DonnyFL silencers - The comparison

[@AirGhandiWorld]

Check my shop: www.jabolo.de/en !

[@themikarenolds2910]

i used the emperor with the extender until i realized after taking the end cap off my emperor pulled out the mettle mesh tube rapped it with a peace of cut canvas tapped over it with duct tape then electrical tape then put it back into the tube filling the outside the mettle mesh and air space in the tube with canvas a easy sound absorption materiel i could make fit inside the tube wrapping it a few times around the center mettle mesh tube applying tape and so on,,, SO... now i dont need the extra 6.5 extender my MODIFIED Donny FL emperor at 357 made my western rattler 357 much less volume then it was with the extender and emperor making the modified emperor the least volume suppressor , so i recommend trying it and not messing around , make one and have the real deal, as it improves it about another 40 percent or more maybe 50 percent ,. less noise its actually perfect and i dont need the extra barrel length with the extender its just not needed any more as my modified emperor is lower volume

[@mickmahal-ol5ff]

Took you 19 lines to write a sentence? 😮wow Assuming English is your 5th language

[@vohramuhammad7677]

No silencer - 87.1 db Tatsu - 80.5 db Tanto - 79.3 db Sumo - 77.4 db Ronin - 76.7 db Koi - 77.9 db Shogun - 74.5 db Fatboy - 84.2 db (80.7 db extension) Emperor - 75.8 db

[@Brianbri-nq3cc]

THANK YOU!💥🏆👍👍🏼👍🏾👍🏽👍🏿

[@agunther08]

Thank you!!

[@rickoshea8138]

If you shoot a pellet the sound will be quieter because the pellet acts as a moving plug that drives air radially into available space. This will affect the ranking of your test to some degree. Also, if you shoot at higher power, the value of the larger moderators will be more obvious.

[@bobbyhaney8322]

Thats what I was thinking also, as he is testing its a straight hole for the air to escape. A pellet as you said would force more air through the baffles.

[@Brianbri-nq3cc]

100%Facts, there would be a major difference in sound, rather the sound would be lower or higher, there would be a big difference💥👍👍🏼👍🏾👍🏽👍🏿

[@Brianbri-nq3cc]

🏆👍​@@bobbyhaney8322

[@Brianbri-nq3cc]

🏆👍

[@MrRockstar1968]

Best silencer review I've seen yet. Thanks for that.

[@dollhausenx]

A round up at the end showing the results in a graphic would have made sense. Otherwise we're left to scrubbing through the video to find the results and write them down.

[@supramanx1997]

Yes, a summary chart is ALWAYS helpful when doing Objective tests or comparisons! At least put the names and dB results in a pinned comment or the description or for 30 seconds at the end to glance at, so people can make informed choices

[@Tomahawk_24]

I clicked the external link to the blog thinking the same thing... seems like ya missed the whole point of the video! We want the data!

[@russellham2094]

Hi Andi Great review, nice to see someone employing instrumention to check sound levels. Seen so many moderator reviews were the presenter just comments "well it certainly is quieter" Keep up the good work! Regards 👍

[@AirGhandiWorld]

Thanks a lot for your kind words! Will do my best for good entertainment in the future :)

[@dr.frankenphoon6254]

Best comparison I have seen yet! Thank you!!

[@shawndubay4050]

Very good comparison video. I am curious about an outdoor test with the audio and decibel equipment thirty yards down range and shooting into a soft target such as a sand bag. Of course with the sound equipment to the side of the target a few feet. This would be the true way to test the performance of each model on the rifle. No mechanical noise and no echo from the walls. Actual report sound from the target in the distance. I will tell you that the Shogun and the Ronin are two moderators that definitely hush the Airforce Condor SS in .25 caliber almost down to nothing. No response from birds and squirrels in the back yard even when they are ten yards from my thirty yard range. They just glance at the spinner targets and go back to what they were doing. Pretty amazing really considering birds and squirrels are very skittish and tend to flee from even a leaf blowing across the yard in their direction.

[@SilverShadow2LWB]

Thank you so much for the English dubbed version.

[@Tomahawk_24]

A conclusion graph/infographic would make this the best review on KZbin.. literally sat with a pen and made my own chart

[@eastcoastsos]

Great video!

[@genuinetuffguy1854]

The Sumo and Ronin seem like the best ones for silencing/size/price

[@asilva781]

Very informative and nice video. Greetings

[@baiwangkonyak2953]

Can you please name that air rifle the one you are doing demo? Looks beautiful

[@esapuhakka5494]

Would have been nice to see compare that Weichrauh too.

[@chrissheila]

Im new to all this but I’m surprised that we’re only talking about a less than 10db change in total volume with the various silencers. The difference with/without seems much higher.

[@agunther08]

It’s not a straight scale 10 db is very noticeable.

[@roblastname9133]

Brilliant thank you 👍

[@AirGhandiWorld]

Thanks for watching mate! :)

[@Bigbopperairguns]

I have Terry's from buck and rail silencer, and it's awesome on speeds below 1100 FPS

[@agunther08]

Have the same silencer - it is pretty quiet. Be interesting to see how it would stack up in this crew?

[@supergreatairgunreviews]

Interesting comparison

[@eliovful]

buen día es la mejor reseña que vi de moderadores; pero me quedan algunas dudas, misma prueba al aire libre con agrupación a 30 yardas y misma carga de aire, también muy importante la misma distancia del medidor sonometro.

[@reinoudpolee6923]

Take note that surpressors like the emperor work better at higher volume of air, not ment for those nutered german pelletguns.

[@r.b.6619]

So the Shogun is the quietest one?

[@DelonYeoh]

I really appreciate the English version. in my country, it is illegal to posses any types of gun but at least this video lets me know what a silencer does. But any of you watching this video felt that the trigger is louder than the barrel or from the silencer? Or am I just really inexperienced at all? I only watched in the movies and never in real life....

[@charlesh5904]

What brand and model air rifle were you using? Just Curious.TIA

[@rickoshea8138]

Anschutz 9015

[@PFunk609]

Thanks a lot for this. My only concern is that you're losing pressure after each shot, so isnt the sound gona drop as well on its own? albeit maybe negligible? i honestly dont know. But thank you nonetheless 👍

[@rickoshea8138]

The air pressure in the main tank drops after each shot. The main tank feeds a smaller firing tank, that has its pressure regulated to a lower but constant level. So, the pressure drop in the main air tank does not affect the sound. Not until you shoot the air tank down to below the regulated pressure in the smaller firing tank. Cheaper PCP airguns often don't have a smaller tank with a pressure regulator. When you shoot and the main tank pressure drops, the valve stays open longer, to maintain the pellet velocity better. "Better", because there is a curve to the velocity over so many shots. The sharpness of the noise from the muzzle depends on the air pressure at the muzzle, as the pellet exits. With a full tank, the pellet is driven by a short burst of high pressure air. By the time that the pellet reaches the muzzle, it has expanded a lot, so the muzzle pressure is actually quite low. When the tank is near the lower functional pressure, the pellet is driven by a long burst of lower pressure air. Because the goal is to maintain the same average pressure down the length of the barrel to produce the same average force driving the pellet, the muzzle pressure of a nearly spent air tank that still produces the desired velocity is actually higher than when the tank is at maximum fill pressure. Hence with an unregulated PCP airgun, the sound actually becomes louder as more shots are fired, compared to when the tank is full of air at maximum pressure. You may need to read the above a few times for it to make sense.

[@arcticairgunner]

Accurate results can't be had in an enclosed space, without dound deepening. Repeat this test outdoors.

[@peyugo2510]

I wonder how will a Fat Boy with extension do with the Umarex Gauntlet 2 .30 cal. Any idea?

[@AtmoTacOutdoors]

I tried the fat boy on my gauntlet 30. Without the extender it was still quite loud. But I put the 6” extender on it and it was extremely quiet. Pretty much just hear the hammer click and the thwap of the slug hitting the target. The g .30 puts out so much power that it really needs a moderator with a lot of volume to hush all that air flow. The 6” extender on the fat boy seems to be the amount of volume that it needs to make it near silent.

[@AtmoTacOutdoors]

Oh and it was only quiet like that with the extender behind the baffles NOT in front

[@Skrillexx]

Fat boy disappoints... it just make the rifle look good, great review !

[@AndriusKamarauskas]

i was looking at AGN Vixen Long 5,5mm and i can't find a video where sound supresion is tested, what is your opinion of its ability to shoot silently?

[@agbcrartsora6918]

Hello sir, I have on my licence a 40 ft/ibs PCP .22. Used a weihrauch silencer but still so loud. Any silencer would mute this power level? I need help. Thank you and good review video btw

[@grumpyg9350]

What happened to the accuracy test on the hw100 with/ without compensator

[@macq1980]

For a uragan 30 cal, which one you recomend?

[@ATLAS-_-.]

So what did you end up going with?

[@fullgas1413]

Very Good! Muito bom

[@valmirkonzen]

Hier in Brazilian gibt es nicht diese donny fl Schalldämpfer.

[@bluesix2843]

Good video although hard to watch using Air pods as you haven’t completely silenced (no pun intended) the original audio while doing the English voiceover. It’s like a crossed telephone line.

[@pwtprojects5610]

The barrel of that rifle is so damn long.... Jesus, i'll buy one.

[@__-pl3jg]

So even the most effective suppressor only lowers the sound from 80db to 70db! Doesn't seem worth the effort to me 🤷.

[@SpyrosAdventures]

You do realize every single DB means the volume got an order of magnitude quieter right? The wave pressure is 10x less from 80db to 70db. That's a massive deal with sound, in real life it would sound as if it got half as loud as it was before and with a pellet would be near silent as the pellet would act like an earplug flying down the barrel and redirect more if not all sound into the moderator. The only sound you'd hear is like the hammer and any vibrations throughout the gun

[@shalinkumarsingh5184]

Nahi so rahaa tha, mummy ko lagaa ki bhookha hai kyun ki biscuit nahi khaya hai, issiliye jabarjasti uthana paraa Bitty ko.

[@secondfirstsecond]

donnyfl The most absolute overpriced garbage on airgun industry since 2014.

[@rzuazua74]

What’s better, for airgun

[@zachofalltrades1111]

Why you say that lol

[@bruceleroy8063]

Every comment like this always says "overpriced", never "ineffective". I'll gladly pay for a well compinsated machinist's time.

[@dutchsailor6620]

If this is a 6 ft/lb limited German air rifle, this test is completely useless. 6ft/lb is hardly moving any air at all. Please give a good bottom line what you are actually testing.

[@rickoshea8138]

Not useless, if you are shooting an Olympic target PCP at 5/5 ft.lb :) Yes. The differentiation between moderators would be larger, if the air rifle was shooting at 30 ft/lb. Find a review of UK FAC or US full power air rifle moderators. Besides, dB is not the only important criteria that would help make a choice. Subjective sharpness and tone matter a great deal too.