F. D. Roosevelt: Replay Analysis

[@WoWsBestMoments]

He had an ENUF divi on his team, and yet it wasn't... enough. :D

[@WoWsBestMoments]

@Graha Danar Hey, Thanks!

[@tim9241]

To be fair, that was an easy win if that suicidal Yamato didn’t ram a nearly dead Kremlin...

[@dr.hououin6638]

Yamato committing suicide is historically accurate tho lol

[@berzec]

@@dr.hououin6638 when? All I remember is the US spamming 11 carriers to kill it

[@alfredconqueror4422]

I love my Haku but seeing this makes me want to cheat on her

[@Dominus_Potatus]

I loved my Haku until I got MVR 2 days ago... Damn it is powerful

[@oui6794]

the midway is just a small fdr. change my mind

[@benjaxalo8698]

is a shit use the torps only 2

[@thesant3905]

Not gonna lie, I think wargaming is gonna add Shinano or something like that as an other nation's counterpart Which, seeing how this carrier is, scares me

[@snowykaze]

Maybe but maybe not. Shinano was never designed as a fleet carrier, instead as a support carrier to carry replenishments.

[@bakaweiner6956]

@@snowykaze At first, there's an option to make Shinano as Japan's biggest carrier with her own combat air group, but instead they choose to make her as support carrier like HMS Unicorn instead...

[@brianalejandro2502]

@@niaagustina4142 lol really? jajajajajaja

[@alexiscolladosolis4257]

@@snowykaze if we abide to historical accuracy I agree with you, but in the end fleet carrier Shinano is far more accurate than M. V. Richthoffen or the Kremlin, obviously the most powerful BB in real life

[@greymms3603]

@You Mom is Green they wont nerf premiums so its going to be a Global CV nerf or American CV nerf. Also for historical purposes Shinano could have Suicde rocket planes....yes

[@DaManBearPig]

MVR is anti-CV but the FDR can at certain times fight back with her dive bombers. If he had eliminated that CV earlier it might've changed the outcome.

[@general_alexus2533]

Would have saved the BB from MRV AP bombs and probably won the game. He also lost all 14 TBs on the thunderer and was almost deplaned after that.

[@xSRGman]

Sowster shall be remembered as the first person to have a reworked CV replay to be featured on this channel

[@itsReiWoWS]

good to know that cv replays are working after so many years

[@ttier]

Yes they are, I'm waiting for your replays!

[@Dominus_Potatus]

@@ttier def send you mine with MVR

[@weallcandoit]

You know where is the breaking point? That Yamato ram

[@ThePilot4ever]

killer soundtrack dude

[@abdullahbablgith5725]

I love your channel

[@ttier]

Glad you enjoy it!

[@brendannichol3490]

Would love to see more of his replays and your breakdowns. Especially with high tier IJNs like haku and shokaku

[@OskarVanBruce]

These numbers feel like old RTS CVs lmao

[@Schorch1962]

Good replay analysis, TopTier. But i see 2 breaking points: the full-life Yamato getting to close to the nearly dead Kremlin and then the point you see with the MvR. I agree with you, teamplay is dead in most battles. I will not waste my time when playing cv with trying teamplay or hunting DD´s with badly designed rockets anymore, just farm damage.

[@tacibana88]

When look at new cv.. Make me not to play the old one.. Ahh.. How I miss the hakuryu.. Huhu

[@Hiro-ou7fm]

One of the best of yours, brilliant battle mate👍👍👍👍👍👍 Durable planes,didn’t need to send back some squadrons, Bomb dropped in British style👍👍, but the most amazing are torpedo bombers payload, just wow...😳💪👍

[@LordSukma]

yes, i want to watch others replay from him i think he's good player at CV i need to learn

[@ScorpionMinds]

@toptier, pls add the names of your tracks to the description pls. Cheers

[@lordsmily3292]

3 blunders I noticed 1) he should of helped the other flank after killing the Salem, might have saved 1 or 2 more team mates by eliminating ships on the west flank and the Montana was essentially out of the game 2) should not have struck the thunder while it was protected by fighters, since fighters kill 1 to 1 you lost 6 aircraft that will take over 12 min to recover plus the aircraft you loose attacking MVR 3)you burned your boost needlessly, use it to make attacks as opposed to getting to the area in a hurry. Discipline yourself to know use boost till the attack run will make a better cv player Other then a couple of miscalculated drops and an unlucky role I felt he could have won the game for the team

[@Dominus_Potatus]

Difference perspective... In Random, I'll commit to 1 flank at the beginning, as the games goes on, I'll support the winning flank so they can make a net and complete the cross. Some people just don't underatand that helping the losing flank is useless... For the Thunderer part... I think he can't dodge it on time since MVR's FT is so stealthy The engine boost part, I agree with you

[@jundachen9518]

I think that 7min into the game, the right flank was won, and there were 5 ships still alive on the left flank. That would have been a good time to switch focus to left flank. CV player picked good targets but farmed for damage and plane survival over the win after the right flank was won, and left flank was dismantled in the next few minutes.

[@danielhuy7492]

Yes Wargaming, introduce more op ships or cvs that makes people quit instandly...

[@vecioalpin8998]

Hello Top tier do you consider is capt skill and ship module the optimum for this ship?

[@Eissen_meteor]

Please make video abou Flak mechanic, TT.

[@redbep]

sick.

[@aetius9]

I think his biggest issue is that he kept wasting his boost getting to the target, instead of using it when attacking.

[@Dominus_Potatus]

yeah... Sometimes I mixed the usage, I usually only use up to 50% then let it full before I use it again. I only use every drops of engine boost when commiting to an attack and when leaving the AA zone

[@chipsterb4946]

With FDR it’s equally important to speed away after a drop.

[@warshipfever2731]

hmm... what is AA? and "feel the balance" ye... what balance? LoL

[@vogan7505]

Percent damage and catapult fighters.

[@kismaaja226]

When i use FDR in game make fatty ships players rage

[@SnapFacts-h3z]

This is a very speical team he had lol

[@MrKamil942]

Nice Sowster :D

[@Jan_kon_kar_dan]

Soundtrack in this video please

[@shp27493]

Next, WG will buff flac so that FDR becomes useless. In the process, WG will make all t10 CVs useless too.

[@eod7509]

Did you know you van start the attack run, get your aiming radical narrow and the turn in without the radical blooming. With torpedobombers and divebombers.

[@MANTRAKKK]

amasing ship. I want one

[@NightSniper2]

Nice vid. What are the names of the music?

[@Frankon81]

What squadron and engine boost (at 15min) he was all out of those.

[@kushagrashukla8653]

Nice replay

[@kushagrashukla8653]

Toptier if you are reading this pls make vid. On low tier ships too. Those poor poor ships........

[@highrank5466]

Can't wait you making video Use CV against Kitakami Specially german cv

[@BSenta]

song?

[@c17nause27]

nice

[@fatseadoggo1017]

calling it Teddy Roosevelt will make a lot more sense cuz Teddy prob packed the same punch irl

[@LUDO-jx2lt]

jolie comba

[@komrb35ss88]

Guys what is the name of this Music

[@jundachen9518]

Game was mainly lost due to no antidd gameplay, single flank focus without message to get back on left flank. Should have been more of a rout if the 2 dds on other team didn't die and the enemy cv didnt overextend on weak flank. Comment for video creator: you should include the drop numbers for the bad/semidodged drops for consistency. FDR seems like a hard-to-balance CV for plane HP: either planes are too tanky and it's OP, or planes die too much for it to be viable. I suppose the only way to nerf would be to slightly reduce damage on each ordinance. Fundamentally FDR and MvR look like potato-farming CVs that do extra well against people who can't or don't have wasd keys, though FDR ordinance does disturbingly have the shotgun effect which may be extra strong vs dds in smoke or dds in front of friendly ships.

[@lin837pr2]

Wow he is a very good player!! And ttier the tips are very good!! Whats the music this time???

[@ttier]

Aggressive Cyberpunk Darksynth

[@Oliver-bl3kk]

i think he didnt know that MVR had fighters on thunderer, due to the fact that MVR fighters has only 4km concelment when noticed there are fighers, it was just too late

[@ttier]

position of the fighters would not change anything, FDR could easily destroy the MvR with the help of the team

[@xSRGman]

either this thing should be nerfed or the other powercrept tech tree CVs need to get major buffs

[@1mol831]

MvR is not, but Audacious needs buff.

[@TheDedictvi]

imagine wanting to buff the most overpowered class in the game.

[@captturnip6020]

@@TheDedictvi CA/CL? DD? Again if CVs were OP you'd see as many of them as you do every other class if not more but CVs are still the most underplayed class by far. Explain that, if they are so OP why aren't double, hell even the same number of players using CVs?

[@TheDedictvi]

@@captturnip6020 Because they are too bland boring to play despite being the God class of WoWs. Strong doesn't always equate fun to play.

[@captturnip6020]

@@TheDedictvi You can make any class sound boring/bland to play. Try again

[@aga7989]

갖고싶다...................!!!!!!!!!!!1111111111111111

[@petrosmarko3092]

Would you say that it is easy to get deplaned in this thing?

[@qiudao5024]

should have saved my stell. D:

[@rickwang890]

The bgm was pretty good, sauce?

[@gyr9803]

How do you dodge flak on FDR?

[@eaglewarshipsgamer1754]

Uss Franklin D Roosevelt cva 42 Is The Best

[@МедведьХоккеист]

Хорошая баржа,у меня на ней за 145 00 средний!

[@ConstantOfTermination]

1:20 Operation Ten Go

[@s01581]

what it in video 🎶 ? ??

[@crashfdx]

where i buy this CV? is not on the premium shop

[@chipsterb4946]

Steel in the Armory

[@landochabod7]

I'm planning to get the FDR as soon as the coupon respawns, so this video helps :) About the replay: mostly good stuff, until the endgame. Running into fighters on the Thunderer, and then missing the rocket run on the MvR, was pretty bad. Still, it's hard to stay focused in a tight game when you're already on 300k+ dmg.

[@matiassacchelli8440]

I didnt get why people do act like the Yamayo: you are 3/4 or max health, see a almost dead bb coming at you at ramming speed and instead of putting reverse or turning early to avoid the ram, they set full speed ahead...maybe i get the yamato think he can citadel anything but i see this in other bbs who cant overmatch and we trade a full hp ship for a dying in fire red... Also i think the damage in this thing should be nerfed, it hit too hard and unlike the other carriers its hard to stop the first attack... Should we be prepared for a russian cv with migs?

[@liocla2331]

The thing is this CV has horribly slow reload times and slow aircraft for T10. I’m an average CV main. What he did was exceptional. Trust me, most people, me included, can’t do what he did. The average cv main who picks up an FDR will see at least 40-60% of his planes shredded before the 10 minute mark as saturation attacks are pretty much the only viable strategy (lots of slow planes, pre dropping with this many planes would be beside the point). And as a result will rarely bring in the big numbers. The average cv main who picks up an FDR will also have at least 60% of his planes in his squadron dead after one attack run and the rest will be lucky to survive the slow reload timer. Think of the FDR as a buff RN cv not a USN ship, damage over the time is the game. Stick to a group and the FDR will never even so much as look at you.

[@simplegamer1775]

How I send mine

[@mr.fridge-lego4985]

Yeeey. Polish reaplay

[@huynguyeninh5789]

Why don't do 330k dam with midway ?

[@youtubeseagull]

if the carrier has its own vid of coming in second then i take it it's not OP or broken.

[@AzXII1295]

Those damage number is disgusting... Other tier 10 cv like tier 8 now lmao

[@sinkingflames5986]

Did u know they work only work on PC Version and mobile Version they are missing ships no Soviet battle ships :(

[@feanorn8409]

I think we all can agree that FDR is horribly broken and needs to get nerfed alot.

[@lukereynolds7893]

No it's not it hits hard, but has slow planes, massive reload..... easy to doge in dds and cvs, bbs should stay with crusiers, if u dont work as a team u die simple.

[@chipsterb4946]

FDR has serious weaknesses too, especially the inability to do much against DDs. Try a match with 4 DDs per side and 2 of them Hallands and you’ll find out ...

[@ASMR.GentleMan]

This CV is the epitome of "ignoring aa" isn't it? Jesus they come up with more and more rediculous designs...

[@fniapuppetrx]

Why the narrator sounds different?

[@captainchoco894]

No AA is balanct for this Planes, the online AA Buff is the modern AA with Auto Getlingguns, PLS WG BUFF AA

[@jackhides3086]

As a CV player , i don't like this CV, people already hate us enough, never mind to add a CV whos planes make players feels helpless

[@AliTayhan]

Imgine fdr using ap bombs justwow easy deleting the BBs :D

[@HammerbiteStudios]

Yeah, this is balanced. Fuckin hate CVs...

[@darthrambo1878]

CVs in all cases too strong and not good for gameplay - but here 2 good teams fight against each other - yepp, less teamplay, but this is in all random matches common

[@saffira35]

nerf soon incoming - like GZ in former times

[@ucup63]

>Steel ship >nerf in WG dictionary Steel ship cant be nerf unless global nerf

[@elmonster84]

I miss old Cvs limited planes...

[@kubiuttopl264]

its broken cv xd

[@oppailers3236]

second?

[@gerrycoke]

how to kill world of warships

[@mysticdreamstar7123]

dislike cause not save and help team for win.

[@lofficieldufishe9823]

Theres no justifying this ships current state.... your cant argue against it

[@DaManBearPig]

eh, its not OP, its strong, but the MVR is stronger

[@ttier]

FDR is OP against BBs but weak against others. MvR is much stronger

[@kai-xuanyao4666]

FDR dive bombers do 25k damage per run yes, but MvR dive bombers also do 25k damage per run, flies at 50% faster speed, and doesn't have to wait 25 seconds between drops.

[@lofficieldufishe9823]

@@ttier All of FDR's squadrons have serious utility, it may not be the best at hunting DD's, but that doesnt justify casually dropping 300K dmg games without breaking a sweat. I believe if you are going to play the easiest and lowest-risk class in the game. You should earn your dmg, by using tactics to evade flak and use islands. FDR doesnt need to, it can do multiple 20k+ drops on a BB without loosing even 5 planes. Talking dmg output alone, FDR is way more OP then MvR, all but the rocket planes are better, and it doesnt even matter if theyre slow

[@lofficieldufishe9823]

@@kai-xuanyao4666 MvRs torp planes are also very lackluster in comparison to FDR and other CVs, the long wait times doesnt matter since it usually takes 15-20s to drop again (needing to turn around and realign) using other CVs, so 15s isnt an issue, especially when u can sit in flak and not loose a single plane.... both are dumb tho, i hope both get dmg output nerfs and also get affected by flak more

[@devidcapponi1593]

STOP PLAY CVs

[@CzipCzere]

This CV horrible!!! NEED NERF!