Erreur de Jugement (short film, LISAA 2020)

// Official 2021 Selection at Anim!Arte - International Student Animation Festival of Brazil //
PITCH FR
En apportant une lettre à Saint Pierre au Purgatoire, Emil, un petit postier céleste, envoie par mégarde une mauvaise personne au Paradis. Il part à sa recherche pour remettre les choses en ordre et éviter la colère de Saint Pierre.
PITCH ENG
While bringing a mail to Saint Peter in the Purgatory, Emil, a young celestial postman, accidentally sends the wrong person to heaven. He goes to find them to avoid Saint Peter’s wrath.
D'après une idée originale de Charlotte Técher
CREDITS
CHARLOTTE TECHER
(FR) Réalisatrice, directrice artistique, charadesigner, storyboardeuse
(EN) Director, Artistic director, Charadesign, Storyboard
/ charlotte-techer-0a208...
GUILLAUME LUCAS
(FR) Chargé de prod, chef animateur, chef compositing
(EN) Production Manager, Lead Animation, Lead Compositing
guimauve_poulet.artstation.com/
/ guimauve_poulet
ALISA IGITYAN
(FR) Storyboardeuse, riggeuse 2D, animatrice, monteuse
(EN) Storyboard, 2D rigg artist, animation, montage
/ @pinokius6009
animation demo : vimeo.com/385836496
rigg demo : vimeo.com/424942029
GABRIELLE KONY-FOULETIER
(FR) Props designer, artiste layout, décoratrice paradis
(EN) Props Designer, Layout Artist, Backgrounds (Heaven)
/ gabrielle-chance-kony-...
SOPHIE RENAUDAT
(FR) Découpage technique, colorscript, décoratrice bureau, chargée de communication, artbook
(EN) Technical separation, colorscript, backgrounds (office), artbook designer, communication manager
/ sophie-renaudat
et ADRIEN ROUX
(FR) Animateur chara, animateur FX 2D, opérateur compositing, motion designer
(EN) Fire fx animation, Character animation, Motion design
vimeo.com/391671322
Musique originale de LAURENT VANG
Original Soundtrack by LAURENT VANG
en.blanktone.com/home
"Erreur de Jugement" est un film d'étudiants en Bachelor animation 2D à LISAA Animation & Jeu vidéo Paris
"Erreur de Jugement" is a graduation movie from 3rd year students in Bachelor 2D Animation at LISAA Animation & Jeu vidéo Paris

[@Guim4uve]

Heyo! Lots of people coming from Tiktok, so here’s our graduation movie from college with the team by Charlotte, Alisa ( @pinokius on yt), Sophie, Chance, Adrien and Me !⭐️(I’m being more accurate since on Tiktok they only said one name, but it was Teamwork 🙂) [more details in description if u want] Hope u enjoy it ! 🧡

[@yayatheobroma929]

I loved this one. But really didn’t expect the mail girl to be allowed to stay in heaven and play cards with the Benevolent Tattooed Mountain ever after. I thought Peter would kick her out. Apparently, St Pete is a lot more easy-going than I thought. Never judge a book by the cover.😂

[@keddakedda7939]

Bet this wasn’t the first time at least she got a warning 😅

[@silkmoth7951]

It's actually an guy, an mailman

[@yayatheobroma929]

@@silkmoth7951 could be, the silhouette is rather androgynous. The eyes, lashes and pink hair suggested a girl to me. Pink hair especially is rare in guys, even in animation films.

[@silkmoth7951]

​@@yayatheobroma929oh yes, completely agree, I just say so because the description treat the character as he 😅

[@billgeniusforever]

What i learned about this short film i guess IS to never judge a book by its cover You might see someone who look evil but he IS good inside while others they pretend to be good by their innocent looks , but their actions in life IS dark

[@yayatheobroma929]

The big guy doesn’t look evil, he looks muscular and tattooed, that has nothing to do with moral standards. Look up BACA (Bikers Against Child Abuse) if in doubt. Note: I don’t have tattoos and I’m not a biker, I have no connection to those guys, it’s just the first example that came to my mind. There would be many more after I’ve had my second coffee. The little granny looked innocent enough, but then, grannies usually do, and you’re lucky indeed if you’ve never met a truly evil one.

[@eishitbalyan1904]

This was soo good,really loved it and the comedic angles in the end credits was epic.

[@Guim4uve]

Thank you so much! We are really glad you loved it and noticed the credits' details! 🌟

[@LaphyTaphyCreation]

Can't judge people by how they look, I like this story

[@cobalt5098]

I’m so glad I follow the author on Instagram! Otherwise I think i might not know about this short animation film. The concept is great! And it looks and sounds very appealing.

[@angelthomasagnas2960]

Remember never judge a book by its cover

[@chaitralifegade1087]

The little old lady has my heart!! Loved the characters sooo much! Lovely Film

[@Guim4uve]

Thank you soo much !!⭐

[@BenayaTrash]

Omg that's so great!!! The expressions!! The delivery! The motions!!! IM DED!!

[@chinawa5379]

Hey ! Je suis en 2eme année 2D et on nous a montré votre film en cours. C'est de loin mon préféré de tous ceux que j'ai vu !

[@Guim4uve]

Holà! Ça fait plaisir de savoir que le film t'a plu ! Merci beaucoup ! Bonne deuxième année du coup ! (c'est là que les choses sérieuses commencent, Amuse toi bien !)

[@joy_of_life_liberte511]

Je trouve ce film d'animation très sympas! j'apprécie beaucoup la pate graphique! c'est très beau et l'histoire est adorable bravo!

[@Guim4uve]

Merci beaucoup de la part de toute l'équipe !

[@saltyllama3137]

This was actually really good! I thought it was a neat watch :)

[@keddakedda7939]

Wow such a beautiful animation I love it “Never judge a book by its cover”

[@jotakamikazeentretenimento6608]

Nunca déixe um jovem coreano cuidados das suas coisas, especialmente se forem celestiais

[@maryreed984]

I’m glad to see u doing short films it looks great 👍🏽. At first I followed u on Instagram for the Detroit stuff but I like this too

[@SkateboardLlama45]

It send s a good message a out don't judge a book by its cover, but like that guy got sent to hell for having alot of money that's not cool

[@Guim4uve]

Well noticed, I like that spirit! ✨ Well maybe it wasn’t only one mistake here, and it will be fixed in episode 2 😌 (that won’t ever be animated since we are all working on different exciting projects at the moment 🙃)

[@rainswamptear8656]

This was the sweetest thing omg 😭🥺💛

[@yyg4632]

this is damn adorable and the colors make my eyes very happy

[@kiwitarts9852]

Oml thet pink haired boy is so cute i-

[@vazak11]

So well made!

[@Guim4uve]

Thanks from the whole team !

[@marionlusin6885]

Je suis parmi les gens qui viennent de tiktok aussi, et franchement votre court-métrage vaut le détour ! j'ai adoré :D

[@Guim4uve]

Merci beaucoup, de la part de toute l'équipe ! :D On ne s'attendait pas à un tel engouement, mais nous sommes très heureux qu'il vous plaise ! 😊

[@user-wj8hl8mb3c]

너무 좋아요.. 이게 갑자기 제 알고리즘에 떠서 우연히 보게 됬는데, 시사하는 바가 의미깊고, 저 또한 평소에 사람을 외모로만 판단하지 않았는가 성찰하게 되네요. 마지막 엔딩크레딧에서 나온 일러스트도 너무 귀여웠어요. 색감도 정말 사랑스러워요. 잘보고 갑니다 !!

[@Guim4uve]

Thank you so much from the whole team ! We are really glad you enjoyed it !

[@user-tf5ww7ll3t]

한국인 발견!

[@fidodenstore9232]

found this on a tik tok but the guy who took it didnt say anything about its was not hes and didnt even giv source, well one guy did

[@mistymoody6291]

Kool short film

[@edwolt]

Was the second guy correctly judged? Or will he be in hel forever because of the mailwoman

[@rairarku2964]

Je viens de tiktok aussi, et je voulais juste dire que j'adore!

[@Guim4uve]

Merci beaucoup !🌟

[@bethgutierrez-vazquez3055]

Ooo nice

[@alastor5291]

C'est incroyablement bien fait

[@Guim4uve]

Merci beaucoup !

[@alastor5291]

@@Guim4uve pas besoin de remercier

[@The_Subscribers]

Soo she want to send the big man to hell? Just because he is scarry and the grandma before that looks nice exualy is a thief

[@Guim4uve]

Yes, exactly, because she was scared and only judged by his look, which was a mistake in the end :) As people say, "don't judge a book by its cover" !

[@The_Subscribers]

Iike this animation thanks keep it good work

[@mashayashina6579]

I enjoy it🐥

[@Guim4uve]

Thank you so much ! ✨

[@juliss2078]

Me gusto 👍

[@soldofficialyt]

Found this through a repost on TikTok, gotta watch the original video if you like it though.

[@masonl.4275]

That was cute

[@ducks7015]

Old lady didnt missed a second tonstart stealing xD

[@sarajevofan]

bias

[@CurseOfFenric]

Wait so did the money bags guy deserve hell or did he just get forgotten

[@Guim4uve]

Well, I guess we should investigate his case further and look through his file to find out 😉

[@panatypical]

That's heaven. Paradise is a lot better than that.

[@FatalCandy06]

0:39 Saint Pierre has a portrait on the wall to the upper left like Xifu's picture with the Emperor in Mulan! lmao I assume it's Saint Pierre pointing at someone important and smiling excitedly, maybe God? Jesus? Another saint?

[@ne3738]

لول؟ الوشم حرام +الميت ما يروح للنار او للجنه الا يوم القيامه + حرام انك تجسد الرب او الرسول او ملائكه

[@Guim4uve]

You are free to have your own belief, and we may not share the same, which is fine as long as it's done with respect towards each other :)

[@cvcvcvcvcv]

Soy consciente, por los créditos, de que ha habido mucho esfuerzo en este corto, pero creo que hay que criticar lo criticable y no elogiarlo solo por ser visualmente atractivo: Por lo que he visto, esto quiere dar el mensaje de no juzgar por las apariencias. OK, es un gran mensaje, más de lo que parece. Pero la forma en la que se abordó este tema me parecio muy, muy normal. Animación y diseños decentes, con un buen mensaje, pero en un guión mediocre. Mi calificación: 2/5

[@cvcvcvcvcv]

Por favor, que ningún miembro del equipo creativo se sienta atracado. Si habéis hecho o se os presenta la oportunidad de realizar otro corto, también se os presenta la oportunidad de mejorar en todos los aspectos dentro de lo posible. Os deseo lo mejor.