Explaining The Flash's BROKEN Timeline

[@Madvocate]

The Flash is a masterpiece. We need a CW live action Flash show.

[@throwbackglitcher]

ThErE's NoWeRe To RuN The Flash Is Insufferably Inconsistent Season 4

[@GIGio_Official]

Sounds like a nightmare show i and many others can milk for content

[@throwbackglitcher]

@@GIGio_Official higher viewers = better show

[@BSJ-Unparalleled]

Hey Madvocate. So when are we gonna get the Flash is Insufferably Inconsistent part 4?

[@robertlafrance9974]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 it's not always a masterpiece

[@JDMaverick6714]

The writers’ goals are beyond your understanding ⚡️

[@GIGio_Official]

Beyond my sanity is more like it

[@JDMaverick6714]

🤪😂

[@alexcirimpei7639]

@@GIGio_Official 😂😂😂

[@zalamael]

It was me Barry. I went back in time and convinced the writers at CW to make you look like an idiot!

[@NeroLeMorte]

@@GIGio_Official XD

[@sonicsega6]

Theres also technically a timeline before season 1 where reverse flash never went back in time to kill Barry's mother and replace the OG Harrison wells. The timeline that thawne and the future newspaper are originally from

[@thundervolt1018]

Damn you’re right, the og before Thawne decided to fuck everything up

[@thetruesora]

yeah the characters all act like season 1 was the original timeline (because for Barry that was HIS original timeline) like as time travel starts becoming a thing they're worried about creating a brand new timeline BUT they already know and seem to overlook that they're living in an alternate timeline, that Eobard killing Nora was something that didn't happen originally and was him acting out because he didn't get child Barry

[@giovannigiovanni.7220]

@@thetruesora OG Timeline: kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3zZgIWHq9qSbq8

[@buincqv67]

That’s the timeline where the flash was supposed to get his powers in 2020.

[@thundervolt1018]

But how did Flash get his powers in the original timeline when Thawne was the one that created the Particle Accelerator

[@stevenlannister184]

"The thing about time travel Barry, is the more you understand it, the less the rules apply to you..."

[@GIGio_Official]

That would at least make a little more sense as long as they don't contradict it in the same episode

[@The_Watcher_0]

@@GIGio_Official hopefully season 9 fixes this fucked up timeline, hopes not that high though

[@LEGOEGGOE]

Its the more you do it not the more you understand it

[@KylarStern244]

@@The_Watcher_0Abooouuuut that..... :/ Not that I can say much, as soon as he *vibrated away a nuclear explosion and its subsequent radiation (somehow)* I dipped XD

[@RandomMackem0069_Official]

The more you understand it the less you understand it

[@TheVortexAMV]

He is only explaining the Flash Timeline. I can only imagine what hell it would be to explain entire CW timeline.

[@RealGateGuardian]

I'd buy that for a dollar!

[@ashbarion]

You forgot that Barry time traveled in the S2 Crossover: Heroes Join Forces (Setups Legends of Tomorrow) Barry went back in time after Vandal Savage nuked the city, killed everyone and told Oliver about his son which greatly affects Arrow going foward

[@GIGio_Official]

Fuck i forgot about that crossover. IT NEVER ENDS

[@vetchable]

@@GIGio_Official not to mention that, since barry was there fighting thawn the night his mother died, the "first" timeline is actually a second one (since barry's mom couldn't have been killed by someone who wont be born for 200 years)

[@nicolas._.2294]

@@vetchable yea, the flash timeline was broken from the first episode

[@josegarcia6997]

@@GIGio_Official not to mention the original timeline where Barry never lost his parents and was still the flash which is the timeline that the reverse flash from season 1 comes from after killing Barry's mom creating a new timeline where his mom is dead, his father is in prison and he moves in with Joe and iris

[@vahevanyan6924]

@@GIGio_Official oh yeah and you forgot else worlds

[@johnplays7600]

I now fear what a legends of tomorrow timeline would look like

[@GIGio_Official]

I'm getting PTSD Just thinking about it

[@regiman222]

To be fair that one's almost supposed to be a clusterfuck, "We screw things up for the better" indeed

[@realusa1776]

@@GIGio_Official i kinda wanna see one tho

[@realusa1776]

@@GIGio_Official but i would be dead by the time it finished

[@sonicsega6]

Legends alone has to have created hundreds of alternate timelines

[@AnonymouslyForgotten]

*I love the writer’s solution for the show’s plot holes:* _Having the characters say it doesn’t make sense over and over again._

[@marronromani]

Don’t forget the time he went back in time after Vandal Savage destroyed Central City

[@GIGio_Official]

FUCK. I forgot about that crossover

[@Hollowmello1285]

@@GIGio_Official understandable the bird couple didn't do jack after the first season of legend its easy to forget them

[@justalittleguy4507]

I would love to see you explain the Legends of tomorrows timeline. Imagine a time traveling show that handle time travel probably just as well as flash does.

[@Ana-rf5cu]

Time travel in LOT is different. The changes they cause dont really affect the characters themselves, since they're outside the time stream.

[@that1nerd756]

It's....... It's certainly a bit odd. It definitely has a lot of issues tbh.

[@justalittleguy4507]

@@Ana-rf5cu but they are effected by the changes in the timeline even when there in the time stream, one of the problem around season 3 episode a character fades out of existence because something bad happened to them in the past, there also other times they lose other things because of a problem in the timeline. But then again there are other times when that doesn't happen. it's almost like LOT time travel has no consistency in the show all about time travel.

[@helzbelle13]

29:39 - I was really hoping you were going to mention how it makes the itty bit of backstory we got for Eobard in season 1 ludicrous. In S1, Eobard tells Barry (in 2015) that he was born 136 years from that point, putting his birthdate in the year 2151. However, in Armageddon, (in late 2021) Eobard says that exactly 200 years from that point is when he first got his speed and his origin supposedly takes place.. but that makes Eobard 71 years old when he first gets his super speed and goes up against Barry… then after however many years of fighting, he goes back in time and kills Nora Allen, bla bla bla, and then spends 15 years in the early 21st century.. years later he spends another 15 years in the mid 21st century.. so… Eobard looks really great for a guy who’s clearly well over 100 years old!!!

[@IM_7031]

Any plothole after Season 6 concerning previous seasons can be considered a Crisis change

[@cobracommander4774]

Btw Central City is in Missouri, it's shown on a map in one episode, and in another one, Joe is looking through some sort of statewide database of driver's licenses or something like that (I forget exactly) and it says Missouri on the computer screen. Also the seal on the front of the file folder from Kramer's time in the military identifies the fictional Fort Dakota, at which she was stationed, as being in Missouri. Specifically, Central City is the fictional equivalent of Kansas City, Missouri, as shown by its precise location in the state when shown on a map, and by the fact that it has a "twin" city, Keystone City, comparable to Kansas City, Kansas, which is right next to Kansas City, Missouri. Side note: Deion mentions in a Season 7 episode that he was going to be the next Patrick Mahomes. Mahomes just so happens to be the quarterback of the Kansas City Chiefs in real life. But in the show, Central City's professional football team is the Sharks. So, in the Arrowverse, is Mahomes the QB of the Sharks, while the Chiefs don't exist? Or are there two major professional football leagues- the NFL and the fictional league that the Sharks are in- and Central City has a team in each league, meaning Mahomes is the QB of the Central City Chiefs? Or does Kansas City also exist in the Arrowverse but slightly north or south of where it actually is, because Central City occupies its real-life location within the state of Missouri? All of these are possibilities. It would have been so much less confusing if Deion just said he was going to be the next Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson, or anyone else other than Patrick Mahomes.

[@GIGio_Official]

Holy shit. I love this comment. Thanks for the information and I love the fact that the show even is confusing in regards to its sports teams. Also lets not forget that Deon was playing football in the late 90's way before Mahomes was even in the league so in reality he should have said we was going to be the next John Elway or Brett Favre

[@ItsJae_37]

for some reason i always thought central city was in like new york or something because it looked like a pretty big and populated city but i guess not lol

[@whynot9421]

17:44 If zoom was stopped by a time wraith then, that means Barry’s dad is still alive, flashpoint was never created because Barry would have no reason to do so, and Savitar only exists post flashpoint, so he won’t exist, and Ralph is dead according to Thawne in season 1.

[@thatlonewolfguy2878]

So we have 2 different endings then, the season 9 ending and the "the time force stops Zoom and only season 1 happens" ending basically, that or they just explain it as the Time Wraith pushed him out of the Speed Force and also erased his memory of seeing season 5 Barry and Nora so he just gets back on his mission in season 2, the rest of the show still happens

[@ItsJae_37]

i always wondered why did wells say ralph died back in season 1. is he not even supposed to be alive right now?

[@hynguyen7375]

Remember guys, is he just recapped significant points, there are a lot more time f*ck moments that got gloss over.

[@GIGio_Official]

If i covered all the fuck moments Id still be making the video

[@hynguyen7375]

@@GIGio_Official yes, and I am glad you do so because Cw writing is so bad it become hilarious as this point :)) keep up the good work

[@CrossOutBryce]

Surprised in the Season 5 recap, you didn't mention that Barry and Nora's plans all go to shit because when they traveled to 2016 to get Thawne's help, they told him EXACTLY what he needed to know to set his plan in motion in Nora's time to free himself from execution 😂 One of the biggest L's from the heroes, but a time travel plot point that...actually had thought behind it and made sense.

[@AnonymouslyForgotten]

I think the biggest plot hole in the show is that Thawne used to be a guy pretending to be A Harrison Wells, but now the show treats him as if he’s a guy who IS A Harrison Wells.

[@eduardomunoz4387]

Technically the Wells Reverse Flash is a Wells thanks to stealing his DNA for his disguise.

[@VwSvNexus]

Not to mention the other wells that are in the show are ACTUALLY real wells from different universes. The wells that we see at the beginning of the show is actually thawn

[@muchanadziko6378]

@@VwSvNexuswell…yeah. Nobody was disputing that

[@faitheffect254]

He’s just a dude playing a dude disguised as another dude.

[@bartholomewnathaniel4900]

​@@eduardomunoz4387that's a good point. Why didn't I think of that.

[@MsCastle1996]

Great video! I have a migraine AND I'm crying but that's nothing compared to the pain you must've felt putting this all together

[@GIGio_Official]

Thank you so much. I will take the pain so you all don't have to

[@poolstroke858]

I known that this has more to do with another show, but my biggest gripes with the series finale for Arrow can be heavily attributed to the changes done by Crisis.

[@GIGio_Official]

I do wish the Arrow finale was more self contained

[@poolstroke858]

@@GIGio_Official Speaking of which, do you plan on doing a retrospective thing now that Arrow’s 10 year anniversary is close?

[@MrDj232]

When Thawne revealed that he killed the real Wells, didn't he also admit to setting off the dark matter explosion sooner than it happened in his own original timeline? Which means even the "clean" timeline from 4:00 is actually an offshoot from another one.

[@that1nerd756]

Well he does both in the same timeline. When Thawne originally got stuck in the past during season 1, he kills Wells because he needs to replace him to speed up the development of the Particle Accelerator. So it's not really another offshoot timeline, it's just season 1.

[@MrDj232]

@@that1nerd756 But there's a timeline that exists prior to season 1, making the season 1 timeline itself an offshoot from another timeline we never see. One which has its own time travel shenanigans because Barry would have to travel through time to meet Thawne.

[@that1nerd756]

@@MrDj232 Oh, I think I misunderstood what you were saying. Yeah, I know the original season 1 timeline is an offshoot. I thought you were saying that there should be another branch in the season 1 timeline. One when Thawne kills Barry's mom and another when he kills Wells and sets off the explosion early.

[@Hollowmello1285]

@@MrDj232 well at least that barry was smart

[@MrDj232]

@@Hollowmello1285 I wonder if that Barry also stood around talking while villains escaped.

[@tinydoowy2024]

I NEED a full video about the multiverse. Please do it :)

[@GIGio_Official]

I may just do that

[@FariZK]

@@GIGio_Official yes dew it

[@buffylovezsupercat]

Thawne's main goal was to get Barry to Marry Iris & altering/ruining his life. In the Pilot the future Article that Thawne was looking at wasn't written by Iris. Thawne wants to ruin Barry's live but yet he's happy to push Barry & Iris together.

[@GIGio_Official]

Honestly at this point nothing makes sense

[@kidkatanatv]

I'm guessing because Eddie was in the picture and wasn't supposed to happen so Eobard had insurance that he'd naturally be born in the timeline

[@鄧焯文]

Because reverse flash know iris only care about herself

[@namecomingsoon9517]

Comic Thawne backstory is that he was a Flash fan so became the Flash of his time then Barry from the past showed up and then Barry and him got along but then Barry found out Thawne was causing crimes just to solve them so Barry went back to his time. Thawne was upset and so went back in time to see Barry again but then found out Barry had a whole life without Thawne and he got upset that his relationship with Barry wasn’t special and then found out that he’s supposed to be his enemy through the Flash museum and became the Reverse Flash Now he’s a living paradox that’s can’t really be killed cause another version of him exists throughout the time stream This is why i love Thawne. He has the powers of a god and is so petty lol

[@GIGio_Official]

I enjoy pettiness. I just wish the petty revenge made sense. lol

[@zemox2534]

@@GIGio_Official Made sense in the comics but of course CW writing fucks his backstory up. Just like they fuck everything else up on the show

[@theunknownvoidz1409]

@@zemox2534The most f-up thing is that Thawne became Barry’s enemy because it was the only thing he could think of to spend time with him. Eobard never intended to become the Reverse-Flash, he wanted to become Barry’s partner, the next “Kid Flash” and that’s the rationale on why he chose yellow.

[@ShermanYeo]

@@theunknownvoidz1409 Well, if I were Barry, I would just ignore him all the time, because all of this bullying and torture to Barry just to spend time with him is just too fucking dumb.

[@theunknownvoidz1409]

@@ShermanYeo Thawne is, after all, a psychopathic speedster fanboy.

[@oliverqueen9886]

Yeah. There have been lots of times throughout the show where I have been confused with stuff. For example 1. How Reverse Flash is still alive after Eddie killed himself. It sort of made sense seeing him only exist in the past as a timeline remnant during s2 and s3. But it didn't make sense seeing him alive in earth x crossover and seeing him in s5 future and later seasons. Plus its strange him not using his real face played by Matt. S1 timeline made sense to look like wells but after that timeline only matt should play him. 2. Savitars origin story is very confusing as well. 3. Some of the time travel changes are confusing. 4. Time remnants

[@enoyna1001]

I've read the Arrowverse Wiki article on time remnants. To be honest, it was easier to understand spin quantum mechanics than this bs.

[@milkman4407]

7:30 it actually makes complete sense when you go insane, time remnants are fragments of timelines that don’t actually exist, but exist because they need to to make the current timeline exist, if they’re stopped before they cause said timeline (like the reverse flash) bad things happen, but if it’s after like Zoom’s time remnant presumably was, it causes no ill effects on the timeline, as its the equivalent of killing an alternate earth version of yourself.

[@skyK7711]

You can see how much his anger has been built up throughout the video by looking at the start of the video and the end lol

[@GIGio_Official]

It was very painfull. I peaked my mic a few times. lol

[@JordyProductions]

my question is how are there metahumans in flashpoint without a particle accelerator explosion

[@GIGio_Official]

....holy shit

[@tregriffin4009]

Remember the particle accelerator still gets made by the original wells

[@JordyProductions]

@@tregriffin4009 yeah but that is in 2020

[@tregriffin4009]

@@JordyProductions it gets created no matter what time line you refer too

[@JordyProductions]

@@tregriffin4009 yeah but it happens in 2020

[@Brandonhung95]

I'd love to see you cover the multiverse!! It's just as messed up as the timeline.

[@GIGio_Official]

This video has definitely been put on the to do list

[@shinkaiatsuya950]

At this point the teacup example that Jay used in season 3 has been grounded to dust, maybe even atomized. Time travel is never straightforward, so you either need rules like Steins Gate, or comedy like Back to the Future. But that's expecting too much out of Flash writers.

[@GIGio_Official]

Very true. It's such a waste to set up rules only to ignore them at every turn

[@adamingram04]

I remember an interview with one of the writers around season 3, and he said they were driving themselves crazy in the writers room trying to figure out rules from time travel and how to keep things consistent and he said they had a major breakthrough when they realized it was all made up anyway and they could just create the rules as they go. And he said this as if it was a good thing. I knew at that point that the time travel would never be anything close to consistent

[@kubomagico8853]

Extra timelines that should be added: 1. Original timeline where Barry's mother was alive 2. Timeline where Savage nuked Central City in the crossover 3. Timeline where Barry goes back in time to create a remnant to help stoping Zoom 4. Timeline where Barry never knew Iris was going to be killed by Savitar 5. Timeline where Barry didn't go to the future and got knowledge from his future self 6. When Despero time travelled 7. All the times Nora and Bart time travelled 8. All the times the reverse flash time travelled 9. All the times godspeed time travelled 10. Every new timeline created in Legends of Tomorrow Conclusion: the timeline looks more like a spider web

[@Rachebart]

I really want to see this ❤

[@yugiwinninglex]

It's like how previously flash point is created by travelling to the past bt now travelling to the future also causes it somehow.

[@GIGio_Official]

Cause rule mean nothing in this show

[@yugiwinninglex]

@@GIGio_Official yea. Eric wallace just writing whatever he wants.

[@eduardomunoz4387]

Well, "past" and "future" are matters of perspective. Even if Barry travels to the Future, that still creates a "Flashpoint" of some sort for the people in the future, including Nora herself.

[@ciarandodrill3562]

You missing a Major fact, from the first episode of the show it was already set in an alternative timeline that was created by Wells causing barry to gain his powers a couple years earlier.

[@Iampaztro]

25:00 my best guess is that he with came back to earth 1 and some how survived, but most likely survived by staying in the speed force

[@margaritacharalambidou9304]

Dudes videos are the best thing to happen to me today

[@bcwgames1083]

U also forgot to mention when Barry reset the day to save everyone from the explosion during the Legends of Yesterday crossover

[@SneakiWasTaken]

The whole flash timeline can be explained in on line. "Congratulations, you played yourself."

[@DemigodShmurda]

Yo, let's talk about the number of retcons in just the season 8 finale alone! Look, this was better than season 7, but that doesn't mean this season was any good!

[@beastonea]

everything after s5 was trash

[@GIGio_Official]

I plan on talking about it. I touch on it here but Just wait till the end of the video I tease my next couple of videos.

[@DemigodShmurda]

@@GIGio_Official Can't wait!

[@beastonea]

@MostaVerse I felt like the second half of season 6 was forcing feminism Wayyy to much. It was really bad. After s6 the show just becomes a feminist shitshow. And yeah, Bloodwork was pretty sick.

[@beastonea]

@MostaVerse how lol

[@ClawlessnessScizor]

Honestly this is perfect in place of a video about Season 8. You've suffered enough, don't subject yourself to more torture!!

[@GIGio_Official]

nah I'm a gluten for punishment

[@JosiahTheMinor]

21:50 not to mention when Barry saw “all the possibilities” he said the only ones were either him sacrificing himself to save the multiverse or everyone dying not some 1990 version lmao this timeline bro

[@SWTobito0702]

Quick thing to note: In season 7 Bart and Nora are from the year 2049 as well. At the start of Season 7 episode 17 there's a title card that says so. Same in season 8.

[@EyedMite]

Yeah……. I’m going to need you to cover those multiverses, that’d be great !

[@GIGio_Official]

Most likely I will

[@HeroSenseiKid]

Amazing Video bro! On the timeline of The Flash 🔥⚡️

[@GIGio_Official]

Thanks bro! glad you liked it

[@golflefleur887]

Sounds like a major case of wibbly wobbly timey wimey. Great video Gio!

[@GIGio_Official]

Thanks ma! glad you enjoyed it.

[@thetruesora]

i remember for the earth x crossover that was explained as time travelling nazis according to notes Cisco put on the white board in one season 6 episode but IIRC they conveniently didn't show his notes on how the events of season 2 went down post-crisis

[@GIGio_Official]

I KNOW LIKE WHAT IS THE TIMELINE IN REGARDS TO SEASON 2 NOW!

[@overdrivestorm6988]

I briefly understood the timeline of the show now I wonder what were the writers thinking

[@GIGio_Official]

Thats easy they weren't

[@overdrivestorm6988]

@@GIGio_Official I'm sure it wasn't

[@Ana-rf5cu]

It must've been pretty hard to keep track of everything for 8 years and they didnt have such a great overview of everything that had happend until that moment. But they really overused time travel in this show. They never should've brought nora into the show.

[@bendyboy7179]

You missed something in the crossover in an Arrow episode in Arrow Season 4 Barry goes back in time a day to stop a Villain.

[@JayFlea]

i’ve been watching this video in parts for the last 12 hours or so and it was a great video to watch. can’t believe you actually suffered through all that it looked really rough to make. because it never made sense to begin with so it’s all a show with no rules i suppose 😂 great video Gio and we all appreciate the quality of it! (P.S nice hand writing lmao)

[@GIGio_Official]

Thank you so much! I am glad you enjoyed and hopefully i can step up the quality next video. (P.S thank you)

[@CalvinNoire]

Watch time go BRRR

[@mandalorianjedi232]

Harry mentioned that he could track Jesse using her frequency he got that idea from 2018 Barry and also since the time wraith caught zoom it probably just earased his memory

[@GIGio_Official]

That is a lot of assumptions to make. I feel like the writers should have explained that if that was the case

[@mandalorianjedi232]

@@GIGio_Official well it was during season 2 they probably didn’t want to reveal anything yet but I do love the connection

[@eduardomunoz4387]

@@GIGio_Official I mean... It could also explain why Zoom was so terrified of the Time Wraths despite probably never encounter them before.

[@Fire_Crystal]

Actually the lack of time wraiths in season 1 make sense. The first time Barry “Time traveled” he didn’t really time travel, kinda just turned back time, explains no time wraiths. The second time he time traveled (In the finale) the reason there were no time wraiths was because thawne was there. In season 2 episode 17, Barry encounters his first time wraith and when thawne finds out Barry isn’t his Barry, he reveals that he knows how to keep out of the way of time wraiths.

[@qucumber_plays]

6:20 you could argue that the first time travel Barry did was not enough for the time wraiths to care about. Or it could be possible that there aren't enough time wraiths for all of the multiverses and all the different speedsters. There is also the possibility that they simply do not care if a speedster time travels for the first time and it is simply a "test drive" or a that they don't notice a speedster time travel until after the first time travel explaining why they go after Barry the second time he does.

[@CaptainphoenixofficialYT]

Alright, I'll throw my hat in the ringer. I'd definitely like to see you do a video on the Arrowverse multiverse. And I'd also like you to dissect what happened to the multiverse after Crisis. Cause in the end of the event, we see other worlds like the ones with Doom Patrol, Star girl and Superman and Lois. Heck even Superman and Lois reference the multiverse in their show, which by the way, takes place post Crisis. So does the Arrow verse multiverse still exist or what?

[@GIGio_Official]

Yeah its a big mess. People seem to want that kind of video so the likelyhood of it happening has increased

[@Brandonhung95]

Apparently Superman doesn't take place in the Arrowverse, or Earth Prime, but on a similar earth but without all the heroes of Earth Prime that's why they are never referenced in the show. It's still dumb thoughbecause technically there is still a multiverse, but I guess they're closed off from the Arrowverse. I dunno.

[@thetruesora]

the multiverse still exists its that the people on earth prime think they're the only earth left since they cant access the multiverse anymore like they used to be able to

[@rootnrut6555]

This video was actually fantastic, keep up the good work!

[@samuelketner1391]

21:55 My exact feelings with crisis and season 6. Vanishing had been built up for 6 years, and then it surmounted to nothing. The first half of season 6 leaned heavily into that plot thread This was the last Jedi moment of the flash for me.

[@CrossOutBryce]

I used to track the timelines like obsessively like this because I love time travel stories, but I gave up around Crisis. There's so many inconsistencies that the writers weren't even trying to keep track of by season 5 and 6 🙃

[@X.v10]

You forgot The Arrow S4 EP 8 i believe 😂😂 When barry went back in time to save everyone from Vandal Savage 😅

[@patton3081]

Do legends of tomorrow's timeline next

[@GIGio_Official]

Are you on drugs. I would die

[@RixesPuffs]

Daaammnnn, the editing and the way you explain stuff in this video is so good. you are underrated.

[@johnprime1147]

And you know the funny thing. For season 8 they could have given the excuse on why Barry doesn't remember key events because he was either visiting the speedforce or he was dropping something off somewhere. And that could be the excuse on why he didn't remember all the things that happened

[@thenine5353]

Also on top of that when barry went into the speed force while nora was time travelling 52 times. wouldnt barry come out of the speedforce way before nora was done trying to fix the timeline because the speedforce is a place outside of time?

[@thetruesora]

on Supergirl that show had other universe's doppelgangers show up. in one episode she goes to a bar she's friends with the owner and him and his doppelganger then became co-owners and live on earth prime as brothers. speaking of the rules and inconsistencies, that show was ok with post crisis having people popping up on earth prime while on Batgirl there being 2 of Kate's sister around meant their existence was hurting each other that one had to die

[@GIGio_Official]

The arrowverse has no consistency when it comes to the effect that other shows and crossovers have on each other

[@thetruesora]

​ @G.I. Gio ironically legends of tomorrow is my favourite by owning up to its wacky nonsense and wearing its craziness openly. I can't remember which show it was for but one of the producers i think admitted there wasn't really much communication between the shows to know much of what the post crisis version of for the previous seasons of each shows then looked like. it was just "well if you want to reuse an old villain then you can change it to whatever you want it to be now". as for inconsistencies, i think between the flash (even within itself) and legends of tomorrow, i'm sure they've used time remnant usually to refer to the past self that is now on a different path but a few times they've called the version that travelled back in time as the time remnant. like in the second season finale of LoT the future versions of the legends i think are referred to as remnants at one point when it should be their past selves. that might be me either mishearing or misremembering it. One side note that also about "trouble with timelines and stuff" is that they had it be because Harry and Jessie were on Earth 2 they weren't affected by Flashpoint and when they returned in season 3 they were able to see that there were changes. suggesting there's a rule that if you're on another earth then you're free to remember your timeline and be unaffected. which feels like it should have some implications. but its just an asspull to say "er yeah post flashpoint they're still ok as we don't wanna deal with what differences they might have gone through". its brought up by them not knowing the "new time lab" or whatever it was that wasn't there pre-flashpoint. surely it would have been fine to have them recognise it from their experience in the rewrote version of season 2 but ok. anyway, kinda rambled a bit there but great videos and look forward to your one talking more about season 8 and all others you make :D

[@TecTitan]

This video being essentially a break down of how hard berry fucks up is so special to me I love the way that's just how it has to be.

[@FushiNekko]

Im sad and happy at the same time that the Flash is about to end in S9. Hope to see zoom savitar or rf in the last season

[@GIGio_Official]

It's really bitter sweet. On one hand the show will be put out of its misery, but on the other hand i need to find a new show to milk. lol

[@ricardozk]

1:45 hey that's this year

[@GIGio_Official]

Dear god. I will never not find that crazy.

[@ricardozk]

​@@GIGio_Official😂 kinda meta tbh.

[@CanaldoPortador]

30:39 Just something: Now, they presume that the Time Wraiths brought him back as a reward but considering how his every action and very existence contributes to Negative Deon's plan I'd say that Season 8 goody-two-shoes Eobard is Deon's doing

[@fishertheadore6095]

Looks like You put on some weight, that's good King. Keep up tha Good Work.

[@GIGio_Official]

Thank man! Been trying hard to gain some weight and muscle.

[@andrewrosser1820]

I always thought it was insane how Zoom from season 2 could keep up with Nora and Barry from SEASON 5 🤣🤣

[@Josh-oj9mm]

Nora is slow as fuck and Barry slowed down purposely because otherwise he would smoke past her

[@studyingeducation8438]

They were not wearing protective suits to run faster, their clothes would fry

[@Celerott]

I'm pretty sure I was subscribed before, it's weird that KZbin unsubscribed me. Another great video, I love your work.

[@MiltonGagliardi]

The biggest victim here is the poor marker at the end. What did it do to you to deserve so much violence?

[@GIGio_Official]

It was just in the wrong hands at the wrong time

[@benward1295]

next try explaining how kate kane was pronounced by the cosmic powers to be the universe’s “bat of the future” only to be replaced by a different bat less than a year later

[@icedflatwhite]

i would just like to add that if Nora and Bart in season 7 came back from 2042... Nora (confirmed 26 years old) was born in 2016.

[@GIGio_Official]

....for fuck sakes

[@penuelodiaka652]

No she was 26 years old in 2049, not 2042. She was born in 2023

[@gracekim1998]

@@penuelodiaka652 thank you

[@Madcup420]

When they accidentally erased barrys memories, surley the events that caused savitar to exist wouldn't happen until barry gets his memories back, so savitar should of just been [ ]

[@BusrtNova]

I subbed just for that Mia Malkova line alone, that's all the Flash lore canon I needed to know😂

[@GIGio_Official]

It's all you will ever need. lol

[@mzothuledlamini7601]

God bless Mia Malkova

[@GoblinMember]

I did like that Reverse-Flashpoint b/c it was basically Eobard having a temper tantrum which was actually very like his character. But this whole video is spot on

[@MinecraftJimmy7951]

I don’t think Thawne was being serious when he said “You just ran out of luck” about the Time Wraiths. I think it was a little joke. What I think the reason they didn’t attack Barry in season 1 is because the speed force knew what was going to happen so they show Barry a speed mirage of his future self time traveling and then Barry time travels and alters the timeline, saving Central City. Like the speed force told Barry that they let him create flashpoint because it knew Barry was hurting from his father's death in season 3.

[@nabeelhussein2918]

Watching this made ME out of breath!!

[@zandermacintyre6879]

I didn’t realize this before but I like how they killed reverse flash who is immune to paradoxes with a paradox but Zoom who is just a regular speedster was completely unaffected by a paradox

[@kidkatanatv]

See that's the thing about time travel Zander! The more you do it, the less the rules apply to you!

[@docplays6508]

Savitar was created when Barry had help from his time remnant to stop Zoom but you said that time remnant was created trying to stop Savitar

[@jaxxpool9630]

There are a few more details I should mention that breaks the lore of the Arrowverse after Crisis. "pulls out presentation stick" 1. Apparently Jay is alive because Henry Allen is dead on Earth 1, so Jay can't get erased. But.....that doesn't make sense either. I need to point out the matter that Jay and Henry would've grew up on the same Earth together, which means they've should've both died a long time ago or something. 2. When Thawne created Reverse-Flashpoint, it should've permanently erased the present timeline that Team Flash lives in. Ex: You know when Despero murders all of Barry's friends? .....That shouldn't have been possible because the timeline should be gone. 3. Gio, you should use this for your Season 8 video. The Negative Forces want to kill Barry because he disrupted the cosmic balance or something when he took Thawne's speed.....Yet there's not problem with Thawne trying to kill Barry all these years? Also, isn't it confusing that the Negative Forces have existed since the beginning of time when Barry created the Positive Forces? "puts away presentation stick" Whew, that took a lot out of me. You know, I keeping hearing people say that Flash has always been bad. But seasons 1 and 2 at least were pretty self contained. In fact even if I were to agree that those seasons are bad, I would say it's not because Barry is dumb.....It's because the villains are underpowered and might not be as competent as their comic versions.

[@thundervolt1018]

I’m just confused, since the Negative Speed Force was something Thawne made to combat the actual Speed Force that Barry had. So how would the Negative Speed Force be there since the beginning of time if it was made as a sorta rip off the the og Speed Force

[@thetruesora]

i thought they went with "Jay and Joan transferred over to earth-prime they were remade as separate people and no longer alternate doppelgangers of Henry and Nora"? that still doesn't cover the other issues of them growing up on the same earth and having the same face as Barry's parents but yeah officially i'm pretty sure its that post crisis and the newly formed earth-prime included having it be "these people are universally recognised as earth-prime Jay and Joan, not earth 3(?) Henry and Nora". However, that doesn't fully cover it as there's the question of Jay's appearance on Stargirl. According to the actor its supposed to be the same version of Jay which would suggest that post crisis he's from THAT Earth and then at some point in the last decade ish moved to Earth Prime

[@GIGio_Official]

Great comment as usual Jax. but yeah the lore has been beyond screwed at this point. I can still watch season 1 and 2 and get enjoyment out of it but season 4 onwards just hurts my soul

[@jaxxpool9630]

@@GIGio_Official BTW, you should tell me if I need to make my comments shorter. Someone said I type too long and it's kinda a bad habit of mine.

[@lexyleighmalinowski4136]

Please I would love to see all those different universes explained and I'm interested in watching your future episodes in your past episodes I get to go back in time in a way

[@arex3071]

yes by the way we do need a separate multiverse vid

[@GIGio_Official]

It's gonna happen

[@ninothewhy7785]

32:01 “…is where I draw the line” Dude, you drew like thirteen lines, I think it’s a bit late to say that.

[@itsmefm]

You really went through it here.... Is it bad that I enjoyed this lolll

[@GIGio_Official]

No, I suffer for your entertainment. Its a tough job but someone has to do it

[@itsmefm]

@@GIGio_Official I really commend you for your hard work!!! You deserve more subs and recognition

[@buttermaster1655]

I just realized Barry dosent need to tell his future self anything Barry does savitar remembers so just learning that it’s because of time remnants should make Barry not summon any in the battle with savitar effectively ending the loop

[@eduardomunoz4387]

The problem is that Savitar killing Iris just push Barry to much into almost insanity, so he could still using the Time Remmants to just get Savitar out of his life and the Time Remmant that survives just goes even more crazy because he knows that everyone hates him because he is fated to become Savitar. Both Barry's just... Gave up trying to changes things without Iris.

[@jussieb7244]

I just can't wait to see how they are going to handle this new Captain Boomerang. Is he the son of Digger Harkness, Owen Mercer? And/ or the half brother of Bart Allen like in the comics?

[@GIGio_Official]

I want it to be a half brother jsut so i can see the show try to explain that shit. lol

[@jussieb7244]

Best of luck to them

[@eduardomunoz4387]

@@GIGio_Official I mean... There's still the ORIGINAL Timeline before Thawne time travelled and killed Nora, so...

[@HoodieNinja_69]

This was hilarious 😂. Thanks for the update cuz I'd never put myself through this

[@jinxysaberk]

It's so sad I actually liked s1-4, 1-2 are amazing and 3-4 are guilty pleasures but I couldn't even enjoy it anymore

[@TheHaas123]

2:57 central city is in Missouri, most people generally say it’s around where Kansas City is, so near the Kansas border.

[@koshinukeprower4477]

Thanks for my lesson of CWology 101

[@GIGio_Official]

All of this will be on the test

[@koshinukeprower4477]

@@GIGio_Official I have to brush up on my studies then.

[@faitheffect254]

The negative speed force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be… unnatural. They could have just gone the Poe Dameron route “Somehow Thawne Returned”

[@naschaos25jxf57]

Explaining this timeline is a running joke in my family cause both my dad and sibling cant really get it. It goes over their heads. At least my sib gets multiverses while my dad is still confused after watching loki I had to explain it and he still only gets half of it. So whenever I just want to make them confuse I just start talking about this timeline with the little knowledge I have cause I droppedthe show after the Thinker was the villian.

[@GIGio_Official]

Yeah trying to explain this shit to my dad is like trying to speak to him in mandarin. Its such a mess it is baffeling

[@rafikshaheed4271]

Eddie is Eobard’s ancestor. When Eddie killed himself, Eobard Thawne/ Reverse Flash is never born, which should erase all of Season 1 for if Eobard was never alive, Nora Allen wouldn’t have died, Henry wouldn’t be in prison for 15 years, and particle accelerator wouldn’t have been created, meaning Barry Allen would not have become the Flash.

[@councilmanbanks6528]

Video Idea: What to do with The Flash Movie with Ezra Miller issue, (Recast, Wally, Comic Accurate, Grant Gustin) Basicly with you being a Flash fan what would you want your movie

[@GIGio_Official]

I have thought of the idea of rewrites and pitches for videos, it just trying to find the time and doing it in a fresh way

[@ig.p3_8m87]

You deserve more subs and views 🔥🔥🔥

[@GIGio_Official]

Thanks bro! I really appreciate it. I'm hoping for 25k before 2023. But gotta keep grinding

[@goofygoober9719]

It's speed force, we don't have to explain shit!

[@GIGio_Official]

That seems to be the rule in the writers room

[@a.p907]

Thank you for making a video that perfectly encompasses why I hate time travel fiction.

[@kateomahoney]

Dude, what's up with your audio?

[@GIGio_Official]

Yeah was using a lav. mic for the first time and didn't anticipate how much it would peak. I saved it as much as i could in the edit but now i know more adjustments would need to be made in the future along with using my normal mic as a back up. Thanks for pointing that out.

[@kateomahoney]

@@GIGio_Official Thanks for the response! If that happens again, the Highpass filter might help. It's saved me a couple times!

[@fazerolyt3882]

There's a good explanation. As the doctor would say "wibboly wobbly timey wimey stuff"

[@FredLloyd-Ward-iu4rm]

I understood that reffrence

[@elperrodelautumo7511]

They the flash timeline is so broken I wonder if the next few will break the dc universe or so forth. Already the arrow universe is so fused.

[@GIGio_Official]

At this point there is no saving this timeline

[@Je-S1001]

7:08 A time remnants is someone from a timeline that no longer exists, and while it’s never outright said which is it, with that info in mind it’s implied that the future speedster is always the time remnant since they’re the ones from a timeline that didn’t have a time remnant. If that makes sense.

[@ONEPEAKFRFR]

Babe wake up Madvocate is live!

[@GIGio_Official]

Fuck. once this video finished premiering i literally didn't even look at my phone. I need to catch his next stream

[@danyaelle1753]

Love the vid. I have watched flash since season one and I still do but I can agree it is a mess. Glad to see a 'complete timeline' of it all. Also loved the stickman orgy line. Fucking perfectly sums up what a show with time travel should not look like chronologically.