to do is go to a quiet place and ask God to forgive you your sins and ask God to wash your sins away with the blood of Jesus. confess with your mouth that you accept Jesus as your Lord and Saviour. And tell Jesus to come into your life. After this prayer, get a bible and start reading from the book of John. My brothers and sisters, please give Jesus a chance as it might be too late. God bless you.

[@alenezi989a3]

This is very wrong, I didn't listen to the whole thing. No just saying there's a messenger from god and that's supposed to be sufficient? No it's not, what about Huja? Proof? Evidence? Kufer is rejection you have to understand something to reject it or accept it otherwise if just hearing about islam is sufficient for someone to go to hell then why did Allah send all these messengers and prophets? Why did he give them miracles? Why does the Quran even exists if just "hearing" the word islam without any explanation is sufficient? No its not sufficient, the Quran has many verses that clearly says that god doesn't punish people when they are ignorant, god doesn't punish people if they don't know that they are doing something wrong. Go read every single verse that talks about Kufar and you'll find that they have been given every evidence and proof of the truth of the message and they all believe in Allah but reject faith based on pride, self interset, desires...etc. you can't find a single verse that says that Kufar are just ignorant non believers, they are always rejecting faith when amble proof and evidence have been given.

[@nurjahanhaq6342]

How about the millions of disbelievers (let’s say 70%) who don’t get to see the evidence? Such as well articulated arguments (only few people in dawah can do) - so are they all going Jannah? That’s what you’re postulating. Just curious.

[@alenezi989a3]

@nurjahanhaq6342 they don't go to Jennah, not even muslims are guaranteed to go to Jenna . They will be judged based on their deeds . Based on the mizan (balance) sins vs good deeds. They will be treated the same way as ahlul fatra the people who lived between two Prophets. This is more inline with Allah infinte mercy and the many verses of the Quran.

[@alenezi989a3]

@nurjahanhaq6342 BTW this is not my postulation many Shaikhs and scholars believe so. They are not the majority and it's not popular opinion tbh. But truth doesn't depend on popularity or majority the Quran gives many evidences.

[@nurjahanhaq6342]

@@alenezi989a3 based on their deeds? What deeds? Any good they do, they don’t do it for Allah, so that doesn’t count as good deeds.

[@triesposto]

​@@nurjahanhaq6342 Shaykh Al-Albaani may Allaah have mercy upon him said: “If the message of Islam reached the people in a forged manner…altered…changed, especially as relates to its principles and creed, then, I am the first one to say that the message has not reached such people, because what is meant by the message having reached them, is the pure clear message; but if we presume that the message had reached them in a distorted altered manner, then the message did not reach such people, and so, the evidence of Allaah against them is not established.” Basically, this is not opinion that belongs only to him, many scholars have said the same thing, Imam Al Ghazali himself was of this opinion, and furthermore, considered that most of the Byzantines and Turks of his time would belong to the group that didn't "receive the message" Imam Al-Ghazali said: "These people knew the name ‘Muhammad,’* but nothing of his character and attributes. Instead, all they heard since childhood was that some arch-liar carrying the name ‘Muhammad’ claimed to be a prophet, just as our children heard that an arch-liar and deceiver called ‘al Muqaffa [164] falsely claimed that God sent him (as a prophet) and then challenged people to disprove his claim. This group, in my opinion, is like the first group. Even though they heard his name, they heard the opposite of what his true attributes were. And this does not provide enough incentive to compel them to investigate (his true status)" (Faysal al-Tafriqa Hayna al-Islam wa al-Zandaqa) So Inshallah, those who message didn't reach in a proper manner, such as people who were sincere but had questions that daee was unable to answer, and they weren't able to find answer to it, will Inshallah have their own test on Judgement day.

[@schwertderwahrheit-islam5200]

But it seems illogical. Then it will better not to make dawa to non Muslims, so they will be for sure in Paradiese ????

[@Lele-ob8pe]

Consider this: Would it be illogical to punish someone without knowing the true message, or that he knows distorted message of Islam (like ISIS?) Regarding your question: There is no good & bad i.e. morals outside of paradigm you're representing. So if you didn't hear the message of Islam, and you went living a completely liberal/atheistic life, you'd be bound to commit evil such as zina, ribba or other types of sins, which in today's society aren't illegal and sometimes are well-paid. There's also a chance you'd be completely good and avoid all evil according to our standards, but who is willing to take that chance? Are you, as a fellow, good human being able to let someone take that chance, or would you rather inform them in a right manner of what good and evil is, so he might avoid punishment? Rewind that further to the age of American slavery and Great Britain, and you'd be employing hundreds of black folk treating them like animals, believeing you are righteous because it's all made legal by human-made laws. Islam tells you: in order to be good and moral and avoid punishment in the afterlife, you are to do this and avoid that, and we got what is good and bad from God Himself rather than man-made laws and what's currently "trending". That's why Dawah is very important and encouraged, because the closer you get someone to God, the more likely he is to commit good and avoid evil. If however your dawah is bad (i.e. ISIS) and you distance that person from God by a hateful and illogical rhetoric, that person's circumstances and reasons will be considered by Allah and he will be put on an individual test

[@SafinaSociety]

You'd be sinful then

[@schwertderwahrheit-islam5200]

I mean without to be tested after death. The Hadith with testing is logical

[@muslimuddin3656]

Who said the Non Muslim, who don't got the message is going to paradise? If they are not going to hell, it doesn't mean automatically that they are going to paradise And sheikh got the thing wrong

[@schwertderwahrheit-islam5200]

@@muslimuddin3656 Yes, i am on your side. I said that the speaker is wrong in saying that the non Muslims who never heard about Islam will go to paradise without test. It would be unlogical and it would be better not to make dawa to them so they can enter paradise. But it is more logical to accept the Hadith wich is speaking about testing the non Muslims who never heard of Islam after death. There no contradiction between the quranic verse and the Hadith.

[@HiddenOne19]

Another Hadithist. Hello Shadee. 1.) Sural Al-Fatiha is the 1st Surah, contains 7 verses, and 29 words. You put this together and it is "1729", this number is a multiple of 19. 2.) Similarly, 1+7+2+9 = 19 again. 3.) Bismillah also has 19 arabic letters. When are you going to realize that Rashad Khalifa received a Hidden Revelation from GOD that self-authenticates the Quran? The Quranists are rising and there is not a thing you can do about it. It has already been ordained.

[@dadzrtrydah8952]

🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@Lele-ob8pe]

this is the logic of: Yemen rhymes with lemon, lemon is yellow. You know what else is yellow? That's right, lemon juice. Lemon juice rhymes with Chinese goose. Goose has five letters. You know what else is 5? That's right, the pentagon.

[@marcorolo4726]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. The quranite mind is so deranged

[@user-bn2nv5mx2g]

@@Lele-ob8pehahahahaha

[@_zaaphiel]

@@Lele-ob8pe it is like Christian logic lol