Drummer Reacts To Led Zeppelin - Black Dog (Live at Madison Square Garden 1973) || LEGENDARY!!

[@setonhillstudios]

*You can support the channel with KZbin Channel Memberships or through Buy Me a Coffee. Never expected, but always appreciated.❤Links in Description!* Dude!!! Ain't nothing like Zeppelin and Bonham in that pocket!! 🔥🔥

[@26shedan]

Led Zeppelin never disappoints.

[@Dan-zq5wt]

Magic! Nothing like Zeppelin in their prime!

[@jeffreyflint6286]

You can't ever lose with Led Zeppelin. 👍👍🤘🤘

[@CosmicVagabondPixie]

YAY YAY & YAY LUVIT!!! Thank YOU ever so Made my day Brighter!!! BEST band EVER!!! to me anyway

[@tjrivers]

This has to be one of the best live performances ever. Sensual and bangin’! Gosh, we were lucky to live in this era of rock excellence!

[@billtaylor3382]

Right on! 66 yo guy here been a fan since 1969 I was 11 years old.

[@tjrivers]

@@billtaylor3382 I was 13 in ‘69!

[@sicotshit7068]

Hard to go wrong with any of their songs, though some live performances of a song, are better then others. Thank you for your reaction.

[@daredevildaryl2645]

This historic concert was later part of their movie THE SONG REMAINS THE SAME

[@maggedo-x1s]

Led Zep's "When the Levee Breaks" has John "Bonzo" Bonham's best drum intro in their deep dark blues'iest rocker! 🤘 Great reactions to "Black Dog"! 👍

[@danielswood]

as an adult i've always been fascinated by the rhythms in black dog. as a teenager i just loved to be out there dancing to it!

[@setonhillstudios]

Such a banger!!! 🔥🔥

[@nancymjohnson]

Saw this tour in Dallas as a 15 year old. Had 6th row center. Before this, I had seen Beach Boys, Chicago, The Osmonds, (lol) and a few other bands…but had never seen a man like Robert Plant! OMG! He was beautiful. Not just looks. Voice, mannerisms, the whole package. It was that moment I knew I was going to be a fan forever. I’ve now seen him half dozen times, seen Page same amount. Tried to get Zeppelin tickets again, unsuccessfully. ☮️❤️😎🎼

[@bowtiefidenine]

Thanks for the Led Zeppelin The greatest band ever ❤

[@pennyoliver2712]

One thing about it they would start a song and you never know where it's gonna go!!!!.....TRULY AMAZING BAND!! I'm a 62 year old woman and absolutely love Zeppelin ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@pamelarex1877]

I saw them live in 73 but not the Garden. The best concert I ever saw!!!!!!

[@DebbieFoxx]

I began listening to them in 1973 aged 13. Never stopped. Legends. 🎶

[@Duketributechannel]

I too aged 13 in 1974

[@daredevildaryl2645]

@@Duketributechannel I too aged 13 in 1976

[@jeffreyflint6286]

I hear sister. I started in 1970!❤❤❤❤❤

[@stephane2137]

Physical graffiti went out the day I was born. I'm not old enough to have seen them live. I wish i have a time machine.

[@DebbieFoxx]

@@stephane2137 Great times for concerts.

[@MrDandanhesourman]

I've watched this MSG concert movie at least a hundred times in my 53 years. What a magical movie/concert.

[@rickeyjohnson6404]

I was 11 years old in 1969 when I heard their first album starting with Communication Breakdown and I've been a fan ever since, I love your reaction thanks

[@boki1693]

Dude , "Since I ve been Loving You" from the same concert. Show stopper. But this entire concert is fire. Also, from Earl's Court, Trampled Underfoot and In my time of dying.

[@mikerichardson8983]

You have to check out. Since I been loving you, from same concert. Plant is unreal! Best live performance i have ever seen!

[@sicotshit7068]

One of my two favorites, the other is In My Time Of Dying, live at Earls Court. I prefer the one night over the other though, the video that’s 12 minutes & I believe 4 seconds long. The one Plants vocals are better, & the visuals aren’t damaged, like they are a little in the other.

[@BhutJolokias]

Watched a couple of your videos and am impressed with your passion. You have a new subscriber here.

[@setonhillstudios]

@@BhutJolokias Really appreciate that! 😁

[@kdm71291]

This, of course, is from their legendary concert film “The Song Remains The Same”…of that 1973 show…..produced/ released in 1976. One of my favorite bands of all time…in my top two, actually.

[@vernhoke7730]

I was a bit too young to make this show at the Garden in '73. Back then 14 year olds didn't go off to concerts on their own, plus finding out when the show was and standing in line to buy them was way different than now. My first Garden concert was Queen in 1980. You might want to check out this whole show. It was released in theaters in 1975 as "The Song Remains the Same".

[@TexasMagnolia]

Steven, because of the close bond/love Ann & Nancy Wilson has with Zeppelin; they cover a lot of their songs. Heart - Black Dog - live …. A must!

[@juliemanarin4127]

Keep going...this whole show is unbelievable!

[@ryanr5319]

Ty for reaction, love the boys! Nobody better.

[@setonhillstudios]

@@ryanr5319 Thanks for hanging out! 🔥

[@tanyaweathersby9393]

❤❤❤Robert ❤❤❤

[@MisfitPhotographer]

Hands down my favorite reaction channel. Well done brother 🤘

[@setonhillstudios]

Really appreciate that! ❤️

[@roadwary56]

Zeppelin is the rock gold standard for me

[@setonhillstudios]

Absolutely!! 💯

[@Laura_Martin42]

My favorite Zepplin song!!

[@jeffreyflint6286]

Great reaction Steve. Been a fan since 1970!

[@setonhillstudios]

Glad you enjoyed it!! 🔥🔥

[@rudymorganti7155]

Thank your for the trip on memory lane. Zephead forever. 🤘 Greetings from Belgium 🇧🇪

[@garya7893]

The Song Remains the Same and the Rain Song together are my fav tracks from this concert Rock on man

[@Carolinafishingtales]

Steven, awesome video ! They are great ! If you'll listen to the studio version, where they all come in and do that run, listen closely, and you'll hear John do a quick click on the drum sticks and then they all cone in.

[@stuBdoc]

Saw LZ in Chicago in 1971, just before LZ IV was released, so we heard all of these songs before we heard the album. What a magical show!!

[@georgeditzel3504]

Listen to the studio track and you can hear a single stick click to bring in the riff. Once we discovered that we had the timing flawless.

[@jack-k6z7n]

MY DAD TOOK ME TO THIS SHOW I WAS ONLY 6 YEARS OLD.

[@holysmokes5817]

Let's GO!! 🍄🌲🍄💥✨🌈

[@bowtiefidenine]

Tea for one

[@roncreswell6843]

Oh hell yeah

[@PaulArnold-z1o]

Im gonna throw some love out to John Paul Jones killing it on bass like usual & who gets upstaged so often & hardly ever mentioned

[@jamesdamiano8894]

How Many Mire Times is one of my favorite tunes by them because it’s hit such a great groove. Thanks for pointing out the bass line. John Paul Jones was great and is often overlooked for the other three.

[@johnshannon9656]

Time signatures. Good.

[@mitchellbeston1033]

Great analysis.

[@setonhillstudios]

@@mitchellbeston1033 Thanks so much! Such a great tune! 🔥

[@mitchellbeston1033]

@@setonhillstudios I have heard other people with some musical experience state similar about Bonham playing behind the beat...it is noticeable in this song. Thanks for the reaction...i always enjoy your videos...is that what they are, videos? God i'm old. lol

[@M63Tod]

Watched a video about how bonzo had some jazz influence and that’s probably the inspiration to how his timing is so different.

[@MsAppassionata]

James Brown was also an inspiration.

[@Spudtaylor69]

You should check out John Farnham singing black dog as a sound check John ,his band and back up singers used this song as a warm up Amazing it was never used during a show

[@SO.CAL-D.Edwards]

"THE WARNING" All my life Zeppelin was my favorite band. I'm 65 now and I found a band that is worth my time. The band is called "THE WARNING" if I were you I would check these 3 sisters from Mexico out. 19,22, 24yrs old. All 3 sing(in English) brother this is a special band. The wall of sound is next level. Rock... Try "DUST TO DUST/DULL KNIVES (Cut better) LIVE AT THE PEPSI CENTER CDMX OR EVOLVE LIVE AT THE MTV VMA'S 2023.. your missing out.. "You have been warned" 🌎✌️

[@Carolinafishingtales]

Yes sir ! I agree 💯. The Warning is awesome !

[@sherryjoiner396]

Thanks for "the Warning"! Love their music. I had never heard of them. ❤

[@stevemee508]

The bit of timing i love is the 5/4 section on guitar. Bonzo continues with 4/4 till they catch up. Page was unsure when bonzo suggested but it gives the song a great broken back feel.b

[@brianmiller616]

Yah got to get the LED out🤘

[@vickithomas7976]

Seeing these guys sitting thru the tribute when Heart sang Stairway to Heaven is surreal

[@nikosalmpanis-ty3jt]

Black Sabbath,Led Zeppelin,Deep Purple the holy triad of rock music🤘

[@jaynethomas7380]

The time signatures of this song were even hard for Zeppelin. I'm not a musician but apparently their playing in different times that meet up every 12 beats??? Idk, something like that.😜

[@BarryOstle-o8z]

great reaction not to familiar with this song but what a tune i love it.

[@billtaylor3382]

The GOAT!

[@tjrivers]

Give LZ’s “Since I Been Loving You” live in the same concert…a true masterpiece, with a killer Page solo!

[@setonhillstudios]

Thank you so much! You’re awesome! 😁

[@adrieleferreira7629]

LED Zeppelin, Kiss,...❤❤ Love

[@billythebootlegger.4376]

Hello dude Regarding the time signature(s)..... It's all very polymorphic ❤ It's primarily 4/4 With snap back for Percy in 9/8 and quick stops 5/8 for abrupt emphasis..... It's a right smorgasbord 😅 Great reactions from ya 👍👍

[@daredevildaryl2645]

Can you imagine paying less than $10 to see this back in the day

[@DebbieParker-nf2ug]

I seen them in 1975 they a awesome band

[@RockinMamaT]

Let's Gooo! I saw Robert live in 88 in Toronto and Stevie Ray Vaughan opened up sooo good. Check out Dazed and Confused live same show it will blow your mind 😮 Trooper Here for a good time 😂Great reaction and Peace out Steven ☮️ ✌️ 🙏 BTW John's drum performance Moby Dick from this show is wild 😉

[@snakeinthegrass7443]

How Many More Times, live at the Royal Albert Hall, 1970. I like that show much better bc it's not spliced up like this one is for the movie. When Bonzo is going ham on the kit, the camera is right on him, or even behind him. The footage is so much better, imo. But hey, this is fire too. I won't hate on any Zep.

[@williamreiser3118]

Damn I was only 11 years old young man when that was filmed and of course had on vinyl and 8-track

[@Dan-zq5wt]

Check out live Achilles Last Stand from Knebworth. Maybe the greatest Bonzo ever!

[@neillenet291]

Good call. The drums are definitely not on the beat. John bonham always followed jimmy page. They had a weird symbiotic musical relationship.

[@Dan-zq5wt]

Totally symbiotic. Page often followed Bonzo. When you listen to Page play his riffs (like Rock n Roll same concert) his accents and phrasing are timed perfectly against the drums for maximum impact - against that cracking snare or heavy bass drum beat - so it sounds way more syncopated and locked than if you just played it the way you think it sounds or follow a transcription. Really really great guitarists and bands do Zeppelin covers - eg Van Halen, Satch, Paul Gilbert, Slash - all technically cleaner players than Page - and all of those covers miss the magic. That’s what makes Zeppelin so unique - that funky deep pocket. Plus, I think there’s so much focus on Page the lead player, overlooking his incredible rhythm playing which is so locked in, with great timing, fills, chord inversions etc. I agree with this great reactor that Zep is a 4 piece unit including Page.

[@Thesmokymountainman]

That pocket, that feel. In my mind I play just like Bonham! Sadly only in my mind. Look up “The Band Feel”. They are new and groove to the classic style of Zeppelin.

[@Dan-zq5wt]

1973 Jimmy Page might be the coolest dude who ever lived . . .

[@MarcLetourneau-t4x]

As a Drummer the ultimate number surely must be Moby Dick !!

[@sicotshit7068]

Bonham’s 15 to 20 minute solo of Moby Dick, live at Royal Albert Hall (1970).

[@alanknox9914]

As a drummer, you should check out APRIL WINE , I LIKE TO ROCK, LIVE HAMMERSMITH ODEON 1981, JERRY MERCER'S DRUMMING IS THUNDEROUS WITH SEEMLESS GREAT CONTROL, you'll know what I mean if you watch it! All the best

[@willyroussel3563]

JPJ wrote the riff on this song.

[@Rosedach]

Another good live band is Quicksilver Messenger Service.

[@eddielawson6653]

🤘👍👍🤘ed

[@rondickinson8741]

Entire Mass Square, Garden concert is on DVD Blu-ray plus it’s got a cold. The song remains the same the movie or less gives you lots of glimpses into their actual home life and the things they do you gotta check it out man John John bottoms got some hot rods and he shows them the top drag run Scenes from England just got just check it out. Don’t miss it. It’s a chance of a lifetime. bye for 25 bucks and the Blu-ray special edition is God the ocean live from Greg is one of the songs that doesn’t appear on the other DVD. I don’t believe it. Just gotta check that out and video to thank, you

[@wls64]

Hey good one bro! Do it if you want to see the best drum solo in history, watch led Zeppelin Moby Dick live, it's the one where John Bonham is wearing an orange tank top. I don't remember where they were on that show but it's the best ever. Cheers bro 👍

[@sicotshit7068]

At Royal Albert Hall (1970), it’s one you get better views of him playing, he played his solo over 200 times.

[@andrewplumb6544]

Always prompts confusion this one. Check out 11yo Yoyoka playing it. She plays Bonham exceptionally well and by the way she is covering an earlier 1972 live performance, no edit. She did not read at the time and being live and Bonham her ability to get inside the band is uncanny.

[@williamreiser3118]

Oh I recognize this song now Becca 2012 August until May 1 was a vocal performance major at GRCC the choir director could sing a cool falsetto of this song well one time he did that he did the first verse before I could answer with the second verse I did the second verse and I looked at him and said and that wasn't falsetto he looked at me and went show off

[@jokervienna6433]

I´m a drummer too, and for the groovy beat in a song, it is my opinion that especially the drummer and the bass player really need to work together. It doesn´t work with a methronome. Often the bass "drives" and the drums "hang" (sometimes it is the other way around). Just a little offbeat, we are talking milliseconds. That makes it groovy. There needs to be some "distance" in between, and there you go. Groovy! :)

[@setonhillstudios]

Great insight! Really appreciate it! 🤘🏻

[@jokervienna6433]

@@setonhillstudios just check out all the true pro´s out there, when they are playing live. James Brown and Prince are two of my favorites. The musicians they had are marvels, all of them. Clyde Stubblefield (drummed a lot for Mr Brown) is an extreme. But there are modern examples too, like Parov Stelar - Catgroove [Donauinselfest 2020]. The bass/bassline drives, and the drummer is milliseconds behind = groove. No, these are not reaction suggestions, just one way to improve the "groove". "Hang" or "drive". All the best!

[@bengazeley9730]

Check out Dread Zeppelin

[@donaldhillman4943]

can you react to 1916 by sabaton plz

[@mrmeerkat6055]

As a drummer it always sounds like Bonzo is hitting the snare drum out of time with the rest of the band not an easy song to play on the drums.

[@kriskammeraad3955]

Have you heard Moby Dick , Bonzo drum solo.

[@anthonyattard6726]

There is a reason bar bands don't cover this song.

[@mikeb36240]

Have you ever seen a two man band? How about a band with bass guitar lead? Royal Blood -"Lights Out" kzbin.info/www/bejne/kITdn6OvfJ52frssi=mDRJ2g8MQfp6t0Hh 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@setonhillstudios]

I haven’t! Appreciate the suggestion!

[@jerrydowney3096]

Man check out the red clay strays new band there's a s***

[@JeffRitchey-g2y]

Moby Dick