Evelyn Miller's Fate and Impact on Dutch Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2)

[@kadenstimpson3167]

Always loved how everything in these games is connected. The whole story is like one big spider web with the gang caught right in the middle

[@antonia7650]

That game is indeed a spider web

[@StuartLugsden]

Dark Space did 2 incredible videos on the GTA lore and world building. I would recommend watching them. kzbin.info/www/bejne/iminqqhvlshplas kzbin.info/www/bejne/fGnTnmCjaqaIoMU

[@IEatBooty4MyDepression]

You could take it further even and say that the gang is the spider, as their actions continue to build the web bigger and bigger, and they never stop, so the web becomes too big to manage.

[@skleem4871]

Its like we are just experiencing a node in their vast web. But idk anymore seems to me the veneer is fading

[@ΔημήτρηςΜαρίνης]

I think is like a real world! Is how the world works!

[@blakeforkins7375]

I’ve also found it kind of poetic how when Evelyn Miller dies, he’s surrounded by fire and his ashes ascend to the sky. But when Dutch dies, he descends back down to the earth, his body surrounded by snow and ice

[@casualviewer1006]

Nice analogy

[@wackmakk8492]

Yeah bro I was gonna type that out

[@wackmakk8492]

@@giorgikharebava4509 when I made that comment and it wasn't going to sound that good like this dude

[@justarandomguy117]

Because Evelyn saw himself a fraud when he was not, he destroyed himself with self doubt and loathing when he truly believed in something worthwhile to himself, whilst Dutch believed he was god because of his philosophy. He thought he himself was higher than everyone around him. Evelyn was also surrounded by people who didn't like him, and Dutch was practically worshipped by those around him. Plenty of parallels.

[@WaveGlydr]

Everytime you’ve posted a RDR2 video lately I’m like “well that’s probably the last one, there is only so much you can cover even in this game” and then you come out with this video, one of the best yet. I appreciate your great content, editing and music choices. Top notch.

[@gjte2947]

As an rdr2 tik tok creator I find it amazing how he hasn’t ran out of ideas yet

[@ChristIsLord55]

Do you know the music that plays at 7.45?

[@kinskifilms]

I always think the same thing. He's had some duds. But this one was great. I remember the Evelyn Miller missions and enjoyed that small story arc. But for some reason I didn't notice how often he is referenced throughout the game. This video is a total home run.

[@JoMcD21]

HAVE SOME GOD DAMN _F A I T H !_

[@thegrimsleeper07]

This is one of the best Red Dead-Channels that there is

[@X-SPONGED]

_"You're just afraid of opening your mind because you just might not like what you find"_ Might just be one of the most ironic quotes in the game, just by the fact that Dutch himself was the one who said it instead of anybody else

[@nightwish4312]

Right. He was always swallowed up in his own pride that he never admits his mistakes and wrongs.

[@edelweiss-]

if you read Millers Book "the american inferno" he writes many right stuff in there. its not wrong in my mind. he was advanced his time. maybe people are just too stupid to think further. and i think, dutch wasnt crazy, he was a really intelligent man. but its well known, that the most intelligent are often the most egoistic, narcissistic and most empathy-less

[@laurapaim9091]

@@edelweiss- i think yeah evelyn miller a good writter but he was bourgeois and had no experience with things that he wrote and criticized, thats why hes a fraud to me.

[@edelweiss-]

@@laurapaim9091 its philosophy. philosophic toughts cant be right or wrong. they are subjective and anyone can think about it. i think Miller was someone who was emotional. he got maybe so mad of all the people critizising him, that he just lost it. That would also explain his desperate situation and the fact that his last book, which was supposed to expose this alleged lie, was his death sentence. Since that's when he really lied. And he was depressed by it and his hunger strike was more like a suicide. Making money from it was certainly also an intention. Of course. But that's always the case when you are famous for your artistic products. No matter if you are an actor, painter, writer or something else.

[@edelweiss-]

@@laurapaim9091 you cant say that his death wasnt sad :(. i think he was a good soul and wanted to make the world a better place with his toughts. he even started to live in nature for this. and that his last wish was completed because you can see eagles flying away if you go back to his grave, says ANYTHING.

[@JayJohnBryce]

You forgot to mention the most important thing: Evelyn Miller is based on writer and philosopher Henry David Thoreau. 1. Both of them left their jobs at the university to live in the nature. 2. Both of them lived in a one-room cabin near a pond where they were writing their most important book. 3. Both of them were critics of the society. 4. Both Thoreau and Miller were friends of the indians. Thoreau wanted to write an extensive work about the indians, but unfortunately he passed away. 5. Both of them passed in their 40s 6. Thoreau, like Miller, wasn't interested in women and he even rejected a few during his life. I had also compared writings of Miller in-game with paragraphs of Thoreau from the books I own and I found a great similarity analyzing them.

[@lorenzmaut3708]

Sorry to be this dumb but isn't there a location in fallout 4 that contains a piece of that story, that they turned the cabin in to an attraction where a robot tell the story of this writer and inside the basement live some raiders that to access you need to go trough the sewers.

[@KrustyBunion]

Yes but did Thoreau have a small penis?

[@horatio8858]

@@KrustyBunion they did say he rejected women

[@NovaBlueNova]

​@@KrustyBunion I thought that whole monologue was a reference to Thoreau rejecting women. She was just spreading rumors about him because he rejected her, hence "Anyone who prefers trees to tits...got what's coming to him".

[@joaquinperez4830]

@@lorenzmaut3708 yes, Walden pond. That's the same guy. If you're interested, the whole nature thing and self reliance is called - Transcendentalism

[@pleaseenteraname5267]

Holy crap this guy wrote one of Dutch's most iconic lines for him.

[@charliemaline223]

It adds a whole new meaning to him completely

[@juggernaut2704]

Tahiti!

[@bhebous]

Ahem.

[@kckilla7211]

Do you really have a plan this time

[@kckilla7211]

@@bhebous wait a damn minute

[@StuartLugsden]

Everyone in the Van Der Linde gang saw Evelyn Miller as a moron. Even Miller himself saw himself as a moron and his books are part of the reason why Dutch went crazy. I bet you if Lenny had survived and abandoned the gang he would have gone on to write a book about how their way of life is a better example than Millers. Also I just realised that not only did Dutch and Miller die for the same cause, they both died in the same area and it was in an area they both loved the most, the nature.

[@daxmaverick2570]

The nature that they couldn't fight.

[@hassansamaden9890]

@@daxmaverick2570 i was literally about to say this

[@danrodriguez7895]

They both died in tall trees 😱😱

[@internetkurator9256]

I did not play RDR1, where did Dutch die?

[@StuartLugsden]

@@internetkurator9256 Towards the end he commits suicide by falling backwards off of Cochinay’s cliff to prevent John killing him or capturing him and letting the government hang him. The area isn't accessible in RD2R because Rockstar didn't update the area when transforming the map and characters into 1907.

[@grilledleeks6514]

John's genuine concern over Miller's well being always stood out to me.

[@Thomas_Angelo]

Lmao Micah telling lies is so funny. How he struggles to say: you are amazing. So funny.

[@Psycho_Yoshi]

I'm just like, look at this suck up lol. He gets his in the end

[@juleswoodbury58]

Micah is way more literate and well spoken than he lets on. On more than one occasion you can hear him quoting the Bible, also his flow of speech and enunciation is on par if not better than Dutches.

[@Thomas_Angelo]

@@juleswoodbury58 but he isn't a good liar.

[@nessarolla]

I think that was his most honest moment. Micah was snake yes but deep down I think he really did think Dutch was amazing. For him to speak his true emotions for once is probably why he hesitated. It's the only time I believed his words.

[@Palindrome3945]

Pretty sure he is not lying at all, that's why he struggles so hard. Maybe we will found out clues indicating that he is in love with Dutch one day, and that he wanted to keep him to himself.

[@EPlainsDrifter]

At the end, one eagle flies into the cabin and dies. I had that happen in my playthrough, too, but at the time I thought it was just an accident. Now I'm not so sure.

[@gurpinderwarar4625]

Same happened with me

[@livewire2759]

I didn't even realize they were eagles, I thought they were vultures. LOL

[@toaolisi761]

LMFAO!! I'm gonna play this entire game again just to find out if that happens on my playthrough.

[@joehanz9217]

I shoot them for Charles item 🗿

[@june61999]

@@toaolisi761 ? Did it

[@RickBelt]

_“How vain it is to sit down to write when you have not stood up to live.”_ ― Henry David Thoreau

[@campos3452]

Not in vain if you helped write The Bible the greatest book on earth.

[@rinzler1801]

@@campos3452 Greatest book ever lol *Deuteronomy 21:18-21* "If a man and a woman have a stubborn and rebellious son, who will not obey the voice of his father, nor the voice of his mother, and though they discipline him, will not listen to them, then his father and mother shall take hold of him and bring him out to the elders of his city at the gate of the place where he lives and they shall say to the elders of his city "Our son is stubborn and rebellious, he will not listen to our voice". Then all the men of the city shall stone him to death. So you shall purge the evil from your midst and all of Israel shall hear, and fear." *Numbers **31:18* "So now, kill all the boys, as well as every woman who has had relations with a man, but spare for yourselves every girl who has not had relations with a man." *Exodus 21:7-8* "When a man sells his daughter as a slave, she will not be freed at the end of six years as the men are. If she does not please the man who bought her, he may allow her to be bought back again." *Leviticus 20:13* "If a man lies with a male as with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination. They shall surely be put to death, their blood is upon them." *Leviticus 21:18* "For the generations to come, none of your descendants who have a physical defect may approach to offer their worship to God. No man who has any defect, no man who is blind, lame, disfigured, or deformed or who has broken foot or hand may be permitted to enter the Temple." *1 Samuel 15:3* "Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy all that belongs to them, do not spare them. Put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys" *Peter 2:18* "Slaves, in reverent fear of God submit yourselves to your masters, not only to those who are good and considerate, but also to those who are harsh" *Hosea **13:16* "The people of Samaria must bear their guilt because they have rebelled against their God. They will fall by the sword; their little ones dashed against the ground, their pregnant women ripped open" *Psalm 137:9* "Happy is the one who seizes your Babylonian infants and dashes them against the rocks"

[@rinzler1801]

@@campos3452 Only someone blinded by faith can read all that barbaric Bronze Age drivel and still defend it. If Christians actually read The Good Book beyond the Ten Commandments, The Beautitudes, Jesus' parables and ministry, and John 3:16, they'd finally realize just how much of a monstrosity it is. But that day will never come, just like The Second Coming. Keep the faith buddy :)

[@campos3452]

@@rinzler1801 You are not wise at all. It takes wisdom to understand The Bible. Go back to school and learn how to read and study.

[@AlexKS1992]

@@campos3452 I’d rather use the Bible to keep me warm by tossing it into a fire.

[@TheShifter1001]

The fact that he introduces you to eagle flies and his story ends with him wanting to fly with the eagles is truly poetic. Also, this guy is borderline responsible for the events of the entire red dead timeline and are you bully his death could be considered and in-canon ending to the actual story of Ductches gang

[@nickjones3075]

Wtf? *ARGUABLY*, not "are you bully". Wow.

[@krops2331]

@@nickjones3075 I hole-hardedly agree, but allow me to play doubles advocate here for a moment. For all intensive purposes I think you are wrong. In an age where false morals are a diamond dozen, true virtues are a blessing in the skies. We often put our false morality on a petal stool like a bunch of pre-Madonnas, but you all seem to be taking something very valuable for granite. So I ask of you to mustard up all the strength you can because it is a doggy dog world out there. Although there is some merit to what you are saying it seems like you have a huge ship on your shoulder. In your argument you seem to throw everything in but the kids Nsync, and even though you are having a feel day with this I am here to bring you back into reality. I have a sick sense when it comes to these types of things. It is almost spooky, because I cannot turn a blonde eye to these glaring flaws in your rhetoric. I have zero taller ants when it comes to people spouting out hate in the name of moral righteousness. You just need to remember what comes around is all around, and when supply and command fails you will be the first to go. Make my words, when you get down to brass stacks it doesn't take rocket appliances to get two birds stoned at once. It's clear who makes the pants in this relationship, and sometimes you just have to swallow your prize and accept the facts. You might have to come to this conclusion through denial and error but I swear on my mother's mating name that when you put the petal to the medal you will pass with flying carpets like it’s a peach of cake.

[@WatchHawk]

@@krops2331 good job, troll.

[@OfficialBeef]

@@krops2331 imagine using copypastas and thinking that you are funny.

[@krops2331]

@@OfficialBeef don't have to imagine.

[@2buxaslice]

That last book, I could see Dan Houser writing that about how this game made him feel after the stress of making it. It mentions America but how he's European. Talks about his doubts but how this land could bring absolution. Talks about how he can escape the hell of thought and come here, the way people play video games to escape their real life stresses. There is a paragraph that says: This world. Pure. Not clouded by idiocy. Not imagining himself as god as so many of us are forced to do, but happy as a child of god. This is a game where you play as normal men. Men who can die of disease or animal attacks or falls. Not a game in which you level up to the point of being unstoppable. In this game no matter what you do, you will die. You are not a god, but a child of god. It goes on to say: But still my thoughts come upon me like wolves. My needs swamp me. My desires overwhelm me. This game was Dan's baby. He wanted so much more in the game but it had to be cut. He stressed himself to the point of leaving Rockstar while making this game. And then there is this part toward the end: That foolish part of man that tells him he is immortal. That tells him, that whispers like the serpent, that seduces like the apple, that charms like Eve, that tells him he is God. I am not God in this truth, I will find my absolution. I shall be set free. and later it says: I pray now only for the talent to make this make some kind of sense. Oh the lot of the fool who aspires to more. This last part sounds like Dan talking about Take Two making him feel like he's god and telling him everything he wants to hear but yet that is not how he feels. He shall be set free from Take Two. He feels like the fool who aspired for more. Killing himself to make this game as good as it could be, only to have to rush the end, deal with multiple delays and have to cut tons of content. I'm high AF so I could be reading way too much into this, but we know how Dan and the Rockstar team like to hide things in their games, and seeing what happened to Dan after this, I don't know, as I read it, it just made me think of him. Can't wait to see what his new game is.

[@smp1256]

Nah your definitely looking too deep into it. I think that it wasn't red dead 2 that made Dan leave but GTA6 as the same thing happened as rdr2 ( constant changes, restarting development multiple times, corporate interference) and Dan Houser just said nope not again. I too am excited too see what Dan Housers new game company puts out as their first game and beyond without interference from take 2. Could be something really special

[@2buxaslice]

@@smp1256 Right after finishing Red Dead 2 he left to take a break for many months, after which he decided not to come back, so he didn't even work on GTA 6. Red Dead 2 was reported everywhere to have been a really difficult development that took a lot out of him. He left because of Red Dead 2. I think GTA 6 might not be too great with both Dan and Leslie Benzies not involved with the development. I am excited for Dan's next game though.

[@proyashnarayanchoudhury2567]

Thank u bro, this is exactly what j was looking for. Your comment is awesome, how u analysed Evelyn with Dan.

[@alexm7627]

Thats true though, it is when we realise we are not gods that we can be set free, everyone worships something, and alot of people worship themselves they're their own god, but only the one true God and His Son are to be worshipped, "and you will know the truth, and the truth shall set you free" -Jesus

[@2buxaslice]

@@alexm7627 Bibles were written by men who want to control other men. None of those words are actually from Jesus. Look up King James and how he edited the bible to fit his beliefs. Just because you were born in a Christian country doesn't mean that you are worshipping the correct god. How is it that grown adults can still believe in magic?

[@AlexGTAgamer]

When I returned to the cabin in-game and saw all of those eagles, I thought it was a spawning bug. I didn't piece together the connection to Evelyn's "...soar with the eagles" request.

[@MrZsasz25]

Please do one on the mystery of the 6 skeletons in prison garb in Roanoke, who are chained together with foot-chains. How did they end up there? Who were they? How did they die?

[@nickjones3075]

^^^^^^^ this

[@talenrothwell3407]

Well we know two of those: How did they end up there? They shambled along to where they died. Who were they? Prisoners. We just don't know how exactly they died, possibly starvation. The real question is: Where exactly did they come from? And: Are they based on a real life event or group of people?

[@kratousek1]

I think he already has video on it

[@dirtydirtmcgogurt]

@ 4:47 - That woman's rant was so over-the-top that John had to break the 4th wall.

[@Slurpified]

This was the last side mission but also one of the most important/legendary ones.

[@sambitbasu6261]

We don't deserve this game. The we play it doesn't do the creators justice. You do deserve it and thankfully show us how the game should be viewed.

[@AngraMainiiu]

I find it interesting that Dutch never met Miller. Also it was a big missed opportunity that Arthur never mentioned meeting him to Dutch.

[@StuartLugsden]

He did and this was clearly shown. When you meet him at the party Dutch comes up after and starts fanboying and later he comes up to Arthur in his room afterwards and mentions his talk in their discussion.

[@rahulverma8774]

@@StuartLugsden Did dutch read books of mary beth after the events of RDR2 chapter 6 🤔 It was clear in chapter 2 that dutch was fond of her Thats why she stayed in camp without contributing and nobody complained

[@54DrHouse]

@@rahulverma8774 but she was contributing. Train heist was possible because Mary beth found out about the train, and there is also a side job in one of the chapters, where we rob a coach and our girl acts like a bait to stop it

[@rahulverma8774]

@@54DrHouse Really ?? Which mission I hv never robbed any stagecoach where mary is used as bait Try to tell me the name of that mission so that i can try it in my second playthrough

[@54DrHouse]

@@rahulverma8774 kzbin.info/www/bejne/o3LWhpqndrh2bZY

[@ZonnexNecton]

This game has loads of interesting NPC missions. They're almost like main missions themselves. Folks at Rockstar team and those involved really worked super hard in this game. I thank them all.

[@Steviebob-]

Holy crap I never even knew you could encounter him, I'll be sure to go back and play through it myself next time I load up RDR2!

[@leventeszaffenauer4142]

how did you played this game? :D

[@Steviebob-]

@@leventeszaffenauer4142 What do you mean?

[@leventeszaffenauer4142]

@@Steviebob- i mean how on earth did you not encountered him? I wasnt tryna be offensive, but if you play the game “right” theres no way you dont meet him :D

[@Steviebob-]

@@leventeszaffenauer4142 Oh, I meant that I never encountered him in the Epilogue, I just haven't explored enough to find him.

[@Steviebob-]

Update: I just found him and got done with his third mission, I'm planning on finishing it tomorrow.

[@ΜάρωΑλακαρτ]

I sincerely hope you reach at least a million subscribers soon, beacause the work and passion you put in your videos is outstanding.

[@nusretabi7222]

The story of Evelyn Miller is pretty tragic. So is the end of it.

[@chilomine839]

The problem with philosophers is they spend time thinking too much, eventually they all end up in the same place. That’s why life places many distractions in our way so we don’t end up thinking ourselves to death.

[@grilledleeks6514]

The real tragedy to miller in my eyes is that, he wasn't even really a fraud. He was a talented writer, with big ideas and passions, who you meet while hes trying to help the natives with their plight. Who when pushed to the edge, chose to abandon fame, wealth, and stability to prove himself to himself living like the people he wrote about. He was a pretty good dude. The self loathing people fueled in his critiques drove him to his early death eventually.

[@edelweiss-]

MY THEORY!! Again. I think Miller has let himself buckle under the criticism. He gave up, really thought it was absolute nonsense. Because almost everyone said it. I rather think he was ahead of his time. Are we going to deny that big cities have dehumanised us? He also wrote very beautifully and made great philosophical approaches. But I think he had self-pity problems, the way he kept referring to himself. And in the end he wrote his last book, unfulfilled, which shines with self-pity and self-criticism. I rather think he didn't lie about his first books, because how can you lie about philosophy?! But rather in his last one, where he doesn't present himself as crazy by saying that these books were only fraud and not serious and that he did it all for fame. Because people think he is crazy because he has such philosophical thoughts. Perhaps fame was also a small intention. But certainly not the only one! Because he already came up with thoughts that many people were missing at the time.

[@Jordilaia1]

I have an idea for a video: The importance of Hosea in Dutch's mind, how he became more unestable after hosea's death

[@theycallmeanton]

I cant believe I totally missed out on this side mission. This is the most depressive yet poetic incounter in the game for me and I didnt even find it in my own playthroughs beside the story mission and some references to his name. What a beuty of a game this is.

[@TheBattleMaster100]

This is why I love this channel. You dig deep into the game and connect many things we don't know.

[@ArzeLvoLsujin]

14:11 those mirrored sunlight peeking from the trees at windows cabin are one of missed detailed about this wonderful game

[@geraltrivia6148]

There should have been a final chapter to the mission where Jon takes the book to Miller's publisher. Seems a shame that only Jon gets to read the final words of a famous author who changed his whole outlook before he died.

[@fazbearentertainment2592]

John*

[@joosh6106]

@@fazbearentertainment2592 you clearly kno0w what he said you dont need to correct him

[@stephenharper9961]

I'll never ever stop saying this, rockstar's best game ever, the landscape, the story, the characters, the realism, in my darkest hour, it gives me my imagination back and a place to escape too

[@bodesea8586]

Rockstar’s games are truly a work of art and the most incredible video games , and red dead redemption 2 is the most well written game in gaming history

[@Schrapnellmine]

Ah, the lovely epic music playing as one of the Eagles slams into the cabin and falls to death at 16:42. My sides shall fly with the eagles. Just beautiful.

[@prska]

lmao

[@ft.christian4649]

I’m glad I wasn’t the only one that noticed and laughed 😂

[@truthhurts3524]

A 17+min video from StrangeMan?!? Oh hell yes!

[@mtj-vu4co]

I found the eagles at the burnt cabin in an extended playthrough. The eagles will be there on subsequent returns to the cabin as well. Many times there would also be an owl on the roof

[@aaronmessick9143]

Ive been playing this since it came out, and never knew I could find him again in the epilogue

[@j-bonemcswiggans4597]

One of your best vids so far man, well done.

[@grep67]

I agree with you.. just brilliant!

[@lauras.64]

Amazing! This just made me cry! Im so happy I found this account. I‘m playing RDR2 the second time right now and there is so much I‘ve missed the first time. I hope to discover all this cool stuff now this time. Thank you so much for the effort you put in your videos. They are great! Best game ever.

[@Nomad958]

Cringe

[@lauras.64]

eeeasy there

[@tahitiplanderlinde8640]

@@Nomad958 Yeah easy there boah, go watch some SSSniperwolf or some shit.

[@edelweiss-]

MY THEORY!! Again. I think Miller has let himself buckle under the criticism. He gave up, really thought it was absolute nonsense. Because almost everyone said it. I rather think he was ahead of his time. Are we going to deny that big cities have dehumanised us? He also wrote very beautifully and made great philosophical approaches. But I think he had self-pity problems, the way he kept referring to himself. And in the end he wrote his last book, unfulfilled, which shines with self-pity and self-criticism. I rather think he didn't lie about his first books, because how can you lie about philosophy?! But rather in his last one, where he doesn't present himself as crazy by saying that these books were only fraud and not serious and that he did it all for fame. Because people think he is crazy because he has such philosophical thoughts. Perhaps fame was also a small intention. But certainly not the only one! Because he already came up with thoughts that many people were missing at the time. and i also cried in this side mission because the tragic end 😭. Miller still looked like a good soul who doesnt found what he wanted to find on earth. like iam also a thinker i also write books over my philosophal thoughts and never got a gf or friends with 20. its just sad somehow, because i find many parallels to Millers Story. he also never had a wife i think. its all because they think he wrote bullshit. iam also scared to publish my books, also if its just toughts. toughts with what you want to bring positive new toughts in the society. nothing bad. and something happy and funny at the end so at leats this comment has a happy ending xD. who also thinks, Miller looks kinda like Bob Cratchit from "a christmas carol" ? 😂

[@firelight1862]

Keep up the good work on these videos bro!

[@edwardjohns4047]

This game is so epic I can see it outlasting Skyrim the story is incredible

[@mariemorgan7759]

What I noticed is how they faithfully copy the style of the books from the 1890s-1900s. The chapters and paragraphs spacing is the same. I have a replica book from the Victorian age,and it's styled the same way as the books in RDR2. Really a amazing little detail!

[@StuartLugsden]

Evelyn Miller was indirectly alluded to by Agent Ross in RDR1.

[@abdullahaltuwaijri8550]

When?

[@StuartLugsden]

@@abdullahaltuwaijri8550 Here kzbin.info/www/bejne/jIXEdpimmtWUfM0 . It shows Rockstar had some of Dutch's backstory thought out back then.

[@Apocalyptic_Revelation]

I never thought of returning to the cabin but I will now after watching this🦅🦅🦅🦅. Thanks Strange man for the incredible content.

[@allibelle]

this is the first video by you, that gave me the chills like never before

[@ordndo]

Bro its been too long since i watched your videos. Why is it still you got more rdr2 content to make. Damn. Youre a blessing to this game.

[@thahotkidd]

Well this is a weird coincidence.I'm currently replaying the story for the first time since it came out. I just did the mission where you meet him on the street and agree to help eagle flies a few hours ago. Yesterday I was wondering around camp and read the two books you find in Dutchs room. I had no idea about the epilouge encounter but now I think might load up my old save file to see it.

[@oldprophet]

:)

[@nightwing3618]

You need to make a playlist of your music, this one at the end truly sent me to tears

[@Setanta9089]

I love the tiny details in the game: the body language and even the facial expression on Arthur's face at 1:52!! Man, that makes the cast feel so alive!

[@rakohardeen2606]

God another legendary and epic video. Good Work!

[@wyattderp581]

Your editing is truly incredible! You've got a gift for it mate!

[@BruceWayne-gm5dz]

Finally! You’re back 😀

[@sbyahnogaming6519]

Another spectacular video

[@Juli.h155]

Unbelievable that he still finds so beautiful details. I miss the nights playing this amazing game.

[@philosopherpresident4896]

I appreciate the tribute.

[@indiana_holmes]

Miller was a fraud until he actually gave up his position and chose to live among nature (where we meet him in the epilogue). The problem wasn't his ideals though, it was his self doubt. He hated himself and his assumed inability to adapt. He wanted to be what he wrote about, but couldn't stand himself, so ultimately succumbed to his own inadequacies. Instead of embracing the natural life he desired, he gave into the criticisms he received and let himself become a victim of cruel publicity and his own self doubt. Dutch just fell into the trap of becoming disillusioned by someone that didn't live by what he preached.

[@kierancaldwell3442]

I agree, in a way I see Miller's story as a kind of beautiful 'redemption' in itself

[@sollucthecowboy9989]

Ducht also learned how to feed alligators with humans from books

[@josephleotorejas1614]

What a story, so proud of the creator

[@ellaaan_96]

Woah! that end scene with the eagles! So breathtaking! 🦅 😍 Love the editing!

[@murphbox]

Haven't even watched it yet but wanted to say you're my FAVORITE red dead channel, thank you so much for your videos ❤️

[@pedroroque829]

This is more than a game, Rockstar made really something else. It was even better than everyone was expecting.

[@enricot.3483]

Totally agree. Sadly, RdR2 ruined all the other game played after this.

[@imagineimaging7387]

@@enricot.3483 how lifeless u gotta be to play the same game over and over

[@enricot.3483]

@@imagineimaging7387 Such arrogance. How could you judge my life by a comment on KZbin?

[@RobinK]

Great video once again! The editing is incredible.

[@itisfreak]

Didn't need the flag at the end though...

[@KaiserWellington]

@@itisfreakBruh, that was the Ukrainian flag.

[@itisfreak]

@@KaiserWellington no shit sheep

[@anthonyjones9256]

Its not just impressive that you put this together w such clear connections. Also, that you are still able to make a lengthy video that has such depth to the content. What a great video👌🏽

[@blkz123]

your editing is crazy, and the video was super well made.

[@zlatko780]

THIS GAME!!! The level of detail in story is just amazing, people behind RDR2 are just something else. i've never seen so much connectivity between main story actors and some guy who just write books, this is just sick, and detail at the end when eagles comes to cabin.... one of yours best video

[@quietbushi]

Your edits are always so awesome.

[@LostArizona]

Beside how good RDR2 is. Why does nobody mention how good this channel is? This is BY FAR the best RDR2 related channel to ever exist. The work, the beauty and cinematography seeks its equal. Good Work, Strange Man!

[@Communisticheskaya_partya]

Friend❤ Thank you for allowing GAMER TECH to use your content, I say hello to him, I myself speak Russian and write through a translator, if not for you I would never have known about that riddle about the man in the hat, John, Arthur and the seller in Armadillo, Thanks again!

[@Ritik_S7]

A 10/10 video after a long time. And my god Dutch really is the most complex character of Red Dead series.

[@eajbkny1976]

Every time I think I’ve seen the last of your videos here comes another one. Best video content about red dead redemption two! 🤠🙏🏽

[@keremm000]

Change of music hits perfectly😌

[@knicknackpattywack6276]

This was great to watch, the music really helped too

[@BennyGoId]

Evelyn Miller was most likely inspired by (and probably got the idea of "soaring in the air with the eagles") by hanging out with EAGLE FLIES and Rains Fall that one time when you meet him and other two outside of that building in Saint Denis.

[@burnthetrolls5971]

I wonder if there was some kind of cut dialogue between Dutch and Evelyn Miller at the Gilded Cage mission it would be interesting to see how Dutch interacts with Mr. Miller given how high of a pedestal he puts him on and also to see what Mr. Miller thinks of Dutch

[@ramoskenneth35]

This is strange I’ve finished this game three times and you my sir are still finding more and more about this game . Kodus to you and to the devs!

[@davidphillips3631]

I think Evelyn embodies the difference in opinion of freedom. weather it’s Dutch’s idea of freedom of doing what you like without control of fellow man, agent miltons idea of freedom to lock up/kill the people that stand in the way of what other people do. but Evelyn didn’t do what society, the people around him, or even what his own body said, he died truly free like an eagle

[@FrenchFamas1997]

lenny's vision was so powerful

[@skullboy1314]

I just found this channel after looking up red dead redemption and I've only been watching a couple of days but I already love his channel.

[@Norolas]

Dude you’re amazing at this

[@L3tsFUN]

Невероятная работа! И спасибо за поддержку в эти тяжёлые для нас времена!

[@Heychuh]

Wow so that’s just Thoreau then. Looks just like him and it’s just like his book Walden. I never even knew this mission existed! Their writings sound super similar too! Here’s my favorite passage of his. “I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately, to front only the essential facts of life, and see if I could not learn what it had to teach, and not, when I came to die, discover that I had not lived. I did not wish to live what was not life, living is so dear; nor did I wish to practise resignation, unless it was quite necessary. I wanted to live deep and suck out all the marrow of life, to live so sturdily and Spartan-like as to put to rout all that was not life, to cut a broad swath and shave close, to drive life into a corner, and reduce it to its lowest terms...” They’re right too. He was just a fraud who borrowed money from people to build a cabin and live deliberately and all that. Great reference rockstar.

[@ninobrown909]

Wooooooow. Wow. Like omg wow. What an absolutely in depth character Miller is. I had no idea. I blew through the play through and didn't really give a second thought about this man more so than "yikes, what a foolishly dedicated man" he was. Only until now have i realized what forefully thought knowledge he was spewing in his ramblings. Damn this game reaches into the depths humanity beyond what any average gamer would think. Holy fuck Strange Man, thank you for this eye opening content beyond your normal entertainment. Truly awesome.

[@ayannawilson1223]

When StrangeMan posts videos, I’m Literally grabbing a snack, sitting back in bed and immediately think “Oh, this is gonna be good!”

[@kaankizilkaya2741]

Your Videos are awesome.Greetings from Germany

[@azadisoleil6319]

This hits real weird. Not too long ago I was writing out my “if I don’t make it” papers before going into a surgery and I wrote that I wanted to be burned and released into the winds so I could finally feel free. I know how he felt in a way.

[@ArthurM1863]

Glad to see you still here. How are you doing?

[@countkabooom82]

I love your work about RDR2. I just played it last month, until now most of the other stories of other npc I still don't understand. But through your work I can understand it. I'm playing it the second time(rdr2) and with your videos are guiding me through. Thanks for the good work Sir! 👏

[@callate5898]

i had no idea about this side missing wow, almost 4 years and this game still surprises me

[@OVERKILL_PINBALL]

WOW there is SO MUCH I didn't even know about in this game... Thank you Strange Man!

[@DaddyVanDerLinde]

Loved the ending man you nailed it. Love ya buddy.

[@mohamadhoseinsoleymani5345]

Evelyn Miller talks about Dutch:"He is a fanboy,that man was a fanboy"

[@jesusguerra6257]

finally interesting and worthwhile content, the reason why I subscribed to this channel years ago, and no more impressive "details" of the game that we all already know, keep up the interesting content and I will subscribe again.

[@clintonarneson226]

This is really well done. Excellent video.

[@Roberto-954]

Since the game came out two days ago i was playing as john and exploring found this man

[@LegalWheel]

Just bought RDR2 since it was on sale and you were the main reason why I bought it because the game is full of mysteries

[@QwertyQwerty-so4kw]

cinematics of mission cutscenes are all so well done

[@MrFlakko30]

Not gonna lie, Evelyn's wish makes a whole lot of sense

[@rivennii-sama700]

Proverbs 19:1 *"Better is a poor person who walks in his integrity than one who is crooked in speech and is a fool."*

[@emur26]

Beautiful work, Strange Man.

[@MrHillbillyjoe]

I was playing this game just now when a thought hit me. There are 2 different stranger missions/quests where the people have the same name. In the stranger mission "Geology for Beginners" the man you talk to is named Francis Sinclair. In "The Veteran" the man's name is Hamish Sinclair. Are these two men related somehow? Perhaps father and son?

[@Noouuuuu]

Mrs. Sinclair, Francis' mother who you meet after collecting all the carvings and thusly ending Francis' side quest, tells either Arthur or John that Francis' father was named Thomas Sinclair and died some time before Francis was born. But you might be onto something; maybe Hamish is Francis' grandfather instead?

[@s.c.p-0493]

Apparently after Jack’s party you can hear screaming around Shady belle.

[@j.escuella5022]

Mr. Strange Man I just find out a little detail If you finished the mission "A Train to Nowhere" before the mission "Geology for Beginners" Chief Rains Fall will talk about the bridge, he will say something like the Army will blame his people about it. The other one is after the mission with Captain Monroe where Arthur intercepts the army wagon for the medicine. The women gathered around the fire (just outside Chief Rains Fall's tent) will say "Don't be deceived / fooled by their kind gestures". Maybe something to do with their trust eh? Since most of the peace treaties were broken by the white mens. Idk

[@Nounours1221]

BRO I need to say its the best vidéo rdr2 I see on youtube nice story

[@RedNeonNinja2125]

Bravo strange man I loved this 👏 ❤️ som much meaning and so emotional such a great video my friend