Economic History of Pakistan - 1947-1987 - Khurram Hussain -

[@CVRao-fz4je]

Dr Khurram Hussain is lucid in his presentation. One rare Pakistani who is fluent with english and make persons like me to understand the Pakistan history.

[@akramjameel4765]

بہت ھی مُنفرد انداذ سے محلومات لوگوں تک پہنچائی گی مجموعی طور پر عمدھ پروگرام ھے اس کامیاب کاوش پر پوری ٹیم مُبارک باد کی مُستحق ھے

[@vaidehivihari3601]

What's interesting is, there's so much intellectual capital coming out of this part of the world and yet it doesn't seem sufficient to end our problems! Take a bow Shehzad, you're doing a phenomenal job! 💯

[@vineetraina119]

Lolzzzz,😭🤣 seems you have intellectual deficiency ...Khurram spoke the gold not shehzad.

[@thelonelyvoice5501]

Lga nhi tha tumhe es trah Ka podcast psand hoga

[@KanishQQuotes]

Intellectual capital? You mean the Marxist brigade

[@Dhhu333]

Not that part of world, all renowned South Asian intellectuals are indian

[@nicholasbourbaki7536]

Please bring Khurram again to cover the other 30 years. I am an Indian and only now learn about Pakistani economic history. I did not realize until now that you had 5 year plans there just as you had here. The point about F16 was very insightful. One plane and such a big deal for the whole country’s economy ! Shows you the real harm lack of peace has caused - what else is out there even if not on the same scale. Wonder if there are such hidden gems in Indian economic history.

[@vkalyan]

I am surprised this program doesn’t have millions of Pakistani views. Very informative and intelligent discourse🙏

[@khandadadada]

Bring this guy again. Probably one of the best podcast i have seen in recent times

[@AM-jr9lg]

Kyoun Atif Mian ka pasand nahi aya

[@waliullah1206]

Brooo khurram Hussain makes me realise im born today as of understanding about economy of Pakistan every second of your podcast much more informative than any book containing the Pakistani history

[@szuberi]

This was perhaps the most intellectual discussion I have seen on your channel. Wonderful work and an a great learning opportunity.

[@hamzakhurram8912]

BEST EPISODE HANDS DOWN. Respect for Khurram Hussain yaar.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@future_islookinginvisible]

happy diwali all of pakistan

[@shoaibchaudhry550]

Happy Diwali Salman khan g...

[@mangishumail]

Happy Diwali

[@future_islookinginvisible]

@believerofcreator world advance ma

[@ahmedrazamughal]

Happy diwali 🪔

[@Cattycattycat]

@@manteshsharma9351 6 months advance mein

[@anuragbhatt6234]

Congratulations Shahzad for 40k subscribers. I am an Indian and I just love the content you provide to international audience especially to indians about pakistan. There are so many misconceptions earlier I had about pakistanis, these podcasts are the best way to understand more about pakistan. Thank you for creating this ❤️

[@kajokutz]

Would love if you suggest some similar podcast from your side as well.

[@samidhchoudhury5809]

@@kajokutz Ranveer allahbadia is decent.

[@arunsar7893]

@@kajokutz If you really like nuanced views on long podcasts similar to what The Pakistan Experience does, listen to 'The Seen and the unseen' . Ranveer Allahbadia's podcast is like the Big Boss of podcasts with a lot of masala and very less substance, and hence naturally more popular.

[@arunsar7893]

@@csheru Awasthi Ji .. Get a job, a life and a brain transplant.

[@orion7326]

@@kajokutz Raj Shamani & Dostcast. But the themes of those are very different. If you want to understand India, watch masters' union. It's mostly a business podcast but has a lot of genuine talk about Indian society. Humans of Bombay is also good.

[@MrNikintel]

It took 3 days to completely understand and fact checking , its 100% pure gold.

[@kpopenjoyer2039]

What sources did you use to fact check this?

[@orion7326]

@@kpopenjoyer2039 Only one. Internet.

[@indrajitgupta3280]

The Kissinger visit was paved by the scion of the Dhaka Nawab-bari, Khwaja Mohammed Kaisar, who was then the Pakistani Ambassador to China.

[@subbiahsivakumar]

This is a rarely seen discussion in the Pakistani media these days...congratulations! Good to see this tenacious persuit of good common sense in Pakistan

[@ssmujoo]

My favorite guy. He is much more informed than so called pin headed pakistani economists.

[@shehryargondal3084]

congratulations on 40k. Love your latest streak of podcasts. This guest is a great choice for commentary on Pakistani economy. Very excited for this one 🥳🥳

[@DiscussionBegins]

I'm delighted to spend my 2 hours listening to you both! Kudos

[@mohanvirick2600]

This is the best podcast I have heard in recent past Enlightening and in simple way to understand events Do present more of content of this quality

[@F-Khan491]

Perfect unfiltered dig into our history. TPE once again proves to be the best in this business! Thank you Shahzad.

[@prashant231991]

Ye ek bahut achhi podcast maza aa gya.. by the way i am your big fan from the start...🙏🙏

[@prashant231991]

@@ThePakistanExperience happy deepawali bhai.🙏🙏

[@aliakram799]

Yoi are doing a Great job, just shows how much basic education is needed. I once randomly played your podcast but then couldn't stop it until finished. I realy appreciate that the talks and knowledge is unbiased,comprehensive and relative. Keep it up, hopefully one day we ll see our country and country men rising with pride among the nations.

[@BM-ym5ik]

Saw this today. Excellent analysis and history lesson by Khurram. All students in schools should listen to this. All true. I grew up in early 60s and remember travelling back to Calcutta to meet my grandmother, easily! But we couldn't visit our other relatives in hyderabad ir bombay!. Then growing up in East Pakistan I saw the discrimination against bengalis. I can safely now say the punjabi mindset against bengalis and other minorities destroyed the Pakistan Quaid wanted to create. A shia. Where shias are now persecuted. No wonder I feel strongky Pakistan was an error, it divided families and created a super rich punjabi army exclusive elitist club!

[@alokranjan5410]

Loved it.....lots of love and happy diwali shehzad Bhai

[@ahsanhabib9820]

Excellent podcast,KH is indeed knowledgeable and articulate.He let me identified some of my own biases that I had about economic history of pakistan

[@aparna19kabiraj]

"yeh hum kya Kar rahe Hain is mulk mein ? " Being and Indian, this is a question that we ask ourselves about certain things going on in our backyard as well. And I think there is hope for democracy to remain in till such questions are being allowed to ask. I am in no position to comment about Pakistani economics / politics because we never had any exposure to anything Pakistani except the wonderful TV soaps and of course the K issue ( with not so wonderful superlatives attached) . The reason such podcasts should keep happening is to show the world and your neighbours that there is also an intellectual discussion on real issues happening right now and that a new generation of Pakistanis are leading the game. So much maturity in the way everybody talks ( this and other episodes). Keep up the good work. You must have a great following around the world, from people belonging to the subcontinent.

[@peacelover2002]

I feel Shahzad to be a very talented youngester. He has very good oratorial skills and very good knowledge. Keep up your good work, Shahzad!!! You are very different and more interesting from other Podcasts coming out of pakistan that I have heard. This is coming from an Indian American, BTW.

[@peacelover2002]

@@ThePakistanExperience Keep up the good work, brother!!!

[@peacelover2002]

@Ex-Muslim Khan - IIT Bombay When i have a universe size knowledge to learn from holy Bhagavad Gita and have a travel a long way to master it, then why should I search for other sources?

[@arunsar7893]

Accurate. What other Pakistani Podcasts do you listen to?

[@Socio-Perspective]

@@arunsar7893 Mooroo is nice

[@arunsar7893]

@@Socio-Perspective Will check it out. Thanks.

[@shekharjuvekar7248]

Khurram Hussain spoke with such a crystal clear clarity of thoughts, articulation and a matter of fact attitude that I was cleared of so many misconceptions about Pakistan. Specially his thoughts on Ayub Khan regime, impact of F16 deals (I thought it was a military aid) on Pakistan's economy and IMF loan in 1987 were eye opener. Shehjad conducted the interview brilliantly.

[@prehmemon]

This episode should be made a mandatory part of our Pakistan Studies curriculum.

[@arunsar7893]

Loved your podcast.

[@shivas9600]

Truth is haram 😂

[@iftyz263]

Excellent podcast Shehzad. One of the best I've watched. Khurram Hussain really should write a book (or two) on the history of Pakistan's economy.

[@AbdulBasitAchakzai]

What a great person Khurram Hussain ...He was more honest than being more philosophical

[@azmatsehar]

OMG this is fascinating revelation, hopefully Pakistani youth will watch this, this interview should be made mandatory in all Universities of Pakistan great job @the Pakistan Experience team

[@echosmith5256]

what was the revelation here? sounds pretty standard for someone who studies pak history

[@AnkitSingh-up2zr]

Regular watcher of your show. Always so interesting discussion here. And this episode was so interesting as usual. Keep the good work up.

[@vlarvind6513]

Take a bow sir 🙇🏻‍♂️ , fast becoming one of my fav podcasts 😊

[@hanzofunai4238]

Khurram Hussain is articulate, erudite and informed, Lots of respect from India. Typically, one observes that a Pakistani analyst has world view shaped by prejudices and narratives, Thier analysis are also oversimplified dumbed down versions missing out on the nuances or context. Khurram Hussain redeems the typical Pakistani analyst by his intellectual integrity, More power to you and lots of respect from across the border. Shahzad , you are doing a fab job. A brilliant foil to your guests and getting the best of them.

[@amandeepsangha2308]

This to me is your best episode so far on your channel. Very precise, to the point, no hold back but backed with data and credibility

[@haroon420]

This podcast episode was more fascinating than even the Miftah podcast.

[@saadamin79]

Brilliant podcast. Getting better with everyone. Much appreciated Shehzad

[@bandoiler]

great podcast ! and that ZAB mimicry was spot on ! 😀😀

[@ThePakistanExperience]

😅

[@ahmedhussankh3546]

What a great lesson in history. Khurram is a gem. You should have at least a podcast a week or two like this. Please invite more economic historians. Also invite futuristic economists like atif. Well done my Jiyala bhai (I am a PTI fan btw)

[@Anonymous_1290-k8h]

Great guest. Please bring khurram sb. back on the podcast

[@ilmahussain4336]

One of your best episodes! Also shared it with my dad, he loved it too.

[@AS-sf7hr]

Brilliant Khurram Hussain 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟Thank you Shehzad 👍💖

[@arsalkassana3360]

Never listened to the whole podcast ever before. A great conversation to listen to.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@mirahkhalid7791]

Best 2 hours of my current year on KZbin ❤️❤️

[@Padosidesi2828]

Always impressed by Khurram Hussein’s analysis and the breadth of knowledge he has regarding the political economy of the world.

[@sibgharehman6291]

At 38:18 can you give the source or something to know more about these military purchases

[@fatimariaz5432]

Great one Shehzad! Khurram has to be invited again for at least 2 more podcasts

[@zainisb]

Loved every bit every second of the podcast. A completely paid content that must be something at Hopin with $100 per participation. (per halat achhe nhi so keep it free). Economy is one of the most difficult subjects and Mr Khurram has put it very very simply. Thank you Shahzad.

[@wanibaloch241]

Thank you Shahzad Thank you Khurrum Hussan my favourites. From Balochistan. ❤

[@AzeemaFaizunnisa]

Very engaging and illuminating. Please bring him back to discuss the economic history from the nineties till now.

[@MadhanNaran]

I don't understand much Urdu, but I am impressed with net worth of the content of this discussion and what I can understand. It is so interesting open and relevant. Thank You

[@kareemkhka]

Thanks to TPE team .. please bring this guy for 2 more podcasts .. second episode should be for the remaining 30-40 years and third one should be about what's the way forward ?

[@sohailosmanali6499]

Very interesting open, frank pod cast with Khurram Hussain who is admirably a no nonsense man. Thank you for this,Shahzad. Please get him back to discuss 1987 onwards.

[@drsubashn4025]

One of my very favourite writers. I wait for his article in Dawn every Thursday.

[@taylorsbikeodyssey]

Such a gem of conversation, Thanks Shahzad bhai.

[@nitin-wb7lt]

What a great podcast! Such an interesting interview and kept wonderful pace.

[@fahd6757]

Please Bring Khurram back for 87-23

[@sau002]

Wonderful. I like the words at 13:10, ""reading the present into the past, "...the relationship between the present and the past is a very tense one.... and that is why history keeps getting re-written ......"

[@Zubair-Khan]

when British Empire conquered Sindh they made Sindhi Language Mandatory for Britain officers and current Alphabet of Sindhi actually made by British language scholar to teach these officers. They didn't do this in Punjab or KP .. this was a clear predecessor example for our elders but they bypass that and we lost Bangladesh and still we have Sindhi and Urdu controversy in Sindh. My thinking is that our founder were actually not political minds they were just made leaders to rule Pakistan, While India was Lucky they have brilliant political Minds when India got independence

[@asadgondal9660]

Only 1 hr through and my mind is actually blown. Thank God I discovered you on Twitter and got to watch this. I am inclined towards PTI but I try to make sense of and find the rationale for all sides. This podcast (so far) has already inspired me to dig deeper into economics and how power and money works. The contrast between what actually happened and what I was taught in school about the Golden Era of Ayub Khan and the Independence of Bangladesh is extremely stark. History can never be changed - no matter if you rewrite and teach absolute lies to the younger generation. I see many people saying many things about you on twitter but keep it up. You are doing an amazing job. Thanks for this. Continuing watching now. Couldnt help write this comment in middle of the podcast.

[@mithsindia5150]

very learned person. dont understand much about pak economy,but he explains well. Shehzad you are helping students of ur country who have to give entrance exams, history is much easy to learn by conversation than reading boring white notes😊

[@ranjitneelakandan9551]

Shehzad ...your recent podcasts have been top class.Well informed and you seem to know how exactly to engage your hosts. Khurram saab is as usual phenomenal. I have observed that he says "hoyaga" instead of "hoga" like in "esa hoyaga" instead of "esa hoga" not sure if this is a karachi thing.

[@sridharsm366]

Impressive discussion, a lot of other history I am learning.

[@fanthony]

Khurram Hussain is gifted. Enjoyed this and learned so much. He is very much in the mould of India’s intellectual giants in the last 30 years. No fake ass, wannabe posh accent like many of Pakistan’s older elites (looking at you, Bilawal), and not biased and brainwashed and idiotic like many of the more Islamist/nationalistic Pakistani commentators. This man would be someone really important in India. Tragic that Pakistan isn’t able to do more with someone of his exceptional talents.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Part 2 with him goes up tomorrow

[@bhaaratsharma6023]

What a brilliant and insightful podcast. Shahzad you are are my favorite pakistani podcaster. I really admire your deep knowledge about various topics. Kudos from India. Keep up the good work. Please call Hussain saab again

[@JaaR_D]

Earned a subscriber from Jhanjheri, Punjab, India... Intellectual talks

[@TheDoc4kids]

Cogent, dispassionate, erudite, scholarly analysis ! Bravo !

[@oShahji]

Does Mr. Khurram have any social media or maybe some platform where one can follow him?

[@basicecon]

Just a small addition: debt chain in the power sector is referred to as Circular because the ultimate cost is borne by the govt as most of the power distribution companies (discos) are state owned. The govt lends these companies to pay off the outstanding loans, so the debt cycle goes round and round...

[@zaidikmc]

An eye opener for the viewers.....! Brilliant analysis by Khurram Sir!

[@josephcleetus2075]

Conscience prevails... May God Bless those who has the will and courage to express it🙏

[@AbdullahKhan-zt6rq]

Very well explained by Khurram Hussain Sahab

[@blazingsun8862]

This conversation is illuminating.

[@santhanakrishnanindhumathy4514]

He's so knowledgeable. Good onya Mr Hussain. Thanks for this podcast bud. Cheers.

[@ayeshafareedsyed8560]

Great man. Interesting discussion.

[@sridharsm366]

Guys I think the more you guys are going to keep looking back, the more you are going to get despair. Break the shackles of past and move on. There is always a new way forward and new ending possible if you apply yourself to it according to the present and future needs. You are not doing anything good for your youth in repeating and highlighting past mistakes. Set UAE or Saudi as example to emulate and change everything in Pakistan.. things will change slowly and steadily.

[@TariqMehmood-nz6jp]

Loved it. Very well explained. Hats off to you both.

[@rabiashafi6500]

Thanks khurram Hussain sahib...u cleared lots of concepts

[@nafyachakzai7359]

Thanks bro for inviting such an intellectual personality. It is really very informative and interesting episode.

[@SuperZain121]

This is the only Pakistani podcast channel that I admire.

[@SuperZain121]

@@ThePakistanExperience actually, Thank you for making such an amazing authentic and useful content.

[@obaidullahkhan925]

Please have him back for a discussion on the current economic scenario and what the future holds for Pakistan

[@jayaslam1763]

Please ask him the following questions in next session: 1- What portion of the economic pie in total or as % total is consumed by armed forces? 2- How much of it is spent on expenses related to salaries and pensions? 3- How much of this expenditure is waste in various forms of corrupt practices and kick backs in purchase of arms?

[@tahirmahmood6796]

I thank Shehzad for setting a high standard of journalism.... if podcast is journalism!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@randmht9976]

Finished the Podcast. What a great great Podcast.

[@Metalfreak327]

This was nothing short of awesome. Amazing. Thank you Khuram and Shehzad.

[@n2201]

It seems like the elite and landlords who were ruling Pakistan right from its creation had no need for a vision or reason to develop the lives of the masses they were fine where they were. They had no competition and wanted none. We always talk about the few families that rule the country.

[@adityajoshi1586]

1:59:45 - Can you please say 'dekhe ye ek tareeka hai' in Musharraf's voice. That phrase is a trademark in Musharraf's lingo

[@rehanahmed1088]

Interesting podcast.. waiting for the next part .. keep it up shehzad ..

[@DiscussionBegins]

Please bring part 2

[@mahnoorzia174]

Bundle of thanks Sir.. for your podcasts... Kindly do make short videos on how economy of a country works , how stock exchange works , how there is rise and fall in price of dollar and it's impacts countries . .. etc Thanks in advance. More powers to you...

[@hassanzkhan]

Great job!. Great host and guest

[@akrpk22]

How well spoken and knowledgeable this guy is!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

The best

[@haiderkhan8542]

Best podcast ever! HANDS DOWN

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Voyager245]

On 36:00 minute which camp He is talking about

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Ojiri Camp

[@usmanmuhammad5061]

Your interviews are amazing and rhe people you call on your channel are amazing as well. Very good work 👍😁

[@usmanmuhammad5061]

@@ThePakistanExperience Please do bring 2nd part of this soon😁

[@kiranmoghe3716]

Very nice discussion!!!!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@daniyalkamran4965]

What an insightful podcast that was, please keep doing podcast like these moree shahzad bhaii… 💯

[@roshanthapa8487]

In Janaab se pooche, jab 1965 Tak free movement tha and India was also selling food aisi kya aafat thi to spend on National Security as first priority. This somewhere shows mentality and also the reason why Pakistan went in the wrong direction

[@olgabooga2230]

This is quite an intellectual and honest show, no wonder I don’t find a lot of Pakistanis here, mostly Indians commenting

[@manu.ba374]

@@ThePakistanExperience main bhi spain se hi dekh raha hun❤🇵🇰😀

[@f.50]

What's this obsession of one-upping pakistanis by commenting that shit under any pakistani podcasts indians watch?

[@DYtechnicalgyan]

@@ThePakistanExperience is there a way to see how much an average indian watch this and how much average pakistani watches.

[@captsudarshan]

Thanks. Learnt a lot and enjoyed.