Everything Wrong With Treasure Planet In 18 Minutes Or Less

[@ForeverTraitor]

I actually appreciate the movie showing Jim's dad just straight up leaving him, it's different from Disney's usual cliche of "your parent(s) loved you so much but tragically died".

[@mjm3091]

Probably, because it's a broad adaptation of 1883 book, lol - and also not first or the last one.

[@ForeverTraitor]

@@mjm3091 Child Jim chasing his dad down to the docks and just missing him with his dad not even looking back is unique to this one though. And some pretty powerful imagery at that.

[@mjm3091]

@@ForeverTraitor yeah, I guess you are right.

[@maidenofthelight]

Or just straight up die or get one line of mention

[@gamewiz720]

​@@ForeverTraitor100th like

[@Jonathan_Collins]

Disney's experimental era is, to this day, my favorite. Treasure Planet, Atlantis, Brother Bear, and Dinosaurs were/are a pivotal moment to me, and anytime I'm feeling like life has kicked me to the ground, these movies help inspire me to get up. Without a doubt, it's a treasure of a film in itself!

[@lloydkranz8159]

Brother bear🫡

[@Surproodles]

Treasure Planet and Atlantis are to this day my absolute favourites! 🥺

[@Wolf36181]

I loved Atlantis but brother bear scared me 😭

[@MarcDize]

All but Dinosaur were extremely great storytelling.

[@harleyhart1497]

​@@Wolf36181Brother Bear scared you!? Why!?

[@TheCommenterDragon]

Treasure Planet itself is a treasure of a film!

[@Szokynyovics]

It flopped, but most people know about it and everybody fucking loves it, so no... it is not underrated. One of the most famous and most beloved Disney movies out there, you cannot spend a week online without seeing people (rightfully) praising this movie... So no. Not underrated. Stop saying "underrated" to anything you like. I swear, half a year ago someone called Gary Fuckin Oldman underrated. STOP! It is an asenine trend.

[@TheCommenterDragon]

@@Szokynyovics Trying telling that do the other people I saw in the comment saying the exact same thing.

[@Maestrohbill]

this movie sucked. The end.

[@irregularsloth214]

​@@Maestrohbilljust like yo momma at that mandingo party.

[@Maestrohbill]

@@irregularsloth214 Or your wife every evening with the pimp nearby.

[@drewcifur3443]

"You lose a few things chasing a dream" is such a hard line. It not only shows Silver's ambition but parallels Jim's dad leaving his family to chase his dream.

[@LiterallyJustF]

The bonding montage between Jim and Long John Silver still makes me cry to this day, beautiful scene in a beautiful movie. Still my favourite disney movie of all time.

[@jazminevaughan5635]

Saaaammee

[@dkjcb3993]

God this is so real. As a kid, this scene certainly made me emotional, but I when I became an adult, I rewatched the movie after many years and it just hit so much harder. Being near tears in this bonding montage, only for silver to betray Jim hurt so much more. Only betrayal in fiction that truly hurts to me

[@LivingFire_BurningFlame]

Treasure Planet and Atlantis: The Lost Empire are my two favorite "forgotten" or "lost" Disney movies. They were both passion projects that dared to break the traditional "Disney movie" formula, and wound up at the bottom of the pile due to Disney failing to follow up on them because they were so different from what they traditionally do.

[@volusian95]

By far my favorite Disney movies as a kid, and I didn't realize until recently how strange it was that one else every talked about them, Disney doesn't keep them alive in any way, etc.

[@LemonOnARock_]

Never saw Treasure Planet but Atlantis was and still is one of my favorite animated movies. I wish this animation was used more

[@WhoCares-i3o]

they literally made a sequel to Atlantis so your attempt to make it seem like some kind of unknown movie is cliche comment section douche-shit

[@isaacgleeth3609]

@@LemonOnARock_ Having Mike Mignola, creator of _Hellboy_ , as production designer was a great decision

[@OkayYaraman]

They may be forgotten, but they aren’t lost. You can still buy and stream them. Things like Buzz Lightyear of Star Command however are lost because there is no legal way to watch them anymore despite them being just as underrated.

[@bad-girl-coventhe-owl-club1119]

Captain Amelia was really inspiring to me as a kid because I think she was the first female character I'd seen that was a leader and everyone just accepted that she was the captain without her gender being a barrier. The pirates didn't turn against her because she was female, they just wanted the treasure. Like, her ability was never in question, she was strong and assertive and proud of herself, but also pretty and kind... and none of it got questioned. She didn't have to defend who she was. It meant so much to me as a kid.

[@Surproodles]

THIS

[@gg1909]

Your comment need to be pined! I remember loving Amelia character

[@OnlyGetty]

Because her character was written to be great. She wasn't a great captain because she was a woman, she was a great captain that happened to be a woman. It's a nuance that makes a huge difference.

[@bloggerblogg5878]

Yes, she is a positive woman leader character, which we have less. The best in it she doesn't have to prove herself continuously, unlike many others.

[@jonsmith5058]

@@OnlyGetty well thats largely cause its a simple effective gender swap where they dont make the reskinned character revolve around said swapped gender.

[@GermanGoestoTheMovies]

As someone who grew up without a father figure (my dad was very absent, he divorced my mom and then died young) scenes like Silver comforting Jim touch my heart. And when he tells him "I hope I'm there catching some of the light coming off you that day"... damn, I lose it there.

[@Rembreiker_lychec9257]

This movie was ahead of its time. It tackled many adult topics that we didn't fully comprehend when we were kids. I loved Treasure Planet. I'll never understand why (nor forgive) Disney for bailing on it.

[@hinata1ize]

What adult topics?

[@PFirefly06]

Ahead of its time how? Dealing with needing to grow up and make something of yourself? Not being self centered? Willing to sacrifice for others? Been done a million times before in other kids movies. Still a great movie and broke ground on cgi animation.

[@Szokynyovics]

​@@PFirefly06"ahead of its time" and "underrated" are two expressions used without realizing what they mean... it is daunting, really, that the meaning of words mean nothing to so many people...

[@mjm3091]

How is this ahead of its time when it's based on 1883 Novel.

[@Fiery_Latina_Goatchan_GF_681]

​​@@hinata1izeadandonment issues and adolescent rebellion with out his father he became a bit of a trouble maker but oncw he joined the crew the hard work helped him along the way and developing a friendship. To then seeing a father figure in longjohn that he really longed for especially how longjohn gave up his lifes wishes to find flints treasure and sacrified the wealth of treasure planet to save jim

[@spilleraaron4748]

The biggest sin is how underrated this movie is!!

[@anubusx]

I agree i really like this film.

[@justinanderson267]

The biggest sin is him calling a Star Trek reference Star Wars

[@Iffy350]

@@justinanderson267 Only disney fans don’t get that literally no one cares

[@Wraith8082]

The lore behind Treasure Planet is crazy, the executives basically tanked the film internally to make sure it would never see the light of day again from a business standpoint

[@BrokensoulRider]

It's still a massive cult classic hit. It fucked up in box office, but its DVD/digital sales are through the roof.

[@chadharger9323]

Probably the same execs who wanted full 3d.

[@gabrielbush1325]

Oh yeah, that's 100% what it was. They deliberately limited advertising for the movie in order to "justify" a full transition to 3DCGI by saying nobody wants 2D anymore.@@chadharger9323

[@DragonGoddess18]

Well,yeah, Disney intentionally released it around the same time as Harry and the Chamber of Secrets

[@nathandomke2721]

Yup the marketing was intentionally godawful

[@fizzypurple5495]

Love the semi-resurgence this film is seeing lately. Truly a forgotten gem

[@nicolasdecastro2510]

Silver was such a unique Disney character. One minute he seems like the typical villain but next scene he’s a supportive father figure. They couldn’t put him in a box, he’s in a category of his own.

[@WhoCares-i3o]

Yeah...that was Disney lol. Not like they straight up stole the characters from a book that predates the movie by a century or so lol

[@mjm3091]

Well it's because he isn't a Disney character.

[@sarahlamper5701]

@@WhoCares-i3oto be fair, he’s not really a father figure in the book. He’s charming, sure, but in the book Jim has no daddy issues so no real reason to look up to Silver like a father like he does in the movie. Disney 1000% did that themselves and it made the movie better

[@yakunohayashi9653]

The scene when Silver motivates Jim deserves a sin off. If you love this movie and you didn’t cry with this scene, then you are not a Treasure Planet fan

[@Konani_the_unicorn_queen]

incorrect; i am just dead inside from circa 30 years of depression :D!

[@bloggerblogg5878]

I always cry in the end when they say goodbye.

[@cyrus_paragon_9291]

Me doing my best not to set the world on fire when he said "Star Wars reference" when it was clearly a Star trek reference while knowing the cinemasins team knows the difference and simply did it to set my brain on fire 😂😂😂😂

[@01134man]

Problem is I dunno if they were just being lazy or not

[@cyrus_paragon_9291]

Highly doubt it. They usually do stuff like that on purpose

[@NobleVI_343]

100% spiteful and intentional

[@lupine.flowers]

i honest to god almost yelled😭

[@jmobbinfoo4838]

So glad I didn't have to look too far for this comment😊 thanks a bunch ☺️

[@calvintabor5734]

Shame you had to replace some of the orchestral music in this film (presumably to avoid copyright) because it is, in my opinion, the best instrumental music in all of Disney's catalog.

[@maidenofthelight]

Yeah, considering the music's from a box office bomb of a movie....

[@NobleVI_343]

@@maidenofthelightnow lookup its digital/ DVD sales

[@crowhogan6854]

To me, who grew up without a father and was raised by my grandfather, this hits home real hard. Treasure Planet is my favourite Disney movie. It taught me that father isn't the one who birthed you, it's the one who raised you. I learned a lot from my gramps. To me, he was my father, just like Silver was for Jim.

[@Mika-ph6ku]

Being in a similar boat, I disagree with the reasoning a bit. Father by definition is the male parent of a child, so your father is the one who "assisted" in birthing you. I've come to make the same distinction you are making, but instead making it a distinction between the terms "father" and "dad." A father is just the man that impregnated your mother, he doesn't hold much significance in your life. Your dad is different though, he is the man that stepped in to raise you to be a strong man/woman yourself. Your father and your dad can be the same person, but can also be two different people. I've never met my father, but I love and respect my dad. Just the way I choose to look at it.

[@melinastoutt9319]

I audibly gasped when I saw this video in my KZbin feed. Treasure Planet is my childhood. I guess Jeremy did have to sin this movie someday, but I can see Jeremy was struggling to find actual sins. I'm happy. Thank you CinemaSins for another sins video.

[@marjosonic]

It saddens me that the incredible work done on this film seldom ever goes acknowledged nowadays. This and Atlantis are treasures (pun intended).

[@xelthos2051]

This movie was a masterpiece and one of the best Disney movies ever made.

[@MrGabeanator]

here here

[@SinHurr]

Glory to me, the 69th like. Also you're super right, this movie rocks face

[@anonymousanonymous4325]

I actually loved the father son bonding part, it was just really relatable as a kid.

[@TheEternalGoth]

If someone hugs me for correctly identifying their obscure nerd-culture tattoo it will absolutely be a highlight of my week.

[@Kaempfdog]

Jim and John Silver are absolutely 10/10 characters in Disneys library. In fact MOST of the main characters are just outstanding. Animation is stellar to boot. Also Dr Doppler I just relate to on a personal level. XD

[@mjm3091]

that's what you get when you base your movie on really good book and change everything (like the times and setting specifically), but the story

[@melevolent]

​@mjm3091 Jesus bruh, you're all over the comments reminding us all. FFS WE KNOW. Most Disney is based on old books and stories. You're not giving anyone any fucking revelations. It's still required reading for lots of people even now. And we've all seen the Muppet Treasure Island too. We're as familiar with the story as we are with Cinderella. Give it a fucking rest.

[@lilypyrope4620]

my fondest memory of this movie was having to painstakingly explain to my friend that it was, in fact, a parallel of Treasure Island This somehow took most of the movie, despite several of the plot beats and even THE CHARACTERS' NAMES being the same

[@cerisejaxel9636]

That’s so funny! I watched a version of Treasure Island at my friend’s house and the whole time I was making referencing Treasure Planet. (“So that one’s the turtle.”)

[@lilypyrope4620]

@@cerisejaxel9636 hehe, that's pretty funny too. Which version did you watch?

[@ScooterinAB]

And the boat, and the old-timey speech, and the flintlock pistols...

[@lilypyrope4620]

@@ScooterinAB I still don't know how it took that long for him to realize it

[@cerisejaxel9636]

@@lilypyrope4620 It was the 2012 version! Just went on a little hunt to find the exact movie, and found out that the actress (Shirley Henderson) who played Jim’s mother also played Moaning Mertle in the Harry Potter movies. Interesting!

[@Wh0isTh3D0ct0r]

12:12 The first Pirates of the Caribbean movie prominently showed skeletons of hanged pirates during the introduction of Jack Sparrow as he approached Port Royal.

[@RebelAngelForever]

AND I--- WANT A MOMENT TO BE REAL! WANNA TOUCH THINGS I DONT FEEL! WANNA HOLD ON, AND FEEL I BELONG! Still gives me the tingles 😭

[@thunderpantz]

Jim Hawkins is the one Disney protagonist to have a parent go out for a pack as opposed to dying.

[@mjm3091]

probably, because it's not Disney protagonist

[@Gamer3427]

@@mjm3091 To be fair, if you clarify that any characters that are based on existing works aren't Disney protagonists, then about 95% of Disney's "protagonists" aren't Disney protagonists. The majority of their biggest properties are based on an existing book or fairy tale, with only a few exceptions. They generally only change a few story beats here and there, usually with the ending getting the most changes to make it happier. No idea why people feel the need to single this one out in the comments section more than the others, especially when it's arguable that they changed more here with it being set in space and featuring various aliens than they changed in the majority of their other works that are based on things.

[@mjm3091]

@@Gamer3427 oh I am fully saying that 95% characters from Disney movies aren't theirs. Disney has appropriated and stolen a lot of ethnic fairy tales and storylines commonly with no respect to original source and culture.

[@ScooterinAB]

Or even had two parents to begin with. I can't tell you how many single-parent protagonists we see in films with zero explanation as to where the other parent is and what this adds to the story.

[@sarahlamper5701]

@@mjm3091except in the OG book Jim had both parents soooo yeah that one was Disney’s doing

[@jarnovanderlaan9002]

6:29 That Hugging Morph-tattoo guy is just a legend😂

[@aliasfakename3159]

The underrated 2000s trinity: Atlantis: the Lost Empire, The Road to El Dorado, & this movie

[@trailingrails9953]

The one film I would have liked a live action adaptation of. You could let the CGI artists go nuts.

[@tanjelly72]

14:20 If you said that was a Star Wars reference ironically to mess with people, then touche, but if not, that's actually a Star Trek reference, not a Star Wars one.

[@TheWarmachine375]

Treasure Planet is an underrated gem.

[@Abyss_Princess]

Treasure Planet is an underrated masterpiece

[@ScooterinAB]

I dunno if I would call it that. It seems pretty insufferable and badly written.

[@chadharger9323]

​@@ScooterinABBEN. . .just . . .BEN.

[@grimreaper99937]

Treasure planet is one of my all time Favorite movies from when i was a kid the dynamic between Silver and Jim is a very well thought out one, Silver was the friend Jim needed and the father he deserved.

[@vitra_]

The animation for this movie has to be one of my favorites from Disney, hands down. The movie is a mix of 2D hand-drawn animation AND 3D animation. Some parts I would say don’t work but it’s honestly incredible for the time what they were able to animate and really created such an incredible fictional Sci-fi world. An amazing example would be Silver himself is practically a literal cyborg because his animation is in pieces. His organic human body was 2D animated while his arm and leg machine attachments were 3D. Even when I rewatch it while I’m much older I cant tell the difference, they colored it so well to blend the two styles together. Still to this day my all time favorite Disney Movie

[@arkkyan]

I honestly loved this film

[@StCla1re]

Same

[@alexjones6114]

You should take off a sin because when silver says bones the second time at 18:48 my friend and his brother thought it was so funny that they would constantly repeat it the way it was said, to the point that their mother banned its usage in their house. Their work around was to say bones like the first when said it

[@newdonktimes2034]

I don’t care how many sins this movie gets it will always be my childhood favorite and still is same with Atlantis.

[@lunaria7415]

Same. They are my favorits❤

[@hckingking]

That tattoo story was hilarious.

[@DisneyLover022]

I love how clear it is that they actually love this movie at CinemaSins-scrambling for sin material there!

[@Trainfan1055Janathan]

When I was a kid, I didn't realize what he meant when he said, "we don't drink." I was like, "You don't drink? Like, ever?"

[@violetphoenix13]

Fun fact, Dr. Doppler was the one who was pregnant. They cut the few lines that mentioned this because they thought it was too risqué. Anyway, this is my favourite Disney movie and I was so fucking excited when I saw this in my subscription feed! (Actually you listed almost all the sins I came up with when I jokingly thought of them one night)

[@jaytrashwade1-1]

How TF did that work?

[@violetphoenix13]

@@jaytrashwade1-1 genitals swap? Idk seahorses got it figured out.

[@jaytrashwade1-1]

@@violetphoenix13 fair point

[@Alskasaur]

Listen, that mid-movie montage set to I’m Still Here is fantastic, how dare you SKIP!

[@ranaewalker4262]

This is one of my absolute favorite Disney movies. It truly is one of the best movies ever, in my own opinion. It takes a well known story and completely changes it. It's a gorgeous piece and such a good story

[@4Corry]

There are quite a few Walt Disney Animation Studios films where both a character's parents stay for even the whole film, even before this one they include: Peter Pan, Lady and the Tramp, Sleeping Beauty, One Hundred and One Dalmatians, The Rescuers (Though they are adopted and very brief), Oliver and Company (Although they aren't seen), Hercules and Mulan.

[@wyndhamcoffman8961]

7:52 (Silver)"Say hello to Mr. Mop and Mrs. Bucket" (Mrs.Bucket) "It's pronounced "bouquet", dearie."

[@jennifersalt3194]

Merida has two involved parents that are alive for the duration of the film, so Disney *has* tried that route. The Banks children also have both parents for the entire movie.

[@RyonDK]

17:25 F*cking Skip!. I died.

[@altSHIFTNerd]

13:09 WAS. NOT. Expecting an Elderscrolls/Skyrim reference in my bowl of Cinemasins. Well done. You find ways to keep surprising me, Jeremy. Well done.

[@alexzitro5866]

I absolutely adore this film! It’s a shame a lot of the early ‘00s animated movies didn’t get as much love as they deserve

[@vastotales4431]

The fact that this or even Atlantis: The Lost Empire hasn't been made into a live-action in beyond sin worth

[@RockismyAir]

I wish they never do.

[@fragileparadox8658]

Idk if it needs a live action considering how much unnecessary changes are made to their other live action films but a remake or remaster would be really cool

[@George_Fl0yd]

How? Thats litteraly worth removing each and every sin all together

[@owlson2527]

Disney would find a way to screw it up, just like EVERY live action they’ve released in the past few years.

[@oriontherealironman]

Here's hoping they keep it that way

[@alejandrochavez213]

17:02 Fun fact, a PC game was later release as a kind of sequel to the movie (Battle of Procyon) and Silver became a corsair for the Empire. Also, I'm sure the recommendation that the Captain is offering is to Jim (who, in the game, went on to become a promising captain on his own after military school)

[@JDRetrolUtion]

1:33 Jeremy sinning the animation here shows his lack of knowledge on proper raspberry technique. The whole point is to go over the top with it like you're gonna eat your child. That's what gets the biggest laugh and it's my son's favorite thing.

[@alcmedia]

I prefer Atlantis but this movie is also an underated gem

[@motherplayer]

Agreed. The fart alien and Martin Short robot takes the number for this movie down a little bit.

[@01134man]

Both are good 😌

[@alcmedia]

@@01134man Very true

[@justincarawan-carawanco.pu1639]

1:42 Never pause a Disney movie! Everone would appear rubbery at some point!

[@AnaandVerity1259]

12:52 What Jeremy said after that had me in hysterics.

[@touremuhammad5983]

17:47 The real Sin here is not making a reference to the CatDog theme song. Ya know, 🎵 One fine day, with a woof & a purr, a baby was born & it caused a little stir 🎵

[@TheDoctor4390_]

This movie is so good and is a building block of my childhood. I like how much attention it’s getting these days

[@agustinfranco0]

maybe morph's body is whole but LOOKS like parts are separate also that montage you skipped is the most emotional scene in any movie ever. its just perfect

[@Aerodrone5]

15:14 haha yes portal reference!

[@Jartist234]

14:23 Actually that's a reference to Doctor McCoy's phrase "Damn it Jim, I'm a doctor, not a [Insert other profession]" which is from Star TREK franchise, not Star WARS.

[@oriontherealironman]

Nicholas Cage should try and steal this movie. Cause it's a National Treasure

[@rodimusprime8616]

Disneys experimentwl Era was a grand point for creativity Treasure Planet was a gem in itself for that time!

[@Poxell91]

Now that you guys have done this, you have GOT to do _Home on the Range._ It's that one Disney movie that needs a good tearing.

[@l33tmaster]

How come no one has called this man out for him calling a Star Trek reference of “Im a (blank) not a doctor” as a Star Wars reference!!!!! I DEMAND JUSTICE!!!!!

[@mathew85]

Jim's lucky to have both parents alive , Disney loves themselves some dead parents 😆

[@forrest6374]

1:14 wow, wasn’t expecting the star fox adventures reference 😂

[@Fazscare87]

Fun fact, that everyone probably already knows. While ever other character was hand-drawn. John Silver's arm, leg, eye, and B.E.N. were CGI.

[@SoLuVaBle299]

12:14 Heh? They showed hanged pirates pretty early on in the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie and discussed it. And Disney showed the shadow of the villain hanging by his neck in Tarzan.

[@ImpofRelentlessness]

Still the best rendition of Treasure Island. Honestly though the biggest sin was Tony Jay as the opening narrator and then never hearing him again for the rest of the film.

[@MorganKing95]

Why do we need a narrator for the rest of the movie?

[@ImpofRelentlessness]

@@MorganKing95 Because it's Tony Jay.

[@MorganKing95]

@@ImpofRelentlessness I still don't see any more need for a narrator

[@ImpofRelentlessness]

@@MorganKing95 If you have Tony Jay, use Tony Jay.

[@MorganKing95]

@@ImpofRelentlessness Ok, that's it. I'm not going to waste my time arguing further with some dumb fanboy who doesn't understand basic dramaturgy

[@markchang2964]

5:16 Never saw Treasure Planet. Saw a few parts, but never the whole thing. Going to watch and be back!

[@yakunohayashi9653]

This movie wasn’t a box office success, but because of that, its very probable that Disney won’t make any shitty live action of this ubderrated masterpiece

[@Fly0High]

Please let us know what you think afterwards

[@valolafson6035]

Thank goodness.

[@jaytrashwade1-1]

Please don't butcher Treasure Planet with a shit live action movie....

[@rebeccale6012]

"Solitude is a snoozefest, Riften is where the fun is"! 😆

[@carlossoto1715]

The real sin is how Disney released this on the same day as Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. They initially planned this to release in April of that year but gave that release to Lilo and Stitch. The most expensive Traditionally Animated film became one of their biggest flops ever.

[@albertcarlsen9320]

9:52 = MID-MOVIE MONTAGE?!?!? YOU TAKE THAT BACK MISTER!

[@sum1liteamatch]

I love just how picky you had to be to actually find a problem with this film. What a great movie

[@OzymandiasMC]

14:24 im sinning YOU for saying its a STAR WARS REFERENCE *AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA*

[@Hailz24x7]

That riften line was gold

[@boudreauxlee]

I'm actually happy that you guys finally did this one.

[@brentsimard977]

14:25 Now did you mean to say star wars instead of star trek? It must be part of the joke, right? Or did I catch an actual mistake!

[@chrisa2310]

I was hoping to be the first one to point this out. You barely beat me by 15 hours. And they claim, "Here at CinemaSins, we love Star Trek"

[@runraggedrhino]

A joke to inspire nerd rage... And boy am I enraged!!!

[@chrismcdonald2947]

John Reznik's "Im Still Here" is STILL on every playlist I make. Soundtrack is sooo good

[@Zombiesnyder13]

When Disney wants us to watch something They'll smother us with marketing But when they don't want us to watch something, they won't even bother promoting it

[@wolfskinchanger]

8:12 I can't say what kind of trouble Mrs. Mop might cause(no guarantee there even is a Mrs. Mop), but Mr. Bucket will just run around spitting in random directions; not much to worry about beyond the inconvenient mess.

[@justanothergrunt9053]

Nah I love everything about this movie. It pulls my spirits up. Your video was awesome though.

[@marisacanessawright6051]

Calling "Damn it Jim I'm an astronomer not a doctor!" a Star Wars reference was the biggest sin of all

[@d00mbr07]

One of THE most underrated bangers Disney ever put out, pleae sin Titan AE

[@elizabethmccandless5765]

You said that twice

[@D34THT4MB0]

14:26 - " making your star wars reference...." I believe you'll find that's a Star TREK reference. 1 sin added to CinemaSins

[@MrsCSHarrison]

Mirabel in Encanto had both parents. So did Merida in Brave.

[@ceeb420]

Who the fuck skips the "I'm Still Here" montage? Literally one of the best parts of the movie.

[@nobiggsdeal6356]

the 2D and 3D blend honestly doesnt bother me, Id love to see some more modern film using this technique

[@maidenofthelight]

Except the 2D and 3D blend was super expensive to make back then, probably more now cause it's a lost art

[@Sandlot1992]

Finally, it's here until now! (@14:26 that was a Star Trek Reference!)

[@TheWarmachine375]

“Wealth, Fame, Power. The man who had acquired everything in this world, the King of the Space Pirates, Captain Flint Roger. The final words that were said at his execution sent people to the seas of space. "My wealth and treasure? If you want it, I’ll let you have it! Look for it! I left it all at that place!”. Men now, chasing their dreams, head towards the Grand Line. The world now enters a Great Age of Space Pirates!“

[@jeffbrehove2614]

Surprised there were no One Piece jokes in this one.

[@AdmiralBlackstar]

Now there's an idea for a tv series. Someone should do that.

[@heintz256]

13:13 yeah, Skyrim!

[@Shadowgod1000]

They were hanging pirates in the first Pirates Of The Caribbean, you didn't see them get hung, but there were definitely some hung, I think three of them. Also Jack was hung in the first movie, but saved by Will.

[@maidenofthelight]

Yep, during Jack's big entrance into Port Royal, he sailed past three skele-pirates with a warning sign

[@chexmixkitty]

14:27 Not sure if he was making a joke or not, but definitely not a Star Wars reference lol

[@geardog24]

“The birth of a generation of furries would be excellent at Cinemasins.” Back when Disney was at it’s finest.

[@bonyannie]

10:56 you missed the sin in that scene where Silver was across the ship and put his hand out, and teleported behind jim to pat hin on the back.

[@imsomewhatcertain1024]

How Treasure Planet was pitched: “Okay, so it’s Treasure Island right, but in space.”

[@maidenofthelight]

That's basically how the directors pitch it as in the 1980s

[@alphamvbeta]

Sin 53, Mulan and Hercules technically maintained both parents of the main character.

[@amegam4705]

This era of filmmaking is probably my favourite when it comes to animated movies. Especially because the stories were just so good. 0 politics, 100% storytelling.