Fans are SO UPSET about this..

[@ForestElfLego]

I think some Star Wars fans have eye problems if they think real people look like CGI.

[@Hei_Darkfire]

It's not really that. It's that CGI has evolved to the point where it's hard sometimes to tell what's real and what's not these days in many shows and movies with decent budgets. Sometimes it's really obvious and your eyes fix on something you know isn't right, but there are times where things look real that aren't.

[@Crazinator]

​@@Hei_Darkfire I think it looks good

[@crplegokid1268]

Fans: ask for something. Disney: actually does it. Fans:BrO WhY dId YoU gIvE uS wHaT wE wAnTeD? dIsNeY sUcKs!

[@nr21_7ndrd52]

@@crplegokid1268agreed people can be hypocrites but Disney did mess up a lot too. Still clones looked really clean to me

[@crplegokid1268]

@@nr21_7ndrd52 yeah, but people should realize that we bullied George so much that he sold it to Disney, so we are responsible

[@MCLegoboy]

The issue is more that they just don't move quite right because we're all used to seeing digital clones in both the movies and in the animated shows, and people are just bad at communicating it because most visual problems we find in media tends to be something digital these days. The practical actually put us in the uncanny valley for a change.

[@mattwalters6834]

They are running around in sand which really affects your footing, I think that’s why they’re running funny.

[@aurorastarfury]

Sometimes people are going by what they imagine something "real" should look like. I remember almost 30 years ago when Babylon 5 aired an episode with a character that had a scar over their eye. Some fans complained that the scar looked too fake. It was a real scar! Similar thing in another Babylon 5 episode which featured a character that was the President of the Russian Federation. People complained that the accent the actress used sounded fake. Funny thing is, the actress was Russian. We're so used to seeing/hearing Hollywood versions of fake stuff that we think the real thing is supposed to look like and sound like the movie stuff...

[@shaunpoland5656]

They had special forces do the motion capture and move around in the REAL suits for the prequals which is why we get that professional soldier vibe from the clones. The clones in the preqs weren’t entirely cgi

[@DerezzedMan]

they don't move right? so how are they supposed to move? They're moving like a human would run...

[@Commander_Shepard.]

@@shaunpoland5656 Can you post a source for this? As far as I knew they didn't make a single Clone Trooper armor for Ep 2 and 3. Even Tem Morrison as Cody was just his head on CGI body.

[@dhdbksks]

I think the scene in ep2 where all the clones are lined up and marching was soo cool. They never would of been able to make it look that good if they didnt use the cgi clones

[@JustAGenericGamer]

They could have, but that would have required training hundreds of extras on how to march properly. Probably cheaper to CGI it then use real extras.

[@victormiller1420]

Ya like military drill exercises basically

[@LTRX_]

i think what makes them look fake is the lighting, since an environment this foggy isn't really very realistic. it feels like a dream in a way, which is most likely the intention of Dave Filoni. Edit: i hate to edit comments but i will just to clarify certain points. 1. what i meant by lighting is the ambient lighting. most environments have a lighting where there is/are primary light source/s (aka sun, lights on the ceiling, etc) 2. about the fog, i still believe it's meant to sell the dreamy aspect of the scenes. she's not really there, just reexperiencing the past battles she has been to (i didn't include Anakin because of Mandalore). sure, budget could have had its contributions on why they chose to make the scene foggy, but it's easier to make transition points between flashback and World Between Worlds shots. they already have the assets for Mandalorian cities since they appeared in The Mandalorian Season 3, which could've also been used if they fixed them a little to match the time. Ryloth could've been made as easily as well since they've made similar environments in other shows before (aka Tatooine, Nevarro, Arvala-7, etc but not including Andor since they had actual sets)

[@kreigguardsman3355]

I imagine it’s the point that foggy dream as well as a way to save on budget

[@popinmo]

ive seen days fogger then that in real life on a farm in texas you couldnt see more then 10 feet

[@wb7585]

trying to remember flash back scenes where things weren't fogged out.

[@kevinmcmillin870]

A real battlefield that intense would be just as foggy because of smoke, dust and debris in the air from explosions and blaster fire.

[@michaelalek6490]

I think you need to get a life nerd

[@joester4482]

I think it’s how the armor looks. People were used to the cgi clones not having such reflective armor, and I also noticed that some pieces flap when irl clones run, which doesn’t show with the cgi clones. The flapping is what irritates me the most, but hey, at least we got something.

[@cooliostarstache5474]

I never even noticed the armor flapping until you mentioned it

[@HungaryBased]

The clones look fat.

[@cooliostarstache5474]

@@HungaryBased Lol remember when a bunch of people started calling Tem Morrison "Boba Fatt"

[@djrubbabi2471]

@@cooliostarstache5474yeah those stupid people

[@ianjtgove]

The armor flapping is the drawback of the way the pauldrons (and a few other parts of the armor, too) are designed. Having made armor following the 501st official specs myself, I've found that the flapping armor can't be helped unless you stray from the original Lucasfilm design, which was initially designed for CGi. I don't think the VFX team back in the early 2000s could have predicted that Lucasfilm would be shifting to lower-budget streaming TV shows that would need real actors in clone costumes instead of CGi clones to cut down on CGi costs.

[@toughspitfire]

The clones more in focus are definitely real people, however I believe many of the clones a ways out were cg, and seem to have a similar run animation you commonly seen them do in the Clone Wars show.

[@StormX6]

I actually like that the settings are very hazy and you don’t get to see much. It’s a spiritual flashback from Ahsoka’s memories and it has that theatrical stage feeling. If the scene was too crowded, you’d be more likely to lose the focus of the dialogue and emotion between Anakin and Ahsoka.

[@ZayecValentine]

When I first saw it I was just excited and amazed to see the clones again especially seeing Captain Rex. I’ve seen lots of Clone Trooper Cosplays so it didn’t really ruin my experience in any way.

[@freddym99]

When CGI back then was so good that you think live action troopers are fake

[@Mr.Alfredos]

There is no way people are saying this 💀 Complaining about a non existent problem…

[@slurpeekyler]

I am! They look so bad when compared to Mando Season 3. The Mando armor in this episode also looked bad, and not to mention Ahsoka's Season 7 appearance looked weird. This episode had a strange case of looking bad.

[@themuffinman5755]

​@@slurpeekylerI respectfully disagree

[@adamcarman5330]

Yeah the P1 clones look a little uncanny because it’s the first time ever seeing them in live action with physical armor, and it’s a faithful recreation of what a real human under armor would look like. The P2 clones on mandalore look fantastic. And Rex in live action was faithfully recreated with really good accuracy

[@Mr.Alfredos]

@@adamcarman5330 agreed

[@blue-vr8dd]

​@Sbkyler the mando armour has always looked cheap. Ahsoka's s7 appearance being weird to you is just the price of converting from animation to live action. not everything's gonna look as good. the lighting is the reason they looked good in mando. it was mostly pretty dark and dim, which is an incredibly famous way of making CGI look better. your problems with this episode don't exist. what does exist are the story and character problems riddled throughout, and not even just this episode.

[@thelukeofficial9626]

Bruh this confirms people just TRY to complain for no reason

[@bloodybuckets7]

Honestly, cant we just be happy we even got this at all.

[@thelukeofficial9626]

@@bloodybuckets7right! like what’s wrong with people!

[@CommanderShepard-wq3wo]

** Reads title** It’s Star Wars fans you’re talking about. What *AREN’T* they upset about?

[@superfrycook6360]

Clones in Ahsoka: P1 armor with P2 armor’s maneuverability. Clones in Attack of the Clones: Chads

[@hfar_in_the_sky]

Some people complaining that certain elements in a dream/vision sequence don't look hyper realistic seems like a special brand of nitpick to me. Like, yeah. It's a dream/vision sequence. It's meant to be disorienting and give a sense of being untethered from reality

[@skyguylmao]

They are definetely real, you can understand from their goofy run

[@PK-Radio]

They got that real guy slide the cgi ones don’t have

[@mitkoogrozev]

Yes, and they were a lot thicker. The CGI clonetroopers from the movies have normal body proportions, while wearing armor. Which means they must be very skinny underneath.

[@kerbal8216]

@@mitkoogrozevWhich is also why they were super skinny in the clone wars tv show

[@aloab200]

Maybe is because they move a little bit clunky but is how a real person would move in those armors

[@shaunpoland5656]

the clones weren’t completely cgi in the preqs. They did build clone trooper armor and hired special forces to move around in the armor and do motion capture so it would have a professional soldier aesthetic and I believe that added much of the realism. the preqs used far less cgi than people think. Much of the affects were image scans of real objects, sets, models, even volcanoes, etc.

[@mewtwo.150]

yeah and some looked fat

[@cside19]

Plus they were running through sand. That’s not easy. It’s coarse, and rough, and irritating, and it gets everywhere….

[@aloab200]

@@shaunpoland5656 and i love em' i think they look great, it's just i can only imagine what would be traying to run in those

[@wilbowaggons]

@@mewtwo.150 Unless they were really skinny, muscular soldiers in armour are gonna look chunkier.

[@Antonin1738]

I thought their running was so weird, but then I realized it's real guys in those suits who can't see anything out of the helmets lol

[@HeliumHelios]

Aside from clones moving different than remembered, I really enjoyed this sequence and how they handled the balance of the budget and the visuals.

[@StudioSmith]

ahaha bruh, nobody thought they looked fake. They look weird but that's because their armor wiggles A LOT and some proportions are off

[@wyattshook2775]

I swear people have to always find something to complain about. It looked pretty good to me.

[@tornadounder5270]

When I hear fans hating Ashoka series, it giving me flashbacks from the prequel era where fans hated that too. But….. Everyone has there own opinion.

[@DippyDapper]

its more how the phase 1 is based not of episode 2 but the fucking clone wars cartoon because filoni just loves to toot his own horn

[@J.L.The-runt]

Now this is specifically for the phase 1 clone trooper helmets, I think the reason the helmet design was somewhat retconned from how we saw back In Attack of the Clones was because in attack of the clones, the clones were cgi and those helmets look like it was hard for a real person to put that helmet on their heads. (If you look at the hole underneath the helmet, it’s too small to easily slide even your ears in.) In both clone wars animation and what we see now in Ahsoka, the bottom underneath looks wide enough for a real person’s head to fit inside, making the design look alittle wide from the original AOTC clones look…

[@vorpal6685]

yup, the white neck is absurd in real life, cosplayers need to work around from that

[@J.L.The-runt]

@@vorpal6685 thanks for also pointing out that the bottom part of the helmet is known as the “neck part”, I couldn’t identify that properly

[@diamondclaw5313]

I was losing my mind seeing the phase 1 clones! I was also looking around everywhere for Rex. I loved the clone seance.!

[@ZayecValentine]

Same here

[@dopesole9474]

Seeing live action is way better than CGI

[@CameronKiesser]

There are actually some CGI Clones in the background. You can tell as they have slightly different armor and are far more fluid in motion. My issue is that they butchered the Phase 1 helmets and gave Rex an animated pauldron.

[@dvmpld9103]

I don't think it's that they look like CGI, I think it's that the armour doesn't seem to fit well. They look like a bunch of cosplayers in cheap clone armour, with plastic plates shaking around and quite big helmets. While the CGI clones and even Kenobi clones look like they have well tailored armour that is perfectly functional.

[@japremehatfield7233]

Couldn’t have said it any better. That’s exactly what the problem is. Their armour seems too loose, clunky, and disproportionate.

[@mewtwo.150]

The problem is simple, some look really bad at running, a lot even look fat Unlike the CGI ones that looked slim and had soldier movements Even in Andor, when the clones were marching, they looked fantastic!!!! Here the clones, specially the phase 1 when they started to run, look silly, specially the 3th one that appeared

[@11ben1000]

The clones in Andor still looked bad, because they were real people.

[@mewtwo.150]

@@11ben1000 And yet better than these

[@e-1235]

⁠@@11ben1000No they did not, the clones in andor looked absolutely fantastic!

[@11ben1000]

@@e-1235 The clones in andor looked bad. You could tell they were ordinary people in costumes, just like in ahsoka. Some were fatter than others and different heights. Their movements and body language were off. Normal people in clone armour will never look as good and effective as clones made from cgi.

[@Daddy-Hundavar]

0:19 I think you mean the mandalorian season 3 No wait I forgot there where clones in obi wan’s series

[@vickygayming]

The fact that this is the FIRST time we're seeing actual actors playing clones for an extended time is historical, and I definitely acknowledge that I was used to cgi before this. I'm excited to get used to seeing more of this!

[@AH64Gunship]

Other than that special forces guy in revenge if the sith

[@ww.apollo]

There was a mix of both, in most shots they were real people, but there were cgi clones in the background at times. I personally think that its good to see controversy over it because it shows that the cgi clones are hard to tell the difference between them and the real people.

[@Revan638]

what is saw was that one mandalorien that quikly rased his blaster and that looked like cgi to me and was was like what was that actor doing XD

[@ww.apollo]

That was totally animated movement 😅I'd def say that guy was cgi@@Revan638

[@shadowtrooper262]

Those who said those clones are CGI, get some glasses. Maybe when team shows a group photo of the crews i the Clone trooper helsmets, they will be the clowns of their own claims.😂

[@rustybeskar4664]

Yeah, all the clones are real and look amazing. My only nitpick is that they could have used better adhesive for the shoulder pads since you can see them flopping around. Other than that, absolutely excellent.

[@darkwolf_3335]

I Loved the episode! People will never be happy no matter what you give them.

[@davidthirugnanakumar7888]

Welcome to the real world

[@e-1235]

“You can’t make everyone happy, but you can make everyone mad”

[@WIC47]

My only problem is that in both battle scenes you just see clones running past the camera, not ducking or taking cover and shooting like real soldiers would in a battle. Still stunning to see Phase I clones in live action for the first time so I can't complain too much.

[@pink_kino]

I don't think the scenes were 1to1 what actually happened either, I think it was kind of a recreation based around memories prolly

[@elsu1004]

its a dream not a reality... give it slack

[@OnlyTimefps9]

It’s supposed to be like that because that’s exactly how dreams run.

[@macvadda2318]

There’s multiple clones crouching and taking shots, thing is most of the frontline clones are ahead, so shooting is risky due to friendly fire, theyre just trying to get to where they need to go, that was the main strat in the early clone wars

[@macvadda2318]

@@pink_kinoi mean thats hiw they fought

[@Elijahlikechicken]

If people are complaining about this, then you know they have nothing to complain about 😂

[@oliversherman2414]

I didn't mind how the clones looked. Those flashbacks were some nice reminders of the Clone Wars

[@julianbeck1888]

That’s something I just personally had to adjust to. From a costume/realistic point yeah that’s as good as it’s gonna get. The CGI just helped make things more uniform. What I mean by that is in the older films and things I’m kinda noticing now is you can tell the costume is plastic/foam some of the plates don’t stay well connected. My only main issue so far with new star wars live action clones was kenobi. During order 66 the color just seemed off and they had no scuff marks which in my opinion just seems off considering it was the end of the war and the 501st saw a lot of combat.

[@venomfoxgames]

Agreed! Don't get me wrong the armour looks cool but when the actors move around you can see the armour flapping around especially in the shoulder area. The Kenobi series 501st clones were just so wrong in my eyes, they used the wrong colour of blue for the armour and made alterations that break continuity, they didn't look like the ROTS 501st in the slightest.

[@orbita5733]

Just like a simulation

[@rne_denz465]

People really just complain about anything omg

[@TerranPlanetaryDefenseForce]

Full costumed Clones is a damn blessing to fans

[@ayeitsjonjon]

Idk bruh, they look completely fine to me

[@conwarlock3537]

Yes, they look absolutely real

[@intergalactic92]

All of which proves that some people are actively looking for reasons to complain and are struggling so hard with this show that they are making shit up.

[@e-1235]

I feel like that’s movies now a-days.. They all look really good but people nitpick and actively look for problems to point out, especially Star Wars. If people were actually trying to enjoy the show or movie they might actually have a good time instead of looking for things to complain about.

[@nerkou2016]

Ppl just got used to animated clones that they thought these were fake 😂

[@Auvas_Damask]

The thing is, in terms of the series, Ahsoka has the best CGI so far, especially for the ships, which I think is so cool. And in my opinion, I'd rather see a bit of fog than a big, expensive CGI battle and have good quality ships on the screen.

[@TheJoseGarcia325]

Yep i dot get the complaints from others cuz 1 the fog adds mystique to the scene not to mention its a past event long gone and having a whole visible battlefront type of scene with the clone wars flashback would havr taken focus away from anakin and ahsoka and focused on the clones and droids 🤦🏾🤦🏾

[@ProfDrBaum]

Well they are real now where as the original movies had never even built a single piece of clone props... Some people need help

[@R2-D2_329]

What really looks bad is that fucking smoke. I don't care if is a "dream", they could do a better scenary for the battles. The only way we know is actually Ryloth and Mandalore is because of the single twilek on the background and the Ahsoka's outfit in the scene.

[@mamajkhan]

The troopers running looks like an animation from a fan made project

[@leannamation]

Bro I can't believe people would complain about an episode like this. Im not even nostalgia blinded either, the writing and symbolism were great, the acting was great, THE WAY THEY TRANSLATED ANIMATION INTO LIVE ACTION SO WELL! I swear, people will complain about anything these days

[@Pinkerton03]

I would disagree. Like captain rex, his design makes no sense-- We know thanks to Bly that their additions are actually designed differently in live action but are still the same item. The issue I have is that instead if translating the design features of Rex from the clonewars to realistic art direction, they just plastered the clonewars art direction on a realistic body. The helmet is lacking important details, the pauldron is the wrong art style and the packet on it is comically large; evermore so with his holsters

[@leannamation]

@@Pinkerton03 Honestly valid. Rex being incorrectly done is different than some background clones looking a little off

[@e-1235]

@@Pinkerton03It’s not that simple, also what “important details”? I don’t really see or can tell anything is missing, you REALLY must be looking close if you’re noticing things like that. Good thing you fought in the clone wars to tell us how the pauldon “art style” is off. The pouch looks perfectly fine, that’s how it normally looks. His pistols are huge so his holsters have to be huge too. This is sci-fi You’re complaining for no reason. People complain too much these days..

[@Pinkerton03]

@@e-1235 Damn dude it's almost like I watched the fucking movies and the TV show. But I forget that people don't realize that information is so easily accessible to cross reference. People are tired of mediocrity and half assed IPs, this whole "just be happy you got something" culture is so dystopian in a world where we should be experiencing things with more accuracy thanks to the collective information of the internet.

[@e-1235]

@@Pinkerton03 See, here’s the thing. You didn’t answer a single thing I pointed out in the original comment. All you game me was “I watched the show”. These things aren’t half effort. You expect a full, no mistake, high production show. That’s not gonna happen. Unless you have robots writing, producing, and shooting a show, that’s unbelievable. It’s not even a bad costume, sure the writing is off but we’re talking about the clones. The clones are very, very, good. You have no idea what you’re talking about and are just following the little hive mind thing of hating whatever you see.

[@epicsshadesmaster-animatio4398]

I think the clones look nice , people are just not used to real proportions

[@RC1168Shadow]

Cope

[@chummygun]

​@@RC1168Shadowcope

[@CamelxRavenNova2]

First seeing the clones didn’t indicate CGI, it indicated Practical effects.

[@henkknoop1351]

For me their movement looked a bit cartoonish so I instantly thought it looked pretty fake.

[@DanBen07]

The way the 2 planets looked reminded me of geonosis in the video game: Star Wars Battlefront renegade squadron PSP. With not being able to see that much of the surrounding environment.

[@HGBMD]

What we really needed was one of them to say “WE CAPTURED A COMMAND POST “ followed by “WE LOST A COMMAND POST “ missed opportunity there 😂

[@questionmark05]

They are real people. Thats why the armour looks a little janky and rubs and bumps into other pieces slightly when they run because the suit limits range of movement. I think they did very well. I thought it was awesome!

[@3liasBlue]

It’s probably that people are so used to prequel and clone wars movement of clones, that they think it looks strange when people are actually wearing the armor

[@ariadnefrolich7243]

I was just happy to see Rex AND have him voiced by Temuera Morrison.

[@SylverFrost]

Just let them bitch about it. I personally like that actors actually played a part now. They're probably crying about the fact that everything isn't cgi perfect with the perfect shape, size, lighting, etc. Which is unrealistic as hell. They're probably obsessed with the barbie and ken version of cgi animations and can't come to terms with the fact that real people aren't going to be that way.

[@duncandonuts5268]

0:30 those clones in the background there were definitely CGI lol

[@metadude1234]

What bothers me is the clone helmets are literally just the Kellogs mask, but upgraded to solid materials

[@poolee77]

Those are absolutely not the Kellogg helmet lol. They don’t have the goofy neck seal and the fin a much larger than the Kellogg, also the proportions on the visor look better. They may be a new sculpt to look more like the Clone Wars animated They should have used the EFX helmet as a base since it was based on the original CGI files.

[@witcher348]

My reaction for real was "are they real?? They look real..."

[@SandraOrtmann1976]

I was soo happy seeing these guys at work. The only thing I was sad about was that it is so short.

[@Jagdkomodo]

I think not only budget is a big factor here. There also is a difference in ambition.

[@saifwasim5807]

Sorry what??? Seems some people are just being nite picking at this point. Clearly they need to go to Specsavers!!😂

[@TacShooter]

This generation would complain that their vanilla ice cream cone was too vanilla-ey.

[@daronhybridgaming3165]

As someone who just cought up to the asoka series i can say look amazingly real and is my favorite ep from the series

[@siighosts0145]

Lol I was like damn how many people did they gather to make this scene! But watching this makes me realize how the hell did people think the clones were CGI 😂😂😂😂

[@valmid5069]

Viewers: man youtube recommendations are boring lately-- Star Wars Content: *Hello There!*

[@omarguerra1838]

0:30 clone behind Ashoka was the only clone that somewhat felt like revenge of the SITH from the pose to the run, every other clone looks and feels clunky, their armor seems like it’s attached by very loose piece of Velcro

[@stephenjohnston7630]

But all the clones in RotS were CGI, even the ones with Temuera's head awkwardly stuck on them. Have we come full circle from 1999 and are now complaining when things are done practically in SW because they don't look fake enough?

[@omarguerra1838]

@@stephenjohnston7630 the clones in the movies while CG never looked bad, it was the backgrounds aliens etc that looked like dogs hit. But the clones were always sick af. Better than cosplayers in my opinion. Not hating practical effects it’s just about what looks good and bad and I’m sorry but the show looks bad

[@abyssalrayz9499]

@@omarguerra1838 the clone cgi was cool for its time, but it looks very dated. You can instantly tell its cgi by the way they move and it dont look that good.

[@XCalibur_EX]

​@@omarguerra1838 I prefer seeing real people moving around in armor, I like seeing all the little bits and things they have to deal with when moving around and running like someone would actually have to do when wearing armor Because the armor has to be attached, but also be loose enough to allow proper movement (which is a real thing they dealt with irl with full body armor, and in star wars as well) The armor doesn't just magically stick to them, I think that looks more goofy and unreal

[@joshwallace7734]

Your average Star Wars fan will find anything to complain about

[@LuisFernandoPuente]

I believe the clone suits, like a lot of storm trooper suits in recent Star Wars stuff are mostly fan made, part of the 501st groups and such. If you’re asking someone to use their suit I’m guessing you’re not going to weather it/ make it lived in and used how we were used to seeing them in the prequels, and I think that’s the disconnect. Compare the suits of the Night Troopers and those definitely look lived in.

[@lesliepaulkovacs6442]

And it took place in the World between Worlds. It was like reliving a Memory in a Dream. They didn’t need to reproduce every blade of grass just to fill in the background!

[@DevonMcDonald1]

The issue isn’t the visuals the issue is how they move. They are trotting across the screen. In battle no one is doing a quick baby step across the field. Ur sprinting to find cover or to rush to provide cover for your comrades cause that’s your ass. If you don’t move. They all look like “well I’m not in a rush to go help but I don’t want to get court martial”. Lazy writing, directing , could have been a great scene but just wasn’t doing it

[@YomamaYodaddyYobjtchassGranny]

For people that aren’t aware. People are saying this because they show real people as clones but there is a scene that like 1or 2 clones are cgi running past ahsoka. Honestly people who are complaining seem irrelevant to me as I was satisfied by seeing enough live action clone armor that wasn’t cgi. I mean hell we got freaking Rex and he wasn’t cgi

[@Maki-qw8he]

Agreed.

[@primal1233]

These Clone Troopers look awesome, no one can tell me otherwise

[@johnathanjones9216]

They are not best troopers then the ones in attack of the clones in my opinion attack of the clones troopers are the best they where spot you can’t not beat attack of clones troopers

[@themuffinman5755]

​@@johnathanjones9216 He said that the clone troopers in this show look awesome. Never did he in his one sentence say they looked the best or that episode 2 clones weren't the best. He in fact didn't compare them to any other version of them. That was all you.

[@johnathanjones9216]

I no what he said and I no he wasn’t comparing them to ones in attack of the clones and if you think the troopers are way better than the ones in attack of the clones then you are a Disney Star Wars fan and you are wrong the troopers in attack of the clones are the best and I don’t not care what you say

[@themuffinman5755]

@@johnathanjones9216 you can't put someone in a category of what they like, people are entitled to their own opinions and likes of their own interests and can still be fans of newer or older things. If I said that I hate the Disney sequels but liked the clones in this episode then who the hell are you to tell a grown man that they are Disney star wars fans? You don't have the right to speak for other people, only yourself. Also, one cannot be "wrong" about liking something or having an opinion on something being better than another thing. Liking something is an opinion and the last I checked an opinion is how someone feels about something which is all relative and is not right or wrong. If I said I like this girl more than that girl then no one in the world can say that I am wrong. That is how I feel. Saying you disagree to a respectful extent would be the ethical and mature way to handle those situations in life instead of coming off as a controlling jerk who likes to project their opinions onto others like it's fact.

[@themultianimator6571]

As soon as I saw that thumbnail I immediately said, “Is that my boy Charger?”

[@CloneCommanderCrater1102]

Maybe? Or maybe it's Coric or Hex, or it could be any random 501st trooper since nearly every veteran/officer in the Legion used those exact same markings.

[@RalphIgnacio]

It was obvious these were real people in costume. The postures clunky but real. Their armor moved naturally and their footsteps had weight to them.

[@what76485]

Lol they see fog machine and are like dude this cgi smoke sucks.

[@snookkadookka2937]

I liked the clones in this episode. That being said there was one Mando Super commando that popped up on screen for a split second that was horribly animated. It actually looked like a TCW model. Still loved the episode tho

[@Jesse12489]

You can see the shoulder pads are loose. So Yes It's real armor.

[@Jesse12489]

@AppleSauce7417 accuse me if I missed a "o"

[@stairmasternem]

The fog is also there because this is a memory not a thing that’s happening. Like based on the other shots they were fine doing large distances.

[@MegaDrain]

This reminds me of the Ty the Tasmanian Tiger incident. Where when the game originally came out it, all the game reviewers said the Australian accents were bad and forced. When in reality then entire cast are Australian and the game was made in Australia by an Australian studio.

[@minecraftmaniac84]

The only people that looked CGI were the mandalorians

[@tylerhiatto280]

I saw this in my notifications and thought, "Oh god, what is the community complaining about this time?" XD

[@mattgiga9761]

I havent seen anyone complain about this. Those are clearly real people lol

[@Amusedwolverine]

I thought they looked fantastic. It’s so kool! I also liked how foggy it was because she was in a memory and we never can see how perfect a memory was.

[@markholland2795]

There are some people who just like to always find something to complain about

[@The_Orb_Ponderer]

Only one that looked CGI was the Mauldalorian Deathwatch guy

[@fabioenchilada9384]

They’re doing the BF2 run and I love it

[@mjcaboose8036]

Comic Book Guy: Worst effects ever! Homer Simpson: But it’s real. Comic Book Guy: Worst effects ever! 😂

[@CommanderGreeCC1004]

I think they look amazing

[@cassettelord2008]

I just want a close up look at phase1 rex

[@VeriasmcBanker]

I was happy when I saw live action Captain Rex

[@MrBioniclefan1]

The thing I like about the clone troopers in attack of the clones and revenge of the Sith is that armor has a matte finish.

[@randorookie8587]

They do look pretty funky but I liked it

[@goodsir1004]

I knew it wasn't CGI whenni saw the first clones shoulder pads bouncing

[@goodsir1004]

Edit* my main gripe with that scene is young ahskoa isn't voiced buy the clone wars ahsoka

[@_Dibbler_]

"Some people are complaining..." Every video can start with that sentence about Star Wars because there are always at least some people complaining, no matter what.

[@iycephoenixx4249]

Didn't even know people were complaining about this, as they were obviously real

[@venomfoxgames]

Yeah it is a mix of live action clones and CGI clones in that scene when Ahsoka is running after Anakin