10-Year Ownership Of My BMW X5 - A Long Term Review

[@icm65]

I drove my Lexus to a local BMW dealership to drop off a friend who was getting her car serviced. A BMW rep said, "you must be lost because we don't see a lot of Lexus owners here..." LOL...nice guy.

[@midiman5045]

Yes but one guy told me to stick with Lexus it's boring, I guess it is when you are not spending your hard earned money on it and your time wasting on the repairs. It can be boring to drive a car around. LOL. Maybe Lexus should advertise the ultimate driving machine since you can drive and drive and drive it by all the BMW's in the repair shop. LOLROF.

[@mikefoehr235]

The sad reality is that Lexus has destroyed the Germans and even Acura to a large extent.

[@midiman5045]

@@mikefoehr235 I wouldn't say it's a sad reality. Lexus earned it.

[@mikefoehr235]

@@midiman5045 The brand sure did. Lexus was gunning for the Germans.

[@rahimi4762]

@@midiman5045 Lexus drives like Buick. Toyota has more tech. I’ll pass I’m good and yes I’ve owned 3 of them. Very underwhelming drive compared to other luxury vehicles even Acura and Volvo.

[@zsb707]

12-year ownership report on my 630i (E63, LCI, 2010) that I've always used as a second, mainly weekend car: - mileage: 85,000 - engine issues: spark plugs & coils - body issues: rattles in the pano roof - cockpit issues: some minor cracks in low quality plastics, wear & tear of driver seat leather I'm still mesmerized by the design and really like the way it drives and sounds.

[@ECPP]

Nice, thanks for sharing.

[@davidtracy9058]

Cool car

[@Adam01Time]

12 years 85 thousand that is a never used car do the math. That was a better year 85 thousand miles is a break in period for a Honda.

[@GrzegorzDurda]

Hmmm so in essence no issues.

[@user-bs9mw1cz9o]

Got 300k on my bmw 2010 x5 3.0in line 6 best motor it just keeps running other then valve cover gasket’s and a water pump and 2 sets of new tiers the truck has never left me stranded very reliable

[@Wipsplash]

Dealership should keep certain items such as injectors and computer boards as tools for mechanics. It's ridiculous that a dealer can't tell you if replacing an expensive part will fix it or not. They can keep a board and injector in a main tool cabinet for the techs to use.

[@ECPP]

That’s exactly my sentiment. Small price to pay for their own peace of mind and validation. Seems like common sense. But again it’s off the hide of the consumer.

[@miketurin5233]

That’s exactly what my non dealer workshop does. The dealer always says..well, we don’t know but we will experiment on your car and you have to pay us. Also sometimes new guys are being trained and you pay for their experiments.

[@arcadiusvinzenz6005]

@@miketurin5233 🤣

[@25myma]

Another thing to be aware of is that "board" or "computer" thing is something repair shops usually throw in a) when they try to scam you or b) when they're incompetent and can't figure out the real issue. I always tell people to run away from that shop if someone mentions the board, cuz it usually isn't that.

[@ECPP]

You nailed it and that was where my mind was wondering too when I was first given that diagnosis.

[@GudInformation]

@@ECPP wait, I was told this about my E46 module and the change the ECU for like $1000 so i wouldn't get locked inside the car and have to climb out of the window. Or locked out of the car when I wanted to drive it.

[@highbrass7563]

Watched every second of this video. I love every ounce of effort that goes into your Channel Mark. Thanks for the upload

[@Anthony-qh1xv]

The E70 X5, is the most beautiful X5. No runner up. It just looks so unbelievably good.

[@Nogi-aka-DJNugz]

Agreed! This model looks so well even among the new ones.

[@Anthony-qh1xv]

@@Nogi-aka-DJNugz Oh yeah! It has aged unbelievably well, and something about the look is so elegant. I will admit, Some SUVs might be "Cooler" looking, like my BMW F26 For example, But not much out there is as elegant looking as this in my opinion. Mine certainty isn't.

[@peteryates8680]

I have an e70 2009 3i petrol engine N52. Your comments and costing is spot on. I’m in Australia. I bought it 4 years ago cheaply when living in New Zealand for NZ $12000. I was intending using to drag the dog around for a couple of years while living in NZ. I bought it online from a guy who fortunately was a licensed dealer. He suggested I buy an extended warranty for $1500. Best $1500 I ever spent as it saved me about $8000. All very similiar to stuff you talk about. But I do like it and I just put it down to cost of owning. I use an independent BMW mechanic who helps manage what I spend. I’ve taken it to dealers a couple of times to get inspections and had some recalls and warranty items done. It’s done about 100,000 enjoyable trouble free kilometres for me. Over Christmas will do about 5,000 kilometres. It’s all serviced and ready to go.

[@ECPP]

Cheers

[@miceinoz1181]

Yep, I have the same 2009 35D here in Australia. Mine only has 190000Kms. No third seat option, but has a towpack which mandates 20inch run flat tyres. No rib on the tyres to prevent rim damage. Makes the ride harsher as well. Gearbox issues where it goes into failsafe every now and then (this ZF6HP28X trans was fully overhauled at about 130000Kms by previous owner). Pull over, turn it off then back on and it comes good until next time. We do not have diesel fluid in this model over here. Interior issues with the rubberized trim coating is the same. Fan control buttons have the legends worn off them by useage. I have anodized aluminum trims in my car not the fake wood. No crack issues. Sometimes the Nav system will not read the disc (yes, I tried a new disc already). Full shutdown, short wait, and restart normally gets everyone talking again. Our problems come from the savage sun, not the cold. We have no salt or ice on our roads. I put a new battery in mine about two years ago, cost me AUD 270. Rear differential mount bush (AUD40). Rear injectors can suffer from water ingress from the back of the bonnet as you say, The plastic walls that hold the hood seal break as poor material. I replaced all mine and got the spares out of China, cost me 1/4 what our local stealership was charging! But this may be more an issue with your weather conditions as not a big problem over here. By the way, the 35D has no more compression that the normal 30D. It has a twin scroll turbo (versus single in the 30D) and an uprated ECM program for more power, and the front guards are plastic, so they will never rust. Steering is a little heavy at low speeds, OK on highway. Oh yes, I would never own a BMW if I could not repair it myself, only the very wealthy can afford dealer servicing in Australia. I would only take it to a dealer if I could not program a module. Dealers rip you off severely over here. But I love driving it, so much torque!

[@JD-eq4dp]

Here in the UK virtually all X5's are the diesel model. The Police use them for traffic patrol & Armed Response Vehicles. Generally the vehicles are pretty bullet proof and will do very high mileages without major issues. Great channel Mark. Keep up the great work you do. Best wishes from Worcester, England. 👍

[@ECPP]

Hi, thank you very much for watching.

[@sammyg805]

Exactly what I commented on another video .. I and my family have always had bmw x models and it’s not had any problem Just normal yearly servicing with Kwik fit or Halfords, we don’t go bmw dealerships cos they’l charge more.. police use x5s and have gotten the latest ones too cos that thing is rugged & goes for decades. I think it’s the American ones that’s lemon from what I see online , it’s usual yanks complaining ..

[@Phoenix_cataclysm_in_2040]

@@sammyg805 To be fair we have very mild winters in England that are forgiving to these cars. Still, $1200 for a battery change? Whoah, the most expensive option for me would be getting one for around £100 and sticking it in myself. It's not like you need to disassemble the engine to put in the new battery, is it. 🤔

[@sammyg805]

@@Phoenix_cataclysm_in_2040 that’s bullocks though no one’s paying a grand to change batteries unless they really reaping them off so badly in the states 😂😂

[@Phoenix_cataclysm_in_2040]

@@sammyg805 He said they run some diagnostics to find a suspected leak. Go figure, but our man parts with his money quite easily, by the looks of it. 🤔

[@vinniedaniels3521]

I previously owned a 2009 E70 but without the diesel and for the most part, it was a workhorse and fun to drive. Once the warranty was expired, repairs were getting costly but they were few and far. When the A/C stopped working, it was time to trade her in but I overall loved the vehicle. I'm amazed at your technical knowledge and appreciative that you share it...

[@vinniedaniels3521]

@@porschefanatic1049 It was time for an upgrade at 10 yrs old anyway.

[@vinniedaniels3521]

HaHa - I wish...I had the 2009 E70 for 7 years and it did well. I only have one home and one vehicle and work hard to keep them.@@rainbowsquash673

[@mchegeni]

Thank you! Great long term ownership review. These type of reviews are priceless.

[@ECPP]

Thank you very much for the watch. Have a great week.

[@Ashley_van_Schooneveld]

2017 X5 xDrive35i M Sport with 183,000km now Only issues I experienced that got me stranded were the water pump and air suspension two years ago. The thermostat also failed by remaining stuck opened all the way. This year will require a new valve cover gasket (original one still holding up but, sweating is visible), new front lower control arms, coolant flush plus hose flange replacement, an intake valve cleaning with walnut shells and differentials plus transfer case fluid replacement. Spark plugs replaced at 79,000km and 175,000km all on the original coils. There's no rough idle, misfire, stalling I experienced. I sometimes (rarely) get an engine light for "catalytic converter efficiency under threshold". Typically caused by driving long distance at low engine speed and load and is not serious. Oil changes EVERY 8000km (5000 mi). Still original windshield after 3 years ownership (I'm third owner, purchased when it had 63,100km) but it chips that got repaired quickly and no cracks. I'm experienced a lot of paint chips on the front passenger door, running board and driver door to lesser extent. Will need a body shop to assess what correction is needed. Due to the excellent mechanical fitness of the X5 it's been tuned to an M Performance Power kit; previous owner had installed an M Performance exhaust. The combination of both sounds insanely good.

[@ECPP]

Nice

[@sandycalderone9757]

i own a 2020 x7 x50i. paid cash for it and totally love driving it. i have close to 40,000 miles on it. I've had nothing but problems with it from electronics to suspension. what bothers me the most is the ineptness of the dealerships i have dealt with. '"we can't reproduce the problem" is the usual reply i get. i take it to another dealership that finds the problem and partially fixes the problem. i then take it back to my original dealership and they fixed what the second dealership missed. i had a squeak in the front end they could not diagnose. i took it to another dealership and they couldn't find it. i was visiting in nj so i brought it to a dealership there. that makes three dealerships. they found the problem. when i got back home i had my dealership call them. it turned out i needed new struts. it took them 33,000 miles to find the problem! my left front headlamp clouded up and needed to be replaced but they had to get an ok from bmw. he said the headlamp cost $7000.00! thats right you're reading correctly $7000.00 not including labor. thank God i was still under warranty. this was the most enjoyable suv I've ever driven but when warranty runs out the car goes with it.

[@ECPP]

Wow Sandy, that sounds like a pile of troubles are brewing and yes warranty is your friend at this point but I have also found the dealer experience in some cases to be sub par. Man have I got stories.

[@thekobechannel4610]

You should have financed it bro😂 always finance a car stop buying things in cash all the time Finance the damn car you'll thank me later

[@remiss3804]

@@thekobechannel4610explain?

[@dljunior2852]

Sir, you are so on point. My 09 x-drive 48i had basically the same issues. If I didn't do a lot of my own maintenance I wouldn't own this vehicle. It's a money pit that I'm in to deep to get rid of. Everytime I may a repair I want to keep a little longer because it drives so good. It's kind of a love hate relationship.

[@ECPP]

Thanks Don, I totally understand where you are coming from.

[@kkdtv3877]

How ironic! I wanted to buy an 09 x drive 48i from someone I worked with, he had issues with his suspension where the car squeaked when it drove down the road. Found a mechanic to do the job for 2000 but the car was only worth 2500 so it was a bit of a bummer for me to drop out on.

[@grayparatrooper]

@@kkdtv3877 buy the parts and get a mobile mech to do the job

[@kkdtv3877]

@@grayparatrooper it’s not that simple. The parts itself are expensive plus you have to buy the equipment. It’s cheaper and easier to pay a qualified mechanic.

[@friedookiehil]

Very informative! Actually essential to watch. This is what we need to hear. We always see the attractive part, being the outside and wish we could own one, BUT we never think of the costs of repair or replacement parts. Shocking! No wonder second hand prices are so "affordable". Thank you for the eye opener!!

[@GuitarsAndSynths]

indeed the X5 drops in value like a rock after a few years. They are 80-100k new but a decade later 10k for a reason!

[@patricknieukirk1163]

I enjoyed watching your video since I have a love relationship with my 2007 E70 X5 3.0 inline 6 which turns 15 years old this month that I purchased new in Denver, Colorado. No injectors nor diesel so the engine has been great. Low mileage - 104K currently. The exterior and interior also has held up very well. Third row seat air bags went out once. I also track my expenses with dealer repair for the first ten years but after that an independent. I haven't had the major diesel expenses but I agree about the $1000 repair bills are common when some thing major happens. I will purchase a BEV as my next vehicle but am resisting the additional monthly investment since my X5 is basic transportation but still averages $200 a month.

[@capturedbyhussnain]

I recently bought a 2008 X5 3.0si with 200K km on it and I'm loving it so far, as long as gaskets are replaced and maintained its a good reliable car. Its just wear and tear like any other car to be honest and I myself can turn a wrench if need be. So I'm very confident with the car. But overall good video :)

[@gsprings43]

well,you can spend a fortune trying to keep it from breaking down too

[@imslightlysick5572]

Hey wish u well im wondering how is the car doing after u posted this comment

[@curtismcpherson4823]

How’s it doing I’m looking at a 2009 x5 220 k km

[@HARDAOREDGE]

Enjoyed it and found it very useful as I own the same car in it's naturally aspirated 3.0 l version upgraded with remapping, throttle booster, air filter and exhaust system to produce 306 hp. Great ride all in all got no reason to replace it. Designwise I reckon it's better than its successors. Minimum wear and tear. Btw on the occasion I'd like to congratulate you for your thorough and truthful comments. Love to you yours and Canada from Greece 🎉

[@mediocreman2]

Okay man, sorry this has happened to you, but a lot of this could have been prevented easily. 1. The rear airbags are cheap and easy to replace. And why would you go with aftermarket ones, if the BMW ones lasted 10 years? 2. Get rid of that emissions equipment and get a tune. No DEF, no DPF, no EGR, and your reliability goes up 10 fold, and your expenses plummet. Not only that, but the entire system is covered by warranty. Even if they have to replace it 10 times, it's still on BMW to cover. It's not a one time thing as long as you're under mileage and age. You should have escalated that to BMW corporate. 3. The injector problem is well known and the solution is easy and cheap. Just preventively replace the rain cowl tray pieces. Just a quick Google search on "common x5 diesel problems" would have saved you a shit ton. 4. 6:04 Those are like $20 on Amazon. Come on man, did you even try? I spent about $2,500 on mine years ago (doing all preventative maintenance and delete), and haven't had to do anything since. My Toyota literally costs me the same averaged per year.

[@telafonic]

Thanks for the first informed reply. Based on what I've seen, the owner was not willing to do some research on anything, including parts prices. My 335d has been as good as my N52 128i as far as reliability. Just got to do a bit of research and get rid of the emissions stuff.

[@joelbullock9720]

Great 10 year Review I am on my second BMW X5 love these vehicles so much great for long weekend trips or if you travel allot for work by road. Comfort is amazing and handlles like a car when you need it to.

[@ECPP]

Thanks for sharing!

[@garagefabroart]

This is very informative and great for someone interested that doesnt know how to work on cars. However , for most enthusiasts who have basic knowledge of working on cars all these repairs are very manageable. Those $1200+ injectors you can find good used ones for $100-$200 and the work is pretty easy. Most people that don't live in emission strict areas get rid of the DEF tanks , EGR parts etc... Will eliminate 50% of the issues, gain you 100+HP and 300+Tq and even better gas milage. I would say for someone with basic tools and doesnt mind getting their hands dirty these rigs are incredible value. If you are unwilling or unable to work on cars then maybe go lease something newer :) Thanks for posting this! Incredible to have both a 5yr and 10yr update.

[@ivalterbaptista2305]

Well said. Was about to post to say the same. I purchased a 2013 e70 35d that was having issues with dpf filter and paid a good price for it as is from a dealer. As soon as I got it I removed the emission equipment and egr system. Been running like a dream ever since.

[@thebrownthomascrown917]

One of the things that grinds my gears on these high end cars is the d@mn battery. A replacement battery last year ran me $300 for the battery alone. Getting into the battery bay of the car requires an engineering degree and a trip to the dealership to register it.

[@ECPP]

You are right, they over complicate matters and this whole coding thing sounds like another gouge fiesta to me as well.

[@lydellleopold5884]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@miceinoz1181]

If the new battery is the same CCA as the old, you can give the registration a miss. Registration is only required for a different capacity battery. It is my information that this is to enable the correct charge rate out of the alternator.

[@MrCrossface007]

You my friend were ripped off. If you pay more than 90 dollars for a battery, you overpaid

[@glenndavis5446]

Hey, my BMW same model as above needed a battery, my auto elec changed it over for $225 fitted. A;so had a front globe go, BMW said $800 my auto elec fitted new globe for $200, sometimes I think we need to shop around a bit.

[@mikeb6359]

Comparison to my former 2007 Audi A6 premium plus Quattro. Bought in 2008 as a CPO with 27500 miles and 100000 mile, 6 year extended warranty as part of the CPO. Gave the car to a friend at 195000 miles. Only minor issues….forget the dealer that always wanted to do unnecessary work. Routine maintenance every 10K miles averaged about $200. Never used oil between changes, new battery every 5 years, tires about 50k per set. No suspension or engine repairs, never changed coolant or tranny fluid, per owner manual. Interior and exterior like new except had to replace leather trim on driver seat for $150. Recharged AC once at 150000 miles, replaced cracked rear lights for $125 from eBay. At 90k did 90 minutes on the Pocono NASCAR track with Audi club…no issues. Only real problem was failure of satellite radio receiver/amp which kept draining battery. Dealer wanted 1200 to replace. Used amp was 150, dealer programmed it for 135…since wiring is fiber optic could not use after market. Car drove great, 6 cylinder with good power and 27-30 mpg cruising at 75. If you have an Audi beware of dealer repair shop unnecessary work. Was told needed $2000 suspension work at 90k miles … not true, never touched suspension. This was the best vehicle I ever owned and I have driven over a million miles so far in Fords, Lincolns, Chryslers, Dodges, Hondas, Toyotas, school busses, Austin Healey, etc.

[@ECPP]

Thanks for sharing, and yes sometimes a second opinion is important or going Indy may give you other options.

[@k-man-dude]

Audis are also a hit and a miss just like any other germans. You probably had a naturally aspirated engine. There are horror stories about 2010+ Audi's turbo 4 and all the oil consumption

[@mikeb6359]

@@k-man-dude I totally agree. I don't like 4 cylinder turbo engines - every one I drove suffered from nonlinear acceleration and the earlier Audi 4 cylinder turbos were definitely oil burners - I don't know how they are now. However, a cousin bought an A4 roughly 6 years ago from a used car dealer with about 50K miles. It burned oil and the used car dealer sent her to an Audi dealer who rebuilt the engine (might have replaced it) at no cost. That free work may have been usual or not, I don't know. But I do know that BMWs are known to be expensive to maintain after the warranty expires. My Audi would have cost a fortune to maintain if I listened to the dealer's repair shop. But they are comfortable, safe, drive well and expensive cars are always expensive to maintain. Yes, I think I was lucky with mine. And I drove it on the NASCAR track at Pocono Raceway with the Audi club, hitting the 133 mph governor on the main straight frequently for 90 minutes with no problems - again, maybe I was jjst lucky.

[@mohammadal-abbasi7247]

Correct me if I’m wrong, it seems to me like the dealership is a substantial part of the problem. If they were more sensible, took ownership of their product, your experience could have been less disastrous. Thank you for the usual great vid 🙏🏼 looking forward to seeing your next brand direction

[@ECPP]

Thank you very much for your comment and yes, I totally agree with you. Those clowns have seen me for the last time in their building, however, they can enjoy the videos from here on.

[@kennethstanton5407]

@@ECPPI firmly believe that BMW is making a huge strategic mistake by gouging on parts through all their dealers. Simple little bolts and fasteners are priced at least 5 times higher than would be considered reasonable. More substantial parts are always a large multiple of the aftermarket price. Our dealership here isn't incompetent like yours, but their estimates for routine repairs are pornographic, mostly because of parts prices. Thankfully there is no shortage of decent aftermarket parts and lots of fully competent independent shops.

[@mohammadal-abbasi7247]

@@kennethstanton5407 Pornographic 😂 quite the description

[@greymark420]

Very interesting video, Mark. I honestly am amazed how expensive it is to repair this car, totally unwarranted.

[@ECPP]

Thanks a lot. I agree, it’s really not worth it. My Lamborghini was more reliable and had lower running costs

[@greymark420]

@@ECPP Well that says it all ,Mark. Lamborghini cheaper to run than a BMW.

[@gaskim]

Wow dude! 100 true review!! 👍 thank you for your honesty

[@ECPP]

Thanks so much for watching.

[@Prophet308]

Mark, I just bought an E89 Z4. In silver of course. AND an N52 not an N20. Absolutely beautiful. One of the best looking BMWs ever made. Buy one mate. Much appreciation from Australia. 😎💪🇦🇺

[@ECPP]

Welcome to the channel and hi from Canada.

[@wes4375]

I was thinking of buying an X6 from the same generation as a fun toy but there’s a lack of long-term ownership reviews likes these. Scary stuff. Thanks for the video.

[@paulsirya6483]

I’m here for the same reason.. thinking of buying a 35i x6

[@zsb707]

An X6 is not a fun toy. Too heavy for that ...

[@WayToManyAssassins]

I feel like it depends on the engine thpe

[@kingzts]

i have a 2012 x5 3.5…….i have had it for 6 years. if not for the CPO warranty i wouldve had to pay for oil filter housing gasket (which failed twice), oil pan is forever leaking, fuel pump sounds like its going. Brakes squeal when it is freezing outside, no matter how old the brakes are. had to do a coolant flush water pump twice and thermostat. I chipped and put in intake from burger so then MAP sensor needs to be cleaned every year with the spray. THe vents for the sunroof are stuck so i have to hammer it close from the inside. One parking sensor is gone so it constantly makes a sound. But overall i still have no check engine light and it runs decent. Considering i only drive 8k miles a year. First 5 years was great. NO issues. Then oil filter went then oil pan then water pump. Expensive repairs but hopefully im done. Going to get rid of the car in 2-3 years. But this car lasted MUCH longer than my old e53. But it is a fun car (especially after being chipped).

[@Turbs2008]

our LCI E70 has the N55, and the only thing was the valve cover gasket, which is common for these vehicles. Still running strong at 73k miles!

[@arfetherussian]

That’s nothing to be proud of lol 215k miles on my m57 e70

[@RichRotorhead]

73k???? Your weeks away from a junk yard 😅 J/k

[@Theman26642]

Jeez...I've owned mine from 60k miles to 155k....still going strong. Only thing I've needed to do is valve cover gasket, expansion tank, tires, and brakes. Probably $400 a year in maintenance total. Been a reliable car knock-on-wood.

[@kennethstanton5407]

The number one takeaway is just don't go the stealership for any service after warranty. Here's a typical comparison: Temperature sensor in the lower rad hose costs $6 after market and 2 minutes to swap out. Cost from the stealership: $80!!!! That is just criminal for a part where there is no way on earth that the cost can be justified. It's even worse for more substantial parts. So far, mine has been a pretty easy keeper eveen though it's got waaay more miles on it than yours.

[@ECPP]

Thanks Kenneth. Yes these people earned the nickname Stealership for a reason. I typically do a lot of my own work too but once in awhile the trouble is a bit too complex.

[@howarddrakeford]

Thank you SO much for this video! I'm a real BMW fan, card carrying club member even. But this is too much! I'm the type of guy who like to keep cars as long as possible, but not at any cost! This is crazy! Jesus! In the past I've bought older, more vintage BMWs. I think that's what I'll stick to.

[@andrewostrom8676]

I guess part of your problem is going to the dealer for repairs that would cost a lot less at at an independent shop or if you do it yourself. You mentioned $250 for an oil service. I have a 2012 E70 X5M. I do my own oil service which is ridiculously easy on this car, you barely have to jack it up. I use Red Line oil which is $15USD/qt (but Pennzoil LL-01 IS $7/qt. at Walmart, and exactly what comes in the BMW bottles). I use 7 quarts, so $49USD for oil and $26USD for a Mahle OX 353/7D oil filter on Amazon. So $75 for an oil change. Many repairs on my E70 have been maddening, a starter that I had to have the dealer install was almost $2,000, and I've had to replace the battery twice at about $225 each (buy the $100 tool to dump BMW codes and register batteries, etc.). I've replaced the IBS twice (Hella OEM version for about $100, and I replaced the alternator with a used one for about another $100. My shifter lever failed, but I got a used on on eBay for $200 ($800 at the dealer). If any of your control modules go bad there are services that will repair them, or there are plenty of used parts available. I haven't kept detailed records, but I've owned my 2012 X5M for 4 years and just about 80,000 miles - the car now has 151,000 miles. I'd guesstimate that I've spent about $5K on repairs including replacing all the brake rotors, pads, and e-break) shoes over the 4 years. I paid $25K USD for the car (sticker price over $100K) so I don't think it's been so bad. Oh. yeah - I had to replace the blower motor too - I hope there's a special place in hell for the person who designed that assembly. I did it some years earlier I about 2 hours in our E90 335i, and this took at least 6 or 8 hours.

[@ECPP]

Thank you very much for sharing and I totally agree. DIY wins.

[@tiabidgie]

Came to see how it would hold up! Was not disappointed.

[@ECPP]

Thanks for sharing

[@ssj4david]

230,000km converts to precisely 143,750 miles my friend. Amazing to see you've kept and enjoyed the E70 this long!

[@ECPP]

Thanks! 👍

[@k-man-dude]

Proud owner of lci x5 35d with 3rd row. Bought as an off-lease CPO and now 7 yrs of ownership and it is turning 10 yrs old. Older 2009-2010 diesels like yours seem to have bit more issues than 2011-2013 lci

[@ECPP]

That may be possible.

[@paulsalvo235]

I do think LCI or in general Face lifted vehicles tend to fair better than post face lifted or pre lci cars. It’s more so due to the manufactur finally getting the car dialed in from customer complaints and ownership surveys.

[@apw2607]

They don’t. It’s just your car is younger. They have exactly the same emission system and DPF issues and the pre LCI cars.

[@Thedirtylittlesecret]

Any update?

[@dereklewinson3018]

THIS is a "must see". Video! I have the 2009 x5 e70 4.8i gas (petrol) model. I LOVE my x5 when it's running well, which is most of the time. When I gotta take it to the repair shop... 😭😭😭 Cheapest repair, rattly exhaust brackets. Most expensive repair: eccentric shaft.

[@ECPP]

Thank you. That’s really the bottom line in ownership of these vehicles. It’s sort of a love/hate relationship

[@joshs3905]

Excellent review like always. My dad X5 is starting to have bluetooth and electrical issues now that it's reaching 100,000km. Ironically there's a 2013 X1 on my court that has close to 180,000km's and still going strong lol we chirp the neighbor but he's proud to drive it. The 1st gen is so small too. What surprised me the most is how a 4 cylinder is outlasting a 6 cylinder, maybe it's a rare case? I don't know much about cars

[@ECPP]

Hi, it sort of depends on which engine of each because for example a B48 will most certainly outlast an n54.

[@joshs3905]

@@ECPP yea that's what i kind of figured too, it's gotta be something about the engine. Anyways, thank you for another great review, I really enjoyed watching. and thanks a lot for answering my question so quickly, I really appreciate it. You definitely deserve millions of subscribers

[@MegaExaile]

My 08 x5 M57 at 264 000km now. I do miss running HVO100 cause enigne ran cleaner and calmer but 30SEK/liter noty

[@andrewostrom8676]

My 2012 X5M with the S63 has 151,000 miles (243,000) km, and the engine is still strong. I know I'll probably have to replace the turbos in the next year or so; at that point I'll go for the upgraded Vargas turbos. 555HP isn't quite enough - I was out-accelerated by a new Corvette the other day and I wasn't happy.

[@tonybrown9875]

Either lease or buy under warranty if you have dough, or if on a budget get them dirt cheap and old that you just run them for a few years then scrap it. I bought a Jaguar S Type R, 400bhp, nice interior and body if rusty underneath, 130k miles, £3500, a gear box failure 3 years later and I scrapped it for £1000. Total costs were oil changes and a tyre, less than a grand a year for ownership total X- D

[@ECPP]

Cheers

[@alekomania]

2010 x5 126,000 miles and I love it !!

[@ECPP]

Which engine?

[@charleschenhua]

Good video, I own the same diesel model, 2012. Some of the problems are caused by parking outside. Garage helps. That said, it’s definitely not cheap to own. We have sports package, tires alone cost $1,200 since the positive camber causes uneven tire wear. This thing drives like a tank, we love it on long road trips.

[@innotafanofanyofjlbjlbissd6777]

How many miles on yours ?

[@Thedirtylittlesecret]

150k

[@eugenet6632]

This is why i always buy basic most common bread and butter german cars so they do not have gimmicks to be failed soon like adjustable air suspension. Currently I own gasoline 2018 330i 3-series with B46 engine, which is a very good designed engine.

[@ECPP]

Thanks for sharing

[@UnknownUser-vu6xq]

Wow I was looking at buying one of these but think I will pass. Is there any used affordable BMW that are good? Is Mercedes better? I'm shocked so many problems with these BMWs .....sounds like just about any car is more reliable than a BMW.

[@CPK007]

100% agree, we own a 2011 X5d with 155K miles and the dealer just quoted us $12K to replace all the emission parts. Over the years we have many of the repairs that you mentioned. We love the performance and mileage but it is time to say good bye! I would not ever recommend purchasing this vehicle. It lives up to BMW's reputation of 'Break My Wallet'!

[@944clogue]

I'M ALWAYS COLD WATCHING YOUR VIDEO'S BUT DO ENJOY, AND INFORMATIVE....

[@ECPP]

It’s cold here most of the time

[@Poppinwheeeeellllllieeeeez]

I just had an oil change and brake fluid flush on my e70d with 165kms and received compliments on its condition from the tech. Urethane bushings are a very good upgrade for handling and durability. When the DEF system fails, I will delete and tune with trans service and tune for 4k.

[@chucknoob7041]

Thanks for this video! I was thinking about picking one of these up because they are going pretty cheap and I’ve never owned a “luxury” vehicle, thought it might be fun - but - hell no not with those prices.

[@Jaguar7444]

I have 2012 BMW X5 xDrive35i and had engine leak after getting it repaired it ended up having engine failure (probably should have taken it to BMW mechanic). Now I'm debating to repair or replace. The line about not giving it to parent or child stuck with me, I was gonna fix it and give it to my mom as backup vehicle but maybe not. I bought certified pre-owned 2020 BMW X3... Wish me luck. I might switch brands next time.

[@ECPP]

Good luck on the new car. Which engine did you go with ?

[@Jaguar7444]

@@ECPP 2020 X3 xDrive30i pretty basic. But turbo 4 cylinder, right?

[@Lego-fs2de]

I had the same model in a 2011. After about 6 years had several diesel related problems and a front end situation. Spent over $10,000 over in 2 years. Sold it when it was 11 years old.

[@Sommers234]

I don't know if this applies but when the airbags on my 2008 Jaguar failed I had StrutMaster installed. Great results. Handles more like a BMW now ;)

[@ECPP]

Nice. Thanks for sharing.

[@mircoslava1330]

love the CONCRETE DRIVEWAY! smart especially in a winter climate with lotsa SALT! good call!

[@petevys9005]

Hello , I'm watching a lot of your videos, very interesting and educational. I have a question , my first SUV rx 350 disappointed me and now I'm back in the market, looking at BMW X3 or X5 with b58 but still considering diesel because it is cheaper to get,but not sure if it is a good idea, what do you think? Thanks 👍

[@paulvarrieur976]

The repairs you note are EXACTLY what repairs mine suffered. But, I am a good diy mechanic and repaired mine for 25% of what the dealer charged. FCP Euro for parts and Amazon or E Bay got the specialty tools.

[@ECPP]

I agree if you are a solid DIYer you can enjoy a great driving vehicle for easy money. Full delete is also a consideration in some spots like Canada

[@mohammadal-abbasi7247]

Loving those heart-to-heart videos 🙌🏼

[@ECPP]

Thank you very much

[@georgegonzalez8818]

Great Video!!! So f'n crazy. I just came across a 2010 and was curious about the diesel engine. I had no clue. Granted, I'm in California, but darn what a head ache. Thank you,

[@ECPP]

Thanks for watching!

[@acidpork577]

10:15 - $150 per piece. Comes with lifetime warranty. I believe mine was made by Continental.

[@ECPP]

I will check it out. Thanks a lot for that.

[@salgis]

EGR: delete DEF system: delete Thermostat: replace and no issues with glow plugs Injectors: cover with a rag, no problem and...no problem

[@ECPP]

True indeed

[@RolandHoltz]

I bought an E53 a few weeks ago (231 T km). By means of preventive maintenance I replaced all 6 injectors against Injectors that were refurbished by Bosch (325,-€ all six off them) and 6 new glow plugs, from Bosch. A new intake manyfold (deleated the swirl flaps, but of course) , AGR valve and a throttle body (by Pirberg, this is where BMW buys it from for production), water pump and thermostat and starter motor. All from premium brands. The bill was approx. 3400,- € including labor and it's running very fine.. Battery swap for over 1000 quid, I'd never pay, rather I do it myself for about 100,-€ (120 Amp hour battery which lasts longer than 95 Amps, plus a new generator 100 Amps very easy to replace on this one 150,-€) Oil change for 250 quid, this is ridiculous!!!!! Plus the E70 is the more complicated car. I still feel the E53 is the better choice, because it is not as messed up with emission regulation bla bla bla. I missed you talking about the differential, and the transfer case. These >>>> must

[@acidpork577]

18:20 - fuel injectors Bosch $400 a piece vs $1200 at dealer.

[@ECPP]

I know I would do it myself if it happened again while I am trying to sell it

[@geppiemockingbird1489]

1200 bucks to replace a battery is ridiculous and absurd. If you have a proper scan and diagnosis tool, you can easily do it yourself. Worth the investment.

[@daviddenley3512]

Apart from the shock of the cost of diesel here in the UK currently being £184.9 a litre, I am very seriously getter a 2017 Mercedes E Class Estate E220d AMG Line, is it better then getting a BMW 530d Touring? The only alternative I have considered is a buy set of Roller Skates.

[@butchfajardo8832]

I know the best way to test any electronics is to use an oscilloscope. This is the ultimate tester for electronics!

[@ECPP]

Thanks

[@nova1274]

Thanks for the informative video. I am actually looking at the 2018 used x5 diesel which has 90k miles on it. I am skeptical about the maintenance cost which is how landed on your video. I was also looking at looking for a big suv, but i guess i will go with 4runner. Doesn’t give a good mileage but at least don’t have to empty my pocket every time i drive.

[@ECPP]

Good choice!

[@Aikynbreusov]

My 2016 BMW X5 V8 with M Package just got an engine rebuild job done that cost $11,000.... good thing the extended warranty flipped the bill

[@ECPP]

Wow, that should never be a thing, but sadly there are some.

[@iuliannita8369]

Appreciate all of this !

[@ECPP]

Thank you

[@Cosmic_Ideation]

I love your BMW related videos, always enjoyably insightful.

[@kevinbarry71]

At least they don't stick you with the electric coolant pump. Designed to fail before 70,000 miles.

[@eastendphotographer428]

I had a Lincoln Mark VIII had same issues and fixed with conventional springs as well.

[@ECPP]

Not as nice as factory but it saves the future hassles

[@rhys9957]

$1,900 USD... for one injector? Even in Australia, far away from Europe where BMW parts are considered premium I can see N57 injectors for $390 USD ($540 AUD). Something doesn't smell right about these costs...

[@acidpork577]

18:59 - yes, they fail because of leaking plastic water guard ($140 replacement cost for aftermarket guard)

[@ChrisVAN92]

Based on the bill papers it looks like you got all of your servicing done at a BMW dealer which they are known to charge ridiculous money for servicing so then why didn't you consider going to a small shop that specializes in working on BMWs or another shop that knows how to work on BMWs you would've saved a lot of money servicing the car that way instead.

[@scott48]

I had an x5 years ago and loved it. It broke down middle of night driving to Vermont to go skiing. Issue was software needed to be updated. Entire car shut down. Oil leaks. Sensors etc. couldn’t take it anymore. Love them new, hate them as they age. I’m convinced when BMWs reach around 80k miles someone in Germany presses a button and that’s it. All implodes. I’d be very very curious to put a new 2024 x5 against the new lexus gx 550 that’s coming out soon. Lexus I’d have to believe would come out on top in spades.

[@ECPP]

Yes the Lexus will not drive as nicely but durability is far better

[@hanshans8612]

Always informative. Keep em coming.

[@ECPP]

Thank you very much. I will certainly do so.

[@wass006]

My car is a 2009 BMW 35d and it's done 195k miles, still running very strong alhamdulillah. Not a speck of rust

[@apw2607]

I kept my 2009 x5 for 10 yrs as well, and I added up dealer maintenance and it was $16,000 usd (I kid you not). The final nail was the DPF needed replacing and they quoted me $6500. So that was that. I now have a 2018 x5 35i. I miss the diesel torque though. The engine was generally bullet proof. It was all that additional emissions monitoring and control garbage that didn’t work properly.

[@salvadorortega445]

Very interesting, congratulations for all the knowledge that you have. I did Enyoy your video and learned a lot from you !!! Thank a lot.

[@ECPP]

Glad it was helpful!

[@1971pyramid]

If one of the reasons to buy a diesel car is to save money fuel, not only does the diesel car cost more to buy, but this one costs an arm and a leg to maintain, which ultimately defeats the whole purpose.

[@ECPP]

Thanks for sharing

[@allesiofondressi2602]

So easy to change the resistor, done it twice on my old x3.

[@ECPP]

Thanks

[@FFE-js2zp]

I have basically the same interior in my BMW, the Texas heat has peeled the same dash material and melted and spiderwebbed the screens. It’s been a nightmare.

[@ECPP]

Thanks for sharing. That is unfortunate, I know the heat of the south does take a toll on a lot of things too.

[@Ceusky]

My 2014 KIA SPORTAGE With 105000 kms have never needed anything other than oil changes. Not even brake pads. Never been in the shop and I live in Dubai where temps can reach 50°C.

[@ECPP]

Cheers

[@bennyb6071]

Have a kia forte 2014 6 speed, just oil change, brakes and a windshield wiper blade 110k

[@AW8UK]

I owned a 1st Gen (E53) X5 for 10 years. Owned from when it was 4 yrs old & did around 10k miles p/a as my daily driver.....(petrol V8 4.4i Sport to be specific). I spent around £1.5K (GBP) p/a on repairs to keep it behaving & repaired. In addition to maintenance I also kept on top of cosmetic stuff. Despite it not being cheap to care for I enjoyed the car. Timing chain guide failure (during an expensive life change event), eventually convinced me to say goodbye. Have had a few other brands over years. MB at present. Toyota & Volvo caused me least hassle.

[@ECPP]

Nice

[@GuitarsAndSynths]

What years and models of the X5 have best reliability? I love how the newer X5 SUV drive and feel inside but long term maintenance costs worry me. I have had two BMW cars and they are not cheap to own long term.

[@ECPP]

The latest engines for the X5 with the straight 6 are best. The b58 only in this vehicle

[@GuitarsAndSynths]

thank you!@@ECPP

[@jorgeosorio1242]

excellent video . Thank you so much!

[@ECPP]

Thanks for watching

[@chrisexperience7]

Great video as always!

[@ECPP]

Thank you very much

[@CaptainDave2010]

wow - what a great video - LOVE THIS GuY ! - makes a ton of sense.. - but after watching this - I will buy a JAP suv now .. I am old and need dependable affordable suv -- I ride a BMW Bike and love it ! .. this man is amazing with his words -thanks - you saved me a lot of $$$ and stress -- bless you ;)

[@ericadams2843]

Didn't you say that you no longer love BMW's because of the maintenance involved? Now you have a new video on the X5. I own a 2012 Bmw X5 and spent $400 on the block valve which would've cost me $1500 at a BMW service center. You can go to an independent repair shop that specialize in BMW's it's cheaper than dealers. The technician used to work for BMW and they are cheaper.

[@ECPP]

That is true and much of my own repairs I DIY too. Part of the issue is the low grade parts sold at premium prices and the greasiness of the corporate side to design obsolescence.

[@acidpork577]

23:06 - $300 for the battery + $300 for re-programming

[@Aikynbreusov]

"BMW and Mercedes are money pits..... Stationary money pits because the damn things don't run most of the time." (Scotty Kilmer, 2020). "When you see them, don't walk away......RUN" (Scotty Kilmer, 2020).... so true, as evidenced by this video......

[@ECPP]

You bet.

[@bruceelliott4822]

This confirms what I thought about BMW diesels, the extra diesel related repairs vs a gas engine cost way more than the fuel savings. You would be better off with the N55 gas motor (but not the N54!)

[@ECPP]

You are right Bruce, the n55 is vastly better then the junk before it and I know even the brother in law runs the n55 in an X3 and it has been ok, but…..

[@mediocreman2]

Not true at all. Unless you're unable/unwilling to remove the emissions equipment, the diesels are much cheaper to run and less problematic.

[@chrisw6337]

Pair of air bags was $130 and took about 1hour to fit. How can you charge $2000 for that?

[@marklivos]

Absolutely a learning point, buy this Germans when they're new after the warranty just sell them

[@ECPP]

Exactly

[@odk1105]

wait until your timing chain start stretching and you have to drop 4500$. On the plus side, you can just delete all the EGR stuff and delete the liquid tank

[@ECPP]

Yes a little delete is great for longevity

[@Mustang427]

Same warning light. Especially it’s something with Brake Force brake light. I suspect one or more wires in the tailgate loom is failing / fraying. My trunk lights are also not working when the gate is fully up. So when something hard fails, I will re-wire the whole harness.

[@ECPP]

Thanks for the heads up

[@devil2jz500]

I’m planning on buying a diesel X5 and deleting all the DEF junk. I’m a mechanic (aircraft A&P mechanic) and I don’t mind doing the repair.

[@ECPP]

Then it could be a good runner

[@devil2jz500]

@@ECPP I’ve heard about people getting 40mpg on the highway with deleted N57 X5. Plus it gains an extra 100hp.

[@kingturk3918]

Over a 10 year period 16 k in repairs .mostly plastic issues is good. So no major motor repairs etc piston rings loss of compresion valve breaking etc etc. For a bmw is good.motor is bullet proof if looked after decently. Once again snow salt cold. Will crack alot of plastic hoses and parts.and mainly parked on driveway .in winter. I got to say built to last.

[@ECPP]

thanks

[@derickd2385]

omg，that is crazy. Great video and lot of information.

[@kevinarmstrong7662]

Hi I have a 2 turbo 40D 2011/10 its great. No DPF fitted so extra good needs diesel additive to de carbon the ERG Use Penrite very good instant improvement on response . have clocked over 170,000 Km great driving replaced front lights assembly with leds. also installed 10.25 inch display qualicom quad core. All great had the software box for media upgraded for apple android car play compatibility. Works well ex BMW guy in Melbourne australia gave me the upgrade software worked . no audio jack needed just blue tooth . He did not give it was a few hundred Dollars Aus.

[@ECPP]

Cheers

[@kevinarmstrong7662]

Hi I looked at your youtube before buying and it decided my buy decision no regrets thanks.

[@gangastasmith]

"hand down to your child, who is essentially a starving student" this was my dream car and I want to buy it but I do fall into this category.

[@ECPP]

Haha, yes it seems to make sense at first but it will literally bankrupt a student, even just maintenance not just unexpected breakdowns

[@noorgaarddamsgaard9866]

My M550i cost me $20k in 5 years of ownership. Used the car as a second car and sold it at 75k miles. Bought it at 32k miles. $20k for 43k miles. Never again. N63 engines are a nightmare

[@ECPP]

You are totally right. They are very promblematic and just not worth the hassle.