[DEBUNKED] One Mistake Destroys Islam? - Challenge Accepted!

[@FaridResponds]

Alhamdulillah after two months of hard work, the Ridvan saga as almost over after almost fifty videos. The only video left is his pathetic video on the science mistakes in the Quran. Keep in mind that I will continue to produce refutations against him whenever he brings forth allegations that DESERVE a refutation. So please don't ask me to refute his trip to Turkey!

[@AkidulIslameditor]

💗 you brother. Waiting for the last one. Jajakhallah Khair

[@osama5371]

Farid Responds Its wonderful for us to see you refuting all of Abdullah Sameer’s videos like “leaving Islam after promoting Islam for 15 years.” We already know Muslim allegation hunter refuted him but only one video about sanaa manuscript. Please refute him like you did to AP... JazakaAllah Khair May Allah SWT bless you and your family Aameen

[@omarfutbol6320]

@@osama5371 would you be interested if I gave a vid that refuted Sameer's vid akhi

[@osama5371]

OMAR FUTBOL yes please I want to watch the video which destroy Abdullah Sameer. He has crossed more than the limit of mocumentary... JazakaAllah Khair brother

[@FaridResponds]

@Abdul Rahman Mohammed Twitter @farid_0v. You can DM me there.

[@moghuz]

The fact that the Hadith-narrators transmitted the question is also a really big sign of their honesty.

[@bennyadammh]

bu ummetin türku yok, arabi yok. Biz müslumaniz ve Islama gurur duyoruz, vatanla degil

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

Their honesty doesn’t correct the error. 😂😂

[@moghuz]

@@thepalmofdeborah2110 watch the video again

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

Halil Isik was it updated ?

[@moghuz]

@@thepalmofdeborah2110 No.

[@AliDawah]

Watched, took notes, enjoyed & laughed ✅ . Hala hala see you on next video 😉

[@ousmaneciss4286]

destiny set me up to be the first to answer. I love you ya akhi ( no homo). Haywa Salam aleykoum.

[@fareedtutorials5649]

@Badger mad sheep from david wood

[@shitpostingtiktok]

@@fareedtutorials5649 BHAHQHQQ

[@yameenhamid]

'sadly, everyone is busy and you stuck with me!' LOL I cannot stop laughing, have to admire the humour brother Farid!

[@yeah7620]

LOL

[@MrAlio84]

"There was in the days of Herod, king of Judaea, a certain priest named Zacharias, of the course of Abijah: and he had a wife of the *daughters of Aaron* , and her name was Elisabeth." Luke 1:5 Tell Ridvan I found a mistake in the Bible, it says Zakaria married the daughter of Aaron 1000+ years after the time of Aaron.

[@averageenjoyer4048]

I don't care about real facts. My Rabbi asks me to do this otherwise the shekels don't get deposited in my bank account.

[@phoenixater]

The daughters of Aaron are all female descendants of him of the priest caste. No matter what generation. However what is a sister of Aaron? Explain. What is the sense?

[@omarfutbol6320]

@@phoenixater These will help out answering it bruh plus In order to understand Qur’anic language one must look into other Qur’anic passages. Qur’ans calls Prophet Shoaib as the brother of the people of Midian. Qur’an says; “And unto Midian (We sent) their brother, Shu'eyb." (Al-Qur’an 7:85) And similarly Qur’an calls Prophet Salih, the brother of the people of Thamud. It says; "And unto Thamud (We sent) their brother Salih." (Al-Qur’an 11:61) In both these examples it is never meant that the Prophets were the real brothers of the each and every person of that tribe. It’s only way to address them. It means that Shu'aib was a (male) person from the people of Midian and similarly Salih from the people of Thamud. So in the very same manner when Qur’an describes Mary, the mother of Christ as 'Sister of Aaron', It means that she is being referred to as a (female) person from the people, the lineage of Prophet Aaron. This is infact an Arabic idiom, a way to address. In Arabia a person from the tribe Banu Mudhar may be addressed as Ya Akha Mudhar, meaning 'O the brother of Mudhar'. www.letmeturnthetables.com/2008/06/why-quran-calls-mary-sister-of-aaron.html?m=1 www.bismikaallahuma.org/quran/mary-the-sister-of-aaron/

[@phoenixater]

@@omarfutbol6320 Be carefull not making cherry picking of facts. There is the terminology calling tribes brothers if they have one ancestor or calling individuals brothers if they have one anchestors. You left this argumentation line (this argument would not lead to an satisfying solution). Then you said that Mary was of the lineage of Aaron. However if you are of the lineage of someone it is called being a son of Aaron (often used in the bible for the descendants of Aaron (the priest caste)) or if you are female a daughter of Aaron (Luke 1.5). Calling Mary a sister of Aaron only make sense if she were Aaron's sister. In another comment I showed the problem that there is only one memorable Aaron: The brother of Moses.

[@omarfutbol6320]

@@phoenixater 1- One thing we need to consider is that Qur’an does not call Mary ‘Sister of Moses’ but ‘Sister of Aaron’. 2- Aaron (PBUH) we know was the first in line for the Israelite priesthood. 3- New Testament clearly tells us that Elizabeth, the mother of John the Baptist (PBUH) was from the lineage of Aaron (Luke 1:5). Also it tells that Mary was a cousin of Elizabeth (1:36). Therefore we can easily call them both ‘Sisters of Aaron’ i.e. from the lineage of Aaron. 4- Infact we have evidence of the similar usage from the Bible. In Genesis 13:8 Abraham and Lot are called brothers while certainly they did not come from loins of one individual. It reads; “And Abram said unto Lot, Let there be no strife, I pray thee, between me and thee, and between my herdmen and thy herdmen; for we be brethren.” A certain Christian commentator, Adam Clarke says in his commentary to this verse; ‘[It means] we are of the same family, worship the same God in the same way, have the same promises, and look for the same end.’ Was the same not true in case of Mary and Aaron? Were they both not from the same priestly family and of same faith? www.bismikaallahuma.org/quran/mary-the-sister-of-aaron/

[@Nsaza]

Jay Smith and other Islamic haters have used this as a ‘mistake ‘ in the Quran. They have failed miserably and so is this AP. So mr AP everyone is busy except your nr 1 fan Farid to refute you! Don’t you get embarrassed AP?

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

They have actually succeeded, because this is 💯 % real.

[@_chrni]

Beryl Gracia did you not watch the video😂😂 god guide you

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

يسين الشارني God guides me , not god and I think you are the one who needs to rewatch the video.🤣🤣🤣because I watched and used my brain to understand but you watched without using your head. That’s why you accepted all the nonsensical explanations in there.🙌🏾🙌🏾Watch and this time try to understand.

[@_chrni]

Beryl Gracia clearly not as you cannot see they fail every time your not blind but it seems you cannot see?

[@yahya2925]

Farid, this THUMB hasn't once been right about any of his attacks on Islam. Islam stands as a unbreakable wall! Alhamduillah

[@zeynabavraham8594]

the only unbreakable is the fact that qram has mistakes, is forged falsely.

[@IoeSpern]

@@zeynabavraham8594 qram? whats that

[@syedahmedshaheer117]

i cant believe Ridwan thinks THIS is is major defeater against islam. ROFL Jesus is called son of David. I guess Jesus lived at 1000 BC

[@averageenjoyer4048]

Don't say nothing about Christianity. My wife, Janna gets angry

[@Mariusesp]

Apostate Prostate what about her boyfriend

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

syed ahmed it actually is 100% , you realise you said Son of David not brother of David right ??? It denotes lineage ; if they wanted to refer to Maryam as a descendant of Aaron; she would be “ Maryam daughter of Aaron..” because the Bible says in Luke 1:5 Elizabeth is a relative of Mary mother of Jesus ; and she was a descendant of Aaron, the Bible refers to her as “ of the daughters of Aaron” she happens to be a cousin of Mary’s: so if Elizabeth is of the daughters of Aaron by decent , how come her cousin Mary is a sister of Aaron but not his daughter too?? 🤔🤔🤔 Think about it.

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

Mr X nice 👍🏾

[@maazhanif8753]

@@thepalmofdeborah2110 dudeeee it is brother/sister in religion not lineage

[@2devious724]

Still love how he's vehemently dismissive of Islamic texts but treats every Christian text, regardless of authenticity, as a scientific theory.

[@averageenjoyer4048]

If I don't support Christianity Janna would kick me out of the house and David Wood would stop paying my monthly paycheck

[@MoinUddin-ne5oc]

@@averageenjoyer4048 ya Allah please enough 🤣🤣 you killed me lol

[@gajiburrahman7378]

@@averageenjoyer4048 Does David Wood wear your wife's clothes??

[@averageenjoyer4048]

How did you know? Are you spying on us? I'll talk to the FBI

[@beverleywells7948]

2 devious That's because Christianity is the true religion,

[@awanderer2661]

Your channel is so underrated It removed all the confusion I found from that prostate guy May Allah bless you brother Farid

[@altheaequatorin1179]

PROSTATE GUY 😭😭😂😂

[@numanshamsi6263]

It is all about the $$$ for Rat-Van 😂😂😂

[@falsehoodbasher7240]

Um. You’re rude. Hateful Muslims

[@al7422]

3:16 Dude WTH! That is *THE* hadith that Muslims use to refute that nonsense!

[@shawnswagger8942]

Man came with the key to his own lock and said its impossible to unlock this. 👍🏼👌🏽

[@Jeem196]

this is honestly the biggest issue I had with Islam, farid. This was the one of the things that really stopped me from thinking Islam is true, this confusion with the names. I had no idea Joachim only appears in these extra-Biblical offshoot books, I assumed it was somewhere in the New Testament. Thank you for posting this. I'm not muslim but this really cleared up a lot, I will keep learning

[@FaridResponds]

May Allah guide you, Jeem. Wish you all the best on your journey.

[@jameswhite3548]

@@FaridResponds Why do Christians still say Joachim is the father of Mary today?

[@user-yp7ke4et7o]

@@jameswhite3548 they have nothing else that's why.

[@amirk7494]

what is restraining u from coming back to islam?

[@Jeem196]

@@amirk7494 A few things, though I still do my research. namely the misunderstanding of the Trinity, and the crucifixion for one

[@al7422]

Christians/ex Muslims:- The prophet knew the biblical stories that's why he could mention them precisely in the Qur'an. Therefore it must be false. Also Christians/ex-muslims:- The Qur'an doesn't match with the biblical stories. Therefore it must be false. Am I the only one who sees this? Christians/ex-muslims can make the prophet both a Bible scholar and a person who doesn't know about the biblical narrative, like at all. It seems too convenient 🤔

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

Akib that’s exactly the point. It’s one thing to know Biblical narrative and another to perfectly understand and remake the narrative chronologically without error. Your point explained it perfectly well; if one can confuse Miriam sister of Aaron and Moses, children of Amram( Number 26:59 Exodus 15:20-21) to Mary mother of Jesus and relative of Elizabeth (Luke 1:36) to be the same; then for sure the narrative is known but couldn’t be matched correctly. Because Miriam sister of Aaron is Miriam doesn’t mean she is Maryam mother of Isa(Mary mother of Jesus )🙌🏾🙌🏾.

[@The1Bozkurt1]

@@thepalmofdeborah2110 1 Chr. 4:15 The sons of Caleb son of Jephunneh: Iru, Elah and Naam. The son of Elah: Kenaz. Joshua 15:17, King James Version Othniel the son of Kenaz, the brother of Caleb Kenaz is Caleb's grandson(1 Chr. 4:15)

[@rickjames9039]

Sheikh Ahmed Deedat (may Allah grant him paradise) destroyed Anis Shorosh, who also claimed a similar situation. When he took out the genealogies of Jesus (peace be upon him) according to the many Bibles, Anis Shorosh was speechless, I'll never forget that moment in history.

[@MohammadAliKhalil]

If you’re a Christian, you already lost. Thousands of mistakes but they still can’t find one in Islam. Alhamdulilah

[@zeynabavraham8594]

so you have this HUGE mistake in the qram yet you look the other way... so childish. The qram also says that camel's urine warm and raw is the best for a healthy body, drink it if you believe what allah says... allahisaliaerinthelandhahahaha

[@suryaya441]

Good video br. Farid, I'm glad you utilized Dye's article on this topic. For the interested reader, I would add (and this is tangential) that furthermore, Mary (of the old testament) and Mary (of the new testament) were sometimes spoken of interchangeably as well, for example, by Aphrahat the Syriac writer. How unusual would it be to accuse church fathers themselves of confusing the two Marys! Church fathers also exploited the fact that NT and OT characters shared names. The fact that the Qur'an is even aware of this shows sophistication on the part of the Author beyond what a 7th century Arab is capable of.

[@quranandbibleblog]

Ridvan the mouth breather...🤣😂

[@omarfutbol6320]

Tony ferguson is the type of guy to contact bro farid to help refute ridvan😂

[@FaridResponds]

LOL! I wasn't aware that Tony Ferguson was so concerned with polemics.

[@omarfutbol6320]

@@FaridResponds 😂😂May Allah bless you bro🙏 and just ignore the haters in KZbin and twitter inshallah because they just mad😎

[@omarfutbol6320]

@44552211 Jazakallah for the reminder akhi😎

[@idurisu930]

Did not expect to find one of these comments here

[@cdseventy6435]

Gaethje destroyed Tony lol

[@obedritein4649]

RIZVAN 😂😂TRY AGAIN 😂😂......Mary sister of Harum means: Mary(mother of Jesus) Comes from the LEANAGE of Harun(Aron)..AP is the One CONFUSED,..AP is the author of confusion😂😂

[@falsehoodbasher7240]

Wouldn’t she be his niece then or granddaughter not his sister? +why sister of *Aaron not Musa*

[@-LTUIiiin]

They were from different tribes. So how can they be descendants.

[@fatimagaye3729]

Thank you so much for what you do. There aren't enough people refuting ridwan and David wood. They are seriously problematic and I hope you never stop. Even when it seem like you are alone in this. You are doing to right thing. Jazakallah khairn

[@Jeem196]

A second comment of mine: if you look at ancient Syriac writings from 300AD, there is an example where a Christian writer talks about MariamOT and MariamNT in the same passage without clarifying these are two different people. He says "Mariam watched Moses in the basket in the river; and Mariam(NT) was with Jesus". The christian author does not clarify, because his Christian audience is well aware of the difference between the two Mariams and he is using a comparison with their names. Other writers, also Syriac Christians, refer to Mariam, mother of Jesus, as "the rod of Aaron" meaning a descendant from Aaron's lineage.

[@MrArb3r]

Alhamdulilah. Thank you bro Farid. May Allah bless you with Jannah with your refutation videos.

[@muamerblazevic1837]

The fact that in place of "Mary's mother" he didn't put Hannah shows how much he knows about islam. Or should I say how little. Stay away from Ridwan friends he's not that bright.

[@muamerblazevic1837]

@@person10 Yeah because most muslims know that the name of Mary's mother is Hannah. So it also shows that he most likely was never a muslim to begin with.

[@divinity176]

@@muamerblazevic1837 How can most muslims "know" that Hannah is the name of Mary's mother when it comes from the same apocryphal source that has Joachim as the name of Mary's father? Does that mean that most muslims "know" her father's name was Joachim?

[@TheMuslimPerspective]

Thanks farid. May Allah grant you heaven.

[@daniyalahmed687]

I want to challenge Ridvan to grow a brain cell...

[@wuriayuoctafany3764]

Its really hurting me watching AP videos. Ya Allah .. 😭😭

[@ahuman9628]

This is better than stand up comedy lol 🤣 keep going.

[@ovobegzino275]

Brother Farid I love you so much you have made my Imaan glow and given me so much knowledge. Alhamdulilah. One issue is it wise to be using 'Virgin' as an insult? May Allah bless you and your Family.

[@nizcomix3721]

Ridvan when someone tells him that their dad's name is "Adam": Impossible

[@gajiburrahman7378]

Actually, the answer given by the prophet( sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) makes a lot of sense. I don't really understand why Ridvan is laughing, other than the desire to make the prophets response sound weak, when it's not. Even today people name their children after ancient Prophets. We Muslims name many of our son's Muhammad, after our prophet.And there are many Jews and Christians naming their sons Aaron(or Harun) or Moses, or Joshua, after their prophets or saints.

[@phoenixater]

However it have to be a famous Aaron. If he wouldn't be famous, it wouldn't be reasonable mentioning him. There is only one memorable Aaron: The brother of Moses and Mariam. This would be the only site where a sibling of the virgin Mary is mentioned. No matter if bible, apocryphs or islamic literature.

[@gajiburrahman7378]

@@phoenixater That is your opinion. But there is no fixed rule saying that you can only mention famous people. If she was indeed the sister of a man called Aaron, then there is no harm in stating that. It doesn't matter if he was famous or not. Maybe there is some wisdom in it, like for example, showing that Mary was not some god-like figure as some Christians will have you believe, but rather, just a normal woman with family.

[@phoenixater]

@@gajiburrahman7378 Calling a person with a name or nickname make only sense when the listener unterstand to what person is referring. Famousness is relative. In a family or a village it would be sufficent if Aaron would be known to these persons. That the so called eternal and uncreated Quran is referring to a fully unknown person is alarming. The brother of Moses, this Aaron, is literally the only known Aaron till in the 4th century some Christian martyrs had the name.

[@gajiburrahman7378]

@@phoenixater The point is, it's not an error as claimed by Ridvan. The fact that you believe it doesn't make sense to mention an unknown person is not relevant. As I said previously, there may be some hidden Wisdom behind mentioning Mary's unknown brother. Just because you and I don't understand the reason for mentioning her brother's name, doesn't mean there wasn't a reason for it. I've already mentioned one possible reason, but there may be a different reason.

[@phoenixater]

@@gajiburrahman7378 Allah's wisdom seems quite unreasonable: These few words make christians making jokes about Islam already in the early time of Islam: The earliest account on Islam (exept quran and the dome of the rock inscription) is by the Christian scholar John Damascene ca. 730. That's earlier than ibn Isaaq ca. 766 and the Hadith collections ca. after 850. And for example therefore he mocked Islam. Does Allah not want that we Christians become muslims? That's literally the only sense these few words can have.

[@Lutestick]

I love you for the sake of Allah brother! You have ignited the Iman in my heart InshaAllah!

[@muhammadbenjuraij7734]

I also researched this and So really calling Maryam عليه السلام the sister of Haroon is valid because A) she actually had a brother called Harun because the Jews like the Muslims today named their kids after the prophets and there is no proof to the contrary. B) She is actually a descendant of Harun and so metaphorical in meaning as in the Quranic verse {واذكر أخا عاد} i.e., HUD; because Hud عليه السلام was not the brother of Aad but the far removed grandson between them are hundreds of years this being even alluded to in the gospel of Luke and is very likely indeed because the prophets are interrelated to each other and Maryam is the mother of a prophet . C): That she was given a pet name of the sister of Harun because of her piety and hence when she brought the child out of wedlock they used it to scorn her as the context of the verse suggests because the Quran is quoting their words and is not making a lineage claim! D): or she was branded with this name as a form of chastisement because the Jews believe quite falsely that Harun عليه السلام made the calf idol that they ended up worshiping and equated the birth with the same gravity and that’s why they didn’t say oh sister of Moses. The fact is that is quite probable that she did have a brother called Harun or a cousin and that at the same time she was the many times removed granddaughter of the prophet Harun because Esa عليه السلام is from the bloodline of the prophets as are all the prophets and that at the same time the nickname was used by the Jews to scorn her either because of her piety or their false belief about Harun although it’s possible that some of them said it for the first reason and the others who actually believed the falsehood said it for their belief which would mean the Quran was right in so many ways the accuracy of which if proven true on all accounts would dumbfound us even more! The strongest out of them however is that she is actually the ancestor and far removed granddaughter of the prophet Harun عليه السلام and a very very very pious woman so much so a few Imams regard her as a female prophet Ibn hazm and Al-Qurtubi are 2 such Imams. These foolish people have nothing original and all they do is go to anti Islam websites run by people who have zero knowledge about Islam and have no access or ability to understand the Arabic sources! They are extremely pathetic!

[@starkidforlife136]

when the “author” of the Quran knows enough about history to not call the ruler of Egypt at the time of Yusuf (as) a Pharaoh allegedly mixes up two completely different Mary’s from different time periods.. these Islamaphobes always have to reach so far

[@pedertony5615]

MashAllah My akhi, amazing refutation. JazakAllah :)

[@TigerTheHunter]

MashaAllah very good job done by you brother farid ✌️

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

Yaldrum SSG 🤣🤣🤣😂

[@AdilKhan-hb9tq]

Hassan ridwan is also an ex Muslim who makes anti Islamic videos Brother can you refute this guy ?

[@Docan690]

Adil Khan He is not anti Islamic. He doesn’t believe in Islam.

[@The1Bozkurt1]

@@Docan690 he is anti islamic

[@pacheco14fu]

Jazakallahu Khairan for this video. Was eagerly awaiting it. You and the other brothers have done a great job over the past 2 months. Really amazing. I hope Allah accepts from you guys and may you guys continue this fight against the opponents of islam.

[@Synocra]

In Hebrew texts the name Miriam and Mary isn't differentiated and used as Mary. In English translation they differentiated between Mary and Miriam so they don't get confused.

[@vortexvampire]

بارك الله فيكم... اللهم اغفر لوالدينا و ارحمهما و اجمعنا معهما في الفردوس الأعلى مع الأنبياء و الشهداء و الصالحين و جميع موتى المسلمين.. اللهم احقن دماء المسلمين و انصرهم على من عاداهم.. رب إني مسني الضر و أنت أرحم الراحمين... لا إله إلا أنت سبحانك إني كنت من الظالمين..... .''''''' ................ .. . . . ..................

[@akmaldiable7060]

Thank you for sharing this. May Allah bless you.

[@ArdoBlueMoon]

Thanks Farid, so there are two possible responses to the "sister of Harun" comment. 1) That Maryam's parents named their son Harun, after Harun brother of Musa pbut. This seemed to me the most obvious reading from the Hadith. Is this wrong? 2) That Harun pbuh founded a family of priests and pious people and Maryam pbuh was a descendant. In Arabic the word "sister" is a more appropriate to describe their relationship because they were priests and the relationship isn't 100% linear, ie there are a few second cousins a few times removed or something like that.

[@ArdoBlueMoon]

@Freedom fighter Be quiet, I'm asking Farid or someone with knowledge.

[@The1Bozkurt1]

Bible 1 Chr. 4:15 The sons of Caleb son of Jephunneh: Iru, Elah and Naam. The son of Elah: Kenaz. Joshua 15:17, King James Version Othniel the son of Kenaz, the brother of Caleb Kenaz is Caleb's grandson(1 Chr. 4:15)

[@cent7169]

I really admire the way you express your words in a respectful way, you truly represent Islam as a peaceful way of life in giving your Dawah, may Allah protect u more

[@desertboy1162]

Virgin Mary has very high status.

[@owaissheraz]

He answers himself. My name is owais does that mean i m owais qarni, companion of prophet

[@alwaysflat7996]

0:21 LOL that was funny Farid

[@asaaasaabb5408]

If he read the same Surah little further he will find Haroon and musa in a separate story ,when quraan says Moses asked Allah to make Haroon also his companion and a prophet . This clearly show that quraan's author is not confused between two haroons.

[@ISLAMICPREACHERAPOLOGIST]

I wish that if possible that more editing could be done to title so we all remember what’s the actual topic of the video like for example challenge accepted (MARY DAUGHTER OF IMRAN ) Topic. So it’s easier to find & remember.

[@qwizzle78]

Blob fish has been finished again. Amazing video

[@alexferdinansyah757]

Ridvan the moth breather :D :D :D

[@AsifAlli]

Man you're hilarious, "Ridwan the mouth breather" lol

[@medsah6096]

Let's get this bread challengers

[@imaadmalik7336]

The thumbnail 😭

[@fedesetrtatio1]

1. The Gospel of James is not rejected as a forgery. It is rejected because it is too late a book and was not included in the canon for that reason. There were other theological issues also. 2. the name of Joachim does not only occur in the Gospel of James it also apears "Gospel of the Nativity of the Blessed Mary", and the Pseudo-Matthew, or "Book of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary and of the Childhood and the Church Fathers. 3. This lie of Mary being the brother of Aaron and daughter of Amran was recognized and challenged by the christian s and jews at the time of Mohammad who in turn came up with the silliest of response. There is no record in Jewish traditions that children were named after famous ones. And off course they objected if that hadith is not an objection it is definitely not a compliment. 4. Ignorance of a fact does not prove the existence of a fact. they definitely knew that Moses and Aaaron were the sons of Amran and they the Christian and jews recognized something fishy was going on to bring up the issue. Saying that they did not know that Mary fathers name was Joachim - when they had the Gospel of james going around there and even copied by the quran in part is pretty far fetched. 5. Farid leaks very confidently says Aaron the brother of Mary was nobody else but Mary. Aaron was a Levite and Mary was from the tribe of Judah. So it could not be this Mary. No mate as much of Juggling can be done here but Mohammad and Allah stuffed up big time. So big that the Christians and jews of Najran present at the time recognized it. You had 1400 to concoct some explanation and this is what you come up with.

[@ahmedabdelrahman4114]

Who said Mary was the tribe of Judah ? Which book in the bibles say that. She was Elizabeth relative, Kinswomen, cousin whatever the bible says. Elizabeth according to Luke 1-5 she is descendent of Aaron. I think you are refering to Joeseph who was espoused/engaged to Mary who id descendant of Judah as the bible said ? Even luke and Matthew didnt if Joseph's dad was Heli or Jacob and they didnt know if it goes all the way up to Solomon or Nathan.

[@fedesetrtatio1]

@@ahmedabdelrahman4114 Even if Mary was a Livite it does not exonerate the glaring error of Mary being the sister of Aaron and Moses. 1600 years separating their existence is colossal evidence that the quran is not from God. It also proves another claims the quran makes that if errors is found within it is not from Allah.

[@ahmedabdelrahman4114]

@@fedesetrtatio1 sister doesnt need to be biological sister. In the hadith prophet Muhammad peace be upon him didnt ser she is Musa and Haruns biological sister. He said that people at that time used to call this comomon names. in your religion when they mention brotherhood of judah and israel, it does mean they are blood brothers, they are 2 related tribes or whatever. Also there are so many other explainations like Mary comes from priestic family or she is dedicated to worship, like what you call in the church sister, is she your actual sister ?

[@fedesetrtatio1]

@@ahmedabdelrahman4114 Yes I would agree with the cousin sister narrative but Allah/Mohammad further complicate things . Allah in his address calls Mary daughter of Imran. Unfortunately Imran is not Marys fathers name. Imran happens to be the Father of Aaron and Joshua and Miriam (the blood sister ) who existed 1600 years before Mary the Mother of Jesus was born. It is obvious this is an error of great concern. It is obvious Allah confuses Mariam the mother of Jesus with Miriam the blood sister Aaron. No amount of mental gymnastics will get muslims out of this one. There are plenty others misinformation which Christian and jews are able to detect in the quran because of their familiarity with their own Scripture (Abrahamic) and traditions, leaving muslim oblivious because of the lack their of and the prejudice to the Bible. All though the quran says if you are in doubt go to the them for clarification.

[@ahmedabdelrahman4114]

@@fedesetrtatio1 well you are rejecting the only source Book of James because it is a late book that has a different name than Imran. You are accepting Jesus lineage to David through Joseph and you know Joseph is not his dad. Luke and Matthew disagree on hos joseph dad is. Is Jacpb or Helli. A person can have 2 names by the way: Jacob others name is Israel. The bible contradict itself in so many places even translation contradict itself why is the quran have to be judged by not agreed upon bible. Bible is 66 books or72 books or 81 books no one knows ? Can you prove Matthew, Luke, John and Mark see Jesus no you cant. Can you even prove Matthew wrote the book of the Matthew no you can't. Are you certain which language Matthew wrote his bible no you are not. As for Moses books, jews confrim that they were lost and Ezra after many years gathered it gfor them. Go criticize your own beliefs 1st. Najran Christian didnt argue that imran was the name of Mariams dad so why are you ?

[@owaissheraz]

If maryam was named after maryam, why cant harun be named after harun

[@ashley_brown6106]

Slayed🤣🤣🤝👏👏👏👏👏

[@abdusshakoorsaafir3985]

HARUN or Aron was the priestly family of the 12 tribes (Levites). Maryam served as a Temple virgin hence the name "sister of Harun." It like the nuns today being called "sisters."

[@divinity176]

Are there any other examples of extended Sister/Brother kindship (i.e. "Sister of Harun") in the Quran? I accept your reasons for doubting Mary's father was named Joachim. Do you have any reasons outside of the alleged error itself for believing it was, by some incredible coincidence, Amran?

[@aq-ghost5038]

Well it's the word of God

[@divinity176]

@@aq-ghost5038 How do you its god? Because the quran says so. How do you know the quran is true? Because god says so. Same circular argument theists have been making for millennia. Eventually they will figure out why it isn't convincing and why non-belief is spreading so fast.

[@divinity176]

@Poop Poop Not my bible - I am an athiest. But your bible - Islam claims at least some of the books as being from Allah and yet they are corrupted. Why couldn't Allah protect his revelation? I.e. Injil, Zabur, Tawrat?

[@ahmedabdelrahman4114]

@@divinity176 well in the quran it talks about that tribe of Aad, Aad who was their ancestor. Quran said Akha Aad. The brother of Aaad. I think i saw a comment by you why Almughairah asked if Arab used this terminology, well Arab used it mostly for tribes and Almughairah might not know how Mary is related to Harun. According to Christians, Marys cousin is descendant from Levy who is descendant of Harun. Also Mary could have had a brother his name is Harun like a half brother. If you are athiest why you are judging islam by the bible ?

[@The1Bozkurt1]

1 Chr. 4:15 The sons of Caleb son of Jephunneh: Iru, Elah and Naam. The son of Elah: Kenaz. Joshua 15:17, King James Version Othniel the son of Kenaz, the brother of Caleb Kenaz is Caleb's grandson(1 Chr. 4:15)

[@fahadusmani2184]

Allah hu Akbar.....my yaqeen on Islam has triple fold i love their allegations against Islam and when the answers comes out its mind blowing

[@sonus89]

Probably those people who met Maryam personally and wrote the Gospel are liars and the people who lived 600 years later know the father of Maryam better. Muslim logic. It is understandable if you dont understand it. :DDD Why would they lie about the name of him????? :DDDD And why is it so obvious that another Maryam lived 1500 years earlier who DOES have a father called amram and DOES have siblings... : DDDD

[@dqschannel]

Isn't that funny.

[@sonus89]

@@dqschannel The are huge huge huge holes in the narrative!

[@dqschannel]

@@sonus89 by now they are more like sinkholes

[@zeynabavraham8594]

...so you can't face the FACT that that was an obvious mistake due the ignorance of a false prophet and the work of a liar from the desert? ...so childish...

[@badassnumber1655]

Ahmad Deedat also talked about this issue and said the terminology was also in the Bible- Mary was a daughter of Moses AS and sister of Haroon AS highlights etc

[@Maraziko]

Also I think that Mary RA is a direct descendant of Aaron Haroun so it could be as reference of her lineage

[@footyfenom2490]

Ridvan, Joachim, Christian Mary and Christian Aaron disliked this video.

[@safaamari1438]

I challenge Ridvan to stop this charade!... 🤐😏

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

Safa Amari I challenge you to read between the lines , seek truth for yourself : listen out to the voice of God.

[@egsdgv5311]

god bless u

[@rasyidihramsyah7992]

The moment Ridvan (Ridwan) meet with Malik (The Warden and the gatekeeper of Hell) 😲🤯 Well, just read the Qur'an so you could imagine what Malik and The Zabaniyah would do to him

[@Solarwind38989]

My brother make a video on fine-tuning. Of universe.... And a sign in dna

[@AhmedSalah-gw4wv]

It's so weird that he says that Muslims don't know about this hadith because it's embarrassing. Like, how? It's in "Sahih Muslim", the third most important book or something that a 10 years old kid used to read and even memorize all of it. It's like he got something from a book that the mosque (Like "the church" LOL) wanted no one to read or know about. He's just there literally to feed atheists and islamophobic modern Crusaders who want to know about Islam in any way possible just to justify their hate.

[@chiaratiara2575]

@Farid Responds, Having agreed that AP's video drew attention to factual errors in the Quran, at what point in your argument did you refute his? My second question is, how would Muhammad have read the Gospel of James?

[@StopSpammingOriginal]

Challenge accepted - and failed. The Joachim fact is not done with by simply stating it's a forgery. If it is indeed a forgery, we still have the name of the father as being Imran and the brother being Aaron. Of course all you have left now is claiming that people used different names when they felt like it and - just by chance - they chose father and son as family members who did indeed have a Mary as a member also. If that is your only line of defence it's preeeeetty weak. But then, what else you got? Nothing. Verdict: not debunked or challenge met, so 2 fails.

[@gajiburrahman7378]

But it's not a weak defence. Coincidences have happened throughout history. Also, if the Quran confused the Mary of Jesus's time with the Mary of Moses time, then wouldn't it makes sense to refer to her as the sister of Moses. Wouldn't we expect to see the Quran mentioning Moses in relation to Mary. But the fact is ,we don't see that. So it is a weak argument on the part of Ridvan and others like him, to say that the Quran confused the two Mary's. The story of Moses is mentioned so many times, and not once is Mary the mother of Jesus mentioned alongside him. Farid absolutely destroyed your idol Ridvan.

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

Finally somebody who has a brain .🤦🏾‍♀️

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

Gajibur Rahman You just made it worse .😂😂😂 Why at all is even referred to as “sister of Aaron” You even know Aaron is Moses’ brother if she isn’t referred to as Moses’ sister why is she Aaron’s? And by coincidences happening through our history you mean mistakes?? How can it be by coincidence that this is mentioned?? 😂😂

[@thepalmofdeborah2110]

Bilal Khan another comment ignored yet you commented and brought 13 others with you to like your comment. That’s a lot of attention.

[@StopSpammingOriginal]

@KZbin Funny _"why didn’t the Christians and Jews object"_ Maybe they did and today they do for sure.

[@jundean5292]

excellent

[@AkidulIslameditor]

How you can comment 3 days ago

[@evansyed4960]

This video was released just now. How did you comments 3 days ago

[@MoinUddin-ne5oc]

How man 3 days ago?🤨

[@FaridResponds]

Dude. Was this a D-mail?

[@evansyed4960]

@@FaridResponds Hey why did u ignore me?

[@ahmedmousa7664]

Jazakum Allah khairan

[@melissaaulia8231]

Im sorry but of course Ridvan is virgin, he seems like he is never touch water and his face are breaking out. Euwww

[@averageenjoyer4048]

That's why my wife Janna doesen't let me into her bed. Otherwise I wouldn't be a virign

[@ibrahimr4690]

Prophet Muhammad (sal) told his wife safiyyah bint huyayy (ra) to other wife about her as ; “[Tell them] how you could fare better than me, while Prophet Aaronas was my father, prophet Mosesas was my uncle and Muhammadsa is my husband!” (The Holy Prophetsa)

[@seedstun4581]

His argument is basically that it isn't the same as in the Bible, and if it was the same, he'd probably claim Muhammad copied it from Waraqah or something.

[@neko7981]

this dudes gonna be like, muslims claim the golden age of islam is during the time of their prophet but us see muhammad giving dawah is his youtube channel even in this day and age (hijab)- the blunder muslims are in!!!!

[@hermanvanvliet1276]

Hahahaha enjoyed that akhi

[@muezamueza2797]

1). Mary and Miriam are different Christians apologist often question a confusion between Mary mother of Jesus and Miriam sister of Moses. They often use this issue as an big mistake in Quran and an undeniable proof that Quran is wrong. This problem has been answered by the prophet himself more than 1400 year ago. Mughira ibn Shu’ba reported: When I came to Najran, the Christian monks asked me, “You recite the verse, ‘O sister of Aaron,’ (19:28) but Moses was born long before Jesus by many years.” When I came back to the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, I asked him about it and he said, “Verily, they used to name people with the names of prophets and righteous people who had passed before them.” (Sahih Muslim 2135) Ibn Kathir said, “This is like saying to somebody from the Tamimi tribe: O brother of Tamim, or to somebody from the Mudari tribe: O brother of Mudar.” 2). Marry is Descendant of Imran Marry was called with honrific name Sister of Aron which show that he belongs to Levi priestly Tribe. Marry mother of Yesus is called daughter of Imran because she is of Amran lineage father of Moses, Aron And Miriam. Jews often called themself as children of Abraham. Marry father was called Imran, He is related to Zakariya, father of Jhon the baptist. Many names in Islam can be very different from joachim a names in the Aphrocipal Bible. The four Gospels do not mention who is Marys Father. Is that a problem ?. Why is that ?. Marry is Theotokos, is Her father not important to be mentioned .... hahaha. Because Marry was From l a priestly family, Jesus was not decendant of David, therefore he cannot be the promisedkingly mesiah. In the gospels of Matthew and Luke there are two sides of Jesus lineage that are disconnected and funny. Those who made this genealogy must have made it up. It shows the Geneology of Joseph, not Jesus because Joseph is not Jesus' father. 3). Genealogy of Jesus was Wrong Tribemanship in the Jewish nation is descended from the father's line. Since Jesus has No father, Therefore it is impossible for Jesus to be a descendant of David. Although his mother may have descended from David, Jesus could not be called king because he had no father. That's why in the Gospel of Matthew 16:20, it is told Then Jesus forbade His disciples not to tell anyone that He was the Messiah. Why did Jesus Forbid his disciples to call him mesiah in publik ? Jesus knew the messiah had to be a descendant of David, while he had no father to claim the lineage of David. Jesus could only claim descent from his mother. That's why in the Quran Jesus is often called Isa Ibn Maryam. Jesus son of Mary. So Muslims have known this story for a long time. It's a pity that there are billions of Christians do not know that Jesus is not the promised Kingly Messiah, because he is not decendant of David. But muslim know that He is a prophet and a priestly mesiah. 4). Al Fadi and AP are two beggars on the internet. AP is just a Christian pretending to be a fake ex-Muslim atheist. They try to spread Christianity to Muslims, by making a lot of lies about Islam..... hahaha. AP and Al Fadi earn money to support their life by making lies about Islam, 24 hours a day. Many Christians who hate Muslims give them money. So the profession of these two clowns are professional liars about Islam and begging for money from Christians who hate Muslims. Al Fadi and AP are beggars on the internet.

[@oliverrepp131]

That thumbnail is a violation

[@leovere]

5:42 the lection of Jeremiah is a 7th century syrian christan text thay was specifically read at the kathisma church, so its literally a contemporary text to Muhammad. Also take in account that Mary many times is referred as the "rod of aaron" or used interchangeably with Miriam for example Aphrahat (d. 345), in On Persecution, writes: "Mary stood on the shore of the river as Moses floated on the water; and Mary bore Jesus, after the Angel Gabriel announced to her" So basically it's a typology used at the time of Muhammad at the area of Muhammad by the churches that had more influence on Islam, but is has nothing to do at all with the historical Christan tradition, and even less with how people used to speak in the first century, because the claim here is that people in the first century said that to Mary not that some christans used that typology, christans didn't even existed at that point.

[@travismcdowell954]

Based on Ridvan's setup you would think that the Hadith said Mary was a time traveler or something. Instead we got a logical and accurate explanation.

[@divinity176]

Accurate? You accept Mary's father was named Amran based on nothing just because Farid wants it to be?

[@aq-ghost5038]

@@divinity176 no because its in Quran which is word of God

[@divinity176]

@@aq-ghost5038 That isn't helpful when the whole dispute is based on the veracity of the Quran. Please think it through.

[@sambayrouti4873]

May Allah reward you brother

[@zeynabavraham8594]

...for a lie? how can humans be so stupid? so you have this HUGE mistake in the qram yet you look the other way... so childish. The qram also says that camel's urine warm and raw is the best for a healthy body, drink it if you believe what allah says...

[@ramlishafial7926]

THE CHRISTIANS NEED MORE STUDY IN ISLAMIC KNOWLEDGE. BEFORE GOING MORE DEEPLY INTO CONFUSION IT IS BETTER THEY STUDY AND UNDERSTAND THEIR OWN RELIGION AND THE LIES BEHIND CHRISTIANITY.

[@beverleywells7948]

Lies behind islam

[@ramlishafial7926]

@@beverleywells7948 JUST BECAUSE ISLAM DID NOT BELIEVE GOD HAVE SON.

[@beverleywells7948]

@@ramlishafial7926 Because they are lied to

[@sexygirlw7031]

@@beverleywells7948 😂 Bible was corrupted

[@beverleywells7948]

@@sexygirlw7031 No it isnt

[@ahnaflfc369]

JazakAllah khair

[@brandonscorner9184]

There’s only one woman named in the Quran, and that’s because the Quran’s Human Author confuses her as being part of the Trinity. It’s illogical to think the Quran is mentioning two different women by name, when it hasn’t named the other 136 women found in the Bible. So no you haven’t refuted this obvious error. Mary can’t be both the mother of Jesus and the sister of Moses.

[@mirakbar9029]

Brother Frid, I have to you are quite tolerant as I can't stand this man Redvan or whatever his name is.

[@ahmetlashin2328]

Jazakallahukhairan farid I wish people sees this video instead of believing blindingly in ridvan and hes right to mention that the Bible had imran and Arabic handwriting but the Romans conquered Palestine and by time Romans converted and changed ALOT of things in the Bible thats why it has errors

[@ex-christiannowatheist8466]

IT IS A SHAME THAT ORIENTALIST ALWAYS USE CHRISTIAN ARGUMENTS IN HIS BOOKS. WHY? BECAUSE THEY WERE RAISED CHRISTIANS.

[@zaidiportal]

Is this guy's face slowly melting. He looks weirder with every video

[@baseermirza2947]

The thumbnail is hilarious

[@azimy9388]

Christians going back to the drawing board be like 🏃‍♂️

[@masudzaman8841]

This video is a perfect example of strawmanning an argument.

[@Abdullah-v5n2n]

how?

[@yigittutenkuken1210]

Assalamu aleykum verahmetullahi wabarakatu!!!

[@SR-hu7qr]

AP is so right,

[@abhmd4481]

Lol

[@PrimordialWaterPracticalMatter]

Alhemdulillah

[@FreePalestine_____]

If the Quran referred to Mary as the sister of Moses then they would be from the same era. Was prophet Moses and Jesus from same era? [Quran 2:87] "And We did certainly give Moses the Torah and *followed up after him with messengers [plural].* And We gave Jesus, the son of Mary, clear proofs and supported him with the Pure Spirit. But is it [not] that every time a messenger came to you, [O Children of Israel], with what your souls did not desire, you were arrogant? And a party [of messengers] you denied and another party you killed." So even according to Quran itself there were many MESSENGERS between Prophet Moses and Jesus [pbut]. Thus they can't be from the same century.

[@themistersmith]

Ridvan keeps lying over and over

[@ahmedsaif6110]

Brother Farid, can you please give me the reference mentioned in 5.54. I couldn't pick from the video

[@muhammadal-amin4531]

Also point noting the bible makes mention of jesus as the son of David