Everything Wrong With Puss in Boots: The Last Wish in 18 Minutes or Less

Puss in Boots: The Last Wish somehow turned out great. It's one of the most charming and best reviewed movies of all of 2022. And THAT ALONE... is sinful!
Thursday: 2022 horror sins.
Remember, no movie is without sins. Which movie's sins should we count next?
•CinemaSins website• www.cinemasins.com
•Channels•
--TVSins: / tvsins
--MusicVideoSins: / musicvideosins
--CommercialSins: / @commercialsins
--CinemaSins Podcast Network: / @cinemasinspodcastnetwork
•SinClub Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• www.teespring.com/stores/cine...
•Podcasts•
--Recotopia: A happy home for recommended movies, shows, & music from two people you can totally trust. Chris and Jeremy take turns picking a movie each week to recommend, as well as talk about other pop culture stuff they are consuming. Become a member of the SinClub to interact LIVE with them every week! tinyurl.com/bdsnw7xj
--Behind the Sins:The CinemaSins B-Team give you an unprecedented inside look at what goes on in the CinemaSins universe. Each week Aaron, Denee', Jonathan, and Ian will break down the videos, KZbin comments, your questions and more! tinyurl.com/2ydudbtp
--Captain’s Pod: A Star Trek companion podcast! Join Ian, Deneé, and a crew of intrepid guests as they boldly explore everything they love and, naturally, everything wrong with the franchise that has dominated the final frontier for more than half a century. tinyurl.com/56eadf84
•Writers•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris:
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé: / deneesays
Ian: / whittsinned
Daniel:
•Other Links•
Discord: / discord
Reddit: / cinemasins
Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com/book
Instagram: / cinemasins

[@XclusiveFilms08]

The fact that that the panic attack scene didn't get a sin off is crazy. It was such a powerful moment of sheer fear and helplessness that made Puss into a true character for me

[@thespeedyyoshi]

Yeah I’m shocked about that one too.

[@weirdguy1495]

There's always Cinema Wins.

[@LucianDevine]

Yeah, it was one of the things I was definitely expecting to see when I clicked, especially when he took a sin off for Perrito in general.

[@Danrarbc]

​@@LucianDevine The scene deserved two sins off. One for the incredibly realistic depiction of a panic attack and another for Perrito's beautiful demonstration of how to be there for someone having one.

[@thespeedyyoshi]

@@LucianDevine at least it’s only one.

[@GmmBeast]

No sin off for Death? No sin off for the panic attack scene? No sin off for Jack being willing to shoot a puppy in the face in a "kids" movie?? No sin off for the actual HEALTHY COMMUNICATION BETWEEN PUSS AND KITTY??? Rigged.

[@cdangelo1843]

It’s a Shrek movie, so you know he’s not gonna be that nice.

[@minkeyandzomble6206]

They never said they were critics. In fact when sinning themselves they state they aren't critics. They're assholes lol.

[@DariusKetchum2010]

That's Jeremy for ya.

[@robfila5046]

DEFINITELY

[@joeguarinoni8923]

you want a sin off for a panic attack scene? literally the meme lol

[@Arcanis_07]

“I’m Death. And I don’t mean it metaphorically, rhetorically, poetically, theoretically, or any other fancy way. I’m Death. Straight up.”, is honestly one of my favorite lines of dialogue from any movie in 2022. I’m kind of upset it didn’t get played, even if it would have been a sin, in this video.

[@alyssaanderson6190]

right

[@DariusKetchum2010]

We still have Lee over at CinemaWins.

[@RitardandoTheMailman]

agreed

[@martialmurdock6866]

i would have preferred if he said "in the flesh" instead of straight up. "straight up" loose the situations seriousness

[@theplague5803]

I'm gay Straight Up

[@mercury.sulfide]

I'm surprised he didn't even mention Perrito's backstory, thought of him as just a comic relief, called him "discounted Olaf" and then skipped the whole panic attack scene

[@Konani_the_unicorn_queen]

Cinemasins really did just say "i can't credit this as anything but a comic relief and a ripoff disney character, because i do. not. want to admit _feeling_ during that scene!"

[@VYDEOS2]

I mean he kinda was. His backstory was a typical sob story except he wasn't sad about it

[@stephaniejohnson5361]

@@VYDEOS2 he contributed a lot more than Olaf. Perrito was the reason puss was able to fight death instead of making a wish

[@davidjellofox]

The 8 empty glasses seems to be a reference to the 8 lives he has wasted, and he is drinking his last life when Death shows up.

[@deandre6559]

Yeah. I thought he would take a sin off for that

[@thatfuzzypotato1877]

He sinned quite a lot of the symbolism in the film because they weren’t literally logical

[@neekogregory1885]

@@AhmedKathiri the people who write the scripts are oblivious to what actually goes on in movies

[@neekogregory1885]

@@thatfuzzypotato1877 they do that in every movie even tho everything they are sinning has a point they just never heard of “chekhov's gun”

[@AcoN0Five]

There are a lot of easter eggs in that scene, including Puss taking 8 steps before attacking Wolf after the "No more messing around" line which is probably unintentional but cool anyway

[@brandonhicks9926]

I love it when CinemaSins sins, but I love it even more when they take sins off in all the right places

[@nickcollins1052]

Lol your comment says it's 11 hours old but this just posted. Of KZbin never change

[@GotenIttetsu]

@@nickcollins1052 videos are available early for members (like a Twitch subscription on YT). This video was probably up for like a day for them

[@nickcollins1052]

@@GotenIttetsu makes sense

[@isabelwilliams8072]

how did u comment on this video before it was posted??

[@isabelwilliams8072]

oh wait, read the replys lol

[@hsfhanaa]

As a movie theater employee, my coworkers and I loved this film and so did everyone else. This was our most popular movie. Even when Avatar's percentages died down, this movie continued to thrive. The art style was so beautiful to look at and the depiction of an anxiety attack was so intense, I felt like I was gonna have one. Antonio and Salma did phenomenal and this entire movie is so re-watchable. Florence Pugh and the rest of the bears also did great as well.

[@paulharper4196]

I commented above about the rewatchability of this, which I'll definitely watch again, compared the the super Mario movie I saw a couple of weeks ago, which I'll likely never watch again. This was a masterclass in how to do an animated movie, for me anyway, and mario was just generic run of the mill fayre.

[@Mr_Mcfeely]

I could listen to Antonio and Salma read cooking recipes and be entertained 🤌🏻🤌🏻

[@princessthyemis]

that's amazing!!

[@simplyMr1]

Yeah perfect writing too, i mean the line by death wolf " i don't mean metaphorically..." Were the best of the year in any movie

[@axelf9947]

Death’s whistle is my favorite detail in this movie, honestly. It’s ominous, it’s frightening, it leaves something to be desired… but at the same time, it’s alluring and strangely calming. Like, y’know, _death._

[@joelrobinson5457]

The notes too, 8 long, drawn, out, notes, with the emphasis on the ninth. The end on the song, beauuuuutiful detail

[@enbysheriff]

I'm honestly surprised a sin wasn't removed for how creepy Death's whistle was

[@Floakaflow]

How's that whistle not a Sin. It's a kids movie for fucks sake! 😂

[@lexnight8345]

@@Floakaflow Both of you are right

[@Floakaflow]

​@@lexnight8345that double take on irredeemable villains was just so cool 😂 I had to refer to it

[@AngelWingsYT]

Ikr! Or the in general creepiness of death. Or you know THEY SHOWED BLOOD in a KIDS MOVIE

[@d3vildog023]

@@AngelWingsYT my God animations for everyone guys it’s not just a kid movie

[@trinaq]

I love that this movie doesn't treat its target audience like idiots. Plus, it handles panic attacks more accurately than Velma, which is supposedly an adult animation.

[@randompolygon8401]

bruh are you really comparing one of the best animated movies of the past few years, to the worst rated show on imdb? anything half decent would be impressive compared to velma. I feel like using it as a comparison here is almost insulting to puss in boots.

[@goreobsessed2308]

I've had bowl movements that handled panic attacks better than Velma

[@Earthball_Productions]

yup, its an example how "kids" movies CAN be good.

[@bentwomey384]

Oh my god you are not bringing back that god damned panic attack discourse

[@cameronbosch1213]

You freaking nailed it. Not all animation has to be FoR kIdS or insult their audience. I think this movie might also be one of the best movie sequels ever made! And the panic attack scene beats Velma's with even 2% of that scene! 😂

[@SkyZeroGigaByte]

A little detailed I loved about death is rewatching the movie, on 4:08 Death says “Everyone thinks they’ll be the one to defeat me, but no one’s escaped me yet” and I love how he said escaped instead of defeat implying death can’t be escaped by anybody

[@Ruby_Sky]

i know its been 6 months, but isn't the whole point that he escaped? you should've said death can't be defeated by anybody, but it clearly can be escaped

[@shieldgenerator7]

@@Ruby_Skynot forever tho

[@maxantubegaming]

What I love about the fact that Puss died because he thought cats always land on their feet is the fact that in the first movie it's established that cats always landing on their feet is just a rumor spread by dogs, meaning in that scene puss was so drunk he believed in propaganda about his own species.

[@wstine79]

Jiminy: "YOU'RE HORRIBLE! YOU'RE AN UNREDEEMABLE MONSTER!" Jack: "Uh, uh, what took you so long? Idiot!" My favorite part of the film.

[@REDNDEAD]

"Jack Horner would be amazing at CinemaSins."

[@PlebNC]

Also he's not called Jiminy because Disney lawyers. I think his actual name in the credits is something generic like Morality Bug or something, which is fine because no one says his name in the film and what he's satirising is obvious.

[@sogeking4958]

​@@PlebNC Jiminy has already appeared in the Shrekverse. He was in a some kind of special and he looked completely different

[@PlebNC]

@@sogeking4958 Eh, everyone knows specials are soft canon anyway.

[@mackielunkey2205]

I had a huge belly laugh in the theatre during that scene.

[@majestyqueenie]

Fun fact: The scene where Jack Horner looses his attention to Pinocchio is ironic now, since this movie lost the Oscar to Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio, thus meaning Jack once again lost to Pinocchio

[@beteopod]

Wow. I'm amazed your hands were able to grasp such a tiny, insignificant straw.

[@InsultMeCauseYoureScared]

@@beteopodand I’m amazed that you’re literally just being toxic for no reason. You must be a “special needs” person.

[@AngelWingsYT]

XD ok thats funny

[@InsultMeCauseYoureScared]

@@beteopod every like you get is another report you get.

[@moorsh88]

That's not irony.

[@bluefiremarkii]

the intentions of the map was to help you realize you do not need what you think you need. for Perrito, he had everything he needed. For Puss, He saw his past lives and what a jerk he was. He doesn't need them. For Softpaws, hers was about being alone, how she does not trust anybody, but their path helped her realize she has puss. For goldi, it made her realize that she already has a family she can love, and the bears are already content with what they have. We do not see horners but he doesnt have to learn anything. His is purely selfish and he knows it.

[@_WaffleWith_Depression]

Great point I never thought of the fact that we don't see Jacks path

[@artsman412]

How did they not take any sins off for the scene where Perrito helps Puss with his panic attack?!? That scene was so heartwarming and sincere, that deserved at least 3 sins off.

[@JosepiThe13th]

Legit that scene makes me cry. As someone who has panic attacks, they portrayed like perfectly 😭

[@10RexTheWolf01]

9:47 Actually the map reflects what's in your heart and it doesn't make you less worthy of a wish, it even tried to help Goldie by having her realize she already has a family.

[@AngelWingsYT]

Just makes it harder easier depending on what you plan to use the wish for. Hence puss n kitty have the hardest paths and most deadly

[@PrincessGamer]

It was a really neat way of doing that bit. This movie was very very creative.

[@bloodwolfgaming9269]

One of my favorite little details I missed the first time was when Goldie was reading the book in their "fantasy version" of their home, the first letters of each sentence more or less spells out that she already has what she is looking for (Or something along those lines....I don't recall the exact wording).

[@10RexTheWolf01]

@@AngelWingsYT Funny how the therapy dog is the only one who doesn't need therapy.

[@AngelWingsYT]

@@10RexTheWolf01 it is very interesting as even therapists tend to need one themselves...but in a way i think thats what can make them the best therapist Im majoring in psychology (therapist area) I been through a lotta shit growing up even needed therapy myself but i came to learn it was my hardships that help make me better at my goal. I can relate and emphasize better :)

[@NickEclipse]

I better see a lot of sins taken away. This movie was a true masterpiece.

[@Fictionboy16]

Were four good enough for you? - The animation decisions during the fight with the giant - Perito, even if he is a goofy sidekick - The map changing depending on whomever is holding it - "What did I do to deserve this? I mean what specifically?"

[@Sefirofe]

@@Fictionboy16 Considering their history, 4 sins removed is a victory

[@Fictionboy16]

@@Sefirofe Yeah, it is. And to strengthen your argument, half of me didn't expect sin removals because they aren't too kind to the Shrek franchise, not even the first Puss in Boots movie. And this sequel is way better than the original anyway, so the video could've gone either way.

[@duncancurtis5971]

And the dark death themes!

[@mrtoast244]

@@Fictionboy16 This movie can be enjoyed completely seperate to the Shrek movies, or even the first Puss in Boots movie, so even though it's in the shrek-verse it doesn't really feel like it. It's one of those once a year type films, like into the spiderverse, where if you even have some vague idea of who the MC is then that's enough to enjoy it.

[@incertnamehere]

The reason puss had 8 empty glasses at the bar when death first appeared was to symbolize his 8 past lives, as he is working on the 9th. Also I love the fact that you added a sin for Jack Horner not being a nuanced villain, while adding another sin for Goldilocks being a nuanced villain, yes I laughed.

[@thomascampbell4535]

I was waiting for someone to mention it!

[@radioactiveleprechaun2604]

Like half of these sins can be rebutted with a simple “that’s the point of the movie”

[@jettdoesrandomstuff4892]

But always remember the phrase “but movie’s gotta movie”

[@TheCommenterDragon]

I love "Puss In Boots: The Last Wish!" the animation is incredible and it was such a treat to hear Antonio and Salma reprise their roles as Puss and Kitty after 11 years since the first film came out! And one of my all time favorite characters is Death he looked totally badass especially with those sickle blades!

[@Adorablepizza146]

I know right! This is my favorite movie ❤

[@ivywt]

agreeed. i watched this movie twice and it’s really good

[@theminecraftbro661]

those SICKle blades

[@TheCommenterDragon]

@@theminecraftbro661 That's literally what those blades are called sickles.

[@jonnypope1537]

@@TheCommenterDragon I believe he was saying that those sickle blades are in fact sick

[@tumorzoomer2813]

Im kinda surprised death didnt get any sin removals or that scene with perrito acting as a therapy dog.

[@khiyonfennell4233]

I feel like he didn’t want to remove too many sins

[@lexnight8345]

@@khiyonfennell4233 Agree skipped a lot of scenes that could easily remove sins

[@gentblue]

​@@lexnight8345 It's still a Shrek spin-off movie. There are standards to maintain.

[@lexnight8345]

@gentblue 🤣🤣🤣 but is not Shrek like the best animated movie... the only one who forced the Academy to award it ?

[@snackeater4990]

@@insidescuff Cinema wins didn’t cover puss in boots…..

[@paulharper4196]

Saw this at the cinema a couple of months ago with my 7 year old, we both had a blast, was one of those perfectly balanced movies where he enjoyed all the obvious jokes and I enjoyed the story and the more subtle aimed at adults stuff.

[@SuperPaperMarioMovieGuy]

I'm surprised you didn't sin the fact that Puss and Kitty were mad at Perito when they saw that that their "wanted" poster said "Team Friendship", as if criminals get to design their own "wanted" posters.

[@jerichojones2722]

one really cool thing i noticed watching this movie, that i see nobody talk about, is how death left puss alone when he decided to retire his old life. all that time he spent in the retirement home, and lobo never bothered him. death never wanted to kill puss, just kill the idea of him. thats why he only started chasing him again when he decided to try to get that wish so he could return to his former self.

[@dairoleon2682]

Lobo stopped chasing "retired" Puss because he was already dead inside.

[@TheOneMagpie]

I wish they stuck to that a bit more. I would've much preferred if Death never had any intent whatsoever to kill Puss. In fact, the movie felt like it had a bit of an older draft of the script stuck in it, where it was originally Death simply 'chasing' Puss to where he would eventually get himself killed due to the fear of dying to begin with. I was really surprised by the fight scene and felt like the writers only deemed it necessary by the rule of cool.

[@jerichojones2722]

@@dairoleon2682 exactly. it gives even more credence to the motivation of lobo. which wasnt to kill puss, because he could do that whenever he wanted too, he wanted to kill this arrogant, vanity fueled creature that didnt value life.

[@thegeneralgamer4921]

​@@TheOneMagpie it's Death lol, and the fight scene was to show Death didn't want to actually kill Puss. Death knows death better than anyone, so he knows the value of life more than anyone too probably. He was frustrated with Puss because Puss never took his lives seriously, so he likely just wanted to scare him into doing so. Of all the times Death could have killed Puss, he never did, and he only stopped when Puss realized the value of his life.

[@oxygenwaste714]

Yeah. The scene where he fights puss and at the end says "I came here for an arrogant little legend who thought he was immortal" gives a pretty good indicator of his motivations. He only wanted to make a fearless hero scared.

[@joecool2987]

It’s super cool this movie has villains. Like Shaffrillas said “It really makes you question what are other studios doing in terms of their villains”

[@TippyHippy]

I put my hamster in a sock and slammed it against the furniture

[@joecool2987]

@@TippyHippy ok. But what does that have to do with what I said

[@jonnypope1537]

@@joecool2987 he's a villain?

[@joecool2987]

@@jonnypope1537 no shaffrillas is a KZbin channel Edit: My B my dude

[@thegeneralgamer4921]

@@joecool2987 he was responding to your question, not asking about shaffrillas...

[@Valetravelgames]

14:48 I JUST LOVE THE SMELL OF SHIT

[@Tsupek]

14:16 alright I’m fine with most of the other sins, but the fact he doesn’t remove a sin off for this , nor for the beautiful scene between perrito and puss in the forest. Hurts

[@QuillWorks]

I love how Dreamworks had absolutely no reason to go this hard for Puss in Boots 2 yet they did and it came out AMAZING

[@TheWinjin]

And also how they heavily dunk on modern Disney through Horner. I hope this means next Shrek is somewhat better at least. I won't expect it to be as good as this PiB though.

[@ze89412]

⁠@@TheWinjinin my opinion it goes Pixar, Dreamworks and Disney for animated movies that hit the soul

[@Dora-xi5ob]

@@TheWinjinencanto was a year before this

[@Dora-xi5ob]

@@ze89412 encanto was only a year before this

[@nellaethelflaed1248]

Isn't this puss in boots 3?

[@wstine79]

Little Jack Horner was my favorite character in the movie. John Mulaney was hilarious in the role. It's nice to have a villain that's just evil.

[@SpiderkillersInc]

Little Jack Horner didn't have any magic. He was a sad, pathetic, buttered, baker's boy. Little Jack's dead! I'm Big Jack Horner!

[@panmateusz]

It's not only nice but It's also a very intentional decision to create such a villain. Puss in boots TLW uses classic fairy tales to create a universal message. In such world a truly evil villain is perfect because It creates a strong contrast between him and the protagonists. Not to say that Jack Horner can be interpreted as a ctricism for modern sympathetic villains. The message is simple but effective in this case: "Sometimes evil is just evil and we shouldn't find excuses for that but just fight with it until it's too late".

[@happybroski2112]

Jack works because Death and the bears are also antagonists. Death drives the story and the bears are on their own sub journey so they could get away with having a comically evil Jack without ruining the movie’s stakes and plot importance

[@rbreachgamer54]

erm ackshually its *big* jack horner

[@thetapperhatz_laboratories2574]

@@SpiderkillersInc beat me to it…

[@rock21611]

Strike one, Puss didn't break the fourth wall. He was asking the giant if he wanted to see something cool, which was the bell headed at his face.

[@bluntlyhonest6803]

3:54 The wolf actually starts cussing at the end in spanish obout how he was fool for playing with his food/prey. So he acknowledges what he did was dumb.

[@derpylovecosplay]

This movie did not deserve to be this good, but it's now considered one of my top 10 favorite animated movies of all time! I had my doubts, but now I love this film!

[@LukeMaps]

For much of the movie, I consider it Pixar-quality minus the excessive expletive-bleeping--just don't have the expletives in the first place, but the animation is very unique with the movie's "Head of Look."

[@dragon3010lol]

​@@LukeMaps The explitive bleeping was the punchline to the best joke in the entire movie.

[@paulharper4196]

It was brilliant, probably in my top 5 animateds ever. I recently watched the super Mario movie and that wasn't a patch on this. My friend said he thought Mario was miles better, I wondered if he actually watched this one because this is a hard 8/10 would definitely watch again movie, and Mario was a very generic run of the mill 5/10 no reason to ever watch it again movie. For me anyway.

[@gemstar5242]

7:54 Also, it’s pretty obvious that Kitty wanted Jack Horner to see that the map was inside the box first, and then make her move after he’s been further convinced that it’s in his possession, and he’s more likely to leave it unattended for longer, buying her some time. (Edit: added time stamp)

[@thegeneralgamer4921]

yeah I don't know why they sinned that. if she waited until Jack Horner left, she'd be all alone and easily be able to take the map and leave unnoticed. She only had to reveal herself because Puss took the map, ruining her plan

[@instantchaos2385]

he's saying why was she waiting for them to arrive to his room in the first place and not steal it way earlier

[@Enderpig124]

4:25 actually, this is a camera trick used in real life. By standing really far away and zooming back in, perspectives change. Think of a distant city, now the moon sets over it and the city looks tiny by comparison.

[@ninjabunnywholivesinsideaw8216]

4:03 Can't believe he didn't realize that those eight empty glasses represent Puss's eight death's. Puss is on his ninth glass of creme as well as his last life!

[@naninyan]

I really like the self contradictory "nuance villain in kid movie" sin joke for both Goldi & Jack, almost a subtle praise to they nail it doing both in one film

[@annasilvestre2984]

Cinemasins is cynical and overly critical, it’s their whole thing. I had to do a double-take on the Goldie sin, but then I realized how funny it was.

[@craigroberts4434]

Ok Death was straight up one of the best most charismatic characters i'v seen animated in years! Need to see more of him in the follow up movies.

[@PrincessGamer]

Yup the completely nailed Death, and that scene got me too, I felt that in my soul. The animation was that good.

[@valkeitos]

When puss finally realised it was death, it's that scene that sold me on the movie let alone that it was my favourite scene by far

[@Turtleman2009]

After all, he’s Death. Straight up.

[@jaket2734]

Absolutely! Super creepy and cool. Perfectly executed. ;)

[@RosheenQuynh]

​@@Turtleman2009 Beat me to it lol

[@esmevigil23]

3:54 I disagree with this sin only because he never causes others people’s death just collects them, but Puss pissed him off so much he said fine I’ll do it myself

[@matityaloran9157]

2:17, I would defend that on the part of the film on the grounds that it’s establishing how arrogant and egotistical Puss is which is something important to the film as it’s about Puss overcoming those flaws

[@eljaminlatour6633]

4:02 that's intentional symbolism because the 8 empty cups represent the amount of lives Puss has lot, Puss is drinking his 9th cup meaning that he's currently living on his 9th life.

[@VYDEOS2]

Yeah no shit, but it wouldn't make sense cause he can just refill the same cup multiple times

[@angrybritishman9461]

@@VYDEOS2it’s a movie Easter egg pipe down

[@VYDEOS2]

@@angrybritishman9461 it was just so fcking obvious

[@agentsauce1966]

This movie is an absolute masterpiece

[@randompolygon8401]

wouldn't go that far, but it's great. 9/10

[@Tylermiller778]

@@randompolygon8401 it is a masterpiece though

[@TheSuperMarioBrosMovieFan2003]

@@Tylermiller778 it’s my favorite movie

[@user-vs9ds3dc2y]

It's great but Death is overrated

[@TheSuperMarioBrosMovieFan2003]

@@user-vs9ds3dc2y Death is part of life

[@JT_VA]

4:02 Him pointing out the 8 empty glasses of milk made me realise a subtle nod to the film’s premise that makes me love this film even more

[@kingbushybeard6543]

I think the movie does show nuance in its villains but just with different characters. Jack is the irredeemable evil for the sake of evil character, Goldi is the sympathic villain, and death is the evil as a force of nature villain.

[@ya_man_poolzy_innit1110]

I loved the part where he said “absolutely nothing” because this movie is perfect

[@playboi.monke_7658]

Unlike the stuff that Jeremy calls a sin for no reason

[@randompolygon8401]

95% of the sins in this one are jokes. and the remaining 5% are pretty subjective criticisms

[@hateyouhumans20666]

I think you meant this movie is PURRRfect ;p

[@PrincessGamer]

@@hateyouhumans20666 LOL

[@treyrex5987]

​@@randompolygon8401 I don't know if you see the problem there or not.

[@alexisvandom8037]

That Cold War sin was top-tier. Also, this is one of the best animated movies ever. Be nice to it, damn it! AND HOW DID YOU NOT TAKE SINS OFF FOR DEATH, MAN?!

[@KemoniAnimations]

I don’t get the Cold War one.. can you explain it to me?

[@Rex_Thanos]

​@@KemoniAnimations two hints: cold war from the 90's and the present Russian-Ukrainian war

[@KemoniAnimations]

@@Rex_Thanos ohhhhhh makes sense lol

[@TARISLAYS]

@@Rex_Thanos OHHHHHH

[@NoMercy13567]

Death’s whistle still gives me goosebumps even now. That final fight was so good and I hope they will make more puss in boots stuff instead of more shrek stuff

[@dragonstarwolf559]

I love how he has to constantly find bs excuses to give this movie sins lmao "It's way better than this movie... but you made me think of this movie so SIN"

[@treyrex5987]

Ikr?!

[@thenyan3095]

It’s a joke channel, calm your shit please I thought we all knew this by now

[@just_a_butterfly]

I'm very mad you didn't take a sin off for one of the best representations of panic attack in media

[@DroZzhat]

Honestly, for what an amazing job they did with this movie, it should've ended up with negative sins. It was a very rare masterpiece, especially when one holds it up against the past few years of movies.

[@ellieholmes608]

I’ve always liked the puss in boots spin offs but this was by far my absolute favourite. As an 18 year old, I still enjoyed every single part of this film. It felt honestly very directed to teens more so than kids.

[@mjserrano32]

4:42 okay but why did this make me laugh so hard

[@dessert506]

At around the 4:20 mark where it talks about Puss escaping death, wasn't the whole ending of the movie about how Puss did not in fact escape death, he excepted his death and Death decided to wait for Puss last life to end instead of taking it himself

[@VYDEOS2]

If he didn't escape death he'd be dead

[@saltygibus5746]

Yeah, no clue why he sinned on an assumption. Did it again at Perrito's Backstory.

[@amentlik]

Yes, Death was angry Puss was acting as if he was immortal. Death was teaching him a lesson about humility, but the point of the movie is that Puss learned that lesson so Death didn't need to prove any point. I thought it was really well done, but, Jeremy's got a job to do I guess.

[@albegian]

This is probably going to be one of the most watched cinemasins videos of this year. I'm glad I jumped into it early. Kudos

[@playboi.monke_7658]

What's up

[@meta527II]

Lucky. I have to go to work first before I can watch this.

[@stoagymahalo5268]

Honestly, the brief moments of "seeing" what you fear IS what I see when panicking, almost like believing the fear is all around you AND the fact a perfect reason to have a guide dog is in that scene. Bravo

[@lurlinmasmultifandom]

The 8 empty glasses are actually a metaphor to Puss's 8 lost lives and he only has one left.

[@geardog24]

11:12 "Why does this work but the chopping didn't?" Well it is Phoenix fire 🔥. That stuff works on anything.

[@LazyOldFusspot_3428]

Even Dumbledore wouldn't try doing this against Voldemort...

[@BambinaSaldana]

Also don't they multiply when you cut them? Because it could be a reference to the Hydra, where Hercules' cousin cauterized the wounds so they wouldn't grow back.

[@calvinmatthews1527]

Goldi is the sympathetic villain, Death is the pure evil villain with a purpose, & Jack is the wonderfully irredeemable villain. How could you not understand that Jeremy?

[@beteopod]

Because that's redundant nonsense? How tf would a villain that's "pure evil" not be irredeemable as well? Typical cinemasins fan, barely any thoughts used to make comments

[@InsultMeCauseYoureScared]

@@beteopod Says the guy who comments on his videos without reading the replies. I know you love Cinemasins, but don’t be an arsehole.

[@AngelWingsYT]

​@@beteopodi mean name a villian worse the literal death himself? That is the most evil BUT he is just doing his job. He isnt evil to be evil

[@darkseeker1112]

Because CinemaSins needs to make lame jokes become sins to stay relevant.

[@cyan789]

Jeremy and understanding don't go well together.

[@hanako-kun22]

14:56 This sin really bothered me because 1. We already have a irredeemable ruthless villain in this movie 2. Goldilocks and the Three Bears serve as antagonists to Puss, they’re all working toward the same goal but in opposing teams. 3. Just because something is directed at kids doesn’t mean it needs to be overly dumbed down. Children are a lot smarter then society gives them credit for, and it’s a breath of fresh air to have a piece of film intended for younger audiences (ESPECIALLY animation) to not talk down to its viewers. The movie’s themes are about learning to live with the fact that death is ever looming in our lives, and how to cherish every moment. That’s a valuable lesson for EVERY age because no matter what part of your life you’re in it’s important to face your mortality and learn to deal with it. I would like to go on a rant (kinda just did) about this but others have done it better

[@mrtoast244]

I love when really good movies have longer CinemaSins videos, it lets me rewatch more of the movie in these

[@saintkofi]

You just made me realise the animators used the 8 empty glasses of milk to signify his 8 lives lost. epic

[@PlebNC]

If half the creativity of this movie was used in the previous Shrek movies, the franchise would be worthy of the memetic obsession it has and Dreamworks would actually be a strong contender for one-upping Disney the way it was spitefully founded on. (No seriously, Dreamworks exists because its founder was kicked out of Disney and wanted to spite them. It's why Shrek is a giant satire of Disney fairy tale movies.)

[@momoluvr123]

Also when the camera enters that scene, you hear eight bell chimes in the background and then the candle above flickers out 😉

[@mythicaldragon4354]

I just want to mention a random detail I found in Death's last scene. When he walked away, the fire moved in the same direction as him as if it was blown by the wind. When he stopped for a second, it also stopped. Pretty neat.

[@matityaloran9157]

0:19, unfortunately yes

[@PanSpaceman]

3:00 take a nice look at the corners of the "1" "2" "3" etc cards flashing for puss's death. Love the details in this movie.

[@playboi.monke_7658]

2:52 jermy hasn't heard of the myth that cats have 9 lives. The movie literally explains to you that puss has used up all but 1 life

[@playboi.monke_7658]

11:31 Jeremy sins an animated movie for being comedic

[@AMS-KungPao]

16:30 I guess you completely missed the actual message of that scene that we should value our lives more as we just have one and we shouldn't just give it up without a fight.

[@Dr.Pelican-bw2zs]

Yep, completely understand why this guy has 9.17 mill subs. Very good critic does not radiate ignorance, apathy, or a lack of knowledge when attempting to discern thematic elements.

[@alyssawilson4870]

The eight glasses on the table at the bar scene where Death is first introduced are supposed to represent his eight previous lives - they're all gone, but he's on his ninth life - and in this scene, he's drinking his ninth shot, which he does not finish completely.

[@Driggsdamonstah]

“You’re Horrible! You’re an irredeemable MONSTER!!!” “Oh! OH! What took you so long? IDIOT!”

[@christianparrish3292]

Any scene in any movie or show becomes a meme.

[@therealagfeild]

15:40 “”😂

[@THEDANCINGCENTIPEDE]

A little fact: Death is based on the folkloric character of the Grim Reaper, whereas the tune he whistles is based on The Silbón, a legend associated with the Los Llanos region of Colombia and Venezuela.

[@michaelhill7308]

how did you not catch that the 8 empty milk shots represent the lives he's lost lol

[@playboi.monke_7658]

16:52. He does so to demonstrate to death that he won't be taken down so easily. He won't go down without a fight

[@playboi.monke_7658]

16:57 death leaves because he realizes that puss isn't the careless and irresponsible cat he was going after earlier and that it's going to take more to take him down

[@rerite-oy4xu]

honestly, him leaving was a breath of fresh air, instead of getting defeated. we know he's holding back enough to test puss considering he got the chance to kill him multiple times, and he didnt

[@Kaltsit-]

I will say that Death wasn’t doing his job. He wanted to kill Puss prematurely, literally going against his job.

[@frisby_ninja]

I can't believe that the Death whistle's orchestral version in the final fight wasn't a sin off or even in the video. That had my spine tingling like MAD. One of the most insane animated movie fights EVER. 10/10!

[@playboi.monke_7658]

16:12 Jeremy criticizes what death does with his weapons

[@playboi.monke_7658]

15:00 that's not what they're doing, they're showing that Goldilocks feels ashamed of her bear family because they are slow sometimes. The whole moral of the movie is that you don't need a wish to be happy, you only have one life ans you're the only one who decides how you want to live it

[@theworm7156]

He’s jokingly contradicting himself

[@playboi.monke_7658]

@@theworm7156 "jokingly" sure buddy. Keep stroking Jeremy off, I'm sure that'll help you late in life

[@matityaloran9157]

7:40, these five seconds were the best Pinocchio movie of the year

[@stegosaurus993]

You can tell he's really nitpicking here, even by Cinemasins standard. I have no idea why this masterpiece of a film doesn't have a CinemaWins video yet

[@playboi.monke_7658]

15:02 Jeremy acts as though no kids have ever wanted to be a part of someone else's family, whether it's a celeb or an influencer

[@playboi.monke_7658]

17:31 they aren't making a wish because they realized that what they wished for was right in front of them the whole time. Goldilocks loves her family more and puss is happy with his 1 life

[@sonicfanboy3375]

Bro thinks he's th3birdman ☠️

[@playboi.monke_7658]

​@@sonicfanboy3375 for sinning this idiots sins? That's like saying every rapper wants to be Travis scott cus they all make rap music

[@playboi.monke_7658]

​@@sonicfanboy3375 and I ain't your "bro",

[@LotionBottle428]

@@playboi.monke_7658 no, just stop. Don’t make me send you on time out again.

[@Ruby_Sky]

No, No. any of them could've wished for both themselves and the ones they care about to become immortal or something, thus avoiding death while also majorly helping the ones they care about, there was zero reason to not do this

[@seanjordan2147]

Wizard of Paws” is actually the title of a television show about building animal prosthetics. Yes, I understand. He’s making a joke, but I’d be sad if I don’t take the opportunity to Sin a sin. 8:54.

[@shinoteseu]

What sets this movie apart from any other Shrek movie is that it makes the point to appreciate life. Death stalks puss because he does not appreciate his own life, and recklessly throws it into meaningless endeavors . Meanwhile, Jack Horner appreciates his own life so much, he walks over the lives of many others to preserve his own. Death is so aggravated by the fact the puss dies and spits in the face of him, that he makes him a personal vendetta. When death gives up the chase in the final fight and throws a tantrum his line in Spanish is: "¿Por qué diablos fui a jugar con mi comida?" translates to "Why the hell did I play with my food?" Death could have killed puss at any point.

[@playboi.monke_7658]

10:40 Jeremy acts as if puss and his friends are the only ones after the wish

[@DawnzeenaMcGill]

I mean I feel like it was implied that the bears and Goldie bypassed the flowers because they were physically knocked off the path. However it’s also shown Baby is great at tracking by scent so he could have easily found their way to them by tracking Horner’s scent alone

[@Legendendear]

I thought it was because they came after Jack so they would pass through the burned down flower field

[@DawnzeenaMcGill]

@@Legendendear yeah which they would have done by tracking him by his scent

[@redscallionanimations2167]

Maybe Baby sniffed the flowers, and accidentally had the flowers let them through, lol

[@SharkkTheEditor]

12:16 is literally that scene in Jumanji 2

[@bloomerangplays6669]

0:26 where's Captain Underpants too?

[@playboi.monke_7658]

15:50 yep, they did have a change of heart, its called character development

[@playboi.monke_7658]

15:57 Jeremy threatens the viewer knowing full well he wouldn't actually do what was said

[@dmaxwell910901]

The fact that the film never feels like it's being held back by the fact it's a supposed "kid's film" just makes it so much better. Usually in such films (even great ones), you just know nobody's actually going to die, so even the action scenes are so much less intense. And when people do die, it's either intentionally vague, completely offscreen or just faceless goons. In this one? Jack Horner's clearly human henchman, who constantly get humanized in little ways, all die pretty brutal deaths directly onscreen. It really feels like this film was made first and foremost for adults, while still being made entertaining enough for children.

[@HaZa917]

15:48 Jeremy threatens you with a hug lol

[@playboi.monke_7658]

13:29 Jeremy thinks a villain is not supposed to fully be an asshole

[@VoodooVDO]

He's not eating an apple

[@TheWarmachine375]

Puss in Boots The Last Wish is pure unadulterated badass and awesome to watch.

[@roccogough254]

2:04 Hello. I am the 345th fanboy here to tell you that this is not a fourth wall break. We are seeing the scene from the giant's POV. Good day.

[@maxanluulnaxam1102]

Aah. I wanted a sin off for Perrito getting to be an actual therapy dog for Puss when he has a panic-attack.

[@gemstar5242]

The audio outtakes for this one were phenomenal lmao

[@dday906]

Never thought DreamWorks could make one of my top 3 favorite versions of Death on any screen. This guy was awesome in this movie!

[@zachcox94]

Just cause I'm curious, what are the other two?

[@dday906]

@@zachcox94 Grim from The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy and Death from Supernatural.

[@Konani_the_unicorn_queen]

man, i was expecting terry pratchett's death too, but to be fair, he's probably better in the books

[@divadiva1968]

this film made me learn to respect and be grateful for the people around you and especially not to be afraid of death, it is true that death should not be feared but there is a reason why you are afraid of death itself. sometimes I am afraid of death because I cant grow as better person or what would happen after i died or afraid if my mother die first because I have not been able replace my mother's position who works here and there for support me and lil brother

[@DoctorSherbet]

😂 I laughed so hard where at the end you have the movie clips and you add a different line. "You! Your supposed to be dead" "I got better"