Moderator Review-DonnyFL vs Huma Moderator in .30 cal

[@harryv6147]

I can't hear anything but the metal ringing from the pellet trap, which I really don't want to hear! I would like to hear just the gun firing and compare with my ear.

[@pointnozzleaway]

I purchased a moderator from DonnyFL for my Marauder. They sent the wrong one. I contacted them. within 3 hours they replied. They told me the correct moderator was on it's way.......and to keep the first one ! They sent the correct one within 3 days + a bunch of extra goodies. That's Next Level customer service

[@ronmcc4]

What is behind that cardboard? It sounds like a bell! Never mind about trying to quiet the rifle.

[@mattolsson8816]

LOL

[@brookejacobsmeyer9907]

Stopped watching after the 4th grouping shot. Was watching to compare moderators but the ringing metal made it difficult.

[@hotchihuahua1546]

I am revisiting some of these test and I have to say you guys put a lot of time into this ! Great job and informative ! 👍👍

[@WiscAirGunners]

Thanks. We learned a lot and have learned much more since doing these tests.

[@jindoisland]

I was thinking of trying a Huma mod40. I already have a Sumo. Your test saved me the trouble. Thank you!

[@mattolsson8816]

The threshold of perception of the human ear is approximately three decibels and a five-decibel change is considered to be clearly noticeable to the ear. This is primarily due to the logarithmic measuring metric typically associated with decibels.

[@richardrojas6306]

This was an Excellent video with a wealth of information. I have done many hours of personal testing with Donnyfl against anybody. I have been extremely happy with Donnyfl products and his are at a very good price. I tested for quietness first, then accuracy and finally cost. I'm a backyard shooter and my neighbors Hate noise. It's good to know that Huma moderator did well in the sound test. Thank you for sharing this information.

[@suprafastmafc]

They didn't set up the huma mod right. 🤷‍♂️ I wish they had, but they hastily destroyed it.

[@Phalanx443]

Thank you! I like an honest review and appreciate it very much. Well done.

[@WiscAirGunners]

Glad you found it useful!

[@mikestone9129]

Now why wasn't I surprised with the results? Never used the Huma, but I have a Donnyfl. I have never found anything as good as his products.

[@nontimebomala2267]

I don't think you can consider either moderator the "winner" until you optimize the setup with each moderator and the pellet that it prefers. Barrel harmonics are ALWAYS going to invalidate any accuracy test until the rifle is tuned AS PART OF A COMPLETE SYSTEM. Good work guys.

[@WiscAirGunners]

I will agree that I know more today than we did then. I still have yet to see a modular design that beats a dedicated unit. Thanks!

[@casperboo5465]

This was very interesting, goes to show all mod's are not equal, thanks again, you got 1 more sub, Cheers

[@derrickmitchell39dm]

Quantitative analysis research don't lie. And the winner is the Donnyfl Sumo. I got a Ronin so oh well.

[@airnut5440]

Same here. Won't group like my other moderators. Strange. Removed first roll. Then all rolls. Same thing.

[@max88nielsen]

Hells bells 😂 a KZbin video about silence that I had to abandon because of the impact sound.

[@allanwind295]

I love these comparison videos. The theory on the Huma doesn't explain the result to me. I.e. some small variations in speed of the gun somehow cause _huge variation_ in speed with only that moderator. Wouldn't that speed changes result in much larger POI shifts than you see? strlok or whatever you use should tell you. Could it be measurement error (how the chrono is placed in relation to the end of the barrel etc)? FX makes no accuracy claims for the Pocket Chronograph on their website, and as such, I don't think it is a creditable measurement device.

[@suprafastmafc]

They didn't set the moderator up right. You're supposed to remove sound dampening from the first chamber or 2 on high volume guns. The internal volume is quite limited if you don't

[@suprafastmafc]

Wish this was a legit test, but yall didn't remove the material from the first module to allow the huma mod to breathe.

[@bertbccfu9564]

That bell ringing sound reminded me of the Monty Python sketch ( bring out your dead)

[@WiscAirGunners]

Love that one. "I'm not dead yet!"

[@guinnster1]

Man, those look more like 150 yd groups in a FX platform.

[@johnpaulstez]

Hi. Can you speak to the difference in tone? In firearms suppressor tests a lower tone is perceived as more quiet. Thank you.

[@WiscAirGunners]

I'm sorry but I do not recall. I know what you mean, but I don't recall which one was lower pitched.

[@WiscAirGunners]

@Frank Caltabiano good notes!

[@heric.4428]

Bigger opening on Huma 30 is the reason why grouping is worse that of Donny fl which has smaller hole at end cap...

[@pelletpusherakapelletpimp811]

Good test guys! Please test the new Weihrauch XL and XL-K moderators against these.

[@WiscAirGunners]

I would love to get my hands on a bunch of different ones and do a round up.

[@caseG80]

Interesting the lcs sk19 has the same looking insides as the Donny FL that comes on the gun at least it does the .25 Guess I’ll hold off from buying one for now.

[@WiscAirGunners]

Interesting.

[@robertwamboldt9437]

What are you using for a backstop the liberty bell !

[@ridinrocks]

I am on donnyfl website and its showing the 1/2x20in threaded version as a 25/30cal does that mean its sized to shoot both?

[@chrisungureanu6184]

Yup shoots both

[@bertbccfu9564]

I remember when I bought my Ronin a while back that Donny recommended going up one size to avoid pellet clipping, so I guess now they just list it as 25/30

[@taurbaby]

Man i would hate to see wisc airgunners not happy with the food in a diner!!!

[@samuelhorowitz5029PLUMBCRAZY]

I was wondering why Donny FL has stopped making moderators? Does anyone know???

[@richardcampbell5762]

I just subscribed to your Channel. Really good video on the sumo. Stay blessed and Shoot Straight. From New Mexico 👍🇺🇸✌

[@aronkeylfb023]

For me that is not true because I have all the brands and the huma is very good this can be promotion as you always do, the people of fx donnyFL and they are from fx they will not speak well of another brand 🤷🏽‍♂️ huma does not have commitment like you with fx

[@unballisticr.i.pdadloveand7055]

As Quasimodo would say the silencer and slugs don’t ring a bell boom boom lol

[@HR3EEE]

Steel targets my man... You had one job Smalls!!

[@unballisticr.i.pdadloveand7055]

The Huma would be a lot quieter if you added another ring which you can’t do with the Donny 👀👌

[@WiscAirGunners]

Unfortunately that isn't how it was sold to us from the retailer, in fact, the extra chambers were not available to us to try out.

[@unballisticr.i.pdadloveand7055]

@@WiscAirGunners it does make a big difference great video 👍

[@garypostell5268]

Accuracy is name of the game here correct?

[@TheDWZemke]

At the 25 cal what is the actual inside diameter and at 30 cal what is the inside diameter?

[@paulandrews3785]

Donny FL look s fantastic to thanks for the great work my friend made me a carbon fibre silencer and it's one hole at 25y in 177 at 790 FPS 8.44

[@WiscAirGunners]

Cool!

[@zato6226]

Brutal, But honest! Nice

[@WiscAirGunners]

Thanks. I feel like we took a lot of heat for this one. Have a great week.

[@a.p.z.]

Well done and thanks.

[@WiscAirGunners]

You are welcome.

[@jbird22cal]

So these are legal in WI? The wdnr is a bit fuzzy on the matter

[@WiscAirGunners]

The DNR has nothing to say about it. Airguns do not qualify as firearms from either a federal or state law standpoint (in WI) therefore accessories are not regulated.

[@brocwavra8813]

Whats the first target moderator ? Or is it without moderator ?

[@WiscAirGunners]

The first target we showed was the worst of the Huma targets.

[@chrisungureanu6184]

You should’ve put some plywood behind the target it ruined the video and the sound should be at least 50 yards from the target .we’re trying the moderator not the impact on the target

[@jefferybernard4800]

That ringing was a pain in the

[@mikeyang8040]

The worst review on KZbin, why use a metal pellet trap when reviewing a freaking silencer? All I hear is ringing in my ear.

[@WiscAirGunners]

Worst on all of KZbin is not what we were going for, but it is a distinction. Sorry to have wasted your time.

[@alicesmoot4191]

Which will fit on my 30 cal carnivore Hatsan pcp

[@WiscAirGunners]

I'd go Ronin on a .30 cal.

[@robertmackenzie2985]

Excellent!

[@WiscAirGunners]

Many thanks!

[@pipzza6733]

DonnyFl hands down

[@WiscAirGunners]

100%

[@natego5150]

I mean… u could have gave it to me instead of shooting it haha. Nice video

[@WiscAirGunners]

Next time.

[@ronaldkonings8117]

so the results are not saying anything because of different guns and differents calibers..... too bad

[@kurtfirestone2761]

This video is like watching paint dry

[@WiscAirGunners]

Sorry to have wasted your time.

[@Gremlin480]

adjust your scope to the right ...

[@mmestss]

I’m sorry to say this sir This is this disrespectful to the brand and 25 to 30 caliber it’s big different to compare.

[@garypostell5268]

DONNYFL 💯💪🇺🇸

[@Fing311]

You need a moderator for your backstop

[@max88nielsen]

Why even bother with a silencer, with that pellet trap😂😂

[@edricheson]

why would you even do the test then

[@rayward7108]

what was the point, total waste of time .. start again

[@2WildRazn]

Man that ringing got my ears hurting

[@heric.4428]

PROS reviewers have church bell as pellet trap...

[@jeraldhessler3435]

Completely bias... I don't believe your assessment one bit