Every SpongeBob Season 5 Episode Reviewed!

Welcome to another part of my SpongeBob project! I plan on reviewing every SpongeBob episode ever, to determine which episodes and seasons are good, and which are pure ScumBob. In this video I review all 41 episodes in the fifth season, which includes giving fun facts, highlights, quotes, and a definitive answer as to weather I find it good, meh, or ScumBob. In addition, I talk about my favorite episodes in the season, and give some general notes, stats, and facts. It's a REALLY long, fun ride, so grab a box of SpongeBob cereal and enjoy this video!
0:00 - Introduction
1:20 - Friend or Foe?
4:07 - The Original Fry Cook
6:14 - Night Light
8:20 - Rise and Shine
9:36 - Waiting
11:22 - Fungus Among Us
14:04 - Spy Buddies
15:22 - Boat Smarts
16:57 - Good OI Whatshisname
19:06 - New Digs
19:58 - Krabs a La Mode
21:04 - Roller Cowards
22:32 - Bucket Sweet Bucket
23:31 - To Love a Patty
25:46 - Breath of Fresh Squidward
29:09 - Money Talks
30:20 - Spongebob vs the Patty Gadget
31:14 - Slimy Dancing
32:16 - The Krusty Sponge
34:24 - Sing a Song of Patrick
36:17 - A Flea in Her Done
38:57 - The Donut of Shame
39:56 - The Krusty Plate
40:45 - Goo Goo Gas
42:25 - Le Big Switch
43:30 - Atlantis Squarepantis
45:14 - Picture Day
46:27 - Pat No Pay
48:27 - Blackjack
50:26 - Blackened Sponge
51:54 - Mermaid Man vs Spongebob
53:28 - The Inmates of Summer
54:35 - To Save a Squirrel
56:08 - Pest of the West
59:25 - 20,000 Patties Under the Sea
1:01:15 - The Battle of Bikini Bottom
1:02:31 - Whatever Happened to Spongebob?
1:04:41 - The Two Faces of Squidward
1:06:44 - SpongeHenge
1:08:05 - Banned in Bikini Bottom
1:08:58 - Stanley S. Squarepants
1:10:14 - Season 5 Pie Chart & Rating
1:11:44 - Bottom 5 Season 5 Episodes
1:13:50 - Top 5 Season 5 Episodes
1:14:55 - Seasonal Notes
1:17:57 - Overall Thoughts & Credits
(Thanks to WebSurfer 2.0 for compiling the timestamps.)
#SpongeBobReview #EveryEpisodeReviewed #PIEGUYRULZ
Patreon: / pieguyrulz
Art: ohemgeeitsern.deviantart.com/
My Twitter: / pieguyrulz
Music by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...

[@TheEpicNintendork]

Season 5: Meh Season 6: PU WHAT'S THAT HORRIBLE SMELL

[@CaptainJZH]

Drum Solo!

[@tomlyndon3500]

CaptainJZH POINTY POINTY POINTY POINTY POINTY!

[@hatstick312]

I HAVE A HEAD IT ENDS IN A POINT

[@user-qj3cp1xu7z]

MustardDispenser TWINKLE TWINKLE PATRICK STAR! I MADE MY SELF A SANDWICH! MY MOMMY NAMED IT FRED! IT TASTED LIKE BEANS AND BACON! AND SMELLS LIKE ITS BEEN DEAD! WRITING STUFF IS HARD SO I USE A POINTY PENCIL, POINTY POINTY POINTY, POINTY POINTY POINT! P.U. WHATS THAT HORRIBLE SMELL? I HAVE A HEAD! IT ENDS IN A POINT! POINTY POINTY POINTY, POINTY POINTY POINT. THIS SONG IS OVER! EXCEPT FOR THIS LINE! YOU WIN THIS ROUND! BROCCOLI!!!!!!!!!!!!! (I wonder if I messed up any of the lines.)

[@BlueSkunkGuy]

Season 7: It's just no longer the same

[@theultimatememelord5494]

Something I like about Friend or Foe is that it makes episodes like F.U.N and New Leaf far more tragic and emotionally poignant. But on the other hand, it makes enemy in law a whole lot weirder and messed up.

[@MidnightMuffin]

PieGuyRulz: "Patrick cannot carry an episode by himself." Nickelodeon: "Hey, let's make an entire show about Patrick."

[@ArtieArchives]

Its probably going to get cancelled after season 2

[@MattSayYay]

To be fair, at least that show has characters with Patrick

[@ArtieArchives]

@@MattSayYay True, also its not as lame as Kamp Koral. It also has interesting visuals

[@familybroakajonny]

Tbf the Patrick star show is not bad Imo, I still enjoy it no matter the deny of spin-offs from Hillenburg

[@theofficialalexshow]

Kamp Koral is getting a finale!

[@animationfan4773]

friend or foe makes one coarse meal so much sadder

[@trgnf3393]

Like how rock a bye bilave makes to love a patty a lot more disturbing.

[@locomotivetrainstation6053]

I don't get it

[@Thischannelsnomore]

@@locomotivetrainstation6053 you'll get it...Because Its a creepy theory

[@zombies4evadude24]

@@locomotivetrainstation6053 Friend or Foe shows that Mr Krabs and Plankton were once best buddies. That means in One Coarse Meal Mr Krabs is driving his old childhood friend to suicide.

[@redplanetproductions7785]

@@zombies4evadude24 HOLY

[@TheMysteriousMrEnter]

I mostly agree this time around, just a few of your mehs I think are good (Sing a Song of Patrick, Intimates of Summer) and vice-versa (The Krusty Plate, 20,000 patties under the sea). But yeah, the good episodes are really good (Roller Cowards is awesome) and the bad episodes are *really* bad (WhoBob WhatPants and Atlantis SquarePantis are in my bottom 10). But now the fun really begins... Season 6 isn't all bad, but... um... good luck.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

Thanks, I'm going to need it. Especially for season 7 which is extra long, and contains a ton of episodes I've heard bad things about. I'd be really interested in seeing you review WhoBob. I hated it, but had a hard time articulating exactly why. It just feels so very off.

[@adrianbryan4573]

***** Oh? Do I sense another Enter/PIEGUY collab special on the horizon? Seeing The Critical Duo tear WhoBobWhatPants to shred would be interesting

[@miatoon]

Totally agreed.

[@miatoon]

***** Totally!

[@miatoon]

***** Some? You mean a lot!

[@Marcos-oc6cp]

Pest off the west would have been the perfect opportunity for plankton's family from "Plankton's Army"

[@Marcos-oc6cp]

It could've been a great cameo

[@thedapperegg689]

Yes

[@samgreenwell4672]

My thoughts exactly!

[@toadrules4658]

Eh, I still really like the comedy in that episode. "I ain't yer paw"

[@isomericgamer6644]

@@toadrules4658 and plankton's referencing an older episode by saying : "this town ain't big enough for the two of us!"

[@Dante...]

Even as a kid, when I saw SpongeBob murder a bunch of clams to protect a rotting sandwich I knew the show had seriously changed for the worse.

[@chloenieuwsma4846]

If I saw that as a child I would probably be horrified and cry my eyes out. It's sad when cartoon network (Burrito) and even Disney channel (Milos magical milkshake) can do this plot a thousand times better!

[@GooderFirki-mn4oz]

83c for coronavirus

[@JaredGriffiths2000]

Same here.

[@YuukiTakemoto1996]

The gross close-ups of the patty made me almost swear off Burger King for life. Burger King has been my favourite fast food place since the Pokemon and SpongeBob promotions of yore. I always thought Krabby Patties tasted like Whoppers. So to see THIS made me throw up and diet on only ramen and toast for a week. Eventually, I came up with a solution: to think of Brainiac from the DCAU, Solid Snake, or other sexy guys I liked while eating BK. It worked. Now I do this every time I see disgusting Krabby Patties in the show.

[@SquidBeatsSB]

⁠@@YuukiTakemoto1996In my state the drinks come from the same fountain so it tastes like shit (I’m not sure if you live in the us)

[@Rigel644]

I like the fact that Pieguy builds up Atlantis Squarepantis through the entire first half of the video, making references to it every once in a while, and getting more and more frequent, as he gets closer and closer to the worst episode of the season. XD

[@ProbablySoon-pv6ee]

Fungus Among Us in infinitely worse

[@liquidpestar8099]

Spongehenge is a depressing episode.

[@dalegarvey8076]

One of my least favorite episodes

[@existenceproductions2678]

Its one of my favorite season 5 episodes

[@PickleRicksFATASSCOUSIN]

@@existenceproductions2678 When you get older, You will understand why it's depressing, For now you're just a kid saying that....

[@toadrules4658]

@@existenceproductions2678 for a second I thought you were 9 volt.

[@andrewmangaming7022]

Yes and the ending is so stupid.

[@JoeDan54]

In my opinion, "Roller Cowards" is the funniest post-movie SpongeBob episode.

[@elizabethsmith7224]

JoeDan54 Harold no!!!!!!

[@clydethelamppost]

The only thing I like about Night Light is being able to shout "OH HAI MARK" when The Moth shows up.

[@YuukiTakemoto1996]

OMG LOL

[@zombies4evadude24]

And also the scene with the freezer. “You want me to go in... there?!”

[@UmbreonAnimate]

And don't forget the ending where Patrick walks to the sun, and then he burns

[@YuukiTakemoto1996]

And "IT LOOKS FLAMMABLE!!"

[@brrgames]

The only episodes I totally disagree with PIEGUYRULZ are Sing a Song of Patrick, Blackjack and The Inmates of Summer. I thought they were really good.

[@underarkduke9172]

hi brr

[@morbidsearch]

+BRRGames I agree with two of them, but Blackjack had some padding in it

[@ambazack]

Definitely agree, I love sing a song of Patrick.

[@scoob1788]

yeah

[@deadchannellol4604]

I disagree with those, and Bucket Sweet Bucket.

[@Duval-In-The-Wall]

Krabs a La Mode is such a good episode, didn’t even realize it was Season 5, thought it was 3 or at most 4

[@Nr4747]

I actually disagree on Inmates of Summer, it's an episode where - while kind of an "old concept" - *sooo* many of the jokes just hit perfect bullseye, I can't help but to absolutely love it. The Warden is also just completely perfect here, I couldn't even imagine him done better in the context of a SpongeBob episode. I can't even remember most of the episodes you talk about from way-back-when, but I immediately remembered some of the visuals of this episode, just hearing the title - that's how funny I found it and how vividly I remember it now.

[@abdullahibouraleh6919]

+Nr4747 I like this episode too. In fact, this is my favorite episode of season 5.

[@mcamman6193]

Same.

[@MemekharTheMechon]

Nr4747 Jr 4 t 96788qw 1 2 e e e kid w g w d1pwfrw o p e09uq old 68361

[@eli-is]

Nr4747 I LOVE YOUR COMMENT!

[@isetmfriendsofire]

I love Inmates of Summer too.

[@princeeris1780]

spongehenge was a creepy episode.

[@ambazack]

I feel like I'm the only one who thinks that episode isn't that bad...

[@karlapinkie7697]

I'm glad I wasn't the only one who was scared.

[@mariopokemon955]

+Snoop Doge THANK YOU

[@princeeris1780]

Karla Pinkie i wasn't scared. It was just weird

[@hopegallows1392]

Honestly I found it somewhat unsettling but enjoyable. It kinda reminds me of older cartoons that were build around a piece of music.

[@trunksrocks1]

"you've destroyed many of the things I love" is what almost everyone says about modern Nickelodeon.

[@Freezepark]

your performance on atlantis squrepantis was amazing.

[@JasminePaygeBrooke]

What bothered me most about the Patrick eating an apple gag was, oddly enough, how he was eating an apple of all things. Sandy lives in what appears to be an oak tree, and I may not have a mastery of plant life, but I'm pretty sure apples don't grow on oak trees . . .

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

Good catch! I love the fact that from literally all angles that joke fails.

[@Ice2441]

google "oak apple".

[@pinkduskstone1543]

For the sake of a cartoon, it could be a hybrid tree.

[@JasminePaygeBrooke]

Ice2441 Gah! They aren't that pretty to look at!

[@notobama584]

JasminePaygeBrooke um

[@hnickel4757]

Musician 1: I hate my life. Musician 2: *I hate your life too, dude.*

[@locomotivetrainstation6053]

One of the best episodes

[@zombies4evadude24]

**dies in the next scene*

[@YuukiTakemoto1996]

AND THAT'S WHY YOU'RE MY KOOKY WOOKY TEDDY BEAR!!

[@summerjonz]

Spongebob's muffled dialogue when Patrick is standing on top of him is absolutely hilarious.

[@summerjonz]

It's so similar to Kenny from South Park.

[@GanonGhidorah]

Here's something else you might not know about Spy Buddies. The whole episode is a Spy Parody, but the ending is actually a Parody of the movie "Trading Places". In that movie, the main antagonists make a bet involving the Switching of two people's lives, all over One Dollar. It's a really clever reference.

[@Flamestar320]

Another note for Season 5 should be there is a lot of singing in this season.

[@brantchristy3490]

+CeleryIsAwesome I'd say it's overall fine. Other than Atlantis Squarepantis, there weren't that many bad songs.

[@BroExpertGamer]

The only song I sing most of the time from season 5, was banned from bikini bottom

[@locomotivetrainstation6053]

SpongeBob has a lot of songs anyway

[@Lost..........................]

And in s1... what's your point?

[@Jelster64]

1:08:00 Poseidon and Neptune are actually the same person, it's just that Poseidon is his Greek name and Neptune is his Latin name. Or maybe you were joking, idk

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

It was a reference to some dialogue in the episode.

[@heatherbabes3207]

+PIEGUYRULZ whats the song in the background of the friend or foe review?

[@lulujuice1]

+Jelster64 one is roman one is greek not latin but you were close

[@Jelster64]

Jesse 10 Latin is the language of the Romans

[@lulujuice1]

but they are not latin they are roman

[@Freezeflame22]

So I guess your bottom 5 overall now is: 5) The Splinter 4) SpongeHenge 3) Atlantis Squarepantis 2) Truth or Square 1) Choir Boys

[@roseydog07]

k

[@Freezeflame22]

Not sure, but if I can I'll tell u

[@roseydog07]

Freezeflame22 :P r

[@Freezeflame22]

We could now but could you not review anything while we're talking, because it kinda feels pointless talking if you're just reviewing stuff

[@Lefty7788tinkatolli]

Freezeflame22 :P I think there will be a whole new bottom 5 when he's done with seasons 7 and 8 :)

[@ChikoCheez]

Your Atlantis Squarepantas song should be the most viewed thing on KZbin

[@noahfarmer3553]

Agreed

[@brattenhugo5643]

The Atlantis song is SAD

[@Vic_v._Gerdenheim]

Nice touch on the ScumBob transitions for episodes like "Waiting", "Boat Smarts" and "To Love a Patty" along with other amazingly clever and subtle nods sprinkled in. Bravo my friend, bravo.

[@BlythePennyBicycle21]

Here's a fun fact. Jack M. Crazyfish is voiced by Greg Baldwin. He's best known for being a voice match for Mako Iwamatsu after he passed away (Splinter in TMNT 2007, Iroh in Avatar The Last Airbender, and Aku in Samurai Jack). Though he was replaced by Tom Kenny in "20,000 Patties Under The Sea".

[@icepeep7265]

Spongehenge raises HUMUNGOUS questions and wrenches into the timeline/continuity

[@SuperIdiotMan00]

I like how the toy changed after the "ScumBob" label. 11:00

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

All the Scumbob pictures change ;)

[@SuperIdiotMan00]

***** Yeah, I noticed that afterwards. I like how you're gradually adding more stuff to these.

[@theronmoore9077]

***** great work, and keep it up!

[@familybroakajonny]

I actually loved Atlantis Squarepantis. It felt like a field trip, and Don’t get me wrong, even though the songs were somewhat trash, it kinda fills up the vibe of discovering INCREDIBLY AMAZING use of technology like an irl museum would. Video game generation, anything-ice cream maker, an extremely old bubble, so many memorable things to still see in my past childhood.

[@davidjensen9928]

You must wish that Sponghenge was BANNED in Bikini Bottom.

[@heyfandomtrashmoved9906]

Nice pun lol

[@thezombiecreeper]

David Jensen thanks for the pun, I will now shoot myself to cleanse the pain

[@thecupheadfan1837]

I will call Stanley s. Squarepants to ban it on His House fancy to the Krabby road.

[@isobelmiller7464]

My favorite part of Sing A Song of Patrick is this: Fish guy to his girlfriend: "This song always makes me think of you" Patrick's song: "PU, what's that horrible smell?" *Fish guy's girlfriend punches him*

[@Nightmare2688theeleckamo]

It makes me laugh everytime

[@alpine190mc]

@@Nightmare2688theeleckamo same

[@tiffanyb94]

Another enjoyable season review! I loved the epilogue..."Never be clean!" xD

[@sampatton3835]

*close up to spongebob a face

[@supernovagames6791]

I think it's fair to say your reviewing skills have definitely improved. Can't wait for season 6. THAT's where it gets interesting.

[@sdougl047]

I’m on a tangent but I just want to point out that the character getting a managerial promotion over another character trope seems to be a running theme on Nickelodeon. In addition to it being done in Friend or Foe, it’s also been done in the Drake and Josh episode entitled “MovieJob” and in iCarly in the episode iPear Store and there’s probably other examples that I’m not aware of

[@avisreviews5471]

Am I the only one that isn't creeped out by SpongeHenge? Don't get me wrong, I think it's bad. It's really boring, it has nothing worth liking, and the ending is jarring. But I don't find it creepy. Also, I don't hate it as much as most people. I probably wouldn't even put it in the bottom 10 for the season.

[@wowserswowsers3307]

I saw it when I was pretty young so I was absolutely terrified by it and it made me stop watching spongebob for a very long time, so I guess most people were young when they saw it like me so they were scared of it. If I watched it now I'd still probably hate it but I doubt I'd be that creeped out by it, except what I remember from it it was pretty creepy

[@frankiglass5106]

Yeah. Youre not alone. IDC THAT THIS COMMENT IS A YEAR OLD

[@TheGoat-nz4gt]

This is I will be in at but how can you not be scared? If you think about it, spongebob is in a cave to protect him from stinging jellyfish. He’s in there for sooo long that he’s insane, and the storm got so bad that everyone he knows and lives left without saying one last word to him. When he does get out, the whole town is buried in sand, and he is left to die with no food, alone, and insane. Then at the ending scene these things show that no one remembers spongebob. That is TERRYFYING.

[@elizabethsmith7224]

Wowsers Bowsers Same thing happened to me but with Face Freeze.

[@Dashiell777]

I agree with you spongehenge is not that creepy.

[@JoeDan54]

11:00 I like how you made the toy into its "broken" state once the ScumBob text appeared. Nice touch!

[@Cheesehead302]

Once again, these never fail to be great. You're one of the best reviewers I know, and the hard work you do really shows. :) Keep it up Pieguy

[@azaleawinchester]

43:31 now available on itunes

[@thezombiecreeper]

Ora Wisteria hell yes

[@spongefan155]

Please

[@mysecondchannelchildhoodca713]

Airing Order: 0:08:22 (Feb 2007) Rise and Shine 0:09:40 (Feb 2007) Waiting 0:34:26 (Feb 2007) Sing a Song of Patrick 0:01:22 (Apr 2007) Freind or Foe 0:14:06 (Jul 2007) Spy Buddies 0:15:23 (Jul 2007) Boat Smarts 0:16:58 (Jul 2007) Good Ol' Whatshisname 0:32:17 (Jul 2007) The Krusty Sponge 0:19:08 (Jul 2007) New Digs 0:20:00 (Jul 2007) Krabs á la Mode 0:23:33 (Jul 2007) To Love a Patty 0:25:48 (Jul 2007) Breath of Fresh Squid 0:21:06 (Jul 2007) Roller Cowards 0:22:33 (Jul 2007) Bucket Sweet Bucket 0:04:09 (Jul 2007) The Original Fry Cook 0:06:16 (Jul 2007) Night Light 0:29:11 (Jul 2007) Money Talks 0:30:21 (Jul 2007) The Patty Gadget 0:31:15 (Jul 2007) Slimy Dancing 0:36:18 (Aug 2007) A Flea In Her Dome 0:38:59 (Aug 2007) The Donut of Shame 0:39:57 (Aug 2007) The Krusty Plate 0:45:15 (Aug 2007) Picture Day 0:46:29 (Aug 2007) Pat No Pay 0:48:29 (Aug 2007) Blackjack 0:50:28 (Aug 2007) Blackened Sponge 0:51:55 (Aug 2007) MM vs. SpongeBob 0:11:26 (Sep 2007) Fungus Among Us 0:42:26 (Sep 2007) Le Big Switch 0:43:31 (Nov 2007) Atlantis SquarePantis 0:53:30 (Nov 2007) Inmates of Summer 0:54:37 (Nov 2007) To Save a Squirrel 0:59:27 (Nov 2007) 20,000 Paties 1:01:15 (Nov 2007) Battle of Bikini Bottom 1:04:43 (Nov 2007) Two Faces of Squid 1:06:47 (Nov 2007) SpongeHenge 1:08:07 (Nov 2007) Banned In Bikini 1:08:59 (Nov 2007) Stanley S. 0:56:10 (Apr 2008) Pest of the West 1:02:32 (Oct 2008) W.E.H.T.SP? 0:40:46 (Jul 2009) Goo Goo Gas

[@locomotivetrainstation6053]

Weird airing order

[@locomotivetrainstation6053]

What an airing order

[@locomotivetrainstation6053]

Wait I already said that

[@Prollan06]

@@locomotivetrainstation6053 Oh

[@zombies4evadude24]

@@locomotivetrainstation6053 especially Goo Goo Gas. Why did it air 2 years after most of the episodes.

[@coasterrebel9956]

These reviews are fantastic for so many reasons. It puts a critical point of view on the episodes to prove nostalgia isn't the only reason people believe the show's gone downhill, it acknowledges when new episodes are good and gives it the credit it deserves, plus these are just fun to watch. Also I actually agree with your opinion for almost every episode. I disagree with Battle of Bikini Bottom but besides that, it's weird how similar I would rank these episodes. Fantastic job, PieGuy! Also I loved the Atlantis Squarepantis song :)

[@myfly4711]

OMG I completely forgot todays's monday! Hell yeah! Seeing this in my subscriptions made my day!!! :D

[@abandonedchannel546]

BEFORE: PieguyRulz: You might not agree in my opinions AFTER: Are you kidding me?! this is the season i mostly agree on..

[@seanmyster6]

+SBells27 I was gonna say that, too. The only one I disagree on is The Inmates Of Summer. (a good episode, in my opinion)

[@locomotivetrainstation6053]

I disagree with a lot actually

[@davidyoutube9305]

I agree with all the Scumbob episodes except Pest of the West and Night Light

[@ProbablySoon-pv6ee]

I agree with most things here but not all. My biggest disagreement is Pest of the West

[@rockofsteel23]

*audience applauds* the atlantis review was amazing and lets not forget that the one SINGER they got to voice someone doesn't have a song

[@peterfinaldi3251]

I was literally waiting for you to post this, and boy is it delivering!

[@obakethesincere1557]

These videos keep getting more and more interesting. I'm glad to know that you had the same reactions to "To Love a Patty" and "Atlantis Squarepantis"!

[@emanatingf]

The one thing I notice is that even in terrible & scumbob quality episodes. Squidward is very down to earth a lot of the time & is nearly always able to bring something funny, realistic & witty with his remarks to the table. I'm starting to like Squidward more than I ever thought I did.

[@skylarmalone8380]

The only redeemable quality about to love a patty is squidwards side remarks, only thing that made me laugh in the episode

[@meko750]

Glad to see such good opinions about Krabs A La Mode. It was my favorite episode this season.

[@clemmu]

Did you know there was a book version of "Waiting"? It was _much_ better than the episode.

[@CaptainJZH]

I think I read that once a few years back. I didn't even know there was an episode at the time.

[@123Yellowberry123]

I actually have that book from when I was in elementary school. I remember liking the book and not the episode. :)

[@Keer95]

I’m glad someone else remembers that lol

[@MegaSparkster]

Hell yeah,it's finally here!Good luck with season 6 in advance.

[@awwhellnawww9239]

“Krabs à La Mode” feels like a season 4 episode

[@BloxCops]

Probably because it was produced early in season 5

[@BloxCops]

And banned in bikini bottom looks like a season 6 episode

[@animeboy7082]

season 3 is the best season of SpongeBob understand

[@EndlessPsychoCycleOfDeath]

​@@animeboy7082Season 2?

[@Lost..........................]

Season 3 homestly

[@JKEBP]

The Inmates of Summer is a lot like SpongeBob Meets the Strangler: SpongeBob and Patrick unknowingly tormenting a tough guy (the warden).

[@noahfarmer3553]

The Inmates of Summer is a pretty enjoyable episode. I had it on DVD along with Club SpongeBob

[@fightingmedialounge519]

Probably because the strangler episode had more focus and had the person being tormented actually deserve it.

[@Lost..........................]

​@@fightingmedialounge519shurrup man. Genuinly no joke in that eo that can compare with inmates of summer.

[@fightingmedialounge519]

@@Lost.......................... fix your spelling

[@Lost..........................]

@@fightingmedialounge519 🤓

[@123Yellowberry123]

I'm always really happy to see these season reviews in my subscriptions feed. :) I agree with a number of things you said. There were some ratings I disagreed with, but like others have said, you bring up some very good points about each episode. I remember watching a lot of these...well, a lot when they first aired, but looking back, I'm not too familiar with them. I guess I'll have some catching up to do with Season 6! Anyway, great video as always! Here's hoping the next season isn't as *quite* bad as I've been hearing. :D

[@HissinSpit]

This video is why you're one of my favorite reviewers. You judge everything fairly by going into an episode mostly unbiased and then giving your opinion. I was actually under the impression that a good majority of these episodes would be bad considering how notoriously bad a lot of modern SB episodes are, but there were a lot of good episodes you mentioned that I completely forgot about after not seeing them in so long. I didn't realize they were in this season because they had, at the very least, season 4 quality. So, thanks for the awesome video! Can't wait for the other seasons :) P.S. The Atlantis Squarepantis "review song" you did had me cracking up xD

[@jdlogan48]

I totally agree

[@goozer326]

My ratings of all Season 5 SpongeBob episodes: My rating system: Amazing (The episode has a great plot or consistently really funny jokes or both) Great (The episode had a lot of good jokes or a good plot or both) Good (The episode had a nice amount of jokes that made me laugh or a fairly good plot or both) Meh (The episode was lacking in humor or had an average plot or you guessed it, both) Bad (The episode had some bad jokes or a dumb plot or both) Scumbob (The episode was either really annoying or had a really stupid plot or both) Friend or Foe? (Good) The Original Fry Cook (Good) Night Light (Bad) Rise and Shine (Meh) Waiting (Bad) Fungus Among Us (Scumbob) Spy Buddies (Great) Boat Smarts (Meh) Good OI Whatshisname (Meh) New Digs (Good) Krabs a La Mode (Good) Roller Cowards (Good) Bucket Sweet Bucket (Good) To Love a Patty (Meh) Breath of Fresh Squidward (Meh) Money Talks (Meh) (very forgettable) Spongebob vs the Patty Gadget (Meh) Slimy Dancing (Meh) (incredibly forgettable) The Krusty Sponge (Meh) Sing a Song of Patrick (Meh) A Flea in Her Dome (Scumbob) The Donut of Shame (Meh) The Krusty Plate (Meh) Goo Goo Gas (Meh) Le Big Switch (Meh) Atlantis Squarepantis (I know this is an extremely controversial pick but Great) Picture Day (Meh) Pat No Pay (Meh) Blackjack (Good) Blackened Sponge (Good) Mermaid Man vs Spongebob (Meh) The Inmates of Summer (Good) To Save a Squirrel (Meh) Pest of the West (Good) 20,000 Patties Under the Sea (Great) The Battle of Bikini Bottom (Good) Whatever Happened to Spongebob? (Bad) The Two Faces of Squidward (Meh) SpongeHenge (Meh) Banned in Bikini Bottom (Bad) Stanley S. Squarepants (Meh) The results: 0 Amazing 3 Great (Spy Buddies, Atlantis Squarepantis, 20,000 Patties Under The Sea) 12 Good 20 Meh 4 Bad (Night Light, Waiting, WhoBob WhatPants, Banned in Bikini Bottom) 2 Scumbob (Fungus Among Us, A Flea In Her Dome) Notes: Lots of forgettable episodes So much Meh Mostly Meh and Good I had a much harder time picking the Top 5 than I did the Bottom 5 Top 5: #5: Friend or Foe? #4: New Digs #3: 20,000 Patties Under The Sea #2: Spy Buddies #1: Atlantis Squarepantis (again super controversial I know) Bottom 5: #5: Waiting #4: Banned in Bikini Bottom #3: WhoBob WhatPants #2: A Flea In Her Dome #1: Fungus Among Us Conclusion: Well, there's no way this is season is Amazing, Great, or Good, And I don't think it's bad enough to be considered Scumbob, so I feel like season 5 of SB is................... A Meh season. The number of Mehs should've given it away. This season doesn't really pull in either direction. It was kinda leaning toward Bad a little, since the Bads and Scumbobs are much worse than anything I've seen before, but I feel like it wasn't enough evidence for it to be considered Bad.

[@goozer326]

Thx

[@chriswood-nostalgic8900]

To Love a Patty is one of the few episodes that breaks Spongebob's character. He literally teared clams in half and killed them. It's like abusing ducklings, over food!

[@anonymousinkproductions8624]

Wow. Someone other than me will defend Atlantis Squarepantis. Thank you

[@goozer326]

@@anonymousinkproductions8624 No problem. I never got the hate for it.

[@about_to_leave_earth]

Atlantis Squarepantis is one of my most memorable episodes. I'm always happy to watch it. Yeah the songs are a bit too much but I like the plot. Glad that other people like it as well!

[@Eltrio2]

37:23) You can't simply squash a flea. Trust me on that. They have evolved to resist claws. They only methods to truly kill a flea are to either drown it, poison it, or use a nail clipper and even then it can be difficult.

[@Mordecai781]

To be honest, I hated Spongehenge. I was not only confused by the lack of jokes but this really strange ending and being way too mean spirited toward Spongebob. I agree with you on that episode.

[@roberttreacy8271]

The Real Shaggy Yeah, that episode was so unnecessarily depressing.

[@helpkirbyhasagun_2047]

Your profile pic really fits your comment XD

[@Matsu_Suzuki16]

I consider it extremely bland and even more boring.

[@michaelwatson4845]

I like when he reviewed Atlantis squarepantis, it wasn't cringe to me but I don't think it's That bad the second half of 11 minutes was bad to me. But not horrible

[@familybroakajonny]

That was the most uncanny episode next to Fungus Among Us

[@1SpeedyYoshi]

Yay, I've been waiting! Thank you pieguy, you are awesome

[@WOSArchives]

"Friend or Foe" first aired on my birthday. What a great birthday gift, one of the best post-first movie episodes and one of the best specials.

[@SplashCity46]

I personally think that the meh and scumbob episodes are more balanced this season, but I still really enjoy your reviews!

[@kenanharristv7956]

Great review!! I love krabs a la mode and every time I watch it I'll know someone loves it as much as I do

[@Scsigs]

Like those new animations for the ratings, man. Nice upgrade.

[@SleepyTaylor]

Pretty sure the long face unwrapping scene is a refference to the twilight zone episode "eye of the beholder" where they take forever to slowly unwrap her bandages to see if the facial reconstruction was successful or if she will have to be sent away to a facility for the hidious. It is a wondeful episode, the one that got me hooked on the twilight zone.

[@the2thomasklu8]

Fun fact: 1:06:44 won a golden reel award for "Best Sound Editing in Television: Animated" in 2008.

[@Robert___98]

*Sees time length* Oh man, this is gonna be goood!

[@kaysonvelazquez4713]

friend or foe meh the oranial fry cook good night light scumbob rise and shine scumbob waiting scumbob fungus among us scumbob spy buddies good boat smarts meh goodoldwhatshisname meh new digs good krabs a la mode good roller cowards good bucket sweet bucket good to love a patty SCUMBOB WORST OF THE SEASON breath of fresh squidward SCUMBOB money talks scumbob spongebob vs the patty gadget SCUMBOB silmy dancing scumbob the krusty sponge scumbob sing a song of patrick star scumbob a flea in her dome scumbob the donut of shame good the krusty plate meh goo goo gas meh le big switch meh atlantis squarepants meh picture day meh pat no pay scumbob blackjack good blackened sponge good mermaid man vs spongebob scumbob the inmates of summer SCUMBOB 2nd WORST OF THE SHOW AND SEASON to save a squirrel scumbob pest of the west meh 20000 patties under the sea good the battle of the bikini bottom meh what ever happened to spongebob scumbob the 2 faces of squidward good spongehenge meh banned of the bikini bottom meh stanley s squarepants scumbob 11 good episodes 12 meh episodes 18 scumbob episodes season 5 scumbob season

[@dannycaceres5119]

This video was really, really good, and then when the "Atlantis Squarepantis" segment came, it became absolutely great. :D Are you going to sing during any of the other musical episodes, like "Hello Bikini Bottom"?

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

Judging by the reaction to this, I just might. I hope what I lack in talent, is made up for in cheesiness XD

[@dannycaceres5119]

Well, at least the song is one "Sing a Song of Patrick"-type bad, not "Atlantis SquarePantis"-type bad. :P

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

***** Eh, that's one way of taking the joke. That's the fun of vague humor, it can work a few ways.

[@beta511ee4]

What episode is that kitten joke from?

[@TheRoxBox99]

***** What's wrong with cheesiness?

[@suuuhhhduude4937]

After rewatching Stanley s squarepants I realized I actually like it a lot more than when I did as a child. There were some jokes I thought were clever and made me laugh out loud and I thought spongebob himself acted more pre movie in my opinion

[@araucanoraptorargentinus3973]

In my opinion, this was the last good season of Spongebob. After that, it was all down hill from here and it was basically something that Nickelodeon could never recover from.

[@baldyairkid1831]

Then Season 10 revived the series.

[@fadibarakat1043]

Rowan Sales I agree too

[@cubersanonymous5180]

Xeito Media season 9*

[@h3526]

True the last episode of S5 is basically someone destroying SpongeBob's house and that's the series The next episode after that is about a "fancy house" and there was a scene in that episode which started Modern Gross Era

[@Veetamin__GD]

I know this comment is old,but i honestly think that season 9 was better than season 5

[@dr.mantistobboggan4065]

Your singing is angelic.

[@LuxyHugs]

A better quote for Rise and Shine (In my opinion of course) I have to put on my teeth and brush my pants. -Patrick

[@Killerbeast-hx5qp]

This got a hearty laugh out of me

[@sterling3625]

When I was little, I actually did legitmately feel bad for Squidward when SpongeBob confronted him in Breath Of Fresh Squidward (and I still vividly remember watching it the exact day that it aired). Usually most kids at my age wouldn't have thought so much about this, and possibly get influenced by the horrible execution, but no. I actually thought this was a bad episode even when I was little. I think this may be an origin of what got me into criticism.

[@ryantaziyah6774]

The part where it turned into good neighbors made me rewind several times to make sure I wasn't seeing things in the background.

[@skx444]

Nice job PIEGUY, recently you have been AMAZING lately and i wish you good luck with future videos.

[@TheJwa66]

I love how many times you foreshadowed Atlantis Squarepantis. LOL!

[@owengette8089]

I like spongehenge, actually. We saw Spongebob in a new light. People talk a lot about how we don’t see him display his intelligence a whole lot, but spongehenge offers that with how he designed the statues. I’m a bit biased, cuz I’ve always liked “farther-out” episodes like Squidward in Clarinetland, but I like it- certainly more than a lot of episodes in Season 5 and onward.

[@jacekdaking9439]

I loved your song insulting Atlantis Squarepantis lol

[@ShadinGirl1996]

I remember I had this set of books that were all Nickelodeon a long time ago and 1 of the Spongebob ones had the same plot as "Waiting" except the toy was a peice of string. Watching that short was a deja vu moment for me.

[@chimeratriplett2319]

Thanks for cheering me up after a not-so-fun day!

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

:D Anytime !

[@WhittyWhitts]

LOL when you sung the review of Atlantis Squarepantis and was dissing it so hard I was laughing

[@isobelmiller7464]

Another thing to note about the ending of Goo Goo Gas is that Spongebob is one of those shows that just resets after every episode ends.

[@ericmichaud1273]

The Atlantis Squarepantis review made me instantly favorite.

[@FrozenUSA]

His song about the episode is lightyears better than the songs in the actual episode. I was laughing hysterically the entire time. I hope he does more things like this going forward.

[@Scsigs]

I think SpongeHenge might also be trying to parody Cast Away, the Tom Hanks film, which I think you touched upon in your initial review of it.

[@plank6293]

Scsigs 4 year old comment and video

[@riddlemefish6217]

I love your singing lmaoo 10/10

[@JakeJakers]

Hey, +PIEGUYRULZ do you still plan a different review Atlantis Squarepantis? With the Season 6 and 7 videos out, I'm interested how you opinions stack up.

[@treehugger0241]

You had me at the Scumbob song for Atlantis Squarepantis. Subscribed. XD

[@FrozenUSA]

That is only the beginning. Keep watching for the rest of the Spongebob seasons to be reviewed as well as smaller videos called "Square Theory" and "Spongy Bits." He also does other reviews like reviews of the new episodes of "Adventure Time" as well as occasional rants and raves of one episode of a different show, depending on what the viewers want to see.

[@tiffanyb94]

treehugger0241 just curious, but how did you come across Pieguy's videos? But welcome aboard, you're in for a fun ride :D

[@treehugger0241]

Tiffany B His collab with Mr. Enter is what convinced me to check out his videos. :)

[@CapnCinnamonBunVideogamemaster]

Not even Casey Alexander likes Atlantis Squarepantis

[@Matsu_Suzuki16]

I know. Look I may not be a generalized cartoon reviewer but if the people that work on your epside that you screwed up. Which is why its my least favorite episode.

[@Scsigs]

Pretty sure Spongehenge is supposed to partly parody Castaway as well.

[@MrJACKBaird]

+Scsigs i was thinking that

[@NickTheEnlightened]

Finally getting around to doing the rest of the seasons. Admittedly from 5 onward a lot of my ratings are based off purely from memory, as it's been several years since I've seen most of them. So if I ever rewatch some of these episodes and my opinions change, I'll gladly edit my comments with my refreshed knowledge. Good: Friend or Foe, Spy Buddies, New Digs, Krabs a la Mode, Roller Cowards, SpongeBob vs. The Patty Gadget (only by a hair), The Krusty Sponge, Sing a Song of Patrick, The Donut of Shame (again, just barely), Goo Goo Gas, Blackjack, The Battle of Bikini Bottom, Two Faces of Squidward Meh: The Original Fry Cook, Bucket Sweet Bucket, Slimy Dancing, Le Big Switch, Picture Day, Blackened Sponge (sorry Pieguy), MM vs. SpongeBob, The Inmates of Summer, 20K Patties Under the Sea ScumBob: Night Light, Rise and Shine, Waiting, Fungus Among Us, Boat Smarts, Good ol' Whatshisname, To Love a Patty, Breath of Fresh Squidward, Money Talks, A Flea in Her Dome, The Krusty Plate (I'll never understand why some people like this one), Atlantis Squarepantis, Pat No Pay, To Save a Squirrel (might've been Meh if the title wasn't a complete and utter lie), Pest of the West, What Ever Happened to SpongeBob?, SpongeHenge, Banned in Bikini Bottom, Stanley S. Squarepants 13 Good 9 Meh 19 ScumBob Top 5: 5. Spy Buddies 4. Friend or Foe 3. Sing a Song of Patrick 2. Krabs a la Mode 1. Roller Cowards (this is seriously a Top 25 or even 20 episode for me) Bottom 5: 5. Boat Smarts 4. Waiting 3. SpongeHenge 2. Atlantis Squarepantis 1. Fungus Among Us (This is one of the few episodes of the show that I legitimately gag at every time I watch it). Overall, I'm honestly not too impressed with this season. While better than the godawful atrocities that were Seasons 6 and 7, it still contains quite a lot of awful episodes and is really when the show began to feel like it was drifting away from its former self. There are some great episodes this season, though in all honesty I'd still watch the best in Seasons 1-4 almost any day over most of them. I get why some people may like this season, but for me, it just doesn't have enough truly outstanding content to come back to aside from my Top 3, and particularly Roller Cowards.

[@kita6097]

You opened my eyes to how bad boat smarts is. Thank you.

[@Trunkalunx]

You know what PieGuy? That song you sang to sum up Atlantis SquarePantis was far better than any of the songs in the episode.

[@MegaAnimazing]

44:50-45:00 is that how long you can hold a note PGR?

[@ToxPhy]

I thought you said PBG instead of PGR at first.

[@qlitch]

+randman pbg is my favorite KZbinr next to ethoslab :)

[@blackmetroid3234]

+MrGlitchmaster03 me too except my fave KZbinr is PIEGUYRULZ

[@gingerandpiggytales]

SCUUMBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO,OOOOOOO, OOOOOOB.

[@locomotivetrainstation6053]

What is a pgr

[@erikstensaas1202]

Unless he's talking about the song that plays when they're referencing Planet of the Apes, remind me to whistle the spongehenge tune if were to see him in real life because I actually think it fits the series and is really relaxing. Seriously, I like it.

[@TyrellBain]

During "Waiting" review: "It checks off everything that makes a _SpongeBob_ episode bad." *Cough* "Oral Report" *Cough*

[@KasualBrian]

When I first saw spongehenge I was 9 years old. I HATED it. They gave it an eerie atmosphere that made spongebob and the audience feel isolated from the rest of bikini bottom. The tune they chose was spongebob's version of lavender town music. And the ending was so depressing as spongebob went through all this trouble to get back to his regular life and when he finally does, it's implied that everything is gone and everyone is dead including his friends. The episode doesn't even try to play this off as a joke they straight up say everyone you loved from spongebob is gone and the only thing left of them are the giant spongebob statues. When I first saw this episode I was left with a depressed feeling that usually spongebob cures, not causes. I'm pretty sure this episode scarred me mentally because every time I remember that tune the jellyfish sing, I just instantly get a feeling of stress and depression.

[@Bioforever120]

How old are u :/ lol

[@graveyard63]

Spongehenge is the worst episode of all time

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

Ah SpongeHenge. I remember when they first invented SpongeHenge. Sweet, sweet SpongeHenge. I always hated it!

[@graveyard63]

***** The 1st time I saw it, I was like "there can never be an episode worse than Good Neighbors" then I saw this......

[@DarkStarboye]

I've got to be honest. When I was younger, I enjoyed the creepy atmosphere and spongebob's lavendertown. But yeah, it doesn't fit in with the rest of the episodes.

[@alexipanda9505]

Your song for Atlantis Squarepantis really made me laugh. Certainly better than any of the songs in the episode

[@UTubeSponge5601]

One fun fact about "SpyBob": The intro music and the short "James Bond" moment have the music form the outro theme of "Action League NOW!" Now, THAT was a nostalgia bomb for me! :D

[@FrozenUSA]

Thank you for another amazing season review. I'm mostly on the same page as you in terms of which episodes you liked and which ones you didn't like with the exception of Spongehenge. The song was what made me like the episode. I have that song in my head for a few days after seeing it, much in the same way as the song from the Earworm episode. My favorite episode of the season is "The Two Faces of Squidard." I loved the way Squidward looked at the end when he was flying around after Spongebob pushed him. I wish he would have stayed that way forever ;) Atlantis Squarepantis is probably the worst of all special up to this point. I was really interested in seeing it when I saw the promos for it at the time and for the fact that David Bowie is in it. However the songs are just so bad that the episode is unwatchable for me. Speaking of songs, I LOVE the "Idiot Friends" song in "Pest of the West." I place it in the same category as the best songs from the first three seasons. I can't stop laughing when I see this song. Overall this season is like you said pretty much down the line at great episodes and pure scumbob. A note for you for next season. There are a few amazing gems including, IMO, an amazing guest appearance by an awesome 80's rocker. Oh and IMO the worst and grossest episode ever "Pets or Pests" is here. I've said it before and I'll say it again, this episode makes me gag to the point of nearly puking it is so gross. I get angry and sick just watching it. This is much the same reaction that many have gotten from "The Splinter" which is also in season 6. I don't want to give too much more away since you haven't seen a lot of episodes from that season. I just don't have all that much either way to say about season 5 because it was almost a throw away (save for a few gems). I'm just annoyed that even though Nickelodeon has renewed the show for a 10th season, not ONE new episode has aired in 2014. The last new episode was "Spongebob, You're Fired!" That one aired in NOVEMBER. It is almost as if Nick quietly cancelled the series, but they didn't. I understand they want to wait until the second movie to air more episodes, but the movie doesn't come out for an additional 6 months. There should be some new episodes in order to make the series slightly new and fresh since the look and feel of the second movie will be slightly new and fresh. Again, great season 5 review. Looking forward to season 6 in a few months!

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

As usual, thanks for the well written comment :) Kenny the Cat aired after the kcas this year, but your point still stands, it's ridiculous that they are holding the episodes.

[@beta511ee4]

That, and he apparently doesn't know Spongebob.

[@wariolandgoldpiramid]

they were working on the movie, thayt's why And it was recently announced that the production of Season 9 will resume now

[@illiniguy34]

Great review! It saddens me that "Waiting" premiered on my Mom's birthday, sorry Mom. That crash test Squid made you laugh too? Awesome! That Atlantis Squarepantis review song, *sniff* voice of an angel. Blackjack pulled a Mandarin, in my opinion. 1:08:04- Um Neptune and Poseidon are the same god, one's just another name for the other. Though honestly I don't agree with The Original Fry Cook (meh), New Digs (EW), Breath of Fresh Squidward (here's a taste of your own medicine you little yellow bitch!), Money Talks (meh), The Donut of Shame (EW), Picture Day (EW), Blackened Sponge (EW), 20,000 Patties Under the Sea (meh), and The Battle of BB (EW). And that epilogue, hilarious.

[@illiniguy34]

***** With Blackened Sponge, I had forgotten about the plot.

[@illiniguy34]

***** Don't get me wrong it had decent jokes, but when it gets to SB's uncle's house everything seems to just come to a screeching halt and the build up for Blackjack was exciting yet in the end it felt like a slap in the face.

[@illiniguy34]

***** Oh crap sorry, just the titles sound so similar. As for Blackened Sponge, I did forget that it was about the Sponge getting a black eye (I hadn't seen the episode in a while and forgot the title), and just found everything to be stupid. Also here's something irritating, there's the Patty Caper and then there's The Great Patty Caper.

[@illiniguy34]

***** Yup.

[@illiniguy34]

***** Definitely, there was no clash to speak of!

[@rayanrahal2944]

Great videos, man! Do you know approximately when the season 6 video will be uploaded?

[@PatrickStar-wl3mz]

Boat Smarts Is Really Funny In My Opinion