Eat It Or Yeet It: All PROTEIN

[@dsadams17]

I love that the Garrett Cam is just him doing the Tom Cruise laugh.

[@Sensei_BigJoe]

Not going to lie, that first Garrett cam made me go "wait."

[@lemongrassass]

literally

[@justalittlealien]

@@Sensei_BigJoe I was confused for a moment and had to go back because I thought I was mistaken and it was someone else pretending to be Courtney

[@tjsquibbofficial]

@@justalittlealien Part of me thought for a second that Garrett had a twin-

[@sagegreeeeeeen]

It got more and more unsettling as the video went on

[@cv55daan]

Now that there are 3 versions of courtney you guys can make “courtney: no way home” 😂👌🏻

[@getquicklier]

Smosh NEEDS to see this

[@scoooodles1429]

YES

[@rey.6334]

OMG YES

[@Alpha13Wolf]

I’d watch

[@hollynguyen8988]

Yo I'd watch that movie lmao

[@tristanduke4296]

Tommy and Amanda trying not to laugh and nodding when Shane says "and I still CAME" Is everything

[@VitrescentObelisk]

i'm so happy I wasn't the only one that saw that

[@mitchelldayboll7375]

@@VitrescentObelisk Meee too xD

[@morginstjarna]

yes!

[@Breadful1]

1:08

[@ivirn97]

Yes. Period 😂

[@majortritone]

1:13 Tommy and Amanda exchanging that knowing glance after "I still came". Love how long Amanda laughed at that too.

[@krisjenner2638]

I noticed that too lmfao I love them

[@yaboiitito]

The fact Shayne was not in a protein episode with Shane is tragic…

[@gluclax]

Right?

[@sovereigndark7792]

Yeah feel like they missed a good opportunity here. Seeing Shane is an Indie Pro Wrestler they could have done some kinda goofy promo for it as well.

[@kloudysecret]

Too much power

[@neurts]

They wanted to have them both but the wide angle wasn't wide enough.

[@maem7462]

That’s what I was thinking as well

[@jaykay8144]

“Many a times…….and I still came!” *Amanda and Tommy have an obviously silent eye connection and shit eating grin simultaneously*

[@GeekExtremist]

🤣 thanks I missed their looks at first

[@hellojello4456]

I THOUGHT NO ONE ELSE NOTICED 😭😂😭

[@WalunirLongkumer-gy8lh]

@@hellojello4456 what are they trying to tell?

[@jasonellis4330]

​@@WalunirLongkumer-gy8lhseriously??

[@WalunirLongkumer-gy8lh]

@@jasonellis4330 It is what it is mate, I got no clue. Any idea?

[@yakamoose]

Garrett’s Courtney impression is scary good. Also stoked to have Shane back. He fits in so well with everyone.

[@TheLivingGamer35]

what do you mean that's Courtney stinking Miller

[@theturkkusu]

Nice pic

[@naveda_h]

That's not Garrett it's Courtney did you hear how many times she burped?

[@TheLivingGamer35]

@@theturkkusu Thanks you too

[@PoKeMoNneo]

What's weird is that Garret's Courtney impression is somehow better than his Garret impression.

[@werbs7776]

Garrett single handedly is keeping the malic acid industry in business.

[@Truecrimeresearcher224]

No Shayne is he straight up will eat it

[@thebadpoet]

Whoever cobbled together regular belts to create Garrett’s harness, and tucked in the sides of Shane’s bib to make him look even larger, is a costuming genius and I appreciate them.

[@SupremeLeaderKimJong-un]

The fact Garrett was managed to pull off being Courtney Stinkin' Miller and being at the care station at the same time shows just how much of a powerful being he is. He is a worthy opponent for me

[@JRBeast-nw3xg]

That was Courtney the whole time Tf you mean?

[@SilverswordsTHEPWNER]

Garret's commitment to this is insane, the fact that he even did reactions after is crazy

[@neo_b]

im pretty sure these were reactions pulled from previous episodes

[@cassandracarlton400]

@@neo_b yeah they did but the op miiight be using that as the joke? I can’t tell lmao

[@Gallivandr]

@@neo_b Does Garret wear the same clothes on every episode of eat it or yeet it.

[@drake7993]

@@Gallivandr Pretty sure he doesn't, I would bet money he did the reactions after

[@jayhatesyou-s7i]

Damien checking on Amanda before she ate is the sweetest thing. He’s always the most genuinely concerned for his friends 😭

[@kaitlin6184]

He’s so sweet

[@jayhatesyou-s7i]

@@kaitlin6184 he really is

[@gabijamatutyte4900]

That was very sweet.

[@krossronin3394]

We need a "Too many Courtneys" video cus Garrett was great and I wanna see what everyone else does. Tommy as Brianna boho?

[@why_do_you_care]

Yess.. similar to when tommy played that gagillionaire in scrabble

[@lilsqueak1469]

Yes!

[@maem7462]

I love that idea. They should also do a too many Courtney freakin millers bc that would be some wonderful chaos

[@Hazlius]

Tommy as Brianna Bozo, an even dumber bimbo

[@gamergunn7139]

Do you want the world to explode!? Even 2 CFM's has the potential! A room full of like 5 or 6 would at least crack the world a few miles

[@Swirlingflame]

Kimmy: "I do not feel jacked." Shane: "You look jacked, babe."

[@maryamtara2934]

😍

[@ngj379]

Is Shane Kimmy’s boyfriend?

[@maryamtara2934]

@@ngj379 yuup

[@lexmcdufflepants4332]

@@maryamtara2934 living the life

[@Baseballman1224]

@@ngj379 I believe that they are engaged

[@emilymorgan1994]

Garrett's impression of Courtney is F L A W L E S S

[@FelipeAkira42]

Wdym Garret never left the care station

[@bharathgchennai1]

milk bean was sitting in the care station all the time

[@taylifts]

I need the Courtney Miller Multiverse pf Madness so bad

[@bharathgchennai1]

@@taylifts we had glimpses of it when Courtney miller and cfm was there but we need more

[@ragingturtle2814]

I feel like they need to do an “is it cake” episode where some of the items are really nice cake but some taste exactly like the food they look like or even worse knowing Garrett 😂😂

[@aaep0]

I want to see Kimmy as Courtney "Fluffing" Miller! It's gonna be hilarious to see Kimmy attempt the "nicest" of the Courtney incarnations :D

[@CAS896]

This feels like the "Garrett finally had a breakdown" episode 😂😂😂

[@Mattriarc]

courtney STINKIN miller being added to the Smoshiverse is the greatest thing I didn't know I needed until now.

[@medademirhan]

Shane is such a good sport!!!! He is like all in supporting enjoying no shame in anything at all, such a good guy it feels like! Great to know Kimmy is together with such a guy.

[@MultiLetz]

YO! I was laughing my ass off with Courtney and when i saw Garret cam still there i almost spit my drink in shock, LMAO

[@E11-u1n]

I was confused for a second because Garrett is Courtney and then you have Garrett cam

[@MultiLetz]

@@E11-u1n what do you mean "Garret is Courtney" that's just Courney, clearly! Same as always

[@rachelfrancis1990]

Im not quick… i was CONFUSED

[@theowren1614]

"courtney's worse today" in just the saddest, smallest voice ever has me CACKLING

[@pedrovasquez5385]

I love Amanda just looking at the camera like Jim from the office. This whole episode was hilarious

[@pearlygirl88]

She was straight up not having a good time Lol. I thought it was hilarious that she was fighting back on taking a big spoonful.

[@aurickbiswas8233]

Now that you mentioned it Amanda does look like Jim

[@sneakatwix]

I want Shane, Shayne, Damien, Noah and Keith in an episode. Keith be yeeting everywhere, Shayne being unlucky everytime and Noah, Damien and Shane just trying everything out.

[@RiP-eq8be]

I need every cast member to get their own Courtney Something Miller character, this is hilarious

[@jasminestiara]

Courtney Freakin Miller Courtney Stinkin Miller Courtney Simpin Miller Courtney Limpin Miller Courtney Trippin' Miller

[@hudsonja]

Somebody need to do one where she only talks in Linkin Park lyrics or song titles... aka Courtney LINKIN Miller

[@Roblitzo]

Yes! Bring on the Courtney-Verse!

[@Yawnybones]

@@hudsonja Sounds like a good one for Link.

[@Bobal27]

@@hudsonja She tried so hard, and got so far…

[@carriehodlik8424]

We need the future Mr. Jimenez on more Smosh things, please.

[@graysonbogert5288]

Everyone now needs an impression of Courtney with a different middle name. They're all cousins of Courtney's giant Mormon family

[@nickdabon1643]

Just have Tommy be Courtney Fucking Miller, but in the most sincere yet sarcastic voice ever

[@lalabear6]

Yes please

[@katdbris]

Shane could be Courtney Beefin' Miller and just be the beefy muscle version of Courtney

[@screaumbly]

either that or the miller multiverse

[@katdbris]

@@screaumbly I love that!

[@SS-700]

Damien checking on Amanda before she ate is the sweetest thing

[@barlowjmb]

Amanda and Tommy laughing at the inappropriate joke makes me laugh. Lol @1:10

[@blueraspberry3486]

Lolllll I didn’t notice them exchanging that till now :D

[@kalliedoscope]

Yesss!! And honestly you can tell Damien gets in on it too

[@CorporalGrievous93]

This was legitimately one of the best of these ever. From “Courtney”, to Shane, to the Garrett Cam making Garrett look completely insane lol.

[@whough]

if theres a “We Pranked Courtney With Too Many Courtneys” garrett needs to be on it

[@jeromegarganera3979]

I like to think that they filmed just Garret laughing maniacally.

[@lIlzerolIll]

Shane is so chaotic it's absolutely entertaining

[@tickledtoffee]

The way he ate that scrambled “egg” had me crying with laughter. I’d love to see him in more Smosh vids, his chaotic energy fits right in lol

[@Jonito_xcx]

Yea he's genuinely having a blast

[@MrRudyc85]

The Mighty Don’t Kneel

[@adrianamora4279]

1. Garret’s Courtney impression it’s spot on 2. Shane it’s so fun it should be a guest more often

[@kf2405]

the two belts crossed over Garrett's chest to look like a harness is so funny 😭 I cracked up almost immediately

[@lucasblanchard47]

You mean Courtney

[@emz2969]

welp i only just noticed it wasn't literally a bdsm accecory.

[@vaudevillien]

Amanda and Tommy both looking at each other and clearly thinking the same thing after Shane said “and I still came!” is my favorite part of this video

[@HiMyNamesAdam]

I would love to see Shane teach Shayne wrestling.

[@vfwestphal]

Do you want more broken ankles? Because that's how you get more broken ankles xD

[@PowerEd8]

Shane/yne -ception

[@wheelycody275]

This needs to happen

[@HiMyNamesAdam]

@@vfwestphal What if they put Shayne in crocs as a safety precaution?

[@Retro_Red]

I think it'll go a little like this: Shayne: Oh, I hope no big strong man pins me down to this mat with his muscular, beefy bod. Oooh that would be so bad! OoOohhh!!!

[@platinumraven118]

Great Idea, "Eat It or Yeet It: Iron Stomach Challange." All bad foods, everyone can take the food every round, if they get it down, they get a point, most points at the end gets a super delicious ice cream Sunday or something like that

[@KatieKatLuvz]

Yesss this would be hilarious

[@_Adie]

I love how you pulled up Damien's receipts about butter

[@terendril]

That was the best. The mans eatin his words lol

[@sotrue5413]

Garrett does a spot on Courtney impression! I also love people like Shane, who are down for anything! Never complain, and are just living their best lives, not afraid to try new foods and experiences. We need more of these types of people on here!!

[@betsydelciampo1732]

Tommy and Amanda are having a moment after Shane says "and I still came" at 1:11 😆😅

[@adamskashalashashka5692]

I actually have a theory Amanda is Tommy, when I release 5 hour video essay on the matter you'll all see

[@beingsodone]

They where trying so hard to hold it in but where doing such a bad job 😂

[@TheShirochan10]

Omg 😂😂😂😂

[@betsydelciampo1732]

@@adamskashalashashka5692 wow, I love this. Please report back 😆

[@adamskashalashashka5692]

@@betsydelciampo1732 The truth will be revealed my friend!

[@Scrofar]

1) Would love Shane back for more episodes, we love to see him eat chunks of foods when he doesn't have to 2) Wow, Courtney's Garrett-inspired makeup looks great today, even her impression is spot-on!

[@hannahwatermelon]

The fact that Garret had to film his part of garret-cam separately is hilarious

[@tanyasoucy9613]

NGL I genuinely questioned whether or not it was actually Garret and not his secret twin or something 😅

[@kittyphyrie2664]

I think its actually old Garret reaction clips that go with the scene XD

[@DarkAdolla]

It honestly is a shame that smosh has lost so much of its fanbase. I have yet to watch a video that isn't just genuinely genius. Even with the long running series like eat it or yeet it and tntl they always come up with great ideas to spice it up. I love you guys and yall deserve so much more

[@Syd448]

I’ve always know of smosh, but I just started watching about a month ago and I have no idea why people don’t like this content. It’s so good and I’ve been binging all their content it’s amazing ❤

[@mutantsandmemes]

1:10 the look Amanda and Tommy give eachother at Shane's "and I STILL CAME!" is PRICELESS.

[@Demi_P]

I love Damien’s “What else is new” after Garrett said all the muscles are from Shane 🤣 Wish Shayne was also in this video!

[@samantharojas6128]

Never worried for Garrett’s sanity more

[@garrettpalm]

Thank you!

[@harryhealey4298]

I’m surprised this hasn’t happened from Garrett sooner.

[@kyleshanebeck1645]

Tommy being silently hostile and disgusted with the broey straight dude was everything this episode 😂

[@karlahernandez-ec6tt]

and Amanda too😭😭it’s killing me

[@Bafael_Reyna]

Everything in this video is cursed... I love it. Make Shane a regular.

[@Rogue_Won]

Love that Shane wore Kimmy's Smosh Games Apocalypse shirt lol His vibe and energy match so well with Kimmy's, I love it haha

[@arianatigue3223]

Shane is just here for the ride lol. His laughter is contagious. Garrett Miller is the damn best!

[@jhandle900]

Shane is such a team player. They should do an episode with Josh and Shane! I think the room would explode though lol 😂

[@SamuelDuplessis12]

I mean the name of his faction is literally The Mighty Don't Kneel

[@TheTsubaKun]

Shane: “And I still came!” Tommy and Amanda (henceforth known as T&A) *Looks at each other, smiles, nods knowingly*

[@jaykay8144]

T&A is Amazing! Lol they are really the 2 funniest sleepers on the channel; the Funeral Roasts prove it

[@RayBeamBlazer]

Garrett's monster creations: Shane, Shayne, and Olivia. With all of their powers combined, they can eat ANYTHING

[@leinaamatsuji-berry561]

I love that increasingly it seems that in the Smosh content universe if your name is any variation of “Shane” you’re automatically a blond dude with incredibly jacked arms

[@ejmovement1613]

Shout out Shane Haste of NJPW and GreatBlackOtaku of Twitch fame. LMAO Shane my guy on the real. Love this.

[@EStramel09]

Damien seems like such a legitimately nice guy. Like his “Real talk, off camera, are you going to be ok?” is really wholesome. Also, props to Amanda for not backing out and eating that nasty food.

[@pranamahardika300]

But sometime i'm tired of damien "nice guy" character, sometime its too much.

[@JetLagVSKenji]

@@Codyiscool28 you alright?

[@firmanchristiansianturi4794]

@@JetLagVSKenji Disliking someone being nice? Probably not

[@ellon1100]

It was Tuna, they why she was acting I thought it was Surstromming

[@Fido06]

So this is the episode we find out Damien is a liar and actually doesn't love butter like he's made us all believe. For shame Damien, for shame.

[@DiscombobulatedSenpai]

Henceforth, he will be known as Shame-ien 😜

[@Wilmar-f6m]

1:11 Tommy and Amanda's look after Shane said what he said and I totally sync with their minds LMFAO

[@dwatts64]

The Garrett cam is the highlight of this episode fr.

[@stewartmoyer5105]

Love when Buffer Shane comes around. always a delight.

[@DamenVain13]

what other videos has he been in? i dont remember him being in any of the UUD crossovers

[@Maxvalie]

This is taller Shane

[@stewartmoyer5105]

@@DamenVain13 He was also in who knows Kimmy best and when Ian slept over at Kimmys house

[@iamfanofavril]

Damien checking on Amanda was so sweet and seemed so genuine💛

[@brianbradford3867]

Eat it or Yeet it: lunch order edition You take a normal lunch order for the group but then add the good ole Garrett twist. (Shayne, make sure you get your lunch order in)

[@hexxygirl7669]

i cant wait for the smosh skit "oops all courtnys!" where frickin miller and now stinkin and other millers join the millerverse and burp

[@smithscullyx]

When one muscly Sha(y)ne is gone, another takes his place.

[@garrettpalm]

Take away the “y” and you get even more muscles

[@Kevin1457A]

The Law of Conservation of Shane(s)

[@pisandro2936]

1:12 Tommy and Amanda cracking up at the "and I still came" and Damien noticing is just 💀💀

[@pisandro2936]

I need them to release all the Tommy footage of this episode

[@yasgam1723]

Damien is so nice the way he just like checks up on everyone especially when being like « real talk off camera » to Amanda I love him 💔💔🫶🏻🫶🏻

[@Aitaitaitai]

Shane is such a good time, Amanda and Tommy responding to the whole situation is beyond relatable. This video is amazing

[@JRSmith06]

Shane just straight up chomping a butter-Monterey Jack combo might be one of the most impressive things yet on EIOYI...up there with Mythical Chef Josh no-selling the ghost pepper jello.

[@indievariety]

Between Amanda doing a mock Australian accent at Shane and Garret's "Courtney Stinkin Miller" this episode was amazing and hilarious 😂

[@spaceguitar3290]

“And I STILL came!” I saw that look, Tommy and Amanda. I too live permanently in the gutter.

[@airmanon7213]

Shane: "I'm gonna yeet!" Also Shane: *ate everything he tried*

[@drpibisback7680]

I love that "what is even happening, my guy?" is the go-to Courtney impression line. Has she ever said that in a video or is it just entirely an inside joke?

[@pearlygirl88]

Yes. Many times.

[@SupremeLeaderKimJong-un]

Wait, you've never noticed?

[@drpibisback7680]

@@SupremeLeaderKimJong-un Apparently I have not.

[@OnyxANZ]

I'm just slowly going through the playlist and.. yeah I wasn't expecting a TMDK boy here. Haven't watched yet but I'm sure Fujita's fun uncle will thrive because The Mighty Don't Kneel. Edit: Yeah pretty much what I expected

[@carolusrex3973]

The fact that this is a protein based episode and Shayne is NOT in there should be considered a crime against humanity

[@Ry1478]

What you mean Shane is there. He just so jacked so he looks different 😂😂😂

[@SpeedbreakerNo1]

This episode was from the multiverse. A Shane variant was present.

[@jordanpeterson5140]

They got a Stunt Shayne.

[@Trevor_Lin]

shane is literally right there dude whtchuu mean xD

[@carolusrex3973]

@@SpeedbreakerNo1 Why yes of course! It makes sense now

[@cindypayne9915]

The B Reel of Garret is my favourite part of this

[@coralcrew3890]

Tommy looks so done with Garret 😂

[@E11-u1n]

😂

[@ItBePatYo]

You mean Courtney, right?

[@stewartmoyer5105]

all Garret did is laugh and clap all episode. dident even react with Tommy

[@bofurlong8944]

Garrett’s impression had me dying the whole time, especially when they cut to the Garrett care station 😂

[@madisonkayy867]

Garret's Boneless noise was absolutely perfect

[@jthegreat90]

Tommy and Amanda ain’t slick with their little mutual understanding at 1:12 lmaooo

[@feliciaenglund3113]

Damien has the best facial expressions in this video. whenever you see him it looks like he is watching everyone get tortured 😂

[@thesilentangel1020]

Imma just leave this tiny note here- I find it somehow cute how Damien blinks multiple times, especially when he is talking. Its so adorable😭

[@MrPurpleNess10]

Eat it or yeet it idea: everyone at the table does one of their characters and stays in character all video. For example Shayne does the wizard and damian Augustus

[@gleeknomatterwhat8958]

Yas to both

[@katieharvey650]

yeesssss, great idea 🙂

[@joaobratkoski1586]

keith as Bobby from the block

[@sxchneiler806]

I prefer Shayne as the Chosen, but good idea! Up so they can see this.

[@teahpeterson6651]

This is such a good idea!!

[@Rach11AnneMU]

The more videos I watch the more I love Damien and him being so caring and concerned for his friends.

[@justgold666]

Courtney should been dressed as Garrett in the Garett care station.

[@FilipGron]

I was hoping for that aswell

[@CuchilloMucho]

Well they usually have a Courtney replacement when she is away for some reason

[@jakehill8690]

I reeeeeeaaally wish they had Garrett do his Courtney impression during the rules. He has the absolute funniest Courtney impression I've ever seen lmfaooo dude is so damn funny, I wish we saw more of him.

[@jakehill8690]

I can just imagine hims saying "THE BIG BITE" in his impression lmaooo

[@awesomepersun]

When Tommy pulled his hood up as Amanda's yogurt thing was being stirred I felt that

[@lfbocca]

"And I still came" Tommy and Amanda's looks are priceless

[@mikecoalofficial]

Idea for episode: make a collab with Mythical Kitchen and do a "Eat it or Yeet it - Food Fears Edition" where every dish tastes and looks amazing, but all the dishes is made with something weird/nasty (of course without telling participants that every dish will taste good) and also, instead of Garrett, do a Josh - Care station

[@landryatkins1774]

Damien genuinely asking if Amanda is gonna be okay is so precious

[@firstpotatoalive]

Today I tried to hang out with some friends, trying to engage in conversation rather than watch KZbin videos and ultimately felt alone again like I always do. So thank you Smosh for always being there to keep me company when I feel lonesome. No matter if it's a new upload or a classic video from previous times, you never fail to make me smile. 💜 Thank you from the bottom of my heart.

[@HuckleberryBlade]

Tommy and Amanda trying not to laugh at Shane's comment was my favorite part

[@marchedlund8977]

Garrett's energy is absolutely perfect.

[@Mase96]

And Courtney’s

[@TalesFromTheShadows]

OK this was amazing! Garret as Courtney was on point and Shane didn't eff around! Absolutely hilarious! I needed a good laugh, thanks!

[@mayaj7585]

I’m sorry. But Damien saying “yeah syzzurp” was hands down the funniest part of this video😂😂😂

[@nikothegoddess]

It's official. I love Damien ❤️ he's so caring and sweet for his friends.

[@allizimm5111]

I love how done Tommy is from the very beginning of this video

[@CeleTrev]

I love that Courtney has different people impersonating her 😂😂😂

[@jessszymanski7144]

Really digging the pre filmed Garrett reactions so we still get a Garrett cam

[@ddsnutz9066]

I love that Shayne isn't in this one because they knew if he ate any more protein he'd explode