Erica Lustig with Sutton Foster - "Gimme Gimme" (Thoroughly Modern Millie)

[@alves1490]

"I'm totally here dude" So matter of fact...

[@xBeluuuuuux]

When Sutton Foster says "I'm totally here", her hands start shaking 😳 and honestly, same.

[@CatherineZhang-kq2cm]

Me too!

[@AlthoughDead]

Foster is such a professional. The way it looks to me, she wanted Lustig to sing "looooove" at 3:05 but when she saw that Erica didn't react, she rescued things in the blink of an eye. Chapeau!

[@EricaLustig]

@@AlthoughDead an interesting take! But we knew what we were doing here (after all it would be silly to cut in at the end of a sentence. :) )

[@stanleycalvin3039]

i love watching sutton watching her- she looks like a proud big sister

[@caseybouldin5000]

"I'm totally here, Dude" YUSSSSSSSS

[@ZomgItsTaelin]

How does she sound so amazing without warmup?! And wow, I think I would have died from shock and pressure instead of singing amazingly like you did!

[@Guinnessrat]

Watching Sutton move with the music...she knows it so well it's just a delight

[@annabellehowe_3568]

2:40 Sutton sings 2:47 she’s getting into it a lil 2:50 *inner Millie snaps* SHES INTO IT

[@chikimc11]

this is SOOO cool!!!! what an amazing succession of dreams! perform your own cabaret, perform it at 54 below, have Sutton Foster in the audience and having her sing with you?!... i shall do nothing else but bow at this vid!

[@LukeeCossey]

I love that this happened, great performance!

[@JohnSmith-iu3jg]

Very well done. Amazing coordination with the piano. Especially at the end with that flawless cutoff. Great voices. Just fantastic.

[@MissGarland1986]

This is totally cool. I'd love it if Sutton appeared at one of my performances like this. I love that she is so so incredibly down to earth and kind. 🥰 One if the reasons she is my Idol and she is such a massive part of my life.

[@laur1801]

i come back to listen to this all the time. i think i found it randomly years ago and i havent forgotten it. thank you

[@adamrayan5647]

This literally is everything

[@chrislewis8752]

I love this song and love this performance. So cool to sing it with Sutton

[@seriouslychris1]

BRAVA Erica! YOU SOUND AMAZING!!!!

[@NicoleMarcus]

Also teary eyed, James! Soooo proud of you! AMAZING performance!

[@jamesrobertsiv]

In tears! So good, lady!

[@gjm1953]

This video makes me smile. In fact, i have a feeling that I'll be smiling for the rest of the evening.

[@sidbid1590]

I think my insides would boil out of my body if I ever had to sing this song in front of Sutton.

[@MrmilesAllister]

oh my, love this so much!!!!!

[@CatherineZhang-kq2cm]

When she began to sing😳…Sutton Foster is just amazing😭……

[@brogis2]

Her voice gives me chills oh my lord

[@reghunt2487]

Love Erica so much.

[@CV-Moore]

Imagine having Sutton Foster looking at you like that.

[@CatherineZhang-kq2cm]

Awwww😭💝……

[@bryguy2000]

I love this!! YAAAS

[@walt1896]

Sutton Foster in "Simply Gorgeous" the Jeanine Tesori Story, Musical Direction by Michael Rafter.... Sutton Foster as Jeanine Tesori and Erica Lustig as Sutton Foster. And, of course Tesori/Sutton would be writing "Gimme Gimme" for Sutton/Lustig.

[@_alannahjade_]

Is the Jeanine Tesori Story a real thing???

[@emilywebster1056]

I love this supporting each other it’s fabulous

[@bonniemccune4828]

Wonderful !!!!

[@jaimemartinezp.a.9294]

AMAZING !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@adairmurray]

Wow!! You're both spectacular! What a fabulous surprise!

[@elliottkane1519]

When people cheered during Sutton’s part I was like “SHUT UP I WANNA HEAR HER SING”😤😤

[@jennagaier6294]

Was it just me or was I the only one just watching Sutton

[@EricaLustig]

Jenna Gaier i usually do that too. Thanks for popping by!

[@SabrinaJohns]

no because I would just immediately pass out 😭

[@fureyize]

I have been obsessed with this video which I only recently came across. So was Sutton there by chance or was this agreed?

[@NathanielPx]

Ugh I wish Sutton Foster would look at me the way she looked at you when you started!!!! I’d die!

[@jacobkeppler1984]

You are great actor

[@RBRoss-jn1sh]

was this planned

[@jacquelineclairereinerical4831]

Omg I would’ve #died