EX-IDF Soldier DEBATES Briahna; Israel, Gaza, Hamas: Watch

Israeli writer Hen Mazzig joins Rising to discuss the latest on the Israel-Hamas war. #israel #hamas
About Rising:
Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
Follow Rising on social media:
Website: Hill.TV
Facebook: HillTVLive/
Instagram: @HillTVLive
Twitter: @HillTVLive

[@swinbot]

#1, stop sending my tax money to fund a war far away.

[@nottherealxandercrews4742]

You don't even need a #2.

[@aaronfudge3742]

So you’re saying America first? What are you a trumper ?

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

Mind Begs the Question: - If USA/West Leadership - Arm,Bankroll a State whose policies are - Starvation,Death Camps,Gas Chambers/White Phosphorus,Pogroms,Ethnic Cleansing,etc - As complicit as Nazis for Holocaust,no?

[@ericmac8110]

i stopped paying taxes .

[@SpotterVideo]

Go to Gaza City and spend some time with Christian Brothers and Sisters in Christ, if you want to understand what it means to be threatened. Why were two unarmed Christian women shot by Israeli snipers while going to the toilet at their church in Gaza? Why were Christians killed while they were taking shelter at their 800-year-old church in Gaza City, when an IDF bomb hit beside their church? How many of their homes have been turned to rubble? How would you feel if armed drones were constantly flying overhead, while you are without food? Why was Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu-Akieh shot by the IDF before October 7th? These people were not killed by Hamas. Why have these people been ignored by most Christians in the U.S. ? Read Matthew 25:31-46.

[@sabrinawynter]

"Do you want me to debate both of you or can I do it one at a time.." you cold Bri

[@Islamsince2007]

She’s sharp

[@BBB_bbb_BBB]

Sharp as a doorknob. She just hates pushback

[@JappaKneads]

​@@BBB_bbb_BBB You misspelled "illogic"...

[@weddingtoastsong]

It's so cringe how she can't keep her cool. That high pitched screeching voice comes out.

[@SuperStella1111]

@@BBB_bbb_BBB I'm sure she'd welcome QUALITY pushback. This stuff is boring and just interrupts her flow :)

[@Tom-kd8si]

Using this guy logic I can go to Africa where human life began, and steal someone's home, cause that's my ancestral land.

[@MrPauahi1]

Tell me who was there first Islam or Judaism?

[@kapunda6741]

@@MrPauahi1 who was first in the Americas?

[@Jessicaro]

​@@MrPauahi1 It's not a matter of religion; it's about the people, specifically the indigenous ones, the Palestinians. You may consider reading the story of Moses in the Bible, which could surprise you with its account of their origins. and you will find out who are the people of the land.

[@shmaya3834]

You live on stolen land right now.

[@ixnivek2236]

​@@MrPauahi1where did Abram hail from?

[@demetriusmixon4141]

Student protest does expose the larger trend that we don't want our tax dollars going to war and genocide. Flint needs water, and our infrastructure is falling apart!

[@Birdylockso]

I totally agree with you. The larger picture is that we are tired of all these conflicts that the government led us into. War is no good for anyone, except the weapons manufacturers, and the politicians in their pockets.

[@schott43]

The rethugs destroyed Flint and moved on.

[@danielsheill6752]

Why does Blinken look like he’s in the witness protection program?

[@sid7804]

You're giving him too much credit.

[@kate7478]

Blinkin’s dad was Robert Maxwell’s lawyer. Blinkin is family friends with Ghislaine Maxwell.

[@fuckbankers]

​@kate7478 the guy who ripped of the pension scheme in the UK for the a newspaper he owned? .

[@andrew_owens7680]

He didn't witness anything with his head in the sand.

[@JehsuBenIsrael]

They chose that studio lighting on purpose 😂😂

[@sguardian870]

😂😂😂😂 lol, Robbie invited his zionist bro for Bri to drag instead of him. He was tired of his lies being fact-check in real time. Bri understood the assignment.❤❤❤❤❤

[@democratsrepublicansbothan7973]

Love Bri. Beautiful and the smartest on the show

[@jackporter8877]

@@democratsrepublicansbothan7973 Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. From the River to the Sea Israel is all that will be. 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha. Without lies, islam dies.

[@jackporter8877]

Zionism is a believe that Jews deserve their own country. That's it. That's why 99% of Jews are zionists.

[@Ayah315]

@@jackporter8877thats very genocidal. Seek help.

[@paulchristian1358]

Robbie’s passive aggressive eye roll at 13:58 was hilarious 😂 So butthurt

[@quent94181]

I’m from Israel. I am shocked you’ve brought this propagandist on the show… disgusting guy. I think he hardly could talk when confronted with Owen Jones.

[@ftftyffghfvghfcht6701]

if youre from israel why do you object to him being on the show?

[@konstantinkrastev4478]

@@ftftyffghfvghfcht6701 Because he is a propagandist, would you be okay with pick your worst American propagandist like Nick Fluentez to represent American views ?

[@ruweidashakhshir2143]

I was shocked too.

[@shlomokenquinn7391]

@@konstantinkrastev4478 A staff writer for Haaretz bothers you?

[@jlassonful]

I've lived in Israel and I think he brought up some good points. There you go. ok.

[@karen-qm7og]

Lawrence Wilkerson, retired colonel in the US military and chief of staff for Secretary of State Colin Powell, referred to Israeli officials as "patent liars". He said anything coming from Israeli officials is propaganda. This guest is a case in point.

[@COC0st4rry]

Takes one to know one

[@musiqal333]

Exactly.

[@schott43]

He is spot on!!!

[@CD-ev2vy]

They all sound the same must be Al

[@VikingSummer]

This guy couldn’t win a debate against a cheese sandwich.

[@joeterzio7175]

You're hearing what you want to hear. Israel lost over 1,000 people in a terrorist attack and you want them to do nothing? What should the U.S. have done after 9/11? Also nothing?

[@rayjames777]

@@joeterzio7175 Considering the war on Iraq was illegal, yeah.

[@Isynchromissity]

He literally used the argument that because a different country expelled his family, his current country has the right to expel Palestinians. He’s delusional

[@Isynchromissity]

@@joeterzio7175 your statement proves your ignorance and the error in your logic.

[@agoogleuser704]

@@joeterzio7175I personally think we should have done nothing, getting involved in several countries for 2 decades resulted in death, destruction, debt and destabilization, we are less safe for having engaged in these wars.

[@kurosaki0001000]

This guy loses every debate he is on

[@kaybee0126]

😂😂😂 funny I thought the same thing

[@BBB_bbb_BBB]

What do you consider a loss? Bri talking over him? She didn't make any points that he couldn't come back from. And even her final point the he should have some empathy for the Palestinians, both the guest and Robby were able to simply point to polling that shows the Palestinians aren't interested in a 2 state solution and aren't interested in equal rights for Jews. And Bri just ignores that because she doesn't have any firm ground to stand on.

[@pkia898]

Yes, but he doesn't have to win any debates. Gaza is going to be flattened and this guy won't get a debate trophy 😢

[@jfranklins]

He wins every debate actually. Bri loses. People, especially anti-semites don't like facts and the facts are on Israel's side. Let's face it, Hamas and the palestinians are never going to win.

[@skontheroad]

In English, maybe. Not sure what your definitions and guidelines are. But he is always well prepared. How come Robbie never gets to run the interview?? Like, Ever??

[@carlhubbell8593]

When i joined Rising a year ago, i was very much against Briahna. She is on fire right now. " want me to debate both of you, or can i take one at a time?" Epic. Good job Briahna

[@Juliagoolia81]

All she did was try to discredit what he was saying. She used the rarest examples against his “most cases” facts. She also assumes that setting up a pluralistic society like that of the US (which Israel does have to the extent hatit can…is it very racially and socially diverse), is somehow without obstacle. She doesn’t take the political and religious and historical history of the region into account, nor does she address the historic removal and persecution of Jews, or the conditions and public opinion of the time. The environment in the Middle East where there are 29 Muslim majority countries, surrounding the one tiny nation that is not Muslim majority - many of them are autocratic regimes, and also based on single religions. But the tax dollar issue is reasonable. I feel Biden or Blinken should more intricately discuss WHY the US and Israel have the relationship they do. How does it benefit all Americans? Because we know it’s not about protecting Jews. So offer Americans an explanation for why we support Israel. They are angry because our healthcare and education and groceries are too expensive but we’re funding an international war, instead of aiding our own citizens.

[@michelhong3355]

He says Israelis are hurt when palastian civilians are killed. So why is there Israelis at the crossing blocking aid getting in?

[@Musa786-lx2ui]

Most Israelis with the rarest of exceptions want this war and aggression to continue various opinion polls suggesting 70+% disraeli's want this to continue and want Netanyahu out for not being aggressive enough cabinet full of monsters filling up the Israeli with more hate n fear mongering, yes some orthodox jews are totally against what's happening I fully acknowledge that but majority are blood thirsty for Palestinian blood May Allah help my brothers & sisters in Palestine... Ameen

[@JB-wh4cn]

Fiction. Are you visiting the Alex Jones Website for lefties.

[@shmaya3834]

Israel is a democracy and the law allows protests. If terrorist were holding your family hostage and the people around them were assisting with hiding them, would you allow them their instacart order?

[@Birdylockso]

Where, and when, please provide the specifics, (about "Israelis at the crossing blocking aid getting in"). You can't, can you? Could it be just more online propaganda that people like to regurgitate without independent verification?

[@reema811]

There are many video clips as evidence of this, sadly for Israel and its defenders, your usual strategy of lying incessantly is useless in the age of social media. ​@@JB-wh4cn

[@matttriano]

This guy wants to talk about HIS FAMILY but not 2 million Palestinians

[@BBB_bbb_BBB]

If you're playing a numbers game, there's 9.5 million Israelis.

[@_TheLONEwolf]

He did talk about 2 million palestinians.

[@chaschristiansen]

​@@user-hr6jrit is not exactly misinformation. The Nazis took over Tunisia during WWII, there was some anti-muslim but stronger anti semitic pushes which did survive after Germany fell. They did push all Jews out. You forget that Nazis were all over the middle east during that time period.

[@bennyrashasha9920]

@@user-hr6jr Arabs should have fought a better war. They are lucky that Palestine wasn't just annexed after losing multiple wars waged by multiple nations all attacking at the same time. Palestinians would have probably faired better with equal civil rights under Israel.

[@shlomokenquinn7391]

@@user-hr6jr Iraq- not Iran

[@McBlammy]

Thank you Bri for not toeing the IDF line like it seems like the large majority of American media is doing right now, and not being afraid to ask challenging questions.

[@jackporter8877]

"How should Israel have responded to the October 7th attacks"? The one question nobody on the Palestinian side can answer. Oh well. Soon Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha. Without lies, islam dies.

[@FaerieSidhe]

She's a big khamas supporter. Fully on board with the cult. Poor Pals.

[@JenZee-oe2no]

@@jackporter8877 Took me a minute to get the pdf. Clever!

[@flamboyentpromotions3471]

Thats the guy Owen Jones roughed up

[@jkadmon]

Who on earth thought it was a good idea to have this pathological liar on?

[@edwardcarley6086]

It was Robbie's of this I am sure of.

[@jkadmon]

@@edwardcarley6086 you may be right but I've also heard there was a booker working there at one point who has a penchant for reaching out to right-wing ghouls and pseudo-intellectuals. So I wondered if it might be something like that.

[@shawndorv8953]

At this point, nobody believes your hasbara.

[@cbs63]

At this point, you might still be hiding from the inconvenient truth. It takes a while to come to terms with being fooled by the tenants of the calliphate.

[@skontheroad]

If "Hasbara" is the only thing you have ever learned from everything you have been "taught" about Israel, you may need some more classes!

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

Mind Begs the Question: - If a States policies are - Starvation,Death Camps,Gassing/White Phosphorus,Dehumanization,Pogroms,Ethnic Cleansing,etc - Has the right to exist?

[@jsnip6720]

I realize that you got your education on Israel and Palestine over social media, but I think you might want to dive back in. This was a horrible interview and Bree is full of disgusting propaganda. She went into this with an agenda and barely gave him or Rbobbie a chance to speak.

[@christianblattler6518]

​@@jsnip6720which version of this interview have you watched???

[@margotkiser]

This is "former" IDF soldier is still quite the propagandist.

[@under-en6lo]

Paid with American Welfare like everything else coming out of Israel.

[@debracampbell9727]

Hes probably a murderer too !

[@ozzy7455]

It's crazy to me how you love Hamas haha. I think both sides are wrong and part of a holy war. I think we should stay out of it. But we got so many people that think they know what they are talking about about in the US because of the media in reality we in the US or anywhere other than Palestine or Israel have not concept of what is going on. They bamboozled y'all with Ukraine and they did the same with this.

[@garygreen2146]

former IDF does not mean he isn't a current employee of the Israeli government or a contractor to the Israeli government

[@donramon9723]

@@garygreen2146 Ceasefire!

[@flipflop1758]

It started on with 75 years of Palestinian suffering from Israeli terrorists' apartheid.

[@ritmo2k]

Sure Bri, just interrupt and overspeak him, he (and no one else who disagrees with you) is worth any respect.

[@stevemonges]

What interview did you watch? She gave him 12 mins before she decided to correct his lies

[@ashheruptah4273]

Robbie can't even win when he double teams Bri,,, LOL

[@tonybanks1035]

bri can't even win in a monologue

[@jackporter8877]

@@tonybanks1035 "How should Israel have responded to the October 7th attacks"? The one question nobody on the Palestinian side can answer. Oh well. Soon Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha. Without lies, islam dies.

[@jackporter8877]

"How should Israel have responded to the October 7th attacks"? The one question nobody on the Palestinian side can answer. Oh well. Soon Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha. Without lies, islam dies.

[@scratchpenny]

She's not really winning, either. She actually hurts leftwing policy most of the time because she makes bad faith claims and manipulates to "win" debates. Even when I agree with her, she argues in such an adversarial way that it's a turn-off. And I know that I am not the only one. That's the biggest complaint against her week in and week out. Robbie is just incompetent at debate, but Bri is intentionally like this.

[@Its2breezy]

😂

[@samselah]

"we arent' from pennsylvania", Brianna - "Benjamin Netanyahu is from right outside of philly"

[@Tk-yx9xj]

Sorry, I hate Bibi as much as the next guy but that just wrong. His father is from poland and his mother was born in jerusalem, Bibi was raised in Israel for most of pre-adult life. So she just lied either from mallise or incompatent.

[@lackerman3975]

​@@Tk-yx9xj are your feelings hurt 😂

[@davidwong5197]

@@Tk-yx9xj He was raised in Philly according to his own bio.

[@SistaCitizen]

@@Tk-yx9xj Everybody's mother and or father is from somewhere else, this is America. Was he or was he not born there, and your point is Bri's, dual citizenship loyalty problem.

[@MauricXe]

As the guest said 55 percent of them are from the region. Nice try tho

[@RanDom-Interloper]

One question Bri didn't ask is why were Hamas able to overwhelm IDF defense so easily on Oct.7th? I have heard by other former IDF that standards used to be different in the past. Israel has, thanks to US funding, some of the best surveillance and arms equipment in the world and yet a bunch of less equipped (by direct comparison, not a blanket statement) terrorists were able to storm and breach the defenses that should have been far more impenetrable. I heard (video with former IDF, I think it was a woman) that even if a stray cat triggered a trespass, IDF would know. So. Why was Hamas able to cross IDF lines so easily? Did the alertness of the IDF less than what it used to be? I get the feeling even Hamas was surprised how far they were able to trespass, they thought they'd be stopped far sooner.

[@syashadeed7552]

Bri just blew this IDF troll out of the water. She made him say Israel is a racist state 😂

[@jessegarcia9418]

IDF propagandists

[@ozzy7455]

Let me guess you live in the US having no concept of the world around you thinking our media is honest. You don't have any idea of what is going. Right now there are 5 actual genocides where you at on those.

[@Los_Servants]

Who? Robbie? Lol

[@Unfamous_Buddha]

@@jackporter8877- Israeli leaders will be arrested and charged with war crimes.

[@theBear89451]

He is bias, but more factual than Bri.

[@Los_Servants]

@@theBear89451 not on this issue.

[@wavymcfly]

Robbie is going to leave the show, I can see it

[@dmp1962]

One can hope, he really has nothing intelligent to add to any topic.

[@wavymcfly]

@@dmp1962 provides balance though, Bri gotta chill, she already has her own show lol go scream on your own podcast

[@Em3ga]

I doubt it. He is barely qualified to flip burgers. What else is he gonna do?

[@jackporter8877]

@@dmp1962 "How should Israel have responded to the October 7th attacks"? The one question nobody on the Palestinian side can answer. Oh well. Soon Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha. Without lies, islam dies.

[@mdocho4944]

Hooray🤣

[@TheChase008]

Netanyahu was born in Tel Aviv and spent some time in Philly. So what. That has nothing to do with anything. Many Palestinians live in Canada and the US. So what. Bri is just trying to deflect this gentleman from having an argument of any substance.

[@joanapires1787]

Briahana you absolute legend 🙌🙌🙌

[@death265]

The war didn’t start on October 7th!

[@svetlana7904]

Of course

[@fedbomb]

Why is my tax money going to pay for this Genocide.

[@azalia423]

Our government and politicians are owned by Aipac.

[@bromack3]

Cause you voted for Biden.

[@strategicandtacticalprocesses]

It has to do with Western security. If we don't support free countries like Ukraine, Israel, and Taiwan then eventually the U.S. will be attacked by the enemies of these countries.

[@Amalgam67]

Whether we like it or not, we've been in the middle of a decades-long ethno-religious conflict. We've been on one side of that conflict for decades and now that one of our allies is going full Marcellus Wallace on the Palestinians we're in the uncomfortable position of wanting them to stop but not having the leverage to make them.

[@plumlogan]

​@@Amalgam67the leverage is the amount of money they pay our politicians with the money we give them ... to pay our politicians

[@00Julian00]

Wonderful job brianna. You did the right thing by raising your voice, So that robbie couldn't interject.

[@MM-kq5ey]

Not a productive conversation. I usually agree with Bri but she is once again, not discussing these things in good faith. Don't have a guest if you're not going to let them speak, constant interruptions don't lead to productive conversations.

[@leannefranson1198]

He constantly talked over her.

[@rickydee5863]

She needed to correct his deluded lies .

[@traviscutler9912]

This guy is the definition of disingenuous bad faith propaganda.

[@samsalas9323]

What's your opinion regarding the guest though? 😏

[@PauloAdriano-zo2ng]

​@@samsalas9323 That's a good point. Robbie's perspective-outlook regarding many issues is questionable.

[@jsnip6720]

She didn’t even let him speak. She laughed when he talked about assault victims. Bree is the definition of disingenuous..

[@samsalas9323]

@@jsnip6720 The video is up for people to see and compare with your comment, LOL

[@jsnip6720]

@@samsalas9323 I know. And anybody looking at that interview objectively can absolutely see how biased, rude and unprofessional she was.. She was disgusting.

[@dm_1236]

19:24 50% of Gazans are children so how do a majority of Palestinians in Gaza support Hamas?

[@l.w.paradis2108]

They don't? Sounds about right.

[@cbs63]

Do you think that they have a choice when their billionare corrupt leaders live overseas.

[@TheRealChese]

It’s by polling, which by most standards reflect adult viewpoints. It’s like how most poll works. The adults are the ones with influence.

[@bellad1063]

@@TheRealChese misleading

[@BBB_bbb_BBB]

Can kids not support Hamas? I'm assuming the polling just means 50% of the adults surveyed, which is then extrapolated to mean 50% of the population, but I'm sure that a lot of the kids also support Hamas. Remember, a 16 year old is still considered a kid, but a whole bunch of them are also Hamas fighters, which is one of the more disgusting aspects of that terror group.

[@camoTiaras]

A blind and deaf man could hear the absolute hypocrisy that Blinken doesn't hear when he speaks.

[@SkylarTheWriter]

AMAZING JOB, Brie. I'm so glad that you didn't let up on this dude and were able to hold a mirror to Hen's family experience to reflect the hypocrisy in Israel's brutality against Palestine.

[@billyv2210]

Defund Genocide!

[@jas_atx3922]

This seems like brainwashing. What is an army to do when their opposition hides behind civilians? Why does the "genocide" crowd not call for Hamas to stop the fight. The war would end IMMEDIATLY thereafter. Try to think for yourself. Look beyond your training and group think. At least try.

[@ashheruptah4273]

It's impossible to reason with spritually bankrupt ppl. Good Job Bri

[@jsnip6720]

Bree is a spiritually bankrupt person

[@JohnTightlips]

What does spiritually bankrupt mean in this context?

[@jsnip6720]

@@JohnTightlips I don’t think you meant that for me, but my response about Bri’s spiritual bankruptcy, was pertaining to her morals. The fact that she smiled and giggled when the guest spoke of assault victims, really bothered me..

[@ritmo2k]

@@jsnip6720 It's ok if you don't agree with Bri, she doesn't think anyone who doesn't share her views is worth any respect.

[@JohnTightlips]

@@jsnip6720 yeah it was for ashheruptah4273. Bri has no principles other than advance her agenda and ideology by any means necessary including lying, and misrepresenting facts.

[@Nano-Thought]

She is GOOD! I am impressed with her ability to deflect lies from this propagandist.

[@truthstarved]

The actual question asked in the The Harvard CAPS / Harris Poll, to which the guest referred, read: "Should Israel move forward with an operation in Rafah to finish the war with Hamas, doing its best to avoid civilian casualties even though there will be casualties, or should it back off now and allow Hamas to continue running Gaza?" Anyone can see that this is a compound question to which the response is highly suspect. How many respondents would support Israel's invasion of Rafah if they understood that Israel's primary aim is the decimation of Palestinian culture altogether along with the theft of remaining Palestinian land? Or, if Israel plans to target civilian infrastructure in a way that undermines the capacity of the civilian population to survive? Americans have been heavily propagandized by their political representatives and corporate media outlets for decades, thus this poll is merely a reflection of the effectiveness of that propaganda campaign. Lastly, independent voters were grossly underrepresented in the poll as they are over represented in the anti-Zionist cohort. Even so, only one third of the respondents approved of Biden's handling of Israel.

[@simonsteen-andersen3181]

Important point

[@343ramana]

thanks for clarifying that.

[@ashheruptah4273]

The spiritually bankrupt will never understand that apartheid is unsustainable.Good Job Bri.

[@jackporter8877]

Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. From the River to the Sea Israel is all that will be. 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha. Without lies, islam dies.

[@donramon9723]

@@jackporter8877 Militarized settler colonial movement using violence seeks legitimacy in biblical myth.

[@patricksullivan1827]

​@@jackporter8877 so then you support the oct.7th attack. That's messed up dude!

[@3rdEyeWide]

@@donramon9723 50% of Israel's population are Mizrahi/Sephardic Jews (Jews of Middle Eastern/North African origin), as brown-skinned as any Arab and most have had to flee muslim-majority countries in the area. Another 20% are Arabs (half of whom are practicing muslims). Only 30% are Ashkenazi Jews (european/western). But yes, please do keep repeating the "evil, white, western, settler/colonizer" narrative.

[@donramon9723]

@@Liberte-bq5rc I thought you'd never ask.... Ancient Israel and the modern State of Israel are not the same thing. That region has been conquered so many times by many nations and powers, so many admixtures occurred in that territory since then. What does DNA say? It says various groups of Palestinians, mostly those found in pre Israeli state of Palestine are closest in genetic ties to the ancient Canaanites and/or Biblical Jews. The many Ashkenazi Jews who now inhabit the state of Israel have strong European admixtures. o claim ascendancy to a region after thousands of years just based on religious historical claims is just false.

[@dirtbagleftist5412]

Bri did an awesome job trying to deal with his gish galloping. It’s so hard to debate when someone throws out lie after lie.

[@cbs63]

It's hard to admit that Ha ms is a big scam.

[@karlknight4678]

Briahana looks like an Egyptian goddess today.Also she owns it in this this segment. I love her.

[@chrisd13086]

Everyone should go read the wording of the question to where Hen got that 70% number.

[@lrwsf1]

Then why are Jews crying about the thousands of years ago and then saying that Palestinians need to stop crying about 75 years ago? They can’t have it both ways.

[@olgasokurova9559]

Because they are "chosen")))

[@lrwsf1]

@@olgasokurova9559 they are imposters.

[@CB-sf9mx]

Because... "you are an antisemite"

[@dirtnap466]

They want it only their way. Its ok they are showing their true faces. This attitude that they are a superior peoples than all others & their hatred for Palestinians shows there is a reason why they were expelled from 100+ countries

[@iceberg8903]

The guy literally said he supports a Palestinian state - both can be true. Jewish people were forced and fled Arab states due to persecution and Palestinians fled and were forced out after several Arab states pronounced war on Israel. To understand both is to better understand the conflict and how to resolve it

[@MrGanyo01]

Why this Zio always lie why why?????

[@mikef6399]

@@Liberte-bq5rc Why does anyone have to do that for you if you will forever believe in lies told by certain group of people? Keep enjoying it.

[@Hail_Sagan]

How is he lying?

[@Isynchromissity]

@@Liberte-bq5rc did your “archaeological research” unveil the remains of the people who were inhabiting modern day Israel when they were betrayed by the families that escaped Europe? Or are you still trying to quiet the guilt by repeating the lie that it was a barren desert when they arrived?

[@ilpostino88]

@@Hail_Sagan- he said Hamas is active in the West Bank - lies upon lies

[@RRA005]

That’s all they ever do!

[@strawpiglet]

So funny how he says war started on Oct 7, when Hamas attacked an illegal military outpost on their land. I guess it's not an act of war for Israel to attack and take land, it's only an act of war to fight back.

[@danporath536]

He says Palestinians have an identity, but he doesn’t want a state for them that might inconvenience Israel in any way, nor does he want a place for them within Israel.

[@billyv2210]

Hen Mazzig Senior Fellow and Propogandist at the IDF institute for Genocide. Have you no shame sir?

[@susan4-6-14]

HE IS AMAZING & VERY INTELLIGENT!!!

[@gabriellejudd1]

​@@susan4-6-14😅😅😅😅😅

[@katong1953]

@billy. No shame.

[@wilburhornshnoggle2619]

He was spitting truth... Turn tv off..

[@elaine5953]

@@susan4-6-14 Actually he demonstrated that he is not very intelligent. His fancy glasses do not make a man intelligent. Briana was the smartest one on that panel

[@classicrise1]

Its unbelievable how many lies this guy has said in one sentence, IDF takes no responsibiity.

[@bromack3]

Oh... you were in the IDF too? 😒😒😒😒

[@devongreaves2495]

I think he could of just said Hamas after every question

[@3rdEyeWide]

Genuinely curious, what were the lies?

[@tiberio1352]

offended by EVERYTHING....ashamed of NOTHING...zionism in a nutshell.

[@sdarcy274]

but brianna doesnt believe all women now? progressives have ZERO core values

[@wadap0]

That's priceless! The conversation is pushing people apart - not the bombs eh?

[@ralphsimone8308]

So do not interrupt Bri, but the minute Bri gets triggered, she interrupts over and over. Worst debating tactic. Bri is a complete activist at this point, she cannot see this through a non bias lense.

[@nelsonmcduff5218]

Whenever she's exposed as a liar, she quickly changes the subject. She's insufferable.

[@TVeldhorst]

Are you blind? Is exactly the opposite here. Haven't you seen this guy complety meltdown in "debate" with Owen Jones?! This guy went unhinged.

[@stevemonges]

​@@TVeldhorstI am convinced some people hate Bri because of her politics and won't listen to her point at all

[@diddydum]

They cant say a sentence without saying Khamas Khamas

[@cosmicbear88-23]

right, cause that's who is responsible for starting this

[@azalia423]

They're detracting from the world seeing how reprehensible Israel has been from the beginning.

[@debracampbell9727]

@@cosmicbear88-23what planet do you live on !!!

[@davidwong5197]

There is no Hamas in 1948

[@cosmicbear88-23]

@@davidwong5197 right, only angry Arabs who lost every war they started with Israel.

[@airdee]

Thank you Bri for standing for Palestinians

[@jackporter8877]

"How should Israel have responded to the October 7th attacks"? The one question nobody on the Palestinian side can answer. Oh well. Soon Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha. Without lies, islam dies.

[@eggggg3577]

Last bit at the end 😂😂😂 Conversation, factual debates Not bringing people together said the guy advocating for apartheid

[@TheChase008]

Bri is so obvious in her attempts to twist history and reality.

[@katsetuis5ryan600]

How

[@TheChase008]

@@katsetuis5ryan600 Difficult to condensce but i`ll try. Judaism predates Islam. At no point has Palestine been only Islamic. When the jews flooded into Palestine after WW2 the Islamists were understandibly upset and retalitated with violence. However , they have no more right to the country than do Jews as historically it was originally a jewish state. . The Israeli`s also understandabley retaliated to the Islamic violence and were superior militarily. The country then ended up in their hands. It is now a country surrounded by Islamic countries not friendly to the Jewish faith. As a result both sides have done unnecessary actions keeping hate alive and also keeping Israel on edge and worried about any Islamic threat. Neither side as a result is innocent. However , once the Palestinians attacked and started this current conflict , they gave the Israeli`s the right to retaliate and try to end the Hamas threat once and for all. Unfortunately for the Palestian people of Gaza , they have allowed Hamas to take refuge underneath them for many years. This is again understandable as there is little they could do and also unfortunately there are many Palestinians who support the Hamas group. Obviously it is difficult to separate what must be done to end this idiocy once and for all. A two state solution is setting up a future slaughter of Jews as has been done historically many times , ie. Lebanon for example. A one state solution will only continue what has been happening. So there is no easy or obvious answer. But to condemn the Israeli`s is simply bias.

[@unitedstatesofmordor]

Briahna crushes it again. 👍

[@yogi4lyfe]

💯

[@pkia898]

Hahahahahahahaha she is a dope

[@Successful504]

lol! Bet she can out debate you in he​r sleep. @@pkia898

[@natcheztracefan]

It’s so refreshing how she gently exposes hypocrisy.

[@deadgolfer6345]

@@pkia898 I would call it more of an activist clown. But I hear ya.

[@bobomber]

Does he believe that the Palestinians deserve to suffer for injustices perpetrated by the state of Iraq? I'm really not sure what point he was making...

[@Mmdhi]

He really not able to debate. Destroyed by Owen Jones and now Bri. This diaper soldier is blamin Palastinians for IRAQs mistakes!!! What a fantastic mor on…oh and Robbie aka Richie rich the same!

[@michiganisthebeststate1081]

I think he's grouping every Arab into one group.

[@bobomber]

@@michiganisthebeststate1081 you're probably right... nothing complicated here, he's just racist

[@Rowe104]

Geez- the comments that think Bri is smart- truly seems to signal the death of the west

[@nelsonmark4778]

Well said darling. You said the truth 👏🙏

[@ponchovanillabean8074]

Wow. They washed this kid's brain out completely.

[@azalia423]

And especially his humanity.

[@jackporter8877]

"How should Israel have responded to the October 7th attacks"? The one question nobody on the Palestinian side can answer. Oh well. Soon Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha. Without lies, islam dies.

[@donramon9723]

@@jackporter8877 Stop worshiping the flag with the Bellamy Salute. Yikes!

[@unitedstatesofmordor]

The US has a government guided by cognitive dissonance. Thus the downward spiral continues unabated.

[@MusingsFromTheJohn00]

At this time it appears Israel has a the strongest influence over the USA than anyone, full stop. That is not saying Israel has total absolute control, but the amount of influence is scarily huge.

[@jackporter8877]

Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. From the River to the Sea Israel is all that will be. 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha. Without lies, islam dies.

[@sherylF5610]

Guided by shareholders

[@andrew_owens7680]

@@jackporter8877 Yeah, and Trump will rule for a thousand years. I may not live to see it, but the beginning of the end of Zionism is playing out.

[@MusingsFromTheJohn00]

@@jackporter8877 peace and freedom will not happen the way things are now.

[@Sinclair6622]

I love Brie! Thanks for debunking all these bad hasbara

[@SeahHiFiTecno]

Bree, you're on fire! Go, girl!! We need more of you on news & media. ❤

[@johnfarrell3171]

A poll . . . out of Harvard . . . and over seventy per cent of American voters think WHAT?

[@davidwong5197]

I read the poll. It was the other way. The biggest lie is we accept Palestinians. Bri ask how about Gaza Palestinians. He goes that's too many Arabs. He busted himself.

[@ashburnconnecttv7860]

That guy was lying out loud!

[@neeleyfolk]

This guys a hack.

[@debraberg4513]

heh...which one

[@tomhollandinc]

Robby, you need to grow a set of balls and call Brei out. She suffocates all conversations.

[@Ayah315]

Bri is absolutely brilliant. The way she schools these bigots always leaves me speechless. Bless your heart, Bri!

[@BDnevernind]

Why are we still using "hostages" for captured Israelis held without charges as bargaining chips and "prisoners" foe those captured by Israel and held for the same reasons?

[@azalia423]

Money

[@MackB2023]

This man knows how important it is to repeat pro Israel rhetoric. He is a liar for Israel.

[@noorazman8001]

he is a LIAR from isLIAR

[@AremuJejeofdavillage]

It’s difficult for the human mind to override successful military programming…he said he supports human rights for all ppl but is supporting an attack on their right to self determination…crazy

[@bobamericano]

Hen started with a pale face and ended spicy red. Ready for Briahna to feast. Everytime she speaks, im filled with hope for humanity! 🥰

[@oboogie2]

This dude has a consistent tic that gives away when he's lying. It's pretty easy to spot if you watch for it.

[@nurlindafsihotang49]

Seen it in the sky interview too

[@strawpiglet]

Yeah, his lips move ;)

[@oboogie2]

@@strawpiglet EXACTLY!

[@alileevil]

Its very easy to debate a Zionist. You just tell the truth.

[@sid7804]

But they lie and censor so they can get the last word.

[@davidwong5197]

A good liar tells 90% true. This guy can't even tell 1% truth, Bri didn't bother debating him. She just said people know you are lying.

[@alileevil]

@@davidwong5197 She didn't need to debate him on the history of Israel -Palestine conflict as that is well documented. She pointed out his double speech regarding his so called regard for Palestinians and his intention for a Jewish ethnostate at the cost to Palestinians who lived there. He justifies the genocide Israel is committing by bringing up a genocide which was committed against the Jews. Sadly one genocide does not cancel out the other. She does very well to reveal this sick way of thinking.

[@elainefriedlander1099]

@@alileevil There are numerous ethno states in the middle east no one protests including those that literally have in their constitution banning Jews

[@yamitwood5200]

If you consider that everything she said was lies and Hamas propaganda that she regurgitated to the shock of someone who actually knows history then I can’t see how you’re so pleased with her performance.

[@alexandertosa4993]

Great show!

[@haiderk3246]

Thank you Brianna for putting this man in the right corner

[@ChristinaGerlach]

Many Americans and Israelis don't consider the Palestinians fully human, or at least not equal humans to themselves. But the only people that are not fully human are those that are O.K. with this Jenna Side.

[@joycelynfatusin5442]

The problem is that people are not telling the truth

[@IFIMTHEDEV1L]

Can someone point me in the direction of this so called "violence" happening in these protests

[@nosuchthing8]

Why call it a cease fire if they won't cease fire?

[@fazalkmd]

Israel started this “war” when European Jews started emigrating to Palestine. They solidified the war when they created a country on a land that was not theirs. Everything since then has been trying to restore justice for the Palestinians.

[@theBear89451]

Israeli Jews are 20% European, roughly the same percent of Israelis who are Palestinian. No one invaded. This concept is just a GOP talking point for people who believe Mexicans are invading America.

[@tustincaviewerguy9802]

The guest is so patronic to the Palestinian people.

[@Bombo10]

Absolutely, lsraeI started the agression and it was acknowledged by BenGurion himself. “Let us not ignore the truth among ourselves … politically we are the aggressors and they defend themselves… The country is theirs, because they inhabit it, whereas we want to come here and settle down, and in their view we want to take away from them their country.” - David Ben Gurion

[@doreeneclose]

Most of us live on stolen land if you care to go back far enough.

[@3rdEyeWide]

​@@Bombo10 Jews made up 1.24% of the Ottoman Empire. The land they were allocated in 1948 was 1.15% of that Empire's landmass. Blame the subsequent landloss on the wars and terrorism instigated by the Arab armies and the "Palestinians". The Arabs got the overwhelming majority of the "Palestinian" territory in the form of countries like Jordan and Syria. Millions were displaced during the partition of India for religious reasons, but no one talks about that, because the muslims got their own country. But we can't go letting the Jews have a tiny sliver of land in the Middle East - the land where their religion, language and culture originated - can we now?

[@abumusaryan4697]

Briahna pushes back well and doesnt let the lies lead the debate which tends to be where the favour seems to lie most of the time. Great work as always Briahna

[@darrellbryant1018]

lol. Brie had Robbie rolling his eyes like a little girl.

[@Amalgam67]

At this point, why would anyone want to debate with Bri? A debate implies one side at least listening to the other which she's clearly incapable of doing.

[@brianmonahan1654]

Really get a stop watch and time it

[@Hansahmed818]

Why would anyone debate with bri since she’s so well spoken that she wins against everyone

[@bernardmoore8877]

Get’em Breanna

[@unipartyhellscape8895]

Briahna came to this armed with facts and logic. Hen came with hasbara. Things did not go well for Hen.

[@charlene9638]

Robbie was so excited to have someone from Israel on the show he almost wet his pants

[@syashadeed7552]

Your audience knows the IDF Hasbara troll is lying Bri. ❤❤❤

[@billyv2210]

Brianna - so articulate and poised - awesome to watch.

[@weddingtoastsong]

Lol is this a joke? You can say bri was right here. You can say she crushed this guy. But articulate and poised? I've never once seen her like that. She's usually emotional and screeching.

[@SANDWICHGIRLNYC]

Give that lady her own show …

[@alimushtaq2589]

she has her own show. Bad Faith Podcast.

[@scratchpenny]

The reality is this is a centrist show. If they go full left-wing all the time with Bri, they will lose more than half their audience. They really need to replace both of them with more capable people. Bri is right on this topic, but the show has turned into this low-information adversarial debate show that doesn't move the needle. Despite being owned by one of the largest TV Network companies in the world, the hosts are less informed than many political bloggers.

[@user-vr5kl6hi2m]

I agree with Robbie on the last point. Americans shouldn't push their ideas on them. But we shouldn't be funding and sending weapons either.

[@nunusnews361]

I dont think the pro Palestinian protesters would mind being beside anti Hamas protesters if it were just for one thing. At the end of the day Israel is the agressior, and they are also the only side of this conflict that has the option to end the problem non violently. And they have continued to choose violence. Palestinians have been denied all peaceful means of protest and divestment in the diaspora and in the West bank (which has nothing. todo with Hamas), If this was a fair balance. of teo sides just ducking it out over land, people would of course come together and condomn all the violence. But it's not, its an illegal occupation that denies peace and vetos every peaceful avenue presented to it

[@tonybanks1035]

gosh, Bri is horrendous at this

[@NabilKhanVisuals]

aww he does not wanna talk about genocide :(

[@ruweidashakhshir2143]

When was the harvard poll? Which poll is more recent @briahna ?

[@Hesham_MK]

I’d like to see one Israeli that doesn’t lie

[@iceberg8903]

Imagine if you’d said all Pakistanis lie, or all Kenyans lie - horrible way to think generalising an entire nation

[@eggggg3577]

Daniel levy

[@alimushtaq2589]

@@iceberg8903you guys do lie. so stop lying.

[@Gilfaizon]

congrats you have become what you claim to hate

[@Hesham_MK]

@@iceberg8903 Your problem might be the English language because that's not my comment

[@Jmay51]

Idk how Robbie does this every day

[@dmp1962]

Money

[@raulduke2035]

Probably drinks like a fish!

[@Takobella]

He’s checked out. It’s why he contributes nothing to the show

[@tonybanks1035]

yeah, anyone should get a special compensation for having to work with Bri.

[@zainubumar]

God! Where are my blood pressure pills?

[@oPHILOSORAPTORo]

"The Jews were there first" isn't a very strong argument. Let's ask the Canaanites their opinion on who was in that land first. Let's ask Abraham, who was originally Chaldean. Besides, there's plenty of examples in the Bible of times when the Jews lost their promised land, and had to wait for God to give it back to them. The only time they took it for themselves was after they left Egypt.

[@identifying.as.asovereignhuman]

I'd love to hear what these "absurd demands from Hamas" are, exactly...

[@yamitwood5200]

Really? Try getting off the Hamas websites and you’ll see them. You are sticking up for terrorists?