Failing to prove national importance in EB2 NIW

What happens when you do not establish how your endeavor is nationally important? This affects Prong 1 of the Matter of Dhanasar and in turn will negatively impact your EB-2 National Interest Waiver application. In this video we analyze a case of a failed appeal to USCIS.
▷ Check out my NIW website eb2niw.info/
✅ EB2 NIW Course payhip.com/b/gfuRU
🇪🇸 EB2 NIW website en Español eb2niw-espanol.info/
▷ If you are interested on EB-1A: eb1greencard.info/
▷Join my Instagram : / oscarsgreencard
Link to the case: www.uscis.gov/sites/default/f...
Contents of this video
00:00 - Intro
02:45 - A Civil Engineer appeal
15:22 - How to find these failed cases
16:20 - Conclusion and www.EB2NIW.info
#uscis #eb2niw #usimmigration #greencard #adjustmentofstatus

[@OscarsGreenCard]

✅ Link to EB2 NIW online course payhip.com/b/gfuRU

[@jeffreyregha113]

Nice work Oscar, I appreciate your systematic approach. thanks for the video

[@OscarsGreenCard]

thanks!!

[@tabindazaren5936]

Hi Oscar thanks for sharing such a detailed informative video

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Thanks!

[@alejandraarrietapalaciow.8627]

Oscaaarr I'm your fan :D thank you for all this

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Thanks!!! 😊

[@Maximus18.6]

Thanks so much for such amasing content

[@OscarsGreenCard]

thanks Nelson

[@princesslizzy5675]

Wow the general concensus is usually having an Engineering or Sciences degree is fine. But you really do need to have a good endeavour that's of national importance.

[@Facts16222]

Hi OSCAR, The reference you told in this video e,g congress,senate or other can help me out to craft our Endeavours accordingly to my experience or my field such as IT industry?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Yes

[@moniralvi]

Hey Oscar It's very nice and informative. I would like to apply for the GC as well and thinking to fill by myself, in this case your video is awesome. I have a MS degee from Germany on Geospatial Technology, and a PhD from Australia, two springer book chapters, and 5 international Journal articles, and around 20 years of teaching and research experience. Hope I will get your advice.Thanks a lot

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Nice, good luck, check my online course if you want to do it by yourself payhip.com/b/gfuRU

[@mudassarbilal8008]

Hi Oskar, teaching computer science to students of secondary school. I m having US equivalent bachelor degree.should I apply for eb2 niw? Which field of IT. Has national importance in US.

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Hi, you need to do your own research on the endeavor because you know what you do better than anyone. I don't do preparation for others at this time. But you are more than welcome to join my online course at payhip.com/b/gfuRU if you want to learn how to put together a petition

[@jcostilla]

I am going to apply for this in the future. But the lawyer cost are pretty expensive.

[@OscarsGreenCard]

They are. You can try to do it yourself without a lawyer

[@erkh9794]

i have to get a form i-797 с stating that USCIS got my petition if they sent me a sms and if so what should i do that i haven't received a notification from them for a month now ?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Hi, i don't follow

[@erkh9794]

@@OscarsGreenCard Are you saying it's normal that I didn't get a notification that they received the petition after a month?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

@@erkh9794 I'm saying i didn't fully understand your message. If the problem is that you didn't get the notification, that could be normal especially if you are abroad. Did you get the e-notification? Did they cash the check? Then i wouldn't worry about it

[@erkh9794]

@@OscarsGreenCard thanks

[@neilc330]

Hi Oscar, any tips please on arguing national importance for an experienced airline pilot? I’ve got an RFE which says arguing the importance of the industry is not relevant, what matters is the specific endeavours the pilot plans to undertake. They also say the regular work of a single pilot fails to meet national importance. Seems like a tough ask to argue national importance in this case.

[@mtartachenko]

Well, I think you should demonstrate that your past work history, could help in achieve more safety and or security in American aviation. For example, you were a flight crew trainer in safety in your current airline, so you can detail what have you learned and how to apply your knowloage and ideas.

[@neilc330]

@@mtartachenko Thanks for the feedback, that’s exactly what I did with an expanded personal plan and an expert opinion letter. RFE response was submitted in May, now I’m just waiting.

[@XenonTV7]

How did it go?

[@neilc330]

Petition denied after a two month wait! 🤦🏼‍♂️ It was as if USCIS ignored all my new documents.

[@XenonTV7]

@@neilc330 Oh I’m so sorry to hear that. USCIS should be more flexible with professionals like you; your knowledge, skills, and experience would definitely improve American aviation, why say no to your petition? I hope you have another option or plan to achieve what you want in the US. If you don’t mind, did you submit the petition just by yourself, or did you have help from a law firm?

[@laurasstyle479]

Hi Oscar, thank you for very helpful video! Do you know what happens to my student visa status and approved STEM OPT if my EB-2 NIW case will be denied? Do I lose my employment authorization? Thank you so much!

[@OscarsGreenCard]

The short answer is nothing will happen to EAD card or your visa. However, you could face challenges if you need to renew that visa because you would have shown immigrant intent

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Better to consult a lawyer in case you have questions about your specific situation . Thanks for watching and for your kind words

[@shaziamalik8799]

Like WES in canada.... Which agency we need to approach for degree equalency in USA ?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

WES US for example, but you can check this video on the topic kzbin.info/www/bejne/j3awfYOjob-foKc

[@hrishi383]

If I have a US masters and a foreign Bachelors, do I need WES US evauation for the Bachelors? Or is the US Masters enough to qualify?

[@Ooooia]

i have bachelor in radiology but only internship and I don’t have any research experience do I stand a chance on this im interested in radiation therapy since I worked for that to treat cancer patients but I guess that not exceptional or qualifying me I need your expert opinion

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Yes you would need to prove exceptional ability if you have bachelor with no experience

[@Ooooia]

@@OscarsGreenCard like what 🫠 im no special

[@user-op9gw4rx5l]

Hello Oscar, Please could you help review a petition, reference letters.

[@OscarsGreenCard]

You can check out the Services tab on eb2niw.info . I do only high level reviews with the "Express NIW I-140 review" service

[@user-ru6sj2js9s]

are there any successful examples for civil engineers?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

For sure , but remember that these are appeals only. Not the general population of applicants

[@walter5137]

Hi!.. thanks for sharing your knowledge . Videos are informative and super helpful. It is possibly to do the endevor part by talking about an invention you can propose and hasnt been patented?.. maybe there is a different greencard for that , just courious. Something in your field , product , chemical , talking how it can benefit US etc.

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Hi Walter, thanks for your words. Answering your question: not really. The endeavor has to be something that continues in time, and talking about a specific invention is a one time event, even if it takes a few years to complete.

[@augustineiwuh5360]

I have a BSC in Philosophy + BSc Management + ICA member+ NIM member + Job = Financial Crime specialist (Banking)+ Experience = 15 years. Do I have a chance ???

[@OscarsGreenCard]

I don't know, that is for USCIS to decide. You can make your case.

[@bashaeralnujaydi6002]

Any tips on websites to look at the important of one's field

[@OscarsGreenCard]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/eZrcoKJpfdmle5Y&pp=ugMICgJlcxABGAHKBQxkaGFzYW5hciBuaXc%3D

[@khushpanchal4171]

Hi Oscar , is this process good for Indian ? How long this process will take for Indian ?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

A long time, longer than a decade

[@AftabAhmadShah]

​@@OscarsGreenCardwhy a decade ? Is there any particular reason for such delay ?

[@musicoterapy2147]

a Chef cook can be consider to apply?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

It may be a hard case, but it's all about the three prongs

[@hollywoodkorolevaik1989]

Hello, Oscar! If I send the denial decision, can you analyze it and tell me your opinion?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Is it a denial or RFE?

[@hollywoodkorolevaik1989]

@@OscarsGreenCard yes

[@OscarsGreenCard]

@@hollywoodkorolevaik1989 yes to which one?

[@hollywoodkorolevaik1989]

@@OscarsGreenCard It is a denial after RFE. Applied the first time, then got RFE and then a denial letter.

[@OscarsGreenCard]

@@hollywoodkorolevaik1989 I see. I typically do not recommend appealing, but it may depend on your case. If you still want to talk to me about it you can check out the Services page on my website eb2niw.info/services/ I offer Express reviews. Express reviews are equivalent to 2h (1h analysis and 1h call). FYI I am on vacation until July 10. If you have more questions, email me at oscar at eb2niw.info

[@saidarashid8493]

Is it self petitioner or by lawyer?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Not sure

[@zafarfarooqui2957]

Can I pay the fees through credit card??

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Yes

[@autotecfin]

Hi Oscar. This man apply in biden or trump administration?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

This administration, it's from 2023 if you check the document

[@mmubeen10]

Is Indian Citizens are eligible to apply EB2 NIW Visa

[@OscarsGreenCard]

Yes, but there's a big backlog for Indian born applicants, more than 10 years

[@mmubeen10]

@@OscarsGreenCard Is backlog is there for this category as well? Then what is the benefit of EB2-NIW category. Right now I am in India, I am thinking to utilise this category without going with H1B route. Do I have to wait even then to clear backlog? Please help me in understanding this clearly based on that I will take a decision

[@OscarsGreenCard]

@@mmubeen10 yes, this would NOT be a good option for you

[@AftabAhmadShah]

​@@OscarsGreenCardis there a backlog for Pakistan as well ?

[@omerugur2134]

I am assoc prof of political science and international relationship. am i eligible for this greencard

[@OscarsGreenCard]

maybe, if you can meet the 3 prongs of Dhanasar

[@sk.tuhinislam4253]

How to reach you?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

check out the contact form on eb2niw.info

[@abushalemnew7981]

hello dear, in which category shall airline pilots apply to?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

what do you mean?

[@smanman-rp5gv]

Almost All cases dismissed in this link.even 17 citations case even other good profiles

[@OscarsGreenCard]

What?

[@smanman-rp5gv]

@@OscarsGreenCard do you work on our case privatly as an advisor?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

@@smanman-rp5gv i don't prepare cases . Right now i only offer the two services you can find on the top of this page: eb2niw.info/services/

[@smanman-rp5gv]

@@OscarsGreenCardı can choose 1 hour conversation but first better ı will send my cv than you will take a look at and than we can discuss on my cv?

[@OscarsGreenCard]

@@smanman-rp5gv i don't provide comments without going through the service, sorry. If you book the jour, yes, you can send CV in advance . Also FYI I am not available between July 4 and 10

[@nonamecanada5437]

Hello Oscar, I am currently using a law firm ( Colombo Hurd ) I want to check with you that if you can comment my model plan and proposed endeavour for a fees would be great If yes please provide me with your details to contact you

[@OscarsGreenCard]

No, I do not currently offer such a service