Everything Wrong With Everything Wrong With Red Dead Redemption...

[@therockinacatsbody1729]

Can’t wait for the comeback video “every thing wrong with every thing wrong with everything wrong about rdr2

[@dukemeiser19]

Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Red Dead Redemption 2

[@Herryyyy]

​@@dukemeiser19 Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Red Dead Redemption 2

[@dukemeiser19]

@@Herryyyy Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Everything wrong with Red Dead Redemption 2

[@Herryyyy]

@@dukemeiser19 you win

[@Srbinrayan]

@@dukemeiser19everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with everything wrong with rdr

[@ianreder2718]

"even though he's an idiot doesn't mean to go hating on him" is one of my new favorite quotes

[@dukemeiser19]

use it

[@ianreder2718]

@@dukemeiser19 I most likely will

[@channel45853]

My favorite part of contrarian videos is when they claim that their opinion is fact. The guy says that the New Austin chapter is boring. Ok, that's his opinion, but then he goes and says that he's the only one with the balls to say it, as if he is just objectively right. Honestly, one of the reasons I don't engage with videos that go against an opinion I have. Most people online are dicks about their "unpopular opinions" so I don't find it worth the time.

[@dukemeiser19]

yea discussion is key

[@reality_is_sin]

His opinion on the first half of the game sucks too lol

[@xLanzer]

Also, "i'M tHe OnLy OnE wItH bAlLs 🤓" like nah dude you're just the only one with that abomination of an opinion lmao

[@Cervidae]

7:10 this sin right here tells me that OOP either has never in his life played a video game, or he hates RDR1 so much he's just trying to find shit to sin

[@grimv4037]

The last enemy that shall be destroyed is possibly the best ending to a main story, you’re doing ranch chores for a long time and start to wonder where the story goes. And then you get hit with John talking to Jack about the future of the ranch, Then panic sets in as uncle spots the army, and during the final cutscene it breaks your Heart when you see the man you grew a bond with the entire game get killed. (Also the mission name is perfect, John is the final of member of the van der Linde Gang to kill, hence the LAST enemy that shall be destroyed)

[@dukemeiser19]

👍

[@commandernomad2817]

Its also a bible quote. The full quote is: the last enemy that shall be destroyed is death" It's from Corinthians and its talking _literally, _ referring to how in the end times the last enemy that shall be destroyed is literally people dying, as we will already be dead and in heaven or something. The amount of layered meaning in this title alone is kind of nuts honestly.

[@grimv4037]

@ Didn’t notice that bit

[@silenceofstone]

9:17 if you even glance at the map you can see that fort mercer is in rio bravo while ridgewood is still in cholla springs

[@redgreen82]

@@silenceofstone Right? What does distance have to do with anything? Jurisdictions are based on borders. I can drive west for almost 10 hours and still be on Texas or drive north for 45 minutes and be in Oklahoma.

[@madmonty4761]

In my opinion johns death shows not how his life caught up but how the moment you find joy something tragic happens after

[@themadtitan7603]

I think it's a fruition of: "People don't forget, nothing gets forgiven". Despite him doing his all to bury his past and reform himself, the universe (even if it's the form of a treacherous government agent) won't let John off the hook for his past. But he also shows that he was truly redeemed by facing it for his family's future.

[@CowpokeCallahan]

Gcn is the type of guy to complain that there is no action at the beginning of an action movie

[@dukemeiser19]

why are there credits

[@LegoSnoopDogg]

He’s the kinda guy to ask “who is that” at the beginning of an original movie they’ve never watched

[@MeepMacArthur]

If someone sins John's last stand them they don't deserve to be treated as credible or with any respect

[@Deanwinchester1965]

Yes

[@themadtitan7603]

One of the most iconic, courageous and badass final standoffs I think I've seen. That shot of John standing in front of the barn with all the guns trained all of him will likely be "forever" memorable.

[@mynamemyers5914]

He basically said for the 3rd sin, "You what this cowboy game needs? Ah yes, more racism." Like what? 😆

[@dukemeiser19]

should’ve had arthur calling lenny the hard r for increased historical accuracy 👽

[@IftiharAbdillah-s3k]

@@dukemeiser19 Like uhh... Lennyrrr?

[@the_knightofnirn9041]

I just want to correct something, there are rewards for the honor system. High honor grants double pay for tasks, item prices are halved (except for Thieves Landing), a random encounter where a nun gives you an item or asks for a donation, and an outfit. Low honor however grants bribing eyewitnesses costs less, item prices are halved (Only in Thieves Landing), Marston insults people instead of greeting them, and whistling for your horse will call a unique horse that will be lost if you become honorable. Max High or Low honor will have people call the law after the second murder/ bank robbery

[@DarthOminis]

31:35: 1) Jack was 4 when the gang broke up. He did not do anything that could be charged and therefore could not be lawfully executed, and by the time he did he was an adult working of his own accord. 2) Abigail did not do anything to be charged, as we learn in RDR2, and we know this guy loves using RDR2 as a point of reference so it counts

[@Waxyyy]

Amazing channel! one of the most underrated rdr channels

[@dukemeiser19]

Thanks for the support I appreciate it 🙏🙏

[@davecurry863]

@@dukemeiser19 And so it begins

[@Roman_55]

Yesterday I played this game, without cheats or tricks. It was the best experience I've ever did.

[@Roman_55]

I beat the game, I mean.

[@corywilson532]

"You should've just left me there to die." "Because I was shot mere feet away from an entire fort of outlaw men who wouldn't pass up a chance to do horrible things to you." I can see where it's implied as Martson Speak, he's really just saying she stuck her neck out pretty far to save his life.

[@dukemeiser19]

teue

[@sam0nator]

at 9:37, hes also ignoring the fact that the map has those dotted lines, it was my impression those marked the different counties there was, so ridgwood is still part of the same county while fort mercer is below that county line in rio bravo

[@DinnerBone2018]

10:51 he KNEW west Dickens was a fraud and still fell for what west Dickens advertised

[@Shadow-zeroone]

14:36 in rdr2 during the urban pleasures once arthur is on the trolley he gets infinite ammo or maybe during escape with hosea in advertising the new art - II , it is mostly made to give player some action without ruining it

[@dukemeiser19]

Pretty much

[@kingman-fm4dq]

7:00 imagine John yelling at kids in a Modern Warfare 2 Pre game lobby

[@dukemeiser19]

he’d rage and go do farm chores to cool off

[@kingman-fm4dq]

@@dukemeiser19 lmao imagine. I now want Rob to post an MW2 vid

[@DarthOminis]

9:34 the Marshal also says he can't raid Fort Mercer because it's not in his county, and therefore out of his jurisdiction. Ridgewood Farm is in his county so he can pursue it. He also says all this in the same cutscene which he sins

[@AverageJoExplorations]

6:14 I always thought he was talking about the Bollard Twins in Pike's Basin. A box canyon is any canyon with only one opening, and while there are trails to get out of Pike's on the other side, there's only one opening.

[@Vegeta-it8ct]

8:38 Bro really said there are no outfits exclusively for low honor or the black horse (Idk its name but it's the same one Micah uses in RDR2)

[@LL15onTT]

I have a feeling this guy thought a game from 2010 would have the same systems and gamplay mechanics like RDR2. The mention of the basic honor mechanic practically confirms this

[@dukemeiser19]

ye

[@blitzvalentine363]

This man sinned John's death just because he stayed behind to protect his family. Jack was a child and Abigail was in one heist, that we know of, during their time in the gang. The government had no real excuse to kill them. John's death may have been foreshadowed, we knew it was coming because the government sucks, but that doesn't make his sacrifice any less impact. He can have his opinions all he wants, but shame on him for saying this death had no real impact

[@borisradalovic1971]

“I got a plan John.….This one’s a good one.”

[@kachnisko]

8:09 gets mad he cant kill people and sins the game 15:04 gets mad he kills people and sins the game

[@dukemeiser19]

crazy

[@jeffholy872]

These videos gotta blow up. Gonna go watch the video on what you have to say about another fools opinion just on rdr 2's sins, guarantee it'll be an easy fun watch! You've certainly gained a new sub so keep it up my fellow rdr coinsure, looking forward to more videos!

[@dukemeiser19]

Thanks man ima keep up the RDR vids, Appreicate the love ❤️🙏

[@Kasrasanei]

This man was annoying afffff kept talking about the sequel for having characters that were not mentioned in the first game that came out 10 years before it. Jesus

[@dukemeiser19]

buddy was yapping

[@XtraOrdinar-y]

Maybe it’s just me but I really like the NA chapter

[@dukemeiser19]

It’s fine just boring

[@XtraOrdinar-y]

@@dukemeiser19 it’s repetitive in a second play through just like colter but idk I have a fascination with ranching

[@dukemeiser19]

@@XtraOrdinar-y yea that’s probably why but even in my first play through i was bored

[@mrmemes170]

the reason john said he was from fort mercer was to see if the law was crooked

[@somedorkydude6483]

3:30 its a pretty safe assumption to think john would bleed out if he survived a gun shot. Although i do want to respond to tbe john needs to survive part. obviously the main charaters have some plot armor. However, good writing tries to make it not very apparent. A few coincidences here and there arent catastrophic but, you got to make the near death momments beleivable. In this case an idiot like bill had a good reason to assume john was dead.

[@TheJudge287]

11:58 When I was playing the other day this line was said and instantly said,” An Undead Nightmare.”

[@Tired_cowboy1899]

bills pretty low IQ but yeah I agree because of how he reacts to shooting him also that spot John got shot in was probably his liver or stomach therefore john almost died from bleeding out

[@NNatsuki_Real]

10:48 gcn literally just fell for dickens scam by thinking it worked

[@dukemeiser19]

He fell for dat dickens

[@Darthkermit_frogo]

I didnt even realise Dutch and Nastas had the same voice actor

[@dukemeiser19]

you can sort of hear it

[@Darthkermit_frogo]

@@dukemeiser19 now that i know i cant unhear it

[@eldartaghiyev8422]

13:54 meanwhile any GTA games since SA: we do not die when swimming.

[@5476Himself]

Not true. In GTA: Liberty City Stories, which released in 2005, one year after SA in 2004, Toni Cipriani cannot swim in water and will drown if he enters it. Even in universe, LCS happens in 1998, 6 years after SA, which happens in 1992.

[@eldartaghiyev8422]

@@5476Himselfyeah but that was 1st on PSP and many people were angry that you could not swim so the next game (VCS) they added back swimming.

[@Gingersnap_Adventures]

Something that is with us humans is if murders in a video game we won’t get tired, that’s society and humanity.

[@TravisBrister]

He’s actually wrong about the honor system not having any perks in rdr1 if you have high honor you get the duster coat outfit but if you have low honor you get a nigh immortal horse that looks like Baylok Micah’s horse

[@dukemeiser19]

true

[@TravisBrister]

@ two things one holy shit thinks for replying im a huge fan and two I think there’s one more thing to add to the honor benefits i believe if you have high honor npc will talk highly about John or jack but if you have low honor they’d be afraid or try to insult you.

[@TravisBrister]

@ two things one holy shit thinks for replying im a huge fan and two I think there’s one more thing to add to the honor benefits i believe if you have high honor npc will talk highly about John or jack but if you have low honor they’d be afraid or try to insult you.

[@Shadow-zeroone]

8:25 Whoever I get bored in rdr2 I load up my 100% save file give myself infinite ammo max honor (for kill cams) and infinite dead eye , then I just killed police me in weird ass ways

[@dukemeiser19]

Valid

[@noahmehalich8629]

I love the fact that nobody brings up the fact that you can see Bonnie in Red Dead redemption 2 if you can collect a letter in the heartlands if I'm not mistaken in the epilogue after you visit the McFarland ranch for the first time pick that letter up and then go back to the McFarland ranch you'll see Bonnie

[@Pigeon_z]

What really annoys me is that people like this have a hard time understanding some things are put in place as a game mechanic. The Rdr games arent survival games like dayz or rust. That's why rdr1 has "regenetive health". Great content Duke.

[@gamerdude612]

Instead of just re releasing the original RDR I would have loved a full blown remaster/remake that gives us the RDR2 graphics and engine and they could add in references to RDR2 Arthur and the others it's probably way more effort than Rockstar would do for Red Dead Redemption but that would be awesome I'd buy it it's still fun to go back to but I ended up missing certain features from 2 like duel side arms or just getting to customize the appearance of John/Jack just a wish I suppose haha.

[@mellomoose_]

@@gamerdude612 a remake with references to 2 would be sooo fuckin good

[@gamerdude612]

@@mellomoose_ Rockstar really outta do it there's plenty of RDR fans that would buy this they are leaving money on the table I'd settle for a expansion story from 2 a prequel of sorts finally showing the blackwater massacre they probably won't but again I'd buy it.

[@John_Drip619]

Great video

[@dukemeiser19]

Appreciate it homie 🙏

[@voidappreciator]

I can't believe that I used to like cinemasins and gamingsins

[@dukemeiser19]

it is what it is

[@amitassasson1893]

“regenerative health”

[@delmuswu-tangbroadnax9056]

Wait a second. This guy made that etw with Arkham asylum? I saw a video of someone breaking down why everything he said was dumb. I love it😂

[@dukemeiser19]

👍

[@virgiljianu7166]

Yeah, that was ClownPuncher139, right?

[@dukemeiser19]

@@virgiljianu7166 yep

[@wittock7129]

Why was the guy complaining about regenerative health as if he would be happy with John having a broken leg from a fall? ☠️ 7:11

[@dukemeiser19]

@@wittock7129 realistic healing would be hell in games

[@unknown_pro_3238]

I like this more than the original "everything wrong" video

[@dukemeiser19]

Awesome

[@eldartaghiyev8422]

02:34 You mean Lincoln’s son was saved by Booth’s brother, not the reverse.

[@dukemeiser19]

yes

[@eldartaghiyev8422]

Oops. I did not saw the text until now.

[@AndrewJW]

16:58 this is also gta iv. Niko is looking for the guy who betrayed him and his platoon during the war. Like almost identically

[@The_Hazmat_Dude]

We arent "phycopaths", just... Morally challenged.

[@dukemeiser19]

VERY morally challenged

[@sam0nator]

32:12 plus abigail and jack were nonviolent members of the gang, jack being a literal child who commited no crimes, so of course the gov isnt gonna execute them, thats [silly]

[@dukemeiser19]

ross was a bad guy, but cmon

[@ashaihimoto]

When he said UNLIMITED AMMO It was exactly like when he said UNLIMITED PAPERS In arkham asylum and It all comes together as If it's a reference bad reference is bad If It's a joke bad joke Is bad.

[@dukemeiser19]

@@ashaihimoto

[@ashaihimoto]

@@dukemeiser19 Let's go bro

[@Croooshader]

31:10 this is the most stupidest take that the human mind has created in the history of mankind

[@jaykemp2861]

Man, I feel like so much was lost on this guy because he never actually interacted with RDR as a story, instead as just a checklist of different tropes he could make a snide comment on. Especially on stuff that I personally think deserves some criticism, like Dutch's ending speech. By reusing it in RDR2 it takes away from the impact of it in exchange for fan service, but does this guy comment on it? Nope. Just makes a comment about Dutch falling being a cliche.

[@Sopranos990]

I’m mad how they made a swimming feature just to remove it after completing a game 💀😭

[@dukemeiser19]

john no good

[@Sopranos990]

@@dukemeiser19 👍

[@MeepMacArthur]

John is related to Tommy that's why it has to be lore accurate 😂

[@channel45853]

your horses still swim in rdr2 and arthur doesn't swim the best, so it seems like the game is trying to encourage not to swim as the characters themselves

[@redgreen82]

First off, Javier talked about how close they were and that they were brothers because he was trying to save his own tail in the moment. That’s not a sin in either game, that's characterization. Secondly, Bill said everyone in the gang wanted John dead. That could easily have just been Bill getting some parting shots in on John before John kills him. They don't have to be true. That’s also not a sin on either game.

[@chris_player2995]

14:24 I hate it when games have a turret section and have to take a few shots because the game is overheating is it realistic? yeah I guess is it fun? no, i wanna go crazy gunning down enemies not pressing R2 at. certain rhythm

[@MeepMacArthur]

3:39 bill is really that dumb 😂

[@JoeyBidenFr]

johns also a smartass if im not wrong

[@dukemeiser19]

@@JoeyBidenFr pretty much

[@lincolnhall1440]

yo chat is this real ggang gang

[@dukemeiser19]

VERY REAL

[@AutomatedMess]

Rdr2 doesn’t contradict bills lines as I think he says “we all wanted you dead” He doesn’t consider Arthur Sadie etc. To be gang members. As they view them as traitors so not gang members anymore

[@dukemeiser19]

true

[@AutomatedMess]

@ Yooooooooo U actually replied. I’m a massive fan. I have a theory if u would like to hear it

[@dukemeiser19]

@@AutomatedMess thanks for the support, i’d love to see the theory

[@AutomatedMess]

@ strange man is the representative being of the honor system

[@ocifer]

27:07 Aren’t Pinkertons just contractors for the government, and not actually government agents? I’m assuming they don’t really deal with stopping bank robberies most of the time, as the real world equivalent did a lot more tracking of criminals than traditional police who would be there to actually intercept a crime in progress. I doubt they were specifically trained for that. Besides, even if they were agents of the government (basically whatever the equivalent to an FBI agent would be), they’re typically not in the place where the crime occurred, but instead are sent in to the area after said crime has been committed.

[@dukemeiser19]

Yes

[@spouwnerring]

So I watched the Game Care Network do a video called "EWW GCN". 1 sin they made is that GCN was ment to be a 12 person video game website (IGN but indie) but that it devolved into 3 friends just screwing around. This let me to believe that 1 guy would play the game and write the script, KidAtari would narrorate it and then a 3rd guy would edot the video and hit publish. However it became very evident that KidAtari was the only person running the channel based on the gameplay footage and how the scripts were written. If GCN was a 3 person team then they wouldn't have gone on a giant hiatus when KidAtari suffert from burnout. I mean, before the hiatus, GCN was the most pupulair Gaming Sins (even more populair than the actual channel called Gaming Sins) but now he's really upscure, meanwhile Dartigan is at the top spot.

[@dukemeiser19]

Nice lore dump, that’s interesting

[@JonathanVicente-o3q]

18:31 bro this shit funny🙏😭

[@MaryHarper-x6r]

The last game to not have regenerative health is i think is gta4

[@rDub_4]

Erm acshually this is the second rdr game 8:48

[@rDub_4]

See, this man is a great content creator even with hundreds of comments he still finds a way to reply to them

[@Mepsi700]

Ross going after pearson next

[@Certified_Nobody]

For the guy saying that all of the missions are so repetitive is pretty stupid. Considering the game came out in 2010🤦‍♂️

[@MistahMan69]

I wish I could buy a Winchester rifle for 350 rifles.

[@somesmallbrain]

Man i was sorta understanding him until he said John's death was stupid like that entire section of yapping was just wrong

[@Nadrajreta]

32:44 idk why I find that so funny

[@IftiharAbdillah-s3k]

Whoa you hate Seth? How could you even after witnessing the best dialogue in the entire game, that is "It's a glass eye! It's a glass eye!"

[@dukemeiser19]

he’s icky

[@Jam-og1km]

Did you seriously sin the fact that he didn't sin the "Far Away" section? (Ride into Mexico?) Despite the fact that you can fast travel if you don't want to do it??? Edit: Oops, I was completely wrong, my bad

[@dukemeiser19]

I sinned that he didn’t remove sins for that ride

[@Jam-og1km]

Ah so you did, I'm so sorry!! I just reeeeally like that part and was only half paying attention 😅

[@dukemeiser19]

@@Jam-og1km 👍

[@stephenbufkin5039]

I also think its implied that West Dickens is stealing some of the money from the race winnings. A nervous coward, he wants to put off this raid on the fort as long as possible. Not only is it padding out the game by giving players more to do, its also part of Dickens characterization.

[@chris_player2995]

the austin chapter being boring? maybe the farm work was , but we got to meet Marshall a, Mr. Wrst Dickens, Seth ,shoot down outlaws, and raiding Fort Mercer

[@dukemeiser19]

it’s more tedious than anything

[@Droidsbane]

14:23 I've watched a few of GCN's videos, and one of the many things that always annoys me is the UNLIMITED AMMO!!!!! Sin, and the main reason's mainly because he never explains /why/ it's a sin and doesn't give an alternative. He just says UNLIMITED AMMO!!!! and dings

[@dukemeiser19]

Unlimited sins

[@leotheskyguy]

5 million sins on them for sinning the best game ever

[@Hikik0m0ri_cz]

A bit late here :P but just wanted to say I love it when someone goes this hard against a popular IP just because... They wanna be edgy or interesting ig

[@dukemeiser19]

it is interesting but aye makes for easy content

[@buzz9900]

You hate Seth?!

[@dukemeiser19]

he’s very irritating

[@ViperBlitzen]

Luna

[@Isaac_646]

I did try red dead 1, but refunded it in like five minutes. I just cant get into this game. Also the golden guns dlc cant be removed or deactivated, that pissed me off.

[@dukemeiser19]

@@Isaac_646 it can be deactivated in the options menu

[@Cervidae]

golden guns can be deactivated.

[@MordecaiCody]

😂

[@shesimpsforsammy]

Love your channel and this video, but I gotta say something controversial, 31:11 he's genuinely not wrong there. John's death was nothing near tragic, it was just irksome,stupid and blood boiling. Worthy of those 10 sins

[@dukemeiser19]

butt

[@Toxic_0_]

Bro might as well have just sinned the game for existing. Sinning health regen? In a video game? These sin channels must love the smell of their own farts 😂

[@dukemeiser19]

facts

[@Cande1890]

It's just me or the guy yaps like a redditor? anyway, good video dude

[@shesimpsforsammy]

His videos are usually just jokes but entertainment purposes, nothing serious

[@dukemeiser19]

me or the other guy

[@shesimpsforsammy]

@@dukemeiser19 the other guy

[@Cande1890]

@@dukemeiser19 The other guy (Go to sleep lol It's too late. Gn)

[@The-OG-Petey]

You eat babies!

[@dukemeiser19]

good source of protein

[@The-OG-Petey]

@@dukemeiser19 they’re fatty and delicious. Great for anyone wanting a good meal after a hard day’s work of ranching.

[@Tekh_Rel]

🍞

[@wildoutaussie2228]

I think box canyon could be a beta name for pikes basin.

[@shutupworkid9735]

This guy was literally going out of his way to shit on the game lol, no idea why he had any problem with the majority of the things he mentioned.

[@dukemeiser19]

Fr brodie was tweaking

[@Croooshader]

31:10 this is the most stupidest take that the human mind has created in the history of mankind