What If Queen Scarlet's Sister Survived? (Wings Of Fire)

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

I really hope you guys enjoy this one! It was a lot of fun to put together, and I just keep loving the SkyWings more every day :) Question of the day: Do you get snow where you're from? My answer: We usually get snow at least a few times each year, but there have been some recent years we haven't gotten much or any at all :( Just depends how the weather wants to treat us lol

[@Shadow-in-space]

We normaly get snow, just not yet

[@Vaporeon_Bookworm]

I got snow yesterday!

[@tabbystar2011]

No. Only on tall mountains, and only in winter

[@Concordthe_dragon]

Nope, ive never seen irl snow before lol

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

@@Vaporeon_Bookworm Yay!! :D

[@mothwingthemedicinecat]

You did my idea? Im happy, cant watch it right now sadly due to work but I’ll definitely be coming back to listen later 😊

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

I did! :D You're even credited -- and I hope you enjoy this story!

[@tabbystar2011]

I'd like to see this! Scarlets reign was filled with A LOT of blood, even at her marriage festival First edit: I didn't even think of that! Now that I think about it, there are a lot of untracked royalty around. Arctic's siblings, Corals army of children and Anemone's other cousins, Moorhen's sibs, and probably many more. I'd love to hear some stories about them, especially about Arctic's forgotten siblings.

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

There really are!

[@35a61aj]

@@tabbystar2011 at the same time alot probably didn't end up living very interesting lives

[@Cattystarla]

Idea- What if Sunny hatched looking like a NightWing instead of a SandWing

[@Snekelord12]

Oooo I like this one

[@Cattystarla]

@ Thanks

[@bano7861]

This is so amazing! I really feel bad for Amethyst and I think Phyrrian history would've been much better if she was the favorite instead of Scarlet. I think Ibex seems really cute and I like her name.

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

:DD Thank you!!

[@qibli-and-roses]

WOAH i love this what if!! let’s gooo

[@ChosenOfHestia]

OMG yessssss please do this!! I always thought she should have!

[@r3duc3r]

just saying thanks so much for still making WoF vids, i used to read this around 5 years ago and only YOUR news on new WoF content brought me back... tv show soon hopefully!

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

Oh my goodness, that truly made me smile! :D I'm so glad my content brought you back into WoF 💜You're welcome in this fandom anytime!

[@Liv-v8d]

Ok. I have an idea. What if Queen Sequoia gave up her throne to Wasp and Monarch was the one who asked for further evidence that Clearsight actually wanted this? Also this was a really good and well written video.

[@GlaceonDragon999]

This is already a what if made by Cyprus but if you requesting moon to make a version that’s fine too

[@Liv-v8d]

@ I don’t watch Cyprus so I didn’t know. I’m sorry.

[@GlaceonDragon999]

@@Liv-v8d it’s fine

[@thehyperscientist1961]

Once again, another beautiful story which never was, but I truly hope is. I have a feeling there may be a good chance that, considering Scarlet's behaviour, Amethyst was truly forgotten, but in other words, alive and safe. All that needs to be done, is for someone to remember her P.S. How I SO wish we had more Winglets rn! 😭

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

Thank you so so much!!

[@thehyperscientist1961]

@@Dogloverlikesdoge 😄

[@TheForbiddenTreasury]

You know its a good day when dogloverlikesdoge post a what if

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

That just made my day, thank you so much 💜

[@BananaDragonNerd]

GASP WHY HAVE I NEVER THOUGHT ABOUT THIS *goes to reread the guide*

[@WingsofFirefan-zn7hu]

Also I always thought she had survived. I just can’t really imagine her dead

[@xXDarkWarriorxX-my2ht]

Began watching, and saw the like number go from 1 to 6

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

:O Cool!

[@_Blackwolf38]

Oooh this is a creative one!

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

:D

[@Skullwolf99]

Wow! This what if is so good! It's nice to hear what could have happened!

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

Thank you so so much!

[@WingsofFirefan-zn7hu]

Love the art

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

Me too! :)

[@Someperson12532]

You NEED to make a part 2!

[@Fireycalamity]

I know I'm a little late, but my suggestion is 'what if clay's siblings had all been raised under the mountain'. Maybe I'll be a bit faster to the nest upload.

[@pluagespeltwrong]

this is an awesome video! also what if queen scarlet never became queen?

[@Ashleyhasp]

This is so well written and read even the art is amazing

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

TYSM, you are so kind!! I appreciate that so much

[@Rosemarythehivewingrainwing]

Two suggestions: What if Orca never an animus? What if the dragonets of destiny were perfect. (Clay was the monster kestrel wanted him to be, Tsunami is probably the same, but possibly "brainwashed" to not hate the talons of peace and the guardians, Sunny is possibly replaced with a "non-defect" dragonet, glory is...probably replaced, and Starflight is basically Fierceteeth in behaviour, and is the leader. Or is Fierceteeth, I dunno, after all, you might not even see this lol

[@aprilhiggs3956]

I love your vids keep up the good work! Can you do IceWing history?

[@TheDarkWolf515]

Hey! Id like to let you know something I discovered! So you know how the Desert tiara went missing? The sandwing missing treasure? Well if you look at Queen Glaciers crown they look similar! I think blaze gave it to Glacier for a deal for some of the propertie!

[@Kevin66062]

Can you do if chameleon and kestrel left with there egg and lived as a family (seeing his family see that he is a rain wing after years will be so funny)

[@Blazeissosilly88654]

Hi I’ve been wondering for a while now what if Clay had killed Peril? I would love to see how you could make that story btw I love when people make what ifs for wings of fire those are my favourite keep working hard your doing amazing

[@mothwingthemedicinecat]

Came back and watched it, its great! I feel sorry for Amethyst, being isolated from all other dragons but one, that cant be good for her, she might have trouble adjusting at first to life in the palace with the other SkyWings, but she can do it. She would be a great Grandma for Sky. I think there is more you could do with the story if you want (i am not just saying this because i suggested it, i promise i like the idea of it) Ibex and her reuiniting again in their old age would be great. (how old is she at the end?)

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

I'd love to write something like that! And as for how old she is, it's a little hard to tell due to us not knowing how much older Scarlet was than her. Amethyst was 3 when she got sent away, and we don't know how long it was until Scarlet took the throne. She's younger than 30 though, since she's Scarlet's littlest sister. Maybe she's around 25 by the end?

[@kristinabegail]

“Queen Firestorm of the Skywings.” My honest reaction: “Oh guess Firestar got promoted from Thunderclan.” :)

[@Shadow-in-space]

Hi Moon!

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

Hi!

[@gladionmymoon]

Wow, that's an epic story!

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

:DD

[@Wonders_horse-life]

I had an Idea you do not have to do it but I thought it would be super duper cool what if Qibli still lived with his family

[@35a61aj]

@@Wonders_horse-life I remember learning about how courage the cowardly dog was based off a kid who was physically abused and learned to laugh at the pain as a sort of coping mechanism (thus why he laughs after getting hurts) perhaps it could be something similar to that

[@35a61aj]

Waves of the starless sea

[@WofNerd]

Can you do one on What if the IceWings took over the NightWings? (Aka Vigilance sold in the war and so Queen Diamond subjugated the NightWings somehow)

[@35a61aj]

@@WofNerd it's things like this that are why I always come back to these comments

[@tylerfriends9490]

What ifs are my fav please do more!!!!!!!

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

So glad you enjoy them!! More to come :) I love telling these stories

[@Minoka_kit]

the definition of majestic

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

TYYYYY

[@ariannaeurek1459]

Have you thought of a What if Ruby was evil or if Scarlet was nice? Another idea is if you make a what if about what if Anemone killed Queen coral in book 9 and didn't run in to Turtle.

[@AutumnShade_13]

What if dark stalker and clear sight switch places?

[@35a61aj]

I like the way you think sir

[@ChrisParker-z8g]

idea what if prince arctic was in the diamond trial instead of foeslayer, what if sunny found out she is half icewing, what if dune never died, what if mastermind died instead of starflight's mother

[@Syd_LovesToDraw]

I meant to say this earlier when I first watched this video buttttt. . . Tui should hire you to write some Winglets 👀

[@Snekelord12]

IDEA: What if starlights sister was born the prophecy Nightwing dragonet?

[@harrykim3932]

What if you did a video that described what would happen if the Skywing egg didn’t crack and the dragonet survived?

[@vfaljayjay9174]

I love your videos and I want to watch more but I’m only on book 8 and don’t want to be spoiled :(

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

Once you finish book 8, check back here! :D You'll be good to go after that

[@Mewten1237_moon]

Anyone gonna talk abt the bird chirpping?

[@kayko196]

What if glory didn’t kill crocodile and took webs, and the dragonets to queen ruby

[@Wings_of_fire22]

Ello could you do *what If turtle died by his sister * when they were fighting

[@Liv-v8d]

Oh my god that would be so cool!

[@35a61aj]

@@Wings_of_fire22 *Versus riff*

[@MultiverseSaga2025]

Infinite possibilities and answer the questions.♾✨ WHAT IF…?🕰🌌

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

:DD

[@OrcaAnimus2292]

I like the names that you choose.

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

Thanks so much!

[@Sparkproductions11]

Can you please do a what if winter does what he promised icicle and tried to kill Queen Glory, big fan Edit:great story and video

[@35a61aj]

@@Sparkproductions11 yes

[@anormalfish-rp9mq]

What if scarlet’s sister is Beryl?

[@Anti.BluBird]

But nobody knew who Beryl was, which wouldn't be possible if she was Scarlet's sister. (Unless Scarlet managed to get rid of everyone who knew her.)

[@Anti.BluBird]

But nobody knew who Beryl was, which would not be possible if she was Scarlet's sister. Plus, Scarlet seemed pretty scared of her.

[@anormalfish-rp9mq]

@@Anti.BluBird Scarlet’s sister was sent away at the age of three, and it was only mentioned that Vermillion didn’t know who Beryl is. I don’t think the guide book said anything about asking other older skywings about her.

[@anormalfish-rp9mq]

@@Anti.BluBird the guide book never mentions Scarlet being scared of Beryl, only that she wanted to kill her. Vermillion said that Scarlet must have hated Beryl to want her dead, but Scarlet may just wanted to kill her to get rid of any chance of being challenged for the throne.

[@35a61aj]

@@anormalfish-rp9mq the more I think about it the more Beryl sounds like a boys name so it possibly be a brother which would still allow the *no one knows who they are* in my opinion and the reason scarlet wanted them dead could be because they were planning an insurrection

[@ShadowClanFan]

What if scarlets sister came back and pretended to be Ruby or Tourmaline?

[@croweja1969]

Hi!! GOSH GIVE THIS VIDEO MORE THAN 7 LIKES!

[@tiffanysuarez5639]

Wait- SCARLET HAS A SISTER? HELP I HAVENT READ THE GUIDEBOOK BUT SCREW IT IM WATCHING THIS

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

She had three of them, but unfortunately killed them all :( Along her with all her daughters other than Ruby

[@PatrickGaul-f8e]

I have and I didn't know!

[@sonyagaonkar8072]

Hi Hi Hi pls make video on what if sunny was more night wing

[@beastmaster0934]

TIL Scarlet had a sister.

[@Petalpool]

Ngl, I like this one

[@noniksatu9999]

Hi can u try makeing an oc from cometes(i cant spell)

[@Jellyfish-the-seawing]

1:35 “birthday”, video ruined/J

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

I put that because I say hatching day soon after and didn't want it to sound repetitive :)

[@GlaceonDragon999]

Amythist is dead because she was sent to the furthest outpost and the nightwings burned down all the dragons at the furthest outpost in book 4. If she survived until then she died along with the crowd

[@Gojiboi_productions]

I like this theory a whole lot more tbh

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

That's why this is an alternate universe :)

[@GlaceonDragon999]

@@Dogloverlikesdoge fair enough. Also thank you for responding to my comment!

[@memecat9830]

Unless she left the sky kingdom

[@GlaceonDragon999]

@@memecat9830 I guess

[@Tikdudeplays]

Whos the main character in arc 4? Book 16

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

We don't know just yet, but it's being teased as potentially Umber

[@Tikdudeplays]

@ thank ypu for the information!

[@bl00dy-r4u]

Me mad at Netflix...THE NEWS I HEARD( btw I did NOT know Scarlet had a sister, I did read the guidebook tho...am I trippin?)

[@Zingo-x4t]

I’m pretty Shure they would have killed her on sight if she looked weird..

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

In canon she was only sent away to the outpost

[@Zingo-x4t]

@@Dogloverlikesdoge maybe I was thinking of firescales

[@Someperson12532]

Its great.... buut I'd had loved it even more if Amethyst was aroace. We have too few aroace characters in WoF! No offense meant though - it's still really great, and I LOVE Amethyst's design!

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

Nothing in the story explicitly says anything about it, so you can believe what you'd like! :)

[@FaydeOut435]

She had a sister?

[@Dogloverlikesdoge]

Three, though all were killed by her :(

[@plane28]

Oof 1 hour late