Elon Musk with Nadiem Makarim 🔴Full Live Interview at Kampus Merdeka Festival | G20 Indonesia 2022

[@herosimobiko]

Main key points: 1. Getting widespread internet for Indonesia 2. Critical thinking for lower-level education 3. Being less wrong 4. Being curious about everything

[@robbanifauzi]

makasih banget sudah memperingkas ini

[@wahyuramadhan195]

Selalu mencerahkan dengar Elon Musk bicara. Selalu logis, selalu mencari yang mana benar dan selalu mengingatkan pentingnya sains dan ilmu pengetahuan 👍👍

[@floura_1709]

Bersyukur anak2 sy bersekolah di sekolah yg mengajarkan critical thinking n problem solving, mengedepankan pemahaman drpd hafalan. Menunggu pendidikan di Indo berubah butuh waktu yg lama, blm lg birokrasi & sdm yg sulit berubah yg spt Pak Nadiem bil..saran sy, byk survey sklh dan metode pengajarannya, interaksi dgn murid2nya apk mereka menikmati proses bljr atau merasa terpaksa bljr, thats really huge red flag for us as parents as awareness to choose school carefully n start to aware what children want not what we want. I highly recommend Sekolah Murid Merdeka, blended learning yg terjangkau, dpt diakses di kota manapun di dlm dan luar negri selama ada internet spt kt Mas Elon atau sekolah dgn metode IB.

[@dinnipratiwi7693]

IB dan Cambridge lebih bagus mana kak ?

[@mr.libluckiestinfinitebene2589]

Tp diajarkan tentang Indonesia dan Pendidikan Bernegara & Berbangsa Indonesia??

[@novankurniadi2325]

@@dinnipratiwi7693 depends on what your kid's preference. I personally teach in a school with Cambridge curriculum and we casually do is a lot of writing and analysis

[@donpepito928]

Emangnya hafalan hafalan gitu kgk pake krtikal thingking...sekolah diindoensia pun jg sdh banyak yg menerapkan kritikal thingking..liat aja pak jokowi cuma lulus sekolah dlm negeri tp visi dan wawasan lbih hebat dari lulusan luar negeri..enggak semua lulusan luar negeri kg berkualitas banyak jg yg zonk😁😁

[@ismipurisa]

@@donpepito928 komentar di atas bukan bilang sekolah luar negeri lo. Tapi sekolah yang mengajarkan berpikir kritis. Saya guru dan saya mengakui kok kalau meghafal itu tidak mengajarkan berpikir kritis. Makanya skor PISA negara kita rendah.

[@Trevor-z7b]

He made a substantial point about relevance. We need to understand the "why" before learning things, that's going to make everything easier and clearer for everyone.

[@amaliafathiarachmah1460]

I love this, very mindblowing.

[@atrudokht]

sangat berkelas, dua tokoh yang really smart having conversation

[@AdiyatCoto]

Yes, this is really on point.

[@erwinyonathan]

setuju dengan pentingnya critical thinking. ga hanya ngikutin aturan hanya karena disuruh atau hanya karena peraturan. terutama di indonesia, kalau ada yang tanya atau berargumen malah sering dicap membantah, kualat, dll.

[@pinoyguitartv]

The interviewer is great, 👍 So is Elon,🔥🔥🔥 Great work Indonesia 🙌👏👏

[@lambeefbiryani08]

12:03 this completely right,,in Aeronautical engineering college in Indonesia, they just show students the tools but never show us how to use it.. we know the name of tools but don't know how to use it cause they never teach us how to use these tools even hold the tools. College have big retired gas turbine engines but they never teach us how to diassembly or assembly the engine with those tools. Imagine how student can learn solve the problem if students don't know who to use these tools. Crazy right.. Sometimes i talk to myself, it's pointless pay that college to make us don't know how to use these tools..

[@carloschau9310]

Lovely to learn that, Indonesia put a tech guy to lead the education ministry

[@sulyzulfinaen1170]

I am totally Agree with Elon, "There is no point to remember, matter is have to decide what relevant and it's not relevant." kita tuh harus belajar menggunakan logika jadi tidak harus hapalan sama persis ketika pelajaran di sekolah. Dulu waktu sekolah banyak banget hapalan dan jujur saya tidak mampu. Seharusnya memang benar pendidikan itu yang paling utama ada adalah melatih logika siswa sehingg cara berpikir mereka tidak harus sama persis dengan yg ada di buku. tapi bisa lebih improve selama logika itu jalan dan relevant dalam case2.

[@hansjohanoei5627]

Both of you Makarim and Elon are really great person and will be the very good to remember for our future generation..

[@TuhTuh-sg1fn]

Agree... 👍👍

[@johnpu605]

Really enjoy watching and listening to Elon. Strange thing is I am actually deeply touched and moved by his drive and devotion to not only business but more importantly humanity. Anyone who has achieved anything in life will understand how incredibly hard or nearly impossible to be like Elon, by that I mean managing so many creative projects and keep pouring his life into inventing. Truly a legend and history will remember him forever.

[@ibrahimhassanlabib3085]

The interviewer did an awesome job ! great questions and managing the rhythm and flow of the convo perfectly

[@SYLMenTan]

he is minister of education Mr Nadiem

[@ibrahimhassanlabib3085]

@@SYLMenTan Oohh okay that makes sense now why he was so good ahahahaa

[@AnasNafisElmustof]

I'm a big fan of these two amazing individual

[@jossmelkr4134]

Truly inspiring and reigniting the spirit to take on more risks in life. I can't thank Nadiem enough for the inspiration he promulgated to the young Indonesians.

[@wahyujus]

having Nadiem inside our goverment giving me hope that indonesia went to the right path

[@vitamink9874]

12.00 Agree, karena di indonesia pendidikan dari dulu mengedepankan hafalan dibanding Pemecahan Masalah

[@profkg6613]

The Indonesian minister is something every government official should aspire for.

[@Storywa75]

Catatan sejarah besar buat Indonesia yg telah menyelenggarakan G20

[@ekasusilawati6441]

Semoga dunia pendidikan indonesia lebih baik 👍

[@madefordear]

I just found this video. Thanks Nadim & Elon. Both of you are inspiring!

[@percurious]

Realy a great interview - from all sides, Elon, the minister/interviewer and the people asking wuestions from the audience. Great watch, thanks so much for sharing!

[@senisundari1543]

Love it so much! Very inspiring, thanks Pak Minister of Education and Elon! ❤

[@reynoldhart6145]

pendidikan agar maksimal menurut Sy : tekankan passion masing2 siswa, focus utk pemecahan masalah, kritis dan etika yg mengedepankan toleransi Dan kebebasan(yg positif) serta kenyamanan(kebahagiaan)+hard working

[@prustysaurabh]

People in different cultures adorn clothings suited to the local climate/weather/seasons....but a middle east propaganda is pushing clothings in the name religion....but loved the way Indonesia has deep rooted respect for own culture...thats great...

[@Actidle]

Mungkin lebih baik kameranya Pak Nadiem di arahin ke orangnya langsung, bukan dari jauh (bahkan sampe ada orang yang ngehalangi kamera di menit awal) Soalnya Mr. Elon kameranya langsung di arahin ke orangnya langsung tapi gpp mungkin untuk kedepannya lebih baik

[@TulusHalomoanMarbun]

Indonesia should make more event like this, it is fascinating to learn something from huge self-made billionaire such as Elon

[@adisetyadi39]

elon.. a self-made figure? 😅

[@alifhunter]

loll elon ain't a self made figure

[@Searchforfulltruth911]

​@@adisetyadi39how is he not self made more proof could be nicer

[@Searchforfulltruth911]

​@@alifhunter???

[@alifhunter]

@@Searchforfulltruth911 his parents are rich

[@juanabosch7827]

ELON MUSK MOTIVACIÓN TOTAL 💪

[@alquranaa]

Elon: Well I read a lot of sci-fi and Fantasy books. Indonesian: my love only Fantasy without books

[@pyeum]

i watched it just now, i think this is the best talkshow/interview that i've ever watched so far, when two amazing people talk to each other and give us so many advice, thank you elon, nadiem, and beach bali channel!

[@beachbalichannel]

Thank you☺️

[@barbarabegany9580]

ElON, YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF OUR CURRENT EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM IS, IN MY EXPERIENCE, REAL AND WELL EXPRESSED BY YOU!!! ALSO, BEING AN OBSESSIVE CURIOS PERSON FROM CHILDHOOD MYSELF WAS DANGEROUS TO THOSE AROUND ME AND MADE OTHERS FEARFUL I HAVE FOUND, SO I WAS EXCLUDED A LOT, SO I SPENT MUCH TIME IN MY OWN RESEARCH, MAKING MY LIFE LONELY TO PRESENT DAY. BUT, I WON'T AND CAN'T GIVE UP MY CURIOSITY AS IT IS STIMULATING AND EXCITING♡♡♡ I WANT TO MEET YOU AND HUG YOU ♡♡♡

[@hesdocelvinnaraha944]

Wooow, this is a very amazingly conversation. Thank you Mas Menteri and thank you Elon.

[@allsaintsacademy9344]

This was a beautiful and brilliant interview. Will have my children watch for certain. Thank you!

[@jadilebihtau19]

I like the way Mas Mentri talks to Elon, well spoken and understood.

[@agusthinacorneliayenythalo9217]

I LIKE that: WITHOUT RISK WE CAN'T PROGRES 🌹👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿🌹 From Ministry Educational and Culture Indonesia: Makarim 💝💝🇲🇨🇲🇨🇲🇨🇲🇨🇲🇨🇲🇨💝💝

[@aishaish91]

Empowring words about education : Nadim : It is not what you know, it's actually do you know what to do with information that you are given or content that you understand Elon : It's trully important to establish relevance to say why are you trying to learn it because our minds are constantly trying to forget things, so that our minds are at a subconsious level trying to decide what is relevant and what is not relevant. Elon : Two fundamentally ways to approach education : by teaching to the tools and by teaching how to solve problem by trying to understand what tools do you need to slove the problem. Critical thinking is very important for young ages. Semangat pak Nadim dan pendidikan Indonesia. We believe you can make our education better!

[@Random-uj1rs]

Wow, isinya sangat berguna bagi pelajar, terima kasih telah menayangkannya di youtube

[@beachbalichannel]

Sama-sama, terimakasih kembali😊

[@andyrayhan39]

Thank you Mr.Elon for inspiring us.

[@WilliamCulver]

2022 Elon hits different

[@dandellionsy6537]

Banyak hal yang sudah dilakukan Elon tapi secara personality, orang macam Elon ini adalah orang yg tidak menyenangkan sebagai atasan krn dia kerja bagai kuda dan selalu menuntut hampir perfection. Sebagai orang yg pernah kerja sampe pagi krn tuntutan pekerjaan, skr lebih suka ke pekerjaan yang bisa memberikan waktu utk keluarga lebih banyak

[@TheGamingMotionTGM]

Tapi balik ke masing2 orang yang mau kerja sama dia. Bisa juga ada yang memang tidak berkeluarga (selibat) atau keluarganya bisa mengelola diri sendiri sehingga dia bisa fokus memberikan dedikasi dalam pekerjaan.

[@PhilKoay]

The best interview questions for Elon that I have heard

[@Talkless142]

If this guy is Indonesias minister the country has a bright future great guy

[@maureenlie3797]

It's amazing how a genius can just use a few words to bring up the whole mind of understanding.

[@juninanda3371]

Ditanya tentang habit, jawabannya curiousity. Mindblowing. Kirain bakalan jawab kaya makan, olahraga, atau jam tidur. Simple question, great answer.

[@ariangx1929]

21:23 murid yg nanya keren...

[@adisetiawan1987]

Saya umur 35 baru belajar bahasa pemrograman javascript php dll melalui e course untuk melatih cara berpikir kritis selain itu jg mau jadi programmer freelance sih hee

[@yusufkimindo7644]

Kalo boleh tau lu e course dimana bang

[@adisetiawan1987]

@@yusufkimindo7644 udemy untuk yg berbayar. klo yg gratis belajar coding bisa di channel web programming unpas

[@abdarafi]

Meanwhile, there’s somebody ever said: “internet cepat buat apa?”

[@navneetakumar1814]

Great inspiration Elon is a magician 🎩👏😳

[@heniapriani134]

I love Mr. Makarim english accent

[@faridsaifuddin1440]

GGnya yg jd pembawa acaranya mentri langsung n poinnya kayaknya lbih ngena pas di jelasin ma pak Nadim

[@vladwochinki3020]

gila nadiem masih muda keren banget

[@Kaotonix]

I've seen every elon interview ever published in the public domain, this one is great because Nadiem asks some great questions (even if Elon responds with things he's already said before)

[@zia-i]

6:11 "physics is the law and everything is a recomendation". Pak Musk mengajarkan kepada kita bahwa penentang bisa diabaikan karena baginya hukum dan aturan tertulis itu adalah omong kosong, selalu ada celah, tergantung pinter-pinternya kita ngakalin. Dengan kata lain kita diajarkan untuk lebih "kreatif" dan pandai dalam problem solving (ngakalin). 🤣

[@joshuanich06]

wow

[@RIRIany]

Simple response with powerful and big impact. No blabbering trash.

[@markmalonson7531]

I think he is a truly nice guy.

[@togilumbantobing]

so inspring watching and listening the explaining. i hope young people in Indonesia can be like Elon.

[@reginaazali2347]

Education of relevance, curiosity and critical thinking….that’d be nice. To do this, first you’ve got to change the system on how one’s intelectual pursuit is being rewarded, which topics should be taught in grade school and the grading system. You can’t encourage someone to be curios when you grade them by their ability to memorize some random information-which is how we currently grade our students at schools.

[@mkc_marikitacoba.]

iya kebanyakan hafalin rumus, pengertian, nama nama yang sebenarnya belum tentu semuanya dipake setiap individu tapi malah simaratakan di pendidikan indonesia harusnya dibikin spesialis pembelajaran tapi susah juga butuh effort dan biaya mewujudkan itu, benar kata elon lebih baik mengedepankan akses internet dan device karna setiap individu dapat belajar sesuai dengan minatnya dan kebutuhannya

[@HapPawhere]

@@mkc_marikitacoba. Kalo rumus memang harus dihafal sih pada dasarnya

[@Fikri0o0]

@@HapPawhere kalau dihapal tanpa tau asal usul rumusnya dan alesan dibalik rumus itu ada sama aja bohong. Kita diajarkan menghapal rumus integral, turunan, limit, dll. tpi bagaimana asal usul rumusnya, dan alesan kenapa rumus tsb relevan tidak di highlight saat belajar. Ujung2nya kebanyakan siswa lupa sama rumus2 tsb pas udh lulus sekolah. Berbeda klo kita paham sama relevansi rumusnya, walaupun kita udh lupa sama rumusnya, tpi disaat kita perlu menggunakan rumus tersebut kita bisa callback dengan mudah krn kita paham.

[@adien31]

@@Fikri0o0 susah buat otak anak sma paham asal usul rumus. Rumus diterima aja utk memecahkan masalah. Take it from someone who went to itb 😁

[@Yanto_Rundy96]

First principle thinking is a great way to learn more deeper and radical thinking. Tapi sygnya disuruh nge hafal doang hemmm

[@theArtiist_David]

Finally, these were questions I’ve been wanting to have had asked, tho Elon didn’t fully answer some of them :(. Most all his interviews. People are asking the same lame questions..

[@mathewhegan4606]

Surely having people who can critically think can allow free speech to bloom healthily.

[@urunangunabangsa]

This is very inspiring, proud to be Indonesian

[@muhammadramadhanpanjaitan233]

Wan Aibon tanding bahasa Inggris dengan Nadiem Makarim, aku yakin Wan Aibon kucar-kacir.

[@hst3003]

"Establish a relevance" Couldnt agree more You see, our education system forces us to learn everything on the menu, neglecting our interest. You probably have been hearing questions like "what would this subject do to my life", "is this going to be useful on daily basis?" ,Questions like these will never come out from they who enjoy or having a relevance to the subject, but in the other hand it just showed us that learning should be fun to everyone, and that can happen by simply consider students interest.

[@graciajay6716]

really inspired …. 🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿

[@ki6eki]

The moderator was great

[@mohini656]

I am a beautiful person who is the best way forward to seeing you all know that you can be found in the UK. Yes.thanks elon musk sir....

[@edwardlewis1963]

That was very worthwhile.

[@mayer1861]

Dsini elon nyinggung untuk ningkatin internet cepat dan merata sebanyak 2x, melihat betapa pentingnya internet untuk hampir semua sector. *Cheers

[@민윤기외이프]

pak nadiem as a pak elon fanboy is hilarious hahah

[@fajarmaulanaramadan7438]

Pelajaran yg harus ditambahkan di sekolah yaitu critical thinking, problem solving dan personal finance

[@IkaMiranti]

Very inspiring!!

[@pierrem.4258]

Very impressed with Pak Nadiem Makarim!

[@ariangx1929]

susah interview dia,, 1. vocab kt gk biasa di denger dia 2. timeline dan viewnya berbeda sekali kyk gula dan garam 3. gk biasa dia mau di tnya ,,, di ksih intro pertnyaan muter dl (liat fridman /joe yg berhasil interview dia)

[@reigenlucilfer6154]

fridman successfully interviewed him because the setting is relaxed, and they both more or less are the same type of people. this setting is more rigid and formal, thats why it feels awkward. i dont think its fair to compare pak this interview with podcast tbh on the first place.

[@saveajadulu]

mungkin elon musk bisa memulai teknologinya di Indonesia dengan menciptakan kipas angin portable.. kasihan para undangannya pada kipasan..

[@mattermosmusic]

Im actually proud of this

[@SastraKehiduapan]

Pendidikan Diniyah (tradisional) akan sangat berguna untuk menjaga pendidikan spritualitas, kemurnian pemahaman ilmu pengetahuan, serta pendidikan etika. Itu yang akan dibutuhkan kedepannya.

[@jnwl5068]

Nadiem punya English, bagus ya... 👍

[@andiqalfizaputra5987]

Lulusan Amerika, bapaknya dosen/professor di sana. Tapi beliau tetap kembali ke indonesia dan buka lapangan pekerjaan di Indonesia.

[@jnwl5068]

@@andiqalfizaputra5987 oh ok

[@dandellionsy6537]

hotman paris itu dulu kerja atau magang ke bapaknya nadiem, jadi mmg sudah kaya dan pinter dari sononya

[@atrudokht]

Jebolan luar negri gitu lho, cumlaude pula. Gak heran bhs inggrisnya bagus

[@yunnypascawatihenukh7570]

Bliau SMA sudah di LN

[@JohnSmith-pn2vl]

this was easily one of the best interviewers of Elon

[@willyjordan7196]

harus diup di ige!!

[@jalesvevajayamahe5670]

facetime terbaru tuh, yg bisa di blur background nya

[@coolfer2]

Great to see we went so far from "Internet cepat buat apa?" to here...

[@TheGamingMotionTGM]

Ya kalau koneksi jaringan nggak cepat, pak Elon dalam hati kayak "buset nih acara, semoga pemahaman kolot begini bisa terganti agar sayanya sama nadiem tidak putus koneksi ilmu".

[@pangeran_alfan16]

Pertemuan 2 orang cerdas 1 orang jenius di dunia Yg 1 lagi menteri pendidikan.

[@genocidegrand2057]

thank you

[@12washere]

Indonesia 2045 Generasi Emas. Dear Government, please make that happen

[@sauron5271]

itu saya terapin ilmu elon kerja 100 jam hasilnya dpt barang mewah wkwkw

[@Onyoutubech]

Buat yang sudah nonton Rocky Gerung di gita wirawan, akan ngerti apa yang dimaksud oleh elon musk di interview ini

[@faktapijar]

Bener. Rocky udah mulai malah, dia develop jurusan filsafat yg cuma lulasan s1

[@heruanggaraputra6966]

Link nya bang gw mau tonton takut salah konten

[@dranegameplay]

Great event, but I hope some of the questions would be more than that.

[@berLIMACrypto]

space x is magic

[@thedailybibleverseawordfro8922]

Internet is my inspiration to learn because I want to create my own internet data if I have knowledge how to create internet signal. Bluetooth connection is just like wireless data and use magnet for magnetic connect about it data internet.

[@alittifaqiahlecah]

Nadim (Gojek) - Elon (Tesla)

[@sike8310]

berdaging banget coy obrolanya gokil

[@osky3301]

menarik banget ini pembahasanya

[@FEYMIFAMILY]

good ..thank you

[@ternakcrypto1]

can u imagine if best dosen from all university doing open lecture in youtube

[@muh.syahrulpadli811]

Dosen = lecturer?

[@reigenlucilfer6154]

@@muh.syahrulpadli811 yup

[@zaupineppo927]

They might want to, but reluctant for doing it on a daily or regular basis as the pay is one concern. Another concern is the pride for their own uni where they dedicate themselves to.

[@tandiangnahapuloan]

Kalo bisa dibuat subtitle bahasa indonesianya. Soalnya saya hanya paham sedikit saja, karena ga begitu memahami bahasa inggris.

[@elsan2380]

That's your problem. Learn english language.

[@tandiangnahapuloan]

@@elsan2380 kalo sub indo dibuat, kan pesan yang disampaikan dari wawancara tersebut dapat tersampaikan ke LEBIH BANYAK masyarakat.

[@elsan2380]

@@tandiangnahapuloan Kebiasaan dinet*in si lu pada, jd ketemu tantangan dikit nyerah/males, pantes ga maju2

[@tandiangnahapuloan]

@@elsan2380 emangnya lo udah maju? 😅😅😅

[@elsan2380]

@@tandiangnahapuloan Ud.

[@1986verity]

I hope someone put a subtitles or dub this to bahasa... i don't agree with all they said, but this is important for many indonesian to be heard, just because you see a minister there and it can make indonesian lend their ears

[@MikasaeaAaah_Aahkercmoan]

Bahasa 🥴

[@VanReactions]

You can use the cc features and change it to auto translate to bahasa

[@achyutakrishna]

On education starts at 8:39

[@harvest1236]

Gila Pak Nadim, Inggrisnya Flawless anjir...

[@FisilaAfla]

harvard graduate bro:)

[@orange3149]

19:16 teringat "internet cepat buat apa?"

[@alhambase7468]

programming league is important skill to survive in digital world, then technical science.

[@manakaYT]

mas elon panutanq