Ed Reed vs. Troy Polamalu

Ro Parrish and Bryant McFadden debate who is the best safety... Ed Reed or Troy Polamalu -- what do you think?

[@dnlpule4367]

imagine if they play together! Man all Quarterbacks wouldn't wanna play against them lol

[@humzahhassan4521]

Id fake an injury and still get paid

[@molson9059]

If they were both playing with that free style mentality the defense would suck. You need at least one safety back there playing within the scheme instead of both safeties gambling. I’m just glad I got to see them both play live in my lifetime, greatness is greatness regardless of who they played for. I am a Ravens fan and I liked Ed Reed even better than Ray Lewis so if I had to pick it would be extremely biased. Understanding that I refuse to separate one from the other and will consider them to be the two best safeties to ever play.

[@russh7914]

I just got chills when I read this.

[@df6148]

M olson I was going to say the same thing. Ryan Clark allowed Troy to roam. And Ed Reed had Rey Lewis calling adjustments allowing him to roam as well. We never even knew the names of the opposite safety to Ed reed. They deserve credit though.

[@ppm_310]

@@molson9059 Ed Reed would cover everything deep leaving Troy free to roam around and do what he feels best. Both could do vise versa because of their great abilities but I'd rather have Ed Reed stay deep and Troy roam around wether at the line of scrimmage or up top with Reed

[@DustinPlatt]

Ed was a Free safety Troy was Strong Safety. It's 2 different play types. Idk why you can compare the two like this.

[@JuanVicioGotti]

Ed played strong safety his first 4 years won dpoy as a strong safety.

[@BenDownTooLong]

Its because these dudes are clowns

[@TCGF808]

Polamalu took on oline troy was the first hybrid linebacker

[@billycarter155]

stayWoke hahahahaha!!!!!!

[@jb8770]

In times when it really matter and all u got is 1 last play left... i will always bet all in on troy because it didn't matter what position was needed he will fill the gap to make a big play.

[@jeztauiliilivincent1916]

Love Ed but Troy for me 👌🏽

[@dariansanchez8007]

I'm taking Troy.

[@spritualflight1187]

Darian Sanchez me to

[@youknowho2541]

Ed Reed led in all but tackles, about 30 less and sacks with 5 less yet Reed had double the ints, 2 or 3 maybe 4x the int return yards. If you know football, you know Ed is the best to ever play the position.People saying Troy are basically saying they would take the 5 extra sacks and 30 extra tackles instead of Reeds 32 more ints and Reeds 1640 int return yards. 🤣🤡🤡🤡

[@milville2329]

@@youknowho2541 troy has more tackles, sacks, force fumbles and tackles for loss than ed reed does and he played 16 less games "which is basically an entire season" than ed reed.. but you can't go wrong with either.. ed reed was a safety who had more cornerback style to his game similar to deion sanders or champ bailey.. polomalu was a safety who had more linebacker instincts similar to ray lewis or junior seau.. both are safety's but 2 different styles

[@youknowho2541]

Troy barely has more of anything than Ed Reed but Ed Reed has double the ints and quadruple the int return yards. Reed was an offensive player on defense. Troy didn't double any metric over Ed. Look at the numbers.

[@milville2329]

@@youknowho2541 reed has more INTs and INT yards.. but troy has more of everything else and he's played in 16 less games

[@chocolate101f9]

Anyone that knows nfl and isn’t biased knows that Troy will always be better! Let me put it this way, 40 sec on the clock who do you choose to win the game on defence??? Troy all day baby

[@bigbudabmore5163]

Ed son son @Chocolate101 F

[@marknethercutt3381]

Troy will be in the NFL Hall of Fame. Steeler Nation love you.

[@tottietaito6468]

Troy Polomalu all day!!!

[@elev8torguy130]

I see constant comments that Ed Reed was a center fielder only. Whatever that means. Those individuals ignore the fact that Ed Reed is the only player in nfl history with a strip sack td, punt return td, blocked punt return for a td and an interception return for a td. Id say he did it all. This is taking nothing away from Troy. He was awesome. But don't forget ed reed was much more then just a ballhawk. By the way he was the BEST ballhawk.

[@parkerb2140]

Troy ftw

[@ambrosiod605]

I'll take the guy who could time the snap count perfectly and then jump over the line and tackle the QB before he could even make a handoff. And not just once either. I can't remember Ed Reed, ever doing anything like that. Or laying out 100%, getting one hand under a ball and actually making the interception. I also don't ever remember watching a game on tv and then seeing a blur come into the screen and blow a back or receiver up, when they weren't even visible on the screen before the shot. Only Troy P could close like that. Reed stayed way back and studied QB's eyes and tendencies to make interceptions, but Troy dominated in pretty much every other part of the game. They are too different to even compare. I would venture to say Troy was not really just a safety, he was "just a football player" in the best sense. He could do it all and be a perfect example of a man on and off the field, a true role model.

[@kp-ig9ex]

If he could do it all then why couldn't he pick off QBs? You do realize the goats like peyton manning and tom brady feared ed reed right? Ask brady how scary the steelers defense was to him and he would probably laugh and say I dont know but iv dropped alot of points and yardage on them ed could play any position as far as db went cb,ss and fs so no reed didnt always stay back since his first 4 years he played ss and won dpoy, look at the play where ed reed picked off peyton manning which in bill belichick's mind was the best defensive play he has ever seen reed intentionally misread a certain coverage from week one knowing manning would see it weeks to come and when manning saw it during game day reed exposed it..

[@df6148]

The real answer is Sean Taylor. He was the combination of Troy and Reed.

[@floydjones1219]

@@kp-ig9ex exactly 💯💯

[@floydjones1219]

Stop using wat troy do at the line of scrimmage against ed because troy is a strong safety and reed is a free safety

[@ufaxpyro4200]

2 total different positions and assignments if you played football before you would know what i'm talking about...ed is more of a ball hawk and troy plays more in the box come on people stop comparing them both

[@jaysonwastell2602]

Ufa

[@michael_caz_nyc]

I love both of them. No doubt 2 of the greatest to ever do it. (however) I've seen #43 do some Super-human-type things over the years. Great football IQ. Hit like a linebacker. "insane Ball-skills"

[@davidvictorsomerville6380]

Sean Taylor

[@MeeksOrtiz]

Both are GREAT! Reed was the better ball hawk, troy was the better ninja all over the field.

[@edwardhernandez2767]

Troy polomalu hands down .simply because the Steelers owned the ravens in the playoffs

[@macturner80]

Edward Hernandez i was gonna like but the likes are at 43

[@kp-ig9ex]

Only since the ravens couldnt get an offense rolling

[@setrump2391]

👍

[@KINGXSAMOAN]

Fact

[@jahqayburnett7736]

Both have 2 superbowls tho and Ed Reed killed Troy as far as interceptions I'll rather throw the ball towards Polamalu than Ed Reed

[@ekim4363]

Bill Belichick says that Ed Reed is one of the best safeties of all time to play. Not that Bill would discount what Troy did on the field. Tough to choose either one as better than each other when they were asked to do different assignments on the field.

[@michaelspencer9605]

Remember when Ed Reed got lit up by Hines Ward?

[@jahqayburnett7736]

@dead by hitboxes thank you 😂😂🤣

[@jahqayburnett7736]

You bringing up one play compared to the many times Reed lit his ass up 😂

[@df6148]

Hines Ward knew he took it too far on that play. It was a peel block. Ed never stood a chance because he didn’t see it. He had a rough day that day because it was the same game James Harrison blasted him for a fumble on punt return. Still, Ed Reed is a beast. He’s a leader and he’s somebody that will never quit in a game.

[@vze4y4hq]

remember when Hines Ward got lit up by Ed reed after that pop in ended he career.

[@jeffreyv8306]

@@df6148 reed didn't see ward? he was right in front of him. I understand that reed's eyes were on the ball carrier, but it wasn't like ward snuck up behind him

[@KINGXSAMOAN]

Trop pick 6 on the raven Force fumble on the raven(both playoff game) CLUTCH

[@Luxmuthafux]

There's the difference between them 😂😂

[@esetasi17]

Both played different positions. Troy Strong Safety and Reed Safety. Both played well at their positions.

[@Rocksteddybelmont]

Ese Tasi true

[@andrejamison2723]

@tone 22 in a different kind of Defense and he is known as a free

[@virginianative847]

Flash forward! Troy and Ed in the HOF!

[@tohitalakai3752]

The reason why he was not in the pro bowls because he was busy getting ready for the super bowl

[@insanemob8508]

He only went to 3 , Ed won every Super Bowl he played in

[@wrokaenation3992]

@@insanemob8508 which is 1

[@insanemob8508]

Wrokae Nation , I guess that still means he’s undefeated in Every Super Bowl he played in , right or wrong

[@wrokaenation3992]

@@insanemob8508 I guess, but your point being?

[@insanemob8508]

Wrokae Nation , jus saying , Ed undefeated in every Super Bowl he played in , take it how you want , jus like you saying he was only in 1 , so what you saying , you must not thank he’s any good cause he played in 1 , Steelers win Super Bowls when there team is loaded , Ravens win Super BowlS wit regular team and hard work and good character

[@df6148]

Troy AFC championship pick 6 to seal the win VS Ed reed.

[@jahqayburnett7736]

But Ed Reed has over half the pic 6's Troy has 😂 so that don't seal ish

[@jahqayburnett7736]

Troy had a wayyy beter QB than what Reed always had

[@df6148]

Jahqay Burnett idk Ed reeds entire ravens career was spent with Rey Rey at mLB. That makes his job easier.

[@df6148]

Jahqay Burnett Not only is Rey Lewis a monster on defense. He had leadership and awareness. Adjustments and everything. It doesnt take away from Ed Reed. He would ball no matter what. But it DID make it easier. No doubt.

[@shannonsharpe7695]

Jahqay Burnett strong safety vs free safety 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@john-bullenglish6343]

There’s no right or wrong answer. Either pick is a win.

[@kennythomas2516]

I've read alot of everyone comments...so far Troy Palamalu has got most of the votes. The fans have spoken...TROY!!!

[@kenkonwick6660]

Seems to me that Polamalu was bigger on big games. Both are absolute studs, there is no wrong choice here. Both physical, Both smart, they were called upon to do different things in different defenses. Ir Reed was in Pittsburgh and Polamalu was in Baltimore, I think Polamalu would have more impact there than Reed would have in Pittsburgh. Based on this, give me Troy by a whisker over Reed

[@nathancaldwell3949]

I’d take Troy over Ed Reed any day of the week

[@brittanybradford9239]

There will never be another Troy. I love Ed but Troy was so unique. He did it all.

[@paulmonfort8747]

Both are great players. Reed is the best ball hawk ever,but no one can touch palamalo on instinct.

[@vaimilicollins7909]

And who always owned the ravens ?? Steelers and ? Troy

[@TheIslandstyle11]

I don't known but Troy is alot more.exciting to watch with his high flying agilities and explosiveness!! GO POLAMALU!!🤘🤘🤘

[@tiyalewhitehurst338]

He was right there is" No wrong answer" pick wut ever style of player u like more

[@kassaiscool]

I am not to going to sit here and act like Troy isn't great. He is one of the most physical safeties that has ever played, but Ed Reed has actually broken records and has gotten close to breaking other records. Hes number one all time in interceptions return yards, number 7 all time in interceptions and could have been much higher if he wasn't constantly injured in the 2nd half of his career. I think he is tied for the most postseason interceptions of all time. He has the longest interception td return only to be break it himself again. The most entertaining player to watch on defense in history in my opinion.

[@saywhatchalikesportspodcas1545]

kassaiscool I'd like to invite you to leave your opinion on the Ed Reed vs Troy Polamalu debate video I have up on my channel. Hope you can check it out, Thanks!

[@BradyIsAfagInHeat]

I agree with most of what you said but Troy and his splash plays were and are much more entertaining to watch than ed reeds. Let's see ed Reed do a flip over the D line and O line to stuff a QB sneak (more than one occasion btw) and show me a play that takes more athleticism and cerebral awareness of cadence QB snap timing and troys physical timing to start running and jump over that line so perfectly to not be offsides, or touch his own D line and get a penalty for that as well. Those plays are some of the most incredible plays in NFL history. Not to mention his highline real of other jaw dropping athletic plays he's done throughout his career as well. Diving totally laid out and scooping a ball that was literally a quarter inch away from touching the turf and turning that into an interception. The dude was straight up amazing at what he did. And if I juries didn't ruin the second half of his career then who knows what other magic he could have conjured up every Sunday on that football field.

[@insanemob8508]

Ken Cranston , Show Troy taking a punt back for a TD

[@Que684]

Youre bias, Troy and Ed were neck and neck, one is not better than the other, because a conversation about Troy will always be a conversation about Ed and its the other way around. These two go hand in hand like peanut butter and jelly. Tell me otherwise

[@Que684]

@@insanemob8508 show ed making plays in the biggest stages, when the team needed their superstar safety to rise to the occasion. Stats are one way of immortalizing players, but seizing the greatest moments, where playmakers transcend to become game changers is another. Troy had those moments, and plenty of it. They are ying and yang, balance.

[@koimatai4600]

Troy all day everyday

[@slummyboss1631]

troy

[@the_grim_saint]

#TROY💯💯💯💯💯

[@al_foodwizard6035]

Troy Polamalu hands down

[@DV-dk5hd]

Man I'll take them both. They play two different positions. Could you imagine them both on the field at the same time, on the same team!

[@hunterwise5156]

Troy without question. Do the averages for their numbers and Ed Reed is barely ahead of Troy in coverage stats but Troy smokes Ed in physical/tackling stats

[@youknowho2541]

False

[@hunterwise5156]

@@youknowho2541 lol it's not false buddy, it's straight up facts cause that's stats. Go do some research kid😂🤦‍♂️

[@youknowho2541]

@@hunterwise5156 kid? I'm almost old enough to be your dad. What're you like 16? 😂 But I'll educate you.

[@youknowho2541]

@@hunterwise5156 Ed Reed led in all but tackles, about 30 less and sacks with 5 less yet Reed had double the ints, 2 or 3 maybe 4x the int return yards. If you know football, you know Ed is the best to ever play the position.People saying Troy are basically saying they would take the 5 extra sacks and 30 extra tackles instead of Reeds 32 more ints and Reeds 1640 int return yards. 🤣🤡🤡 5 sacks and 30 tackles is not more productive than 32 ints and quadruple the int return yards. And I haven't even started on kick returns, punt returns and blocks. Do YOUR reaearch kid. 🤣🤡🤡

[@youknowho2541]

@@hunterwise5156 Ed Reed was an offensive player on defense. Troy was great. But the numbers don't support what your saying. I'm providing cold hard facts.

[@mattyb884]

Troy 💯

[@dayztogia9374]

Troy all day baby

[@membersonlyyouweirdo1136]

Comparing Troy to Ed Reed is like 2pac to biggie ! Both Great players . This is a hard one . Both hall of famers no doubt

[@saywhatchalikesportspodcas1545]

Members Only You Weirdo I'd like to invite you to leave your opinion on the Ed Reed vs Troy Polamalu debate video I have up on my channel. Hope you can check it out, Thanks!

[@ucheokoroafor8273]

Biggie was better. Ed Reed is biggie

[@problemdj1893]

@@ucheokoroafor8273 your dumb

[@babyjesus1056]

@@ucheokoroafor8273 Tupac was better. Ed Reed is Tupac

[@tuttwith2ts]

@@ucheokoroafor8273 i like Guns n Roses

[@basically9751]

Those stats are very misleading. For one thing Troy didn't start his rookie year so it's more like 142 games for Troy, 174 for Reed, and secondly Troy had 783 tackles to 646 for Reed, not 531-581 and it also excludes TFL which Troy leads 56-34

[@DDDD22244]

Context is important to these stats. Just like you said it’s misleading for Troy these are misleading Ed too. If you watched the film instead of stat watchin, you would know Ed ain’t play in the box as much as troy, considering Ed was a FS most of his career.

[@teddygibson6731]

I grew up and got to see Ronnie Lott Steve Atwater. I watched film on Tatum. Ed and Troy are number one and two. They re-defined the safety position

[@jamesmatthews5365]

Ed was a free safety and Troy was a strong. That's the difference.

[@Eckster93]

Sheeeeiittt. Gimme either one. You won't hear my complain. Let's go Steelers

[@danielzajacjr3739]

Ed Reed was a great safety but overall Troy did way more

[@youknowho2541]

Negative.

[@bryanttisdale2446]

Ed Reed had multiple block punts and punt return for touchdown. Not to mention strip sack fumble. Int's , f.f. for those who thought Ed Reed only played free safety. Ed played games at strong in rookie season too.

[@youknowho2541]

@@bryanttisdale2446 his first 3 seasons I believe were SS.

[@chazd66]

Coming from a Steelers fan there's no wrong answer. These guys played different styles that complimented each other. Troy was a pre-snap mastermind, diagnosing the play and stopping it before it could develop. Then Reed would be there to assist by limiting 1/2 the field the quarterback could throw to. Having fewer options to throw to causing the quarterback to hold it longer, which could then turn in to more sacks by the front 7, or the offense starts running the ball more allowing both Troy and Reed to play up or the quarterback tries to be risky and test Reed, which more often than not results in failure for the QB. When either of these guys played in a game it wasn't a matter if they would make a big play, it was a matter of when they would make it.

[@elev8torguy130]

Raven fan here. I agree no wrong answer. We could argue till the cows come home but they were both awesome.

[@jimmydavis6192]

Troy all day every day

[@biglilfro]

Ed Reed has broken records but if you wanna win games and Superbowls just go with Troy. Troy got that Mamba Mentality even Kobe mentioned him in a documentary filmed by Spike. With that being said I'll go with Troy Polamalu

[@l.u.a4501]

2 completely different players. Ed is a bigger cornerback and troy is a faster and quicker linebacker

[@JAMESJJEFFERS]

It's Easy... What was the Steeler Vs Raven's Record?... Ed Reed might have been the Best to Intercept a Ball But Troy Will Get You The Game... UnMatched in Talents. Hell Troy Tackled Desean Jackson Backwards...Enough Said!!!!

[@kp-ig9ex]

You do realize the ravens had horrible quarter play for years right? Not taking anything away from troy but the steelers as a team were lucky to have big ben

[@JAMESJJEFFERS]

@@kp-ig9ex Wait You Mean Joe Flacco who beat the Pats in the SB and got a Multi Million Dollar Contract was Horrible or Maybe you are talking about Dilfer or the people inbetween.. 😂😂😂😂😂... Well Well Well... And You're saying this is why Ed Reed couldn't affect Big Ben like Troy affected Flacco?😳... I'm guessing the same can be said by All other QBs as well..

[@kp-ig9ex]

@@JAMESJJEFFERS JAMES J. JEFFERS that superbowl run wasnt even on joe Flacco did he play well? Yes absolutely but that offense got hot at the right time and lewis giving his retirement speech? And you really wanna talk about the impact each player had on the opposing team? When you had an offense like Pittsburg did through the years the defense stays fresh and name me one player Flacco had to throw to in the 2008 playoffs that could even compare to a Heinz ward? And dont worry reed had his fair share of games where he lit up big ben just look at his week 3 stats in 2011 against the steelers not to mention iv never recalled troy getting high praise from qbs like tom brady or peyton manning like reed has bill belichick himself said if he had to start a defensive backfield reed would be his first pick they guy could hit (not like troy) but he also could play man zone and special teams where troy lacked in coverage hence why brady and manning always lit up those 'steel curtain defenses'

[@kp-ig9ex]

@@JAMESJJEFFERS and dilfer wasnt even playing for the ravens when troy got drafted you goon 🤣🤣🤣just look at the praise reed has gotten from real goats guys that actually know football defensive players can only impact a game so much if the offense cant put up points

[@TheShepdawg9]

Ok I like troy too, but this level of assessment is so stupid. They're on 52 man teams. Just looking at their record is ridiculous.

[@gregoriojuliano4419]

Troy all Day

[@palmtrees6228]

#43

[@James-gk8ip]

Love the way these guys are using injuries as a factor on the positive side.

[@shfreeman4428]

Idk...I grew up watching both of them for over a decade.and to me, it was definitely Ed Reed, bros. Troy was like a Jesus..but Ed was like the GOD

[@darenlefeau4798]

Ed was in the NFL to do one job, is to play back field.....Troy was in the NFL to play football, hebwas every where...so there you go.

[@df6148]

Troy was more instinct and reflexes. Ed reed was more study film and execute what he saw on tape.

[@josecolon4248]

TROY ALL THE WAY GAME CHANGER VICIOUS

[@floydjones1219]

Reed was even more of a game changer

[@adamz38752]

It really depends on what the defensive scheme is

[@ronduckett5017]

No comparison. Troy could play both safety positions! GOAT!!!

[@xsincity_usox5702]

Troy Polamau is the greatest of all time

[@jahqayburnett7736]

Nahhh Reed is

[@spritualflight1187]

Jahqay Burnett Troy on top boy

[@jahqayburnett7736]

@@spritualflight1187 boy you smoking dope Reed was a killer on defense and special teams

[@spritualflight1187]

Jahqay Burnett what you sayin Troy play like a linebacker, cornerback and he can interspect the ball and hits his better then reed dude boy you smoking crack dawg and he was more aggressive and smarter dumbass

[@babyjesus1056]

@@spritualflight1187 Reed easily better

[@kathydisney7619]

Troy

[@THTCyrus]

Would it make sense to say that Reed was the better safety overall but Troy was more impactful?

[@denisjohnson8198]

Nah, b/c he wasn’t more impactful.

[@Que684]

@@denisjohnson8198 yes he was, show me a clip of Ed winning a meaningful game for his team. Troy did it on many accounts

[@denisjohnson8198]

@@Que684Congratulations on that highlight! I can show you clips of Michael Vick doing things Joe Montana & Troy Aikman never did. They both played 15 playoff games across 7 seasons; the biggest moments under the brightest lights. IMPACT: *Solo Tackles:* Polamalu 40 (0 fumbles) *REED 43 (2 fumbles)* *INT - yardage:* Polamalu 3 - 58 yds (7 PD) *REED 9 - 168 (19 PD)* . . .& no one was ever EVER afraid of being tackled by Polamalu. People feared where Reed was lurking. . .& it wasn’t b/c he has the most interception return yards of all time either. That’s impact, kid. #ReedTheGOAT

[@Que684]

@@denisjohnson8198 obviously u dont know wtf Im talking about. Tell me why Troy is considered along with Ed Reed as two of the best safeties of the last couple decades. It because Ed Reed was a complete safety and Troy was a an impactful safety. Show me where Ed Reed took his team to the SB. Where Ed won his team a playoff game. Troy has the ability to change games, sure Ed is a ball hawk monster but it doesnt mean he change games, his stats say more than what his impact entails, meaningful games for that matter.

[@denisjohnson8198]

@@Que684 notice how I have facts & stats. . .and you have “🥴wTf I’m TaLkIn’ ‘bOuT🥴” REED has set more records than Polamalu has “impacted” games🤣GtFoHwTbS #YourEsteogenLevelsAreSpiking

[@collinwilhelm7554]

Troy all the way

[@jaysonwastell2602]

TROY

[@BradyIsAfagInHeat]

Troy all day. Ed is good but his int. Numbers are inflated from catching batted balls that the cb would break up. They'd pop right in the air and instead of focusing on the tackle ed would focus on leaching off the work the CB already did. I'm not knocking him at all for it. But most of those ints. We're softballs underhanded right into reeds hands and chest. They weren't coverage ints. Like troys were. When troy was healthy he was hands down the best athlete in the NFL. Highly cerebral as well. Both are great but troy can add so much to your defensive scheme and packages that ed can't. based on that alone troy gets the nod. When Co ordinators gameplan against troy they didn't just have to worry about him down field they had to worry about him downfield, on the line, inside, outside lb positions, blitzing, dropping back, playing man or zone etc etc. Ed reed was an opportunistic ballhawk. That's it

[@shadowlazers]

The 1 thing I'll give reed that troy didnt do ..is the special teams blocks...sure ed has more int and tds..troy was more linebacker/safety..and most of Troy's ints..were thefts...jumping routes..while most of reeds were gimmes on over throws..allowing him to set up like a punt returner..just watch the highlights to verify..troy did things ever game no one else could..reed played great free safety and was more of a traditional fs..troy could play fs probably as well..but he was such a menace up close his skill set would be wasted having him play centerfielder fs

[@thejordan7114]

ED had torn sprained Mcls on Both knee's during the Superbowl

[@ToolTimeSlim27]

Ask Peyton Manning & Tom Brady who the better safety is? They was always worried about where Ed Reed was

[@donniedixon679]

I want both

[@mookeychase0907]

@Dustin Platt Bro you're right It's their ignorance Troy being a SS is suppose to have more sacks and tackles than Ed, and Ed being FS is suppose to have more INTs and TDs than Troy but TP only has 3 more forced fumbles and 6 more sacks they both have over 530 tackles (tho Troy has 50 more) so it aint like Ed wasn't cracking dudes and was just a cover guy and it wasn't like Troy wasn't getting picks. You defined it the difference was clearly in their positions.

[@TooTurntTurt]

You can't compare great to great

[@LillyLigaya]

Id take Troy Polamalu over Ed Reed because he was extremely intellectual. It seemed like he knew where every play was going to be. He also had very key moments in very key games. Troy made huge plays in the postseason, Im sure Raven fans know too well. Much respect for Ed Reed though, complete ball hawk.

[@DDDD22244]

No no no, Ed was intellectual too. It has been mentioned by all time greats and coaches that the intellect he had for the game was something they’ve never seen. His study habits and ability to know where plays were going were some of the greatest of all time, according to coaches, and players who played with or against him. Ed also had big time plays in big time games. INTS, punt returns, blocked kicks, he could do it all and he’s one of the hardest hitters ever.

[@Vmh1717]

Ed reed was amazing but Troy was just a better football player

[@jarviswilliams4374]

Lol you're fucking crazy!!!!

[@df6148]

Jarvis Williams by football player he really means to say that Troy was more versatile as a defender and could fill many roles as a hybrid whereas Ed Reed typically played Free Safety Only. By football player he means that he can line up at more positions and still ball out.

[@badbrad4154]

Troy polamalu

[@b.7811]

Ones a better run stopper, ones better at coverage.

[@jetdr]

If you must compare, Troy played fewer games and all numbers except INT are higher. Troy was hurt they were a beatable team, when he played Teams had to design plays just to go against him. Not really comparable. TP43 probably the biggest game changer since Mean Joe.

[@RushAnthem69]

Um, Lawrence Taylor? You must not be a football historian. 😂😂

[@floydjones1219]

All the other numbers were higher cuz troy played strong safety

[@DRWRITER08]

I'm taking ed reed. Can't go wrong with either tho.

[@iZargon7]

I agree there is no wrong answer.

[@gladius1275]

Truth is that of Troy switched and roamed the secondary as much as Ed, he would produce those interceptions and TDs. We all know how unbelievable Tryouts Troy’s hand and instinct was. But Troy ran a legitimate 4.3 and Ed ran a 4.58. Troy was much faster, and well stronger to boot. The truth is Troy could Play the way Ed did, but Ed could not play the way Troy did.

[@alexbaltimore]

Troy plays like a crazy person and it works but Ed is way smarter can read QBs head before they even made a decision. Ed plays the position way way WAY better than Troy. Troy just played the lottery most plays with timing Ed used his head

[@bryanttisdale2446]

You mean troy had to have Ryan Clark cover for him when he freelance. Ed Reed just had to be right. Not mention Ed Reed had more punt blocks. Also returned a punt return for a touchdown.

[@sethers9922]

Troy is more versatile. If I had to pick one, I want a guy that can do it all. I also would look at the Ravens-Steelers games and Troy was just so much better in those.

[@saywhatchalikesportspodcas1545]

Take Notice I'd like to invite you to leave your opinion on the Ed Reed vs Troy Polamalu debate video I have up on my channel. Hope you can check it out, Thanks!

[@killahuce6073]

None of Ed Reed's td come close to Troy's 2008 AFC championship heartbreaker pick 6 for the win against Reed. That game winning pick will be haunt the Ravens forever.

[@Beaumont99]

A Steeler/FSU giving unbiased opinion on Wd Reed ??? Nah I’m Good !

[@Silvertiger87]

When Hines Ward block Ed Reed then signaled for the medic…😂….I never saw Troy get rocked like that …

[@jrpelenatino8365]

Troy the king

[@hoseamatavao1483]

That is a good (Evaluation) both player like that i should had seen that in them 2 👍

[@marknethercutt3381]

Troy Polamalu play for the Pittsburgh Steelers his whole career

[@xreptar43x25]

polamalu

[@patrickfaima7764]

Troy was the only rover safety at the time

[@oriolestragic-feelithappen4806]

As a saftey, Ed Reed was much better than Troy was - as a linebacker i'd take troy hands down

[@TheTruthis5285]

I will DEFINITELY take Troy Polamalu EVERY SINGLE TIME!!!!!

[@TooTurntTurt]

Ones a free safety ones a safety not the same position technically so as far a overall defense them two on the same field

[@tylerengstrom9051]

they play 2 different positions...no comparisons

[@arielulogoifiti8522]

#TroyPolamalu

[@marknethercutt3381]

All day Troy Polamalu

[@dasiamathews8835]

Troy by far! we dominated the ravens in the decade we had Troy and I mean dominate them! dominated our division with Troy. Ed Reed was a bad ass no doubt and both class acts. But Troy played his position as safety so different from anyone I'd ever seen. And when he was hurt Pittsburgh struggled hard without him. He dominated the field

[@kakkacarrotcake1393]

you're wayyy outta line now lol..stats says it all...although they both have rings, troy has more iconic moments as with ed he's had some but most of the time he played how you expected him to. he also exceeds expectations

[@ContextReallyMatters]

dasia mathews Rex Ryan and Bill Belichek said Ed Reed is the best safety they ever saw. Rex said he is the greatest safety of all time and it's not even close. Bill said he thinks Ed is the most complete and overall best safety he has ever seen in the NFL

[@killahuce6073]

Id like to hear Ed Reed's thoughts on Troy's 2008 AFC championship heartbreaker intercept.

[@AntiLeftist]

TROY tops ED except interceptions with 16 GAME'S LESS... teams need 2 safety's FREE And STRONG they were the VERY BEST OF BOTH POSITIONS!!

[@orlandopadilla2464]

Troy played all kinds of coverage. Nickel and dime. His rookie season. What did Reed do his rookie season? Troy wasn't the same as Reed. One played free. The other played strong safety. Troy played at the line more then Ed did. That's why Ed had more pick offs. For TDS. Troy had more sacks and more tackle for lost.

[@DSrDavis-tq9qp]

Compare Troy with Dawkins, they where the same type of players

[@jackjackson811]

The correct answer is Brian Dawkins

[@georgecoull1883]

Troy 💯 love B Mc 🖤💛🖤💛

[@isaacmax2252]

Ed’s prob greatest cover safety ever but polamalu just does so much for a team. If you were building a defense from scratch, polamalu>reed.

[@youknowho2541]

Ed Reed led in all but tackles, about 30 less and sacks with 5 less yet Reed had double the ints, 2 or 3 maybe 4x the int return yards. If you know football, you know Ed is the best to ever play the position.People saying Troy are basically saying they would take the 5 extra sacks and 30 extra tackles instead of Reeds 32 more ints and Reeds 1640 int return yards. 🤣🤡🤡🤡