Farmer Protests Expose Real State of Present Punjab & Haryana | MSP | Delhi Chalo | UPSC GS3

New StudyIQ Channel - / @upsccsestudyiq | Subscribe Now for Exclusive Videos and Amazing Content. Use the code ‘ANLIVE’ to get Our Courses at Maximum discount!
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3T20cQW
For any queries please whatsapp on bit.ly/wame895...
UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation P2I 2025 February Batch 2 : bit.ly/3T20cQW
Batch Starting on 24th February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3T20cQW
In this video, uncover the ground reality of Punjab and Haryana revealed by the ongoing farmer protests, focusing on MSP and the Delhi Chalo movement. Gain insights into the socio-economic challenges faced by farmers and the agricultural sector, pertinent for UPSC GS3 preparation. Explore the implications of these protests on agricultural policy, rural livelihoods, and national development. Stay informed with StudyIQ on key issues impacting India's agrarian landscape.
UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I February Hindi Batch 2
एडमिशन की अंतिम तिथि 27 फरवरी 2024 | बैच का समय शाम 6:00 बजे
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3IhXOQd
UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I February English Batch
Batch Starting on 26th February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/47XLChH
UPSC IAS Long Term P2I Foundation LIVE 2026 Batch 2
Batch Starting on 21st February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3OGqnKH
UPSC IAS Live SIP+ 2024 February Batch 3
Batch Starting on 23rd February'2024 | Class Timing - 11:00 AM
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3OMzLMK
UPSC IAS Prelims to Interview ( P2I) 2024 Live Advanced Batch 6
Batch Started on 16th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:30 PM
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/46nl6h4
UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Optional Batches : bit.ly/3DrHsmw
(PSIR, Sociology, History, Geography, Pub Ad, Anthropology, Mathematics, Hindi Literature)
Set of 18 - General Studies books
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/416mF1T
UPSC IAS (Mains) PSIR Optional Live 2025 (Comprehensive) February Batch
Admissions Closing on 20th February, 2024 | Class Timing -1:00 PM
To know more visit : bit.ly/48XDYVO
UPSC IAS (Mains) Sociology Optional Live 2025 (Comprehensive) February Batch
Admissions Closing on 29th February, 2024 | Class Timing -1:00 PM
To know more visit : bit.ly/42zYARP
Uttar Pradesh PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation Sampoorna Batch 5
Admissions Closing on 24th February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3STienx
Bihar PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation Sampoorna Batch 5
Admissions Closing on 24th February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3HSf0v9
Gaurav Sir Current Affairs bit.ly/3jwDRsv
Complete Static GK by Dr. Gaurav Garg bit.ly/3O0FaxE
Banking Awareness (Static) by Dr Gaurav Garg bit.ly/36dElAI
Vipan Sir Courses - Courses to help you gain an edge with MCQs preparation
10000 MCQs of GA by Vipan Sir bit.ly/367qqMi
GS - Dr. Vipan Goyal bit.ly/3vbslbn
Buy our Best Selling UPSC CSE Books
From Online Stores
StudyIQ App/Store
bit.ly/3i9FCyg
Amazon
bit.ly/StoreSt...
Flipkart
bit.ly/3IDL33A
Read all Information Rich Blogs & Articles here - www.studyiq.co...
📌 Connect with [Our Social Media Platform] :
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Join our Telegram Group:- t.me/Studyiqed...
Whatsapp Channel - bit.ly/3M1i8Ya
Facebook: bit.ly/3PZTJDo
Instagram: bit.ly/48RZNGO
Twitter: bit.ly/48On8t7
#FARMERSPROTEST #KISANANDOLAN #PUNJAB #HARYANA #PUNJABFARMERS #HARYANAFARMERS #PROTEST #FARMERPROTEST #MSP #MINIMUMSUPPORTPRICE #FARMERS #STUDYIQ #UPSCPREPARATION #UPSC
Download the App to Subscribe to the Course - bit.ly/StudyiqApp
For any doubt, Call 080-6897-3353 or Click here for Whatsapp Chat wa.me/917703861353

[@StudyIQEducationLtd]

Use the code ‘ANLIVE’ to get Our Courses at a Maximum discount! Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3T20cQW For any queries please whatsapp on bit.ly/wame8952084937 UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation P2I 2025 February Batch 2 : bit.ly/3T20cQW Batch Starting on 24th February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3T20cQW UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I February Hindi Batch 2 एडमिशन की अंतिम तिथि 27 फरवरी 2024 | बैच का समय शाम 6:00 बजे Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3IhXOQd UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I February English Batch Batch Starting on 26th February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/47XLChH UPSC IAS Long Term P2I Foundation LIVE 2026 Batch 2 Batch Starting on 21st February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3OGqnKH UPSC IAS Live SIP+ 2024 February Batch 3 Batch Starting on 23rd February'2024 | Class Timing - 11:00 AM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3OMzLMK UPSC IAS Prelims to Interview ( P2I) 2024 Live Advanced Batch 6 Batch Started on 16th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:30 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/46nl6h4 UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Optional Batches : bit.ly/3DrHsmw (PSIR, Sociology, History, Geography, Pub Ad, Anthropology, Mathematics, Hindi Literature) Set of 18 - General Studies books Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/416mF1T

[@MDsahil77743]

they are not farmers they are paid goons

[@MDsahil77743]

Are you a dumb...pichle saal toh issi ka kanoon aya tha ,..tum logo ne protest karke hata diya..bola ki kale kanoon ha@@TheHimalayanTiger

[@MDsahil77743]

Are you a dumb...pichle saal toh issi ka kanoon aya tha ,..tum logo ne protest karke hata diya..bola ki kale kanoon ha @TheHimalayanTiger ...

[@hopnews_jr]

And also Punjabi high end music videos.. Punjabi o ki life expectancy bara diya... Without tractor kam hi nahi hota.. Most car buying with loan is from punjab..

[@ArshdeepSingh-qd7ng]

Punjab can never develop unless people do something beside agriculture and try to attract Industries in the state so that it can also develop.

[@Yuvrajsingh-yd3uu]

Bai akal te samaj di ghat he sade lokka ch

[@Aaaa-x9q4b]

Kya karenge industry ko bula hai, aabhi 10-15 sal, ese farming karenge, uske baad nature barbad hone ke baad Canada hai na backup.

[@charnpreetsingh8952]

Bilkul

[@jeetsathyank9703]

Khatara khatara bol kr Sab videsh me bas gye ja kr or kiya karenge .

[@davinderkumar3230]

Industry pollute environment 100 times more than agriculture

[@DarthV-wy3mj]

Canadian PM supports Khalistani Farmers but the same Canadian PM opposes the MSP & other farmer schemes at WTO against India.

[@bahenkeloudebollywood9051]

​@@tejindersidhu2379yes Canada is a hindutvavadi state your logic is right😊😊😊

[@AO-xd2ml]

@@tejindersidhu2379 Hindutva is a beautiful faith. More people should absorb and learn from it and their lives will automatically improve.

[@shubhamjatt02]

​@@tejindersidhu2379तुम भी उसी से निकले हो

[@sanjon6681]

India could not handle Canadian PM interference in India

[@yashwant_6845]

@@AO-xd2ml What we learn from Hindutva, Castism. The beauty of Hindutwa is castism. Hindutwa is a beautiful word but it is destroyed by Brahmin.

[@smartbaba1321]

Haryana winning factors. Hindu majority state. High stability. Good infrastructure. No separatist movment. No naxalites. Nearby to Delhi. Exploring to new sectors. Mhara Haryana... ❤❤❤❤❤

[@KhizarHayath.]

😂😂

[@hardikkhrera2112]

Labour policy 2006 ,single window policy 2005 ,full road connectivity wala state 2013 me hi ban gya tha

[@mastermind29]

Only one point hindu majorty who focus in education. In punjab only hindu is leading industries all other doing dharna road block etc

[@myamwayinfo8776]

सही बात है! "साथ रहने पर ये सब विकास हरियाणा का नही हो सकता था

[@hrithikravi8624]

Bhai tera aur mera haryana, unemployment index m poori country m number 1 p h, abb is m bhi proud feel howe h k

[@JaydeepSinghTindori]

As a climate scientist I can say the next few decades are very challenging for Punjab Haryana Rajasthan and madhyapradesh. The decreasing water level and monsoon irregularities will lead to drought over the region. Some of the implications are even visible at present time. God save my people.

[@amrit_raj_dubey]

Day by day it’s gone worsh . Earlier EL nino use to comes in decades but now it frequent. We are just facing repercussions of what we have done to nature.

[@HarshGupta-py3dw]

Give msp and subsidy to only poor farmers and govt should take tax from these rich farmers

[@rimurutempest2130]

nope . it will ruin Indian economy .

[@evansforever3144]

@harshGupta I agree with you

[@SailorThepirate-vk2dp]

How can gov identify farmer between poor and rich ?

[@HarshGupta-py3dw]

@@rimurutempest2130 it will only ruin rich farmer Or big landowners economy will flourish

[@HarshGupta-py3dw]

@@SailorThepirate-vk2dp one the basis of gross income per years just like they abserve small businessmens and employess

[@ShubhamSinghRajputYesofficer]

Punjab should diversify its agriculture sector and can focus on small startups like dairy and fpo and can get benefits from its long pool of NRI citizen in diversifing its income

[@amardeep492]

😁😁😁 Bihari or Uttar pardesh pardesh se log yhaa kyaa karne aate hain 😀😀

[@ShubhamSinghRajputYesofficer]

@@amardeep492 bo to tum jano ham to apne mp me hi thik hai

[@amardeep492]

Punjab main dairy pta bhi kitni hain??

[@c-zanasu5749]

​@@amardeep492aise to dilli/bangalore mein bhi bohot sare sikh doodh bechne, charpayi banane aur sabzi bechne aate hai... Unke bare mein kya bolega santa

[@mr.nobody5244]

Har seher mei punjab ke log Dhaba kyo kholte hai, ye koi logic hai. ​@@amardeep492

[@SimpleHack-cs7ys]

Then what Punjab state government doing There is need to diversify there economy dependency on different sectors

[@harshpashte4871]

Voting lo aur paisa khao development kya hota hai 😂

[@vineethsn]

Any farmer who want MSP should also pay income tax 😂😂😂 Let’s see how many diks will come.

[@prajakt0789]

Every person pays taxes in the country. What an illiterate idiot.

[@RathHaf__bar]

No bed idea💡 I agree with your opinion🤔

[@manishnimbar]

Petrol diesel free me nhi milta tax ke sath and seeds bhi 3trippl rat me milta hai unbh

[@dhankha]

still income will not cross 5 lackh which is exempted , go study

[@khushagrawal]

That’s why they have bought tractors worth 10 lakh - 15 lakh to these protests. Go study economics.

[@az-ayush_creation7264]

इन सभी परेशानियों का एक ही समाधान था - तीन कृषि बिल😢😢😢

[@myamwayinfo8776]

जितनी बार सरकार झुकेगी उतनी ही किसानों की नाजायज डिमांड भी बढ़ेगी 🤔

[@shubhambhardwaj6896]

Punjab was growing fast in 80s but then insurgency came & things got messed up. The current issues in Punjab includes : 1. Low water levels due to continues rice cultivation against environment. 2. Religious & political unrest. (Christian conversion is one of the biggest threats for our future) 3. Massive corruption.

[@IamSuperman154]

4. Drug Menace 5. Jat Sikh doing caste politics, misbehave with lower caster Sikhs leading to lower caste Sikhs converting to Christianity.

[@dr.pardeepkumar5793]

It should be implemented for other states and other cropes especially to give benefits for small farmers and agricultural labour

[@heet9988]

All Kisan schemes to be decentralized to individual states of India. So such rallies are carried out to that particular state only... Also every state has its own unique crop cultivation. So kisan scheme can't work on centralized terms.

[@sahilsharma8594]

Due to this adamant and nonsense attitude of some punjabi, no industry comes in Punjab

[@shaun3008]

Exactly these sort of punjabi people are aggressive in nature and in corporate world you cannot do that ...

[@josh-l4r8k]

@@shaun3008 it is called not being corporate slaves.

[@harshitbhandari5713]

​@@josh-l4r8k Canada mei CEO bngye hai sikh?😂 Tatti saaf krte hai usa,Canada mei😂

[@Wrti-u4t]

पंजाब को हरियाणा से सीखना चाहिए कि ज्यादा प्रोटेस्ट करने से राज्य की इमेज खराब होती हैं और इंडस्ट्रीज स्टेबलिज नहीं होते है।👍👍

[@sauravsingla6351]

Haryana gets a lot of advantage of location economies Gurgaon gets developed because of it's location (Like Noida in UP gets similar advantage) It right to say that Handloom Industry Cycle Industry and Sports Industry which could have supported Punjab economy couldn't actually do because of bad govt. policies. I'm in favour of crop diversification in Punjab but not by keeping on the stake the income of farmer.

[@6458-c5b]

Same thing happened to bengal also. Both punjab and bengal came down due to militancy. Punjab for khalistani and bengal for communists.

[@AbhijeetRajwar-k4o]

10:40 - 3rd largest software exporting state of India. Please provide reference/source. It's 5th largest, behind Karnataka, Maharastra, Tamil Nadu, Telangana.

[@Jnana-v4d]

You can Google it. It is the 3rd largest software export state of India.

[@vinaymann838]

Haryana is 3rd largest software exporter and 5th largest IT services exporter. Correct yourself.

[@evansforever3144]

Well researched, this vdo should reach more and more people

[@charrot9352]

Haryana already gives MSP on 13 crops .. we have no issues considering the lower degree of crop diversification here . I am from a farming family.. we never had any problems

[@shailendrasingh9024]

Punjab should protest against punjab state government

[@amitmahala7834]

Because haryana is nearby Delhi it's development is near 50 km near delhi all IT and etc. Faridabad and Gurgaon gets its position benefit and Punjab is much away Second Punjab is border state it's own drawback And also check unemployment rate of haryana also not much pleasant.

[@ashuexcel]

Industries can be developed anywhere, what on earth do you think there arr industrial areas in himachal, jk, uk? Panjab had everything to offer to industrialists but the socialist mindset/conspiracy theories kept them away. Who would invest when some sword flashing mob can threaten you every now and then as if setting up some unit is a crime..

[@parmeetsingh2381]

Ranganathan ke saath agar aap Swaminathan ke views ko bhi analyse karte to ye discussion kaafi balanced hota. But this discussion is very one sided. Yes analysis of the different approaches of Punjab and Haryana towards their diversification of sectors is true.

[@ssb9054]

Swaminathan had also changed views on his earlier recommendations, from taxing agri income to subsidies.

[@mulhidq6734]

Swaminathan report 20 saal pehle ki hai, jiska data 20-30 saal purana h. In 20 saalo mein water depletion, soil depletion, etc chize add hokar uss report ki recommendations ko darkinar kar diya hai. Acha to yahi rehta ki farming ko bit by bit free market economy mein laya jata.

[@vinaykhanna1975]

I agree, this is baised analysis. It looks like you just want to downgrade Punjab farmers and their issues.

[@AbhishekKumar-ub2uj]

Farmers should be the decision maker while setting the price of their own produce like corporates....

[@kaushikreddy1660]

Really, then if your doing any job ask them to pay more than 20 lakh per month as a salary.

[@pavanshetty9806]

MSP means Minimum Suppirt Price if they fail to sell their crop. This is the burden on taxpayers and governmemt. Even when there is surplus, govt has to buy. MSP cuases imabalnce at so many levels.

[@Jigar_patel07]

​@@pavanshetty9806bro aese hi msp ki price nhi niklati sab calculation hota hai formula se koi company product banati hai to usme bhi raw + transportation + holding cost + profit book milake price banti upper se GST to kisaan k product ka bhi MSP sahi value deta hai.

[@Jigar_patel07]

​@@pavanshetty9806govt muft me corporate ka loan maaf kr sakta hai tab burdan nhi Aata or kisaan K MSP pe Aa jata hai??

[@pennytrading1281]

our govt did nothing for the farmers....

[@maheshbeniwal115]

Good to see anand Ranganathan view.

[@santanude9777]

Hariyana aligned its interest and reputation with the country so became hero, whereas by going against the country Punjab became the vilian.

[@invincible6702]

Gem of knowledge Anand ranganathan 😘😘😘😘😘

[@gyanprakashwadhwa7666]

Excellent observation. Agree with you. 9th schedule of constitution must be removed for free market for agriculture products.

[@kkkumar6552]

MSP ki jimmedari state level per daal deni chahiye. Central government sabko barabar support kare. State apne level per centre ke krishi kanoon lagu kare. Bhavishya me jab un states ki progress hogi to baki farmers laws ko lagu karenge.

[@BharatBeyondBorder]

People are more Redical in punjab does not support their goverment . But haryanavi people even having less resorces are more faithful towards govt. Polices .

[@JohnyWickerson]

Haryanvi jats protested violently against the govt at times so not so happy with govt it seems keep in mind jats are 30% of haryana

[@tivo3720]

Bengal give the highest amount of rice to India. But Bengal farmers are not protesting at all. They are demanding higher msp than market value for every crops + free everything+ remove dept. By whose money govt will pay them ? From us ... Govt will rise the tax on people, on only Hindu temples,will increase the price.

[@palpreet1996]

I remember when the jaatt agitation was going on for quota. Public property was damaged, gangrapes took place. But no sikh farmers fighting for MSP and implementation of swaminathan commission are terrorist etc etc using Pellet guns which are used in kashmir.

[@nishantpoonia1068]

Punjab government should support small and large scale industries to set up an infrastructure project over there which will provide lots of employment opportunities and increase their contribution in the gdp of our country. With this the small scale farmers will get other employment sources also

[@mayankpj]

Well done! very nicely made video..... much appreciated.

[@ipsofactoraj]

We will import if needed but we will not fall for blackmail. Down with all these rich farmers

[@Yadavbgmiयादव]

Haryana k naa hai Punjab k farmers hai. Main Haryana se hu or is protest me kabhi bhi naa jaau.

[@Singh-hp5kj]

Tane bulave kon h 😅

[@rajeshmalik5254]

Waise bhi tune aakar humaare hukke he bharne hai...tu apne Ghar he rah 😅

[@sandeeparya6990]

​@@rajeshmalik5254हरियाणा मे एक अकेला तू ही नही रहता, हरियाणा में एरिया के हिसाब से सब किसान है दक्षिण हरियाणा में यादवों के पास खेती-बाड़ी है, तमीज सीख ले थोडी, अक बूढापे में दिमाग खिसक गया है

[@rajeshmalik5254]

@@sandeeparya6990 तो तू क्यूं यहां चौधर के फार्म भर रहा? आर्य समाज के ढोंगी..

[@deepaksharma1273]

Dogle hai Punjab ke haryana ke syl k naam pe kal ko haryana kol galiya nikale ge ye hi

[@ankushyadav6814]

The best quality wheat grown in Russia are sold at Rs.18/kg in international market while MSP on wheat in india is Rs.22/kg, Now come to export goverment has tried many times to donate these grains for free to countries like afghnistan but they rejected because of the high pesticide content, Yes indian goverment has recently sold some wheat to Egypt but those were from Madhya Paresh. And I request you all to whenever you buy wheat or rice try to avoide Punjab and Haryana grains recently demands of MP flour has gone up but that's far far better for your health yes price is atleast 1.5x higher but for the healthy family if you can afford you should buy flour and rice of any other state except Punjab, Haryana and western UP.

[@sammya.662]

Respect for Haryana Police.

[@rahuljoshi639]

I respect farmers but ek bat munhe btao kishan se hum kya free main kharidte hain wese to army wale bhi bahut sari chizo k liye lad sakte hain majdoor bhi bolega main kam karta hu har kam ek dhsre se connected hai ese solution nahi nikalta koi chala raha hai or kishan chal rahe hain

[@beingreal4742]

😂😂😂

[@TheSunAgain756]

Tax Rich Farmers and pay the received money to poor farmers. Giving higher MSPs to every crop will only inflate food prices.

[@AbhishekKumar-ub2uj]

Haryana is won in terms of unemployment rate as well ..

[@Abhi3604]

Kerala has the highest unemployment not Haryana.

[@Rajankryadav12-v]

​@@Kumaraniket2212also most Isis recruitment state😂

[@cba070288]

As part of WTO India cannot provide more then 10% msp....and 2nd farming is a state subject...

[@Anuj-fx8rn]

This is not farmer protest.....this is khalistani protest

[@hariomsen2655]

सरकार को छोटे किसानों को सपोर्ट करना चाहिए उनको एमएसपी दे दे पर कानून न बनाए बड़े किसान सक्षम है उनको सपोर्ट ना करे

[@gaijin_simar]

I think the current Punjab's Government is doing pretty good work . They are focusing on diversfication of Punjab's Economy . Punjab will definitely grow . This year Punjab's GDP will grow nearly 10% and I think this is not a bad number I mean it's the first time it will grow at 10% in the last 2 decades . I admire Haryana's economic reforms ❤

[@adventurek2845]

Punjab people protect own rights and protect future own childs

[@pavanshetty9806]

Thats why Punjab is so ahead, isnt it?

[@hrishikeshsarkar6513]

​@@pavanshetty9806Not Punjab, Kerala is ahead.

[@mrdemo7172]

Ahead in debt😂😂​@@pavanshetty9806

[@Rehann.T]

​@@pavanshetty9806 ahead in UDTA PUNJAB... nothing else 🥹

[@thespiderguy3515]

36 lakh crore I mean really ?? Are you dumb ?

[@sahilsharma8594]

Biggest reason NO separatist movement in haryana. Companies invest in haryana due to this

[@evansforever3144]

Ye konse garib kisan h jo crores ki ki gadi lekar pradarshan kr rhe h , tax ye dete ni lkn har crop pr msp , pension, free ,bijli, pani , karj mafi sab chahiye. Kyu bhyi baki desh ki janta kya inka muh takegi

[@sameerrana2149]

Isk bad bhi acha organic best quality anaz de sabko to bhi mane...produce Krna sell krne k liye chemical se bhra hua anaz..inki bhi se aam janta ka paise ka nuksan alg sehat ka nuksan alg

[@theseeker_]

Thank you for analysis ❤

[@shaun3008]

Another eye opener....thank u for th video

[@AshishGupta-rp4nh]

MSP should be based on crop quality, pesticide use should be limited

[@gkpandita2532]

MSP should be made the state subject, not the central govt subject.

[@harmanjeetsingh6226]

People who talk about free market, indirectly support the big corporates who hoard wealth, it will lead to chrony capitalism, like in USA. There should be free market but govt monitoring is necessary

[@gauravmangla7885]

3 Point for providing msp on every crop. 1. agar Msp sabhi product pe hogi to farmer sabhi crop ugainge jisse zameen ki fartility badegi or jaida crop bhi 1 yr bhi cultivate hogi. 2. kisano ki aay badegi or market me income badegi or naye upbhogh vastu ki maang or rojgar vridhi hogi.

[@hardeepchaudhary942]

All development you showed in haryana is in its southern part bcoz Delhi Capital is near. But why the industries not developed in north part of haryana which was part of punjab at one time?

[@gurmeet2858]

In south haryana water is also less than north haryana in terms of river and under ground

[@kartoosjat]

😂😂 It was part of punjab only from 1858 to 1966

[@Lib-cb3ob]

LOL, What about sonipat, panipat,karnal and ambala industries. Please tell us what kind of industry situated in Palwal,Nuh, Mahendragarh these district are also part of South haryana. In Rewari and Mahendragarh mostly ground water goes to 700-900 feet that's why we request for syl.

[@mazinboo9406]

@@Lib-cb3obsonipat, panipat and karnal have good industrial growth

[@JohnyWickerson]

@@kartoosjatpuadh covers parts of haryana to which is punjab basically

[@mahabaleshwarpandit2378]

Farming should also depend on market forces and demand and supply mechanism. Govt. has to take care of the poor and provide free and very cheap grains. Therefore, this MSP is a loot by rich farmers.

[@akshaysingh5290]

Only Punjab and Punjabis have the guts to oppose what is wrong

[@kalpanadadwal2392]

Well researched

[@JayPhalswal]

khalistani movement led to the decline of Punjab because of which Industries moved out of it, and same is happening again.

[@akashchandra5652]

Free and floating market for farmers and no middle men, Mandi systems.3 farm Bill will help farmers across the country which is earlier taken back by government due to pressure of Punjab farmers protest. Actually marginalized farmers are working in the field of landlords. These landlords responsible for this protest. their demands are unrealistic. I'm not in favour of this unfair protest. We need 3 farm to be passed again.

[@adventurek2845]

MSP basic needs to protect framers from big companies. M.S.P. The farmers of the country have finally improved. The government can waive off the loans of bad companies, then it doesn't help the farmers, it gives crores of rupees to other countries, then it doesn't help the people of its own country, the government wants to privatize everything, so it weakens the government companies of its country. Here are the companies like BSNL or similar companies which you will know, if you use your brain properly.

[@ssb9054]

​@@adventurek2845 You lack basic economics knowledge, may be spend some of your brain power there, instead of poking others ? India followed your socialist BSNL MTNL policies from 1947 till 1990 before economic liberalisation, average growth rate of India till then was 3% and finally India went bankrupt because of the policies you so proudly touting as revolutionary as if we have no knowledge of their effect. Again read some economics books and come back, limited liability economic ventures are not the same as taking a personal loan. You can always try blackmailing but if you over produce, just like any other industry you will suffer losses.

[@yogeshsingroha5346]

Aaj ye bol rhe ki Haryana k Kisan hmare sath aao... Kl inhone hi bola SYL ka paani nhi denge

[@logarhlandu2538]

to tu mat aa

[@sach1234saxh]

Msp , subsidy only for poor farmers,,,tax rich farmers

[@ShaktiSingh-kl5jb]

Good explanation sir

[@LovepreetSingh-kg6hu]

Last month kinu furit jo Punjab mai 2 rupees bik rah tha wo adani Ka store mai 50 rupees Ka bik Ra tha msp lgane sa adani Ka nuksan Hoga na ke kaise aur ka greebo Ka Khūna pīṇē vālō Ka nuksa hoga

[@harshpashte4871]

G wagon Mercedes range Rover wale garib farmers 🥲😭

[@jassa49]

Government needs to stop declaring minimum wage stop narega no export ban on eatables in conditions of shortage

[@Good_Vibes_247]

Panjab ke kisan parali jalana bandh karega kya. Dilli walo ko bhi iss ke viruddh protest karana chahiye. Jay Hind

[@Haryana_aale001]

3:01 अपना ज्ञान बड़ावो ३rd है सस्ते दरों पर दारू बियर फैक्ट्री को अनाज बेचना और दारू से टैक्स लेना जो की लगभग ३०%h 😊

[@ketanchadha3685]

Why Punjab Lost? The Centra governments since independence never wanted Punjab to flourish in any way as Punjabis are rebellious, fight against injustice and not docile like Hindus.

[@vibhusharma9098]

Hahaha 😂

[@Vvfhkkfsaetyhhnmkkkh]

Hindus alawa tumlogo khana hajam nhi hota na

[@Wethepeopleofindia0001]

Adani&Ambani ka 15lakh crore ka Mafi ka bat honi chahiye, Kisan desh ka asli hakdar hai hme green revolution nhi bhulna chahiye❤

[@AAKSHAS]

4:44 Why only Punjab ? 9:24

[@podfestt]

Because Punjabi choose Canada while haryanvi choose india

[@honeysinghsidhu6479]

Why Haryana still have most unemployment rates in whole India?

[@explorerakshat4907]

How much?

[@honeysinghsidhu6479]

@@explorerakshat4907 Indian Express website-The Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE), in its unemployment rate data released Monday, has once again shown Haryana with the highest rate of unemployment at 37.4 per cent in the month of December, followed by Rajasthan at 28.5 per cent, Delhi 20.8 per cent, Bihar 19.1 per cent and Jharkhand 18 per cent.

[@jainikmakwana9680]

Check government data meghalaya and punjab are on top earning farmers in nation. Just because someone protest does not mean you have to target them.

[@suneelkumarsingh6989]

क़ृषि कानूनों का विरोध, फिर सरकार द्वारा उन्हें वापस लेना, किसानो के पैर पर कुल्हाड़ी मारने का काम हुआ.... उन कानूनों मे कमियों को दूर कर लागु होने देना था.....अब अगले कई वर्षो तक शायद ही कोई सरकार कृषि सुधारो के लिए व्यापक कदम उठाये...

[@L_K_S_]

Kyuki PUNJAB ke kisan VIKLANG hain , government ki wajah se hi jinda hain

[@strawhat9319]

Take every developed country...each economy depends heavily on manufacturing and service sector for its success.

[@brhamjyotsinghsandhu798]

Thats why MSP needed on all crops and not just wheat and rice, so that farmers can experiment with other crops as well.

[@vibhusharma9098]

Abe gadhe, lega kaun sab govt? Govt ko consumer banaoge ? Saara paisa desh ka sirf kisaano ko baant dein Open market na jane se kisan darta kyun hai, aur itna hi ghaate ka sauda hai farming toh chodh k kahin naukri kar le

[@AAKSHAS]

7:27 why not industry?

[@homosapien5442]

Mai farmer ka beta hi ye farmers protest galat hai.

[@anmolsingh842]

This video was more based on Haryana development rather than msp discussion.

[@evansforever3144]

It was fact based vdo , which you could not digest bcz it doesn't support your scripted protest

[@DevotionalJSR]

crore rupye ka tractor lekr protest krne wale farmer nhi foreign funded khalistani h👾

[@SomuChoudhary-mz6ki]

Kisan ekta jindabad 🇮🇳🌾💪❤

[@anmolsingh-wk4hb]

You have a very good explanation 😅😅😂 Mja aaya...😅

[@pabitradash8139]

Punjab ka ab ye haal hua ki sab log Gyan dene lage hein ki agriculture ke alawa aur kuchh he duniya mein 😂

[@amitsinha8250]

पंजाब हरियाणा छोड़ दे , यूपी बिहार मध्य प्रदेश महाराष्ट्र वगैरा वगैरा राज्य से ये खबर आती रहती है फसल बंपर हुआ रेट नही मिल रहा रेट नही मिल कभी आलू कभी प्याज कभी गन्ना का भुगतान मिल वाले टाइम से नही कर रहे ,ये बताइए 2साल पहले हिमाचल के सेब किशन क्यों आंदोलन कर रहे ये

[@aviatorboy19]

It's Punjab-haryan and few from west UP. They support khalistan idea..

[@sumitkumarmahato2382]

Please make video on bihar and jharkhand 🙏🙏

[@amitkamboj4783]

this is your reserch level seriously . you are bending facts according to your needs . Frp is also given on Sugarcane States like maharashtra were water levels are already very deep they are growing Sugarcane which requires more water then wheat and rice combine .

[@ThunderingClouds]

U r an antinational who r demanding Khalistan and release of Islamic terrorist who planned to cut north east from rest of India in the name of Farmer protest

[@ayushmankar4100]

States like Maharashtra had diversified themselves and different industries are running there successfully . Punjab sirf Agriculture mein hi stick kar ke raha ishiliye aaj ushka ye hal hey .

[@harshpashte4871]

​@@ayushmankar4100 wahi na bro khud ka galti nahi man nege bat gyan sabse pehle hai

[@ayushmankar4100]

@@harshpashte4871 yes

[@upscaspirantdelhi9561]

You should also take view of agriculture experts jo msp ko support krte hai................

[@pawanprabhakar202]

Excellent

[@radhey0305]

If Punjab govt can balance agriculture industry with other industry than govt income can be increased and from agricultural income Punjab govt has no revenue because agriculture income is not taxable. So to prosper a state govt revenue govt should balance agriculture with industry.

[@abhiraj6494]

Anurag pandey naam h hmara 😂😂mst tha

[@mandarp9472]

Punjab farmers should diversify from low value wheat & rice to high value items like fruits, vegetables, fisheries, poultry.

[@rx-vr]

Jai haryana💪

[@kumarprince1407]

Punjab is the new Jammu and Kashmir of India.

[@beingreal4742]

India is the new syria of the world

[@martand200]

Bhai Jammu kbb asa illigal protest krte hai only Kashmir bolo

[@beingreal4742]

India being new syria of the world

[@eklavyajain09]

Hero started from Punjab but they had to shift because Punjab stayed only limited to farming.

[@raghuangara7855]

pretty good analysis

[@sukhdeepsukh874]

Punjab ka kissan educated hai baki states ke kissan ko apne haq ka pta bhi nhi hota

[@a.d8198]

Educated loge khalistan ko support karte hai jiske karan industry nahi ayi 😢😊

[@lostttkkk8038]

8:45 total states 28 nhi h kya