Do We Really Exist? Concept of "Anatta" In Buddhism | Buddhism In English

[@ATHUL-zc8xx]

I am a 15 year old boy who started changing myself because of you...Thank You.....

[@xiaoqingling1500]

Namo Amitabha 🙏

[@sandywolfe9587]

Well done young man❤

[@silunithilakarathne6684]

I'm 16 and me too

[@gethypnotherapy]

Your life will be so beautiful and powerful if you remain committed to this work... wow! I can only imagine who I might be if I started this work at your age. Keep going beautiful soul!!

[@ali-karimi1]

LOL

[@MyTableForThem]

Even the most complex teachings in Buddhism are taught in a very simple way , it's awesome. Namobuddaya

[@12345678932123]

Thank you for wonderfully explaining 💖

[@CharityDeA]

I thank your parents Bhante, for giving their precious son to the sasana to deliver Buddha's deep dhamma to the masses who are ready to understand it. 🙏🙏🙏

[@adeeshaherath5396]

True....❤

[@Upāsaka_11]

Think of it this way: You bought a car 20 years ago. Over the years, you replaced every single part on the car until none of the original parts are present. You still have a car. It might even look the same. However, the truth is, you now have a completely different car. Our bodies go through this process naturally. You are, quite literally, a different person than you were 20 years ago (if you're at least that old). There is no permanent self.

[@John3.36]

Why is it necessary to claim that there is no permanent self if there is indeed no permanent self?

[@hotclipsz]

Its right but that's have more deeper meaning

[@surangasampathkaushalya2845]

Actually you are changing our minds from negative to positive and you made us to feel how to understand the reality of this birth and the stile of this life. Actually your are a real son of our Lord Buddha. Nano Buddhaya.

[@pronunciationway8502]

Now today is the 4th day I'm watchin this video 4th time and I don't know but every time I'm able to understand it 1 step more deeper... I stopped here while watching to express my feelings towards this deep teaching like ocean❤ Less words but deep like ocean❤ 🙏Namho Budhaya🙏

[@softlikesilk]

There is one sentence that encompasses this video in one. "There is no permanent unchanging self." All the answers to this question are right there. And thank you for clearing up something that is always lost in translation in western thoughts of buddhism.

[@ChillAndPeaceful]

There's no self Because all organisms are being reborn because of the mind desire that create manifestation to the universe We are in simulation of "self" There's no "me""I""mine""I'm" Only hormones, 6 senses, chemical reactions to the brain, and the mind nature is greedy for pleasant pleasure to the 6 senses that is why people reproducing to suffer more

[@Study.then.dialog]

​​@@Sifat-y9t The manifested universe is an infinite succession of interdependent phenomena which form a whole without beginning nor end, this is in a perpetual movement of transformations and mutations. What we define as “I” or “me” is a being individuated during its experience, but the Buddha goes further in the teaching on the fact of individuality to explain the traps of the ego.

[@Rockman-qo7zy]

​​@@Sifat-y9t there is something....there can't be nothing at all. Yes , there is something but that something is very deep hard to see and hard to understand, peaceful and sublime, unattainable by mere reasoning, subtle, to be experienced by the wise. But this generation delights in attachment, takes delight in attachment, rejoices in attachment. It is hard for such a generation to see this truth, namely, specific conditionality, dependent origination. And it is hard to see this truth, namely, the stilling of all formations, the relinquishing of all acquisitions, the destruction of craving, dispassion, cessation, Nibbāna.

[@sunkintree]

@@Sifat-y9t It's an illusion. A chair is only a chair because a very specific assembly of atoms organize themselves in a certain way. In reality, there is no chair, it's just something the mind makes up because it finds it useful to point to things and call it names. Likewise, what we call the 'self' is nothing more than a specific assembly of memories, sensations, mindstates.

[@shylajaka-ji3ux]

❤❤❤

[@alexandrecordeiro4957]

the teachings of buddha are such a great help to one's understanding of how to live a fulfilled and happy life, if people learn at a young age to meditate and buddhism it would benefit them and the world so much. thank you.

[@amitmalakar92]

Buddha is very smart ❤❤. Namo Buddhaya

[@tanyakatoch18]

This question comes to my mind whenever I wake up at 4:00 am

[@Pallabexpeditioninsight]

How can I express that how much i admire this heavenly priest. I wanna meet him once in my life. Nama Buddhay 🙏

[@pamodarajapaksha694]

🙏නමෝ බුද්ධාය!☸️ ✨අප හට මහත් අනුකම්පාවෙන් අර්ථයෙන් ධර්මයෙන් අනුශාසනා කරන පිංවත් ස්වාමීන් වහන්සේට මගේ නමස්කාරය වේවා..!🙏☸️🍃🪔 🙏සාදු.. සාදු.. සාදු..🙏 ✨පිංවත් ස්වාමීන් වහන්සේට මේ භවයේදීම උතුම් චතුරාර්ය සත්‍ය ධර්මය පරිපුර්ණ වශයෙන්ම අවබෝධ කර ගැනීමට මේ ධර්ම දානමය කුසලය හේතු වාසනා වේවා..!🙏☸️🍃🪔 🙏සාදු.. සාදු.. සාදු..🙏 🙏තෙරුවන් සරණයි පිංවත් ස්වාමීන් වහන්ස..!☸️

[@klinton2968]

I'm Klinton...I will improve myself from Today...I respect myself... From Today I protect myself... thank you so much....❤❤❤

[@danielkoher1944]

0:21 I have jostled this question around within my mind since childhood.

[@pronunciationway8502]

The way your voice is soothing & calming to our ears.. Your surrounding Is mesmerizing to our eyes In the same way your knowelege is nurturing our soul❤ Thankyou soo much Namho Buddhaya🙏

[@sithuminikapugamage6447]

Namo Buddhaya! May you triple gem bless you 🙏🙏

[@sheld0n]

Great work generally on the channel. First time i take issue with the answer. The language-based "I" does not exist, it's just a series of firmly-held thoughts. Our bodies do exist but are not distinct from our surroundings, like a wave is not distinct from its ocean. The distinction is created by our thoughts.

[@AntonioTorcasioo]

"A wave is not distinct from its ocean," what an amazing way to put it, I will write it down so I don't forget! Thank you 🙏🏻:)

[@adeeshaherath5396]

True

[@nenastyaaanastasia]

Do thoughts exist?

[@sue9552]

Beautiful Dhamma Banthe. The moment you realized this, finally your peace finds you easily by letting all kind of attachments go naturally even without feel any pain or suffering in one's imaginary self. Thank you for sharing the truth of Dhamma Banthe . Namo Buddhaya 🌸🙏🌸🙏🌸🙏🌸

[@dec66.18]

Very informative on Buddhism.Not self , rather than No self.

[@a.b1266]

A complicated subject for a short video, but very well done.

[@jaymenezes180]

Brilliant explanation of non self!! Thank you Bante. Namo Buddhaya ,🙏

[@rs9807]

Excellent explanation of annatta. Dispels a lot of false notions about what the Buddha actually taught! Also removes the needless conflict with schools like Vedanta. Thank you!

[@panaduresarananda6455]

I appreciate very much your efforts Sir,to spread the teachings of BUDDHA to others , who believe in an almighty GOD . Buddhism doesn't reject GODS. Gods too are Living Beings who are subject to Rebirth,because they havn't realized the true nature of Existence and its Cessation .

[@musicfuhrer]

I was schooled as a Christian and still appreciate being taught the teachings of Jesus Christ. However, when I was about 12 years of age I suddenly felt an affinty with the Buddha. Despite being born in a rich nation, and having a free education, and no hunger or war in my life. Even at 12 years of age, I could see that all attachment was eventually going to lead to pain. People you love either die or leave you. So, for decades I just lived in the moment as much as possible. Now in my fifties I found I am attached to somebody. I care so much for this person, but I am also depressed because I am attached and I know they will die, or I will die, or they will leave me. I think in the modern world, we have all forgotten how important wider relationships are, as we have been sold a lie about pairing off. In fact, we should be living in communes, families and tribes and sharing love and attachment so that the grief of loss is never so horrific.

[@SarahBlaylock-u8g]

Thank you We can be the best being that we can be!!! ❤❤😊😊

[@shreyasawant6355]

Namo Buddhay May Buddha's supreme teachings lead you to Nirvana

[@matildaweerarathna8718]

Sadu sadu sadu 🙏🙏🙏 Namo Buddhaya 🙏🙏🙏🪷🪷🪷🙏🙏🙏 Namo Dhammaya 🙏🙏🙏🪷🪷🪷🙏🙏🙏 Namo Sanghaaya 🙏🙏🙏🪷🪷🪷🙏🙏🙏

[@SudipBhattacharyya]

So beautifully explained. Pranam Vante 🙏

[@milanbasnet8783]

Namo buddhaya to our supreme teacher BUDDHA and this is an era for following him.

[@NatsukiTakama]

*THE 👳🏾👳👳🏾 ARE DOING FAKE PROPAGANDA IN JAPAN AS WELL AS SOUTH KOREA THAT* - BUDDHA WAS A MZLEM - BUDDHA WAS ALSO A PROPHET BECAUSE BUDDHA WAS ENLIGHTENED UNDER A FIG TREE AND A FIG TREE IS MENTIONED IN K☢️RAN (BLA BLA BLA) *PLEASE REPLY TO MY COMMENT AND TELL ME WHAT ARE THE ALL POSSIBLE ARGUMENTS THAT BUDDHISTS CAN GIVE TO 👳 IN RETURN THAT WILL COMPREHENSIVELY DISMISS THE VALIDITY OF THE CLAIM THAT BUDDHA WAS THE PR0PHET OF OLA* *THIS IS A HUMBLE REQUEST, BECAUSE SOME OF MY BUDDHIST FRIENDS WHO ARE OFTEN TEASED BY MZLMS BY THEIR PREACHING HAVE ASKED ME THIS QUESTION. YOUR LOGICAL AND INTELLIGENT ASWERS WILL HELP THEM REFUTE THE 👳 ZOMBIES AND KEEP BUDDHISTS FROM FALLING INTO THE DECEPTION AND CONVERSION TRAP OF 🕌*

[@Ed-quadF]

Yes I learned something with this video. Thank you.

[@crimped357]

once again a wonderful lesson. thank you! Namo Buddhaya!

[@sarasitv687]

Great explanation.

[@sammysliver]

Thank you for teaching, Namo Buddhaya

[@YasmminKalpesi]

Supreme Buddha the Great. Namo Buddhaya. Thank you. 🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤

[@danielkoher1944]

I believe the majority of us have tormented ourselves with this question our entire lives. Along with what’s our true meaning.

[@SupriyaChatse-mb3fz]

✨Namo buddhay 🤍😌

[@Ruksh885]

Sadu sadu sadu anumodami

[@swamivedantanandapuri1322]

Sastanga pranaam🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@sujathagada7532]

Thank you so much Sadhu 🙏NAMO BUDDHAYA💖

[@padminipradhan3409]

Namma Buddhaya 🙏❣️

[@redstar5]

💯❤ Without having Tags ...like I am Muslim...I am Buddhist...I am Hindu...so on.. and killing each other without knowing who we are...How sad...Buddhas teaching is for every human being who is not afraid to ask the question...like.. who am I ?....Buddhas teachings are Not for people who think we have religious Tags since the day we were born and we have to follow ..without asking any questions about it...if not we will go to hell.

[@sindhuudayakumar7979]

❤❤❤🎉🙏🏻🙏🏻👍🏻😍🥰Loka Samasta Sukhino Bhavantu Namo Buddhaya ❤❤❤🎉

[@Sourishb-h9x]

Namo Buddhaya 🌸🌻🏵️💮🌷🌺🥀🌹💐🌼

[@basavarajkaujalgi3947]

🙏🏻😊😇||नमो बुद्धाय||😇😊🙏🏻

[@M.Ojha9435]

Thank you❤❤❤❤ Namo Buddhaya❤❤❤❤❤

[@Its1417Girl]

I just start assuming your words SIR.. Sometimes🥺 I wish that the day one will come when I can take a visit at your monestry.. Whenever I feel down I just watching your videos 🥺

[@matarasriyani9256]

Namobuddhaya .Theruwan saranai .🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@Bijou_248]

Wow 😍😍🥰 This is the BEST explanation I have ever heard about the little personality self attached to ego. New intake. new way to see it. Such golden words from you feel so good in my soul. Thank you so much! 🙏❤🎉✨🌈🦜🪷💗🙏 . . . Namo Buddhaya . . . 🙏❤🎉✨🌈🦜🪷💗🙏

[@naveenraj5418]

Namo Buddha ❤

[@AravindPolu]

Om Namo buddhaya❤

[@namelessmonster55]

Namo buddhay 🙏🏻

[@sarithabalaji8572]

Thank you🙏🌹 sir, be blessed by the divine🙌

[@imashanimasha7728]

Namo Buddhaya !🙏🙏🙏💐

[@stephaniebate6814]

I certainly did learn something new , thank you

[@LenovoA-gy7cs]

Yes, Sometimes life is so hard n Painful..wit somepeople who make life so unhappy Wish this too shall Pass like the Clouds.. Namobudaya 🙏🙏🙏

[@purnamanmotivation]

I have learned to keep smiling everyte 🙏💖thank you sir

[@johnmarkjimenez8658]

Very nice.... Thats it's life is challenges.... Emotional spiritual and GOD WORDS..... COMBINATION WE MUST LEARN MORE..... GOD BLESS

[@annescholten9313]

Indeed an interesting question.❤

[@nimnaliyanaarachchi8151]

Namo buddhaya❤

[@ushan559]

Namo Buddhaya 🙏🙏

[@Elijah_Al-Naysaburi]

Thank you very much شكرا جزيلا لك 💕😘🥰⚘️✌️✨️

[@MVrik001]

Bhudha is guiding us to live peacefully as he was expecting us to be.❤😊Nammo budaya

[@rosemariecangas]

Thank u for bringing us into enlightenment sir

[@rakeshkumarpradhan3767]

All is request please like this video , because this is life changing video ❤❤❤❤

[@rupsonarabegam1830]

Suddenly, this question came to my mind that, do I exist? Without watching your video, it really puzzle my brain, I shut down for half an hour and came across your video.

[@rashmi6127]

Namo Buddhaya 🙏

[@indrapalasilwa9168]

Great teaching

[@bobinapeter5041]

Thanks Brother🙏

[@mkdes40]

Revd.Sir, Thank you very much for explaining this important concept.

[@ATHUL-zc8xx]

Like guided mindful meditation

[@samanthisena1]

That was totally awesome Bhante 🙏

[@krisiam]

Ita a concept of Ego. Thank you its fantastic, how clear and simple, very deep knowledge

[@garyholman2947]

Very understandable explanation of a complex concept ... Thank You!

[@lindalin6484]

Thank yoi Bhante🙏

[@lorellamazzotta3306]

Thank you 🙏

[@ThoughtsInspired.]

Namo Buddhay ❤#ThoughtsInspired

[@WhyDoWeExist-k9q]

Namoh Buddhaye 🙏🏽😇💓

[@parkermeng]

One of the best explanation I have ever hear. Thank you 🙏

[@84zero00]

Thank you for your teaching. 🙏🙏🙏

[@128cparambratadas7]

love ur videos thanks it is helping me a lot but make another video on controlling anger issues

[@lovadesi]

He has already done many on this anger issue

[@johndoe1.196]

I always had a problem with the "no self" concept and still do. I'm not Buddhist though. Regardless, there's a lot of truth and wisdom in Buddhism (I prefer "zen") one can benefit from. Thanks for the explanation. 🙏

[@andrewwater5836]

Namo Buddhaya 👍

[@ridhamatri9447]

Thanks for explaining sir. Beautiful explanation 👍

[@aravindadharsh]

Namo Budhaaya.... 🙏🙏🙏

[@anadossantos1429]

Listen to you ❤ I start to feel better right way ❤ Makes me relax ❤instantly

[@shineisle2263]

Namobuddhaya🙏 🪔🪔🪔🪔🪔🪔🪔🪔🪔🪔

[@amitmishra-dg4lw]

Namo budhaya🙏

[@lindasapiecha2515]

Do unto others as you would have them do unto you ❤

[@Study.then.dialog]

On this topic we have to consider the fact of interdependence of all things, all phenomenas, all the creations in the serveral worlds , in the Universe which have no begining and no end. When we meditate on it, we can say notably that if all is interdépendant, nothing can exists by itself, as a tree can't exist without the elements of earth, sky and water and these elements can't exist without other elements and this process has no end. The fact of no self is mainly supporting by the realisation of the interdependence into the mystery of the creation which can't be described with a beginning and a end and where all things move in transitional and cyclical ways. The science which is at the origine of this process can't be exposed with accuracy nor in its entirety, so we are a lot of ignorant about "ourselves" . That's why Bouddha did'nt speek about one self nor about God, what or who is God. But he didn't deny nor affirm something about, just teached on how to get the enlightenment to be aware on what can't be said and described. In islam the idea of God is named but it is also said that Allah is indescribable and without beginning or end, that is why muslims people also must be humble regarding to the immeasurable and the science which surpasses all the intellectual concepts of human beings. That is really interesting to recall and meditate. But at a moment we have to let down the mental activity, the analysis. Be careful because when you let go of the intellect, mental activities, to stand is peace and silent, you open the door to a kind of land which is called infinity.

[@adeeshaherath5396]

True 🌻. There's no teue self as we thinking here we hv. We're all pure conscious or Shunyatha

[@elizabethalex5003]

Yes.. I have.. I used to ask this question myself during my school time.. Sometimes looking into the mirror this thought comes to me...am i real!! Its complecated

[@XinoSakura]

Namo Buddhay ☸️

[@hamshihamsu5461]

God bless you forever ♾️❣️

[@dammikaangela2067]

තෙරුවන් සරණයි !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@senudajayarathna699]

Namo Buddhaya

[@NatsukiTakama]

😰 PLEASE 😰 PLEASE SAVE JAPAN FROM 👳☪️🕌

[@SithuminiChathurangi]

Everything change everytime

[@Elijah_Al-Naysaburi]

Iridescent black pearl Everyone loves her, except the boy Because it is talismanic, with longing✨️✌️⚘️🥰😘💕

[@PritySakhare]

Namo buddhay. Sadhu sadhu sadhu 🙏🙏🙏

[@KaleelKaleel-s6h]

I have been watching your videos Really very good. Worth knowledgeable thanks

[@ManohariMalki]

Very smart....❤ namo buddhaya ❤

[@sonali_0310]

Namo budhhaya 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@mindgame1904]

expose the true self kindly❤