Eat It Or Yeet It: Halloween Edition w/ Brandon Rogers

[@shreyamukherjee3638]

The closeups on Amanda's face from time to time is so funny for some reason

[@m.nuruddin9570]

I just wanna know how many people got jumspscare from it 😂

[@emericcson123]

It feels like those viral photos of the stone faced kid dressed as No Face with her preschool classmates crying lol

[@marissamason596]

I thought the same thing

[@KingOfGaymes]

I cracked up every time it zoomed on her 😭

[@lewis5341]

honestly it just made me laugh so hard for some reason 😂

[@sowiejose5712]

Seeing Amanda as the Nun was not something I was expecting to see today

[@cheesecakelasagna]

When I saw them post a sneak peek pic, I was like, Amanda's just made perfect sense!

[@thomasstocks8219]

I didn’t recognize her at first lol

[@Shinryu949]

For a sec I thought it was Erin🥹

[@davidwestlake6047]

Who's Dani supposed to be... Himself??!! 😂😂😂

[@lucimeyers8900]

@@thomasstocks8219same. i was side eyeing her and they i went “oh it’s amanda”

[@juliodelrosario51]

This is the sanest, well-behaved brandon ive ever seen

[@pamelah1220]

He was really trying to be a team player and a good guest ❤

[@HeatherQuinn-Psykhae]

Saaaammeeee it fully gives the same vibes as Samuel Jackson being on sesame Street

[@Meepers_the_Great]

That’s what I was wondering, I was like JESUS CHRIST IS HE OKAY? 😂😂😂

[@randomgachawithvicky8445]

Check Anthony Padilla’s “I’ve spent a day with”

[@alchemist3661]

13:21

[@brotherkhrayn3525]

Amanda broke character REAL quick during her bite 🤣🤣🤣 must’ve been Holy Water 🤣🤣🤣

[@reneehoenicke4765]

It was like she had been possessed and the drink IMMEDIATELY shunted the Nun out so Amanda could be herself 😂

[@hilmiahmad9274]

It's just like someone in a bad mood because of hunger gets to eat🤣

[@chachaluv7]

The fact Olivia actually guessed right on the last bite was hilarious. Tastes human meat and turns out was the Invisible Man. Classic

[@AndrewJW]

She literally said it's human flesh and all the candy. She was double right

[@ksis86]

The random close ups of Amanda smiling with the scream sound effect is perfect 😂

[@gilly_axolotl]

Especially when the scream gets cut off so quick 😂

[@deewmountainz4252]

I found it annoying tbh

[@acoolpieceoflettuce2557]

It was my favorite part

[@rhettmitchell]

@@deewmountainz4252 sorry it was too spoopy for you, I thought I might’ve put too many close-up screams into the video 🥲

[@ImTwerkinAsWeSpeak]

@@deewmountainz4252u must be fun at parties

[@fantasticallyfan]

Amanda saying she’s been trying to get her hands on the blood of christ while dressed as The Nun who was indeed thwarted by the blood of christ in the movies is hilarious.

[@rhettmitchell]

And that he’s been ignoring her

[@kaitlynmorgan4613]

well maybe she could hide the blood of christ so no one could use it against her 😏😏

[@alessiarakaj5309]

not really, its blasphemous..

[@InuInugami]

​@@alessiarakaj5309actually, it's an opinion, and people can have their own.

[@InuInugami]

Maybe she wasn't The Nun from the movie and she was just A nun

[@willscarlet0]

Olivia’s dish was literally the “ I HOPE YOU’RE HUNGRY…FOR NOTHING”!

[@sagegreeeeeeen]

But I think it was a good practice for their acting

[@mixmastermind]

The most brutal gift of all... NOOOOOOOTHIIIIIING

[@AcesGym]

You get nothing good day sir

[@Missteree87]

​@@mixmastermindMetalocalypse nice 🤘🏽

[@savannah4439]

I can only assume these are filmed decently far in advance, so I’d like to imagine her walking around all day in that terrifying nun costume in like August 😂

[@hadleyritter2549]

I think it's more like 2 weeks in advance. Still pretty hilarious ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@desertrose3511]

@@hadleyritter2549yeah I agree

[@maddieleigh20xx96]

They filmed this mid September

[@JeskidoYT]

​@@maddieleigh20xx96still so long ago

[@maddieleigh20xx96]

@@JeskidoYT yeah absolutely

[@kevinmartin2318]

The millisecond horror re-cut to Amanda after “crows are friends” absolutely killed me. 11/10 editing

[@BaloneyPeep]

I love how everyone was explaining their costumes and then Olivia is just "And I'm a pumpkin :D"

[@SuperFlawless2010]

Damn, not even a sexy pumpkin from HIMYM

[@Venomonomonom]

Pink drink?

[@adrianazilova3513]

genius move on Damien’s part - taking the first dish, so he can show off that slay Sanji costume asap 🫶🤣🤣

[@rhettmitchell]

Exactly what I thought

[@nibberfabbot5592]

Good thing he didn't spit out the food or else it would've been a disgrace on sanji's name

[@thespankmyfrank]

Olivia was 100% the right person for the big bite lmao, she played that off perfectly.

[@kalyguti24]

“OH MY GOD THERE’S SMOKE INSIDE IT” was said with such visual emotion I had to replay that at least 3 times 😂

[@Kouttta]

I’m glad I wasn’t the only. I replayed that 10 seconds probably 5 times to take in Amanda’s comment and chance.

[@_simply_distracted_]

We NEED Brandon on the couch for Shane’s Reddit story times, like PLEASE, also love you guys, this was awesome!!

[@HP-io2qu]

Yes please! :3

[@freedomcat]

And have him do his Blitz(o) voice. (The o is silent.

[@EmpCalick]

​@@freedomcatthats just his regular voice, if you close your eyes and listen to him talk its same

[@SplatoonSLAYS]

YASSSS LETS GET A PETITION

[@KaraLacuna]

@@EmpCalickthey went the Steven universe route for the voice acting which I kinda love cause it connects the characters and their VA’s together beautifully 🥲

[@Tigerlilly22]

Thank you editors for every zoom in on Amanda's face and the scream sfx it SENT ME every time lmao. What an amazing costume!!

[@inoroth2001]

I think it's my favorite part of the whole video.

[@angel2mosha]

that was so goddamn funny

[@TooHighCat]

FOR REAL!! I /had/ to re-watched some

[@Magalicious4508]

Replayed every single time😅

[@ungoodthinkful]

I don't think I've ever laughed as hard as I did when Chanse gave his little "what the fuæh" after trying the skull potion

[@jordanpeterson5140]

Doesn't Chanse also have Grave Mouth?

[@grey6703]

@@jordanpeterson5140am i stupid what does that mean

[@RenataKaleah]

@@grey6703they always say Shane has “grave mouth” because malic acid doesn’t affect him. It seemed that Chanse had it too since he usually isn’t much affected by malic acid. I think the reason he had a strong reaction this time was to the bitrix. He said he didn’t think it was sour but bitter

[@PineappleMemess]

Amanda just going “crows are good friends” and the close up at 10:37 made me choke on my drink 💀

[@petrichoranddreams2276]

YES! I ABOUT DIED LAUGHING 😂😂

[@Poefeathyr]

I love how Brandon Rogers is in this and yet Amanda is the star of this episode

[@BoyMac13]

Brandon is such a fun guest for this format!! Also, knowing this was Amanda’s actual Halloween costume makes this episode even better.

[@crschreier]

Olivia getting the opportunity to make-up literal nonsense is incredible…A+

[@abstractfriends6722]

yesss!

[@jacobhogan3208]

I love how the bib hides the fact Damian is wearing a costume, especially when he's opposite Amanda who is basically unrecognizable.

[@alexicon18]

Olivia: Hi, Barbie! Courtney: Hi, Barbie! Amanda: hI bArBiE Chanse: No....... 🤣🤣🤣

[@avagoh]

wasnt that brandon who said no?

[@Verylengthyapple]

1:18

[@andad]

good question they sound similar @@avagoh

[@demetriam2408]

​@@avagohthey can sound pretty similar with those short responses but I'm decently sure that was Chanse

[@bestnumberever73]

The behind the scenes look at Garrett making nothing... *chef's kiss* The commitment to the bit was SCARY good. XD

[@Venya9]

”That’s in my top 3 textures for sure” as a fellow neurodivergent I felt that in my bones 😂

[@whitehuayra]

Food texture is personal taste/preference. Has nothing to do with nuerodivergency.

[@Sarnatuile]

@@whitehuayra Some people just like to feel unique, hah.

[@emass1620]

@@Sarnatuilegod, so true.

[@awhellyeah12]

@@whitehuayraexcept enhanced sensitivity to texture definitely has something to do with neurodivergence

[@Alex-ut5ou]

​@@whitehuayrait has a lot to do with it actually. Its common for people who are neuro divergent to have insanely heightened senses, I would know. And because of this certain foods can be impossible to eat just because of how they feel. I can't eat grits and beans for this reason.

[@yanica2568]

Amanda as a nun is literally the best part lmao

[@alessiarakaj5309]

it's literally disrespectful.

[@springtronic.]

@@alessiarakaj5309?

[@janine2957]

@@alessiarakaj5309 we could not care less girl get a real problem

[@DancerMusicanActress]

​@@alessiarakaj5309she's just like the nun from the horror movie the nun.......

[@alessiarakaj5309]

@@janine2957 thats because you arent part of this religion. you have NO say.

[@berriescream9538]

chanse freaking out at Damien’s bite has me DYING 😂😂

[@jahnabanana]

Chanse freaking out is an EIOYI staple at this point. If his own dish doesn't break him, someone else's will. This show has broken that man. :P

[@reddale5952]

“It’s too big it’s too big”😂😂

[@tanmanpop4266]

I love Brandon Rogers so much. New helluva boss just dropped!

[@Kate-qi7rn]

His screams would be perfect for a soundboard

[@lacylove3052]

Im losing it at Damiens "I gotta focus up" as Chanse is almost out of his seat!!!! 😂

[@meghannicole1474]

I don't know why, but Amanda saying, "Oh my God, b*tch! This looks awesome!", while dressed as The Nun made me laugh too hard! 🤣

[@Sunnyomori649]

Brandon should definitely be featured on the channel more. He works so well with the cast for real. Its also always great to see Olivia as well.

[@MeghanEM3]

Olivia’s commitment to the bit is always incredible!!!

[@abimorrisonpossibleplantba9783]

I loved that she was like bye family lol when they were eating the pumpkin literally my favorite!!

[@sanjusansanjana]

The entire sequence during Olivia's turn genuinely felt like a fever dream, I kept expecting something to happen and then nothing did? Lmao 😭

[@BearManVern]

I'm so high right now watching it is like a mindfuck

[@MetalWald]

Damien saying that something is one of the worst things he ever tasted with this suuper calm and relaxed face made me really look up to him.

[@grey6703]

him saying anything is bad is rare, so that statement from him truly hits much harder than if it were from anyone else. you know it’s fucking rancid

[@rhettmitchell]

Yeah he usually loves everything lmao. I’m not surprised by how calm he was though

[@odgykins]

The editing for Amanda was killing me 😂

[@4PawSquad]

Amanda's nun character and Chance's terror at everything was so great

[@sn0wyc0sm0]

Seeing Brandon Rogers on Smosh is the most unexpected surprise and I couldn’t be happier

[@Enderwave22]

Ikr. Feeling the same.

[@wyrvern8010]

You can't tell me that Olivia didn't show up to the set and said "Oh, it's Halloween themed today? Ok, just give me whatever costume we have in store and i'll make it work." and im surprised it did 😂

[@aNoMyNous_I_am]

Patrick has worn that same costume before, lol.

[@demitriussmith741]

It would actually make more sense if Olivia thought it was a regular day and came dressed like that anyways lol

[@wyrvern8010]

@@demitriussmith741 You're not wrong now that i think about it

[@boomgirlbucko]

It's videos like this that show just how shy Brandon really is when he's not playing a character

[@mrcheshire104]

FR seeing Brandon freak tf out after accidentally hitting Chanse's hand at the bell was so strange

[@Prof.GoodFeels88]

I almost never laugh to the point of spitting out my drink. "Dulce & Gabbana" made me spray all over my desk as I was sipping.

[@The_Midnight_Writer]

I love everyone’s costumes this year! Damien dressed as Sanji is something I’m so here for!

[@bakfietspriester]

Factsss

[@regularheather4830]

Amanda just being herself at the table in this costume is absolutely sending me!

[@alma37551]

Almost didn’t recognize Amanda her costume is AMAZING!!

[@BusinessSkrub]

Olivia's little punkin costume is beyond adorable 😭

[@madelineweickert4133]

Damien's ability to describe the atrocity of the dishes is something I come here for. Such poetry!

[@Mckayla_Muffins]

He was dead on with the Vegemite description too

[@lanamadness1439]

Damien as Sanji is an absolute DELIGHT! Also Damien’s lil face scrunch blinks are the best thing. Lighten my heart so much😭

[@blaaarrgggggg]

The editor really knocked it out of the park today with the Amanda edits. So fucking funny

[@LOLWAAHH]

Amanda really got into character until she saw Jesus during her bite 😂

[@AceinHyperspace8922]

Just, shout out to the editing team because the music, the lights, the zoom ins on Amanda.... Perfection

[@lilacsky8833]

4:28, Chanse's entire reaction to Damien's dish made me laugh so hard but this moment especially

[@ShayHavok]

Also, I love Olivia, please more Olivia. She's my fav and she was so freaking funny in this. Absolutely hilarious.

[@BeanBread-2008]

Yesss

[@lexiekaboom]

Chanse not learning from Angela's mistake and yelling "That's too big, that's too big, Damien"... good luck in the compilations

[@k_fuller]

That's going straight to smosh out of context

[@KingQueerio]

Oh god 😂

[@Nekrozz4]

worthy of listen to this with your eyes shut bit/challenge

[@milkteamarwa]

the scream before it too makes it extra hilarious out of context

[@syra1541]

LMFAOO

[@JustAMulti]

Amanda's "He's not talking to me right now" killed me 😂😂😂

[@paytonalysse3574]

I was just about to comment this😂

[@teethfacts2671]

Chanse’s “how did you find him” so seriously is hilarious

[@33p3rs]

When Brandon said "I eat blood" or "It was either this or nude" I immediately pictured Blitz saying that

[@toastedcabbage2791]

The cutting to Amandas face with the scream has me laughing each time! Thanks for that!

[@JaimeCard]

Chanse being so concerned about how Garrett found the invisble man is hilarious 😂

[@fishbo_uses_soap]

The absolute joy on Olivia's face when the big bite was nothing.

[@Joyboy9891]

Damien sliding the m&m’s to chance and saying “chance this one’s for you” cracked me up

[@imaginaryenemy2565]

He was gunning for a Peamutbubber cup

[@AlwaysxLively05]

Same! Took me all the way out! 😂

[@AlwaysxLively05]

Same! Took me all the way out! 😂

[@Rrusso92]

So subtle!!

[@imaginaryenemy2565]

@Rrusso92 lol right when he's excited or wants something he looses all his chill

[@EnjoyingLife930]

Olivia's "That's my cousin" caught me off guard😂

[@ImNotElijah]

I love Brandon Rogers SO MUCH! Seeing him was the ultimate surprise! Plus the video he just uploaded is hilarious!

[@ryder389]

Seeing Brandon Rogers being weirded out by Damien at the end is so funny 😂 I didn’t think Brandon could ever be weirded out by anything!

[@jersenshadowz]

I just wanna say thank you Kevin for your editing of Amanda in this, I laugh everytime the zoom ins and scream come in😭😭

[@SweetCarolineBAMBAMBAM]

Brandon has never seemed more wholesome and chill 😅

[@rosykindbunny1313]

I'm kinda loving chill Brandon

[@Dwoalin]

I’ve never heard Garret say “that’s too big of a scoop” 😳 I quite enjoy Marmite but two jars? 💀 The Garrett poison causing everyone to have out of body experiences 🤣 Olivia getting the Big Bite suited her too well. The jump cuts to Amanda as the Nun made my day ❤️

[@WrenRemm]

0:48, 1:21, 7:54, 8:30, 10:38, 12:26, 12:34, 14:52, 15:43, 16:04, 19:28, 23:27 Thanks for inviting Brandon on the channel

[@dionneeee18]

Thank you for the timestamps!

[@liriodendronlasianthus]

Thank you I love these

[@icedteapancake159]

All of the cuts to Amanda with the split second screams are killing meeeee

[@TheDarkSide73914]

I NEVER KNEW I NEEDED THIS CROSSOVER SO BAD UNTIL I GOT IT

[@caracat2076]

Garrett having to explain his costume was so dad vibes wholesome 🤣🤣🤣🤣❤️❤️

[@elizabethanne4400]

Amanda is an icon. She is the moment. Stunning performance.

[@JYang0602]

Amanda as The Nun feels like a new Smosh character that I’m thinking of calling “Reassuring Nun”😂😂

[@Im_Behind_You]

Seeing Olivia again after so long feels like a fever dream. I thought she left smosh

[@samanthahartley6841]

I was just wondering the other day if she was still around

[@rhettmitchell]

Yeah she had to have been on vacation or filming something

[@justsomeguywithhalfamustac6837]

I think she got a marvel role

[@moonriverinc7896]

I think on the podcast they said she just does Smosh part time now to make room for her other projects.

[@Stuie299]

There's always that moment when they bring on a guest you're unfamiliar with, where it takes you a minute to figure out how they're going to effect the episode. But honestly Brandon Rogers completely understood the assignment. He just read the room and absolutely nailed it.

[@cliffordbunton8788]

Chanse, Damien and Amanda were absolutely killing it. It's nice to see Miles Morales getting more representation...

[@RyanG0899]

More? He's had way too much representation already lol

[@becky7433]

@@RyanG0899and it’s still not enough.

[@rhettmitchell]

@@RyanG0899he needs more

[@Dietskittles]

The editing was top notch! Every zoom on nun Amanda had me in stitches 🤣

[@Buggsamillion]

The invisible dish bit was the most fun I’ve had in a while

[@esinger23]

Amanda: I bet they’re good Brandon: I bet they’re human Me: 😂😂😂

[@Mariposa_oo]

thats where our wings went

[@Whathappensifidothis4]

Being obsessed with the spiderverse movies and seeing Chanse dressed as Miles made my day tbh

[@aleandra3945]

amanda saying "dolce and gabbana" as the Nun will be stuck in my brain forever

[@mmproh]

Chanse’s deadpan “how did you find him?” Sent me😂

[@Smv09]

Damien as Sanji AND then directly quoting the live action AND Chanse as Miles Morales .. YES YES YES and YES obsessed YES 😭😭😭

[@fightmonkey4750]

This was such a fantastic episode of EIYI. Amanda's costume, Brandon Rogers, the big bite, and Garrett's poison effect on everyone. 😂

[@fictionalheroine]

Olivia is the perfect person to get that big bite. She's just the right amount of weird for that.

[@emilybarron5073]

a collab we weren’t expecting but are very excited for

[@NeonWafflez707]

I expected it because of the community post

[@soy3581]

I love Chanse's eyes, they hold so much emotion

[@RearMostline95]

Olivia saying “That’s my cousin!” Had me laughing

[@alertArchitect]

Brandon actually works with Smosh so well, I hope he does a TNTL and some other stuff too!

[@whoami.24601]

Amanda in the nun costume was killing me the entire time. The constant close ups lmao

[@IceMetalPunk]

Amanda: "It's like warheads." Me: "Oh, so malic acid." Amanda: "And rinds. Burnt rinds." Me: "Also Bitrex? Damn." Milkbean is predictable, but that's still a devilish combination 😂 It's so perfect you got the demon head of IMP himself in for this episode!

[@itsbombervr8611]

Missed opportunity to have him dress as a demon

[@matthewelliott7294]

@@itsbombervr8611I agree

[@zanderblankenship3849]

Shayne would think that was just water or something

[@emilyspruill3702]

@@zanderblankenship3849 hahaha!

[@hmmm6145]

Oh honestly i didn’t even need to hear any comments from her i just saw the visceral reaction and Knew

[@soysaucelover12]

i’m so high. everything the editor does makes me fucking die. amanda’s zooms 😂😂😂😂

[@missybarbour6885]

The inviable plate improv game was already funny, but seeing Garett mime invisible food prep??? Gold.

[@KillerFr0st07]

Been praying for this day when Brandon Rogers would finally make an appearance on Smosh!! With Anthony back, I knew it was only a matter of time!!!

[@MongoTheMagnificent666]

Holy crap, I honestly didn't even put 2 and 2 together on that, but it makes so much sense now!

[@ToneTone126]

I missed Olivia. I feel like we rarely see her these days!

[@cristiebell4584]

💯

[@RoyaleMusical]

same! i legit commented the exact same thing!

[@4everTogether94]

Damien scooting the peanut M&Ms over the Chanse was the funniest part of the whole vid

[@c_eggy]

"Sorry, I don't last long'' destroyed me im wheezing

[@jennahuh6228]

I’m so excited to see if they collab more with Brandon! This energy was ridiculous, it felt like a clash of characters, they all played into their costumes really well 😊

[@estetkaninen]

Damien as Sanji might just be my favorite ☺️

[@kinetsu8115]

Amanda is the best thing that's ever happened to Smosh.

[@soupy_soup2]

I applaud Brandon's bravery for trying every dish.

[@xbeccalynn24]

I feel like all 90s babies wore a similar costume to olivias at one point in their lifetime 😂😂😂 memory unlocked.

[@nehamaw]

that big bite was peak comedy lol. incredible improv

[@samanthahicks354]

Amanda as the scary nun MADE this episode 100% one of the top 5 Eat it or Yeet it episodes. Amazing 😂