Dungeon Upgrade! What If Minecraft had a Dungeon Heart?

Upgraded Dungeons for Minecraft!
Minecraft needs new dungeons! These new dungeons have an arcane wall of force, and a new magic lockable block with rune keys!
Welcome to "What If?!" where I write custom, crazy mods for Minecraft testing out new, fun ideas.
Please leave a Like if you enjoyed!
Dungeon Heart Mod Download:
Looking for an amazing, friendly, well moderated survival server?
Join Season 5 of Titancraft vanilla server!
/ tangotek
Outro Music: Underwaterbeats - Delete
• Underwaterbeats - Delete!
My Patreon server is hosted by BuildCraftia!
The home of Fun Minecraft game types such as Destroy the Core, Slime Run, and Paintball! Check them out!
bcsn.us
─────────────────────────
Help support my channel
─────────────────────────
►Watch the whole "What If" series!
goo.gl/sPejcT
►Watch my Breaking Bytes series! ("What If" predecessor!)
bit.ly/P8VOfP
►Check out my Minecraft tutorials!
bit.ly/1bQx2WI
►Follow Me On Twitter
/ tangoteklp

[@SuperGamerCody2224]

If I could; I'd totally make a world with all of your "What if?" mods.

[@ejzeida3478]

Now that sounds like a good KZbin video. Similar to those "I put loads of mods into one world

[@lydierayn]

Im still waiting for more mods tho

[@SuperGamerCody2224]

@@ejzeida3478 no... Just an "if I could I would" And as it is; I can't because A; computer I use computer doesn't seem to like mods B; I lost my Minecraft account C; Even if the above didn't apply I've been (unvoluntarily) away from home for months and I heard said computer doesn't even work any more.

[@FlamingFatality]

So you have chosen...death

[@ejzeida3478]

@@SuperGamerCody2224 ik, I'm just saying someone should do that

[@cubfan]

Inside the chest of these dungeons you find a rare item, The Heart of the Dungeon. 5 Heart of the Dungeons + 3 Obisidian + 1 Nether Star = Anti Beacon. A Beacon that has negative effects including: Tier 1: Slowness (anti-speed), Mining Fatigue I (anti haste) Tier 2: Receptivity (anti resistance), Grounding (anti-jump) Tier 3: Weakness (anti Strength) Tier 4: Decay (anti regeneration) or level 2 of the previous effects. Awesome video tango! I hope that Mojang sees this and takes note of the many very good ideas about improve dungeons. They are drastically in need of improving.

[@samuelfefer]

Combine that item with a key drop chance on tier 4 dungeons to get in and out of a force shield on the end portal room and even more reasons to adventure here.

[@livedandletdie]

cubfan135, that would make your superhero stunts even harder, I'd approve of that change.

[@RhianKristen]

Perhaps I’m unimaginative, but why would you want something that harms you?

[@Player-hx1gs]

@@RhianKristen, Mining fatigue might be useful to defend your base against intruders on SMP servers. Some of the other effects might be interesting for minigames.

[@redmage777]

I always thought that an anti-beacon would be a variant of spawner and typically spawn as part of prebuild structures. Their main job would be to act like an elder guardian and prevent players from breaking the structure before completing it. Breaking one should destroy it so it can be used in common low-level structures without giving the player easy access to use this block. I also propose a "Builders Block" to be a possible debuff to prevent players from placing blocks in its area of influence. Now add this idea beside a mod like Recurrent Complex...

[@remaudy6409]

Who thinks he should bring What If’s these back

[@flashtime9927]

ME! ME! ME!

[@tamsuemomwife]

Yes

[@DavidKassa]

Yes please

[@iSyriux]

Yeah I think he got lazy after he entered Hermitcraft

[@wdrbumk]

ME!

[@MCEvans66]

What if ... it's called "Decked Out"

[@williamwester223]

Referencing to tangos game in hertitcraft season 7

[@loturzelrestaurant]

Another Epic Mod, but Tektopia is still 'waiting' also... ... ...

[@loturzelrestaurant]

Despite saying on his Mod-Videos they are serious suggestions most of the time, Mojang never gave a flip about it. 'Mojang should pay Tango' is not just a Meme or something like that - yet, they never did anything. Even his Customa Pathfinding System for Villagers, which is something that would 'invisibly' and 'objectively' improve the games efficience, was never adapted or even considered by Mojang. What a joke.

[@Xavire1603]

Some ideas for this dungeon mod: - Trapped rooms - Puzzle rooms (using redstone contraption) - Boss mobs that hold the arcane runes. - Reward for the dungeon hearth, the master spawner. A spawner that can be picked and choose between different type of mobs to spawn.

[@timewarpdrive77]

Of course the types of mobs that can be spawned should be limited.

[@sebastianjost]

@@timewarpdrive77 maybe it's a random mob from the dungeon the spawner came from. Higher level dungeons can have a chance to include several spawners

[@timewarpdrive77]

@@sebastianjost thats an idea

[@EmTom44]

I’d say a mini boss rather than a boss, bit too op for something that could be found in minutes

[@timewarpdrive77]

@@EmTom44 i'd wouldn't call it op

[@pvt.dicksimmons2225]

I think that the barriers themselves are a great reward. They need to be able to have the key removed by clicking on them though, maybe also by dispensers like with water and buckets. If you want a good reward, put in netherite as part of tier 4 tables.

[@daan626]

Joshua Mihail yeah then have you finally something that nobody except you can brake trough.for multiplayer it would be very handy

[@user-nk6dw5on7m]

Netherite isnt even in The game yet, and definetly not in that version

[@camhadland6227]

The barriers should be able to spread over larger distances for force-field doors and stuff as a reward! And there could be themed smaller chests in the wing rooms as well and- I better stop with my ideas or else this comment could get too long. This is awesome! Maybe a dispenser-and-hopper combo could create automatic door opening mechanisms?

[@TheGreatQbert]

With that, when a key is used on a barrier it needs to be linked to that block so it can not be used to unlock any with that symbol.

[@florbengorben7651]

Oh god that barrier idea would completely revolutionize Minecraft defense, especially in multiplayer pvp settings. I’m salivating thinking about the dispenser application

[@wurmschn3693]

I want this in vanilla D: Which rooms I would add: - Foundry - torture Chamber - Training room - Arena - dark Temple - Garrison - guard room - ritual room - Tavern - Casino - Prison Basicly every room from Dungeon Keeper and War for the Overworld

[@roccyrapture4684]

good idea

[@loturzelrestaurant]

Another Epic Mod, but Tektopia is still 'waiting' also... ... ...

[@SlasherTheFox.]

i still miss this :(

[@MrSnownah]

"What if "Tango was hired by Mojang as a dev?!

[@MonaFlowers__]

Cody Mangus Minecraft would be so much better

[@CyberSkuII]

Minecraft evolves to hytale

[@wilmas7535]

We would never hear his (manly) screams and love of boombooms and happy fun sause and chickens every again. We do not see enough of that as is these days! Please Moyang do NOT hire this man. We needs to see his vidz!

[@maximsavage]

He'd be forced to work more slowly on boring stuff, and you'd never see his amazing mods again.

[@timtam3730]

Like thats what they do at Media Molecule, the guys behing LBP

[@dlcoatn]

A single netherite ingot would be enough for me to fight my way through this. Lol

[@wanderinwolf3804]

I would say a Netherite ingot should be T4 Jackpot item. Very low chance to get one, but still a chance. and maybe at least 1 guaranteed ancient debris lol. I wouldn't care if I got anything else besides that.

[@theapexsurvivor9538]

@@wanderinwolf3804 90% chance for 1 debris would be a bit more balanced than getting a guaranteed one.

[@wanderinwolf3804]

@@theapexsurvivor9538 not really when you would think how rare t4 dungeons would be.

[@catalyst9955]

Idk diamonds are too easy to find so I think ancient debris should only spawn under ground in the nether so you actually have to put yourself in harms way to get it

[@johnking1058]

unless he amps up the mods powers to the point where netherite is useless. 😈

[@aqua3791]

Mojang: *Doesn't make better dungeons* Tango: *Fine, I'll do it myself*

[@simonbaxendale1083]

lol

[@nerotoxin0661]

*Petition to bring back this series* you don't have to like you can just comment

[@theultimatememelord5494]

Ayy

[@AlexClipsSFM]

Mojang: *Doesn't make a cave/Dungeon uptade* Tango Tek: "Fine, I'll do it myself"

[@animorph17]

Mojang: Makes a villager update. Tanko Tek: "You call that an update?! Fine. I'll do an even better one myself."

[@Ashadar_Resouley]

i have a saying "If you want something to exist that doesn't already exist you'll likely have to make it yourself"

[@Accuaro]

Even if Mojang did make a cave update, it'd be complete dog shit. Look at the mansion and the villiage that finally got an update after what seemed like a decade.

[@Sirdeathvids]

Tango Tek: launches Dungeon Keeper for ideas

[@jakemorrison1005]

ah yes

[@wamscag]

Just imagining the automation of mob farms that could occur with such a powerful spawning effect. A Tier 4 with 5 spawners that are going off very fast, OOF!

[@OMFGcataFAN1]

would that even be faster than the farms you can make today? dont think it'd even be close. it would be very good early on though.

[@wamscag]

Jhazzrun in comparison to the standard one mob spawner farms that we have in vanilla I would definitely say it would blow them out of the water in rates. If you are talking about a mob farm in which you created the dark spawning rooms to manually produce spawn rates and had red stone or a water stream dropping mobs to their death then no it wouldn’t be that beneficial. But early game, yes massively. Late game red stone, no. But you have to start somewhere.

[@Hyrum_Graff]

@@OMFGcataFAN1 If you could get lucky enough to have a Tier 4 with 4 witch spawners, that could be an insane redstone farm.

[@livedandletdie]

Hyrum_Graff, a regular 4 witch hut witch farm is good enough, or even better for that matter.

[@Hyrum_Graff]

@@livedandletdie Maybe, but I would need to try it to be sure; he did say that the 4 spawners are faster and the master spawner is also fairly fast.

[@crabbylobster8099]

Nobody let Mumbo download this mod, he'll make mob farms too powerful for our universe to handle

[@loturzelrestaurant]

Another Epic Mod, but Tektopia is still 'waiting' also... ... ...

[@ixelhaine]

Another useful addition, As long as the dungeon heart is active, it slows mining speeds so people will not as easily mine around the dungeon to the spawners.

[@SkyanUltra]

The loot table for the dungeons seem a bit scuffed, so here is my idea: -Tier 1 Dungeons Iron Ingots/Nuggets, Gold Ingots/Nuggets, Emeralds, Iron Armor/Weapons, Chain Armor, and rarely a Golden Apple. Also, a rare chance for the armor to be enchanted. -Tier 2 Dungeons Iron Ingots/Nuggets, Gold Ingots/Nuggets, Emeralds, Iron Armor/Weapons, Chain Armor, and most times a Golden Apple. Also, an uncommon chance for the armor to be enchanted. -Tier 3 Dungeons Iron Ingots/Nuggets, Gold Ingots/Nuggets, Diamonds, Emeralds, Iron Armor/Weapons, Diamond Armor/Weapons, a Golden Apple, sometimes a Golden Carrot, and very rarely an Enchanted Golden Apple. Also, an uncommon chance for the armor to be enchanted. -Tier 4 Dungeons Iron Ingots/Nuggets, Gold Ingots/Nuggets, Diamonds, Emeralds, Iron Armor/Weapons, Diamond Armor/Weapons, a couple of Golden Apples, a couple of Golden Carrots, and sometimes a Enchanted Golden Apple. Also, a common chance for the armor to be enchanted. Thank you so much for making these videos, I love the ideas you come up with! As a recommendation, what if Minecraft had classes? If you want an idea on how they would work, look at Terraria for ideas. New magic and summon weapons, New armor that boosts specific class stats, that you can get from various things like Spider items for a summoner set, Chain Armor could be for melee sets, and various other things.

[@youngboi3739]

Tier 4 dungeons should have netherite ingots and armour as loot

[@grimgrauman7650]

@@youngboi3739 to op i think, even Diamand armor is strong for an overwould dungeon

[@reeznaya6283]

TOO MUCH READINGGGGGG

[@Speed001]

@@reeznaya6283 My version is shorter, here. Loot Tables: (All this in addition to standard dungeon loot table. Better enchants for higher level dungeons.) Level 1 Dungeon: Leather armor. Stone tools. Some enchanted. Low chance of iron tools/armor/ingots. Level 2 Dungeon: Gold/chainmail and some Leather armor. Stone tools, some Iron tools. Some enchanted. Low chance of iron armor/shield/ingots, gold ingots. Level 3 Dungeon: Iron armor, some gold/chainmail armor. Iron tools. Shields w/custom patterns. Some enchanted. Low chance for a diamond and an enchanted book, gold ingots, emerald. Level 4 Dungeon: Iron armor. Iron tools, some diamond tools. Shields w/custom patterns. Some enchanted. Good chance for multiple diamonds and an enchanted book. Low chance for iron, gold, and emeralds.

[@tardisman602]

Get rid of golden carrots, those wouldn't be natural as they are never seen in dungeons before

[@Jebbuh]

"So today we are going to completely reinvent Minecraft dungeons." But Minecraft Dungeons hasn't even been released yet!

[@abbenylund]

okay this one is actually funny

[@blarg2429]

@@donaldchandler2520 Moderately funny blew air thru nose

[@IllagerCaptain]

Ya, and I think Tango should make a dungeon mod for 1.12.2. I wanna play with all his mods altogether.

[@CarpeDiem-et9jm]

@@IllagerCaptain I only managed to download two of them, where did you find the mummy one etc?

[@joltganda]

Well it has now, friend.

[@Goodgu3963]

Hey Tango, I know this series is a bit old now but I had an idea for a mod, and I can't think of anyone else who could or would tackle it. What if every time you changed biomes Minecraft would use an AI to generate a completely new biome. To make things reasonable you would probably have to use a terrain generator with presets the AI could mix together to create a massive variety of biomes. But you could also tell they AI the last biome the user was in, and have it generate something similar so you would never go straight from a desert into a frozen biome. It could also include different types of buildings for villages, different (maybe AI generated?) skins for villages and mobs, things that you could reasonably get an AI to generate without having to train a model specifically on generating Minecraft biomes. Either way have a good one Tango!

[@IchiroFuma]

If not already a thing, I would add a config that lets pack makes specify what the special loot item(s) is.

[@AlethaPrime]

As always, I love this and look forward to testing it out. I'd love to see different dungeon types with the different biomes. Maybe the loot could be themed based on that, where plains might have horse armor and saddles, mountains would have emeralds, oceans could have a heart of the sea. You could even include ender chests or enchanting tables as higher tier loot.

[@TangoTekLP]

Hey Aletha! Yea, biome specific loot is a fantastic idea. It encourages exploration even more!

[@jend9761]

I did not know how much I needed this until right now.

[@literalyfish4370]

i would make it the only place bats spawn constantly for ambiance and maybe there is a rare chance of it flying with one of those discs, it would be a fun little kick to the experience, great video as always

[@maddhatter1986]

After the dungeon heart is deactivated the surrounding spawners can then be deactivated by light levels so mob farms can still be built.

[@CamoCraft109]

Tango, you need to make a modpack with all your 'What If' mods in it. I would love to play something like that!

[@kaikloppers7307]

yeah

[@khaos2844]

He already did thst

[@f2progamer80]

@@khaos2844 only the Villager mod

[@zexa252]

How about , where when u unlock the chest there is the loot you get, plus a broken key piece , where when u go to enough dungeons , u can use this key to open the door of a *MEGA DUNGEON* . multiple floors , with each floor being more difficult than the last and at the top you'll find the owner of the dungeon The Lich king (since you mentioned an arcane lock this would make sense that someone made them and the Lich king is that someoen)

[@justicebrown1077]

I would love this, as he could incorperate this into an overhaul for the Fortress that has the portal to the End. The boss room would be just before the portal room, so you have to fight the Lich to get to the dragon. Then maybe he can overhaul the dragon too (dragon fight is someone bland imo). Im thinking maybe 4 of these dungeons to unlock the new version of the fortress?

[@zexa252]

@@justicebrown1077 Its a brilliant idea , tying the lich to the end (honestly now the end needs an update after the caves as it has become the second most bland place in minecraft), but the Lich King being connect to the end dragon is great , also 4 peices make sense ,plus I dont think the players are gonna like going through more than 4 dungeons to get an to a place they dont know about

[@Fillyourdarksoilwithlight]

Y'all keep saying Lich king making me think Arthas

[@demeincosmos1164]

Love mega dungeon idea but why just lich when can go random using set up with the neither or end portel format using the symbols blocks with each deffernt configuration to get a complete new dimension to battle from 30 block size slime mob to a maze dungeon with tons of traps or combos with range from 1 floor to endless amount

[@zexa252]

@@Fillyourdarksoilwithlight Actually when someone says Lich King I think of Acererak form Tomb of annihilation (its Dungeons and Dragons if u dont know)

[@RenanMsV_YT]

You know the next mod will be huge when he takes more than a year to make it.

[@mcwithshift]

tektopia s2???

[@MrMooEatsRocks]

2 years now

[@Healthandwealth9422]

Ok is is actually making a new mod?

[@RenanMsV_YT]

making a new minecraft at this point

[@voltr3d569]

What If?? These All Mods Were Actually In The Game

[@Jaydee-wd7wr]

Wouter Jansen, and Tango wouldn’t have a series anymore. Also how is coming up with original ideas instead of copying some KZbinr lazy....

[@theshadowking3198]

Minecraft isn’t lazy it just doesn’t want to make the game to complex or to diffrent from the original for older players

[@jamesmilesassassin4179]

I'd cry with tears of joy

[@jamesmilesassassin4179]

@@Jaydee-wd7wr hire the genius behind the KZbin

[@abdulazez3074]

Wouter Jansen mojang is not dumb they know what to do don’t worry

[@Ella-bm2xt]

How about making a tutorial on creating a mod (i know that there are many tutorials out their but your vid is way more intersting and easy to comprehend) or in every what if videos you make show us what your doing behind the scene .....

[@samuelfefer]

Upvote

[@yokonamigaara]

If you look waaay back on his channel, before What If he used to do a similar series called Breaking Bytes, and the first couple eps of that do show some of the coding/behind work!

[@cobrasrock]

As a modder I can say that knowledge of java is a necessity. If you are in school take the programming classes, if your school doesn't offer them or you are out of school there are plenty of places to learn Java online for free. Once you have your knowledge of java you can choose your api(forge or fabric) and then read the documentation and you will be off to modding. It's not really possible for tango to make a series on how to make mods like his. It requires hundreds of hours of learning and programming to get to his level.

[@Ella-bm2xt]

@@cobrasrock iam studying on my own

[@beepbitfutures]

@@Ella-bm2xt keep learning then, you just need to get good and learn the forge api

[@amateurishauthor2202]

"What if Minecraft dungeons had a dungeon heart?" you mean like.... Dungeon Keeper Dungeon heart?

[@TangoTekLP]

Precisely

[@valdirbruxeljunior]

Well, the piglins sure love some gold.

[@wanderingmadman558]

I was thinking the same thing... Dungeon Keeper.

[@TwistedChungus]

I wish. Imagine him using the base of that Villager mod to do a Dungeon Keeper mod...

[@non-haereticicoalition8392]

What if the nether had a soul sand worm that breathed fire? What if glowsquid dropped bioluminescence? What if zombies had more variations? What if Minecraft had stealth mechanics? What if Minecraft could become an RTS with a magic staff? Just a few ideas

[@username2639]

I'm sooo glad you came out with another mod video. I love them bc there so in depth and perfectly nice, but you haven't made much of them(I'm assuming bc each project takes forever) :)

[@HelloIAmAnExist]

Unique item: an enchanted book that increases a specific enchant by one (for example: sharpness 6 prot 5 and that sorts of stuff) the idea isn't mine but the following is: it can only work on a random specific item from boots to netherite hoes

[@wanderinwolf3804]

netherite boats and hoes

[@st4ndg4mes87]

@@wanderinwolf3804 netherite diorite

[@TheOneAndOnlyPookster]

I love this series so much!

[@OWNEDGAMINGwasd]

I didn't knew the were called dungeons , i was calling them spawners room

[@wndrman5444]

Please we need another episode of the “What If” series plz

[@saltyghast4037]

"What If?"is back!

[@The_Fat_Controller]

As much as I love HC. I’ve missed these

[@ejzeida3478]

Same here

[@MihoFroggySMP]

Yeah

[@baguetteboy5466]

I really like this! It makes dungeons much harder, and good gear can only get you so far. This feels pretty vanilla-y, too.

[@icotica921]

Back at it again my friend! I love your vids!

[@erinkarp6317]

Other than the dungeon heart, this feels very vanilla. Nice.

[@DeweyVladimir1761]

"It is payday!" "A minion is angry because it hasn't been paid!" "Your gold reserves are running low."

[@valdirbruxeljunior]

Dewey1761 I was looking for a dungeon keeper in the comments. Glad I found one

[@gremlinfifty2308]

Dungeon keeper?

[@adambalintszucsi]

You could combo it with tech topia like there would be randomly appearing dungeons in which new creatures spawn to attack the vilages and you could use those barriers to fortify the walls but necromancers or magicians would be able to break it and stuff like that :D

[@mistersiemsen8090]

Tango, you never cease to amaze with these!

[@jackh3mmerjack]

A new what if! Huzzah!

[@adrazuel]

your dungeon heart is under attack!

[@nandimoozle703]

Really love stuff like this that takes base Minecraft and just upgrades it to a better experience in general

[@wermaus]

randomly generate 1 or 2 side rooms that can branch off any of the outside rooms adjacent to them horizontally or even vertically that are their own isolated little challenges/loot areas like the old dungeons almost.

[@JH-gg8je]

Hey can the next “what if video” can be of a better end city or a better abandon mine ?

[@alexhanuscheck8591]

i love this series!!!!! amazing mod tango. I guess you simply just did it again

[@matthewfichter5549]

What an easy concept for Minecraft to implement. Very creative idea. Thanks!

[@veronicashekochikhin7509]

Please add more what if videos!! I really enjoy them and hope Minecraft will one day include them!

[@arstov7697]

I really like your mods!

[@virginlungs420x]

I think there should be lore here in some form. Maybe a new block of stone bricks with some ancient writing in scripted on it in minecraft language. Just feels like of this was added it would feel a bit more mojang and less modded Also those force fields look cool

[@sebastianjost]

Maybe the language from the enchanting table as runes like it was on chiseled sandstone.

[@epicjulian99]

A couple of ideas I have for this mod is to: A. Create a negative effect of some-sort on the Arcane Barriers if you run into them (even as simple as Knockback) B. Use similar systems that are used here, and apply them as dungeons in the Nether and End as well with different loot tables Love the concept here :D

[@BinLox]

I'd like to make a mod with you - a living biome that is it's own boss. Rooms that branch off one big "airway" down are its organs. You have to use an axe for flesh blocks, with its heart requiring a diamond or netherite axe to chop up. Stomach acid, leeches, rot, and sphincter-muscle doors. I've got a lot more written down, but I'll keep it to this. I also do textures, still and animated. Cheers!

[@igricRBX]

Tango: "This new block can't be blown up by TNT" *angry ilmango and world eater noises* Btw, check out yt channel Opisek, he's doing some magic with redstone.

[@jasonlovesdoggo]

IDEA: in the center of the Teir 4 dungeon there will be a netherite anvil thats nearly unbreakable and will only use HALF of what a vanilla anvil uses

[@machadeon7743]

I wouldn't make it unbreakable, just more durable. That way it's not a one-and-done reward

[@jasonlovesdoggo]

@@machadeon7743 ok nearly unbreakable

[@jamespitts8068]

Here’s an idea - For each of your mods, you introduce a special item you can access by completing a certain task, for this mod, it would be defeating the dungeon, for your villager mod, it could be getting one of every villager type, for the necromancer, it could be defeat a max level one, and for the ogre, it could be the ogre eye drop you get from defeating him. Combining each of these items with a beacon will give you a dimensional beacon which will unlock new abilities that cannot be accessed anywhere else that have a lot more power than a regular beacon. Speed IV Strength IV Peace IV (Makes all mobs within its radius peaceful) Controller IV (allows you to control weather + day cycles) This would be very powerful, and it’s range would vary depending on how big the pyramid you built is.

[@TheMadRatKing]

I’ve been waiting for so long to see another post from Tango and I’m happy with this Next thing I’m waiting for is a jungle temple upgrade

[@that_filmguy]

"Welcome back to What If, a series where I..." remind you of just how bad mojang's official game updates are! This mod looks epic! I can't wait to try it out... but honestly, the dungeon is awesome and all, but I just wanna see how awesome of a security system can be made with the force-field combobulator thing.... (goes back to watch what it was actually called. Pls hold) Arcane Locks!! You never cease to amaze, Tango! Awesome work as always!!

[@SkyanUltra]

be glad they even update this game at all and support modding unlike some other scummy companies

[@ohthenoises]

I laughed, gg filmguy

[@timewarpdrive77]

@@SkyanUltra "support modding" eh?

[@SkyanUltra]

@@timewarpdrive77 minecraft bedrock has had the addition of addons that allows for players to create what are essentially mods. they don't try to take down modifications of the game itself and support it by providing some tools. they aren't like nintendo, who take down modifications and fanmade projects related to any of their games.

[@that_filmguy]

@@SkyanUltra Truth!! The "bad... official game updates" is just my running joke at this point. I appreciate the updates to the game, and the work Mojang puts in, but when you know what vanilla MC can do, and then the potential that quality mods like this one adds, its disheartening to see "new features" be added to the official game that in reality is just a "hey, we added 4 new versions of the zombie we all know and love". The game can be so much more than it is, and the mods highlight that... its just sad to see the same running theme in vanilla updates of "its a re-textured "

[@Hunnter2k3]

I love the idea of being able to make these arcane walls useful in your own builds. Being able to control them using redstone would be nice, face a dispenser in to it, it will suck or dispense the rune key. One thing I wonder though, they could get rid of spawners entirely now they have 3D biomes. We can go full-on NUTS with dungeons of various ideas similar to the types you see in Terraria. I look forward to future updates that take advantage of this. 3D biomes seriously open the game up. Whether this will be the end of the spawner or not is up to time. I doubt they will add the crazy levels of progression Terraria has, where you can progressively access more regions of the map locked away by tougher blocks your picks can't break. They'll stick with the "everything is here, go for it, your death" approach which is where this idea really shines since it takes the basic dungeon and makes it actually harder.

[@drakardmexigun7280]

Kris Johnstone or instead of redstone the gate opens with proximity of the key when a player carries it.

[@Kyrbi0]

This is a great idea &, even better, well-implemented

[@armoredcf3536]

Ok, heres some changes id add: A. Possibly a boss you have to defeat to unlock the dungeon heart(dungeon guardian, corrupt golem, etc) B. possible another ring of rooms around it? (even higher tiers) C.More random generation(heart isnt always in middle, two spawners beside each other, etc) D.*MAKE ALL MODS IN WHAT IF COMPATIBLE WITH EACH OTHER!!!!!!!!*

[@LuxrayLloyd]

YAY! I Loved This Series!

[@cliff9291]

It would be cool if they even added multiple Spawners in the rooms

[@attackofthehog]

Pretty neat! I think it would be cool to have stairway rooms and various levels of the dungeons to make them feel larger and more sprawling. Maybe even add a dungeon type that only spawns illagers as a sort of "bandit hideout". Maybe one of the rooms for that could even be a "necromancer room" where there is an illager capable of summoning skeletons and zombies, and guarded by hostile iron golums. Lots of potential to go a lot of different ways!

[@ASMR_News]

I'd include a boss in one of the spawn rooms per a dungeon, like a necromancer for the zombie and skeleton spawner, a queen spider for the spider nest, a warlock for the witches, etc etc. Someone who's "in charge" of the dungeon. I'd also include some height variation to break up more lines of sight.

[@makanivalur]

Fantastic video! This looks so good!

[@rmdcade1717]

Maybe make the "ignore light" mechanic a toggle, or have some way to turn it off in-game? That way you can keep the spawners and build farms without being constantly attacked.

[@sebastianjost]

Maybe make them like blaze spawners: Requiring light level 13 or 14 to prevent spawning.

[@9dash]

Sebastian Jost the whole point is that it is hard to use them.

[@PrincessNybor]

Anyone else notice how Minecraft just announced Tango’s idea today? So that’s neat. 😂❤

[@Ginjaninja0051]

Tango, You're amazing! this is exactly the content the vanilaa game needs. granted maybe not ALL dungeons should make the change, but yes a few of these scattered would be AWESOME gameplay, even if it means we "despawn" a bit more. :-) more happy fun sauce next time!

[@MadManiacGamer]

I really like the concept but If Mojang did something like this it’s very low that they would let the player uptain such a powerful block like the force field block with out creative mode or commands. It would be like getting bedrock or the end portal frames in survival mode. Other then that it seems like something Mojang would create or very similar.

[@livedandletdie]

Nah, at 4 per dungeon, you can't really expect to think that's OP, just have the dungeons at the same shitty rarity as they are now, I mean, I've been playing on and off for 11 years and I've only come across dungeons once the last 5 years. Before that they were everywhere, but now they are nigh non-existent so it doesn't really matter, Woodland mansions are more common than dungeons...

[@Lyarrah]

@@livedandletdie idk what version you're playing on or how much exploring you do, but I probably come across a dungeon every 1.5-2 hours of digging or caving... they're still pretty common, you just seem to be having bad luck.

[@magnusanderson6681]

@@livedandletdie I have the same issue, but then again I almost never go caving, preferring to strip mine (I played for over a year on a server and didn't find a single dungeon for example). I speedran the game a couple of times the other day, and found two dungeons in two attempts, so I think the issue is more how I play than their existing.

[@TristenLawson]

@@magnusanderson6681 Some servers disable stuff like dungeons, more likely someonw got there before you and took all the stuff (chests, mossy cobble, broke spawner)

[@magnusanderson6681]

@@TristenLawson It wasn't a big server. I just never went caving.

[@siyacer]

Well, Valentine's day would be a lot scarier

[@otterfox488]

I’m already Sans Undertale 😳

[@ClockworkGearhead]

The best thing to add to dungeons, to get people to go there, is primarily cosmetic blocks. One of the reasons people explored strongholds was for the stone brick block before they could be crafted. After that? Maybe a spell item, or a new enchantment you can put on, exclusive to those dungeons, since it's "loot."

[@kindleow]

I had the idea of creating some sort of overhaul to dungeons too but I absolutely really love your take and I'm glad this video exists, because this is truly the start of what I think dungeons should be changed too. I think there should be all kinds of different types of dungeons with different challenges though, the hard part is giving players restrictions in a puzzle because a lot of objectives can be nullified due to players being able to break blocks and solve problems in ways that face you to think out of the box, so I think a design like this is a great start, because a player can't just say, dig around all the obstacles and get the loot, said obstacles need to be faced in order for the reward to be offered. The protective box prevents players from finding a sneaky way to the loot and avoiding the problem, and I also really love the idea with how the spawners works. I think it's really hard to come up with puzzles and solid linear solutions to puzzles in a game like Minecraft because you have so many more options in how you can interact with the world and the environment in comparison to most games, so props for coming up with a good solution to a problem this game's had for a really long time; lack of challenge/puzzles in generated structures/ in general from exploring the world. (Not saying Minecraft can't be challenging, I just think better alternatives like this video to the pre-existing ideas already integrated into the game should be welcomed and appreciated) :) I'd love a dungeon like mechanic similar to BOTW where perhaps you find little tiny "shrines" that perhaps either enter you in to some sort of new type "dimension", being that just a small tiny little realm where the dungeon/puzzle/challenge exists, but there's no other blocks around it other than maybe bedrock or something, and there's a linear entrance and exit to the dungeon/shrine, with no easy access to the loot until the challenge has been completed. You'd have to prepare yourself for truly anything before even attempting to enter, because you would have no idea weather or not it would be some sort of combat based challenge, some sort of maybe flying or shooting type precision puzzle, some sort of redstone or "game knowledge" testing puzzle (a puzzle that requires knowledge of a obscure or not commonly known mechanic or something like that) I don't know if I even fully like that idea, but I also think there's gotta be a way to introduce interesting puzzles that players have to think of outside the box solutions for, rather than just say fighting some mobs, getting a key and so on. I'm not saying I don't like this concept, I just think it could potentially be expanded on in a lot of different ways! Kinda sad a lot of the simple aspects of Minecraft like dungeons have been untouched for so long, with no significant change even though it's so desperately needed.

[@andrewthefoxxd2913]

The mobs that would have keys could be something like mini bosses, they would be random mobs who would have names and with that surnames based of what ability they have, like "Zombo the Poisoned" which would throw poison, or "Skell the Slow" where he would be also slow but he would slow you also and such other mobs.

[@CaableGuy]

hey those rooms look pretty good :P

[@camerongray7767]

The best series on KZbin is back!

[@captainbdawg8613]

This....MUST be a vanilla feature!! Awesome work!!

[@SVoided]

This is amazing I need this great job Tango Mojang should hire you for new updates

[@andrej8413]

1:40 quite a nice shape with those lines, they remind me of something

[@edred4050]

Damn it

[@ShockNameBlast]

Hilte r

[@toreadum8ass]

Ah yes, the windmill of friendship and tolerance.

[@chaosincarnate7304]

AHAHA LOOK GUYS HE MEANT THE FUNNY BAD SYMBOL, THE MUSTACHE MAN HEHEHAHAHA

[@ShockNameBlast]

@@chaosincarnate7304 k

[@javierowo]

OHHH those arcane locks look so damn cool! Tbh this looks in line with vanilla amd it heavily needs it

[@deoxysman9854]

What if all evil mobs could be turned good? As in with a "Mob Defiance Rune", just right click to throw it at an evil mob and it becomes good. But zombies and skeletons still burn in sunlight unless given a special new potion called 'ZS Burn Resistant Potion'.

[@johnland8372]

I love it perhaps maybe make some lava dungeons or magical dungeons!!!

[@tungstendioxide3055]

But you didn't watch it. It only been a minute

[@sirkilium8549]

@@tungstendioxide3055 KZbin doesn't work like that

[@mitthrawnuruodo7517]

Grian has also Ideas for new Dungeons .

[@officialcringe-3724]

Ok but this is Tango Tek not Grian

[@mitthrawnuruodo7517]

@@officialcringe-3724 But he could and should also do a mod about grians dunegons.

[@kfcbully9842]

Great job, keep doing these "what if" videos there great

[@deon6045]

Loot ideas: -Equipment with altered base stats, such as +1 or -1 on damage, armor, toughness, w/e. (Altered Durability too, if possible) -Legendary, unbreakable, golden items -Potion arrows -Potions -Slime balls/blocks -Otherwise-useless, enchanted "trophy" items relating to the mobs of that dungeon, such as an enchanted feather as a callback to zombies in the past. -Custom map art that isn't connected to the layout of the world? I tried to come up with stuff that wouldn't require more modding.

[@Cona-vh7vi]

Damn bro what happened to the what if series

[@joners45]

1:42 my Dude over here drawing Swastikas

[@rock1soul]

Man, your what if additions to the game should become an update (probably with the villagers one an optional feature) I love your ideas and the fact that they are completed features. Keep up the good work man, cheers.

[@thebulletbot3329]

I suggest also adding an arcane support block, that connects to nearby arcane locks, and basically allows for barrier generation without the need of already unlocked arcane locks. this way, players can use the arcane locks and supporter blocks to make their own barriers.

[@bigboyroblox860]

"What if?" all his mods worked together in minecraft 1.15?

[@Komatic5]

"no" -Mojang, 2020

[@mossbossyea1494]

Its really cool. Grian also made a video of his idea for updating the dungeons

[@ZizZap4]

I think classic RPG-style loot could be a lot of fun. New tools, weapons, or magical artifacts to play with. -Spider’s Fang Dagger: a lower-damage melee weapon that gives enemies a weak poison effect. Could make a good secondary weapon. Cannot be enchanted via enchanting table, but can have enchantments placed on it via an anvil. -Bludgeoner’s Shield: a more defensive shield that can also be used as an effective (enough) weapon. Given the heavier build of the shield and the dual-use nature it also has a higher durability than regular shields. -Ancient Halberd: a melee weapon with more range than a basic sword or axe. While it has good damage and can even skewer multiple enemies, it’s charged-up, similar to a trident (just without the throw). Can be enchanted! -Crown of Blindness: a low-defense helmet that has a chance of blinding nearby enemies temporarily while worn. Can’t be enchanted, but can have enchantments applied via an anvil. -Totem of Undying: Yeah, it’s vanilla, but it fits the theme. -Phantom Blade: A sword with decent damage with a charge attack that, when released, performs a spin-slash-attack, damaging all nearby enemies and knocking them back. Can be enchanted. -Enchanted Quiver: Finally bringing back the unused Quiver. By holding and “using” the quiver you open its inventory, which is limited storage for arrows (normal or tipped) or other ammo (fireworks). By having the quiver in your inventory, your bow or crossbow will draw on the arrows inside. (Optional: A quiver can also be put inside a dispenser, allowing the dispenser to draw on the quiver’s arrows.) -Pacifist’s Tunic: a low-defense torso armor piece. While worn, hostile mobs will become neutral mobs, only attacking once provoked. Cannot be enchanted. -Redstone Automaton: A pet! “Spawning” it (like using a spawn egg) will automatically affiliate it with the player who spawned it. It looks a bit like an armor stand with a dispenser for a head, but it’s small - about one block tall. It has a dispenser for a head and will shoot out whatever you feel like giving it as a projectile (this includes junk items, though they may not do as much). It can die, in which case it drops whatever items it may have along with a broken automaton. Crafting the broken automaton with iron bars and redstone blocks will return it to its former glory, letting you use it once again. -(Optional one, mainly because it’s not really useful at that point of the game) Void Pouch: A small, dark green sack. Right-clicking while holding it opens an inventory with a single slot. The void pouch is essentially a hopper into your ender chest. Putting an item or a stack into the pouch will remove it from you and place it in your ender chest inventory. If the chest is full, the item will remain in the pouch slot until you close the pouch interface, at which point it returns to your inventory (or is dropped on the ground if your inv. is full).

[@harbl99]

What if Minecraft had a dungeon heart? "You need to build a lair for your creatures." [slaps Imps with merry abandon]

[@Aeonsteel]

Man I miss 'What If?!'.

[@legendaryswordsman2279]

Same, I absolutely loved his Tek Topia series but it looks like he hasn’t done anything like that in a long while, I get it tho, it’s hard to come up with ideas like that, let alone execute them well

[@onigirinyaa6854]

Combining all of Tango's mods make an incredible dungeon crawler,open world, sim game.

[@ammazer1229]

“What If Tango brought this series back?”