Ep. 22: "Moonshadow" (118) or The Big Gig and a Big Fight | with Sam Trammell

[@NeptuneLady1957]

My plan was to watch along; watch the episode then watch the relating podcast. I FAILED! I ended up watching ALL SIX SEASONS in a matter of days after the 2nd podcast🤦🏽‍♀️. I am now trying again. Watched this episode; now I am ready. ❤

[@jenabans7350]

Me too!

[@amynapier3551]

Same. You're not alone. There is some shaming that people face in watching multiple episodes but it makes sense. Some episodes are really intense or have cliffhangers. It was tough to deal with the first time around because it hit too close to home or triggered anxiety. Now we have the freedom to watch how it makes sense to us.

[@chitchens1496]

Same. I've just stopped at The Train. I have rewatched plenty of times but with this podcast I am even more emotional.

[@mgr_rgm]

Same here

[@juliathrush4401]

Yup, did the same. Got to midseason and couldn't wait anymore.

[@ClemEverettYT]

that argument was EVERYTHINGGGGGGGG.... emmys immediately should have been given. they GOBBLED

[@sweetlife031]

I still don’t know how in the heck Mandy and Milo still managed to say those overlapping lines so coherently - even with Rebecca and Jack having to holler at each other! Whew 😥

[@carmellem6813]

Pleeeease come back for Season 2! This podcast gives me so much joy. You can tell you guys love each other even after the show ended ❤

[@afiaali4159]

Yes totally agree

[@jbc22112]

That fight may possibly be the most realistic married couple’s fight ever put on film. Yes, there are movies with great fights but they’re still more movie-like. This fight is something else, the whole lead up, silence, looks that speak volumes, slow roll erupting into yelling contest, it’s honestly incredible scene.

[@stephaniecoles2138]

The line that got me was when Jack said he was supposed to have another date that night and Rebecca said I wonder who she was and Jack said, “I never have”. Boom! That was it!

[@ThatWasUs]

Classic Jack.

[@sweetlife031]

@@ThatWasUs - *Ummmm… *timidly* … you guys - about the upcoming episode (with Milo) … is it still going to be watchable- and coherent- on here … even if some of us out there can’t make the live version? You know … in case … life’s priorities interfere? 🥹 And will Milo be on for the episode’s entirety, just as Sidd and Jon were? 😔*

[@Tach905]

THEY TEASE US WITH A PICTURE OF MILO IN THE STUDIO AND EVERY TUESDAY I THINK ITS THE NEXT😭

[@juliathrush4401]

I totally thought today was going to be the day!

[@michelina2765]

When it didn’t happen after the second or third week of the obvious tease, I decided it will come after the end of season 1. So if it’s not next week………

[@Teacher-Thayse]

Omg same! Can't wait 😅

[@lavernemason6904]

😂yup

[@jasminejames1090]

I have a feeling Milo's in THE episode of season 2... The Superbowl Sunday episode that breaks our hearts. SHATTERS them... Wrong or right, I can't wait to see the episode with him.

[@maiasilva709]

I love how fiercely Sterling defends Jack and Rebecca's relationship😂 and Mandy brings everyone back to earth because every man who approaches Bec romantically fades completely, doesn't even hold a shot. Bec is always doing her thing for herself, she knows where her ❤is

[@valeriaeapen6111]

"The biggest gift my parents ever gave me was to put me in a position where I did not have to guard anything" - those are some amazing parents ❤

[@ishakumar3055]

I can't believe we are already at the end of this season.. it feels like it flew .. I am sooo looking forward to the next season and everything you have in store for us!!! Mandy Moore congratulations on the new addition to your family ❤

[@jenniferperez212]

Sterling’s laugh gets me every time 😂

[@sealuck99]

It’s been so lovely rewatching with you. I really hope to continue season 2 together!

[@msandrews87]

I know this is old but Sterling's Jack impression is the best! 😂it gets me every time

[@darlenestokes368]

It was good to see Sterling and Chris on the Talk promoting the podcast. More promotion, please!

[@lynnlee157]

The argument scene was SOOOOO realistic. So many people can relate to this. So legit. AMAZING WRITING AND ACTING!!!

[@ane05]

“no wonder hillary didn’t get elected” LMAOO

[@emmamartin813]

This has been the greatest gift this podcast. My granda had dementia and watching Rebeccas storyline really helped support me during this time. Sadly, we lost my granda who I adored nearly two years ago and Ive loved being able to have an excuse to rewatch!

[@itomanpr]

That Jack and Rebecca fight was heartbreaking! Amazing performance by Milo and Mandy. Crazy to think we covered a season already with this podcast. Looking forward to what comes next. Very excited for Deja to join the story :D

[@SydneyKong]

“You keep volunteering information that he didn’t have” “What are you doing” LMAOOO BAAHBAHAAH

[@meggobeggo]

I’ve quite literally been telling and sharing to everyone I know who’s seen This Is Us, and some who haven’t (bc why haven’t you seen this immaculate show?!) Love this team so much, thank you all so much for reliving your experiences and sharing your perspectives. This show is a good hug when you need it the most, and this podcast is a forehead kiss right after ❤

[@ThatWasUs]

We love that analogy!

[@Estadisponibleparami]

😍😍😍

[@phoenixmoon3]

I wish y’all knew how much this podcast means to me. Thank you. ❤❤❤

[@ThatWasUs]

Thank you for being here!

[@ajpreclaro1608]

The scene, as Sterling put it, was so powerful and intense. It gave me an anxiety attack the first time and I have had to brace myself every time I rewatch it or just skip it completely. The way that it started with Jack and Rebecca acknowledging and rebutting each other’s grievances and escalated to just yelling over each other was too real. And the fact that later on we learn that Randall overheard everything. Chills. I’m hoping we get all 6 seasons on the podcast. It’s been something I look forward to every week and I recommend it to any and everyone I run into, usually when they ask if I listen to music and I say “not as much, but you know what you should listen to, my favourite podcast That Was Us”.

[@BigThreeChiu]

Congratulations on a fantastic Season 1! 🎉 I can’t wait for more Pearson family adventures! Each week, you all share so much wisdom and love, perfectly balancing episode breakdowns, BTS stories, life lessons, guest stars, and fan segments...it’s all beautifully executed!

[@johnnykalloniatis6350]

This the greatest trio. The show has all the feels . Thank you !!!!

[@yldnierfiol]

Aside from discussing the episodes. I love it when these 3 discuss about the entertainment industry (how to get in, how they were casted, and the like). ❤

[@kimberlywilkinson5445]

My husband and I recently finished the series for the first time. My hubby is still dealing with all the emotions the show brought out in him. This show is so relatable on some many different levels, I related to Kate throughout the show. I am excited to watch it all over again with the podcast!

[@sweetlife031]

That Was Us - This season has been terrific! 😊❤‍🩹 Can’t wait for Milo to come on the podcast! *PLEASE* you all……I’m begging you- please do all 6 seasons! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐😊

[@anja4740]

And also chrissy.

[@lukanyisonogambula5155]

The morning after the argument Rebecca was expecting Jack to be sleeping outside the bedroom door like the last time they fought. I can't remember which episode it was but it was earlier in the season. This might be my third time rewatching the series, this is the first time I noticed that. I still feel uncomfortable watching the argument between Jack and Rebecca 😂😂😂

[@MsShortstuff333]

Yes! I caught that as well.

[@AJA188667]

When Rebecca said the line of "just like your father" I was like WOW!! HOLD UP RIGHT THERE!! That's an incredible low blow!!!

[@janinasimmons7731]

Loved Season 1 of this podcast. Any revisiting of This Is Us I'm here for. Thanks Sterling, Chris, and Mandy!! 😀

[@jenniferryan501]

I have throughly loved watching yall and rewatching the show. I hope you continue for ALL the seasons :) Thank you for being such rays of sunshine in this world!

[@ThatWasUs]

Thank you for enjoying the sunshine!

[@MovableNu]

I can’t wait for season 2 of the podcast. I’m one of the heathens that has never watched the show before now. I’ve binged into season 4. I’m honestly glad I waited. It was always on my list, but after some other shows have broken my heart. I now ONLY watch shows once they’re completed. I would have died trying to watch this show in real time. And the podcast is the perfect dissection And behind-the-scenes enhancement to the show. Please keep all this awesomeness up! 💚🖤💚

[@c_a_h_1_1]

Season 1 has been a wonderful ride. I so enjoy the reflections every Tuesday. The BTS of Memphis had me like 😭😭😭❤️ Can’t wait for Season 2!!

[@LisaCrain-s5e]

I tell everyone! Please do all 6 seasons! Love it! 😍

[@ClemEverettYT]

i love this podcast so much... thanks yall i need all the way to the finale!! ESPECIALLY the episode with jack's mom's funeral, i sobbed like a baby and called my mother

[@wendylee13]

I think and I’m hoping that you guys continue to do the podcast even when you’re through all the episodes even if you’re just talking about life or what you ate yesterday you guys are seriously getting me through some very hard days right now, so please please continue the podcast no matter what it’s phenomenal!!!❤

[@xxangeleyes40xx]

I am so happy that you’re going straight into season 2 on the podcast, I’m not sure I could wait, especially as I have just watched Season two, episode 1 (it’s very difficult to not binge watch the whole season but I’m loving watching along with the podcast). Thank you for this gift 🥰

[@LizaJane761]

The big blow up….i felt everything Rebecca was saying. When she said “I have no life” as a stay at home mom of 3 and two with special needs and not much support from family…..I felt that……a lot of moms put their needs to on the back burner, because as a mom we feel everyone else’s needs are more important. Powerful scene. But Jack in the end all of the things he says of why he loves her ❤❤❤

[@juliathrush4401]

Wait, tell me you already recorded some season 2. I can't imagine my Tuesdays without ❤

[@lavernemason6904]

RIGHT! I'm like, why did they stand right there with the money??? LOL

[@CamilaCorinaB]

PLEASE keep doing this... I'm begging you

[@aromany]

Thank you from bringing all these characters from the show.. everbody is sooo nice, or very good actors😅 either way, it's so much fun to hear their perspectives

[@stefanienovodor4936]

I totally relate to being 40 with older kids. After giving them absolutely everything of me, I find myself at the point where I need to figure out what I like again and what fulfills me outside of the home. I often find myself just floating along like a ghost. Existing to maintain balance in the home while trying to figure myself out. It’s a big transition for everyone but for a woman and mom it’s adapt or stay a ghost.

[@brittanyyoung3009]

After I got off my couch from grieving and watching the show crying I started tell ppl watch it I needed it lost a brother in May this helped me deal with it

[@MovableNu]

My condolences 💗💗💗

[@stefanienovodor4936]

The man that played jacks father was on SWAT. I’ve seen him in many shows and movies and he is excellent. Every casting choice was perfection. Sophie, jacks mom and dad, Rebecca’s mom and dad, all the way to the mailman are just perfection. I’m watching this again with my boys aged 15 n 9. Such diff perspectives but profound. Also, has provided an insight into my own family as I have three brothers. How we could all grow up in the same home with the same parents and have such diff perspectives and ideas of how we grew up. Every woman has a right to be fulfilled esp at that age where being “mom” has evolved and we as moms need to redefine each other.

[@annikahilton6139]

Just want to say that I absolutely adore all 3 of you. Thank you to whoever came up with the idea to not only have a This is Us podcast, but to have 3 of the actors FROM THE MOST beautiful ensemble come together and lift our hearts all over again! You guys make my day every episode, and I look forward to smiling from ear to ear again season 2. This last episode was wonderful🩷. #ThatwasUs #WeloveLOVE

[@SydneyKong]

“Of course a g sharp minor what other key would we sing it in” LMAOOO AHAHAHBA

[@Lilhard5229]

Keep this podcast going !!

[@CarrieJordan-oe5wf]

"we had a white power bbq at Sam's house....in the film, in the film!"😂

[@annikahilton6139]

😂

[@liparedes1]

Pls pls pls SHAREEEEEEEEE I NEED THIS PODCAST TO CONTINUE

[@aileen847]

yes! Please come back for season 2 and more, my plan to follow along with each season, it was great rewatching the series w you guys 🙌🏽🙌🏽💯

[@ElizabethHofman]

I really enjoyed this podcast. Can’t wait for season 2!

[@aromany]

I love it when you all start narrating stuff or remembering stuff and laugh so much together❤

[@shivaniilangovan7590]

One really heartwarming and heartbreaking thing I noticed during the rewatch was that when Rebecca gets out of their bedroom, the morning after this massive fight, she looks outside the door, expecting Jack to be there but he isn't and then proceeds downstairs to talk with him... like this is pretty bad but this is not the end and Jack says something similar before leaving to Miguel's

[@chloegoulden5094]

“No wonder Hilary didn’t get elected”😂😂😂

[@pattytindall187]

Love the hat behind Sterling!

[@SydneyKong]

“That is somebody getting drunk” LMAOOOO AHAHAHA

[@alexandragrace5740]

This is the best rewatch podcast ever!!! I’ve been watching along with you guys

[@aromany]

I did my parte😂I've already told my bf and she began binging the podcast!

[@SydneyKong]

I’m glad I’m not the only one who thought that Jack and Rebecca were being set up on a blind date with each other

[@ativoflegacy]

Well yeah that was pretty clearly the misdirection they were going for

[@stefanienovodor4936]

This is a highlight of my week. Thank u for doing this.

[@Delaluz13]

Love this podcast! I will tell everyone we gotta make it to 6 seasons

[@giovanafischer8354]

I want this so bad to go on that I’ve been like haunting my friends for them to become weekly listeners as well 😅

[@angd4268]

I think this episode left us with hope for Jack and Rebecca. We know that Jack is not giving up on Rebecca.

[@katrelclack5356]

LOVE THIS PODCAST!!!

[@Jkm7fh]

Mandy, I loved Rebecca from the beginning. You portrayed her magnificently. Great job on silencing the nay-sayers.

[@andysvabygirl]

THIS PODCAST CAN"T END !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@alexandragrace5740]

Please give us another season!!! Im begging 🙏

[@SydneyKong]

“I don’t think he was just a mechanic” 💀💀💀💀

[@aromany]

You say "sure" then go figure it out!😂😂 is that a J.O.E.Y. reference??❤

[@manishajoshi7815]

wowowowow will there be no episode next week I AM GONNNAAA CRRYYYY!!!!

[@ThatWasUs]

We are back next week!

[@giovanafischer8354]

@@ThatWasUsoh thank god! I can breathe now 🥰

[@beasadler]

I feel so sad that Rebecca never got the chance to realize her dream

[@mqk1697]

Milo channeling Jess Mariano there!

[@SydneyKong]

It was soooo intenseeeee. But what made my blood boil is the fact that she let him leave after he told her how many things he loved about her. I was like WHAT ?!?!? WHAT ??

[@stefanienovodor4936]

Sounds like when Randall tells Beth she’s a middle aged woman teaching suburban housewives to twirl.

[@ShadowBlade79]

Randall flashes back to that when he and Beth have their big blowout, remember that?

[@SydneyKong]

“You sure this is how you want to end the show” LMAOOO AHAHHA

[@SydneyKong]

“Ex lover my ass” LMAOOO

[@alexandragrace5740]

I need a real life Jack Pearson please!! That “I never have” line made me cry!!!

[@elodie_k221b]

I was so angry with Jack in this episode, ruining the one opportunity Rebecca had to do something she loved and belittling her with his "that's not a career, it's ridiculous".

[@christinakoch2738]

I love you guys so much!! ❤️❤️❤️

[@mehaileyb]

My favorite day of the week

[@giovanafischer8354]

Hey isn’t season 2 one of the best seasons of the show? Its coming! Yeyyy 🌷🌷🌷

[@wispycrys1]

I watch the KZbin version every week, and it's clear to me that I'm missing whatever platform it is where they ask the questions of the audience. I keep thinking I would like to participate, but I don't know where to go to do that. @Thatwasuspod can you help direct me to the place with the questions?

[@ThatWasUs]

We post questions to the That Was Us social media platforms, and you can email us with your stories and reactions to episodes too. We do film ahead, so questions will post on social channels much earlier than they appear in our episodes.

[@wispycrys1]

@ThatWasUs I don't know how I've missed them... I guess I've only been following on KZbin and Instagram

[@soapyfankatie]

My favorite rewatch podcast

[@beatrizlopez2733]

I will definitely be telling everyone I know about this! And now I will also watch Predator- thank you for the recommendation, Sterling

[@SydneyKong]

But come to find out in season 3 he wasn’t just a mechanic he was a staff sergeant and was responsible for a whole group of people

[@nicholasgoetz7212]

I wonder if they have Justin on when they talk about season 4 finale

[@TheWelwicha]

Do you know you have 30 minutes to give us S2?! 30, yes 30, 30...... yes.

[@nayecervantes9126]

I thought this would be the Milo episode :( quoting Rebecca on s1 ep 12: How much longer? 👀

[@ThatWasUs]

Soon!

[@sarahagoune7006]

Chris Sullivan could have been a shrink. Failure came from inside that's true very often.

[@ClemEverettYT]

I was Team Rebecca!

[@BigThreeChiu]

if all the haters from season 1 could see themselves now

[@SydneyKong]

I sent you guys an email about my thoughts on this episode when you guys were on episode 14 on season 1. Because I wanted to see your guys reaction between their whole fight scene. I am now on season 3 episode 8. I haven’t watched it in about a couple weeks. Idk I’m not in the mood to cry and get emotional. But I should watch it because I haven’t watched the show in 2 weeks.

[@julieako]

One reason people were mad at Rebecca was b/c of William. I have a friend who is still mad at her about it!

[@jessdubose188]

Here's the thing about forehead to forehead contact: If Rebecca was doing that with one of her girlfriends before the show to get some encouragement and grounding, it wouldn't be seen as romantic or sexual at all. Women touch to support each other. So I think it's completely reasonable that she in the moment, was not remotely thinking this to be inappropriate.

[@aromany]

Did you think young Rebecca gave up too easily on her singing dream? When she met Jack that was her main aspiration and then after the LA rejection it just disappeared

[@giovanafischer8354]

So fast 💛💛💛

[@creejackson1575]

Listening to this Podcast has caused me to re-watch the show.

[@aromany]

That's the only episode, i think, that i didn't like Jack at all..