Eat It or Yeet It - Gone Bananas!

[@shealynn0390]

the fact that shayne gets every malic acid thing except when it’s literally named after him

[@shealynn0390]

wait did smosh just like my comment…*dies*

[@TylerPCoyne]

He either really has Grave mouth or a Stomach of Steel!

[@courtneyfreakinmiller2003]

If it's up to fate, otherwise he won't get it

[@janaloff]

🤣

[@matthewelliott7294]

Malic Acid is clearly no match for Shayne, who looks like his ankle is fully healed.

[@maxim_beatbox]

Concerned Courtney: “You were supposed to share that with Olivia.” Shayne: “mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm”

[@stephenmahilum285]

Shayne: Okaay!

[@Tyranzor64]

Everyone dying and Garret cackling like a lunatic during Noah's turn was great

[@TylerPCoyne]

This is such a twisted but entertaining game to watch!

[@AxxLAfriku]

hi its cool AxxL

[@mikelarocca3831]

I'm done with Olivia leave her out of everything except skits

[@PutRandomNameHere]

I saw this comment before I watched the video, and it made the ending so much better, I wasn't expecting Shayne's turn 🤣

[@thottusthottusxoxo]

@@mikelarocca3831 Olivia’s great idk wym

[@scrap-bot]

Everyone's like "Wow, Shayne didn't get the malic acid this time! He's so lucky." He literally ate worms

[@johnsmith2875]

No like we was unlucky actually LOL... Garrett was the lucky one

[@sarahdelicia-king9089]

Shayne ate fish food in a malic acid burger. Man even ate toothpaste

[@aff77141]

He can't even taste the malic acid, THAT would be the lucky part!

[@psychic_vampire_88]

He’s into that 😂😂😂😂

[@moonlightblair]

*everyone disgusted* Shayne: "I'm just peeling a banana"

[@mashupotato_]

I'VE BEEN LAUGHING AT THIS FOR LIKE A STRAIGHT 5 MINUTES NOW

[@reversidly]

11:02

[@arikazoo3332]

🍌 🤢

[@Mgkatie19xx]

They probably knew what was in it

[@alchemist824]

@@Mgkatie19xx and we might see Shayne's Revenge part 2

[@angelachen2458]

I love how in this room full of adults, shayne's just there, screaming, "IT'S SHITTING!! IT'S POOPING!!!"

[@savannahbradley8602]

Me too it makes me laugh every time

[@camloch]

Noah's reaction is *exactly* what Garrett wanted from Shayne the first time. I don't doubt they put sooo much in it betting it'd land on Shayne and we just got to experience what a Normal Person would do when eating that much malic acid at once. The look of pure joy on Garrett's face was hilarious.

[@channingscott009]

Exactly

[@sethhoffman6138]

“They’re edible worms” Garrett says like next time it’s going to be a banana full of tape worms lol

[@angelachen2458]

Oops I just fed you parasites! Sorry!

[@NinjaRose23]

New fear unlocked, ngl 😩

[@animaleal]

13:13 lmao Olivia pissed that she didn't get his half of the banana

[@Galiant2010]

And Keith looks like he's 60 with that face, too lol.

[@loyael]

I felt that

[@Commander_Shepard.]

Olivia sure loves Banana.....

[@shadeth90]

Garret dressed in a banana costume has me laughing hard. He needs to dress up for the theme of each eat it or yeet it episode.

[@SilkyCrow]

Garrett dressed as a banana costume, scrolling through Shane's banana selfies and asking Google how to spell *"banamda"* was pure comedic genius. Also Noah's "thank you banana man" 😂😂

[@kellytat2190]

I love how Olivia looked so hurt and betrayed whenever anyone said they didn't like bananas

[@oliveiradmdiogo]

As you should

[@hblake5213]

Almost as hurt and betrayed as she looked when Shayne didn't share the banana

[@AngelicaJCardona]

I think the takeaway from this episode is don't let Garrett prep things on Friday that are going to be eaten on Monday 😂😂

[@Jim-tb7sj]

Eat it or yeet it ideas: -clear liquid in shot glasses -mystery (have to ding in before the cover is lifted) -everyone at the table prepares one dish each for the game, but no one knows who made it when it’s presented -smelly foods but the players wear clothes pegs on their noses until they ring the bell to eat it -just go all out and put poison in one Idk guys I’m just brainstorming 😅

[@the_honey_rat]

omg I totally would watch the first two

[@loyael]

The last one would be interesting to watch (:

[@belliejelli1642]

Ok lmao maybe not the last one we don't want anyone dying sisjsjsjjsn but all of the others r such cool suggestions!

[@phoenix_king_0611]

The fuck is a clothes peg

[@squisheebean]

@@phoenix_king_0611 it's something you use to keep clothes in place when they dry on a clothes line, no need to be so aggressive lmfao

[@marvelanddcretrospective]

Shayne antagonising Noah and then it backfiring, allowing Noah to mess with him was hilarious.

[@maem7462]

Olivia and Shane fighting over who likes bananas more is so funny

[@Farstr1d3r]

Nothing with Olivia is funny…..

[@karenkane7125]

I died at Oliva "yeet it in my mouth..." Gurl we need to have a talk about what needs to be thought and what can be said!!!! Lmao

[@starstepstoheaven]

Each time I watch Smosh I'm grateful that they're still here

[@lolisimp693]

True

[@TylerPCoyne]

If Wes was still here, he would not like the food in this video at all!

[@brandontadoff347]

After binge watching all of the squad vlogs and show w/no name episodes dating back to 2015 when they just barely joined, it makes me so happy to be able to click on their latest vids and still see them together and as close as ever (have nothing against the new members though!) Love em all but it’s just so great to see the connection is still there yk?

[@Goldra93]

They should do a Eat it or Yeet it where they need to ring the bell BEFORE Courtney opens the Cloche to reveal the "food" they have chosen. Maybe give 1 hint to coax them into going for it.

[@Kazutoification]

I was expecting one of them to be "banana, but cold."

[@llewtree3013]

Banana but green

[@samaelkylie]

@@llewtree3013 Banana but apple

[@gummy605]

Banana but its all peeling

[@aff77141]

Banana but melting

[@dogdays7597]

@@samaelkylie thats the first thing i thought

[@glendaDUB]

Garrett dressed as a banana while laughing his ass off is by far the highlight! 🤣

[@chickenfriedmeats1618]

That poor Banana having survived Milkbeans torture devices only to ge torn apart by Olivia

[@draisens]

That was savage from the get go. Like Shayne said once - 'Olivia is from another dimension'

[@blazypika2]

more like milky beanana, amirite?

[@moonray4687]

Noah: *Doesn't like cake* Noah when he eats malic acid banana: "Honestly pretty delicious."

[@vlahakisnick]

Despite all of the dishes on today's episode, Garrett's biggest achievement was putting Milk Bean into a Banana

[@TylerPCoyne]

Sometimes I question his mentality, and how it causes him to do the things he does.

[@supershinigami1]

when was that

[@vlahakisnick]

@@supershinigami1 the whole episode! (Garrett's nickname is Milk Bean)

[@supershinigami1]

@@vlahakisnick how do you know

[@selish2904]

@@supershinigami1 if you actually watch the vids u would know..

[@xyfuras]

If you watch these in order you can noticably see Shayne's sanity crack away like so much old drywall. & Garret is obviously a cartoon villain come to life.

[@alishawty]

i’m so excited to see so much to go wrong in such little time!

[@BaltoSojnekah]

Shayne: "That's a beefy banana. Like that banana went to the gym." Me: So it's a banana if it was Shayne.

[@angelachen2458]

You are what you eat so it's just regular shayne

[@thedrifter5531]

so it was a shaynana?

[@Jubileenie]

Garret, the man who surprises but also makes the most cursed food I’d ever laid eyes on

[@tickledtoffee]

Indeed. And I think this episode contained some of his best (i.e. most heinous) work 🔥💩

[@coolman72891]

aka Milkbean

[@sammiebelle6424]

I saw these ideas and wanted to re share because I thought they were good. -mystery (have to ding in before the cover is lifted) -everyone at the table prepares one dish each for the game, but no one knows who made it when it’s presented

[@Little0Miss0Alice]

"That was potASSium, that was just ass!" Another banger from Kimmy Jimenez of Smosh lol

[@carlosalinas8254]

“Internet don’t make this weird” “Yeet it in my mouth”

[@ccykwok3]

Garrett laughing in a banana costume is just the best 😂

[@TylerPCoyne]

He’s just casually vibing on his phone looking at pictures of Shane and thinking about everyone’s misery!

[@emchammer1831]

You have no idea how much respect I have for the editor after they put that DK64 sound clip in there. Perfect touch.

[@BlackuKnighto]

This is what Donkey Kong's fever dreams look like

[@TylerPCoyne]

**B R U H !**

[@draisens]

Do not!!! Do NOT go there!!!! DDDDDDDDDDOOOOOOOOOOOOO NNNNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOTTTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!

[@Shaduza]

ok im out xD

[@angelomordini6779]

The banana filling is definitely the most impressive thing Garret has done

[@iBrusmaN]

We need a Smosh and order episode with Olivia suing (pun intended) for not getting the half of the banana from Shayne.

[@gabetatoe]

Lol Olivia looks so offended that Shayne didn't split the banana 😂

[@SunDragon1221]

There should be a Eat It or Yeet It where everyone submits a list of food puns, and the final menu is chosen from the combined list

[@dumbeetle]

Yes

[@cyndilouhoo9116]

Can we please acknowledge how adorable Shayne looks swinging his feet because they don’t reach the ground in that stool. As an even shorter person, I relate 😂

[@A_Qwynide]

I want Garrett to do a solo Eat or Yeet with things he's created. Give him 6 things but only 3 skips. Like put a banana in front of him, but he doesn't know if it's cookie butter or worms, and he has to choose to hit the Bell or send it to Hell.

[@nonlokomotor8467]

Yes

[@kurousagi23]

Can we take a moment and appreciate the entire og smosh pit squad is back together for a video

[@NAHArawr]

IDEA: Should do a mystery box lunch similar to the random prop boxes done on Try Not To Laugh. Each box lunch can have a picture or sticker of what kind of food is in the box (a sandwich, fruit, candy, some theme) and it can either be delicious or f*cked with, who knows. Set up all five boxes on the table and bring the wheel back to decide who picks a box and they can choose any of the boxes still left.

[@Naya818ken]

i love how every time garret makes something with worms he has to say they are edible

[@NuramonX_]

You should sell a button that only plays Garret's evil laugh.

[@stream-5star]

Olivia was so cute during her turn 😭 she was just smiling the whole time

[@kaivdm04]

It really feels like Courtney is the main villain in this series and she’s controlling Garret

[@oliveiradmdiogo]

Courtney's more like a servant in this series tbh

[@randomfockingname4719]

No milkbean is using her as a villain cover so suspicion won't fall on him

[@angelabryant9766]

Shayne shouting 'WHHHHHY GOOOOOD' to the heavens with a mouth full of banana is amazing.

[@yach2009]

I think there needs to be more consequences for "yeeting". If someone yeets during the regular bites, they also have to participate in the big bite with the last person standing.

[@Jagger-Tyr_13]

For real. Chumps 🤣

[@AlexSuOfficial]

Oh I love that!!!

[@dafuzzbear7711]

Nah. Some of the dishes are made to be yeeted.

[@Predated2]

I mean, the consequence is already missing out on potential better bananas, or taking a bad one early so you dont have the worst one. Just as not taking any food means you risk getting the worst dish in exchange for the best dish. It would be kinda odd if you yeeted a dish, and then get rewarded with the best dish. It would make more sense that the people who ate it get rewarded with the best dish. But then it would be weird for the people who ate it to get punished with the worst dish because they got lucky. Personally, I think the better solution is that the people who yeet it have to stay in competition and potentially get a worse dish.

[@yach2009]

@@Predated2 I can see it both ways..I had thought of the way you mentioned earlier and I think commented it on a previous video. I just think theres a lot of potential with this game. I also had the idea that they do something similar to the bidding reward challenge in Survivor. I think thatd be interesting..they could even integrate other videos/games to earn currency like TNTL "pays out" monopoly-type money and so does Bored AF and Beopardy to the winners and so on...they can then use that to "bid" on Eat it or Yeet it items.

[@princessadel1631]

You should have a State Fair themed Eat it or Yeet it episode. You could base the dishes off of popular or unusual/weird food items from state fairs all over the country.

[@shubhamnath8888]

It would be a good idea if the Garrett part of the wheel increased by just a little bit each episode, to give the fans hope

[@TylerPCoyne]

YES!

[@logannyf]

Theres no more wheel

[@TylerPCoyne]

@@logannyf que?

[@jocelyn_studios]

@@TylerPCoyne There isn't a wheel anymore its back to the OG format of people ringing the bell, there is no element of chance involved

[@alisaishere]

What wheel? They got rid of it awhile ago.

[@mollyharris6389]

Some ideas for Eat it or Yeet it. 1. Weird Cocktails (Cement Mixer better be one of them.) 2. Fermented Foods 3. Malic Acid Episode (sans Shayne) 4. Pregnancy Cravings 5. State Themed episodes (Both famous and infamous foods) 6. Weird Meat (Gator, Chicken Feet, Pizzle, etc.) 7. All Sandwich (Fluffernutter, Peanut Butter and Pickle, etc.) 8. Snow Cones 9. Soda 10. Build your own Tacos a la the Ramen episode.

[@Dream146]

"We have one thing and one thing only on our minds...Banana's!" Courtney says wearing a lemon shirt.

[@ek7713]

Well, the shirt isnt on her mind is it...Only Banana's there.

[@logannyf]

That's on her body not her mind

[@TylerPCoyne]

This video is brought to you by the color yellow!

[@edibleandsentientautomobil5396]

Shayne should've worn his Lime shirt

[@octoberboiy]

😂😂😂 I’m laughing so hard at the Shayne Topp Banana, laughing so hard I can’t breathe omg. Noah’s face when he was told malic acid eats through the banana 😭😆😂. This is the best Eat it or Yeet It of all time.

[@punishercastle5487]

“I eat green bananas” “Yeet it in my mouth” And yet another vid that shows how weird Olivia is

[@pvic6959]

I thought I loved bananas.. clearly im second only to olivia

[@punishercastle5487]

@@pvic6959 I mean, I think it’s safe to say her love for them isn’t natural

[@TylerPCoyne]

I know Wes is trying to stay as far way from this video as possible right now!

[@kalpic11]

Maybe you knew but it's "Put it In My Mouth" and "Eat It Or Yeet It" combined.

[@aniyilator]

@@punishercastle5487 Well Olivia herself is already supernatural, so that makes sense

[@wolfdemon-sterling5349]

"I like it when they're green." I'm like 60% sure Olivia's talking about plantains

[@olivia6728]

nope, i prefer green bananas too !

[@mrgabest]

In terms of healthiness, a banana is best when it's slightly green. All of the nutrients are there, but it's less sugary. If you wait until it's going a little brown then the flesh will be sweeter, and some of the nutrients will have broken down.

[@hannahsawesomelife914]

I can’t keep a straight face when Garrett is cackling in a banana costume

[@hazeltilder8978]

Love Noah’s impression of dumpster wizard while eating the forth banana

[@michig1845]

that quick cut to garret texting @ 8:19 and the edit they put in killed me 😂😂

[@MysterySteve]

I must be 9 fucking years old because I laughed harder than any other point in this video when Shayne screamed "IT'S POOPYYYYY"

[@ellelim6796]

I’m willing to pay so much money for Milk Bean to teach me how he put peanut butter inside that banana.

[@karmaday8467]

My money's on really thin creamy peanut butter and a hypodermic needle syringe.

[@cairi6711]

There is a device that lets you poke a hole(a bit similar to an applecorer) it will take out a small cylinder of banana and then you can fill it with a syringe. That's why stuff was able to drip out from the bottom of the bananas in the video. It leaves a hole when you do this.

[@karmaday8467]

@@cairi6711 Oooh, that makes so much more sense! Thank you!

[@rickkasutoro880]

11:48 they turn their head away in the same time when Shayne Yeet

[@chickenfriedmeats1618]

Even more apprication for the hand models after the stream ❤

[@Lea-is-sleeping]

Can someone please gif 12:36 where Garrett is just sitting in his banana suit, laughing easily? That moment is the best thing I've ever seen

[@detektiv9196]

0:40 this edit is perfection, kudos kev

[@brandontadoff347]

he left smosh the other day :/

[@tortugapoet]

@@brandontadoff347 aww man! Not the shredditor!

[@szombie]

Keith's face when they actually toss a real banana to Shayne is the best thing that happened to me today

[@brandontadoff347]

watching this live was an absolute blast, it makes everything 10x funnier and I actually felt the anticipation/dread of each dish right there with them haha. can’t wait for the next one this Friday!!

[@aliciaballesteros-mitchell1059]

Milk Bean in a banana suit: They're edible worms!

[@winterwolf7689]

This vid is finally here! Loved watching this on the Twitch stream before. 💙

[@sydneymitrecic]

The look of betrayal on Olivia's face when Shayne took a bit of that banana was priceless

[@smoked_roulette73]

Just seeing Garrett maniacally laughing in a banana suit in the intro is hilarious

[@DarkWatcherDS]

That "how to spell banamda" skit sent me dude I'm crying

[@debduttap173]

11:42 Bananas won't be the same for Shayne anymore. They officially broke the man.

[@MeaganAshley]

Courtney telling Keith “It’s okay”, when he looked at her while his banana was literally shitting, was just so sweet.

[@Crescentknight8189]

Shayne was like "BEGONE, OLIVIA! FOR SHAYNE TOPP SHARES HIS BANANA WITH NO ONE!!"

[@ilovecaulk2542]

Keith chewing that banana with his mouth open is a crime against humanity

[@teehee.1862]

exactly and he really had to tell noah to wipe his mouth at 9:14

[@amybananana]

He always does it and I always skip him

[@Just1for2le3Randoms]

"They're edible worms!" Oh yeah that makes it all better Garret, thanks

[@datastronaut8293]

OH MY GOD just when Shayne said he's banking on the 1% chance the big bite is a banana split, I thought “Quick, douse a banana in malic acid!” lol then it was drippy + Noah’s face, and I KNEW. This is so hilarious but I can't help but imagine if Shayne got it sgcjjfufu

[@mrmadmover]

13:06 Courtney: "while these love birds split the best treat that nature can give." Sam: ...

[@petem6755]

I can see Olivia liking Shayne for sure....

[@Vandarius]

Olivia knew damn well what she was doing when she broke that banana in half. Straight up wanted to see if she could just bite without worrying.

[@ghoesings]

12:03 shayne goes from toddler to angry teenager in 10 seconds

[@Mezzy..]

11:20 shayne: Well there's stuff. sticking. out. of the banana. Courtney: fell like telling us your strategy? Shayne: no.

[@carverlabarberaofficial]

Ok, let's get this straight: Shayne got revenge on garret in eat it or yeet it, he finally got Gus Johnson to laugh, and NOW HE DOESN'T EAT MALIC ACID ON EAT IT OR YEET IT?!? Wow, Shayne's having a good year so far.

[@randomfockingname4719]

Wut but he's good with malic acid

[@ChaoticMushy]

@@randomfockingname4719 malic acid makes his body react weirdly

[@Jebsie]

... Other than the broken ankle...

[@randomfockingname4719]

@@ChaoticMushy true tho but at least it doesn't taste badly to him

[@ChaoticMushy]

@@randomfockingname4719 because malic acid doesn't have a taste. It's just sour

[@wellnessbylauren3767]

Shayne's Monday posts are the only thing keeping me going

[@BRACEwits]

I wish we got a behind the scenes of Garrett cackling away preparing these and pitching ideas and being shot down Especially for this one. How did he get Bolognese in a banana?

[@SammiiSmith420]

Garret saying "They're edible worms!" as if that makes it better. 🤣

[@Morster]

Every Eat it or Yeet it brings me such joy, it is easily my favorite Smosh show 🤩 *Edit* : Is it me or is Noah wearing, “You’re my favorite pizza place!” themed pants? 🤣

[@NeneChanne]

Garret just on his phone is comedy gold 😂

[@emilythompson3756]

We need an EIOYI with everyone, cast and crew… One cast member versus one crew member. They each have to eat the same item, if they eat it, that’s a point. If they yeet, they lose a point.

[@collin.a.]

Bring back Smosh court for Shayne not sharing the banana with Olivia

[@sheilamaerockwell839]

For some reason, i find Noah’s disgusted exclamations the funniest

[@saturnxicana]

it’s actually a good thing that the one person that loves bananas got a good banana, cause i would cry if something i loved got ruined for me this way

[@kaldo_kaldo]

But Shayne didn't get a good banana

[@NinjaRose23]

I feel like Olivia would still not hesitate to eat anything she liked that Garret previously got his hands on, she's chaos lol

[@baukerman100]

Banana: * has protein * Garrett: * puts worms in it * Noah: "Shayne that was a protein banana!" 😆 No, Noah, that's just gross dude.

[@DrakeAJC]

Yeah, I wouldn't count 1.3 grams as having protein. You need that much per day for every 4 lbs you weigh

[@Nox360]

Any time shayne tries to scientifically breakdown a situation, it becomes a nightmare for him

[@alexamjenn]

“That taste like a DMV” ……oh god that’s horrifying

[@SnappyKid17]

I love watching Smosh! You guys are amazing with all of your content!! Huge Shartney fan, but has anyone else noticed Shayne and Courtney’s amazing styles and how it’s changed or evolved over the years? They are amazing!

[@Eagle93A7X]

Olivia only likes her bananas green, meaning when they have the least taste to them... yeah I think Shayne got this :D

[@3llevate]

Those Garrett "phone screen" edit were gold. Kudos to the editors lol PLEASE make that a regular thing!!!

[@crispyliza7050]

Ok but how did Garret fill the bananas???? I need a Hacking Off episode where Shayne and Damien invent different hacks on how to do it and Garret says if their method is anything like his own or not

[@annlyp6303]

Garret laughing maniacally in the banana costume was hilarious

[@TylerPCoyne]

What surprises me the most about this video is that Garrett didn’t do the “Peanut Butter Jelly” dance or the “I’m a Banana” dance in his banana costume!

[@TTV_Hydration]

Normal people- i need the bucket Olivia- yeet it into my mouth Lmfao