The Unrigging of Drag Race Season 11

Vote for who you think would win in the finale at my social media links below!
Let me know in the comments what you thought about my opinions! Would you change anything?
Instagram: / thedragdetective
Twitter: / dragdetective
Patreon: / thedragdetective

[@Cam-ch9iv]

Yvies judging was so weird, she was both favored and also robbed at the same time throughout the season.

[@DragDetective]

So bizarre. Could have had 3 wins and 3 bottoms.

[@Cam-ch9iv]

@@DragDetective she’s clearly an amazing lip syncer so I don’t know why they were so hesitant to put her in the bottom anyways.

[@Robertdbd20]

@@Cam-ch9iv because if someone lip syncs more than once in the normal drag race us they can't typically win, no one has exept priyanka and shes canada

[@yee6870]

It's weird. It seems that riggory never stays isolated in one episode.

[@dipassignment6037]

season 11 was wild. It's the same way Silky was favoured but also given one of the worst edits of the show.I mean, I do think fans went overboard with the hate in a way they don't with white fan favourites who behave similarly cough Alyssa Edwards cough, but even so.

[@taroknight8464]

“I promise I’m not a crazy scarlet Stan” *scarlet wins the season*

[@-t8909]

Right🤣

[@abbyb17]

yeah....final four I think was stretching it. Beating A'keria and Brooke at lip syncs in the final absolutely never.

[@Will-db4qo]

@@abbyb17 A'keria didn't know the lyrics to SOS

[@Jhawk2711]

@@Will-db4qo and still would've beaten Scarlet

[@bruh24318]

As soon as she beat Rajah in the lipsync and was then high for snatch game I checked out lmao

[@hopii5177]

I love the idea of Scarlet winning against Brooke when she cant dance if her life depends on it and Brooke is a literal ballerina.

[@brynniefresh9746]

well she didn't win the final round and i don't even really remember what she did...there wasn't a huge outfit or anything like yvie seemed to put more into it so i would see scarlet pulling out some sasha velour type shit, leaving everyone shook

[@bernardsoul5186]

@@brynniefresh9746 Maybe she could pull a velour gag ONCE, in the first round, but to assume she could pull off TWO, just because, is [R word], sorry.

[@kolcheks]

scarlet winning the whole season while having two left feet would be the funniest thing ever

[@naluzoniro]

Kim Chi made it to the finale, everything is possible lol

[@naluzoniro]

@Eikie K totally agree, her runways were FIRE, but she couldn't dance either x)

[@iseahprince4958]

Wtf is happening to us lamo . Omfg this shit is poison

[@naluzoniro]

@Eikie K yeah, that's why I compared them ??

[@naluzoniro]

@Eikie K because they're both great queens who can't dance

[@kolcheks]

i’m a huge scarlet fan, but i can’t wrap my head around the idea of her winning. top 4 though?? hell yeah, i would have loved to see her go that far cause i know she had the talent to, and she deserved it

[@imroxxxyandrewsand-344]

Idk why, I can just see her winning. I think it would be a really great redemption arc, imagine if she got a second dose of determination after winning the lip sync against Rajah and did really well? Like he said, scarlet uses stunts to bring the energy that dancers bring, because she’s smart enough to realise she’ll lose if she dances. It would also be herstory if she won and was a bad dancer ( and besides, lip sync smack down for the crown was the stupidest thing they ever introduced)

[@kolcheks]

@@imroxxxyandrewsand-344 ngl that’d be completely epic

[@raymondjacque6594]

Ya like me with Jan or rock m Sakura, I’m STAN! I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THEM but I can’t see them winning

[@alexanderbassett2901]

agree and scarlet was my favorite of the season

[@bernardsoul5186]

Seeing a stunt like the flower petals or, I don't know, Aquaria's sparks is possible, but it has to be timed perfectly and very visible to the audience as well as the cameras. It's super rare and difficult, and there's no evidence that Scarlet could do it other than "I feel like..." Now to do it in not one, both BOTH lip syncs in the finale is impossible. I think DD thought about this so much that he broke his brain.

[@joeytravis8752]

i think what we learned here is that scarlet is an icon

[@meowwwmeowwww5555]

but we already knew that

[@blackmanta9697]

Can't fait to see her on as6

[@missnoirz]

She’s my fav celebrity in the world and obvs fav drag queen

[@chapogyr]

@@blackmanta9697 you mean some stars 2

[@PotatoInABeanie]

@@blackmanta9697 happy shes gone

[@ashjcamp]

Hearing "I know silky is not the greatest lip-syncer on earth" in this video just opened my eyes to how much she's improved and evolved from s11 to as6

[@bernardsoul5186]

Not to mention Canada vs the World

[@rebeccafugard7105]

sometimes I wish Scarlet stayed longer. She was my fav

[@Javii1]

right she was so mistreated

[@elasiaval904]

“Sometime” is an understatement

[@dxcksxcker9881]

im happy she’s coming back ik AS6

[@ashersmith1391]

@@dxcksxcker9881 can I see proof

[@Sevarate.]

@@ashersmith1391 you'll find out right after 13 finishes lol

[@Kyarochefort]

Scarlett lasting that long is everything I ever needed. She was probably my favorite of the entire season so... Thank you

[@_.Idk._]

Same!

[@Mummychild888]

If Yvie can’t win, I wouldn’t have been mad at a miraculous crowning of Scarlet if she Sasha Velour’d her way to the crown with stunts 🤷

[@coqui9879]

I find it ironic that this hypothetical scenario is supposed to be if there was no rigging yet your main argument for keeping Scarlet over Rajah is that it makes for a better storyline.

[@dexterlaverick1579]

yh i found that kinda weird

[@purr7310]

Tea ☕

[@ashishsingh4867]

COME THROUGH!

[@ellamayothethird906]

he’s such a hypocrite like

[@normalizenatalie]

i think it's different when it makes sense with the arc

[@successfulsomewhat]

i really doubt that anyone but yvie would win s11.. ru most definitely LOVED her, and she was the biggest fan favorite at the time.

[@isaacmahoney5947]

I think they my be hesitant if her track record is bad enough, but as long as she makes it too the top she probably lip syncs and wins in every occasion.

[@wissamahmadieh2155]

Statistically speaking, brooke has a better track record than yvie's, a KZbinr named Uckey does videos about that

[@alexhaig9582]

@@isaacmahoney5947 but yvie was in the top almost half of the episodes she may have only won once but she still did a good job in the competition

[@zootmoe]

@@alexhaig9582 Yes, between episodes 2 and 7, Yvie had 1 win followed by 5 high placements. That’s quite strong.

[@matiasivanyanezvaldivia8511]

@@zootmoe Brooke won 3 challenges and was high 6 times. Much stronger than Yvie. Yvie was safe after the bttm2, in every episode.

[@manicpixiecassidy]

I think there is NO WORLD in which Scarlet wins "Bootylicious". No matter who she's up against. She could bring all the gags in the world, but she just can't do that song. And I am one of the aforementioned rabid Scarlet fans, who genuinely think she could have won this season. SOS... maybe?

[@matiasivanyanezvaldivia8511]

People loving a queen shouldnt cloud your judgement. She could do great, but the finale would be difficult.

[@bartek7733]

They could change the lipsync songs to make her do better

[@thekiiing2073]

@@bartek7733 Bootylicious is a song that Brooke is used to dancing to and slaying, it’s literally her element. Scarlet would’ve lost 100%, had they change the song maybe.....

[@benjamintic3653]

I don't really se her winning SOS as well, both are dance songs so stunts wouldn't work in them.

[@kotosqoposrly]

Umm .. shall we remember the edit Pearl (someone as stiff as Ru's makeup abilities) in her lip syncs where she won each one of them?

[@elsolinn617]

Unpopular Opinion: Shuga should have won the rusical

[@DragDetective]

Shuga was my fifth fav tbh. But she did super well and that runway omg haha

[@yee6870]

she could and that runway was the BEST of the week

[@theamazingsirsteve5486]

I think Shuga did great on that episode.

[@EscSłonecznika]

Not sure if she should have won (Id have given it to Yvie) but I think she should have been top 3

[@Olafscrochetworld]

Just cause of that runway Shuga should have won as fuck

[@dannyrice1484]

I loved this, I agree with a lot of what you’ve said. But you gave Scarlett waaayyyyyy too much credit 😂😂

[@alanosmarceballosfranco7205]

The title has to be "Scarlet is iconic in my imagination"

[@wetsock7790]

Scarlet IS iconic but she's not a lipsyncer

[@alanosmarceballosfranco7205]

@@wetsock7790 actually she did good in both lipsyncs

[@livelisabeth4892]

in conclusion : Scarlet was robbed and should have gone way further

[@kevinmichael3371]

To me, I feel like in the finale scenario, Brooke vs Yvie would’ve been double shantay to replace the one that we would miss out on, and then in the final lip sync Yvie would’ve won, because that head reveal was truly a moment.

[@psycane8462]

Brooke and Yvie in the first lip sync would have been a way better double shantay to the final lip sync than Aquaria vs. Eureka, but either way, I think Yvie wins? Brooke did great but she did the same thing she did in every other lip sync, and it would not have worked nearly as well in S.O.S. as it did in Bootylicious. But I'm also a delusional Yvie stan who can't comprehend Yvie not winning the season lol.

[@cuppateia]

If I recall correctly from being on the Spoilers Reddit at the time, Aquaria majorly flopped in that lip sync vs Eureka and stumbled multiple times, and a tie was the best they could try and salvage for her bc Eureka was the clear winner in the room. One of the very very few times I have been thankful for producer/editor shenanigans because I did Not want Eureka to win that crown lmao.

[@amcuevas]

@@cuppateia Imagine a world where Ru had to choose between Eureka and Kameron. I fully believe she would've been like "wait, nevermind, Asia come back."

[@cuppateia]

@@amcuevas "Come back girl it's okay... Those butterflies had it coming anyways!"

[@daveliamjohnston]

This was fun, but, yeah, you're nuts. No way Scarlet wins over Brooke. No. Way.

[@keyvwee1367]

Yeah I love Scarlet her and raja are my favs of the season but she would be pummeled by yvie and Brooke a do think she would pull a real cool stunt but no

[@kittikats]

Also the future challenges results are all based on runway and what she MIGHT have done ... you can't know for sure. And we've seen time and time again queens who are strong at something (design, acting, comedy, singing) completely bomb on their speciality. I could see her making top 5. Top 2 is a stretch

[@aadenshawn2888]

Right this gavs me rigged vibes for scarlet

[@napoleonplays5924]

Um ...if Yvie was saving her moves for Brooklyn, why doesnt she use those moves against Brooklyn in this setup?

[@RayatoTV]

I was onboard until Snatch Game. You would’ve denied us the epic Sorry Not Sorry lipsync? I don’t think!

[@Darthlauralou]

Same. Silky was not funny whatsoever imho

[@valentinadevogueofficialx]

@@Darthlauralou she was, what crack you smoking?

[@thetailsgamer1085]

Since Yvie was the winner it feels like the production kind of ignored her for like the whoule season

[@vergaramaruchristophert.2722]

Same with jaida

[@thetailsgamer1085]

@@vergaramaruchristophert.2722 True

[@oliverbrydges]

Scarlet’s two options were Lana and Lucille Ball who are so different yet I can see Scarlet doing both of them amazingly 😂 Edit: omg if scarlet made the finale I could see them trying to get her and yvie in the top 2 because they were friends so that could have been the scenario

[@xo_blonk_ox9905]

I think brook would probably win in the scenarios where she’s up against yivie as yivie lip syncs twice in this scenario but I agree I couldn’t belive how well scarlet would do if it was fair and she continued in the competition but yeah wow shocked she would probably win

[@isaiahmunoz6257]

But priyanka lip synced twice as well and still won

[@Nobootsmama]

@@isaiahmunoz6257 there hasn’t been a US winner that has lipsyncs twice in the season.

[@anish6750]

@@isaiahmunoz6257 cdr is produced by different people and it was brooke who made that decision

[@xo_blonk_ox9905]

@@isaiahmunoz6257 its an international judged by Brooklyn not ru it’s just a pasific statistic with every main series winner and it makes sense to take it into consideration when looking at hypotheticals

[@dondericks4302]

"I don't even like her that much" Umm I think u like scarlet very very much 😂😂

[@keghan4824]

I think Scarlet going this far is probably easier to imagine just because when we don’t see the actual competition, it’s easy to imagine people crushing things they’re good at. But really even if they were her strengths I think Scarlet could’ve realistically floundered on one of the challenges. Also it seems too convenient to assume she’d have gag-worthy theatrics for her finale lip syncs.

[@otaviocohen88]

Fun, now we all need a video called 'the favouritism of Scarlett envy' as a response to this one

[@elsolinn617]

another unpopular opinion: Brooke was sooo forgettable on the Trump Rusical. Plastique, Shuga, Ariel, Scarlet and Silky did so much better.

[@onlyrealtalentedartists]

Plastique, sghuga and Scarlet did netter than Silky

[@benjamintic3653]

I call bullshit and Scarlet favouritism! She just couldn't. She's a great queen but she isn't a lip syncer.

[@Javii1]

Scarlet making it to top 2 and winning is the season I'd like to watch.

[@MiguelMartinez-mc5kn]

The twist and turns to get Miss Scarlet to the top 😂😂

[@N1ghtGlider]

What if Season 7 had been judged fairly. I just really want justice for Max and Mrs Kasha Davis 😂😂

[@cenlan71]

Probably Violet, Ginger & Max in the Top 3, change Max for Kennedy Davenport if you like.

[@zaknotkyle]

Imo it would be Violet, Ginger, Kasha and Kennedy in the Top 4? Maybe Katya instead of Kasha.

[@aldricmartinez-olson9953]

@@zaknotkyle I think Kasha would get eliminated by Ginger in the dancing challenge and the top 4 would be Kennedy, Ginger, Violet, and either Katya Max or Trixie (leaning towards Trixie because Katya and Max both bombed their challenges hard and got slayed by their opponents)

[@andregiusti5329]

i think that maybe brooke would have “tried harder” in the final lsftc knowing that she has a actual chance at winning (only 1 btm placement), specially if she was going against scarlet who she had some time of rivalry (as seen on reunion)

[@cenlan71]

I think the same. Brooke knowed already she was going to lose. That's very obvious when they do the Crowning Reaction.

[@nellychuu]

Suggestion: how a season could have been better

[@aldricmartinez-olson9953]

This, cuz sometimes it makes sense to rig things a little to let people who are contributing to the storyline/overall competition stay a little longer. Season 5 and 6 were a little rigged but they were still amazing!

[@kingvamp8267]

A'Keria losing to Scarlet Envy? Not even in her wildest dreams

[@uni5956]

That Part Or Rajah Love Her Or Hate Her She Killed Her Lipsyncs

[@elocc9570]

POV - You are a huge Scarlett Envy fan, who is oddly in denial.

[@sebastianpenuela4138]

Not gonna lie, Scarlet winning season 11 makes total sense with my french vanilla fantasy

[@Noalexis62]

alternative title: what if drag race season 11 was judged unfairly but by a scarlett envy stan this time? lol

[@gigifabulous]

Oh no... Anyways

[@maartengijsel8776]

I don’t think Scarlet would win, I would love to tho! But the judging this season was so weird so I could definitely see Scarlet lasting until the top 4, it would’ve also been such a great story line with Brooke and Scarlet having kind of a rival storyline would be so cool!

[@boywonder3439]

The mediocrity of this season is surreal...i just can't.

[@weeeeee4844]

The final, final lip sync never matters. I think that just needs to be said. The previous two absolutely, but that final one...no

[@hamnjax]

hearing that scarlet has a chance at winning the season just works well with my fantasy

[@IWillBeHers]

After watching AS6 so far, Scarlet would definitely have killed the farm to runway challenge.

[@velky_reeds]

I love Scarlet, but I think it's too much of a stretch for Scarlet to win this season, reveals don't equal a good lipsync performance

[@silencesteel5246]

Can't wait for videos about other sesons! Mostly Canada sesons 1. This version could get like 2 hour documentary

[@im_the_tribute]

I think in any case Brooke can’t win. I don’t think they would’ve let her win because they wanted her for Canada’s Drag Race and I think they didn’t want it to seem rigged

[@im_the_tribute]

@Droidcore But The Vivienne wasn’t going to get her own tv show. The producers most likely wanted to have a Canada’s Drag Race and they knew Brooke could be a judge. RuPaul is already super busy doing All Stars, US Drag Race, and UK they he would need someone for Canada

[@inventions178]

@@im_the_tribute The Vivienne's prize was a TV show lol

[@PaperVisions]

@@im_the_tribute wouldn’t it be even more valid to have a drag race winner than a top 2 for Canada’s version. You point doesn’t make any sense

[@im_the_tribute]

@@PaperVisions you do have a point. Anyways I’m the actual season Brooke had to lip sync twice. No winner of a regular season should be up for elimination twice. Brooke was and that almost voids her being able to win the crown look at Ginger on S7. She did the best but didn’t win because she was up for elimination twice

[@AngryCandy89]

I have also thought the same thing, they didn't want too make It look like It was rigged for her

[@dpm8780]

I think it would be great if you put the track record at the end so that we can have like an overview and see who did the best track record wise :)

[@AlexMartin-ek9ox]

I think that if it comes down to Scarlet and Brooke they scarlet would win the lip Sync but they would still crown Brooke because she would of had a better track record and the final lip Syncs don’t really matter usually

[@victoriatalika8284]

As much as i love Scarlette. I don’t think she would’ve made it that far tbh

[@ethanholder3908]

I can’t stop thinking about how in the version of the LSFTC where Scarlet beats Akeria, they would be lipsyncing to Bootylicious. Implying that SCARLET ENVY would AKERIA C DAVENPORT to BOOTYLICIOUS 😭😭😭

[@JojoJojo-he7mn]

This is even more rigged than the actual season lol

[@woolyvaro7814]

Thing is, with Vanjie winning the episode prior, her energy and confidence in Queens everywhere might have been where it needed to be, and I actually think she maybe would've done well enough, that they might not have sent her home, even though she had the worst track record, because I personally enjoyed her verse more than Akerias and Brookes.

[@amcuevas]

To be fair, in S11 she lost her momentum in the performance cause her heel broke. If she wore different shoes she may have stayed over silky.

[@montanaripatrick]

I was with almost always, I just think in the finale Scarlet would lose round 1 regardless; yes she can pull gags but so can the other three, you keep sleeping on A'Keria but that's okay many people did sadly.

[@wenniejo4070]

This completely fits with my fantasy, scarlet is the winner in some time line somewhere. I hope she does well on all stars 🙏✨✨

[@cruz8537]

hope you do this for other seasons I really like this

[@PotatoInABeanie]

The favoritism of scarlet envy went above and beyond I see 😭

[@EmHannibal]

Loving the videos, the insight is gold! I have one wish, which is that you would include some pictures from the episodes in the video, especially when discussing the lewks? I'm so engaged, but am distracted by having to look up references all the time XD

[@sebastiancano7058]

Actually ariel put on instagram the look she would have made for the farm to runway challenge it was a scarecrow thing

[@beandrag9019]

Yeah but she wasn’t like actually there using the same materials yk

[@hannahtangwell]

This video recognizes Scarlet for what could’ve been and I’m HERE for it

[@iz6130]

SAME.

[@granttiss]

I think Scarlet’s storyline here would be PERFECT. It would be like the underdog, the hated confident bitch becoming top 2 and possibly winning. Fans would adore this shit. I honestly would love a horrible dancer winning the season while all the dancers lose the lipsync. This would make this season great

[@shinnyboppers9802]

found and binged a lot of your videos last night! very entertaining lol

[@DragDetective]

glad you enjoyed!

[@yepitsthatguy5278]

I get that it's hard to try and come up with hypothetical placings for when queens have already gone home but like .... Scarlet wasn't THAT amazing. I like Scarlet but I don't think Scarlet would have been in the Top 3 so many times after leaving tbh. The queens have literally a year to come up with new runways after being eliminated, improve their makeup and looks, and having a professional photoshoot is so different to showing up on drag race with a strict time limit to get dressed while on drag race - scarlet's makeup while on drag race was also like bad... her walk-in look, orange runway, gold runway did not have very good makeup ngl. I don't think she would have done an amazing makeover if she had been there. Basically I don't feel the photoshoots are an amazing thing to use to place queens after they've gone. Great video though! Love how you explained things and clearly showed your placings etc per episode

[@ytscrownjewell]

Vanjie safe in farm to runway wearing just a rope and glitter? That was THE worst look

[@IaMShadows1]

I’d love to see a full fantasy season! Your dream cast, challenges, lip syncs, elimination order, etc

[@darkmask5933]

I think with the final wheel spin, the thing you have to figure out is let's assume all four scenarios, one where Scarlet is picked by the wheel, one with Akeria, one with Yvie, and one with Brook. I doubt Brook or Yvie would have picked each other because they know they are both dancers, like you said Scarlet probably would have picked Akeria, but who would Akeria have picked? Also I wouldn't just assume Yvie would lose round 1 against Brook, because Yvie would have likely tried a lot harder against Brook, no shade to Akeria. You're comparing Bootylicious Brook against SOS Yvie, but honestly if you HAD to choose using Sorry Not Sorry Yvie vs Brook who would have won? Assuming they do an awful double save 3 way finale like s10, I think Sorry Not Sorry Yvie may squeak out over Brook because Yvie had a better story and was something we had never seen before, but feel free to disagree with me.

[@Hex852]

The "I know that Silky is not the BEST at lipsyncing" definitely aged well LMAO.

[@Camerino17]

I'm including mini-challenge wins, since those affect maxi-challenge stuff. Akeria - 4, 3, 3, 3, 3, 5, 1, 3, 5, 3, 2 = 35 = 3.18/ep Brooke - 5, 2, 3, 4, 3, 4, 3, 2, 4, 4, 4 = 38 + 2 = 3.63/ep Scarlet - 3, 5, 2, 3, 5, 1, 4, 4, 2, 4, 4 = 37 + 1 = 3.45/ep Vanjie - 4, 3, 4, 1, 3, 3, 2, 1, 1, 1, 5 = 28 + 1 = 2.63/ep Yvie - 3, 5, 3, 5, 3, 4, 5, 1, 3, 2, 1 = 35 = 3.18/ep Making the last episode follow how it did in season 11 Yvie - 5 Akeria - 4 Scarlet - 3 Brooke - 1 Vanjie - 0 Brooke - 41 = 3.42/ep Scarlet - 41 = 3.42/ep Yvie - 40 = 3.33/ep Akeria - 39 = 3.25/ep (If we include the placements for the top 4 as another competitive episode, with only top 2 getting points of 5/4, it doesn't change too much. Akeria is the only one who can't make top 2, and she already has the worst score) (Vanjie only gets 29 in 12 competitive episodes, or 2.42/ep, which is really bad for a top 5 contestant) This top 4 is incredible. Look at how balanced these numbers are, this never happens. However, I genuinely believe that in THIS world you have created, Yvie can't win. Up to this point in the series, no one has won with 2 bottom 2 lip syncs. Symone being the only exception, and that was in the largest season with the most competitive episodes, and the top 4 format was designed retroactively for her to be the only winner of the season (Gottmikk and Rose got 3 left feet and an ear infection at all times, while Kandy just didn't do well enough to earn the win). Which I think sucks. I like that Yvie won over Brooke, because Yvie was emotionally the correct choice, and she fit every criteria for a winner up until this point. Yeah Brooke did better by point average, but Yvie was the second best score in the season and only had the one lip sync. So... who wins? In my mind, in EVERY reality, because of how judging works in this competition, Brooke wins. Now let's do what you did and not give Brooke the last episode lip sync. Her score is even more impressively above the cast. She is a full win over Yvie, and Scarlet doesn't have the emotion behind her that Brooke and Yvie do in this season. Akeria never felt like a player, and faltered pretty darn hard in the finale, so... she kinda can't win. We're never given reason to want Akeria to win, and the edit does matter, so I can't justify her winning in any top 4 format. So the winner is either Brooke or Scarlet, and Scarlet could have stunts for days for all we know, but Brooke will out-dance her. I think that Scarlet loses to Yvie and Brooke in Bootylicious, while Akeria also probably beats her in Bootylicious since Akeria IS bootylicious personified. So, Scarlet needs SOS to beat Akeria. Cool, let's give her that. Yvie loses Bootylicious to Brooke, because Brooke killed that song so hard. Now Scarlet vs. Brooke happens, and Scarlet feels like she'd get swallowed up in this song. Yeah there's a world where Scarlet werks the haus down boots yass gaga kween sleigh, for sure, and gives us a gag/reveal to remember like the second head. But also, Brooke is a professional. What you saw in that finale is Brooke giving a phone in, and she still looked and felt like a genuine competitor. But, also, that lip sync against Vanjie? That was the weakness Brooke needed to BE the rightful winner of the season. She spent the entire season being perfect, untouchable, and unapproachable. That was her problem. Once the Vanjie wall broke, and you could feel Brooke in that lip sync, and how much emotion they both put into it (super underrated lip sync, love it every time), you have finally given Brooke everything for a complete storyline. Kinda like Alaska blowing up in AS2 and winning, because we love to see peoples weaknesses and how they react when pressured. Brooke DELIVERED when pressured here. So... yeah, I kinda feel that in this world, the only timeline Brooke doesn't win in is the one where Scarlet steals the dress from Yvie and her bone hurt disease to become stretch armstrong for a song. I'm saying this as a massive Scarlet stan. Brooke wins in 92.75% of worlds in this situation, whether you give her the lip sync against Vanjie or not. In the world without the lip sync, it's like not giving Bianca the win. You always give Bianca the win, because she's perfect and nice and did it every week. Brooke is one of the few queens ever to come for that title. With the lip sync? You've made a perfect story. There's a meta narrative you've got to consider, and with your scoring, you accidentally made Brooke the only winner. Which is totally fine because she's a great drag competitor and all that jazz. But yeah, as cool and wild as this world is, Yvie can't win and that feels bad man :(

[@alessaleatoria]

Scarlet should've the silky spot on top four and that's that. But Yvie's win was well deserved, I love her

[@iz6130]

I want to live in the fantasy where Scarlet wins , I agree she won the rajah vs scarlet lip sync but the finale?!! 😭

[@bernardsoul5186]

No way she had TWO Sasha Velour-type gags for the finale

[@krisnathebalinese]

Drag Detective, you need to make a video on RPDR UK Series 2 as soon as the finale airs this Thursday. This is an order.

[@balibabby1316]

I would’ve loved to see Rajah go further on her season I actually really loved her actually more than Yvie but that’s an unpopular opinion my take is Brooke Was The Winner Of Season 11

[@PotatoInABeanie]

I love these videos but lately they seem really biased . I think she’s talented but she wouldn’t have lasted that long let alone win 💀

[@corpseinthesky6111]

I don’t know anything about drag race but your videos are so nice for background noise because of your way of speaking (sort of like listening to an audiobook?) so thank you for putting them out here!

[@pletter]

"I'm not a Scarlet Envy stan" lieeessss! Anyways, here's how the elimination order and ppe score would go: Top 4: - Brooke Lynn Hytes [3.5] - Scarlet Envy [3.33] - Yvie Oddly [3.25] - A'Keria C. Davenport [3.17] 5th: Vanessa Vanjie Mateo [2.25] 6th: Nina West [3.09] 7th: Silky Nutmeg Ganache [3] 8th: Plastique Tiara [3.11] 9th: Ariel Versace [2.57] 10th: Ra'Jah O'Hara [2.17] 11th: Shuga Cain [2.6] 12th: Mercedes Iman Diamond [1.75] 13th: Honey Davenport [2] 14th: Kahanna Montrese [0.5] 15th: Pedoju [0]

[@pete_er]

yes, you're losing it xd the top4 simulation seems nuts indeed, Scarlett would never win against Brooklyn nor Yvie. Brooklyn winning against Yvie is also not very probable. however, they're both among the best dancer and lipsyncers of the whole franchise and wouldn't be defeated by any other queens of the season, no matter what.

[@niekklaver3030]

Scarlett was not ready for this season. Im excited for her all stars run, but she would not have made it to the end anyway

[@richardcrafton1805]

I would wait for the court case to finish before I made any decisions of soju. There's been no real proof on either side yet. Just a lot of talk. With sherie pie, there was evidence shown to prove their actions. That's the difference that makes me want to wait.

[@murraypeat2871]

imo shuga would beat silky, just because she stuck to one sorta part of the stage doesn't make it a bad lip-sync. I loved her lip sync tbh

[@ashishsingh4867]

Scarlet cannot Cannot CANNOT beat Brooke Lynn Hytes in the lipsyncs. In any lipsync. ANY LIPSYNC.

[@Annarekscia]

So basically if Scarlett stayed after last dance (which she should have) she would have won the season…..

[@katiescallon4049]

Best channel I’ve been suggested in a longgggg time 🤩

[@genodragotto1203]

I feel you showed just about as much favoritism to Scarlett Envy as Rupaul showed Silky and Vanjie. While yes, she had those amazing looks post elimination, her monster ball runway was far from as great as you made it seem. Water concept aside, the look she made was just her generic trumpet skirt dress in latex with a face mask and would not have beaten Plastique or Brooklyn. Also, to say she would’ve been safe as Lana Del Rey is a bit of a reach and the only way I can see laughing at someone impersonating Lana is if they do it announcing an album while at a Denny’s.

[@samhorsfall4822]

scarlets monster ball was the most creative of the night, u can’t tell me otherwise, as for snatch game i agree she shouldve been low but not bottom 2

[@ivankervis4374]

You could make a case for Plastique but Brook Lynn wasn’t even a monster in the most important look she just put a snake on her head

[@samhorsfall4822]

@RedundantFallacy i never said it wad the best executed, i said it was the most creative with the best concept

[@goeegoanna]

Brooke wore body suit after body suit but was never once called out on it and a good portion had a strappy look about them.

[@Hybridteddy]

Soooooo in theory she slayed the challenges even though she was not there . I want her career in your mind

[@SamAdamsDesigns]

Omg there is NOOOO WORLD where Scarlet beats Akeria are you kidding me 😳😳😳... we’ve reached the delusional segment of the drag race stan populous

[@landoncox875]

I mean he thinks Scarlet could beat Rajah so the amount of Jinkx’s perfume is strong

[@griffinoleary1053]

If scarlet bothered to learn the words she would beat her

[@amcuevas]

@@landoncox875 there is no world where Scarlet can outperform any of her season 11 sisters, aside from maybe Pedo-ju and Nina. And I say that as a massive Scarlet stan.

[@dali722]

I'm sorry can we talk about Scarlett isn't even that great at lip-syncing. I don't see Scarlet beating anyone in the top four. To say she'd pull a Sasha Velour is criminal.

[@PotatoInABeanie]

The change of the final 5 performance challenge by cutting the bottom 2 lip sync to keep scarlet from being in the bottom is sending me 😭😭 you really weren’t gonna let that girl go home. This more rigged than the actual season

[@racheldolezol7390]

So I found a common thread in these videos. Rigga Morris! You will take one of the Queens that you like the most all the way to the top despite how they actually did in the competition.. Scarlett wasn't even there.. bombed the acting challenge and you put her in the top SNATCH GAME... Stop these! They're pointless when you're biased. Scarlett lost every lip since on drag race.. She beats Rajahhhh??? Girl... are you ok?

[@benjihoward3398]

Okay I was intrigued (and lowkey obsessed with this type of video), so made the DoB scoring based on this video, including score and overall performance out of 10, in descending order based on scoring from the DoB page on the wiki, naturally excluding Ep 12 as there was no winner or BTM 2 (I hope my maths is correct lol) Brooke = 6 (6.364/10) Scarlet = 3 (5.909/10) Yvie = 3 (5.682/10) Plastique = 2 (5.556/10) Nina = 2 (5.455/10)* A'keria = 2 (5.455/10)* Silky = 1 (5.25/10) Shuga = -1 (4.5/10) Ariel = -2 (4.286/10) Honey = -2 (3.333/10) S*ju = -2 (0/10) Mercedes = -3 (2.5/10) Ra'Jah = -4 (3.333/10) Kahanna = -4 (0/10) Vanessa = -5 (3.864/10) * - A'keria and Nina got identical scores, however since Nina reached the score in less episodes than A'keria, I put Nina above I also calculated the DoB of S12 fair judging, may put it up on that video as well lol

[@ToyTALLz]

I've watched a couple of your videos and it's clear that a LOT of references go over your head because of things you just don't know. I,E. Bone Collector, Coming To America (you called it a play, it's a cult film) etc. on a previous video about the Halloween ball there were loads you missed too which skewed your judgement.

[@ToyTALLz]

Silky's second look was a black pop culture reference - of a witch from The Wiz (Rajah referenced The Wiz in the ball too).

[@ToyTALLz]

Ariel Versace isn't a dancer. She's not known to be one either. She said herself - she is not a dancer.

[@ToyTALLz]

Your judging of Scarlet wasn't 'fair' it was biased

[@Casey-sl7ek]

@@ToyTALLz of course the whole thing is one persons fantasy season cmon now

[@ToyTALLz]

@@Casey-sl7ek He said he's not being biased verbatim.

[@shirleyanne6573]

Scarlet had some great looks, but she spent most of this season looking nervous and defensive. Where she got really robbed was on AllStars.

[@beandrag9019]

Scarlet is literally my favorite drag queen and Idek why but I feel like they would give it to Brooklyn because of them wanting to put her as the host of Canada. But then again it would be a really good resolution to their episode one and two storyline of scarlet being annoyed at Brooke flaunting her win and being underestimated then winning against her in the top two

[@georgebroadhurst5483]

Whilst I agree Scarlet would've performed well in the later challenges, she would never out lip sync Rajah O'Hara.

[@travisslade6860]

Scarlet winning against Ra’jah in a lip sync? I don’t think.

[@sarahd6728]

I feel like this scenario is kinder to rajah’s storyline too because she did good in the farm to runway only to get sent home, so we don’t get that robbery here. Revisiting this season kinda makes me realise how many queens (rajah, scarlet, shuga) got a raw deal because producers obviously didn’t favour them.

[@trentintampa9328]

I usually love the big girls, but Silky needed to go sooner than later. I'm so glad we got to see more Sugar. I was not a Scarlett fan at all. Overall, in spite of Silky, I was happy with the season and outcome. The Brooke vs. Yvie lipsynch was EVERYTHING!!!!

[@mayruuh]

i really think yvie was robbed of her farm sewing challenge. plastique was good but she was serving the same kind of look and sillhoette she always does while yvie was amazing the farm musical number and was showing a new side of her in the runway. yvie totally deserved her win in s11 tbh

[@waffletuff1042]

Hey!! I love your content and I think your personality is so fun! If I could, I’d recommend maybe adding some music to the background of your videos so that they don’t feel as empty (audibly speaking). Keep up the great work!!

[@jamesa.fitzpatrick1566]

Silky got a LOT of help from the judges.