EXPLAIN THIS KATIE! New Info!?

[@lifewith9cats153]

Nina's attorney needs to subpoena TN CPS for these records so she can protect Faith.

[@grandmaof4811]

I can't imagine what Sebastian endured at the hands of little man Chris. 😳 😮😢 Why as the father wasn't Seth notified? Sebastian could be safe right now! SHAME on Katie for failing to protect Sebastian! Where is vulgar, profane little man Chris now?

[@judichristophersen7238]

Chris has a terrible temper! Can you imagine poor Sebastian

[@debsibson7071]

I hope Seth takes CPS to court. These cases have to stop being let slide

[@earlinechatagnier7252]

This child was going to be a Witness to Nina’s case coming up

[@MargaretSullivan-ob7yk]

I do not want to believe LE and CPS could be involved in this mess. As time goes by... I really wonder. Are the CPS workers being threatened? What is up with the TBI? Unprofessional to allow a potential subject to use the first name of an agent on social media! Same goes for Sumner county Sheriff's department employees and Hendersonville police officers. It looks bad. Like CP is buddies with LE!

[@kaykaysma]

Yes it's something up with cp an law enforcement because with all the threats an stuff he has said you would think law enforcement would step in an clearly thier not,it's like they are behind him on everything, it's not making sense ,ITS EITHER SOME REAL GOOD FRIENDS IN LAW ENFORCEMENT ARE SOME $$MIGHT BE INVOLVED IN COVERING UP INFO AN HIDING INFO.. IMO THATS WHAT I BELIEVE JUSTICE FOR SEBASTIAN 💚💚💚💚💚💚

[@debsibson7071]

It’s weird that the sheriffs office had the CPS paperwork by TBI didn’t. What else don’t they have

[@ProudChristian73]

Justin you are the only other channel beside pascal that I can watch without feeling like I’m gonna pull my hair out! You seem caring, calm and you don’t put down other creators you don’t agree with! I respect that! God Bless!!

[@maryrodgers7898]

I agree

[@jenniferdavis2110]

I totally agree..Brightest Blessings to you Justin always 🙏❤️

[@cindykeenon2744]

I pray that those Cps reports help Mia and Faith with their court battle against CP.

[@Sj13952]

They failed that poor boy 😢

[@ToshaRaeNailed]

I what was going on in that house with Sebastian has everything to do with why he went missing

[@LandiRae]

Oh yes... I agree!

[@NecroLiquor.]

Exactly. Once cps makes contact the situation becomes far more punishing and dangerous for the child.

[@tharrison0043]

I noticed CP has been quiet since he went on that disgusting rant the other day, he knows he messed up big time, and as for CPS being called, I do think they were called more than twice, and shame on KP and CPS for letting CP stay in that house with Sebastian, if CPS had done their job Sebastian might be with us right now. Nobody can count on CPS, they have let so many children down over the years, and so have the Judges.

[@deborahvandenheuvel1904]

But Chris was gone in Feb during investigation and the disappearance . So it is on Katie . Your all guessing and listening to hearsay gossip and no proof . Just saying police are on this just watch

[@MargaretSullivan-ob7yk]

It appears CPS was called at least 4 times to the Hendersonville home. CP has had CPS in his life in California and New Mexico. This little man is a menace. Supposedly he allegedly punched a step daughter in the mouth busting it open as she had braces. This CP is dangerous to children and women. It would not surprise me if he went too far.

[@wisewillow5731]

So did TBI get told by local authorities "these parents are upstanding parents, from outstanding parent$$" no need to check CPS records??

[@debsibson7071]

God I hope not.

[@lanacmurphy]

So this is why Chris wouldn’t release dates on when he was visiting home. Why you said law-enforcement told him not to give specific dates about that. He probably was told that he had to leave the home or Sebastian had to.

[@ToshaRaeNailed]

I hope what they did is haunting them to no end

[@maryc1849]

Yes, exactly!!! And I am so glad we are all still thinking/talking about Sebastian 2 1/2 mths later..I myself have been thinking thos whole time & i truly believe that CP & KP did not think this case would blow up the way it did! They felt Sebastian wasn't very important to anyone so it'd be and open/close case, Boy were they sooo wrong!! And also they figured they wouldn't get caught due to them being friends with L.E. & whatnot & sadly, they were prob right about that had it not been for Seth, all of the YT creators & us followers who are refusing to let it blow over!!

[@Milosmomma24]

I’m sure it is and especially Katie leaving the home

[@carolbruner5226]

Happens all the time

[@DaisyJo82]

CP reminds me exactly of my X. Hence X. He was a narcissist. Everything was about him and his military career of being in the special forces. He got to where he was trying to dictate everything I did. When I say it was about him, I mean everything. He was a OTR truck driver and it got to where I dreaded him coming home on the weekends. He would tell me to get ready and dare I ask where we were going. Never asked what I or my son was in the mood for to eat. We ate wherever he took us. At the time, I smoked. He started trying to tell me when I could go outside and smoke or if he thought it was too soon. He had heart problems but I think he enjoyed going to the hospital because we would get in the car and never failed we would end up at a hospital somewhere regardless of it being 10 miles from home or 110 miles from home. My son was 14 at the time and he would make him go with us. My son didn’t want to set in a hospital on his weekends off from school. He got to where he would set a timer when my son would shower. Just anything to show his authority. Well he ended up having open heart surgery and the day after he came home from the hospital, he was irritable etc. I went out to smoke and he started yelling I needed to wait another hour. I stood up to him and said ain’t no man gonna tell me when I can or can’t do anything. My son got upset and went to his room and shut the door. He was sitting in his bed crying and the X went in there and got up in his face yelling that he was crying like a little pu$$y. That was the first time he’d ever been aggressive with my son and it was the last. I left him. I packed all of his stuff and made him come get it, open heart surgery or not. I never looked back. CP reminds me so so much of him. Poor Sebastian my heart hurts for what he probably endured at the hands of CP the monster.

[@MargaretSullivan-ob7yk]

Sebastian Rogers, Summer Wells, Tabitha Tuders and on and on. What is happening in Tennessee, CP refers to TBI agents and other LE by first names??? Wth is wrong. I love Tennessee but would never bring a child to the state. KP should be arrested for child neglect. CP should be arrested for making verbal threats against Seth and the woman. This is horrifying.

[@bellawinfield8577]

Sebastian tried to tell the school the teachers. But CP got called down by CPS last time in end of Jan. Then Sebastian gone Feb 26. So very sad 😢😢

[@user-sf4sj1in3s]

Is that why Chris is saying he hasn't been at the home since February 1st? Like he's a good guy and they separated. He left 3 days later?

[@KatVog]

A caller on BHB (whether true or not?) said several people, including him, called CPS. CPS told them they couldn't do anything. So, people stopped reporting to them.

[@triamaria]

@@user-sf4sj1in3s CPS likely removed him from the home during the investigation, he didn't say he hadn't been there he claimed he couldn't say! He was sneaking back home, neighbors saw him

[@triamaria]

​@@KatVogExactly why Chris knew the CPS lady who came to his house, he told Smiley's World channel he knew her from previous reports made against him but tried to down play it!

[@lisabotkin4858]

😢It was interesting to find out Sumner County LE already had the CPS report when Seth took his newly acquired CPS report to show Sumner County LE

[@annetrisshuntsman1637]

I think I recall Seth saying TBI disnt have them. Maybe TBI has them now

[@pameladefague6119]

Would be interested to know what went on at their previous address. If there were CPS reports there, and from neighbours and school back then. For exactly how long this (alleged) abuse has been reported, and going on.

[@ronjaggers7756]

💥 Here's another clue CP keeps saying it talking about No one is Going to search there home or he's families Property so The Authority s need to search there Property there could be something there on families Property.💥💥💥💚💚💚💚💚💥💥💥💥💥

[@user-gr8ts4le5r]

I think that there was bruises and marks on Sabastian,he was injured in my opinion and succumbed to his injuries.

[@judichristophersen7238]

This breaks my heart😢

[@annetrisshuntsman1637]

Katie may have also had CPS case because CP was on a live i was watching and someone said something about a CPS case and CP ask the on me or who. Makes me wonder if KP had one too

[@andrealamont5367]

She also didn’t talk about being on the phone with Chris to that neighbor as well. She told the neighbor she was sleeping on the couch in the living room.

[@ToshaRaeNailed]

I thought that call was CP as soon as I heard the voice

[@victorialander]

I agree

[@carolcarol62]

Agree

[@wisewillow5731]

I agree Justin. How do we cut the bullshit out when this whole case is full of it..

[@NecroLiquor.]

Ill never forget years ago there were cases of families in counseling and the focal point was teaching children to understand the importance of allowing their mothers "to be happy" and "to move on" from dissolved marriages. The point of being emotionally, mentally, and/or physucally abused would be purposefully excluded and counselors would be left with the interpretation that many wirst case scenarios were the result of them not wanting their mothers to have a life apart from being theur mothers. Several of these horrible cases would slowly further come to light much like these missing/deceased children discovered. Too little, too late... but these are the things that im reminded of when these issues come up 💯

[@claudetteharrison9739]

I know he told one of his teachers about the belt and they can't CPS came to the house

[@lanacmurphy]

I missed your life. But the question you asked does anyone believe he only did that one time. Well I believe he did it more than once for sure and I think he also gave him more than one lick. We have all seen how long it takes him to calm down once he’s angry And that’s pretty messed up

[@ToshaRaeNailed]

Thank you for filling us in. I don’t watch the P show.

[@claudetteharrison9739]

LOL THAT WAS CHRIS

[@pameladefague6119]

Sounded like him didn't it....

[@Sugarplum33]

I thought so too as soon as I heard it

[@Truecrime822]

I think Tony is doing a great job. Who cares what other people think.

[@cathysmith6956]

The pertains to the lady called in about child protective papers Seth received yes that would explain a lot of things how this case has been going on due to the fact that 911 was not called. The sheriff department was called because of connections. This is something attorney needs to find out what’s going on FBI needs to be brought in big time

[@marthariddlegarcia2991]

Justin’s new word, serious matrimonist. Also known as a serial mattress moaniness. It would explain 5 marriages. Lol

[@autumnsnanni]

Too true!😂😂😂😂

[@TobyMarieGenX]

Are the Proudfoots still camping in the RV? My suspicions believe they are not comfortable at home because neighbors are watching and reporting. He doesn't like the fishbowl.

[@jazz5132]

So why did Katie say she owned an infinity? If CPS was called on several occasions Nina could have used that against Chris in court. Honestly I think Sebastian never made it home. If Chris & Katie were abusing Sebastian I think one took it too far. And they had all night to get rid of him.

[@MargaretSullivan-ob7yk]

Imo, Sebastian left Texas Roadhouse and something happened.

[@adrianakessler384]

I do love how calm your voice is! 💙

[@mywrench]

Justin in the beginning it was said KP was having an affair with a neighbor. Also it was said, Sebastian was spending time at the guys house. Has anyone looked into that?

[@MichaelWH]

Was also said Chris was having the affair ,?

[@mywrench]

@@MichaelWH what I heard was that Sebastian spent time at that man’s home prior to going missing

[@MichaelWH]

@@mywrench I have heard both had side action, who knows ? 🤷‍♂

[@lindabaileybrown3383]

The lady that was on at 1:07.16 , I know it isn't but she sounded just like Leticia Staunch .

[@AmosLiz]

I work with individuals with Autism and just a note. They certainly do know how to lie.

[@babyfirefly8149]

I know it’s true. My high functioning niece told her therapist a lie about her neighbor that was so bad. She made up a story to excuse her not wanting to work and blame it on “anxiety”. Thank god the therapist has worked with her for awhile and can see that she has a tendency to lie.

[@atlramona]

Ability to lie is based on intellect and d is developmental.

[@Loveitorleaveit777]

Replay warrior here.. I think the Pascal show was a lot of hype. It was switched to members only halfway through😢 If he is only going to answer qqq from superchats then being a member is a waste. If I'm paying 5.00 for membership then at least answer questions.

[@andrealamont5367]

That wasn’t Pascal’s fault it was the Mod’s who decided to do that until he found out and made them switch it back.

[@annetrisshuntsman1637]

Has anyone heard where CPs motorcycle was at the night Sebastian went missing

[@kristinasnyder1409]

He can't tell because Sebastian is underage.

[@adrianakessler384]

Love 💕 the show, BUT INTRO is way too long, Justin. I guess one let it play, but I skip intros pass 30 seconds 😉.

[@LandiRae]

Yes, cp has a harley!

[@annetrisshuntsman1637]

I wonder where it was the night Sebastian went missing

[@MargaretSullivan-ob7yk]

CP got a discount for wearing the Harley store's t shirt on Nancy Grace. KP had one on as well.

[@ceceliawenn340]

I always dance totge musuc so relaxing

[@maryd3695]

That was a strange first call.

[@Hawkeye_Pierce_]

Maybe he was carried out and that was why there was no scent

[@debsibson7071]

Or he didn’t make it home after roadhouse

[@pamelakingrry1177]

Child protective service is kin to chris.There are 2 cousins of chris that work there.

[@annetrisshuntsman1637]

I seen yesterday that CP went on Brooks channel( I think) and was doing the crazy rant he does

[@user-yr1cq5nx8l]

I love the one comment on the Pascal show regarding the boundaries of maybe a social worker or a teacher that might have Sebastian. Tony and Seth laughed it off as if it were a lifetime movie or something they’d seen on Netflix. But I don’t think that’s so off. I think this needs to be investigated. Perhaps Sebastian did find confidence in someone and they are taking care of him. That’s just my thought.

[@earthdog9552]

IF your child is Autistic, _please_ look into getting them a metal detox, and, measure the water they are drinking to make sure they aren't getting heavy metals with every sip of water they take. It can make a _huge difference_ trust me.

[@ronjaggers7756]

Yes I remember that him saying that

[@shelley4295]

KP I a survivor. It may be that KP is threatened by CP and that is why she is quiet.

[@debsibson7071]

She wasn’t so quiet on that rant call. She was in the back ground egging him on

[@adrianakessler384]

Why doesn’t someone in the area just go record from 3 a.m. until 6 a.m., to see what garbage truck pulls in, and at what time between those hours, as far as garbage trucks. I just don’t understand how we do not have him or a car pulling out all night long? It just feels like there should be footage of SOMEONE or something. I hope he is out there, but I get a gut feeling something is wrong 😑 in this case. I believed Katie, for three seconds, when I had seen her on a short. As far as spankings, they still gave them in school when I went. Times have changed though. The actions afterwards, make me question what was done ✅ to/with Sebastian 💚. I think 🤔 a strict home can harden you, and I know from the hospital, mute patients aren’t the best patients in my opinion, as some may prefer that, but Katie having nobody, then caretaking for Sebastian, and her responses on his stance, etc.., and a distant, condescending husband like Chris, I could see a shit storm ⛈️ brewing in that home.

[@andrealamont5367]

Whatever he did seems like it did get him out.

[@chopperchic8443]

Does he ride with a m/c does anyone know?

[@mayla8477]

I'm wondering the same thing.

[@matildagreene1744]

Overworked and under staffed.

[@atlramona]

Haley’s Law

[@smileystoreysworld2882]

Replay ❤️

[@sis233]

I wonder when Sebastian became verbal

[@debsibson7071]

When he was young. He’s been verbal all along it’s not new

[@marlenabryant5547]

That would be with a belt that "he swatted" Sebastian one time over his clothes.

[@carolbruner5226]

No excu

[@fibbermcghee23]

She's awful and why so formal- ?

[@charleneinman3625]

My niece got mad at my husband and I once so she got spiteful and tried to hit us in the spot that would hurt worse .She called CPS on us with off the wall false allegations.Before they came to our home they went and talked to all our children at the schools .They even questioned our autistic child that was eight yrs old at the time .Did these workers ever talk to Sebastian by himself? The calls were mostly coming from the school teachers .Did they not believe these ppl ? The workers came to our house and said they just had to follow up .They said they spoke to our children and knew the allegations were false .I asked what if they were true ,what would have been done .They said immediately removed! Now ..how on earth did Sebastian not be removed from Proudfoots home ? I was so scared my kids were going to get taken over the things my niece told them .The worker said they can tell when allegations were fake .The wrkrs on Sebastian’s case need to be reviewed or fired from that job .The lack of common sense was a big issue in this case! My heart aches for Sebastian.I pray he’s alive and comes home to his Dad! 💚💚💚💚💚💚👑👑👑👑💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚😇😇😇😇😇💚💚💚 😊