EP-223 | Ballot Over Bullet: A New Era for Kashmir? | Haryana Polls | Yana Mir & Rasheed Kidwai

[@l.d.agarwal3893]

I went to Kashmir first time in 1969 after my marriage and was shocked 😳 and surprised to find every Kashmiri Muslim reminding us that they are a different country by asking “aap Hindustan se Aaye Hain” This was handiwork of Jawaharlal Nehru and Sheikh Abdullah !

[@svojask5312]

We visited in 2012 and felt like foreigners the kashmiri driver the commoners were not free very aloof

[@pm_91_]

I visited recently & they treated me well. I think they have the ability to sense the bullshit & categorise them. Grow up folks.

[@svojask5312]

@@pm_91_ yes we grow up we adjust that's y you felt them.changed Grow up??? is we adjusting.

[@renukagolappanavar6005]

But still they have it inside, something which you feel.wr visited very recently kashmir.we could feel it.

[@premkumarparikarath1569]

60% voters turned up for the polls defying Pakistan dictum. As Yana said, that was the biggest victory for Mr. Modi. People face no fear now, breathing the free air, kids are going to school without fear, people are happy overall. That is victory for Sh. Modi. Not electoral victory.

[@CrickTrader]

Don't worry wait 1 year sir you will see naya Kashmir 😅

[@Lakshyam9]

After this 'big victory' for Modi, KHANgress will come and send the state back to Middle Ages

[@lonenomaan5821]

In 2014 it was 65 %

[@stickyfanchoo7568]

People voted against artificial silence and suffocation modi created these years , to have at least someone they can question abt policies

[@prasathgopinath1959]

Actually it's less than the last election in 2014 , how it is big victory for modi

[@salmanrather5432]

Yana mir such a courageous lady.. she has more spine than our kashmiri leaders..she represents us -the modern kashmiris.. she should have been our leader

[@asnfhtmlzxsje274]

She is different

[@Stardusk380]

​​@@asnfhtmlzxsje274 Come from real ID, bihari.

[@Mnio160]

For all Muslims … First it is .. Modi vs Islam BJP vs Islam India vs Islam later Sunni vs Shia Final stage barbad like Pakistan Iran Iraq ..

[@anujsethi7845]

For all Hindus Dalit vs Brahmins Bihari vs kannada Geeta vs Indian constitution Hindi vs non hindi

[@Mnio160]

@@anujsethi7845 true , country always comes first to Hindus or Christians or Buddhists … unlike Islam

[@abhinavsinghraghuvanshi2047]

Still we are successful in our lives unlike youuhhhh​@anujsethi7845

[@Mnio160]

@@anujsethi7845 but for Hindus , Christians , Buddhist … nation comes before religion .. unlike Muslims and Islam ..

[@gods-best-friend-gbf]

For all Muslims, Ummah comes first, no matter what. Converted Muslims love the Ummah more than Saudi Arab Muslims ( who themselves were forcefully converted by that desert Monster born in 571 AD ). Even Arab Muslims call the converted fakes in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh as Hindus, themselves. What more to say 😅

[@vinodraina8526]

Should have called Rajdharam reporter instead of Yana

[@khalidhuzaif3517]

Ek kashmiri sab tiwari p bhari 😂

[@GurjarUmesh-y9y]

​@@khalidhuzaif3517 rahn de nhi Kara ryme ...we like yana but rajdharma shows the view of muslims

[@pranavsinghgautam7279]

​@@khalidhuzaif3517 Bhai hum log ke paise jo tumpe barbaad ho rahe hain wapas kardo. Humare tukdon pe palte ho aur Hezbollah ke gaane gaate ho. Yahi karna hai toh Iran se paise lo humare tax ke paise mat lo

[@jatendra4925]

Rajdharma 😂

[@gods-best-friend-gbf]

Her name is Archana Tiwari. She and Yana would've been great combo. These days, even few Pakistanis are better and more honest than Kashmiri Muslims. They are guilty for what they did to Kashmiri Pandits. But nothing to worry. Karma is watching.

[@Vedansh-g4i]

BJP is much better than Congress My entire family is a BJP supporter but BJP did not campaign at the grassroots level in Haryana. After 2014, Haryana is developing but they will have to work at the grassroots level. No BJP leader has come to my area to know what people think about him and what are the problems?

[@anujsethi7845]

Haryana developed in the last ten years? Ya we can see roads of haryana. Haryana money going to UP

[@Vedansh-g4i]

@@anujsethi7845 Before 2014, there was power cut for minimum 5 hours and maximum 4 days in summer. But now if I register any problem anytime at night the problem is solved in less than an hour

[@Vedansh-g4i]

@@anujsethi7845 I know that Bjp have some issues but still it is better than any other party If Rahul Gandhi is better than MODI than why Rahul Gandhi say that sikhs can't wear turban in India And why he is doing meetings with the terrorist in USA HE SAID THAT THERE WAS A HINDU TERROR IN INDIA AND NOT THE ISLAMIC TERROR

[@Vedansh-g4i]

@@anujsethi7845 the main problem is that the Congress has a pr team better than BJP GO AND CHECK THE LIST OF SCAM AND ATTACK ON HINDU UNDER UPA GOVT. BEFORE 2014

[@anujsethi7845]

@@Vedansh-g4i might be you are getting electricity but in rohtak and gurgaon we still faced long electricity cuts. And some areas have been improved in recent years so they took almost a decade to resolve things. What is your age? Haryana is facing a high unemployment rate in this country What this government did with the farmers shows that I have zero respect for the government. Agniver scheme, wrestler protest. I can go on and on but if you think this government is doing something might you are just bhakt or blind which can't see the things right. Infrastructure in haryana still worse

[@abhisheksaini1964]

Shame! ma'am comparing Kashmiri pandits boycott with jamat people boycott because it's not same !😢

[@rakeshraina9846]

Kashmiri Muslims have been pampered over the years by having receiving doors and taught that they are separate I think they are now facing the harsh reality

[@krunalpanchal6415]

Exactly summarised

[@gods-best-friend-gbf]

Not just Kashmiri Muslims. But, all Muslims all over India and in all Secular, Liberal Democracies all over the world. They did not have guts to go to their own 57 Islamic countries and repair them. They just want more and more countries... 58, 59, 60...

[@bookloverblogs]

1. First of all, how many Kashmiri Muslims believe and can honestly say that Kashmiri pandits' was a genocide and not an exodus? Yana is trying to be diplomatic and that does not help. Be clear in your views. 2. When and how many Muslims were driven out of Kashmir during the time of Kashmiri pandits' assassination?! Who did it?! Where do people come up with such theories?!

[@renukagolappanavar6005]

They don't even acknowledge it

[@satyabodhmutgi1287]

This time the CM will be from Jammu for sure.

[@UsmanParray-k2j]

Sapna ma

[@CrickTrader]

70 years dream jus sleep and see it again 😂

[@suniltambe1]

Everybody wants that...vote whole heartedly for BJP just like the mullah do...no matter what your issues are,whether you're happy or highly dissatisfied with BJP...screw that just vote for BJP.

[@Kapil-w8l]

Bhai we need saprate state for jammu, we don't want to live with kashmir

[@bhatfarhana]

The most fearless voice of Yana ❤ This is something very eye opening and worth watching 👍

[@shivampatil23]

Modi ji did everything for J&K, but still he will NEVER get MAJORITY in J&K 😢😢

[@affanzaman6683]

He did ghanta. Can you tell me what he did..

[@shivampatil23]

@@affanzaman6683 Pakistani Mulla BOT spotted 😂😂

[@shivampatil23]

@@affanzaman6683 What, he did for J&K is on Internet. Do check if Internet is available in Pakistan 😂😂

[@anujsethi7845]

​@@shivampatil23lol stupid internet is a basic thing and modi shutdown the internet at the highest number of times in Kashmir. That shows modi did nothing in Kashmir. If people aren't voting for Modi, that means he is not doing his job. Let the people of J&K decide You are no one to decide

[@shivampatil23]

@@anujsethi7845 SAME applies to you too ☺️☺️ YOU ARE NO ONE TO DECIDE, What Modi did & What NOT ??? OK, Congressi....

[@markets28]

Yana, this is not debate. This is a podcast.

[@curiouscasey2309]

Yana wants to decide for Kashmiri pandits .....whn they should or should not move on.....man this woman needs to learn to be a human being

[@FurqanDrabu]

Haters from the both sides must be crying in the corner. Knowing yana in person she is an amazing person. Yana keep up doing your good work. Well wisher from anantnag

[@krislo4788]

Crying? she is a wishy washy person...odd even days pro max

[@youthwave]

Very lively and informative conversation... Smita staying as cheerful as ever ... 😊

[@poonamsingh4369]

This girl who spewed venom for archana tiwari on showing kashmiri 's real face , Yana showed her masked face. I am not listening to her ,never.

[@Unapologeticallynationalist]

Very true

[@Unapologeticallynationalist]

Very true

[@renukagolappanavar6005]

Yes ,at the end of day , they show what they are

[@suhailreshi3635]

Thank you Smita Ji for bringing yana ji for talks she talks sense. Radicals from the both sides will judge no matter what. We love yana and we stand with her. She is a gem kind of person

[@gajananranade9429]

Ms. Yanaji your assessment is very apt, and good at it.

[@shafiarather9174]

Yana gets attacked by Indians becoz she doesnt suport killing Kashmiris Yana gets attack by pakistanis, becoz she supports India Yana gets attacked by Kashmir's political parties becoz she represents Kashmir better than them But YANA DOESNT GIVE UP! What a strong girl ❤❤

[@ankitra3667]

true ....

[@binakhimji6509]

I agree with you 💯

[@krislo4788]

Yana never supported Kashmiri Pandits...never acknowledged the ethnic cleansing of Kashmiri Pandits from Kashmir valley...yeah...she is a jihadi with a nice secular mask..I think all you Muslims are the same...

[@touseefitoo9789]

Yana is a pure soul without any hypocrisy and it make many sad. They want people to be hypocrite like they are. Yana is a wonderful person i got opportunity to meet her at her home in Srinagar along with her family. Such a wonderful family. Remember Wazwan at your home. It was delicious

[@indiancitizen9716]

Rashid kidwai can never show his respect for bjp. He is a staunch congress supporter

[@TheKewlP]

Archana Tiwari should have been invited

[@aniruddhalonikar9605]

Very good logical and rational debate good to hear both generations of these two panelist

[@Interstellar2123]

Yana is hypocrite

[@Unapologeticallynationalist]

Absolutely agreed

[@sandie1306]

💯

[@krislo4788]

Totally...lekin andh bhakt BJP ke maanenge nahi

[@paddysubramaniam1481]

PLEASE Come on media people...meritocracy is the ONLY way to progress in a fair manner....PUT A STOP TO DYNASTIC POLITICS !! India is a country of billion people ...voters should SHUN the mindset that only dynasties can be in power !!

[@ChandraKanta-r7m]

Support your thoughts.

[@kuldeepkumarbhat9648]

Jammu is not happy with the BJP. Because the people here feel that this party has also appeased the KMs.

[@ipsitajohrirane3888]

Yana gracefully put her point across, even though it may not have been popular opinion or that she was being politely told this how things are done or not done, yet she held her ground, and made her voice heard. Well done

[@DrAmin-zl3nf]

Modi Ji had always delivered it's best. Very well expressed by Ms Yana Mir

[@Lmsa111]

There is such a thing as Responsible journalism this mr. Rashid should learn

[@rameshtamiri7759]

Yana Mir's intolerance is appalling.

[@sudhirnair]

Hi Smeeta, please reduce the duration of your podcast. It's a bit too long.

[@Komal_US]

Watch it at x1.5

[@SyedFurqan-n4q]

I agree with @Mir Yana ji and am happy that he spoke about the Kashmir in clear terms based on facts. The NC and PDP candidates and former elected MLA's are mostly corrupted who all the time benefited their famlies & workers, selected development , employment to keep their parties alive on ground. Here are also those people who sacrificed their loved ones for the Nation but their talk , debates is neither in the media nor in of the common people. Every scheme was taken advantage of by these two political parties and on the other hand people in the villages don’t even know the word governance. The center policy makers should to listen to the thoughts of the youth like as Yana je etc. Then go and find peace here. Otherwise on ground level here everyone thinks that the ; every poltical party is coming here for votes & seats.

[@uditsharma4798]

Well said Yana Mir. You are a journalist, but you are also an Indian and a human

[@dinshalimar01]

She is not a Kashmiri and her real name is yana mirchandani. What an irony she can fool even ANI

[@khalidhuzaif3517]

We will make sure she leaves this Indian path and supports azadi... Once bjp leaves from Kashmir wwe know how to deal with her

[@Komal_US]

Haha Jihaadis like you are so scared of BJP 😅 Good..ye darr acha hai ​@@khalidhuzaif3517

[@kamalkantgupta4507]

No, she is Kashmiri only but with multiple ethnicity. May be having Mirchandani surname, due to her one of the parent being so.

[@AbcXyz-hm8cu]

How khalid? Please enlighten us. If your pager hasn’t already blown.

[@mr_deep_singh]

Watching after J&K and Harayana elections 😂😂

[@BasudevAcharia]

Smitaji you are a great moderator, Ms Yana is emotional nationalist and Mr. Rashid is pragmatic nationalist, the results of the recently held elections shows the divide is still in place, if BJP had one plus point is voter turnout, it is going to be a long journey which can be summarized as: The valley woods are lovely, dark and deep but you have promises to keep and Modiji miles to go before you sleep

[@l.d.agarwal3893]

Farooq Abdullah a strange creature, he is Nationalist in New Delhi and Pakistan 🇵🇰 supporter in Srinagar !

[@Unapologeticallynationalist]

It's not strange that's how most of kashmiri muslims are

[@MNSNaidu]

28:40 Mr.Rasheed! You got the answer now.. BJP is the largest vote share party in J&K now❤❤

[@rishabhgoyal8145]

More power to archna tiwari

[@jAyAntswAmi]

70 Saal se na "Naya Kashmir" ban paya hai aur na hi "Naya Pakistan" Problem is Deeply rooted radicalism and corruption in society.

[@kashmiryouthweb5456]

Amazing Yana Ji ❤️

[@binagupta3308]

Great discussion

[@mahimaraina5803]

ANI - Why could you not get someone from Jammu to have more diversity. It looks like elections and 370 is a kashmir only issue.

[@anilkumar-qf8lf]

Yana rocks as usual! ❤🇮🇳

[@cv4network797]

At 25:26 why couldn't yana MIRCHANDANI disclose her true identity being Sindhi of Kashmir 😅😅😅

[@madhuhawaldar1237]

देशवासियों को आत्म गौरव और सम्मान से जीने की शिक्षा देने एवं एकदम सादगी से जीने वाले प्रधान मंत्री आदरणीय लाल बहादुर शास्त्री जी , जिन का कार्यकाल मात्र 10 माह का ही रहा पर था बहुत ही शानदार और गौरवशाली 🇮🇳 देश की महान विभूति लाल बहादुर शास्त्री जी को मेरा सादर प्रणाम ,सादर नमन🙏🏼विनम्र श्रद्धांजलि🌺

[@avyangnag3892]

I'm found and respect of Yana Mir works of journalism but i disagreed with what she has said because if people are fed of dynast politics in J&K than how NC won the most seats this general election?.

[@prashanth7097]

It's eventually a fight between religion vs development. Let's see what happens

[@ravindravadke850]

Thanks 2 Smeeta Prakash for the intelligent discussion. But, why the 'Gen. Next' participant appears 2 b ill fed? Not enough rations reaching Kashmir?

[@suhailalikhan4269]

Very well said Kashmiri’s love u u r pride of Kashmir yana❤

[@kuldeepkumarbhat9648]

Fractured mandate. Amit Shah is a real strategist. ❤❤❤👏👏👏👌👌👌

[@sumanpra]

Thanks

[@Yawar-q2v]

Proud of you Yana, for putting points on behalf of kashmiris. Keep rising and shining 🌟✨

[@chandrashekarkr]

As a non-Kashmiri Hindu, I still say without addressing Genocide there can never be peace for J&K…. You cant out it in the side to deal with later…, disagree with Yana here.

[@satyamvadami2770]

In Kashmir anti national and anti hidutva are popular not a new thing. They like what they are😅😅

[@angshukNag]

28:35 yana made a superb observation here ... I remember a line from the movie Pirates of the carribean, when calypso is freed and she transforms to millions of crabs and dissapears in the ocean .. one of pirates said "oh why she is no good at all" .. but then the captain noticed strong winds and yelled "aye the wind is on our side". So democracy is like that only, it's like the wind which helps you to steer in your direction. Modi governments biggest achievement in kashmir is to help it run a Democracy. This is not being understood by Rashid ji.

[@youthwave]

Wrong education creates a narrow and militant mindset. To stay fair requires guts of the charismatic kind.

[@sajeevank7203]

An interview of Bharkka Dutt with JNU activist Shehla Rashid is out . Just watch it.. you will get a different perspective about JK. A Modi critic to Modi Fan

[@irfanattarikashmiri]

Well done yana, proud of u dear

[@explorernik]

She's speaking all that I tweeted on her X page.😅

[@irshadpeerzada9009]

Yana mirchandani didi bas karo abb, etna b kyun karna. U r great in pretending to be a pure kashmiri but unfortunate is that you are not. Get a life didi 🎉

[@ThePolymerisst]

If she is not Kashmiri, what is she then??🤔

[@irshadpeerzada9009]

@@ThePolymerisst Bro, I leave this upto you, now you read and have some info about her.

[@affanzaman6683]

​​@@ThePolymerisstShe doesn't even know how to speak kashmiri. She is not even a muslim..

[@vyshakhm.s4947]

@@affanzaman6683yes he is Buddhist.why all kashmir men are radicals like you?.I think kashmiri wemen will turn kashmir a heave.

[@adarshkumar4383]

For you only Masood Ajhar,Hasrat Gillani are muslims....​@@affanzaman6683

[@VoiceOfKodava1971]

M's will always be M's like so called Yana. They can't digest the thing that Hindu Kashmiri Pandit's issues be exposed. And other religion people dominate J&K that's y this hate is towards other Lady ouTuber. J&K Muslims even say that they won't allow to build temples. Why? It's their fathers land😢 Of course There is no contribution from local j&k people in bringing back peace. It's only & only BJP's 200% effort.

[@Unapologeticallynationalist]

Very very true Ekdam sahi bola

[@Shabirkhan20233]

It is better to be silent then to speak about any issue. Yana is doing tremendous work very less people understand it.

[@krr3502]

Rashid is more poised personality he knows the real nature of kashmiri people and political system

[@prashantraut8920]

Ideally it should be divided into 3 states ...JAMMU ,KASHMIR & LADAKH

[@achieversacademy9691]

I love Yana Mir. She looks so beautiful

[@youthwave]

😂😅

[@shuibansari229]

Yana hamesha salamat raho ... Proud muslim proud kashmiri.. kashir koor ❤

[@amolpatil6120]

Education is most important❤❤❤yahi satya hai

[@Learn_IT4U]

Invite archana tiwari she will give her opinion

[@The_Denizen]

Smitha was partial. Very clearly she was favouring Rashid

[@mraquib6786]

Keep it up my love my sister my deda ...Yana dii ❤

[@knowledge_forever]

Bansuri ho ya koi pankaja munde ya poonam mahajan, they are not "CM or PM dawedar" as soon as they are born. Rajiv Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi, Stalin, Uday Nidhi, Uddhav, Tejaswi, Akhilesh, etc. became CM ke dawedar by just being born. They did not get a mere ticket and are small players even after serving more than a decade like BJP leaders but they became babas and babies, called as party high commands by turning adult.

[@avinash66]

Why is rahul gandhi is larger than life ?? What is his contribution for this country till now

[@IrfanAttari-m9f]

Proud ❤️❤️

[@9999914032]

What an Irony Rashid Sb setting with Yana lol

[@laygupta9116]

What a live podcast.... While almost everything she says is correct... Yana's approach is very limited in a certain sense... The lady who went to Kashmir and asked the questions has all her right to do so... And Yana has got the right to criticize if she doesn't agree.. But you can't tell she can't do it... She has a got a lot to learn from the other two pros.

[@aftabahmadmir9773]

She is not from Kashmir

[@vyshakhm.s4947]

Where she is from?

[@krislo4788]

She is a fake Kashmiri Muslim...she is a Sindhi...married to a Kashmiri Muslim

[@The_Denizen]

I think smita was partial towards Yana. Understood Yana is young, less experienced but inviting and not treating equally is wrong.

[@binagupta3308]

I am sure Kashmiris must be in a state of fatigue having gone through years of disturbances. I am sure they too want to breathe freely and focus on their life.

[@shailjabhardwaj5783]

Kattar vaadi hindu is against modi, very well said yaana.

[@rajeshcheemalakonda4862]

Who is the female journalist Yan’s was referring to?

[@The_Denizen]

Exactly

[@vrnair1951]

Kashmir was an international issue since 1947 even in UNO. Haryana is and was in indian state. Kashmir still not fully mixed with other states people. They always find fault with cente govt. Yana mir is not an exception.

[@tahir786-]

I was use to watch your podcast Smita prakash but unfortunately today i unsubscribe and for your information she's not a kashmiri she's predent

[@adarshkumar4383]

That doesn't matter what she is saying that is all it matters...Today Kashmiri youths are not loosing their eyes or lives from pallette guns,they are not forced to pelt stone on security forces,they are fed up of dynasts like Muftis and Abdullahs,Tourism industry and industrialists are seeing postive prospects,people are believing in democratic participation and peace rather than chaotic separatist ideas...That is a really positive news coming out of Kashmir and we as rest of Indians are pleased with that.

[@abhisheksharma4996]

Yana mir indirectly called jammu Hindus as extremists bcoz there is anger against BJP in jammu 1:31:35 .He gave this as a reason for anger against bjp comparing UP Bihar losing seats in loksabha bcoz of sabka sath sabka vikas.

[@TheKvjoshi]

Jai Shri Ram. Smita has turned into a Dholakbaj.

[@koran5407]

Book ?

[@user-explanation]

Yana says she couldn't vote. You mean you didn't vote. Is it true?

[@chakravyuh4709]

She is trying hard to show the good face of kashmiries...

[@Mnio160]

Yana is realistic …speaking facts

[@curiouscasey2309]

Yana mir is annoying as hell .....she just talks whenever she feels like talking .....even when smitha is asking Rashid the q.... etiquettes!?

[@pannagarao8894]

Whatever you say Yana, most of kashmiri Muslims doesn't want pandits in the valley they just want money. Even she doesn't have the clarity in her thought

[@rationaloperator4165]

Wow Smita interrupting for literally no reason

[@harikrishbhat]

Yana Mirchandani is a non kashmiri. Woh kya kashmir mein vote degi, eoh kashmiri hai hi nahi. Uska vote hi nahi kashmir mein.

[@AP1989c]

Who said that Kashmiris are ready to welcome Pandits😂 No One is talking about to settle Pandits to their homeland with security. Discussing how kind kashmiris is kind of pseudo seculars. 😢 If this continues then Hindus have to leave their land and either migrate or accumulate at one place. This is a threat to the Nation's integrity😢

[@rush666666]

I remember. Indian media behaving obnoxiously after Nepal earthquake inside Nepal was a big turnoff in Nepal public

[@HassanAli-xl8kr]

Why bjp has not Fielded yana mir as their cm candidate in Kashmir elections she spoke too good than any bjp spokesperson

[@satyam-evajayate438]

Are we expecting stone pelting and separatist activities back in Jammu and Kashmir?

[@roufdar959]

Yana have a courage to call a spade a spade. Lot of haters who are born to speak venom have problem. Let them. We Kashmiris love Yana.

[@mjanjan9528]

She prmoting herself. This podcast is for her promotion

[@Stardusk380]

Lol.😂

[@Lmsa111]

Mr Rashid pls know that Rajiv Gandhi & Congress were rewarded by. Mizoram people by voting congress into power many times but their corruption and lack of bringing progress in Mizoram has put them out of Power Now

[@pradipdarji4437]

Yana Mir kayel kar DIYA...when u said MODIJI NEY DIL KHOL KAY RAKH DIYA IN KASHMIR...PHIR BHI MUSLIM KAHA VOTE DATEY HEY❤❤