Dutch and Mary-Beth's Affair Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2)

[@heatheryyy]

I genuinely felt badly for Molly. To me, Dutch used his charms on her and sucked her in because she was beautiful, exotic, and a romantic in all likelihood (see her conversaion with Abigail, she can't admit to herself that Dutch doesn't love her, she's totally blinded by her feelings for him). Her paranoia is what led to her undoing, she had intense feelings for Dutch and he never reciprocated them, truly. We know she wasn't the rat, she was just trying to hurt Dutch in a way she thought would be close to the way he hurt her, and she died for it. Tragic.

[@cameronanderson3304]

Ask Abigail.

[@colleencrews9739]

She was simply murdered in cold blood, after having her mind stripped by manipulation. He just got bored of her and moved onto a younger girl.

[@X_The_Quiet_Wolf_X]

People are quick to dislike her due to her distance towards other members of the gang and not pulling her weight around, like helping with chores. Molly came from a wealthy family, she went to the USA in search of adventure, as she grew bored of her life in Ireland. Dutch charmed her and she fell for it. I believe that was the adventure she was looking for, riding with outlaws, being in danger and having a relationship with one of them, in that case, the leader. She knew her old life was forfeit, she had slept with a man out of wedlock, in those times that was a big deal, I believe she expected Dutch would be with her forever and genuinely love her. Of course, Dutch being Dutch, he grew bored of her and was trying to charm Mary-Beth. Molly was miserable because she was trapped, she couldn't go back to her family, Dutch just used her and she felt like the rest of the gang hated her. She is a tragic character in my opinion. I think she knew telling Dutch she ratted the gang out would get her killed, I think she saw that as the only way out.

[@Kenny1999tra]

​@@X_The_Quiet_Wolf_X possibly, being someone that had found themselves in situations just like that, that's real, constant manipulation does strip everything away, litterally everything to the point people victimized by another are self sabotaging, it truly is one of the hardest things to come back from

[@lib.777]

So true couldn’t of said it better

[@samuelrodrigues5616]

4:29 Dutch flirting with Mary Beth Charles and Arthur: 👀

[@victinho09ferro]

And the player

[@Thaicatlove]

Mary-Beth takes the flirting with a grain of salt. Very classy. Very kind of her.

[@tilaquilahell]

😂😂😂

[@jackiecooper9439]

Other PPL having pvt conversations Arthur: 👁️ 👃 👁️

[@X_The_Quiet_Wolf_X]

Arthur hears people having conversations that don't concern him: 🏃🏃🏃

[@dastemplar9681]

Arthur: Okay, see you later then.

[@SnobbyBird_]

🧍🏻‍♂️

[@AlexGTAgamer]

I always felt so bad for Molly in every playthrough. The fact that we couldn’t even play cards, or have some side activity with Molly, made her feel even more distant and isolated from the rest of the gang.

[@leshurlementsdelacave9563]

There is a poem written by Molly we can foind in the camp. Pasted here : I was a girl - until your call Commanded me to cross the sea. I've nothing left. I gave you all. My darling Liffey was so small. Your land and love are vast and free. I was a girl until your call. You stood so strong, and dark and tall. You stole the heartbeat out of me. I've nothing left. I gave you all. Your lips enchant, your eyes enthrall, Your empire is of ecstasy. I was a girl until your call. Your parasites and lackeys crawl, Mocking a love they dare not see. I've nothing left. I gave you all. I sit in solitude and scrawl These wretched words, and wait for thee. I was a girl until your call. I've nothing left. I gave you all.

[@RotValkyrie]

That fact you remember the full poem is goated

[@kingartison]

I read that I’m on my 3rd or 4th play and I thought damn she’s losing it and nobody can help her

[@TheOceanBearer]

I remember first reading that and being reduced to a puddle of tears. I was sobbing and screaming, and I had to stop playing for years. Dutch really grinds my gears. It was just too much for me to bear. I hate Dutch and how he treated Molly with a burning passion, I could just tear him apart with my bear hands. Yes, you read that right, bear hands.

[@michalurbanful]

She gave him all she had ...

[@cristianiiv6418]

​@@RotValkyrieit is a powerful poem

[@whatscout78]

the way charles looks at dutch at 4:30 is fucking me up

[@44oinky]

💀💀💀💀💀💀💀

[@Antttttiiiiii]

😂

[@freyamorris622]

🤣🤣🤣🤣 I can’t stop laughing

[@luko177]

Bro said 🗿

[@You_Kitten_Me]

💀💀💀💀​@@luko177

[@topmansquad9558]

many people don't notice this, but Dutch is actually a serial groomer lmao. He groomed Arthur and John to become Criminals. He was with Ms. Grimshaw, then left her for Molly because Molly was young, innocent and Naive. Now he's doing the same with Molly, where now she's growing older, he wants to drop her for Mary Beth, who is also young, innocent and Naive.

[@Thaicatlove]

Yeah, that's right. He likes to groom girls. I think there would be more of that, if we saw into Dutch's past.

[@thesilentassassin1167]

Dutch was in Mid 40s and Mary Beth was in early 20s if I am not wrong

[@lukeofmary5704]

Molly was 22, Mary Beth 21.

[@topmansquad9558]

@@lukeofmary5704 Molly is somewhere between mid 30s, to late 20s, Mary Beth is somewhere between Mid 20s and early 20s. Meanwhile Dutch is damn near 50

[@lukeofmary5704]

@@topmansquad9558 what?? Sorry bro but is molly is mid 20, 22 or 25

[@neutrallynonsensical3477]

Wouldn’t really call if an ‘affair’ & more Dutch’s wishful thinking. I don’t think Mary-Beth was particularly interested in Dutch romantically. Flattered maybe, but mainly put in a tricky situation, considering if she rejected his advances he could have kicked her out / the gang was her first proper family. But super interesting video! I’ve played it through 3 times & have missed most of these interactions.

[@cocob0l0]

It wasn’t an affair at all since she literally never reciprocated any feelings for Dutch. Clickbait as always

[@lynette50]

She is seen leaving Dutch's tent at Beaver Hollow in her underwear. And if you read her notebook and story that she is writing. Her heroine loves a leader.

[@michalurbanful]

@@cocob0l0 First - You are wrong. Second - It is not a clickbait as always, Strange Man's videos are top notch.

[@cocob0l0]

@@lynette50 Characters walk around in their undergarments early in the morning or late at night. That doesn’t PROVE anything. She also very clearly had a crush on Arthur (a leader type), and had feelings for Kieran but there is NOTHING to suggest that she ever reciprocated Dutch’s creepy feelings for her. It was very clearly one-sided and therefore NOT an affair.

[@cocob0l0]

@@michalurbanful Just claims I’m wrong but doesn’t bother to explain why. Typical.

[@angrybiker]

The fact that all of this dialogue is easily missable by walking away / rushing through the game is crazy. Thanks to RDR2, I stop to listen to all the rando NPC conversations in whatever game I'm going through, although few can hold a candle to the world Rockstar created here

[@pizzazombie5209]

Agreed. I’m so many ways, this game ruined other games for me. It sets the bar so high for background NPC, dialogue.

[@sleepy0strawberry]

Molly is one of those 'how fucked up and sad can we make their story?' characters

[@afghantroop]

no, she's just desperate and annoying

[@Wingu1982]

To be honest idk why dutch would tap that like mary beth i understand but molly...

[@stephendavis6267]

Molly is actually one of my favourite characters in RDR2, and it really bothers me that she is the one gang member we do not get an actual storyline/mission with. She comes off as haughty but she is truly a broken woman, blinded by love and adulation for this charismatic man who used her and tossed her aside, like he does with everyone else in his orbit.

[@pizzazombie5209]

Agreed. She’s the first character to see Dutch for what he truly is, putting himself before his family. It’s a shame that we can’t spend more time with her.

[@stvvrrz]

I feel like rockstar purposefully gave us no mission with her just to make her death more depressing. There was one that started out with her, but I think it ended up turning into an uncle mission which is so disappointing, I just wanted to help her, and uncle's mission literally turned to sh*t! :(

[@NaturalBornLoserrrr]

molly is one of my favourite characters too! i researched the fuck out of her & whatever we knew about her story and life after my first play through. i found her so interesting and i felt so bad for her :(

[@X_The_Quiet_Wolf_X]

She was supposed to be in the Gilded Cage. People found an outfit she was going to wear and she would help finding clues about Cornwall. Sadly, her part in that mission was removed.

[@Tristan_Shuler]

What’s even sadder is she doesn’t get a grave like everyone else that died. Burned one pit outside of camp and the ashes scattered to the wind.

[@InSpades0]

I wouldnt call it an affair, tho Dutch definitely flirts with marybeth i dont think marybeth fully realizes or at the very least isnt interested. I do believe that this is one of Dutchs flaws first it was Susan, then annabelle, then molly. I wouldnt be surprised that if annabelle hadnt died tragically Dutch wouldve wandered over to molly or a younger woman anyway. I think her death definitely made Dutch more attached to the idea of her than he wouldve been otherwise.

[@Thaicatlove]

Exactly!

[@thesilentassassin1167]

Dutch probably didn’t even loved Annabelle, just used her death as a excuse to keep feuding with Colm O Driscoll

[@cocob0l0]

@@InSpades0 Thank you! She never actually shows that she reciprocated his (very creepy) feelings towards her. I was getting flamed under another comment for point this out lol.

[@samredmond5196]

Molly was a kind soul just led astray, I always thought it’s often forgotten just how sad her story was. I think this video brings it to light very well. Another fantastic watch

[@thesilentassassin1167]

When we think about it, she’s probably the Only Non Criminal in the gang lol, maybe beside Revered, I don’t remember her doing anything

[@ItsYaBoi-iy5fi]

I don’t think Dutch loved either of them, he just wanted them to be infatuated with him and to desire him at the same time and loved to see someone literally go insane for his attention, but that comes with a consequence when Molly dies

[@jeffk.9075]

He didn't love any of them. He loved Annabelle.

[@septarria]

@@jeffk.9075 Annabelle didn't live long enough to be discarded, so she became some sort of symbol for Dutch of his noble heart. But even Colm, while talking with Dutch (who just said 'i liked Annabelle') said that he was womanizer. Annabelle wouldn't be there for long anyway.

[@jeffk.9075]

@@septarria That's a good point. Was Dutch always incapable of real love you think?

[@septarria]

@@jeffk.9075 it's hard to tell to be honest, but even if he was able to love others, he definetely always put love for Himself in the first place, even at the expense of others and far above them. That's what i think at least.

[@_CrissoN]

The best part about this game is how you could make whole DLCs about every gang member because of how rich their stories are. Honestly the GOAT when it comes to video games. A work of art.

[@Vincent-ev4qe]

Yeah but we know that won't happen considering Rockstar don't love Rdr as much as they love GTA

[@virtuoseanderzigarre6392]

They love money

[@aylafree3881]

It is very sad. Molly was young, came from a well off family and from the sounds of it was a city girl who had everything she wanted. Then Dutch charmed her and she gave up her whole life to be with a guy old enough to be her father, live life on the run all for a guy who never fully loved her the way she loved him. Is quite sad....

[@FrostVideos]

The more I see of Dutch, the more I understand that Micah simply unlocked what was inside Dutch all along. He was always a bad man. He just didn't want to accept it or at least couldn't rationalize it until Micah picked and prodded

[@ThatOneChick420]

Molly's story was sad. She truly loved him, and Dutch used her and discarded her just like he did the rest. The way he did Arthur and her were the worst. Be betrayed Arthur's trust and loyalty, and he betrayed her love and loyalty. She never told the Pinkertons about them, she said that because she was angry, she was hurt, and she wanted to hurt him like he hurt her. As far as Marybeth goes, she wasn't interested in Dutch romantically. The gang was more like her family. If anyone I think she may have been sweet on Keiren. As they shared a really wholesome interaction about reading and him thinking she was "purdy". Still an enjoyable watch though, thanks SM!

[@Hannah_G]

After Kieran dies she can come up crying to Arthur saying that she was sweet on him. If he had lived they probably would’ve run off together in chapter 6 I think

[@lynette50]

Dutch's women are just eye candy for his ego. He lost interest in Susan Grimshaw when she reached 30 and Annabelle showed up. Annabelle died before she lost her youth, so he never fell out of love with her, and then he took up with a younger and beautiful Molly. Now that Molly is 30 or almost 30, he is losing interest in her and trying to court Marybeth. Before you ask why Grimshaw stayed with the gang, its because if anyone left, they'd be hunted down and shot as traitors, for being disloyal. That is why Arthur was resentful & complaining that John was welcomed back like the prodigal son without consequences. After running out on Abigail and baby Jack

[@ladykinsei]

That's why I respect Micah more than Dutch. At least Micah never pretended to be a good guy. He just did whatever he could to survive. I mean, ofc he was selfish and a fkn rat, but that's still a bit better than being a narcissistic manipulator like Dutch.

[@EllanaWolf]

Same. I don’t hate Micah. He never pretended to be anything other than what he is. Dutch on the other hand…….Arthur spent 20 plus years by his side, and when he lay dying, Dutch looked at him with indifference. What a Snake.

[@kevinross6235]

Uncle to Arthur: "Didn't we just get rid of you?" Uh oh, sounds like Arthur was antagonizing the whole camp

[@xmynationalanthemx]

*Arthur creeping on the girls* Abigail: *notices Arthur and sighs* "Arthur, please, you don't care about this nonsense...away with ya." Arthur: *doesn't listen and continues to stare at her and Molly*

[@goboltz26]

I don't think he was creeping as much as in this format, it's like a Book seen through his eyes and we'd miss parts of how the story play out if he doesn't see it happen !

[@drinkwater3453]

Such a sad character. Her death at the beginning of chapter 6 shocked me so much, my jaw was dropped for like a minute straight when I first saw it

[@WarDragon72345]

Forgot how creepy Dutch gets.

[@bizza5715]

Way too few people realize whats going on inside Molly's head. She doesnt deserve the hate she often gets by the fanbase. Yes, she is arrogant but her whole story is just sad and makes me despise Dutch even more.

[@thegreeter7027]

Arthur when there’s something dramatic or lore going on: 👀

[@winterbalm]

Molly should have left Dutch in chapter 2 once a man treats you with disrespect there is no reason to stick around it will not improve

[@Tabasa05]

If you didn't feel for Molly before and you still don't now, you're probably Dutch reading this

[@Cramblit]

7:12 Poor Arthur taking a stray bullet XD

[@cicadax5886]

5:05 the way he goes , umm umm umm 😂

[@KatieUnoXX]

I shuddered omg 😂😂😂

[@Yopapivito]

I was about to comment this😂 Dutch freaky

[@julidee_]

😭😭😭

[@raymontana-pl1vc]

He had a plan

[@Em-yd3sn]

I have done 3 playthroughs of this game with my most recent being a 100% playthrough, and not once did I know of this sub plot with Dutch and Mary

[@grosni-qd7wj]

i only managed to 100% rdr2 once and even that was pure pain just because of the challenges and dinosaur bones

[@Em-yd3sn]

@ I did all the collectibles in a given zone of a map for the sake of not losing my hair going back to locations back to back for different stuff. I followed a walkthrough lol

[@fallenarchangelgaming3621]

Dutch spoke the truth when he said threats aren't the way to a man's heart. Women nowadays don't get this fact sadly.

[@davieisnerd]

I just wrote exactly this to someone else! 100% and 3 play throughs. Spent time in camp to get rare events to happen and still not a clue.

[@maxl5738]

Off topic, but i love Molly's accent

[@noahtoftegaard]

dutch preying on a girl he’s known since she was probably a teenager, a girl who is twice his age, (which is literally something he’s known to do) is not an “affair”…

[@ethansdaisy7531]

Exactly the title is so clickbaity

[@AirGoddess1087]

Dutch was being a creepy sicko! Mary Beth is only 20 while he is in his early 40s! He is way too old for her! He was even too old for Molly, who was 25! But i don't know, I guess some men just don't care about age or maybe age didn't matter back in the 1800s 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

[@Mr.Nobody-.]

It is an affair tho.

[@noahtoftegaard]

@@Mr.Nobody-.that is not what an affair is. mary-beth doesn’t like him in that way, she basically sees him as a parental figure, he is her leader and twice her age. It is predatory and one sided.

[@Adiddy927]

Dutch made it clear that the only woman he loves was Annabel. Mary Beth would rather be with Arthur then old Dutch

[@Alan78941]

Dutch treated Molly so bad, she loved him dearly, she would do anything for that man. She even died for him 😢

[@lanefurno]

Molly's death sure was tragic. "Not all love is kind". Truer words were never spoken, Nazar. 😥

[@timcarter7616]

I missed it because whenever Dutch goes off with another vocal word salad my eyes glaze over. Him and Micah are idiots that got the gang into more trouble than they were worth. Just sit in your tent, Big Mouth, let Arthur decide.

[@stvvrrz]

2:55 Evermore free? More like he wanted to be free of committing to one woman because he thought way too highly of himself, like a king with concubines or whatever. It's crazy how many tiny details rockstar puts in throughout the game's chapters that show Dutch being slowly unraveled by Micah and his "plans" and starting to think of himself as higher than everyone else, like I said before, a king.

[@septarria]

A king and messiah, that he said he wasn't. Exactly.

[@jaymac7203]

Lol I love how they're all having a go at Arthur for creeping around spying on them 😭😭 lol 😂

[@luko177]

I use to think it was a waste we didn’t get to see more of Molly in a mission or something but I think they purposefully left her in the back ground as much as possible to show how she was being pushed aside. Her mission was pushed away by uncle and she constantly being put off by Dutch very interesting way to write a character

[@B_razzer]

This affair is so secret in many playthroughs (since the game came out), like actually spending time in the world and in the camp, I’ve never picked up anything with Dutch and Mary Beth. Thinking back maybe that dance with Mary Beth, when Dutch is dancing with Molly could be something. 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@davieisnerd]

Ive completed it 3 times and 100% percented the whole thing and didnt have a clue.

[@pachcarter5291]

Dutch’s ex killed his current girlfriend for his future fling… He really had a bad influence on the women in the camp

[@alaynadiaz7918]

6:01 that shot is wild

[@metalfordays]

beautiful shot

[@gabagaba761]

She should not sit next to Micah of all people

[@Jayince]

The shot at Molly was wilder.

[@teekay7668]

Could have just as easily said it was “diabolical” or “savage” or “fire” or “crazy work”, that’s how brainless that comment was

[@AirGoddess1087]

It's a very nice shot ❤😍

[@cultureofignorance4410]

It's even more poetic that Molly is killed by Grimshaw, Dutch's former lover.

[@elmeeme]

Fantastic video! Keep up the work! I've noticed you haven't made a video based on MacFarlane's Ranch or at least the history/story. I know it's not that significant of a place, but it's definitely one of my favorite places since RDR1 and still is in Red Dead Online.

[@masterofallthelakesintown2472]

From the interactions I saw, I always thought he was grooming her. Maybe to be his next paramour, but I’d never thought she was interested 🤷

[@masterofallthelakesintown2472]

Also Mary Beth is the one wheaping for her when she is shoot.

[@_original__]

Some people think Molly was pregnant, which is why she was acting like that.

[@amberkinney6118]

You don’t have to be pregnant to behave/think like that. Men like Dutch can easily drive a woman who’s passionate, romantic, and sensitive into a spiral of desperation and madness. In my almost 30 years of life I’ve never been pregnant but I’ve been on the verge of insanity because of the manipulation and emotional abandonment by a man lol

[@_original__]

@amberkinney6118 I just say what I hear from some players. 🤷

[@septarria]

@@amberkinney6118 yeah, it's like Dutch made her he made her a trophy that was dependent on him, manipulated her and made her unstable and obsessed, and then discarded. Very abusive.

[@InsomniaYoutube-wz1ju]

Thanks so much for this! I think I caught most of this but missed the book scene. I love your videos so much and am beyond thrilled you still do them. Even things I’ve discovered are new with the artful way you angle/capture etc ❤

[@mediarare2386]

What happened to Molly was tragic but she was so out of place in the gang. She was neither involved nor sympathetic. In my first playthrough I even forgot she existed.

[@tristar9998]

Yeah looking back i feel terrible for Molly. At least she got the drop dead part right on the money. Dutch was a groomer plain and simple i mean look at Arthur literally lived his life loyal to him from a young and traumatic time for him.

[@Xavier_Breaking_Bad]

Typical Dutch behavior where he goes into Gaslighting someone. It took me this video to realize that the way he did the women in this game was the same way he did his boys. Tells them what they want to hear while he reaps most of the rewards and then tosses them aside when they're no longer useful to him.

[@Wwefanatic-c1q]

I have played this game many times and seen most interactions yet- I never ever knew or thought about it like this!!!

[@cameronanderson3304]

Dutch has fun with all the women of the camp, hes not lying, cause thats how it was back then. Everything new woman was fresh piece of meat. Grimshaw was like his first sort of. All the ladies knew.

[@speed_demon_031]

The last thing you wanna do is upset an Irish woman, doesn't end well 🤣

[@nadiyaangeloff3420]

I've been through multiple play throughs, and never caught on that it was Mary Beth that Molly was jealous of.

[@gumbyshrimp2606]

Noooooo Mary Beth is mine

[@MrProducer395]

Simp 😂

[@dynamic-d2539]

Nah she's mine!

[@maggotbeIIy]

Liar

[@sehliim]

Cringe asf

[@DJFrankeeTNT]

I agree @heatheryyy. Sad and tragic. I felt bad for Molly. She was dealt the short end of the stick and treated poorly

[@619KJ]

6:56 shes also right about dutch being the opposite of what he says

[@MB-ln4yx]

This was a very well put together video. Good job. Ive played as other have countless hours and i have never seen some of these reactions.

[@TheSeptacle]

I really wish we as the player could’ve done something for her. I made sure to get her camp request at least. 😭

[@amberkinney6118]

Molly was such a relatable tragic character. Favorite aside from Arthur for sure.

[@shedevilishwings7469]

Dutch was significantly older than Molly and says she’s from a good family. He’s much more worldly and he’s an experienced, confident, lifelong grifter. It would be easy for an unworldly, young woman like Molly to fall for his wiles. It’s her undoing in the end. Mary Beth is young and she’s a romantic at heart but she’s not as naive as Molly. Molly was a tragic character.

[@matthewcioffi6385]

Molly's story is a sad one for sure. Initially, it's hard to sympathize with her, as she clearly comes off as uppity and snobbish. But it becomes more and more clear as the game goes on that, much like the rest of the gang, she's being constantly gaslit by Dutch. She was drawn to his charisma, used for his purposes, and discarded when Mary-Beth came along.

[@cubic9960]

At 1:24 you can see Mary Beth walking at the back of the tent and then she stops and looks .

[@Amehmeti]

Perfect notifocation to get tonight before bed

[@MrBebetoadful]

Dutch would’ve gotten bored of Mary Beth and moved on to the next one .

[@speedy316uk]

Abagail spelled it out for her and she still couldnt see it. The best thing Molly could have done is left the gang but she met a horrible end because of her obsession

[@dynamic-d2539]

This was an interesting video I'd love to see more stuff like this about relationships between gang members

[@HammersBoyJim]

6 years old, multiple playthroughs and I’ve never seen the Dutch and Mary-Beth encounters

[@mmenendez93yj]

Ever read that sad poem on the night stand?

[@shutup_play]

Poor Molly

[@CaptainSurf]

What are the rules? Ooooo what are the rules? When you've just shot Molly, but you're just not sorry. Well it's time we go and find out the rules.

[@fizzy3766]

Please please can someone tell me the song name that’s playing?? I know it’s part of the rdr2 soundtrack but I need the name at 11:40

[@leighwakeham3735]

I thought that Dutch also had a thing for Miss Grimshaw, bcos he's really sad when she gets shot by Micah at the end of the game before the Epilogue.

[@MidwestArtMan]

Does anyone else think Molly was pregnant? The conversation at 0:54 makes it sound like she'd be telling Dutch she is. I swear, there is a story mission in that campsite, as well as one in the second campsite, where Molly wants to talk to Dutch about "something important," but he blows her off because he's explaining a plan. By the time you get to Shady Belle, I remember always seeing her sitting in the corner of the dining room next to an empty bowl of stew, like she was very hungry and tired. When she dies, I remember saying, "Bro, you shot her in the baby!" From a quick internet search, it seems that the time from Chapter 2 to the beginning of Chapter 6 is about 4-5 months. I think she'd be noticeably pregnant by then, so I could be wrong.

[@danielvillalba5375]

Dutch: What are you reading? Charles: What the hell?

[@TohmaNokuu]

The thought of him and Mery Beth is so repulsive

[@mmaxphenom]

Bro I want to meet u in real life u helped me so much on my runs on read dead thank u strange man keep making these amazing videos brotha 👌🏻💯

[@ashcan6]

Kudos for using my favorite song from the entire game for this video

[@Amicus624]

Thank you! I saw this in camp and not seen many videos on Mary-Beth being the "Her" Molly is referring too.

[@EganBar]

I found a poem Molly made inside Dutch's tent in Chapter 3. I don't know if it was always there or if its specific on chapter 3 but I found it after the mission where you go shopping with Sadie (One of the first missions on chapter 3). Maybe it's not that important for the video but I found it interesting because Molly writes that Dutch made her a "woman". Maybe Dutch started dating her since she was young 🤷‍♂️

[@noepp]

Actually I had the feeling that in Chapter 2 Mary-Beth had a crush on Arthur before crushing on Kieran. Dutch was a creep for so openly flirting with her.

[@twistedhellhound666]

I dont think Mary Beth had a crush on Kieren. He liked her, sure, but she only felt pity for him. I think she did like Arthur but nothing happened between them because he got sick.

[@Mr.Nobody-.]

Creep? For what? For liking someone?

[@noepp]

@@Mr.Nobody-. He was more than twice her age and taken.

[@Mr.Nobody-.]

@@noepp If a 20 year old likes a 40 year old woman, is he a creep?

[@noepp]

@@Mr.Nobody-. If you wanna reverse the genders than you'd have to ask that for a ca. 46 year old woman hitting on a 21 year old guy. And yes, it's also kinda creepy.

[@BluewaterJohn]

This video for me has a sad vibe and I think it goes the same for strangeman Thank you ❤

[@Rajindadakan]

Read "Letter to tom from Colm" Guess who she is.

[@thegoblincleaver4040]

He talks a big game about the difference between seeking vs finding, and in seeking can he truly be free. Yet in constantly seeking - in this case seeking female companionship - he is never truly satisfied once he's actually found what he has sought. Therefore to be free he needs to constantly be seeking and never finding. He has found Molly, but because of this he cannot be free, and so continues to seek female friendship with Mary-Beth.

[@89Jalberts]

I’ve always wondered if Molly actually did eat out the gang about the Bank Heist, I mean we know Micah ratted out the gang from the time they got back from Gaurma, but did Molly rat out the gang from 2 to 4?

[@89Jalberts]

“Eat” I meant rat, stupid autocorrect

[@noahtoftegaard]

even if she had heard something about the bank before running away from camp, I highly doubt she would’ve said anything. as for if she ratted out the gang prior? no. she never even left camp, and even when her and dutch fought she still tried to make him happy, make him interested in her by dressing up, following his orders and engaging with him. molly ran away from the gang at the end of chapter 4, she went to town to drink her sorrows away. she had no idea what happened between the bank heist and then moving to beaver hollow- and was then brought back into that hellhole by uncle to get murdered. micah most likely occasionally ratted them out earlier, that and the fact that they had gotten extremely sloppy (as arthur put it). something like the train robbery; all gang members involved were people that micah either disliked or feared (arthur, john, charles, sean) and the law was tipped off about that job. could’ve been micah, could’ve been a civilian.

[@89Jalberts]

@@noahtoftegaard I would be willing to bet Micah gave anonymous tips to the authorities about all the big things they were doing, then by the time they got back from Guarma, he couldn’t be anonymous anymore

[@ianperry4974]

Completely random thought. But the church in Rhodes is pastored by a man named “Grimshaw”. I wonder if it’s a relations to Susan?

[@RichZee777]

Now we know what he means when he said I have a plan.

[@ArnoldJudasRimmer..]

'Have you seen, how Dutch looks at Mary Beth?...' *'Like a piece of steak!'* 😂

[@hamd7r7]

نحن نتابعك من العراق أستمر يااخي ❤

[@phil7144]

I had a suspicion that Dutch was "double dippin" on my latest playthrough

[@Beepster81]

Hi from the uk love the vids. Have you ever considered doing myth busting vids for red dead or gta? Sorry I’ve missed you doing them cheers.

[@Soldier_Boy_V]

Strange man ❌ Detective Arthur ✅

[@sheikhalieuswarray-deen581]

Miss Grimshaw had an issue with Molly as she was Dutch's Ex😂

[@hsb1599]

Grow up kid...if other person loves you, obsessed with you, cling to you and you actually don't love her/him...then the other person is just considered as to be a stalker not lover to you...and ther other person's heart is broken by you that doesn't Mean he/she has right to harm u..... So Molly's death is justified, because dutch never loved her, and its ok...every body has someone speacial no one can replace that....

[@juiciestlemonadeofyoutube]

4:51 BRO DUTCH HE’S LITERALLY RIGHT THERE CHILL

[@basedman3555]

Ah yes my favourite western journalist from armadillo Mr. Strange Man

[@eliaspanula7145]

Can you make a video of hosea's sickness?

[@amuchan5913]

i always felt so bad for her