I‘d say Codsworth would be chaotic good character. He has the best of intentions but still flames people alive and rebells against his own programming from time to time
@tnagelsАй бұрын
Also when we first meet Ada she‘s a robot filled with most rage her programming would allow her to feel with plans to enact revenge and is absolutely internally pissed when we don’t kill the mechanist she also doesn’t give a shit if we absolutely eradicate the half of the commonwealth you cannot be sayin‘ she‘s on the same level as curie
@verybadwordfornameАй бұрын
Codsworth is also totally chill with cannibalism and actually has some funny lines when you do
@AdmiringCrab-zn2ncАй бұрын
if you keep drinking buddy instead of sending to rexford he won't be mad
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@verybadwordforname I remember he “hated it” when I ate people.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@tnagels I don’t think wanting revenge is inherently bad, and I remember how happy she was when I showed her how good the world is. I’m keeping it!!!!
@todd.cannonАй бұрын
Dogmeat should have his own alignment. Goodest Good Boy.
@ageinggamer3049Ай бұрын
Strong actually hates it when you steal. And I still can't believe that is the same guy who voices Goku
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@ageinggamer3049 I’ve never looked up something so quickly in my life… Instant promotion to Lawful!
@ageinggamer3049Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus yep Sean Schemmel, he voices a lot of the ghouls too.
@senseistick9942Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcusstrong follows the principles of super mutants. The super mutants don't own things and share with there brother's. They have a hierarchy based on strength and respect each other as long as they follow the principles. You can see super mutants as Kommunist raiders
@Matt-td8xwАй бұрын
He also likes when you help other people if i'm correct, i can't renember well but you could farm friendship with him by doing minutemen quests.
@ageinggamer3049Ай бұрын
@@Matt-td8xw that's the milk of human kindness he's been looking for
@topperman4541Ай бұрын
Piper is chaotic good. Piper has this tendency to shot first ask questions later. She has gotten me in so many gun fights trying to sneak pass an enemy I just didn't want to deal with and then comes in ole Pipper with guns a-blazing!
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@topperman4541 I haven’t found a companion yet that doesn’t blow my cover the second we see enemies. My institute stealth character doesn’t use a companion for a reason haah
@darcichambers6184Ай бұрын
Her stories are also written in a very provocative way. Like she is trying to get a fight going. Yes she wants people to wake-up about the Institute, but she fans the flames of paranoia instead of trying to find a solution. I would move her to chaotic good.
@mikitzАй бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus Strong being the worst culprit.
@sattymike0155Ай бұрын
Right. I agreed with the placement of everyone except Piper. She’s clearly chaotic good.
@StacieMMeierАй бұрын
She shall also use people to get to her goals.
@kippies66Ай бұрын
Don't worry, I won't change Preston Garvey's position. What does need to change is the precarious position of a nearby settlement that's in trouble. I'll mark it on your map.
@JustanjesterАй бұрын
GOD DAMN IT
@NordRageLevicus19 күн бұрын
Fun fact, in my first playthrough I helped so many settlements that I broke him, he no longer asks me to help settlements on that save. I have to listen to that god awful radio freedom to get radiant settlement quests. In numbers, my pip-boy said I had done 59 minutemen quests when he stopped, which annoyed me cause I wanted an even 60 😂
@TheWhanos18 күн бұрын
DANG YOU GARVEY!
@theextracrispycolonel9502Ай бұрын
Strong i disagree with the "chaotic" part, because strong does have a set of principles, as strange as they may be.
@ThebigZ1353Ай бұрын
Strong must find the milk of human kindness
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@theextracrispycolonel9502 Maybe I wrote off his quest for the milk of human kindness too quickly.
@HunterBowalkaАй бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus strong talks about making super mutants stronger and that super mutants share everything that super mutants are all brothers. I would have put him in Lawful Evil.
@wolfmantheimpalerАй бұрын
I'd argue putting Hancock in Lawful Neutral or even Chaotic Good because he likes it when you help people as well as stealing from/hurting bad/corrupt people, meaning he does have good morals
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@wolfmantheimpaler the random stabbing when I first met him made me question his morals just a little bit. But I thought he’s certainly a good guy that is willing to make some tough decisions for the sake of Goodneighbor.
@wolfmantheimpalerАй бұрын
@T.J.Marcus granted, the guy he stabbed sort of made a veiled threat to him, saying, "If you get too soft, maybe somebody will take your place"
@thebiolibrary5572Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus Not really random. He saw a man threatening a visitor, he decided to tell him what he thinks about causing trouble to strangers. It's just his thoughts on that involve stabbing the troublemaker.
@darcichambers6184Ай бұрын
The rest of the conversations you have with Hancock put him as chaotic good in my book. He tries his best to do good, but it doesn't always work out like he plans. I figured the stabing was a last straw kind of thing. But I'm very biased. Hancock is my go-to romance.
@nalyddylanАй бұрын
@@T.J.Marcusthe stabbin seems random at first, but when you look into it, it really isn’t. finn seems to have a history of extortion, especially those new to goodneighbour. he also threatens hancock in some sorta way, sayin that if he lets newcomers “walk all over him”, he won’t be mayor for much longer.
@stephenwood6663Ай бұрын
I feel like perhaps Piper should lean more towards the Chaotic side of the chart: there's a strong anti-authoritarian streak to her character, to the point where Diamond City Security have nicknamed the lockup "The Piper Suite". She also *really* likes it when you lockpick your way into places you're not supposed to be. She's more Robin Hood than Batman.
@CodPatrolАй бұрын
MacCready might be more evil, when you find someone in a random encounter needing a cure from radiation he says he wouldn’t have bothered.
@Nick-zp3ubАй бұрын
Sounds more selfish than evil. Macready will steal and lie but he won’t murder innocent people without provocation
@annareifer2249Ай бұрын
@@Nick-zp3ub also McCready HATES it when the player is killing some innocen people. and he is a loving father but afraid to be near his sick son thanks to his past
@mikitzАй бұрын
@@annareifer2249 He is also quite repentant of his past.
@StacieMMeierАй бұрын
Sounds like he is a survivalist not evil. I always saw MacCready as True Neutral because he seen many people die and knows death is there all around him. Life in Fallout is a live or die. He knows this, he lives this. He shall help if it helps him, it doesnt matter if other is good or bad. He is there to survive. But what really makes him true neutral, he only kills if he is required to do such. He isnt going to kill anyone unless they force his hand. Only a true neutral would react like this.
@gymhayes461327 күн бұрын
Dogmeat's alignment is GB, Good Boy.
@ptorq27 күн бұрын
Danse and X6-88 are definitely lawful. Where they go on the good/evil axis depends on what you think of the Brotherhood and Institute respectively; if you hate the Brotherhood more than you hate the Institute I can see a case for switching their positions.
@atari_o6169Ай бұрын
When you said Ada not knowing about the commonwealth is wrong and should not be included with curie because, yes curie hasn’t seen the commonwealth so it would make sense that she needs to embark with you but Ada has seen the commonwealth because she was in a caravan that travels throughout the commonwealth and has probably defended her self from raiders robots etc so she would know what it is like.
@shireboundscribbles26 күн бұрын
I see it slightly, differently with Lawful being about structure, whilst Chaotic hates structure. Good meanwhile is about beauty, whilst Evil enjoys vandalising the world. On that scale, Cait and Hancock both strike me more as Neutral Evil, with Cait maybe even being Chaotic Evil.
@T.J.Marcus25 күн бұрын
🤔Not a bad take. I need to reflect on this.
@ProjectNathanielАй бұрын
Just to add to Nick, while he currently does things for cash, he tells you about when he first started he didn't even think to ask for payment, he was just happy to be treated like a person. He has no preferred faction coz at the end of the day, Nick stands for the people.
@_NIKOS9_NIKOSАй бұрын
Strong actually likes when people work together and he disapproves stealing. I wouldn't call him good but chsotic evil is a bit much
@EmperorElmo501Ай бұрын
I think Neutral would be good for him
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@_NIKOS9_NIKOS He likes all displays of strength, and sees stealing as cowardice. I still see him as chaotic evil but that is so subjective to my view of who is good and bad.
@kriegmesserdclxvi283327 күн бұрын
I hate to go all Jedi, but from his point of view, Strong is both good and principled.
@TheQuenchiestCakeАй бұрын
I understand why you would consider Strong to be Chaotic Evil but I think he fits more for Neutral Evil, he has some rules of his own, they're just super mutant rules, which are mostly might makes right and stealing bad, sharing good. So basically a communist barbarian, which true Americans like Sergeant RL3 would find detestable! Everything else, though, I think your choice in placement checks out. Maybe Dogmeat could be lawful Neutral like Danse, since you (the Sole Survivor) are basically Dogmeat's BOS, whatever Dogmeat does is in service to you, and all the ends justify the means. I'm indirectly saying Danse (And by extension X6-88) is a dog for whom he serves.
@TraceyIsTiredАй бұрын
I'd say Hancock does have better morals than some of the other Chaotic companions, one of his voice lines being "We help those who need help, and hurt those who need to be hurt." Loose definition, but he definitely prefers to be helpful to those deserving of it. Those who don't deal in shady businesses.
@alphastormeex946827 күн бұрын
I like how you mention in the video that the deeper you dig into a character, the more you can argue for them being almost anywhere on the alignment. My D&D group and I have argued over Hancock a lot. Arguments have been made for him to be aligned as chaotic good, lawful good, chaotic neutral, and lawful evil. I can see an argument for all of them except lawful evil personally. He does have governing moral principles as simple/few as they may be. But he also expresses that he prefers to follow his gut and act on impulse. And he values freedom of choice in life.
@danerman73Ай бұрын
To me, Dogmeat is lawful neutral instead of true neutral. His guiding principle is being loyal to the player and following commands without question.
@T.J.Marcus28 күн бұрын
THAT... is a good argument, actually. He does have a guiding principle.
@jonputnam7953Ай бұрын
I’d have strong as chaotic neutral. He has no malice in his actions and evil intentional. Is a lion evil for eating a gazelle? Or for killing a lion challenging him?
@rootbeer66629 күн бұрын
Pfft. Ada is an absolute chaos machine and goes along with anything you do. Definitely not the same as Curie.
@T.J.Marcus28 күн бұрын
Yeah, I am realizing I might have based her alignment on how I lead her (which was good neutral). There were definitely other paths for her so I agree she is neutral but she could have been all 3 neutral spaces.
@DJFurious619Ай бұрын
Love how you use the D&D alignment system!
@T.J.Marcus28 күн бұрын
It's a fun system and applies well to other worlds.
@dmitriblyat8237Ай бұрын
Strong is one of my favorites, because he approves war crime
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
He's just down to clown and I respect that.
@plaguenplay351623 күн бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus"down to clown" is more suitable for Hancock imo
@fliegendertitanfliegendert8691Ай бұрын
I would put old longfellow mire in chaotic neutral and hancook in chaotic good
@samdrop9223Ай бұрын
Your first interaction with Hancock is him stabbing someone to death after they try and Rob you
@fliegendertitanfliegendert8691Ай бұрын
@@samdrop9223 yes but he want Rob you and he don't like stealing and he likes if you help people
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@fliegendertitanfliegendert8691 I thought his morals were a little all over the place. But he does have a good side, you’re right.
@simonacerton3478Ай бұрын
Good list. Ada doesn't seem to care what actions the sole survivor takes or really have lot of sense of self so I might list her as neutral
@Flecchicutlets27 күн бұрын
Batman is every alignment.
@ManuFortis8 күн бұрын
I've always figured this morality grid needs a 4th column and line for the 'paradoxical'. The characters that are so fleshed out and sometimes even twisted in the ways in how they are, that it's almost impossible to place them in any of the original 9 squares properly. Hancock might be the best example of this with FO4, because even though he may seem chaotic, the fact he understands that some rules have to exist makes him also kind of lawful. His shtick isn't so much a lack of principle, but rather having a different set of them from what our society looking at this black mirror would judge him under. His whole thing is "Do as you will, so long as you are NOT doing things that harm others... but if you do, harm will come to you." sort of deal. To the sort of people who cannot live without someone else giving them laws to follow, his sort seems very unprincipled. Lawless even in some cases. But they perhaps have the most sane reasoning around the most important tenet of why our laws come to exist in the first place. Freedom. Laws are all about the expression, protection of, and sometimes even restriction of freedom in some form or another. He just wants the most free version of society, which he understands means that there still must be some ground rules to follow for those who like I said earlier, just cannot live without laws. So, if a 4th column and row were to be named the paradoxical, his square would probably be the one labelled as Lawful Chaotic 'good', where the squares all in total would read some combination of lawful and chaotic in the order of hierachry for their personality, and then good or evil or neutral where it applies. The neutral one would sit in the far corner being the most odd ball of them all. So Lawful Chaotic Good, Chaotic Lawful Good, Lawful Chaotic Neutral, Chaotic Lawful Evil, Lawful Chaotic Evil. That goes from the top right, down to the corner, to the bottom left, to keep it roughly in line with how the 'good and evil' sections run. Why no Chaotic Lawful Neutral? It's effectively the same square. Being neutral would mean that these two are basically balanced out in such a way that it's hard to tell if they are good or evil, and so the default of lawful takes over since they are lawful to some degree even if not by much. Kind of like Hancock again, but ultimately he hates tyranny which makes him good compared to one who wouldn't care, making them neutral. One last thing. Hancock might not care if you hurt raiders, but that's because raiders hurt others. They bring tyranny upon others, so he doesn't mind them getting their own medicine. I figured this might get brought up, so I'm handling it ahead of time.
@michaelproctor8100Ай бұрын
Like you said, Cait doesn't like it if you sell little Billy into slavery, but she likes it if you tell him that his parents are probably dead. When you do, Cait basically tells Billy to get used to life's disappointments.
@danielr.1922Ай бұрын
Bro 😹😹
@vegastrinaАй бұрын
I think you did a great job! 👍
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
I don't deserve you 🥲
@memcremАй бұрын
I did something like this in the fallout 4 subreddit, X6-88 was lawful evil on mine too but a lot of people were arguing about him being neutral evil, hadnt really thought about ADA being neutral good, i put her in true neutral as she's indifferent to the player's actions, good and bad, like dogmeat, but yours is better considering that she does have that set of morals i hadnt taken into account
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@memcrem she can be convinced after the Automatron DLC that humans are good and worth saving. But I think you can convince her to go the other way.
@Keymaster2022Ай бұрын
Where would you put the faction leaders like Father and Elder Maxin?
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@Keymaster2022 lawful evil and lawful neutral. I consider the BoS morally neutral but I understand some people will disagree.
@RXTRUX1Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus Max is pure evil.
@fluffycamoАй бұрын
Id hardly call the bos or Maxwell evil, neutral at worst. The only one from the bos id call evil would be father Elijah, tho I'm biased since he's my least favorite character in the franchise besides Lucy.
@isupposeiexistАй бұрын
@@T.J.MarcusI'd go lawful evil for both, mostly because Max isn't willing to give people who have shown they ARE PEOPLE a chance. He had the chillest, nicest BoS leader save his life and went kind of crazy with the power at such a young age. He's not the SAME level of evil, but he's nowhere near good
@DirtyDevАй бұрын
@@fluffycamoI’m curious, what makes Father Elijah your least favorite?
@NorthernChev23 күн бұрын
On every play through, I will complete every quest in the game that I can except “Benign Intervention”. I absolutely depend on Cait’s “fuck them all” attitude in order to accomplish certain tasks in the game without worrying about upsetting someone. Yeah, yeah I could also use Dogmeat but I enjoy Cait’s banter.
@owensimpson4950Ай бұрын
Now hear me out. Elder macnamara is lawful nuetral
@TheQuenchiestCakeАй бұрын
Checks out, IMO.
@orangesqueasy21 күн бұрын
I think as it stands at the point of the game, super mutants by fault are chaotic evil. It’s not clear where Strong will do once he’s learned about what the milk of human kindness actually is but I would imagine he’d break past his mental programming to a more neutral or even lawful stance.
@gothicnight96Ай бұрын
It's fallout. Everyone is either evil or incompetent, often both.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@gothicnight96 Are you familiar with the Warhammer universe? EVERYONE is the bad guy. Fallout isn’t too different but I’m not taking my boy Preston Garvey out of Lawful Good and you can’t change my mind. Though, he is a little incompetent 😅
@gothicnight96Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus as a matter of fact, I'm VERY familiar with 40k. I know EVERYONE is evil and everything blows. And it blows hard. As for Preston, he just falls into incompetent but not evil. Definitely kinda stupid though, like everyone in FO4
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@gothicnight96 I play a lot of Total Warhammer 3 and I love factions like the Empire, but when you read the missions and events, you realize how evil these people actually are
@gothicnight96Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus As far as the video games go, I've only played Dawn of War, Fire Warrior and Space Marine, but I used to be VERY heavy into the 40k tabletop before my dad passed in 2020. I also keep up with Arch and Luetin for lore since I quit playing the tabletop.
@user-lj3ee2fu9iАй бұрын
Perfectly done
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@user-lj3ee2fu9i I’m putting you in lawful good 😎👍👍
@joshuacain9845Ай бұрын
I’d say strong isn’t exactly evil, he likes it when you help settlements, and he doesn’t like raiders or slavery because they harm human society, his principles are different than ours, and they come across as chaotic at least to us, but he’s not ruthlessly evil like the other super mutants
@BigDavetheMiddleAgeGamerАй бұрын
Which is why he was locked up with Rex.
@S4v4gedragon129 күн бұрын
He dosen’t like it when you aren’t nice because it gets you further from finding the milk of human kindness
@BigDavetheMiddleAgeGamer29 күн бұрын
@@S4v4gedragon1 ALMOST like he knows what it is....almost.
@user-KR38619 күн бұрын
I would say Piper is Chaotic Good, Hanncock is Lawful Evil, and Strong is Chaotic Neutral. Those are the only three that I would move. Piper has her own principles and morals, but hates authority. Hanncock, has no issue with killing people if they break his rules and he has a code that leans closer to Evil. Strong has some morals, he hates stealing, respects strength, and the cannibalism is accepted by him because he doesn't think any source of food should be overlooked, but doesn't seem to enjoy torture. Other Super Mutants are Chaotic Evil because they have no morals and enjoy torture.
@latro6205Ай бұрын
13:40 codsworth: would you like some salt with that?
@shaunholtАй бұрын
I think Danse is 100% a lawful evil. He'll do anything the Brotherhood wants, slaughtering mutants, ghouls or synths, no matter if they are hostile. The Brotherhood will forcefully take over farms and settlements. They'll nuke an entire part of town if their enemy is located there. They'll wipe out the Railroad, killing humans who are sympathetic to synths. If they could build and use a Death Star to defeat their enemies, they would, and Danse would go along with it. Danse is absolutely willing to do terrible things if the Brotherhood orders it. He's a lawful evil.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
But sometimes the Brotherhood asks him to do good things 👼
@MorganTheGorgon24 күн бұрын
I agree, it stings a little but Danse is definitely lawful evil leaning neutral. He has good ideals but his willingness to go along with any order no matter how evil it is pushes him over the edge for me. Treating synths like shit-and often outright killing them-stealing food from starving settlers, hostility towards non-feral ghouls, and just generally treating non-brotherhood peeps like shit aren’t things someone can be totally on board with and still be considered neutral to me. Danse himself treats your ghoul and synth companions with disdain and hatred, he just isn’t the best dude morally speaking, even if he is definitely very principled.
@thatcanada29 күн бұрын
It's 100% Cait for me - loves caps and scraps.
@T.J.Marcus28 күн бұрын
She's fun for a scrapper build.
@CaelumRoxasАй бұрын
One thing to add about Strong, and I don't know if this affects his placement on the alignment chart in any way, but when you actively agree to help settlements, he likes it when you do that.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@CaelumRoxas He seems to “like” every sign of strength. I guess aiding settlements is a sign of strength.
@yomandingaАй бұрын
Any Fallout 4 player knows Preston is lawful evil 😛
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@yomandinga you SHUT your MOUTH.
@AndroidNoir-L06kАй бұрын
@@T.J.Marcusdamn are you diamond city guard, did the bullet in the ass finally got to you?
@shxxoАй бұрын
“Theres another settlement that needs YOUR HELP. I’ll mark it on your map.”
@RXTRUX1Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus He heads a busted protection racket he's trying to rebuild.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@RXTRUX1 he would never. I swear!
@terminateshereАй бұрын
Only change I'd make is Ada being true Neutral. Other than hunting the Mechanist, she has zero capacity for moral judgement - like Dogmeat. In the game, reflected by not using affinity in any way. Curie remains neutral good though - her programmed medical-care duties give her a 'healer' aura - her only real flaw is naivety. Unlike Codsworth, she hasn't had 210 years outside to learn 'who to trust and who to kill' - hence she back the Brotherhood of Steel despite their hostility to synths and 'peace only through war' mentality. Agree with Strong, though. Whilst he does sometimes show appreciation of 'like helping like', he only believes humans should co-operate in order to further their ability to kill, not for any higher purpose.
@GrantReedIIIАй бұрын
I would call Piper Chaotic Good. She is willing to not follow the law, especially if she sees the law as detrimental. She is not above lying to get what she wants. She still only wants to do good.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@GrantReedIII this is very fair. I was leaning into lawful because she is very principled, almost as if she has her own journalistic laws. She does, however, not care about the laws of diamond city 😅
@mikitzАй бұрын
Then again, she dislikes when you steal or demand more money from other NPC's.
@GrantReedIII27 күн бұрын
@@mikitz when you steal, yes. That is when you are causing harm to someone, theft is like that. She likes when you pick an unowned lock.
@liamvillasevil86414 күн бұрын
Personally I would have put Piper in chaotic good.
@kylen7351Ай бұрын
Deacon is the fallout 3 playable character. Cant change my mind about that 😂
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@kylen7351 I’m gonna ponder this for a while 🤔🤔🤔🤔
@kylen7351Ай бұрын
@T.J.Marcus oh yea. Sarah Lyons was the lover who was a synth. Would explain why maxson hates the institute so much. Maxson was trained by her, so upon learning she was a synth, began a campaign to hunt the institute. Hence, the anger about Danse being a synth. Deacon has been to capital wasteland, is the correct age of the game. And has had extensive surgeries. "I put myself under the knife every year or two."
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@kylen7351 Slow down, I can't handle this theory so early in the morning.
@kylen7351Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus the gang deacon was talking about. Tunnel snakes
@browniecakes20Ай бұрын
I feel like lawful and chaotic also apply to world laws/ethics as well. Batman has his own code, but in his universe he’s a controversial character because as much good as he does, he’s still breaking the law.
@davidcollinsjr4288Ай бұрын
MacCready felt hard to place to me, because he's only in the Commonwealth to look for a cure for his kid, which seems good. But thinking of this from a selfish v selfless streak, that's the most selfless thing, and is even a little still "for *my* kin" right? He's opposed to Gunners, for selfish reasons. Wants to end those two, because they're after him. The fastest way to rush affinity with him is to pick owned locks. Anyway, maybe he should fit to the evil end of the spectrum, is I guess my thought to express.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@davidcollinsjr4288 he does so much good and bad that I thought neutral was the only proper place. However, a sign of a good character is being hard to place because real people aren’t black and white.
@gmeletrk26 күн бұрын
I only had one disagreement with you, X6-88. On the basis that IF we had an interesting institute ending, the sole survivor could change his orders to do good. I just think he's the counter beat to dance, but they're both neutral to me.
@todd.cannonАй бұрын
Good video. Subscribed.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@todd.cannon I’m putting you in Lawful Good 🥹
@strayling1Ай бұрын
Preston Garvey needs a whole new category: Lawful PITA.
@BigDavetheMiddleAgeGamerАй бұрын
That's called AWFUL good.
@T.J.Marcus28 күн бұрын
Reported for making fun of my best friend! (not really reported)
@pluck8913Ай бұрын
As for this list, I agree with just a few changes. Piper CG, she's too much a loose cannon. Strong is more Neutral or lawful evil, as stated in the comments below, he's got his pown morals, wierd as they are. Ada, TN. Outside her revenge quest she has no care what you do. And even the revenge is easily altered by you explaining what the Mechanist was trying to do.
@BroncoJoeAKАй бұрын
No, if Preston Garvey is Lawful Good because he follows a set of principles then Paladin Danes should also be Lawful Good, as he believes the Brotherhood of Steel to be morally correct.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
That depends on your definition of "good". I consider the minutemen "good" and the BoS "neutral". Feel free to make your own based on your own principles because all of this is subjective and nobody is really wrong.
@talideonАй бұрын
Cait starts off as chaotic neutral, but she arguably edges her way towards true neutral over time. Mind you, that's not a hill I'd die in.
@bruh-ni1fy26 күн бұрын
I don't think cait is "neutral" lol. She is a malicious person who likes hurting people for no reason. She likes it when you off the little girl's cat in vault 81.
@lazy_guy_2525Ай бұрын
Preston is chaotic evil only because that there is another settlement that needs your help, i will mark it on your map.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
You thank your lucky stars he sent you and not somebody more appreciative of his Lawful Good status.
@WolfwaysАй бұрын
Dixie should be a companion.
@gameboy12373Ай бұрын
I would have put dog meat in good neutral but hey it’s your opinion
@oddjarbАй бұрын
Dogmeat doesnt care what you do. He doesnt like or dislike anything. If you wanna do an evil run with dogmeat, he will oblige lol
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@gameboy12373 Dogmeat has no objections to my evil play through.
@FlokobaАй бұрын
But he's a good Boy!
@wokky02Ай бұрын
If X6-88 is LE, so is danse. Same MO for both, same motivations, same lack of personal code over organisational ideology. I think you've conflated the alignment of their faction with the NPC... Ada is LN, she has an absolute moral code guiding her questline.
@grumpygramps9542Ай бұрын
Hey, enjoyed the video and I just subscribed and I wanted to give you a heads up that the link for your book is broken, it just goes to an "oops" page. Other than that keep up the good work!
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@grumpygramps9542 omg thank you and thank you 🥹
@unclejoker9956Ай бұрын
Long fellow is an old bar fly with guns
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@unclejoker9956 He loves and hates with passion (and alcohol)
@flavivsaetivs5738Ай бұрын
Are you a little kid? It's said KILLED
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@flavivsaetivs5738 no but the KZbin algorithm is
@flavivsaetivs5738Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus no it fucking isn't. People with WAY more views than you have openly said KILLED and THEY WEREN'T SUPPRESSED OR ANYTHING THIS IS NOT SUPPRESSED, IT NEVER WAS. IT'S JUST FUCKING WHITEWASHING AND AN ENSHITTENING OF THE INTERNET BY CORPORATIONS
@NorthernChev23 күн бұрын
Curie, although speaking with a French accent, is not “French speaking”, as you state. Unless I am mistaken Curie never actually speaks French in the game. Correct me if I’m wrong.
@user-he2qf5pe6v23 күн бұрын
i didnt see the boring/useless categorie for preston garvey . where is it !? 😐
@ThemuffenthusiastАй бұрын
Good and evil are a matter of perspective.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
100% agree. This video is my perspective. If someone thinks the Institute is good, then X6-88 goes from lawful evil to lawful good.
@Hayden-ql6fhАй бұрын
Personally I'd swap strong and gage
@sergeant_cheeseАй бұрын
cool good video
@T.J.Marcus28 күн бұрын
I don't deserve you (thanks).
@sergeant_cheese28 күн бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus make one on like skyrim
@jamescox180528 күн бұрын
Whhhhhhay piper is sooo evil. She lets her sister all alone at a young age. She lies manipulate to get inside diamond city...wtf
@teddrewflack400Ай бұрын
Dog meat is the best companion of all time .
@ejinfl23 күн бұрын
Isn’t Batman more neutral good?
@skrog907Ай бұрын
First time watching your video. Been on a major new vegas kick recently, if you make an alignment chart for FNV companions I'll instantly click on it.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
I’ll do it for the New Vegas fans, because they would do it for me 🥹
@B1_1_9_7_5Ай бұрын
13:25 you are so wrong if anything he's neutral evil he hates it when you take from other humans he likes it when you share with other humans he likes it when you help other humans and if not evil person he's just have the differing look on things and when you tell the little boy Billy and that his family is dead strong is sympathetic about it he will say life hard deaths come to wall best little human learn now and if you help Billy find his parents strong will say human should help human this is good and if you don't help Billy he will say human should help human strong know like this strong no like
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@B1_1_9_7_5 I didn’t know there were so many Strong supporters until I made this video. I’m keeping him in chaotic evil, but I get your point. Might be doing a Strong playthrough soon to see what this guy is all about 🤔
@B1_1_9_7_5Ай бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus he is also very wise not matter how hungry human don't eat dirt tastes like dirt pure poetry
@antagonisstic23 күн бұрын
I agree I love Piper and i hate Preston and his annoying voice. While i do like Dogmeat because he's a dog and Deacon is cool along with Valentine.
@lechumps9381Ай бұрын
make one for new vegass
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@lechumps9381 that’s all the pep talk I need. I think it’ll be a little more controversial though, because New Vegas hits on some serious topixs
@andrewleah1983Ай бұрын
Not sure getting any help (consciously or not) from that weirdo Oxhorn is a good thing.
@T.J.Marcus28 күн бұрын
Sry man but I love his lore videos.
@The.lnstituteАй бұрын
Nick Valentine is one of our greatest creations and I’ll admit we miss him at the institute
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
Bro! Huge fan of your clean water!
@The.lnstituteАй бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus thank you
@sambo314Ай бұрын
Dogmeat can not be good or evil as he has no knowledge of either. He will be by your side no matter what you do
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
The truest neutral companion 🐕🦺
@zoriononlineАй бұрын
I dont think that Cait nor Hancock belive they are "good" per se. Pretty sure that Cage also knows he is rotten. This in reference to you saying "alll think they are good" On the other note Strong for instance isnt directly good either, but he may think he is it, hard to tell due to his cognitive abilites being imparied to say the least :P (Kind of hard to know if he even can grasp the concept of good/evil etc the way normal cognitive persons do)
@keithtravelrnАй бұрын
sorry batman is nuetral good at best.. lawful good is superman
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
My Fallout lore knowledge is way better than my DC lore knowledge, so I yield 🤣
@folcotook3049Ай бұрын
🤓 Um, actually, Danse is a paladin, and paladins MUST be lawful good, so he cannot be lawful neutral. /s 😉
@dubuyajay9964Ай бұрын
Changed in 4th Ed-Present.
@Hoodini903Ай бұрын
This guy sounds kinda like paladin danse
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@Hoodini903 I’m not a synth, and you can’t prove I am.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@Hoodini903 also thank you because he’s one of my favorite companions.
@Nick-zp3ubАй бұрын
Piper, curie, valentine, preston, danse, deacon and codsworth are good. Macready, dog meat, hancock and cait are neutral. Strong and x688 are evil
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@Nick-zp3ub Morality is subjective, so you aren’t wrong. But I’m proud of you for being brave enough to call the BoS “good” 😎👍👍
@Nick-zp3ubАй бұрын
@@T.J.Marcus The brotherhood are morally grey, but they have both good and evil members. Maxson is a deranged fanatic, but Danse has a code of morals
@PlederckКүн бұрын
Porter gage is dead
@ajosralastname7823Ай бұрын
Wouldn't the police think Batman is chaotic good because he dosent follow technical law as they do?
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@ajosralastname7823 Yes. And if you think the institute is good, X6-88 is Lawful good. It’s all subjective.
@pluck8913Ай бұрын
Batman is Chaotic Good. He ignors laws and only follows his own morals. Like V from V for Vendetta. Batman would never surrender to the police if they wanted (seriously) to arrest him. Superman would be considered Lawful Good. As he has surrendered to police when they called for his arrest.
@boss06829Ай бұрын
Joker isn’t chaotic evil even the joker won’t work with Nazi’s
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@boss06829 he also was wise enough to not challenge the IRS.
@VictorLiso28 күн бұрын
I stopped when you said Batman was lawful. You don't understand the lawful-chaotic axis.
@Keymaster202227 күн бұрын
Or maybe he doesn't understand Batman
@certifiedhoodclassic982518 күн бұрын
do fallout new vegas next!! please :3
@jayartz8562Ай бұрын
Mara - R-404?
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
I fixed the link😎
@HK-pq7peАй бұрын
I think Danse and X6 should be together in lawful evil. It's kind of a double standard to say the Institute is evil but not Maxon's BOS. While the Institute are mad scientists rivaled only by Big MT, the BOS in Fallout 4 are a bunch of raiders in power armor, not to mention they actively work towards ghoul/super mutant genocide. Edit, Strong isn't chaotic, he follows super mutant ideology as closely as possible
@DarkdayzzАй бұрын
I never considered the Institute to be "evil." If anything, I find them to be misguided "good." They want to fix the Commonwealth, but they will do it while ignoring the pain of said Commonwealth. I don't consider that evil, persé
@MorganTheGorgonАй бұрын
Ehh they’re definitely evil, even if their stated intentions are otherwise. I think “Well-Intentioned Extremists” to borrow from TV Tropes is about as generous as you could get with them. They kidnap and replace people, unleashed super mutants into the commonwealth, and generally do literally nothing to help out while spreading fear and hate among the people. Even if their stated goals are to “help” humanity, in practice they’re not much better than the Enclave. The institute is way too detached from the commonwealth-they live *underground* for gods sake-and that detachment coupled with the dehumanization of anyone outside those walls has led them down a path of cut and dry evil; even if they purport to do good. Very few evil people/organizations openly know and think and state they do evil.
@monochrome_soft9472Ай бұрын
the road to hell is paved with good intentions. the institute is almost entirely evil in their actions, regardless of how they may try to justify them
@DarkdayzzАй бұрын
@monochrome_soft9472 Agree to disagree then. In my first playthrough, I picked them, and out of the Railroad, BoS or the Institute I prefer the Institute as the lesser of 3 evils... After all, if you stick with them, YOU get to decide how they continue. You don't get that in the railroad or BoS.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@Darkdayzz and that, my good sir, is perfectly valid. I disagree but Good and bad are so subjective. I expect your full alignment chart on my deck by end of business day.
@DarthJoJoSage47Ай бұрын
"Everyone wants to save the world they just.... they disagree on how"
@chainsawz5618Ай бұрын
while these rankings would make sense for the real world (mostly) it seems you kind of forgot that you're ranking fallout characters, and that's a completely different world with a completely different set of rules, doing drugs in a world where they actually literally give you superpowers doesn't suddenly make you go from lawful to chaotic, especially when they're not even illegal, would be the equivalent of saying that smoking cigarettes makes you evil
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@chainsawz5618 An excellent point. I expect to your alignment chart on my desk first thing in the morning.
@liomurasakiАй бұрын
Look, I'm not a psychologist, but i can clearly see, that you weren't good on painting inside the outlines as a child. Good Alignment chart tho
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
Brb looking for when I said I was an art channel
@BruceLee-kf7rl29 күн бұрын
Stop doing cringe Batman voice
@T.J.Marcus28 күн бұрын
I'm flattered because this is actually my voice.
@sonosoloioАй бұрын
in all sincerity it doesn't interest me much, anyway I only do the Deacon, Valentine, Maccready, Danse quests and if someone sends me to a certain place, even Cait's quest, the others don't interest me and then I travel exclusively in the company of Deacon. and as far as I'm concerned the dog doesn't exist.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@sonosoloio I’ll put you down as “solo traveler” then 👍 Ideal for stealth builds because all of these idiots get caught.
@NobodyinAmerica-z4rАй бұрын
Kind of a weird game to use this ancient DND compass on. None of these caricatures do ANYTHING unless the player interacts with them, and they are written to generally be as accommodating as possible. What they do or dont believe is meaningless because YOU do all the work.
@T.J.MarcusАй бұрын
@@NobodyinAmerica-z4r Invest now because the alignment chart is making a comeback. And I’m basing my decisions largely on how they act when you do things. Many of these characters will complain if you do something they disagree with. Do it enough times and they’ll leave you.