Electoral Politics, Revolution PTI Supporters and the Left - Aasim Sajjad Akhtar -

[@akhtarkhalid9080]

What a man what a man, treasure him, really a great man

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@nofi8783]

I love how youve challenging every guest in the last few podcasts on their philosophies and reasons for running in elections and what the hope to achive howevermuch you agree or disagree with their views it is very interesting too see how people balance their philosophical views with the electoral realities of the country

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@kushog1646]

Let’s exchange citizens ,the one Anti Nation gets exchanged & neutral go dual citizens and see the mess. 😂 Islamic extremism wanted this always right ? Except educated one. Talim ka Talha, Allah tallah he lagayega 💯 , mazzzhab toh bun jata hain , Insaan kab Banoge? That’s the question.

[@nofi8783]

@@kushog1646 how is this related to anything in this podcast or my comment tho :/ mei tou indian houn bhi nhi nah mei muslim houn na pakistan mere baap ne banaya jo mereko bol rhe ho do smthn productive with ur life

[@kushog1646]

😂 that’s why we are here commenting, Which is productive 🎉

[@toobasiddiq5716]

Thanking Sir Asim and others like him for helping make their students lifeling learners at Lums and elsewhere. 😊

[@khubaibsweat7029]

Excellent! How sir asim pointed out digitisation of politics has narrowed down our vision further and moved us further away from change is very pertinent and important to understand 👍🏽

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@KhalidHussain-uw1lr]

Very intellectual discussion. Sir Asim is literally an inspiring personality! Good job bro! Appreciated 👍

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ihsanqazi]

Asim Muneer 😂​@@ThePakistanExperience

[@abeebrattar5921]

Asim is kind and loving, bravo my leader✊✊💡💡

[@abeebrattar5921]

Asim always brings precisely and concrete facts and conclusions. Well done the Pakistan Experience

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@masroorahmad8835]

Yr Shahzad I am a very big fan and I think I am one of the few persons who watch almost all your videos I love you my friend keep it up best wishes

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌🙌🙌❤️❤️❤️

[@AbdullahKhan-zt6rq]

Phenomenal man asim Sajjad akhtar sahab

[@toqeerahmed8843]

Thank you so much ❤! Your way of questioning is amazing!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@samar9192]

So thought provoking. I wish I could take notes and echo the same to my relatives and friends and school going children.

[@DuaWaqas-i8f]

No poster banner of AWP was removed in islamabad .

[@venkataraghotham7586]

Sensible and extremely articulate I have some heard such incisive criticism.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@atokimruk937]

Karim, how are you ? HOW are things in Pindi ??

[@AbdullahKhan-zt6rq]

Kudos to you shehzad Bhai that you invited him❤❤❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@AmrinderSinghHundal]

My favourite podcaster from Pak-Shehzad

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@shivampatil23]

If Pakistan want to become a Develop country, Pakistanis 🇵🇰 have to keep ALLAH aside & Start Focusing on "Research & Innovation" along with "Entrepreneurship"

[@GuzzarAwan]

That is core of Pakistan. It will collapse without it.

[@mylakshmiveganheaven4562]

Pakistan has to open up its society to Western standards like india has done . Why do you think West trade with india not Pakistan, why usa Europe isreal france sell weapons to india , we are like a western nation . I tell to all Pakistanis stop living in past , Develop like India and gulf nations . And stop wasting money resources in useless elections , your nation has no money , takes loan from IMF china in high interest and you spend it on Rich landlord politicians their rallies 😂 In india poor wins elections and does work for his country, Rich will never help the common citizens. All the Pakistanis do is talk and talk but no Work this is reason why Pakistan is such conditions

[@MuhammadQasim-gq5eo]

What will you say about Saudi, Qatar, UAE? Development doesn't depend upon religion.

[@prakashkify]

Indians should focus on their own development first before worrying about Pakistan. India is even behind Bangladesh in terms of per capita GDP.

[@shivampatil23]

@@prakashkify 🤣🤣🤣🤣 madrasa knowledge

[@shivampatil23]

Aasim bhia Obsession with MODI Jo is just "WOW" ❤❤

[@GuzzarAwan]

Gaan fatti pari hai purey albakistan ki . To royengey hi. India ki 200 million ki poverty decrease ho rhi hai . According to Oxford. Usasey bhi inki jali hui hai 😂😂😂

[@AdityaKumar765-r7v]

Bhai Modi ki baat kis timeslap par hai . Plz

[@atokimruk937]

Half of Pakistan Punjab is where Khalistan will be. But by then all that will be left of Pakistan is IRPP - Islamic Republic of Punjab Pakistan. A land locked country like 🇦🇫

[@TheGrimStoic]

6:52 First mention of 'moodi'...C'mon guys - its got to be within the first five minutes - you're slipping

[@sajeelqayyum3363]

Being a PTI supporter, I would say that there is a realization even in the mainstream(punjabi) youth that the state has been the perpetrator in the periphery since the start of this country and this manifested in the form of support for Mahrang Baloch

[@B95RWBR]

Support? Where? When? Aside from a few left-wing activists no one visited the camp, no one held solidarity protests or discussions on campuses or online, no one tried to collect and deliver supplies for them either, didn't see a single public call for funds. Do people in punjab hate the army more than before? Yes sure. But do they care about baloch lives, pashtun lives, gilgiti lives, or the lives of working class men and women around them? I wish they did but I highly doubt it.

[@chusamamumtaz4608]

​@@B95RWBRWorking class?Why are you acting like somehow punjabis are like proper rich and are indifferent to other ethnic groups?

[@B95RWBR]

@@chusamamumtaz4608 You're missing the point Which was: What support?

[@sajeelqayyum3363]

Man why do you think that people in punjab dont care about innocent lives? It was just that before there was information asymmetry. And referring to your comment that no one visited them in their camp but that just it no one visited imran khan in jail or tried to visit him after May 9th. And maybe you dont wanna believe that punjabi did show solidarity with them online because you have already made up your opinion@@B95RWBR

[@aunthegeek5788]

Fantastic discussion.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@AneesKhan-vi5yn]

Great discussion. 👏❤It is requested to the producers of the podcast keh aglay episode main Saulat Nagi ko as a guest bulain. It would be an awsome discussion. Thanks!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ikramghauri9179]

Shahzad sahab, thank you for having asim sajjad on your talk show. After the AWP came in existence as an alliance of leading leftist parties of Pakistan, the then chairman of AWP Late Fanoos Gugar, Hasan Nasir, barrister safi ullah ghauri and myself invited imran Khan to join the AWP alliance and he was quite agreeable but the only cavil was that he wanted the AWP to merge itself in the PTI. Several negotiation rounds with him included incorporation of AWP's major objectives in the PTI's agenda. Then suddenly, Pakistan was reborn on 11th August 2011 with the new idealogy of imranisation of Pakistan and its institutions with electables herded in to the PTI to officially enact imranisation as grund norm of Pakistan.One has never heard Imran's fanclub demanding anything for people of Pakistan. Their narrative closes on nothing other than imran Khan so what can we expect from our youth. Try talking to them but you will be shocked to find that they can't see anything beyond the person of IK. The rest all is not their concern. I will request you to often invite asim sajjad to your show and contribute to the enlightenment of your audience specially the AWP's agenda. Regards

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@knowledgezavia]

I agree with many notions presented by Dr Asim. But he has the tendency to make a simple subject vary complicated. Many practical implementations of ideals presented by 20th century scholars provide a very bleak scenario regarding any further intervention for distribution of resources. Yet one cannot confine his imagination to dwell on the prospects of reforms in the near future.

[@ayaz372]

That's because those 20th century implementations were not concerned about changing the root cause of the problem (i-e capitalistic production system). They were only concerned about income distribution. So they were adding high taxes in the same capitalistic system. But he is talking about Land reforms, Public ownership of resources through nationalization, worker coop etc. Punishing unproductive industry like real estate etc. This is different from social democracy & reformism implemented in Europe. Yes this is not final stage, there are still changes needed but this is the step in the right direction to achieve even big change.

[@knowledgezavia]

@@ayaz372 let's see what the future entails for us. Social acceptance and subsequent coherence of such ideas is an interesting prospect regardless.

[@mustafaayaz2152]

In Pakistan, there's a crisis of cooperation as well where people despite having shared experiences and goals can't find a common ground to manoeuvre. Maybe its because of of the geographical faultines.

[@awasimdar]

Very engaging podcast

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@arslancheema6520]

Na 67 pp 37 hafizabad mein aap ka umeedwar or un ka intahabi nishaan Kya sir? Please bta dein

[@ThePakistanExperience]

No AWP candidate in hafizabad

[@ishtiaqkhattak7528]

love this podcast and Sir Asim is superb

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@arainmk]

Local government and proportional representation needed

[@ThePakistanExperience]

100%

[@ayaz372]

Yes, this first-pass-the-post electoral system needs to be replaced with proportional representative democracy. In our current system more than 50% votes go to waste. And small parties almost zero represention despite getting many votes. We need to replace this system like the current system in Europe where small parties have a good chance for making change. This will automatically solve many issues like Balochistan & KP issues But no mainstream party is talking about this. Because they are only concerned about their benefit. They don't care about democracy. kzbin.info/www/bejne/foeYon2clJWHrMU

[@ZS0719]

Before you say or start anything ..you have to change the name of PAGALISTAN to Pakistan!!!!! Because at this moment we are living in a country called PAGALISTAN

[@TheGrimStoic]

No one who has held any of the multiple apex of power that is Pakistan has ever been pagal - they have all been very rational players, including those like Gen.YK or PM.IK who were unfairly blamed to be of impaired judgement under the influence of substances. The problem is three-fold: 1. Multiple power centers due to disregard of due process and the resultant powerplays 2. Not enough patriotism in any of these power players 3. Populace's acute lack of understanding of how a system works and inexcusably short-term memory ( I was surprised it was claimed by someone yesterday to have been accurately identified by none other than NS for not starting his campaign in October) So the moniker that most accurately describes this unfortunate pathology is - MWKMNAISTAN (Mukhtalif-Walid-Kam-Mohibbulwatan-Naadaan-Awaam-istan)

[@civilrights20]

Maza agaya Boss. But realized at the end k hum jaise aam log Kuch nhi kar sakty

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@adeelakif814]

wow very deep discussion

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@anoshayfatima1611]

Bro ik TPE Islamabad is lit but why every episode in this series is shorter than rest of the podcasts 😢💔

[@ThePakistanExperience]

This one is close to 100 minutes bro

[@WomanAndLeadership]

The host was respectful of the guest this time and was not showing his over-confident side. Maybe he realized that his knowledge was far below that level of guest finally!!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

I always give the guests their due respect

[@WomanAndLeadership]

@@ThePakistanExperience you were very disrespectful with Sahil Adeem. I am not a fan of Sahil and do not follow him but the way he tolerated the questions (and most of them were antagonistic), I have developed respect for him.

[@ZS0719]

ITS NOT THAT MY LEADER IS IN JAIL!!! ITS BECAUSE HE DOES NOT BELONG THERE!

[@zeeshanasghar7065]

Brother Shahzad great work as always. What is the way forward for the younger generation? Which political party should they follow?

[@ThePakistanExperience]

AWP or HKP are a good start

[@anshuraj4277]

Free trade and free markets are good thing

[@sohrabjehan5799]

Fantastic ❤❤❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@gauravipal9518]

He says that he does npt support Palestinians only because they are Muslim. So where is his tweet on ictover 7 when 1200 Israelis were killed on Sabbath? Has he agrressively spoken against forced conversion of Hindu teenage girla in Pakiatan? Has he ever spoken against what Pakistsni supported terrorists did to Kashmiri Pandits? Unless he can give me examples of when he has spoken up for non-muslims oppressed by Muslims, I question his credibility.

[@TheGrimStoic]

Aap please samjhein - "only because they're..." is a loaded phrase. It does not exclude his supporting them BECAUSE they're..., it only means his support has some more reasons too. You only need to see Pakistani Human Rights Champions' completely brazen silence on the treatment of ... by the deeper than ocean higher than Himalaya sweeter than honey atheist eastern brother

[@danialhashmi1125]

اگر آپکے پاس واقعی کوئی معقول قابلِ عمل حل ہے تو نوجوانوں کو سوشل میڈیا پر انگیج کریں. آج وسائل نہ ہونے کا عزر میں کوئی وزن نہیں ہے.

[@MAzeeshan-po2nu]

bhai please ammar ali jan ko b kabhi set py bulayn. ya unky set py chaly jayn

[@ThePakistanExperience]

He’s been on set twice, TPE Lahore dekhayn

[@DuaWaqas-i8f]

Drawing room parties and unsuccessful person gives these types of lame excuses

[@alokranjan5410]

❤❤❤❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️❤️

[@DiscoverThal520]

❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

[@DiscoverThal520]

@@ThePakistanExperience Must episodes with old politician Javaid hashmi ,PM gelani Kher etc. Also talk on education policies❤

[@munvaray]

Kya zabrdast baat ki hai around 25 min. Hamaray logon ki masoom soch yeh hai k kutton se bachne k liye un se bara kutta le aao. Mathira tau bohat hi pehle keh chuki thi

[@ZS0719]

I have NO idea what you are talking about??? What’s the topic?

[@nofi8783]

Recently read a book by asim and it was very enlightening His analysis might be the best ive seen in recent times

[@ThePakistanExperience]

He is great

[@muhammadusman8583]

Grappppeeeee!

[@ShiaNoorAhlBayt]

He is my class teacher at Quaid e azam university, Islamabad.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Lucky you!

[@atokimruk937]

Condolences.

[@sardarmehmoodzaman1474]

بردارں لیفٹ آپ لوگ خود ہی خود کو لیفٹ کہتے ہیں پھر لوگ کیا کریں لیفٹ والے کیا رائٹ کریں گے دعا ہے کہ لیفٹ رائٹ والوں سے بچے رہیں

[@faautobahna9416]

This man is so obtuse. Glad was not his student. He needs to learn how to be coherent and complete points. Too jumpy from one point to another to another with no full meaning. Poor.

[@MuhammadQasim-gq5eo]

Assalamualikum! Give vote to Jamat E Islami for better future of yourself, your beloved ones and our beloved country. Thanks.

[@ZS0719]

What MAHAUL?? OMG this is non sense!! Waster of time

[@suttonhechmer7515]

😑 Promo sm

[@tanveerbd8748]

❤❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️❤️

[@nighatbhandari4821]

😂😂😂😂😂😂 Ap log aam Pakistani ki bat kar rahe ho OR bat sari English language ma ho rahi hy jo aam admi ko samajh hi nahi aa raha This is only ur satisfaction ky ap good vlog kar rahe ho 🤔🤔🤔🤔 Pakistan ki language Urdu hy jo ap logoon ko aati hi nahi 😡😡😡

[@ZS0719]

What???? You don’t think that PAGALISTAN needs a REVOLUTION in every field of life!!!! Judiciary/army /establishment/ government!!!!! I can’t believe that you are so naive?!!!

[@TheGrimStoic]

Revolution occours at a certain stage of disturbance, and it first destroys whatever institutions remain at that stage. It also requires a certain homogeneity in the populace. You guys are not there yet...perhaps never will be

[@ayushvikhe3796]

Pakistan should select a far-right government

[@landplus6231]

PPP was leftist and now right and people of Pakistan have. No choice

[@landplus6231]

❤ Not bonding with the masses

[@landplus6231]

Use ur strength through technology and not go for ballot politics

[@landplus6231]

Asim Sahib use AI technology to contact masses instead of direct contact

[@landplus6231]

Marxism is not like Quran needs to understand ground reality and to adopt community