DOCTOR WHO LIVE REVIEW: MINDWARP | A Cursed chaotic production or Brian BLESSED?

[@noblerees1]

So pleased you enjoyed the chat. I myself loved the discussion. We certainly covered the different angles.

[@diviningdragon]

Blessings, Brendan! This was a terrific stream and VERY well executed. You covered all the bases of this troubled chapter in Doctor Who history. I'm sorry I was unable to participate in the live chat, but at least I could enjoy the replay here. (And yes, I'm a fan of Brian Blessed.) Thank you for sharing!

[@noblerees1]

Thank you. For what it’s worth I thoroughly enjoyed this stream discussion - wide ranging and fun

[@iluv2b]

Whilst appreciating the reservations discussed about this production, and being grateful for the wealth of information provided, I invariably find Mindwarp to be highly satisfying, the behind-the-scenes consternation in no way detracting from that, perhaps even contributing. Where Colin Baker remaining in the role was concerned, Michael Grade inevitably had the final word; nonetheless, I've always been greatly cheered that Trial of a Timelord undoubtedly represented the production team flying in the face of an establishment so mean spirited. Hugely contributing to the enjoyment of this story was a typically unselfconscious turn by Brian Blessed as Yrcanos; a superbly-crafted alien in the form of Nabil Shaban's Sil (to which Christopher Ryan's understated Lord Kiv provided a satisfying contrast); possibly the most unsettlingly pragmatic portrayal of a 'mad scientist' being showcased by Patrick Ryecarts's Crozier; an atypical, yet compelling, performance from the two leads; together with a consummately antagonistic turn from a scene-stealing Michael Jayston's Valeyard. The altered personality aspects of Mindwarp remain as discomfiting a watch as ever, serving to highlight the impressively unusual nature of this entry and, whilst not in any way disputing the plot inconsistencies mentioned, I never judged them to be jarring enough to undermine the story. Also, although disliked by some because of the interruption they present, I have always found the courtroom scenes in 'Trial' to be a desirable complement to the narrative, particularly for this tale, as they provide hope that the ending may not be as unutterably bleak as first it appears. For me, this offering has always come across as brave, unapologetic Doctor Who, with Colin Baker's era (and the show) being all the better for it. Many thanks, Brendan, Rachael and Jeremy. Your own typically incisive thoughts made for a great discussion! All the best for now. Paul

[@michaelwebster8666]

Thank you Brendan, Rachael & Jeremy. When I saw Mindwarp on original broadcast it made an impression on me. The music score really added to the atmosphere of the story. Despite the bleak ending Iwould have prefered it was left as originally intended. It was a total kop out to have Peri married off to Yrcarnos. The trial scenes can get in the way, however I enjoyed this seasom when first shown in 86 and still do. Grade to quote Del Boy, was a 24 carat plonker! 👍

[@noblerees1]

I had notes to give a shout out to Richard Hartley who did the original music soundtrack and I failed to do it so let me fully agree with your compliment to the music

[@PaulRichards-vz4pl]

Excellent show. I always liked Sil, he’s a lot of fun. I’ve fond memories of Trial. I thought Michael Jayston was wonderfully menacing as the Valeyard. Mindwarp is my favourite of the 4 segments. That scene where the Tardis is taken out of time just as Peri is about to die is so dramatic. I agree with you that Derek Jacobi was superb playing the Master. His transformation from sweet old professor to nasty bitter villain was a stunning piece of acting. I’d have had him play the Master for a couple of seasons if it were up to me. I’d never bring the Valeyard back because Michael Jayston is the character and modern writing would probably spoil it.

[@noblerees1]

I agree with every word

[@PaulRichards-vz4pl]

@@noblerees1 Thank you! 😀