Doha Debates - Political Islam 4/5

[@Muaththin]

Shadi and Sarah win the debate for sure! Awesome panel against the motion

[@aatayyab]

The only magic word this "traitor" Maajid Nawaz has to offer to the debate is "politicizing". Well, how stupid is that Political Islam and "politicizing" are completely two different things. I have serious doubts about this guy taking too much anti-depressants and distanced himself from even logically and reasonably discuss or differentiate things.

[@Signalement]

To understand her one requires intelligence, a sense of rationalism and ligoc and last but not least - a human heart.

[@MrCostiZz]

Sarah Joseph Let me be as clear as possible so can understand ....You can promote whatever politics you like as long as you don't challenge Democracy it self, human rights .....Simple!! Now you tell us if Political Islam is compatible with Democracy and human rights.

[@deedee130675]

the only one that knows Islam here is Sarah Joseph...the rest is only pupets!

[@izaccy]

Okay, One effin question I would have asked Sarah Joseph. Do you and your partner who frankly do not all agree with the Islamic Brotherhood, willing to take the risk regardless if you do not agree with them, for a political Islamic movement that legitimately may not approve of a Christian woman as an elected leader. are you willing to take that risk to allow them this motion.

[@agnieszkaniemira]

2:12 - making room in democracy for non-democratic practices is quite problematic.

[@murderedboy]

This imam is seriously... How did he get to be an imam???

[@Haterofkuffar2]

A bunch of appostates who know nothing about Islam and rejected verses, hadiths and the ijma(consensus of the Moslims) within their conversations. Thats why RasulAllah(sallallahu aleyhi wa sallam) said:"Speak good(the truth/with knowledge) or keep quit."

[@agnieszkaniemira]

I don't think that Sarah Joseph understands what Maajid Nawaz is talking about.

[@DeepHauz]

Sarah Joseph is not terribly bright.

[@myyou1]

Yahya Pallavicini? 'Jewish-Muslim Initiatives in Italy' by Imam Yahya Pallavicini, President, Italian Islamic Religious Community

[@shwenu]

Don't blame Islamic teaching.We have to know true Islamic teaching.Our religion is overshadowed by wrong Islamic teaching which is originated from India not from our dearest prophet.

[@trebronrehts]

Time for a non-sensitive comment: Miss Sarah Joseph has been fortunate enough, not having been wipped through the streets or stonedto death. Obviously! How can she speak so carelessly, almost infantile about Iran. She surely must be brainwashed. I just don't get this passion.Maybe she is pretending being someone she is not! Very disturbing.

[@greeko25]

as for nuclear weapons , im really opposed to israel having them but i wouldnt want iran having them either . nowone knows who is gonna be running the partiucular country from now and i dont trust their current administtration as being serious and sober either . pakistan has nuclear w. and that country almost collapsed a moonth ago

[@nazifdaniel]

only sarah can defend islam fuh what a debate without participant real muslim

[@CloseTheseEyes]

@az11z9 The lady makes no sense either.

[@mark_8780]

Woman has no idea of ground realities. LoL

[@Steve-eh4db]

Wow this woman Sarah Joseph was so far off the deep end..... Today, Iran and/or their proxies is in Iraq , Yemen , Syria , Lebanon , Libya & will arrive in a country near you.

[@trebronrehts]

+ please!!! Tone down that annoying voice of yours, and start listening to eather the questions and/or remarks, Miss Joseph! And don't try to work your pamphlet all the way down by all means, that you so desperately have been putting on.

[@Ronaldo573]

There is no such thing as political Islam. Islam is political. The problem with Islam is that there are always people who try to impose their political ideals on the masses. It's the same with sharia law. Get a sizable majority of Muslims and most of them will advocate the imposition of sharia. Now people would say that in a democratic country this should be permissible. No, sharia allows no room for amendments nor is it a democratic system. It is inherently prejudiced against non-Muslims.

[@greeko25]

governing and religion should not be combined .see saudi arabia , algeria and others the woman speaking is rather feisty but the weakest speaker in essence from them all