Famous Flounders | Hashtag Wars |

In honor of Henry Winkler being the only guy who can pull of posing with a fish, tonight���s Hashtag War is #CelebrityFish! Play along with Taylor Tomlinson, Andy Richter, Aasif Mandvi, and Penn Jillette in the comments below! One of our favorites will be featured on tomorrow���s After Midnight! The panelist with the lowest score at the end of the round is eliminated.
#AfterMidnight #TaylorTomlinson #Comedy #HashtagWars
Subscribe to the "After Midnight" Channel: bit.ly/42hqlyx
Watch full episodes of "After Midnight": bit.ly/48QsrqQ
Follow After Midnight on Threads: bit.ly/3HkKvh9
Follow After Midnight on Instagram: bit.ly/48Qsz9O
Follow After Midnight on TikTok: bit.ly/4215e3a
Like After Midnight on Facebook: bit.ly/3HmTajh
Watch After Midnight with Taylor Tomlinson weeknights at 12:37/11:37c, after The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, on CBS and Paramount Plus.
---
AFTER MIDNIGHT is the smartest show on television about the dumbest things on the internet. With celebrated comedian Taylor Tomlinson at the helm and a panel of guests from the worlds of entertainment, comedy, music and beyond, AFTER MIDNIGHT is a late-night comedy series about what set the internet abuzz that day with a game show feel. AFTER MIDNIGHT airs Monday through Friday, 12:37-1:37 AM, ET/PT on the CBS Television Network and streams live on Paramount+.

[@Entroper]

I guess Penn is mightier than the Swordfish.

[@AdrianColley]

Awesome!

[@drbarnack1885]

Callback!

[@Neyshtradamus]

🏆

[@umairusman]

Loved it

[@MysterySteve]

I want to wake up in the morning with the same energy as Penn's "Two fish! TWO FISH!"

[@simonpeteradkins]

Stefin Colbarracuda (TWO FISH!!)

[@youtubeyuki323]

Cindy Crawfish

[@thatwordjr2309]

Molly Hagfish (TWO FISH!!!)

[@JustinHavelock]

I don't have a fish pun to share. I just want to hear Penn do the audiobook for One Fish, Two Fish, Red Fish, Blue Fish now.

[@Canderson1989]

TWO FISH!!! TWO FISH!! LMAOOO

[@youtubeyuki323]

Goldie Prawn

[@kevprange]

Oh, please get Henry Winkler to be on the panel. He would be awesome!

[@JacqueArmijo]

with Conan!

[@shaman9]

Hashtag wars as the elimination game is the best format

[@petecoogan]

No

[@nikandthepartz]

I strongly disagree

[@justdesignonly169]

Yeah they've made some good changes.

[@zoelee4990]

Strongly disagree also. They’re gonna break those stupid buzzers

[@youtubeyuki323]

Red Hot Chili Snappers

[@youtubeyuki323]

Anchovy Hathaway

[@marcsimard9994]

William Sharkner

[@reticentman1042]

Marlin Wayans

[@krzysztofwrona2426]

Marlin Monroe?

[@youtubeyuki323]

Ned Flounders

[@alexperaza9475]

Finding Leonard Nimoy #CelebrityFish

[@josefmanga]

New Squids on the Block. #CelebrityFish

[@bryan9931]

Bobcat goldfish

[@wirelesmike73]

Patrick Orange Roughy (Two Fish! because Patric is a caked starfish!)⭐ Bass Eliott Timothy Scalop-met Carp Garfunkel

[@alexandertucker6140]

2 Fish!!! LOL!!!

[@coff328]

Um actually, Free Willy Nelson should not have counted as Willy was an Orca which is a mammal, not a fish. Andy was robbed.

[@casbot71]

And Moby Dick Van Pike got double points for two puns when it only should have gotten points for the Pike reference. But that was Penn, so it really didn't count.

[@wirelesmike73]

NERD!!!

[@deementia6796]

Glad to see us Jackals make it over from Seth's realm to After Midnight.

[@wirelesmike73]

Common', man, Y'all know that was funny. 😏

[@LateBloomerMedia]

​@wirelesmike73 lol it really was. The best one imo but I am hella biased as I just moved to where that movie was filmed! 😅

[@BreandanAnraoi]

Penn's reaction to "Bradley" 😂

[@fullmetalpancake9722]

Gar-th Brooks (thanks, Animal Crossing!) (it's not two fish, but a fish and its home)

[@paulielipman]

Barracuda Gooding Jr. #CelebrityFish

[@youtubeyuki323]

Yogi Barracuda

[@solarblitzX]

Dolphin Lungren #CelebrityFish

[@dielaughing73]

Not a fish but OK

[@justincastillogayray]

Halibut Berry

[@josefmanga]

Bradley Grouper #CelebrityFish

[@jopalm3649]

Shaq-eel O'neel.

[@yew2oob954]

The Rock-fish.

[@Jaggoloat]

Codnan O'Brien

[@youtubeyuki323]

Jimmy Carp

[@Jaggoloat]

Ryan Stingreynolds

[@josefmanga]

The Blue Tang Clan #CelebrityFish

[@marcsimard9994]

Elton Prawn

[@jgodin312]

Phoebe Walleye-Bridge #CelebrityFish

[@solarblitzX]

Megalodonald Glover #CelebrityFish

[@withershin]

Taylor at 2:54 when Andy chimes in. Look at that smile she's trying to hide. Aasif can't hold it in. Andy and Penn together is great TV.

[@youtubeyuki323]

Jessica Shrimpson

[@paulielipman]

Eelon Musk #CelebrityFish

[@paulielipman]

Kattfish Williams #CelebrityFish

[@tommymorgan2019]

Seal That is all

[@lisadawne]

when andy said he lives close by, he meant the set old of the late night show. yes, he still lives there even though conans not there anymore. 😆🤣

[@solarblitzX]

Hedy Lamarlin #CelebrityFish

[@paulielipman]

Fluke Wilson #CelebrityFish

[@atomschmidt1]

Mark Walleyeberg

[@josefmanga]

Jack Blackened Tuna #CelebrityFish

[@twajuonp]

- Oscar-fish Issac - Jeff Goldfish #CelebrityFish

[@solarblitzX]

Harry Codfish Jr! #CelebrityFish

[@swathinarayanaswamy7145]

Who won last week's fan hashtag? Just asking for a friend (who plays everyday and is unaware of her self worth without the external validation of a fake game show)

[@RandyHumorous]

Weird they edit that out on youtube..

[@swathinarayanaswamy7145]

Oh, so it's still in the broadcasted version? That's cool to know, thanks!

[@wirelesmike73]

@@RandyHumorous Since when?

[@RandyHumorous]

They stopped putting the online hashtag winner name on the youtube videos since monday for some odd reason. Hmmm…..

[@jaebee1121]

Glad you didn't just make Penn the winner right there, but this doesn't feel like it's somehow going to end with For The Win...

[@wynoglia]

OMG PENN BANGED IT WITH THE FISHES 🐐

[@youtubeyuki323]

Manta Ray Romano

[@denisefromdc1796]

Blue Tang Fish. Genius. 💙

[@gjameson6503]

They missed the most obvious one--Lance Bass!

[@SadhviJenn]

2:55 in a game where the points don’t matter

[@marcsimard9994]

Prawn Mellencamp

[@shaneg9081]

Prawn Mellencarp. Two fish!

[@josefmanga]

Phish. Really it was just sitting there. #CelebrityFish

[@hashtagshalako3619]

The Rock-Lobster #CelebrityFish

[@simont390]

Kit HerringTuna (TWO FISH)

[@josefmanga]

Insane Clownfish Posse #CelebrityFish

[@e-manr.486]

I like seeing two speed games, so i prefer hastag wars at the beginning, but i see what they're trying.

[@agentid36]

Dwayne The Rockfish Johnson

[@youtubeyuki323]

Michael McDonald's Filet-O-Fish

[@westcountycrumudgeon5992]

Shark Mcgwire

[@teh201d]

Penn is mightier than the swordfish (ONE FISH!)

[@asterismos5451]

Sardina Carpenter (two fish!)

[@paulielipman]

Kim Carpdashian #CelebrityFish

[@felixtapley6045]

Salmon Rushdie #CelebrityFish

[@youtubeyuki323]

Keith Herring

[@paulielipman]

CCH Flounder #CelebrityFish

[@GareBare90]

Lance Bass

[@youtubeyuki323]

Jessica Langoustine

[@micahpilson9836]

Jon Von Anchovy Sardina Gomez ...and Lance Bass #CelebrityFish

[@cvogue]

Sailor Tomlinson #CelebrityFish

[@zorbatic]

Abalone-o Banderas #celebrityfish

[@youtubeyuki323]

Sharkira

[@PlanckRelic]

Leonardo DiCarprio

[@youtubeyuki323]

Kate Bassworth

[@youtubeyuki323]

Eel Pacino

[@youtubeyuki323]

Marlin Matlin

[@jayfabe620]

Cod Stewart

[@alextoth9853]

Eelon Muskie

[@joshrobinson8360]

#CelebrityFish Rockfish Hudson.

[@EdwardInSpiteOfMe]

BARBara SpratSand eel (THREE FISH)

[@josefmanga]

Dwayne "The Rockfish" Johnson #CelebrityFish

[@DreadPirateRobrt]

Matthew Mackerelfilet

[@JohnWilsonComicsGuy]

Anne Bassaway #CelebrityFish

[@josefmanga]

Squid Rock and Squid Cudi. #CelebrityFish

[@youtubeyuki323]

Sushi Quatro

[@AdrianColley]

That's a great one.

[@Infinitesimal-ho7it]

No, Moby is not a fish. Rematch!

[@solarblitzX]

Henry Caviar #CelebrityFish

[@solarblitzX]

Megalodon Knotts #CelebrityFish

[@Tonyhouse1168]

Zoe Sardiña

[@zoelee4990]

No one’s gonna do Dolly Varden, eh?

[@OpinionsNoOneCaresAbout]

#CelebrityFish Swimothee Chalamet

[@Bartcmh]

Taylor Marlinson

[@JeffSchall]

Gary Goldfishman #CelebrityFish

[@KigurumiInuyasha]

Salmon L. Jackson #CelebrityFish

[@JeffSchall]

David Swimmer #CelebrityFish