[EMOTIONAL REACTION] Johnny Cash Reaction Video - Hurt

[@passionsquietrage]

This is a cover of a song originally by Nine Inch Nails. The biggest(and best)difference is that the original NiN version was about the regrets of one mistake, while this version is a reflection on an entire lifetime's worth of mistakes and regrets. This was also the last song Johnny recorded/released before his passing in 2003. Closing the piano at the end was his way of signing off and saying goodbye to his fans.

[@pegatheetoo1437]

Not quite ... Timi Yuro in the 60s

[@passionsquietrage]

@@pegatheetoo1437 ?What are you talking about?

[@pegatheetoo1437]

@@passionsquietrage Sorry ... Just noting that the song was originally performed in the 1960s by Timi Yuro.

[@Valecan]

@@pegatheetoo1437 That is a completely different song that you can verify by looking up the lyrics. The song sung here was originally written and performed by Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails and was about his drug addiction. They have the same title but very different songs.

[@passionsquietrage]

@@pegatheetoo1437 Valecan beat me to it, but it's a different song. Johnny covered one written by Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails.

[@disturbed4733]

Two halves of one life; BEFORE June Carter and AFTER "June Carter". Johnny often said, "In my moment of greatest despair, God sent June to save me". But no matter how successful he became, or how much good he did in the "After June" half of his life, he could never forgive himself for all the harm he did, the people he hurt, and the destruction he left in his wake during the "Before June" half. Sadly, a month after this was released, June died unexpectedly from complications following surgery and 4 months later he was gone.

[@marcusblackwell2372]

What was the surgery June had for?

[@disturbed4733]

@@marcusblackwell2372 To replace a heart valve (not sure which one), which nowadays is pretty common. But there were unforeseen complications. His daughter Rosanne Cash said after she died, Johnny lost the will to live and died.

[@trevorsongary3431]

OMG!!! FINALLY!!! Someone who understands!! NO ONE every makes this comment. No one seems to know his life and how this song absolutely encapsulated his life. Thank you!!!

[@markwaldman5389]

Please watch the ending again, and don't stop before Johnny completes his gesture closing the piano cover. The entire song is in that moment! You'll see!

[@chadbennett7873]

The important thing to know, is that he never opened that piano cover again. This was his final recording.

[@Aleks-fj5tj]

Обожаю эту песню.Любите друг друга друзья,ведь жизнь она дается один раз.Всем мира .

[@97warlock]

i spent my first 40 years growing up. th next 20 years made me appear old. one day, the mirror is something we avoid more & more often.

[@maryannanderson2213]

Johnny Cash's cover of this NIN song is just ONE example of why he is a legend. Back in his heyday, it is said that of every five records sold in this country, ONE of them was by Johnny Cash. I'm an old woman and I have been a fan of Johnny Cash's for as long as I can remember which was when he came out with his first song, Cry, Cry, Cry back in the mid-50's. Hurt will flat rip your heart out but if you want to hear one of his song's that will make you smile, listen to Boy Named Sue, One on the Left is on the Right, or One Piece at a Time. His passing left a huge hole in the world of country music.

[@davidaquarius9089]

Johnny Cash lived the 60's celebrity life - fame, fortune, drugs and despair. He had his own television show, held concerts with tens of thousands of fans but fell into some dark places and spent time in prison. When Trent Reznor (author of the song and front man of NIN) first heard Johnny's version, he was not impressed. When he finally saw this video, he did a 180 and declared that the song was no longer his. The video encapsulates Johnny's turbulent life from beginning to end, he passed away a few months after its release. As someone who experienced his music from beginning to end, I can say that the video does an amazing job of giving him his last act as a performer. RIP Johnny Cash and thank you Schnell for allowing us to see your honest reaction to this epic performance.

[@markhorton8578]

He never spent more than a night in the cells, for offenses whilst drunk or drugged. He was famous for visiting prisons and giving prisoners concerts.

[@rickwelch8464]

County jails and no real time.

[@davidaquarius9089]

Jail is jail. City lock up was like the waiting room at my dentist's office, county was 20 hours where I didn't want to close my eyes for a second.@@rickwelch8464

[@antivanti]

"-It feels like you're saying goodbye.." "-I am" 😭

[@randyhawley7202]

I loved your reaction ! As @dagmar.6954 mentioned, this was a cover of a Nine Inch Nails song - but Mr. Cash has put an indelible stamp of his own on it. He changed the focus of the lyrics by his phrasing and how he presented the message. The video producer (can't remember the name at this time) used the film clips to very effectively communicate and reinforce that focus. Enough so that the original composer said that is was Johnny's song now. Incredible performance. Strong, even forceful. Impactful. If this doesn't get you 'in your feels', you need to check that you still have a pulse.

[@johnpegues5701]

Hurt himself, his friends and fans, with wife, and his Savior...losing himself more than once...he did not write the song, but his version was/is so powerful...at 67 watching friends die, watching my career come to an end, looking at my own failures as a follower of Christ it left me in tears...as it was meant to do so powreful...from a great artist. I Walk the Line Johnny Cash with His Hot and Blue Guitar! · 1957 Folsom Prison Blues Johnny Cash with His Hot and Blue Guitar! · 1957 Ring of Fire Ring of Fire: The Best of Johnny Cash · 1963 God`s Gonna Cut You Down American V: A Hundred Highways

[@secretarts]

Trent Reznor wrote a good song with Hurt, and Johnny Cash turned it into a legendary anthem. Trent was quoted as saying he did not want a cover done, but after seeing the video, Trent agreed it was now Johnny Cash's song with so much feeling. "HURT" was nominated for six VMAs at the 2003 MTV Video Music Awards, and won for Best Cinematography, Justin Timberlake who won for Cry Me a River in his speech said "This is a travesty! I demand a recount, John Cash deserves this more than anyone here tonight." As to other songs by John Cash, there are no bad choices. But start with The Man In Black.

[@johnforsyth7987]

Thank you for your kind reaction. Something that most people do not know is that Johnny Cash is in the Country Music, Gospel Music, Rock and Roll Music and Songwriter's Halls of Fame. The only other person who is in all four music Halls of Fame is Elvis Presley.

[@lextek.]

The whole song and video hits you like a train. Trent Reznor (Nine Inch Nails) wrote this as a young man raging at the world. Johnny turned it around as a lament really, as an old man looking back over his years, trying to put triumph, torment, and loss into some sort of perspective. He knew his time here was now short. The very end where he closes the piano lid tells me that he knew and his mission on Earth was complete, all the good and the bad. From the fast cuts at the end that include Jesus and the cross he knew where he was going and could now be at peace finally. I'm 75 and frequently go through those reflective periods, and I can see the end of my runway from here. And like Johnny I know where I am going too. Thank you my God, Lord and King Jesus, Amen

[@dagmar.6954]

This song was originally written & performed by "Nine Inch Nails". It was written about drugs & depression. But Johnny Cash's version is considered the best. His version is more about regret for past mistakes in life & realizing material things & fame mean nothing in the end. When the video was filmed in February 2003, Cash was 71 years old & had serious health problems. His frailty is clearly evident in the video. He died seven months later, on September 12 & his wife, June Carter Cash, who is shown gazing at her husband in two sequences of the video, had died on May 15 of the same year.

[@1perfectpitch]

Johnny did his share of drugs too.

[@l0ngh4mm3r5]

I loved this song when I was young, and it was a nine-inch nails song. Now I am over 50, and Johnny's version hits in a whole different way. Much more power. Much more intense. Trent is a great songwriter, To be relevant and arguably better 30 years later? Damn.

[@douggauthier6878]

You left out the best part... When the original songwriter, Trent Reznor heard Johnny Cash's cover, he was asked something along the lines of: "What did you think of Johnny Cash's cover of your song?" He replied: "That's Johnny Cash's song, now."

[@macmcgee5116]

​@@douggauthier6878... From what I understand... When he first heard the cover, he wasn't that blow. Away. When he saw the video however, he changed his mind and said that.

[@macmcgee5116]

Interesting fact about the scenes with June. Supposedly, they were spontaneous. She was upstairs while they were recording. They had been at it for hours. Knowing how unhealthy Johnny was and how emotional this song was to him, she came downstairs to check on him. The director instructed the cameraman to zoom out and get her in the shot, then get some close ups. The look on her face is genuine concern for Johnny.

[@anthonymalovrh2912]

At 72, I can totally relate. Cry with every listen.

[@johnsonpaul1914]

I am 76 years old and this song really hits home. All those years gone by and what the hell was the point?

[@kennethbryson7751]

Of all of his great hits he has had in his lifetime I think this song was a masterpiece in the way he sung it and with the videos and pictures in the assembly of this video. He realized in his older years that all he had accomplished would soon mean nothing! I think his best work! Low bass Kenneth!

[@DesignerMillworx-nn5ec]

This was the last time Johnny played his piano. You see June (his wife) standing on the stairs. She had come down to make sure Johnny wasn't working too hard and the director captured it.

[@seloss5734]

Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails , after hearing Johnny Cash sing "Hurt" that Reznor wrote said, it's not my song anymore.

[@LincolnHawk-bk5yr]

As a life long Cash fan, well over a half century, this one tears me up every time.

[@shaunmoller2997]

Epic this is Johnny Cash at its best what a legend we miss you Sir Cash love your reaction Schnell

[@duanerutherford9033]

Heart wrenching is a good descriptor. That's the point. He's warning us. All the things we seem to think are so important.... Our empire of dirt.... Will be the last things on our minds when our time comes. Keep yourself. Find a way.

[@anthonycampos8057]

Johnny really liked the video and when he showed it to his daughter, she told him she didnt like it because the video made it seem like he was dying. Johnny was perplexed by her reaction. He didnt see what she saw. He just thought it was cool video.

[@surfingsub5854]

Sadly I'm reaching his age and slowly but surely starting to see others in my age range pass away. Have already lost both brothers as well. Wonderful song and thank you for the reaction video.

[@Thomas_Harkins123]

Good reaction

[@geoffmower8729]

Johnny saying goodbye. The video and song were released on Feb 2003 his wife died shortly after this was released on may 15th of may 2003 and Johnny shortly after that on Sep 12th 2003. The picture on the wall was his mother in law whom he was very close and the lady on the stairs was his wife June Carter Cash also a famous country and western singer in the day.

[@cowbuzzer]

The 2019 release was a remastering and re-release of the 2003 video. His wife June passed not too long after the video was released. He passed about 6 months after she did . He never opened that piano again after that video.

[@Derolo808]

Wonderful. Thank you. Now do R.E.M. - Leave. Trust me on this one.

[@thomastreece6773]

Schnell, it’s so wonderful to have you back! Johnny Cash is always a great choice. 3 songs to try next… A Boy Named Sue (humorous story), Man in Black (kind of Cash’s creed), and Folsom Prison Blues (one of many live performances for prisoners).

[@biglew1161]

when Johnny was still alive someone told him it sounds like your saying goodbye, he replied, I am.😭😭 When the video was filmed in February 2003, Cash was 71 years old and had serious health problems. His frailty is clearly evident in the video. He died seven months later, on September 12;[27] his wife, June Carter Cash, who is shown gazing at her husband in two sequences of the video, had died on May 15 of the same year.

[@xanadu6784]

Can you imagine being NIN, making a song, and having Johnny F---ing Cash decide that this song will convey the final message that he wanted to give the world during his limited time he had on this planet? As a songwriter who was entirely capable of making a song all his own. Johnny Cash could have been a completely unknown local singer in a rural town no one knew about, and that would be the greatest honor of anyone's career. Way more important then a thousand Grammies. Instead, it was Johnny Cash. What an honor.

[@629GSMITH]

This is DEEP DEEP.

[@jonathanwetherell3609]

This is a masterpiece. Crafted with a life time of musical and personal experience. So very different from the original.

[@dannydaniels2787]

You did better than me...I bawled my eyes out the first time and every time lol

[@roncarey8810]

Trent wrote a brilliant testament to all of our fragility.

[@dianegott9336]

It was his life. Unfortunately his beginning into the music world was tough. But boy he was amazing. I saw him live several times with June.

[@ronaldmcrae4896]

Saw him and June many moons ago. My late wife was luke warm to his music at best. She went with me begrudgingly. She came away a fan. Johnny was one of a kind.

[@JohnChilders-x9t]

I cried Like a baby on this song. I grew up on Johnny Cash

[@RobinC63]

Hey there. Canadian musician here also. 🇨🇦 Having grown up listening to Johnny Cash and knowing his life story I tear up every time I hear this song.

[@Zireael83]

nice reaction, thanks! btw, "Schnell" means "Fast" in german ^^ greetings rom germany :)

[@thodstagshorn1198]

Don't care how many times I hear this, it still gets me tearing up. As soon as it shows June, his wife, I lose it. Believe she passed away right after this.

[@bdlongshot07]

This video is so amazing, It lays out this man's life in under 4 minutes

[@nightwolf4185]

Great reaction

[@Sean-bf3lh]

Hello beautiful human

[@oriedy221]

I loved the NIN version, but Johnny blew that away. Even NIN said ots now his song bc they were blown away by it!

[@oriedy221]

This was recorded shortly b4 he died, shortly after June died. I still get emotional hearing it. So much that if it comes in at work out of the blue, I sometimes have to collect myself b4 continuing

[@doobiedave9686]

Trent Reznor of Nine inch Nails wrote this song and the NIN version is much more loud and aggressive. Producer Rick Rubin convinced Johnny to cover this song despite his reservations and it turned out to be one of Cash's top 5 songs of all time.

[@steviesellers]

His daughters when they listened to this song , they said daddy this sounds like your saying goodbye , Johnny said It is

[@troyvineyard3780]

Played this song at my dads funeral in 2004. He loved the song.

[@module79l28]

It's not the lyrics of the song that will make you cry, because he didn't write them, it's the lyrics applied to the person and his history. I've known the original since it came out and it never gave me chills or made me tear up like Johnny's cover does.

[@EverydayWithBobby]

You’re so beautiful 😩 amazing reaction miss!

[@JoeBlythe]

Schnell, you are gorgeous!

[@NathanMalnaa]

This song/video never fails to bring tears to my eyes. It's so good

[@marvinboswell6889]

This man has live a life on the throne of greatness but time always win and you sometimes regret what might have been

[@sca88]

The needle reference is fitting considering his years of battling heroin addiction as well as other substances and alcohol. He regretted the pain he put his longtime wife June Carter (in the video), his family and friends through.

[@MichaelBreeden-t6e]

He NEVER had heroin addiction, he was addicted to pills

[@clydeatrowbridge]

thanks schnell...great pix of johnny and june....

[@ronaldleach9899]

Epic....❤ 👏 👏 👏

[@jliggetts]

Saddest part was after recording this, when his daughter heard it for the first time she said it sounded like a goodbye letter and he said yes. Passed shortly after this

[@blinkybill2198]

RIP The Man in Black

[@Josh31287]

The way he slowly closes the piano gets me every time 😭

[@hadymrady]

Hello, to the beautiful artist lady,❤❤❤

[@kidpoker007]

Eva Cassidy Over the Rainbow live performance...25 Million views

[@lw3918]

This chick is smokin!

[@charlesheld3725]

The original was good Cash made it better But the video is what makes it a classic. It's a cover but you'd swear it's autobiographical.

[@bradenconway9066]

Johnny Cash died in 2003 and this was his last song. This song was originally a nine inch nails song and Trent Reznor said it was Johnny’s song after this

[@MichaelBreeden-t6e]

This was not his last song. People want to think it is because of the message but his last song was "like 309" which ironically is a full circle song and ending to his first song "hey porter"

[@priscilliayard6375]

Ooo thats wuz a long ago thanks i like to listen to you from curacao🇨🇼and holland ❤

[@paulkossak7761]

I'm sure he had his share of regrets but he also brought joy to many through his music. Rest in power big john, you'll never be forgotten.

[@Duke00x]

I am sure others have already commented it but I will make one just in case. The song is a cover of a nine inch nails song. But his and the original are completely different. One is clearly a young man at a very low point in his life where as this one is clearly an old man looking back on life and past mistakes as he says goodbye at the end of his life. Both are emotional in there own very different ways. This was also from much longer ago then just 4 years. That is just when that video was uploaded to KZbin.

[@michaelmagnum7132]

Johnny cash still affects people. Perhaps more than ever. After his death. Great choice!

[@nicholassoucy1543]

Notice how he always looks left. Like he's looking back on his life

[@royjohansen7472]

❤️ your reaction and ❤️ Johnny Cach 👍🥰

[@igosha9824]

This song must absolutely not be interrupted, under any circumstances!!!

[@b1blancer1]

It's quite the message, isn't it? Johnny Cash had pretty much seen everything and done everything. He either already had or could have anything material in this world he wanted. But as he felt the end approaching, he counted it all as an empire of dirt. At the end of his life, he had the same pain and regrets as the rest of us.

[@daveschreier1911]

Hey Schnell. Sweet to have you back! Mr. Cash is unequivocally a master, as was Merle Haggard and George Jones. If I may can I suggest reacting to another master: David Phelps. Notably his treatment of ' Ave Maria/The Lord's Prayer' medley. I assure you you will be just as moved. Can't wait!...

[@boblethbridge6292]

[@matttanner387]

Schell I wish I could give you a hug and a shoulder to cry on and wipe away your tears from your face as they trickle down your cheeks. 😢

[@scottdean2199]

Greatest. Cover. Ever!!

[@CalvinTownley]

Our pain is about the only thing that's real and we must learn from the pain or we will continue to hurt others 😊

[@heikkieronen5226]

❤

[@Iowacowboy4283]

Good song This song is how I feel every day

[@beltonite2243]

I would keep myself, I would find a way. Amen

[@bite28]

like ttheir a lot! and just now October Ends dropped a banger 🔥 You gotta react to it!

[@daviddavison3970]

It is said that when Johnny's daughter saw the video, she said, "It's almost like you're saying goodbye" in which he replied, "I am."

[@TakezoMusashi]

Be kind generous honest humble, to feel light of soul. Guilt compunds and cause trouble for the pshyce eventually. Basicly karma. Great lesson, this video, especially in this cold age where we are taught to be selfish.

[@blortmeister]

As you are a performer, I would recommend watching Elizabeth Zharoff's The Charismatic Voice where she breaks this song down. Elizabeth understands vocal performance better than almost anyone--and this just about destroyed her, but can bring a deeper understanding of what you just experienced.

[@Carln0130]

I don't know which Cash songs you may have already reacted to. Such a vast library of great songs. Here are some suggestions. From his late life time period, Further On Up The Road is great as is Ain't No Grave Going To Hold My Body Down. From his mainstream library, Sunday Morning Coming Down is amazing. Lighter hearted stuff, A Boy Named Sue, the version he sang live at, I believe it was, San Quentin. Folsom Prison Blues, I've Been Everywhere and Ghost Riders in the Sky should get you off to a good start. These are my People and I've been everywhere are great too.

[@Proudmule1]

Most of these people doing these reaction videos to this song stop the video before it is completely over. The closing of the piano and then his brushing the top of it with his hands then having his hands settle on the lid is such a powerful ending image. I hope she went back and watch it in its entirety.

[@TROUSDALE1313]

I like when they say “ without further ado “ and then you get further ado…

[@hellhound551]

The original song is about addiction and the regret and pain it causes. Johnny Cash had addiction problems that nearly destroyed him and his career. He was able to cover this song and make it his own because you can feel the pain and regret he feels for the life he lived. There are many kinds of addiction but that "prison" addicts create for themselves destroys them and everyone around them that loves them. A very emotional song to say the least.

[@GrandmaEllen]

Go next to "A Boy Named Sue." The feelings are different with that one. Then go to Ring of FIre. Grandma Ellen, out.

[@victorpratt9920]

Its not the little things, he's an addict feeling regret for lies and deception

[@coelacanth9821]

@ 7:15 you probably know this buy now but Cash didn't write this song Trent Reznor did. i'm an only casual nine inch nails fan but Trent certainly deserves credit for such intense and poetic lyrics... illuminated though they are by Johnny's application of them. (see the post by passionsquietrage below) Thank you for the video. i still haven't seen a "first time hearing" video for this song where the host is snottily crying by the end like i am! rest in peace J.R.

[@AlessandroOlla-h9c]

R I P Legend ❤

[@ericksoderquist8612]

Almost lol, he died in 2003, 21 years ago. I am 2 years older than he was when he died. His wife died months before him. This was how he said goodbye to his children.😊

[@brianjordan-5357]

Johnny Cash; Man named Sue.....

[@larryclark4297]

RIP J/C he passed away after he did

[@pietersbart]

For me (to paraphrase Joni Mitchell) music is touching souls. When you listen to this rendition from purely a technical point of view, this is not a hard melody, the reach is easy etc. But oh! how he hits my emotions every single time with this song: a sad reflection on his life.

[@kelvingaspero1822]

To understand Johnny Cash's life please watch this movie Walk the Line, His wife June Carter Cash standing on the stairs Died May 15, 2003 not long after the release of the song November 5, 2002 and Johnny Cash died on September 12, 2003

[@andyschnell58]

Schnell, thanks for reacting to the man in black, Johnny Cash. Sadly I missed the premiere due to a doctor's appointment. Hope you are doing well and enjoying your new home. I encourage everyone to check your library of reactions and try listening to a couple new artists. Might just find a new favorite.

[@KCBassPerformer]

❤❤❤

[@davidguerrero2305]

👀🌹🍷

[@scottpierce4547]

Another good Jonny Cash song is his cover of Gordon Lightfoot's "If you could read my mind". Recommend you check that one out.