Etrata vs Titania vs Tymna | Akiri vs Meren EDH / CMDR game play for Magic: The Gathering

[@ErikTheRedd1]

4:38 Meren: Aw man that ooze is gonna become a problem Terminate: You have other things to worry about, honey

[@joshuajinsu2559]

I'm so confused with some of these plays. The players hated on each other pretty equally despite Andrew or (more often then not) Adam needing the most attention in terms of attacking and removal. 🤔😕

[@shayneweyker]

Moral 1: It's called graveyard recursion for a reason. Moral 2: If you can't keep Meren's grave empty you have have to kill the player first.

[@ErikTheRedd1]

4:58 Peter, already missing land drops: I love these 5 cards from LDV that are also not lands apparently

[@cesarpiedra9165]

I know right? Missed like 3 land drops by then, and decides to keep those 5.

[@jamesknight2914]

I don't understand Scott's plays this game, recasting Akiri into a known Fleshbag Marauder or outright refusing to play Tymna when their were plenty of times he could of got in and draw extra cards to try and manage the board.

[@guiguippp]

Scott deck and decisions weren't the best at all

[@RJMM]

Scott simped for Adam in this game.

[@blazebullock3684]

Your Chanell is really my favorite it helps a lot of people like myself who doesn’t have a bunch of people around my town who play magic and play it for fun it sucks honestly I wish there was more people

[@Zackeus1992]

I'm so confused on why Scott killed Peter at the end there. Just... because? Like, he locked the already fairly one sided game down in Adam's favor.

[@MTGMuddstah]

Because they're all friends and it made the table laugh as he did it.

[@zylowolfzan3345]

Everytime Muddstah has someone threaten him during a combat phase, then attacks them anyway, I just picture him glaring across the table, "We don't negotiate with terrorists." *Swings even more creatures than before*

[@DAsrada]

Kind of confused by the Meren deck's lack of sacrifice outlets outside of the Birthing Pod.

[@VincentPascoe]

Thanks for Posting as someone thats just getting into commander its interesting to see how these decks are played etc.

[@thesadseal2electricboogalo597]

The attempt at mass land destruction with Natural Affinity has convinced me to add it to my Yedora deck

[@NoGloveNoLove32]

This game is why whenever my friends and I play against our buddy's Meren deck we make sure to focus her down and run a couple graveyard hate pieces

[@AffinityForCommander]

I do love a good Etrata deck! Something about her alternative win condition always excites me! 😁

[@JohnTalbane87]

I love mine but my local shop treats her like the plague. Which would make more sense if I could consistently win with her but I think I’ve pulled it off once.

[@shayneweyker]

Phased out creatures phase in at the start of the controller's next turn. Not sure why Peter's creature phased in early.

[@kyojitakenouchi9706]

I was going to say this. Phasing in happens before cards untapped during the untap step. I really don't thing it affected the game that much though.

[@VzDeath]

It also doesn't let him get an etb

[@mahjgaming1222]

Recently moved to Ottawa, and with the new Wizard Tower location, I can't wait for the pandemic to be over! Really want to play in store again. Might see Muddstah there some day :)

[@brendylove4285]

I look forward to mondays and thursdays every week! Thank you muddstah

[@hawkeye137137]

Inevitability of Meren strikes back once again. I don't know you, but she is my one and only Golgari queen.

[@rayquaza4948]

I keep wanting to build meren..I see this and say no thanks I'll just play poly k unchained great video and great video editing as always!

[@matiasrochaix2234]

The moment you see the Meren player you must crush it until its out of the game, otherwise the game will devolve into what this game is.

[@jdbrad07]

Did you guys have a bet going to keep bad opening hands? Lol good game though thanks

[@gdiridium5525]

i almost wonder if they're scared to go to 6 and have fewer cards than everyone else, so just end up keeping bad 7s

[@clrl936]

What I cant understand is Peter tutoring for nonland cards while he was stuck at 3 lands and didnt have land drops. He had the perfrct oportunity to set his draws with lim duls vault but decided to keep a baleful strix (that also didnt draw into a land)

[@Amaurn89]

Always enjoy your content, my dude; nice to see a wee throwback episode :) There you go, algorithm is fed

[@AidanWR]

It must be interesting seeing how your decks change over time by watching old games

[@TK-zd7ym]

This is why Meren is such a pain in the ass to play against

[@ludwigfleischhacker3673]

why did Scott never cast tymna? I reckon he doesn't like drawing cards.... playing akiri with no pay offs in another flesh bag marauder was kind of painful too see. Meren is just nasty when unopposed

[@BadCookies1234]

I am almost positive that is not how phasing works. I believe, if he phases it out, it does not phase back in until his turn before his untap step. I am almost positive of it.

[@MTGMuddstah]

You might be right! This was the first time I think the whole table had come across phasing. I know we got the part where it doesn't leave the battlefield right, but I guess we got it wrong when it comes back.

[@m4k4v3liii]

I'm here becuase I just built my first Meren deck. I noticed that the Meren player should have gained 6 life when attacking with the wurmcoil engine. They missed out.

[@JustforKikX]

I hate to say this as a Meren player, but you NEED to rush the Meren player/run grave hate. She's almost impossible to beat otherwise.

[@patykaarplegos6282]

Arixmethes gameplay? Do you have any? I hope to see him more but no one uses hi.

[@DarkEinherjar]

There have been a few in this channel, but they didn't do much, sadly.

[@gapeape3895]

how did scott never get a rest in peace out, thats like the first thing I tutor for when playing against meren decks

[@adameister5883]

There wasn't a RIP in the deck to tutor for.

[@plain6677]

RIP is not very common in commander, never seen it actually. More for higher power tables probably

[@DarkEinherjar]

Scott's deck runs a lot of graveyard recursion, so I don't think he'd want to lock himself out of it. RiP usually finds a place in Stax decks.

[@mage2175]

What sleeves and inner sleeves are the Titania player using?

[@nikos731]

There were some misplays, but otherwise, a nice and interactive game. Loved the sneaky attempt of Natural Affinity in response to the Deed activation.

[@owenwells7692]

I loved that play, would have won Andrew the game if someone hadn't had the counter.

[@simonisphording]

Should have cast Zuran Orb with Rishkar's Expertise for the memes

[@DETHofMAN]

I'm confused how Adam got the fleshbag back the turn Meren came into play and then the next when it has zero and then only 1 experience counter? Doesn't the cmc of the creature have to be less than?

[@scaredycat3146]

Meren will always return to hand whatever creature you want. You only need experience counters to bring something to the battlefield.

[@DETHofMAN]

@@scaredycat3146 Ah, OTHERWISE... reading the card explains it lol it's just a bit wordy..

[@philiprossin9489]

Golgothian Sylex be damned, we must protect Argoth at all costs!

[@DarkEinherjar]

Meren

[@stefantincescu7169]

peter deck annoyed me. Casually passing 5 turs without playing any land. What did he use the vault for?

[@mark3826]

Wow great game as always! One question: shouldn't the fase in of clever impersonator happen at the beginning of Peter's turn instead of Andrew's?

[@commanderpower99]

How did that guy cast LDV and not keep a pile with a land?

[@syntaxerror2409]

Everytime it is going to be Andrew's turn again, Titania and command beacon be like: ah sht here we go again

[@PeterClausman]

The url to the Akita decklist gives a 404 page missing. Is that just me?

[@zo-zu7158]

Peter, no. Where did your lands go?

[@plain6677]

I love this game, especially the sword plays. Commander as its finest

[@chicago928]

That was a fun game, whole lot of removal.

[@ChristopherGermain]

How did Merren get the fleshbag backat the start of the game with no experience counters?

[@MTGMuddstah]

Meren's return to hand happens regardless of how many experience counters she has. The ability to put it onto the battlefield cares.

[@ChristopherGermain]

@@MTGMuddstah ah, i don't know how I missed that, my play against Merren is limited because she's soft banned in my playgroup right now

[@m4k4v3liii]

@@MTGMuddstah I just built the deck and I didn't know this either. makes her even better in my books.

[@liban9704]

At the risk of sounding stupid I'll ask this question, isn't it an illegal move to add a card with higher cmc than the number of experience counters you have to your hand at the end of the turn? Talking about meren btw.

[@adameister5883]

Not a stupid question at all, but the card text itself explains how her ability works: "At the beginning of your end step, choose target creature card in your graveyard. If that card’s mana value is less than or equal to the number of experience counters you have, return it to the battlefield. Otherwise, put it into your hand." So you hit your end step, and target a creature in your graveyard. The game then checks your XP counters versus the CMC of the creature you targeted. Depending on the outcome of that check, the card returns to play or is returned to your hand.

[@aidanhavey2368]

Hey muddstah, idk if you realized, but its actually Tyman, you made a typo

[@DaweMannen]

How can he take Fleabag Murder from the grave at the start without any experience counter on Merren?

[@chrisbos7696]

You can take a creature out of the graveyard without exp counters on yor end step, you can put it into play with counters

[@DETHofMAN]

Not sure why you didn't bin the chasm and keep bringing it back with titania etb...

[@Kazz1187]

Ah yes the meren shenanigans

[@seliphsnom2596]

I have an answer to how many goblins could a goblin gob if a goblin could gob goblin's? My answer is Goblin!

[@DecrepitFlunky]

WHY KILL ZURAN ORB INSTEAD OF BIRTHING POD?????

[@gamefreak203]

i read the decks doesn"t excist anymore. Is it cause its an older video or just break down their deck?

[@adameister5883]

2 of the decks are mine (Meren and Akiri) and I don't play either of them anymore. I've sent Andrew links to those decks anyway, so I imagine he'll update the video description at some point.

[@gamefreak203]

@@adameister5883 thanks :)

[@hafusan]

I don't know Scott or Scotts decks. But everyone else did apparently as they kept targetting him and his poor mardu artifact deck.

[@neelebeuth3235]

Good Episode😀

[@MageSkeleton]

the chaos warp would give the player in control of the permanent the "shuffle and releave off top" effect, not the owner of the card.

[@Grunik1618]

Puppeteer Clique was severely misused this game. The creature it brings back gets exiled at the next end step. Edit: Nevermind. I misremembered Puppeteer Clique. It states "at the beginning of *your* next end step", so it was played correctly. My mistake. Call it excessive aggro towards a Meren player because that commander is silly.

[@pablopascual9320]

"At the beginning of your next end step, exile it"

[@MTGMuddstah]

I'm not sure what you're referring to. We played it appropriately. If the creature dies before the end step, you don't exile it. It's only exiled if it makes it to the end of turn, which is when the trigger goes onto the stack to exile it.

[@Grunik1618]

@@MTGMuddstah You're right. It was played correctly. I misremembered how Puppeteer Clique was worded. Edited my comment.

[@ollidd1141]

The second akiri cast was not smart.

[@papaburgundy20]

Adam is not only a lowly Meren player, but also brought back the Sun Titan again with Puppeteer Clique when sun Titan should have been exiled. I definitely see that changing the outcome.

[@MTGMuddstah]

When was it supposed to be exiled?

[@adameister5883]

At 17:28 I recast Pod, and Pod away the Titan. It goes to the graveyard, which lets me grab it again later.

[@papaburgundy20]

Adam I didn’t see that good play!!!

[@adameister5883]

@@papaburgundy20 All good, it's easy enough to miss.

[@NordicRest]

Board Wipes: The Game

[@michaelrichards5253]

Go Meren go!

[@brendylove4285]

I really hate Meren decks, they’re just no fun to play against

[@afspeellijstnaruto]

y and they are super easy to build on a tight budget as well...which also says something about the power level of that commander (imo)

[@shekki3192]

@@afspeellijstnaruto yep, I have casual semi-budget meren, top € card is birthing bod. One my friend won 5-man game with it and it was way back I optimized it, but big genesis wave wins game to every deck anyway.

[@mrdjuggernaut]

God I hate Meren decks lol absolutely kill on site.

[@JordanCirksena]

I’ve never seen a playgroup / multiple playgroups like the ones I see on this channel. Why do people insist on keeping terrible hands? When will the madness stop?

[@gustavoportugal3763]

fleshbag marauder loves akiri in his breakfast

[@Treebeardbratac39]

I really miss the VS system

[@afspeellijstnaruto]

3 minutes in and I am already disgusted by Meren. Cheesy fleshbag spamming XD hate those effects early game. (also it completely fucks up most of my voltron strategies >.>)

[@darkrexkigntstone8773]

Edicts effects due mess up voltron decks. I know from experience. Have a nice day.

[@thatoneborosplayer2577]

Hey

[@romanmccoy5074]

Wow, threat assessment sucked in this game

[@stevenbuck4090]

Scott's plays in the first few turns have me literally cringing. Plays Akiri a second time into Meren and Fleshbag, when he could have Pathed the turn before instead to avoid all of it... I don't even know if I want to continue the video.

[@stevenbuck4090]

And then Peter blows up Zuran Orb over Pod. I literally yelled "What!" out loud. The threat assessment this game is so stupid.

[@stevenbuck4090]

Why would you Beast the Study when it wasn't even going to be your turn, and your biggest threat is about to untap??

[@stevenbuck4090]

Peter playing Erata into nothing 3 turns in a row, and then Scott taking out Peter instead of swinging at Adam is just laughable. Yall did not deserve to win verse that Meren deck. Adam was 100% the best player on the day. Why was this game even uploaded??? I love your stuff usually Muddstah, but this was peak cringe to watch!