Everything I can find wrong with the guns of COD:WW2

[@198thairsoft]

The real US gas mask is accurate but the gas mask on the soldier is actually French.

[@redactedagentdataexpunged9431]

Like your thumbnail

[@sloppyoyster5779]

I bought ww2 gas mask

[@vargasjorgeissac3b679]

Oui

[@abnerdiaz683]

Yes yes

[@moistteeny2898]

Cause the division is called french medic

[@PsychoRavager]

There were no hit markers in WW2 from my knowledge.

[@mako_happy]

Yeah thats true actually. In real life there are still no hit markers. Why are there hit markers in WW2? Unrealistic!

[@mr.picklejar]

Last time I checked if you die there's no coming back

[@jimboonie9885]

@@mr.picklejar Only on earth. On my home world we have VR technology far better than your earthling ones. We can go back to when giant lizards roamed your planet and interact with them!

[@mr.picklejar]

@@jimboonie9885 *GASP! ITS A ALIEN*

[@Adriiiiiiii1]

Neither did WW1

[@echo2713]

We "Promise Historical Accuracy" FORGETS TO ADD Soviets and Japan

[@antonikubiak5798]

They would have to show soviets destroying Poland, killing and robbing everything that coupé be robbed od killed, betraying Polish people and calling it freedom

[@antonikubiak5798]

Could*

[@echo2713]

@@antonikubiak5798 so whats wrong with that

[@antonikubiak5798]

It would make them lose many customers od russia and japan, that would be uncomfortable with the content

[@antonikubiak5798]

It is all about money

[@johnnyzero8853]

2:48 Looking back at this nonsense, Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2019 has a scoped Kar98k rifle and reloading animation is way better than this.

[@guts-141]

Indeed I've seen some players kicking ass with it despite being scoped

[@jonathanthomasjohn8348]

2 years later no shit. But yes mw got much more love in production

[@tiporial]

That's because hyper, the person who animated all of the guns, has fuck tons of years making purely first person animations, he actually has a KZbin channel. Check him out

[@Simon-lq5uk]

Plus, when having a scope on the kar, instead of using a stripper clip, you load each individual bullet in.

[@locness.monsterr]

Still hate the stripper clip reloads when there are still bullets in the gun. (Talking about variants that doesn't cover the bolt)

[@kempodle4665]

As the owner of a Garand, I can tell you the opening on the rear sight is MASSIVE in game, much more so than in real life

[@Aureus_]

Definently

[@milktea6455]

My only answer to this is for gameplay purposes, I mean would you even use the Garand when the rear sight is tiny ?

[@Mogo-jan]

Rear sights in most games are huge due to games the dof blur our eyes do when looking down a sight. There was a game that tried to use realistic proportions for the m16 and grease gun, but changed to unrealistic sizes because people were complaining they couldn't see anything. Afaik, Arma are the only games to pull realistic sights properly.

[@GunnerySurgeon]

@@Mogo-jan I believe Red Orchestra 2 Rising Storm also did this. The M1 Garand rear sight is small

[@nanotech1921]

its for gameplay purposes

[@brycebennett3065]

Oh no. You said black women didn’t serve on the front lines in WWII Better hope tumblr doesn’t find out

[@marah4847]

Corbin McDaniel thats the point

[@fancy4663]

Nobody is saying that black women served on the frontlines People are saying that black people fought on the frontlines (Harlem hellfighters)

[@frankless7044]

in a game with zombies and the most cliché american clique for the story mode, people still find the need to nit-pick about african americans in a ww2 era. it’s a game, grow up

[@turtleboiyt2792]

FANCY, Isn’t that WW1 not WW2?

[@fancy4663]

Turtle Boi YT both

[@x-treme_gamer]

You forgot to mention that the Winchester Model 1897 "Trench Gun" only carried 5 shells.

[@johntoddmcallaster4922]

5+1 but yea ur right

[@whitegradient5182]

@@johntoddmcallaster4922 cod never counted the extra shell in the chamber but you're not wrong

[@lugiasimply6054]

He also forgot that the PPSh-41 was never used by American forces. Unless they hypothetically managed to get one captured from the Germans that captured it from the Soviets originally, that was not gonna happen.

[@jakeroly2593]

You forgot how the combat shotgun can hold TEN shells with extended magazine.

[@Smong_Bobby69420]

Nevertheless 7 shells. The M1897 Winchester Trench-Grade Shotgun holds only 5 shells not 7.

[@huangchanyou7465]

TBH,WAW is better.

[@Smong_Bobby69420]

@@huangchanyou7465, I loved everything about world at war, the maps, the guns and even the uncensored parts of war. You couldn't show that stuff nowadays

[@huangchanyou7465]

@@Smong_Bobby69420 yeah,+It's dare to show Hitler Handsome Face to you.

[@Khan--nr4lw]

Why did you bold “magazine”

[@aidanpatman-clark7131]

The only historically accurate part of the whole game was the black female nazis

[@cjtn10]

Yeah! And you can kill people with shovels, Corkscrews and a baseball bat! Whats next? Lamps! Cant wait Sledgehammer TAKE MY MONEY ALREADY! GIVE ME EARLY ACCESS FOR A JETPACK!

[@stalk3r5]

The germans had jetpacks in WWII and this is not a fucking joke.

[@chillywang3659]

my grandfather's friend was shot down and he injured a german rifleman with an oil lamp (not lit) because his gun was in his burning plane to hot to touch he also found a pitch fork in the barn that he crashed neer he was captured by a recovery squad and held by a german infantry platoon only to be let go as the war was nearly over and he knew german quite well he befriended his captors drank with them in the last days of the war they stayed in a small town the only building that wasn't damaged was the tavern and it was stocked so they stayed there early 1945

[@vilppuheinonen1034]

@@chillywang3659 I want your lämp, Moth

[@ethan1746]

C r/woooosh

[@JackClockerinos]

A few corrections: The pistols and rifles being used at the same time is only there because it would be dumb for players not to have a backup weapon. The Lewis gun was in use by the British army until 1942 The MG-15 was used during the end of the war as a last-ditch light machine gun. The Winchester 1897 was still in use by WW2 and Korea. But other than that spot on.

[@ethankral3215]

yea i get the first one about it being dumb to not allow players to have secondary pistols, because in the end its just a game. Thanks for telling me the other info though!

[@JackClockerinos]

Your welcome man. You should do the same for BF1, which I have much more experience in. I'd love to help you out on that one.

[@JackClockerinos]

Also, the Thompson in the game is not actually a specific model of Thompson, but an amalgamation of both the M1927 (which it is named after) and the M1A1. so technically, the drum magazine is still accurate since you could just say that any Thompson used with a drum mag is an M1927, but it still uses the model of the M1A1. With the 1903 scope stripper clip feed, apparently you can use stripper clips with that scope, you just have to put the clip at a really awkward angle that would take time and definitely would not have been employed in the heat of battle. The Johnson rifle that you are thinking of is not the same one as in the game. The game's version may have the name of the 1941 10-round semi-rifle, but the game's version is actually a 1944 version that was made to be an LMG that held 20 rounds. With the PPSH, you could argue that the person loading the magazine simply just loaded only half of the bullets into the magazine. MP-28 was used as a backup weapon by Volksturm units during the last years of the war, same with the previously-mentioned MG-15. It was also in use by police units and Japanese forces a little. You could argue that the Type 100 is a souvenir from an American soldiers transferred from the Pacific front. Also, fictitious names for the SMLE and Mp-28 should not get a mention, as copyright issues and other such things are often the reason they exist, and not for any historical laziness. Same thing with BF1 calling the Beretta 1918 the Automatico in order not to get in a tizzy with the Beretta company.

[@ryanhamdyl2692]

Nathe Lark another thing is that the British used their Piats rather than Bazooka M1A1

[@ryanhamdyl2692]

Nathe Lark and the only female that served in WW2 was i believe the French Resistance but not US army

[@thomasxqr5226]

99% historical accouarcy. First mission in campaign is D-Day and when you kill german solider u can see him drop PPSH-41... Nice shg...

[@michaelfoster9296]

SomeRandnomForeigner That's actually not inaccurate. Lots of Axis defenders on those beaches were Ostruppen using captured Soviet weapons. The PPSH under German designation was known as the MP41r. It was widely used by German soldiers and Ostruppen because it could fire german manufactured 9mm rounds used by the MP40 and MP34

[@michaelfoster9296]

*MP28

[@thomasxqr5226]

Diego Claudio Sergio but that looks like in Russia.

[@carlopulanco183]

SomeRandnomForeigner Yes it is in the Eastern Front, but the defending Wehrmacht battalioms in Normandy were Eastern Europeans, most of them were armed with Soviet weapons, re calibrated to fire 9mm ammunation. It was actually very common to arm them with captured Soviet weapons, since most of the German arsenals werr given to German Wehrmacht battalions, while the Eastern European Wehrmacht battalions were given those captured weapons. There was even this weird shit in Normandy where a Korean guy who fought with the Japanese Army, then for the Soviet Union and then in the Eastern European Wehrmacht battalion where he was finally captured in Utah beach by US forces

[@kazoolordhd6591]

im sure that making new barrels and bolts and magazines and mag wells to shoot 9mm was a common thing. on the ostfront germans used ppsh 41's ect because they worked better in the cold conditions and there was ammo when the germans couldnt get supplies

[@lorenzogironi7593]

Am i the only one who noticed that most of if the mistakes were due to him selecting the equipment

[@motorsphere356]

Still shouldn't be in the game

[@bulletsandmilk1985]

@@motorsphere356 If there were only historically accurate guns in this game there wouldn’t be many guns. And that would be boring.

[@motorsphere356]

@@bulletsandmilk1985 Nothing wrong with having rare guns as all sorts were used in ww2 but its the modifications which are the problem. Get your modern warfare out of my ww2

[@dablux3892]

This was all pre-release footage, hence the message at the end where he clearly states he doesn't have the game

[@dashikashi4734]

@@motorsphere356 Lmao go play Post Scriptum then

[@ProudCascadianPilot]

Cod WW2 is not historicaly correct. Its politicaly correct. Edit: BFV is even more polit. Correct than cod.

[@ulisesr614]

Until I'm allowed to play as a transgender, nonbinary, pansexual, German character, this game is not politically correct!

[@videomaker1326]

Not as politically correct as Battlefield V

[@ulisesr614]

@@videomaker1326 Amen brotha! Even the Nazis are transgender jews over in Battlefield V!

[@patrickmacready1779]

Oh my god I found another enclave member, hello my brother

[@videomaker1326]

Hello

[@AndyGuyCantYouLiftForLife]

Heres a little story. My grandfather carried the BAR during ww2. He was young and hated the weight of the weapon. At some point, he put it down in favor of a german stg 44. Everyone around him chewed his ass due to one fact:If you fire it off, every allied will shoot back due to the distinct sound. Now apply that to every axis weapon. At no point would an allied soldier have any axis weapons unless its like a keeper after war.

[@aarontheperson6867]

Nice story lol. Pretty cool dude.

[@somerandomguy5995]

AaronThePerson Yes, very true, not only that, but the ammunition for captured arms were very hard to come by because they used different caliber weapons.

[@angle7765]

Did everyone calp after that?

[@KUCHIS1]

Stg was used by the Soviets

[@AndyGuyCantYouLiftForLife]

Buddy 441 Definitely not. The stg 44 was manufactured by the Germans for a lower cost so they could still have a high powered weapon while not breaking the bank even more.

[@CactusCacti2000]

no soviets in the game?! BLYAAATTTT

[@laynebonham3968]

J C soviet underground for the infantry

[@thorhaveron]

A R E Y O U A N D R E W M A Y S M Y M A N

[@CactusCacti2000]

im born in Georgia but i live in russia now (in penza) penza = city

[@rebelRed_]

*Western Front*

[@Vladimir-xr2qz]

БЛИН

[@198thairsoft]

1:34 I’m not defending this crappy game, but marines in Guadalcanal did use the drum mag. 5:27 Also, the guy with the weird gas mask is a French medic, not a US soldier.

[@ycgoh603]

The gun is an M1A1, which can't accept drum mags. For some reason they modeled the gun after an M1A1 but used the M1928 name.

[@theluiginoidperson1097]

@@ycgoh603 That is correct. The M1A1 literally just cannot accept those under any circumstance.

[@foxtrotsierraproductions8626]

@@ycgoh603 copyright

[@ycgoh603]

@@foxtrotsierraproductions8626 ??????????

[@Sweatedsiren895]

@@foxtrotsierraproductions8626 does the manufacture company of the Thompson still exits today?

[@marcyweiss9107]

At the end with that gas mask, there's a little mistake. The Expeditionary Uniform is actually a French Medic Uniform, which explains why the gasmask was different than the US Army Gasmasks.

[@mmorvi]

The Gas Mask is the model of French TC38

[@KWyzel]

Doesn't matter. Any French units under US/British command at this point of the war would not be using home produced French equipment but rather US and British equipment due to France Falling in 1940. Given that the campaign focuses on D-Day which happened in 1944, the French equipment in game would literally be the same as US Infantry equipment, with MAYBE a rare French helmet or rifle.

[@ryancook6452]

The tc38 was not a good mask and was mainly issued to new recruits. The design had it's routes in the first world war and was not as popular as the American masks being given to them post d day, mainly old mask m1 and m2s which have a lower breathing resistance and a wider field of view. They were less prone to leak as the cellofilm lenses on the tc38 wore out in sunlight and became brittle. Also, the mask being worn appears to be the "civilian" tc38 with the smaller diameter filter intake.

[@Poetry4Peace]

Last ones ignorant as fuck, sheesh hate ppl tryna put down a game n get fax wrong!!? 6*/5*4/4/4

[@shiva3549]

Imagine how pissed this guys team is. They're barely scraping by while he's shooting off snipers at the wall in the back of the map

[@peepuschrist5670]

bots exist

[@vizionpsbo8105]

its the shooting range

[@shiva3549]

Vizion PSBO like halfway through tho watch the video

[@mom0367]

It's even better he he said he "would buy the game" even though he owns it in the vid

[@maxkosterlitzky6597]

Why isn't this video 3 hours long

[@michaelroblesmedia]

Because I'm sure the mistakes you would like to point out simply aren't possible to implement into a video game....

[@birdissmall2677]

Entity File why can’t I feel pain when the guy gets shot, why can’t i go through the training the guy did to fight in the army, how come I can’t climb things and go out of the map, 0/10 IGN not enough pain.

[@maxkosterlitzky6597]

Ya but alot of this is just pure laziness

[@michaelroblesmedia]

Max Kosterlitzky it’s not lazy it’s just not possible to do with the team side they have and the time restraint they have

[@lazydonkey3617]

The campaign doesn’t seem right... I think it’s the fact that you simply can’t die

[@Ghost-pq8td]

I like how he didn't question the BAR with a bayonet

[@sargentfoxy155]

5:06 you forgot to mention that the Lee Enfield takes 2 stripper clips for 10 rounds not 1

[@cameronchristian309]

Sargent Foxy also the clip can be removed

[@foxtrotsierraproductions8626]

Even CoD 1 did that right

[@applebl3ach]

Call of Duty: Western Front

[@bigbengamer]

Call of Duty: We Forgot How The Franchise Began

[@Lemon_man69]

Call of duty: the eastern front never happened

[@peaznouhh]

Call of duty:Fictional War II

[@brobruh7850]

Call of Duty: what even is the pacific ocean lol

[@n0kt0h45]

Call of Duty: No, Japan and Italy Don't Exist

[@sheacorduroy5565]

Forgive the uber-rare German Pistol. Black Ops 1 had the China Lake. Only 20 or so of those were ever made. I agree with everything else though.

[@crazyafrican9955]

Viktor Arvidsson and the G11 , spectre SMG that wasn't even invented

[@nicholassternon5857]

Viktor Arvidsson yeah but black ops definitely wasn’t going for historical accuracy tho

[@sheacorduroy5565]

Jerome derp And yet the game felt more real than WW2.

[@busbear6899]

Viktor Arvidsson at least was fun

[@darrengarcia4937]

Afrikaner boerseun tj He g11 existed it was an advanced bullpup rifle

[@CoreRealm]

4:17 Actually this is the LMG version so it actually holds 20 rounds not 10 The 10 round is for the Johnson rifle theres a big difference here

[@user-ou3lu6oz8r]

5:25 : when you order something online 5:29 : when it arrives

[@niulagoo]

Black Shadøw no when u order from wish

[@wolfgangcloutcapo675]

@@niulagoo when you order from eBay

[@presidentofidiots520]

When you order from MOMM

[@jonathonalvarez6058]

Black Shadøw close enough lol.

[@meidlakenejajaanusekene3000]

XD!

[@newtclovers]

"Of course none of these imperfections will affect how the game will be ...and I will still buy it" Wish more people realized this, lol

[@truck965]

Sharky_ your opinion

[@gipt995]

Sharky_ game was still shit though

[@kauaoliveira989]

not his opinion, you didn't even watched until the end, did you?

[@gipt995]

Kauã Matheus Oliveira Uzeika no, I'm just talking generally.

[@variations-]

Gipt the game isn't shit

[@diabolicespurr]

i wouldnt call the M30 Drilling a Incorrection when its sole purpose was used if Luftwaffe Pilots were shot down (which happened quite a bit)

[@griggs8345]

I think the inaccuracy for him is it being on basic infantry.

[@kommandanthanz8346]

@@griggs8345 Yes. German Army hated shotguns since WW1. The M30 Drilling was supposed to be a hunting shotgun and in this case, was issued to Luftwaffe pilots as a survival weapon in case of surviving a crash

[@NiCoNiCoNiCola]

@@kommandanthanz8346 what would the pilots use when they would be attacked by other soldiers then?

[@FBIAGENT725]

@@NiCoNiCoNiCola they all had pistols and besides, a 9.3×74mmR against people? Jesus Christ

[@declangaming24]

@@NiCoNiCoNiCola German pilots where often issued with the M30 Drilling and a P38 pistol so you had 3 types of ammo 12G shells the rifle bullet for the shotgun and the 9MM for the P38.

[@TheWhitestMan]

I could've sworn I saw the Grim Reaper with a watermelon camo on his gun in a recent lobby. Must've been part of the whole, "Historical Accuracy".

[@colemanchristy2770]

2:24 Arial is a font, aerial means in the air.

[@coltonbush6040]

Coleman Christy umm did you never hear of the great font wars

[@printix9496]

Typo mistake?

[@tikunhiplaaja631]

The eastern font.

[@core2cascade]

Coleman Christy hey look a dictionary can you find the definition of sarcastic?

[@Mit852]

MG-15 was used by ground forces as well. They were adapted for infantry use by addition of stock and bipod as they were phased out of air service when the MG 81 ,MG131, and other heavier guns replaced the MG15 in air service.

[@michaelt9443]

4:18 the M1941 LMG had a detachable magazine. I’m guessing you’re thinking of the M1941 Johnson rifle, which did have a rotary magazine

[@heckler3119]

One major incorrect feature of the Lee Enfield: Its the No.4 Mk. 1 T that somehow uses a single 5 round clip to reload a ten shot magazine past an optic at a .45 degree angle. And the fact the cocking piece turns with the bolt is just horrible. Its meant to cam and stay back when opening and closing, hence it being a 'cock on close' rifle.

[@peanutbutterboi8489]

One correction the Lee Enfield in the game is the SMLE pattern rifle (short magazine Lee Enfield) but all else is right

[@heckler3119]

thesourpatchkid27 *Facepalm* No. It isn't. The only rifle with the designation SMLE is the No.1 Mk.1 and the Mk.3. Don't try to be an expert where you aren't.

[@personwithmemes5454]

HecklerRommel i noticed that too but eh

[@imasnekkkk6073]

Heckler it's a game chill

[@core2cascade]

I’d still buy it...

[@AvidAmericanJingoist]

4:11 I love how his teammate came to check out if he was ok

[@ai8788]

Lmao

[@rossy1339]

The M1911 was issued to Infantry as well as officers and pilots/tank operators

[@leamas1210]

NCOs maybe but i don't think infantry has ever been issued a sidearm other than security/MPs/etc unless you can provide proof ofc

[@toddanderson3449]

Are you guys high? The 1911 was standard issue up until 1986.

[@leamas1210]

@@Nick-bu2kp that's just straight up not true

[@Nick-bu2kp]

Leamas prove it then

[@leamas1210]

@@Nick-bu2kp ok www.armyheritage.org/images/stories/Ready_for_Battle_-_World_War_II.pdf "Due to the high demand for pistols at the beginning of World War II the Army reissued M1917 Coltand Smith and Wesson Revolvers to rear echelon troops including prison guards and military police. Revolvers were replaced by the M1911 automatic pistol as they became available. " "Due to the high demand for pistols at the beginning of World War II the Army reissued M1917 Colt and Smith and Wesson Revolvers to rear echelon troops including prison guards and military police. Revolvers were replaced by the M1911 automatic pistol as they became available. The Smith &Wesson Model 10revolver was produced for the government from 1940 to 1945 with a ―V‖ prefix in front of the serial number, primarily for use by aircraft crews" all branches of the military were issued 1911s, not all infantrymen. they were reserved for specialised troops

[@Rodach34]

You left out the fact that the fire rates are wrong

[@LandonChaoOfficial]

Eric Cartmam If the PPSH and the MP28 could trade fire rates, I’d be satisfied

[@samueljespersen8976]

Yeah, the mg 42 shoots 1200 rounds per minute irl but In cod it feels like half of that

[@idontwantaname9750]

They have to try to make the game balanced.

[@yannickhacking6370]

Samuel Jespersen why? O yea, dying in 0.01 second isn't balanced for a multiplayer shooter.

[@norwegianboyee]

Play Red Orchestra 2 and you'll see that games can both be historically accurate and fun. No need for this "IT'S EITHER HISTORICALLY ACCURATE AND BORING OR FAKE AND FUN!" bullshit.

[@michaeltefft3260]

The m1 garand did need to be "bumped" sometimes even when clean

[@aprilwang3562]

Ok but in this game it’s every time

[@MadConMan]

Actually if you look at the training films you can see how is army loaded it and they bumped it most of the time the automatic chamber is what is probably from wear

[@freeziboi3249]

@@MadConMan yeah that sounds far more likely, like maybe bumping it ends up breaking the catch mechanism for the bolt

[@MadConMan]

@@freeziboi3249 but there's is always more to it every gun is different

[@Jonathanfrost2231]

Later iterations of the M1 Garand had a modification that kept the bolt open in order to prevent Garand thumb. Even with training, in the middle of battle Garand thumb still happened.

[@Mate-vg2ft]

With the "Commonwealth" rifle you didn't realize that he loads a whole clip into the magazine even if you don't empty the rifle.

[@Mate-vg2ft]

Joel time stamp please?

[@Mate-vg2ft]

Joel different rifle but same error so yeah, guess I'm an inattentive dumbass

[@stevenyarnell]

Also, the KZbinr didn't realize that the sniper rifle used in level ''Battle of the Bulge'' is the incorrect type! Daniels is an American, not a Britain.

[@EdgarMorrisandTheDead]

When they talked about historic accuracy they where talking about the campaign

[@KomradeDoge]

Oh don't you worry there were a few headscratchers for the WW2 history nuts there too. lol

[@motorsphere356]

Campaign was still inaccurate

[@brady9618]

The campaign wasn’t accurate

[@regularperson5647]

the campaign was a load of hollywood style bullshit that made cod: world at war ashamed to exist in the same universe as that 2017 cancer

[@soldierstudios7316]

You could get PPSH-40s in the campaign which first of all were not really used by Germans, only if a German soldier lost his weapon and needed a weapon to temporary replace it until got another German weapon with plenty of ammo for it. Second, the PPSH-40 is a Russian weapon and who in their right mind would transport a PPSH-40s across Europe to France and don't even have much ammo for it since its Russian the caliber was different and was never made by German factories.

[@ABC-in2le]

0:39 i watched the hickock45 video on “How to not load an M1 Garand” and he had to push the thing after reloading the clip

[@aidenwhitaker7941]

When you fire the last cartridge the magazine follower will hold the bolt open. Then you can either press the clip in and it will close when you pull your thumb away (be wary of garand thumb) or you can pull it back to the second stop, push the clip in and tap the handle forward.

[@caseymoonman7574]

DogSubZero same

[@smokestack534]

wow dude no way but have you stopped to consider that its a game and not a weapons guide and hardly anyone cares about a 3 second animation

[@christianh4723]

Criticizing a COD game for historical inaccuracies is probably one of the most pointless things anybody could do. Also, "incorrections" is not the proper word to use here.

[@risensoldier9386]

CoDmaster 7000 The age of the firearm wouldn’t make a difference if it’s kept in peak condition which, I’m sure someone like Hickock45 would do. The game simply used that reload animation because it was easier for the motion capture team.

[@canadapwns886]

The thing about the gas mask is that the default Expeditionary guy is French, not American.

[@cruz21pasionz80]

I like Asian girls not only that but the gas mask don't do s*** anyway in the game XD Its on their for show !! Lmao

[@Vantor01]

And the LMG man is british

[@ramona4869]

Yeah I agree with both you

[@lazyboy395]

I think I found a couple issues with you finding issues. 1: even well maintained m1s required a bump to the op rod to chamber rounds due to wear and tear on the single spring inside. 2: bazookas were commonly issued to two man teams, but there is army doctrine and precedent for singular usage. 3: the 1941 Johnson rifle and Johnson LMG are two different guns altogether, one using a box mag and the other a fixed rotary mag, but overall the same concept, and both were used in the pacific. 4: trench guns were not common issue, but the Marine Corps often made use of old guns such as the Springfield and M1897 due to lack of priority and funds compared to the army. Its also worth noting the springfield sniper shown resembles the marine variant.

[@maxmusterman6001]

2:01 in realife the plate mag of the lewis lmg is not spinning around like a freakin fidjetspinner

[@strling111]

it sure the fuck is, that's how the damn gun works. the magazine is wound, loaded, then unwound as it fires. That's the fundamental workings of the lewis gun.

[@maxmusterman6001]

Josh Bruns but if u look u see that its spinnig around like a fidjetspinner in real life its spinn every 2 or 3 shoots

[@maxmusterman6001]

Justin King this is what i want to say thanks

[@geoffkeighleysleftshoe3839]

Josh Bruns it really shouldn't be spinning like that, if you look at real life footage of firing a lewis gun, it barley spins, cod WW2 got the lewis gun very wrong, and if im not mistaken the fire rate is off aswell

[@castle9165]

Max Musterman mg15s ware used by sas during some of Britain’s most swag operations.

[@Thenumber360master]

The main things you pointed out were issues with class setups not necessarily incorrect aspects of history just the way a certain class was setup.🤔

[@KWyzel]

Yes but these "Classes" didn't exist in WWII, there is a reason the phrase "Standard Issue" exists. Standard Issue equipment made production easier, and streamlined and this game doesn't represent that in any capacity with all these incorrect weapons and equipment on various "Classes" yes it is just a game but that's no excuse because plenty of other games have made realistic recreations of WW2 combat and still made them rather fun.

[@ceoofbusiness8511]

You have a great point. A lot of these are pretty much saying the game is wrong for having customization?

[@ET-Gamer]

Jimmy Johns Juicy Dong Historically yes, look at the game Red Orchestra 2, a game with nearly double the classes this game has as well as tanks with fully functioning crews (one player for each crew member slot) and see how they accurately have each class setup to have completely different roles whilst using historically accurate weapons and gear. The fundamentals off this games design are the issue.

[@ceoofbusiness8511]

ET Gamer while this is true, it’s not a better excuse. They are two different games that flow and play completely different. You don’t play cod for the same reason you play red orchestra. Ones a fast paced arcade shooter and the others a tactical strategy shooter. While I PREFER those more historical accurate games I understand some people prefer to play with the weapons they like regardless of team/side.

[@tavisnettleingham693]

Comrade Kommodore good luck playing a cod with what 12 standard issue guns and no attachments because they aren’t historically correct

[@xyxser63]

this game needs Soviet

[@xyxser63]

Panzermann11 Thats not soviet, its just a map

[@xyxser63]

Panzermann11 Thats American

[@xyxser63]

Panzermann11 Lol

[@5thfjreenactor602]

XYXSER no it doesn’t

[@dillonc7955]

XYXSER They have just 1 map dedicated to them, plus an event week where you can unlock Soviet soldier apparel. Otherwise I agree entirely that this game does need more factions represented.

[@dolch8253]

5:28 because its a franch mask

[@mako_happy]

Franch

[@Sabmerk]

The gas mask is a french on, therefore it is actually accurate

[@logankim7743]

yeah, but the french are never actually included or mentioned anywhere in the game

[@Sabmerk]

Logan Kim incorrect. the default expeditionary uniform is called French medic.

[@logankim7743]

Oh ok then. Thanks for correcting me.

[@Sheridan2LT]

lol k nerd

[@frankiebambie8425]

Lad you are a legend not once but twice made the logan Kim guy sound like a idiot and dam I have to give it to you for the actual history you know I applaud you my good sir 👏

[@ugandanknuckles9595]

This is pretty spot on, but the 1911 was in fact used in large numbers and was the service pistol at the time, so it was in no way rare. However, it definitely did not have an extended mag. Also, the Lewis Gun was still used in WW2, although in much smaller numbers than in WW1, and was mostly replaced by the Bren, but was still in use by the British. The Winchester 1887 was still in use as well. Otherwise, like I said, pretty spot on. A few of the things here can be excused by saying "Oh, it's for gameplay reasons", but with stuff like the M1 Garand reload and the 7 round clip on the Kar98K, it truly shows how little they cared about the authenticity of this game.

[@monke6776]

Comrade...?

[@Giggoer1998]

Иосиф Сталин it was only given to officers and pilots

[@ryanmclaughlin9041]

Иосиф Сталин there also was a toggle action shotgun with a round 4-shell capacity called the walther toggle action

[@jfangm]

Иосиф Сталин Actually, the M1 Garand was returned to battery by RELEASING the bolt, which would have been held back with one hand to prevent "Garand Thumb," however pushing the bolt forward was also done. I refer you to Forgotten Weapons for more information.

[@adriansaavedra950]

Иосиф Сталин, if pistols were issued to every soldier, than explain to me the massive phenomenon of photos showing only NCO’s and high ranking officers in the field, as well as machine gunners carrying a sidearm.

[@fishfashfosh]

M1's bolt doesn't slam forward all the time, dirty or not. Either you didn't push the clip all the way in during intense combat, or the spring is worn and needs extra friction. Also, Lewis gun went back into production after the brits lost most of their equipment during the evacuation. But they would never bring a skeleton lewis gun into combat lol. You need to clear the chamber before putting a new mag into the b.a.r when it's empty. Trying to find accuracy in this game is like finding clean and new books in a town library

[@viperish6103]

Yes, but the bolt was very sensitive so it was kinda rare for the bolt to not close automatically but you are right

[@mattshap9731]

In a week old town library, that is. The m1 bolt failure would be equivalent to playing a Vietnam game and every 5 shots with an m16 you would have to manually clear the chamber. Yes, it happened, but it wasn’t standard or intended function. Giving players the lewis gun would still be rarer than a bren, considering production and the fact that they were used only when a bren was not available, and a unit could submit an equipment acquisition request if they wanted their lewis updated to a bren, it just took time and wasn’t always accepted. Edit: reading the original comment again, I misread “accurate” as “inaccurate”

[@callofdutyloser6758]

Matt Shap Also technically the BAR was not an "assault" rifle. The BAR was used as a supressive weapon, much like the Bren. The BAR (IMO) is similar to the magazine fed Stoner 63, which is classified as an LMG.

[@prophethaze]

Matt Shap does the stoner 63 smoke a lot

[@strling111]

Actually, it works more accurately, conversely. The sears and locking lugs are a little tight on a shiny Garand. In it's first few (and I mean quite a few) loads, it will not send itself home at all. You WILL have to send it forward. It only sends itself forward if you don't take care of it or it's actually been through hell.

[@snowfall5171]

The MP28 was used pretty much exclusively by German police and paramilitary units, it would have probably never seen combat outside of small engagements with resistance groups if even.

[@frankrichter1634]

Cough cough ss verfügungstruppen had mp 28s

[@KomradeDoge]

@@frankrichter1634 Basically the entire German Army had Mp-28s through the whole war. The SS had the most because they were supposed to be the elite troops so they were given the best stuff early war. Many sturm troops also had it for similar reasons. The MP-40 wasn't created until 1940 so they had to all use SOMETHING. lol

[@frankrichter1634]

@@KomradeDoge yeah exactly i mean there was the MP 38 too some mp 35s and such ^^

[@choiettech]

It probably was more used in Japan and China considering the Type 100 wouldn't come into production until 1944.

[@Sweatedsiren895]

@@choiettech type 100 come out in 1940 , 1944 one is 100/44

[@beast0339]

2:26 yes and no. There was a huge stockpile of surplus MG15s from scrapped airplanes and what the Germans did was convert it for ground use as a last resort machine gun (It saw limited use) the MG15 in game although goofy looking. Is actually pretty authentic to the normal MG15 conversion

[@LandonChaoOfficial]

CasualGamer MG15 are always mounted due to the caliber and rate of fire....overall you’re spot on

[@beast0339]

Landon Chao Cheees! I guess watching Forgotten Weapons really paid off :D

[@ashipnerdoffical4260]

Technically, the mg-15 was used as an infantry machine gun at the end of the war due to shortages on the mg34 and 42. Most of the airforce was gone at that point, and they had a lot of them not being used. The vacuum had to be filled somehow.

[@meykiegrandpa5630]

This is not correct. There are only some hist. pics of some SdKfz.251 MTW' with triple mounts of the MK151 MK airial gun as a stopgap for an AA weapon against the fighterbomber plague for this MTW. In some emergency cases airial gunners of grounded JU-87, JU-88 and ME-110 planes outboarded their guns for using them to defend their airfields or as part of the so called Luftwaffefelddivision. Here, the shortage of fuel has grounded the planes and their crews were used as Infantry and the airial gunners grapped their guns and ammo for groundfighting. Regular german infantry never used the MG15 as a MG.

[@ashipnerdoffical4260]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/iKTEen2qp5ane7s Check this out.

[@grandpapybubba5346]

RONG

[@ashipnerdoffical4260]

@@grandpapybubba5346 Lol. It's WRONG not RONG. XD

[@the_real_Kurt_Yarish]

From what I recall, the M1941 wasn't "quickly rejected" for being "unreliable" but rather was issued to a few (some number less than four) battalions as a sort of "field test" and then never formerly adopted due to the US military already having weapons that fit it's intended role equally well. The involved Marines in the Pacific Theater even fancied the gun, leading to them using it for quite some time after the testing officially ended. In any case; Melvin Johnson Jr., the gun's designer, was one of the most innovative gun designers of the time, and was later on directly involved in the development of the AR-15, a weapon who's derivatives the US Military still uses to this day as the standard troop's firearm. In fact, the AR-15's bolt design was based off of Johnson's earlier rifles' bolt designs, including the M1941's. The weapon, while being a bit awkward to lug around, was functioning and more than reasonably reliable for the conditions it was in. Saying the Army and Marines rejected it for being "unreliable", when their alternative was the BAR, is disingenuous at best. P.S. Your "incorrection" about the gun not having a 25 round box magazine; and instead it should have a 10 round rotary magazine, is in itself incorrect. You were thinking of the M1941 Johnson Rifle, while the weapon portrayed in the game is an M1941 Johnson Light Machine Gun. Two very different firearms, which not only don't operate the same, but don't even look similar what-so-ever. Kinda goes to show that you went the "bare - minimum" route when it came to researching this video.

[@foxspirit1755]

Melvin Johnson preferred to call it an Automatic Rifle instead of Light Machine Gun. Internally the Johnson Automatic Rifle and Johnson Rifle do function in almost the same way. The main difference to the internals is the addition of a sear and a few other pieces to make the action automatic. The fire selector of the Automatic Rifle had three positions which were automatic, semi-automatic, and safe. Changing to automatic pushed the semi-automatic catch out of the way of the bolt carrier as well as releasing the hammer when the bolt is in battery. In automatic the bolt and bolt carrier are held to the rear of the action making it an open bolt gun. In semi-auto the carrier and bolt stays at the front of the action and fires as a closed bolt. Changing from full- auto to semi-auto would release the carrier and bolt letting it lock into the barrel. The Automatic Rifle retained the internal rotary magazine which could hold 5 more rounds that would feed into the action. It usually came with a 20 round detachable box magazine, but 30 round magazines also existed. The internal magazine meant that 5 more could be added to the 20 in the magazine by use of stripper clip or putting the rounds in one at a time. In the game the magazine looks shorter than it should be. I would say that the magazine appears to be about half the size it should be for a 20 round magazine. The gun was liked because the barrel could be removed making it more compact for use when parachuting. It was also lighter than the alternative. Because most of war is not actually shooting people. It had a bipod but that was usually thrown out. One advantage of having the magazine on the side is that the gun could be fired prone much easier than the BAR. The Marines really wanted to adopt it but having a different gun from the Army would make logistics even harder. Since the Automatic Rifle is so closely based on the Rifle it had about the same reliability. The Rifle was pitted against the M1 Garand and the result was neither was better than the other. The main reason it wasn't adopted was because they were already in the process of fully adopting the M1 Garand. Another reason might have to do with the functioning of the Rifles. It used short recoil which meant that the barrel moves back and forth. This is a problem when you want to use a bayonet because the extra weight could affect its reliability. Melvin Johnson did create a bayonet but it was a simple spike. He did later make improvements such as a mono pod which made barrel changes easier. He also changed the stock and added a catch to prevent the bolt from bouncing out of battery. He also added a gas assist to the barrel to make it more reliable in adverse conditions. In game the sight hole is also much larger but that I would say is for game-play reasons. Although I'm pretty sure the wrong sight hole is used. I believe the top is for volley fire while the bottom is the normal sight.

[@YouTubeViolates1A]

Kurt Yarish Really?! I heard it jammed 24/7, and it was an overall shit gun. Maybe soldiers liked it, I like my uglies too though. I like guns that look thrown together like the Sten, M1941 even, FG42, Bren, Type 100, and a few others, but that gun really was shit. Vietnam M16 kinda shit. They probably only enjoyed the way it looked honestly. Haha! Plus, it was called an MG I believe, and for an MG, that fucker would be light at the time.

[@BloodDragon592]

It was also looked at being used for the airborne as it was much lighter than said B.A.R so it could be used as a LMG and take the B.A.R role and also be used as a rifle/AR.

[@derpyderpy2923]

Kurt Yarish its just a game chill

[@trevillyan5515]

The m1941 Johnson saw widespread service with Marines in the Pacific theater only

[@acv6224]

The M1911 was actually sometimes issued to NCOs as well, and Infantry could sometimes purchase them

[@ptsm]

*A incorrection I saw was that you said you were going to buy the hunk of junk*

[@Wabbaaajack]

Pootis Mun *a incorrection*

[@ImJustFynn]

*AN INCORRECTION I FOUND OUT WAS THAT YOU WERE BORN, BITCH*

[@ripplycreature6678]

Fizzy_ Cooki Oh wow such an original insult. Great job. You figured out that the internet exists.

[@danielflanard8274]

Ripply Creature Now that's an insult

[@ImJustFynn]

Ripply Creature Yep, of course, just like him, you don't know what good content is, you *FUCKING 9 YEAR OLD EXO JUMPING SHIT EATING BITCH*

[@freakinguy4588]

5:16 Sledgehammer laziness confirmed?

[@hunterkiller4578]

Freakin Guy45 yes

[@adxo]

it would take more time to load the rounds individually

[@CloudRollerFox]

Ádám Strasszer they just think that putting stripper clips would make it look cool and badass when it would really just ruin the way a gun actually works. If it were up to DICE or any other publisher who have made boots on the ground shooters, they would fix so much in this game, like instead of reloading snipers with strip clips at impossible angles because of the big scope, they would have your character reload one shot at a time, like in world at war

[@adxo]

Cloud Roller yes

[@kingbeezo]

Ádám Strasszer In waw they didn’t do strip clips but you just loaded it quickly

[@xaviertrujillo506]

you said that the toggle action is a browning auto 5 when it is actually a walther automatic shotgun

[@ricocheval3258]

Not to mention that that 1911 magazine is for a 38 super

[@randomthingz2showrandomthi208]

Lol,call of duty 1 from 2003 got most of these correct.

[@UnforgivenM4]

Randomthingz2show Randomthingz2show cough cough early 2000's banking on popular war movies and miniseries cough cough

[@ET-Gamer]

Some things in here seem to be misleading or untrue. The MG-34 wasn’t just used in air combat (though it was the standard issue machine gun for bomber gunners and such) it was the main machine gun used by infantry early in the war and was later replaced by the MG-42 as an infantry weapon. The MG-34 was still in service along side it’s replacement till the end of the war and was used on most German AFV’s. The M1928 model Thompson submachine gun, at least to my knowledge did see short lived use of its drum magazines early on such as at Guadalcanal and (though I’m not 100% sure about that being true) but was completely opted out for being too loud and cumbersome. Also prior to the U.S. joining the war many M1928 Thompson’s were given to Britain as apart of lend lease for military use and some testing (later to be replaced by the Sten Mk 2) and can be seen with its drum magazine in some photos. The drum magazine being used is mostly a myth from Hollywood propaganda films during and after the war (as well as other films and media). You missed a point about some of the weapons fire rates being either unrealistic or improbable such as with the M1911, Lewis gun, Thompson. The whole Lee-Enfield point looks to have made people even more confused than anything, so here’s the run down on it. The Lee-Enfield is simply named after the man who partly designed it and it’s manufacturer. The “Lee” comes from James Paris Lee who designed the bolt system that is used in the Lee-Enfield rifle as well as its predecessor the Lee-Metford rifle (William Ellis Metford). The “Enfield” comes from RSAF (Royal Small Arms Factory) which was located London Borough of Enfield. People seem to think that the model number is the proper way of saying its name. Which is more accurate but not necessary for most discussions like this video. You have the different variants of Lee-Enfield and then their model, then their Mark designation. There’s a lot of different types of rifles in that most of which are fundamentally if not quite literally the same rifles out of 17 million built. Just calling a Lee-Enfield No 4 Mk II (also a short magazine), and an SMLE No 1 Mk III both Lee-Enfield’s isn’t incorrect. The M1917 did see some use in the pacific and with combat engineers to some degree. Also they can’t hold 10 fucking rounds Sledgehammer. The Johnson Machine gun did have 20-round single stack box magazines. Not 10-round rotary magazines. As for its service life it’s a bit interesting and I suggest reading up on it yourself. The Lewis guns magazine is rotating far too much, the M1 Garand reload should be cutting of the characters thumb, as for all the class incorrections, well this isn’t Red Orchestra 2 it’s the sad shallow just of a once great franchise called Call of Duty which has now even forgotten its namesake. Aside from that seems like you got most of it right anyways so good video.

[@ZwizuCS]

You do know it's not the MG-34 right? It's the MG-15....

[@fruitella196]

Oh hey i recognise you from phly

[@anthonyvos3795]

Late ass reply, but you're right on everything except the MG 34 part. In game the LMG being used is the MG 15 and NOT the MG 34. The MG 15 was normally used on German Airplanes, but was sometimes converted for infantry use as a makeshift last ditch LMG late in the war. (Also nice Pacific reference)

[@theblazingpegasus9151]

ET Gamer Idk how to tell you this but its the mg 15 he was showing and talking about not the mg 34

[@bomyers5345]

4:15 the Johnson 1941 light machine gun had a 20 round box mag and a 5 round rotary mag. The Johnson 1941 rifle had a 10 round rotary mag

[@Nyx4A2]

A lot of these "inaccuracies" stem from the fact that the create a class system (which has been a core aspect of the multiplayer experience since at least Modern Warfare) is a thing that exists and it shouldn't because it's "inaccurate" in a game wherein you constantly resurrect, get promoted every couple of skirmishes. You might as well have also said "soldiers didn't need a prerequisite number of points/kills to call in support" or "soldiers didn't have the means to know the layout of an entire area as a sort of sixth sense map in their hear whilst being able to precisely pinpoint where every single shot they hear comes from"... other than that though yeah you were pretty much spot on barring the M1 Garand and the Gas Mask (and weapon attachments but... y'know... core game mechanic)

[@jasonbarrios2229]

Savas Atesoglu also I was looking forward to the incorrections based on single player (campaign) as that was suppose to be historically accurate and not multiplayer

[@FLOODEDxOUT]

I was getting confused when he was talking about “US Soldiers were never deployed with German pistols” it’s like wtf are you talking about you selected that for your class 💀

[@theblazingpegasus9151]

That and the devs said the campaign was the part that was historically accurate and the multiplayer was gonna focus on fun and not accuracy

[@DarkSpartanFTW]

Ferret Master24 The thing is, I personally don’t care much for the historical inaccuracies. I’d have more of a problem if they put some of the accuracies in the game. The action of the game would be dulled in service of history. History is obviously important but it should be taken lightly if it gets in the way of the fun gameplay. Battlefield 1 did this perfectly. BF1 was largely accurate, but it changed mechanics to make the game more fun. Quickly reloading the M1 is in service to the gun’s effectivity in gameplay. If they made the reload slightly longer, the gun would be worse in the meta. A bazooka as a sidearm is a COD staple, and since rocket launchers are fun to use, why not let the player use them? The Thompson’s circular mag is in service to the cool gangsters of the past, so why not put it in if it’s not fun? The only argument that makes sense is the player’s ability to change the gender and ethnicity of the soldier. It’s really, really awkward for a WWII game, but it really doesn’t change much of anything in terms gameplay. Fighting them isn’t really immersion breaking either since COD’s fast gameplay overshadows that fact and the player will probably just gloss over it without a problem.

[@lucasfreitas4803]

this is why they should not have made cod ww2 but a remake of cod 2 which is much better

[@cruz21pasionz80]

Cara Doido one of the best games ever made , always fun to play with some friends 👍

[@axb3542]

It's funny how the devs act like they did so many research but I can get a kid out of 2nd grade to do a better job

[@wesleygaray2666]

They did research but not a ton

[@meowcow21]

"did so many research"

[@qwertytwinkletoes3955]

Yeah after the cod iw controversy they have to think of something that relates to "boots on the ground" so sledgehammer games had to come up with ww2 and how this game was made is a production rush because of the controversy. But I love it when they say "It was 3 year of the making" in one of their video since it was clear rushed.

[@meowcow21]

@@qwertytwinkletoes3955 call of duty games in general are rushed

[@zewydk]

Vladimir Makarov No you can’t

[@Mit852]

MG-15 was used by ground forces as well. They were adapted for infantry use by addition of stock and bipod as they were phased out of air service when the MG 81, MG131, and other heavier guns replaced the MG15 in air service.

[@Ona-H0L3]

Womb Raider wasn’t that WWI?

[@omeidishope7220]

That was from WW1

[@yes5937]

Am I the only one who thinks these gun sounds and reload sounds are just so.. satisfying? All the clicks and clacks..

[@dusathemaid]

Thought I was the only one. It feels so good

[@tuccerjim3084]

Especially the Kar98k bolt action. I hate the scoped stripper clip reload, but that bolt sound is so soothing

[@core2cascade]

This is the kind of videos I like seeing. no commentary, straight to the point, and still amusing to watch. Although you could have made some shorter cuts but that’s my opinion.

[@YouTubeViolates1A]

Supa Boss Let's not forget to be thankful for the lack of ,"What's up guys! Insertgenericgamertage here, coming at you with another overused intro."

[@nicolopez4963]

The pistol thing is true for ww1 but in wwII the 1911 was given to as many soldiers as possible

[@sergeantmarcusstackerM1903]

Mainly it was issued to support troops like cooks and mechanics as well as officers. Then the M1 carbine came along

[@KianaKaslana366]

The people in the comment section clearly dont understand this video isn't meant to be taken literally or as an insult to the game at all. Lol.

[@SamVarvodic]

Finally someone who sees that it's just a fun video and it's not talking smack about the game thx

[@BlueStone-qt9md]

The lewis gun was used in WW2 after it's "replacement" since the UK had a shortage in equipment after the Dunkirk

[@_anonymous_gamer_8689]

this game needs one more faction:soviet union

[@winstonkurniawan_]

_ANONYMOUS_ GAMER_ *russia's national anthem intensifies

[@tibinicle]

winston kurniawan **soviet unions

[@Yuri-gg6nv]

_ANONYMOUS_ GAMER_ With PTRD 41 With Extended magazine Or Scoped DP 28? Or red dot Mosin Nagant M91? No thanks

[@coleman4840]

_ANONYMOUS_ GAMER_ the real winners

[@17MrLeon]

Wait, so you are telling that COD went back to WW2 and does not have usual brits and soviets as playable factions? Who the hell has the PPSh ?

[@nebiyuesayas5600]

Here are some you could add: 1. Every gun sounds the same to some extent, then tweaked slightly. 2. The lack of recoil on many weapons. 3. The M30 (German) shotty had 3 rounds: 2 pellet rounds and the small one had a rifle round. 5. No M1 Carbine or Ben (that one was on u, tho). 6. The Lewis pan mag doesn't rotate 360, once for each bullet. It fires, rotates after a certain number, stops until that section is empty, and repeats until the full mag is empty. 7. It's unlikely the MG15 had a strap on the mag. 8. How does an allied soldier (ignoring that she's a woman) have a German LMG? Same with the Machine pistol and MP40. 9. The infantry M1911 has 10 in mag, while airborne M1911 has 7 (inconsistent number of rounds). 10. All the bolt/pump action weapons are cycled faster than the average soldier could cycle. 11. Karabin and Toggle action look surprisingly similar. 12. Karabin (likely not real name) has no option for Iron sights. 13. Why does the female sniper not have a scope (unless she's a marksman, which is different from a sniper)? 14. Why does a soldier have a shovel as a secondary? This isn't BF1, soldiers have knives now.

[@asubaruthathatesexistance6871]

For 14, I really don't know. Its not like they got this soldier secondary shovel from TF2 or something like that

[@nebiyuesayas5600]

@@asubaruthathatesexistance6871 well, I say this because in ww2, most American soldiers were issued knives (and/or bayonets). And there is some proof that they would bring their own stuff (remember, privates weren't issued m1911s. Only NCO'S and above were given sidearms. Privates had to get their own). I would think that shovels as weapons was somewhat redundant.

[@asubaruthathatesexistance6871]

@@nebiyuesayas5600 I really agree with the statement "Shovels as weapons was somewhat redundant" cause it makes actual sense in my opinion. Shovels are heavy and blunt objects. Just because shovels are heavy, does"nt mean they do a lot of damage. Now knives and gun bayonets.......... THATS A LOTTA DAMAGE (sry for the stupid flex tape meme at the end)

[@nebiyuesayas5600]

@@asubaruthathatesexistance6871 the quote was fine. Now don't get me wrong - in a pic or emergency, if the only thing you could grab was a shovel, that would work. And it happened in ww1-it happening in ww2 is accurate. It's just not as common as the game is portraying. Of course it's a game, so it's not gonna be "WW2 the simulation", but this one is stretching it a bit more than the others.

[@asubaruthathatesexistance6871]

@@nebiyuesayas5600 agreed

[@darkshock42mlg05]

Lee enfields also had magazines. Not the kar98k. The reason the British used stripper clips was you could carry more ammo and they were cheaper do you wouldn't get in trouble with your commander for leaving them behind.

[@AllWeNeededWas]

*"well actually"*

[@mattiazarrillo301]

About the gas mask. The soldier in game is French, not American.

[@hernandezmartinezivan2153]

Mattia Zarrillo I dont think so

[@mattiazarrillo301]

Yeah, because he have the Adrian helmet(possessed by French soldier) and in the presentation video the guy who talk about the division has a French accent

[@dieselmaceln2071]

It's a French TC-38 gas mask.

[@Immolator772]

yeah the french do have this gas mask.

[@cangergaming8716]

I think he thought he was American because of his shotgun. Either way the resistance used the sten gun, not the Winchester

[@dreauthrams8871]

The 1897 only saw action in WW1? U wrong it was used in decent numbers up to Vietnam

[@miselkos4996]

Thats not ww2

[@dreauthrams8871]

Misel Kos I know fool my point is that it was used in ww1 and for the time in between ww1 and Vietnam. Aka ww2

[@dreauthrams8871]

Quackity Quack I’m not saying the game is good, the game sucks ass just your shit straight

[@djbroadhurst7142]

Dreau Thrams your wrong the 1897 was used in ww1,ww2, and the Korea war

[@jackargie1092]

Dj Broadhurst it was used by ARVN forces in Vietnam. It was still used by the US but mainly used by the ARVN with a rubber recoil pad on the butt stock.

[@pizza-for-mountains]

Prop hunt is the only redeeming quality of the whole game

[@notdrbright8927]

Mehhhhh. It’s also fun to hear someone’s reaction when you sniped them from across the map with ur insights ;)

[@remyfromratmoviebuthuman4282]

I like how he goes to a multiplayer match to tell us this info His team mates : is he brain dead or something? Get him outa here

[@susfringgaming4018]

I'm late as hell but the mg 15 was actually used by the German infantry towards the end of the war

[@onion-qw6hg]

You can chalk most of these up to "gameplay" because what would a call of duty game be if you could only use all of 5 total weapons, depending on which side your on

[@DudeInWalmart]

All of the guns modeling have inaccuracies starting with the massive m1 rear sight, the 1911 using a 38 super mag ect. It really bothers me.

[@americanchickenlover3048]

3:19 the Winchester was actually used in ww2

[@locness.monsterr]

I knew it, there has to be a country using the gun. Maybe the model 10 replaced it but the Marines probably used it. Like there can't be a country that didn't use it once.

[@logger22]

The Marines used it in the Pacific. Since they had more older equipment than the Army

[@jabobofweebs]

Who else only read the comments that were hate

[@josefmartin1917]

Me

[@fckaduck1311]

Hey bosssk

[@mcblazar1061]

they're all hate lmap

[@gitarthsonowal6703]

Jabobo Fweebs me lol

[@barsoktay2119]

"That army didn't have that gun " logic only makes sense in singleplayer. In multiplayer everyone is free to choose whatever factions gun.

[@foxtrotsierraproductions8626]

I miss the old cods where every faction had their own weapons

[@tristanblerf8356]

Watching the Kar98K reload gave me glaucoma

[@notdrbright8927]

Y?

[@Iosif_V_Stalin]

Mistakes in this video 0:50 Colt M1911 was used by infantry (before M1911A1 exist). 0:53 Colt M1911 extended magazine exist, but most of them used by pilots. 3:36 Magazine fed shotguns exist, but never used by infantry. 4:16 The max capacity is 20 not 10. 4:45 The Mp 18 was rarely used by german infantry.

[@donkomatik7860]

While I can get some of them, most of these are for gameplay purposes, not historical accuracy.

[@nilez9455]

The Lewis Gun was actually used since the British lost a huge part or their Brens at Dunkirk. But they still had loads of Lewis guns in storage and since they desperately needed machine guns they were pushed back into service. At least according to what I’ve read.

[@jacobgalfi1420]

Also despite the fact the thompson drum mags were not liked for those purposes he talked about, the M1A1 thompson was not even made with the ability to accept a drum mag. thats whats incorrect with it.

[@avshutsach]

There were extended magazines for the 1911, the one in the game was an extended magazine for the 1911 chambered in .38 super

[@OssaLuctus]

Few Problems -That ain't a Red Dot that's a Reflex Sight. Red Dots are a sort of middle ground between Scope and Reflex, Scope being a full optical operated sighting aid without using tech and the Reflex being a light and compact CQB sighting aid -The American Thompson (M1-M1A1 Models) did not have the ability for drum magazines even though the Commonwealth armies had Thompsons that could do so -The Lewis And Bren saw action side by side until about 42' if I'm not mistaken -The M1887 was switched out for a model of Ithica Shotgun that saw use during the war But you did a great job pointing out the rest

[@ricefieldman]

2:24 False, the MG 15 was pushed into infantry service.

[@bobhatessinners8327]

ricefield_man true, it’s notable because infantry wasn’t given any with bipods

[@bobhatessinners8327]

ricefield_man ah, my mistake, they did

[@ricefieldman]

@@bobhatessinners8327 All good man, history can be confusing.

[@gurmansinghtakhar5098]

You know your bored when you make a video about how a COD game isn't accurate

[@highground7923]

Gurman Singh Takhar it’s a free country

[@Mate-vg2ft]

Well they did say they would portray the worlds biggest conflict.

[@gurmansinghtakhar5098]

@remo2500 remo2500 yeah I was bored for about 10 seconds

[@FourDozenEggs]

@remo2500 remo2500 You know you're bored when you have to copy someones comment and use it against them. Wait...

[@bowserthedog5444]

remo2500 remo2500 this is also a video game not real life so really there is no reason to be angry

[@KomradeDoge]

A couple of innocent corrections for anyone curious: -The 1911 WAS given to all NCOs (sergeant and higher), not just officers and could often be found in the hands of regular infantry because of changing doctrine allowing more equal distribution of sidearms. -The MP-28 WAS used in the early war fairly extensively due to the lack of production capacity of other more modern machine pistols for the shock troops. It, like the P08, was phased out when the new equipment became available, but could still be seen around due to supply line issues, especially so when the Volksturm was formed and thrown any weapon they could find. -The M1897 shotgun could be found in WW2 also. If it ain't broke don't fix is usually the order of the day with US ordinance doctrine. It was a rare find, but not phased out of service like some of the other entries. -I'm surprised you didn't notice the suddenly modern style BAR reload. The gun in real life is open bolt, meaning that the bolt has to be locked back by simply pulling the charging handle back (and not pushing it back forward) before the magazine can be inserted. In game it appears to be closed bolt, like many modern assault rifles. -The Grease gun doesn't have a bolt handle. it is cocked by pulling the bolt back to the locked position through the ejection port with your fingers. That dust cover is also the safety, as it completely blocks the bolt's movement when closed, preventing the bolt from triggering the next bullet. As said in Fury "Open that there. Good, now you killin. Close it. Good, now you ain't."

[@TragicTester034]

6 months late but the early M3 Grease guns did have a charging handle and the BAR while yes it was open bolt it had a non reciprocating charging handle which ment that after the bolt was locked open the charging handle could be moved foreward without closing the bolt

[@KomradeDoge]

@@TragicTester034 This M3 looks like it's a weird amalgamation of the early and late models. And as for the BAR, I know that you would, as procedure for shooting the gun, push the handle back forward to have it in the right spot for the next time you reload, what I'm mentioning here is that they do that AFTER changing the mag, which is opposite what the US taught their BAR operators. On a mag empty change they would pull the charging handle back, then put the new mag in. In the game it looks like they modeled the animation after (hopefully) the STG-44, but more likely it's after a modern AR like the SCAR.

[@TragicTester034]

@@KomradeDoge one thing I find funny is the KG/M 21 (Swedish BAR) has a more correct reload animation then the actual BAR

[@calvinboyd9139]

Also the 1887 trench gun held 5 rounds in the tube and one in the chamber, not 10 in total.

[@tanzhikai9913]

1:59 they still used them in ww2 but it quickly got replaced

[@TheMateoFischerShow]

Somehow on the first mission...you could find a PPSH.

[@LandonChaoOfficial]

King Mateus5 Nah it’s a true fact. German soldiers did use captured PPSH on Omaha beach...just in small numbers

[@TheMateoFischerShow]

Ok. Thank you.

[@KrazeRednek2534]

King Mateus5. At the wars end Germans started using any weapons they could get there hands on cause of all the Allied bombings on Axis manufacturing facilities

[@mrboomsnook3671]

3:14 I slight mistype, that’s called an Winchester 1897 shotgun, the Winchester 1887 was a lever action shotgun

[@mrboomsnook3671]

But just imagine if they actually had soldiers wield the bootleg version, they would be so bad ass

[@isaali1389]

Why is nobody wondering how he got all this footage without even having the game to start with?

[@kojeta3200]

Wut? Explain

[@owl1095]

@@kojeta3200 At the end of the video he said that he'll buy the game, but he had all of this footage of the game already.

[@kojeta3200]

@@owl1095 yep, that's really strange ngl

[@purplehawk2271]

@@owl1095 it was a video from ign posted on KZbin during the games buildup to release.

[@detectivepayne3773]

he just downloaded pre existing footage? it's not a big deal

[@KingofGermanic]

Kar98k and Gewher 98 had 20 round detachable magazine variants produced in limited numbers. (But you're right there was no 7 round magazines). I think the gun they were going for with the "Waffe 28" was the MP-34 a gun produced by Austria for the German Army to allow a secret re-armament. The problem there is that they only semi-accurately model the MP-28 which was replaced quickly by the MP-34. I suppose that having MP-28's still in use would make some level of sense (especially if they're trying to portray last days of the German Army) but it makes no sense why they didn't just have an MP-34. If they really wanted to show last days instead of using the MG-15 they could have used the MG-42 or the MG08 to show desperate they are and should have had the MP3008 an absolute trash gun that was thrown out the factory door into the hands of soldiers like the PPS-43.

[@wyattsmothers5757]

You clearly never owned/ operated a M1 before

[@gdlegofatxd5620]

Wyatt Smothers ok but the reload for m1 in this game is insanely inaccurate, if you don’t support the bolt with your hand while putting the rounds in, your thumb will get crushed by it

[@WxrcomGen]

@@gdlegofatxd5620 not crushed but it is not a slight hit. You wont lose your finger but you might want to go to the doctor

[@m0rkmuzzl]

SomeGenericPlayer your thumb will definitely hurt if you don’t hold the bolt back

[@barnaclebarn2510]

SWG12012 we can all agree, that shit hurts

[@johnhoma7145]

@@gdlegofatxd5620 its called garand finger and I think the man is aware

[@garretthammond8503]

the notches for the iron sight on the thompson is also incorrect. the user is using the top notch which is meant for 250+ yards and the circle is meant for 100 yards